Composition and paleoecology of the mid-Jurassic bony fish assemblage of the Vaches Noires cliffs (Normandy, France) Authors: Simon Beaufils, Romain Vullo, Damien Gendry, Laurent Picot, Lionel Cavin, Leon Claessens, Leon Claessens, Leon Claessens, Leon Claessens Published: 2026 ABSTRACT The Callovian fossil assemblage of the Vaches Noires cliffs in Normandy, France has played an important role in French paleontology since the end of the 18th century. The bony fish component, which includes coelacanths and ray-finned fishes, is represented mainly by fragmentary material. In this study, we provide the first overview of the bony fish assemblage by examining isolated remains collected mostly by amateur paleontologists over the years and housed in public collections. The assemblage comprises remains of Actinistia (Trachymetopon sp.), Pachycormidae are represented by the filter feeder asthenocormin Leesdichthys problematicus, and by hypsocormin Hypsocormus cf. leedsi and Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris. Ginglymodi are represented by cranial elements of cf. Scheenstia and Halecomorphi by ‘Eurypoma’ grande. Pycnodontiformes (Mesturus sp. and Athrodon sp.) are represented by isolated vomers and prearticulars. The presence of small-sized actinopterygians is attested by small amphicoelous vertebrae. For each taxon, estimated body size and trophic level are inferred through comparisons with extant ecological analogs. Finally, we compare the Vaches Noires assemblage with other Jurassic fish assemblages to assess broader evolutionary and ecological trends in bony fish diversity during the Jurassic. Introduction The fossil site of the Vaches Noires cliffs and surrounding regions (France, Normandy, Calvados) is important in the history of paleontology and has been studied for over 250 years [1,2]. Public and private collections testify to the intense research carried out in the region since the 18th century. The first references to fossils date back from 18th century, with Abbé Jacques-Francois Dicquemare (1733–1789) who published an article entirely devoted to the ‘osteoliths’ from the Kimmeridgian of the Cap de la Hève and the Callovian-Oxfordian series of the Vaches Noires [1,3]. In the 19th century, local collectors gave Georges Cuvier access to fossil material, which allowed him to prove the existence of previously unknown extinct species [1–6]. In more recent times, private collectors have continued to amass extensive fossil assemblages, further enriching the paleontological record through their dedication to the discovery and preservation of significant specimens. Among those who made their collections available to researchers and public institutions are E. and G. Pennetier, M. and J. Charles, D. Gendry and C. Bara [7–9], this paper]. Most of the published fossils from the Vaches Noires cliffs and particularly from the Marnes de Dives Formation are precisely located in the local stratigraphy, corresponding to the Upper Callovian, and the Lamberti Zone. Few fossils not found in situ were removed from the study, to avoid uncertainties in the succession of the ichthyofauna assemblages. Contrary to common belief, fish remains in the Vaches Noires cliffs are abundant, but their fragmentary nature sometimes makes their systematic identification difficult. During the late Callovian, central England and northern France were covered by an epicontinental sea, as evidenced today by the thick marl series [7,8–11]. This gigantic mudflat open to the offshore waters received terrigenous sediments from the Armorican massif as evidenced by the Marnes de Dives Formation [7,8,9,12]. The driftwood, seeds, and cones found on the rocky platform just above the vertebrates are indicators of terrigenous inputs via storms (oyster-rich limestone deposits and settling of clays with wood and seeds). The Marnes de Dives assemblage includes gastropods, bivalves, cephalopods, particularly ammonites, used for biochronological studies [8,9,12,13]. Vertebrates are abundant, including cartilaginous fishes (mainly hybodontiforms [14]), marine reptiles (plesiosaurs, ichthyosaurs [15] and crocodilians [16]). Some remains of terrestrial animals such as dinosaurs have been rarely found [17–20]. Bony fishes are well represented in the Vaches Noires cliffs since they include ginglymodians (Lepidotidae), pycnodonts [21,22], coelacanths [ 23–25], representatives of thunniform (Hypsocorminae) and suspension feeder pachycormids (Asthenocorminae) [] 26–31 and halecomorphs [22,32]. Abundant well ossified vertebrae are attributed to undetermined actinopterygians. The aim of this paper is on the one hand to depict the taxonomic composition and the food chain of bony fishes based on previously described material and new specimens, and on the other hand to integrate it within the whole vertebrate assemblage of the upper Callovian of the Vaches Noires cliffs. Finally, we place and compare the trophic web within the general Mesozoic context of pelagic fish faunas in order to understand the beginnings of the Late Jurassic actinopterygian radiations [33]. Geological setting The fossil site of the Vaches Noires cliffs is located in the northwest of Calvados department in France. The cliffs extend over 4.5 km of coastline between the towns of Villers-sur-Mer and Houlgate (Fig 1). The visible sedimentary series outcrops continuously from the upper Callovian (≈163 Ma) to the Middle Oxfordian (≈ 160 Ma), the upper part of which is formed by the “coral – rag” (Tenuiserratum Zone) [8,9,34], i.e., an oyster-rich limestone facies deposited in marine subtidal proximal environments. The Albian-Cenomanian flint chalk rests in unconformity above the Jurassic deposits. The Marnes de Dives Formation is well-known for their beds rich in vertebrates dating from the upper Callovian (Lamberti Zone, Praelamberti Subzone). Approximately 15 metres of the 20-metre-thick formation are exposed [13]. These marls are the French equivalent of the British Oxford Clay and outcrop in some areas, such as a rocky flat [7,23,24]. On the Villers-sur-Mer side, the upper Callovian is covered with a recent layer of sand 50 cm to 1 m thick, sometimes uncovered during high tides. Only a few Leedsichthys bones recovered from the Henrici Subzone complement the material described from the studied level. All other known specimens originate from the Praelamberti Subzone. The fossiliferous bed is more often exposed on the Houlgate side where several lithostratigraphic markers allow to delimit the different beds between the soft clay-silty layers and the more indurated marl layers [8,9]. Benthic bioclasts are rarely pyritized and contain brachiopods, bivalves such as oysters, gastropods and trigonids all associated with pieces of pyritized wood often decametric in size [8,9]. An assemblage of foraminifera found associated with a vertebrate fossil from the Marnes de Dive provided a Middle Jurassic age, without further precision [24]. Sequential stratigraphy indicates a dynamics of High Stand System Tracts (HSST) at the end of the Callovian [9], with essentially marine influences but also significant terrigenous sedimentary components, including illite, kaolinites and smectites clays [8,9]. Geology and stratigraphy of the studied area. A, geological map of northwestern France showing the location of the Vaches Noires cliffs; B, simplified geological map of the site of the Vaches Noires cliffs; C, stratigraphic profile of the Vaches Noires cliffs from Marnes de Dives Formation up to Marnes de Villers Formation, black fishes indicate vertebrate-bearing level. Materials and methods The list of the material studied (Table 1) includes bony fish remains available for study in the collections of the Paleospace (MPV: Museum Paléospace Villers) and the geological museum of the University of Rennes (IGR: Institut de Géologie de Rennes). In addition, we figure bony fishes remains from the National History Museum of Paris (MNHN: Muséum national d’Histoire Naturelle) and a stomach content FBS 2012.4.67.30 associated to a Metriorhynchus specimen FBS 2012.4.67.80, housed at la Fabrique des Savoirs (FBS) (Elbeuf, Normandy, France) [35]. All the material likely comes from the Marnes de Dives Formation and was found either in situ or washed from rocks by the tides. Specimens were prepared by needle when required and MPV 2019.1.1 was prepared by dissolving the matrix with an unknown acid. Specimens were photographed with a camera Olympus TG-6 and drawings based on photographs were made with Inkscape Vector Graphics. Little direct evidence of predator/prey relationship, such as gut contents or traces of predation evidence were available, and consequently the trophic network was reconstructed on indirect evidence such as functional morphology. Trophic levels (TL) are represented by a scale ranging from 1 (primary producers or plants) to 5 (top predators). Pauly and Palomares [36] defined the trophic level of a consumer species i, TLi as: 10.1371/journal.pone.0344519.t001Table 1Summary table of the material available for the study of the Callovian ichthyofauna from the Vaches Noires cliffs.TaxaBoneCollectionCollection NumberTrachymetopon sp.PterygoidBara IGR 153441 Trachymetopon sp.PterygoidBara IGR 153442 Trachymetopon sp.PterygoidLe Mort MPV 2023.2.3 Trachymetopon sp.PalatoquadrateGendry IGR 153443 Trachymetopon sp.BasisphenoidBara – Gendry IGR 153444 Trachymetopon sp.BasisphenoidBara – Gendry IGR 153445 Trachymetopon sp.BasisphenoidDaumont MPV 2024.1.1 Leedsichthys problematicus NodulePennetier Batch MPV 2021.1.3.1 Leedsichthys problematicus Ceratobranchial (Halved)Pennetier Batch MPV 2021.1.3.2 Leedsichthys problematicus CeratobranchialPennetier Batch MPV 2021.1.3.3 Leedsichthys problematicus Ceratobranchial (two parts)Pennetier Batch MPV 2021.1.3.4 Leedsichthys problematicus CeratobranchialPennetier Batch MPV 2021.1.3.5 Leedsichthys problematicus HypobranchialPennetier Batch MPV 2021.1.3.6 Leedsichthys problematicus Hyomandibula?Pennetier Batch MPV 2021.1.3.7 Leedsichthys problematicus Ceratobranchial-like elementGendry IGR 153446 Leedsichthys problematicus Cranial element?Papazian MPV 2024.3.2 Leedsichthys problematicus HypohyalDaumont MPV 2024.1.2 Leedsichthys problematicus HypohyalDaumont MPV 2024.1.3 Leedsichthys problematicus HypohyalDaumont MPV 2024.1.4 Leedsichthys problematicus CeratohyalDaumont MPV 2024.1.5 Leedsichthys problematicus Ceratobranchial-like elementRivette MPV 2024.2.1 Leedsichthys problematicus Metriorhynchus stomachal contentFabrique des Savoirs FBS 2012.4.67.30 Hypsocorminae gen. et sp. indet.RostrodermethmoidLe Mort MPV 2019.1.1 Hypsocormus cf. leedsiRostrodermethmoidLe Mort MPV 2023.2.1 Orthocormus cf. tenuirostrisDentaryPennetier MPV 2022.1.23.1 Orthocormus cf. tenuirostrisFive coronoid fragmentsPennetier MPV 2022.1.23.2-7 Hypsocorminae gen. et sp. indet.HypuralLe Mort MPV 2023.2.2 LepidotidaeBasioccipitalGendry IGR 153447 LepidotidaeHyomandibula?Pennetier MPV 2022.1.14 Lepidotidae6 ganoid scalesPennetier MPV 2022.1.16 LepidotidaeJaw fragmentPennetier MPV 2022.1.15 cf. ScheenstiaJaw fragmentPennetier MPV 2022.1.22 ‘Eurypoma’ grande Anteroventral skullNicolet MNHN.F.JRE45 Athrodon sp.VomerDrijard MPV 2010.6.1 Athrodon sp.PrearticularDrijard MPV 2010.6.2 Athrodon sp.VomerCharles MPV 2014.2.183 Mesturus sp.NeurocraniumNicolet MNHN.F.JRE46 Mesturus sp.Dermal tessseraePennetier MPV 2022.1.17 Actinopterygii indet.31 vertebraePennetier MPV 2022.1.13 Actinopterygii indet.33 vertebraeCharles MPV 2014.2.183 Actinopterygii indet.47 vertebraeRanson V176R Summary table of the material available for the study of the Callovian ichthyofauna from the Vaches Noires cliffs. Where TLj is the fractional trophic level of the prey j, and DCij represents the fraction of j in the diet of i. We cannot directly calculate this value for extinct species. Accordingly, we estimated the TL value of taxa from the Vaches Noires by comparison with TL provided by Fishbase [37] for extant taxa that are phylogenetically and/or ecologically closely related to the extinct taxa. Figures of the fish assemblage network is based on the model proposed by Cavin et al. (2015), Cooper & Martill (2020) et Veiga et al. (2023) [38–40]. The vertebrate trophic chain composition follows the model proposed by Martill et al. (1994) [10]. No permits were required for the described study, which complied with all relevant regulations. Institutional abbreviations as follow: FBS: Fabrique des Savoirs; IGR: Institut Géologique de Rennes; MPV: Muséum Paléospace Villers; MNHN: Muséum national d’Histoire Naturelle; MB: Museum für Naturkunde der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin; NHMUK: The Natural History Museum, London, U.K. Systematic paleontology Actinopterygii Cope, 1887 Actinopterygii Cope, 1887 Neopterygii Regan, 1923 Neopterygii Regan, 1923 Holostei Müller, 1846 Holostei Müller, 1846 Halecomorphi Cope, 1872 Halecomorphi Cope, 1872 ‘Eurypoma’ grande Woodward, 1889 ‘Eurypoma’ grande Woodward, 1889 Material An anteroventral region of an articulated skull part MNHN.F.JRE45(Nicollet collection). Remarks There is only one mention of halecomorphs at the Vaches Noires Cliffs, that was referred to Eurycormus grandis by Wenz [22]. Arratia and Schultze [32] revised the genera Eurycormus and Eurypoma, and referred the first one to the Teleosteomorpha, more specifically the Siemensichthys-group, and the second one to the Amiiformes. Based on this study, the specimen described by Wenz (Fig 2), consisting of a lower part of a skull, was consecutively attributed to the genera Eurypoma [32]. Fig 2 shows the specimen and a drawing made after [22,32]. A study of the caturoids of the Vaches Noires cliffs, based on new material, is in progress. ‘Eurypoma’ grande anteroventral skull part MNHN.F.JRE45. (Nicollet collection) Callovian, Villers-sur-Mer, Calvados, right side (Redrawn from Wenz (1968, pl. 38, fig D) and Arratia and Schultze (2007)). ang, angular; de, dentary; eceth, ecethmoid; io, infraorbital bone (= lacrimal bone); met, mesethmoid; mx, maxilla; na, nasal bone; pmx, premaxilla; q, quadrate; smx, supramaxilla; vo.t, vomerine teeth. Scale bar: 10 mm. Ginglymodi Cope, 1872 Ginglymodi Cope, 1872 Lepisosteiformes Hay, 1929 Lepisosteiformes Hay, 1929 Lepidotidae Owen, 1860 (sensu López-Arbarello and Wencker, 2016 [41]) Lepidotidae Owen, 1860 (sensu López-Arbarello and Wencker, 2016 [41]) Genus and species indet. Genus and species indet. Material A basioccipital IGR 153447; a hyomandibula MPV 2022.1.14; a batch of 6 ganoid scales MPV 2022.1.16; two jaw fragments MPV 2022.1.15 and MPV 2022.1.22 Cranial elements Basioccipital IGR 153447 is 24 mm long (Fig 3A). It was identified by comparison with ‘Lepidotes’ toombsi (species considered by Schröder et al. (2012) as a semionotiform and included in the genus Macrosemimimus [42]) described in detail by Patterson [43]. The occipital condyle incorporates at least one vertebra, as indicated by the pair of facets for ribs present posteroventrally to the condyle. The ventral part shows the sutural surface to the postero-dorsal part of the parasphenoid. The left-wing extension that was sutured to the exoccipital is preserved. The latter forms a 70° angle to the vertical axis of the bone. Lepidotidae indet. cranial elements. Basioccipital (A) IGR 153447 and hyomandibula (B and C) MPV 2022.1.14. Photograph (A1) and drawing (A2) of the basioccipital IGR 153447 in posterior view. Photograph (B1, C1) and drawing (B2, C2) of left hyomandibula MPV 2022.1.14 in internal view (B) and lateral view (C). op. proc. hym, opercular process of the hyomandibula; f.r, facet for ribs s.pro.exo, suture process with exoccipital. Scales bars: 10 mm. The hyomandibula MPV 2022.1.14 (Figs 3B and C) is identified by comparison with the hyomandibula NHMUK PV P.6841(3) of Lepidotes latifrons Woodward, 1893 from the NHMUK collections and a ‘L.’ gloriae hyomandibula USNM 279856 described by Thies [44]. MPV 2022.1.14 measures 53 mm in length and 55 mm in maximum height. The anterior lower part is developed in a massive condyle that articulated with the lower jaw. The bone is textured with fine striations radiating from the condyle to the curved upper margin. The lateral surface bears a wing-like extension that forms a shelf and a semi-cylindrical groove. The medial surface bears a shallow crest with a semi-cylindrical channel. Ganoid scales Six scales that have a typical “peg and socket” articulation (Fig 4). Following Schultze (2018) [45], ganoine is restricted to the free field. The posterior margin of ganoin cover has a finely fringed edge. Lepidotidae indet. ganoid scales MPV 2022.1.16. Photograph (A1, B, C, D1, E, F) and drawings (A2 and D2) to show the peg and socket articulation. Scale bar: 10 mm. Scheenstia López-Arbarello & Sferco, 2011 Scheenstia López-Arbarello & Sferco, 2011 cf. Scheenstia sp. cf. Scheenstia sp. Material A dentary MPV 2022.1.15; an undetermined dentigerous element MPV 2022.1.22. Jaw fragments The dentary (Fig 5A), 150 mm long and 40 mm high, is identified by comparison with material described in [46] and [47]. The ventral margin is concave, and the occlusal surface is convex. A series of openings for the mandibular sensory canal runs in the mid-depth of the dentary along on the anterior half of the bone. There are four complete teeth remaining, three broken and two alveoli. Teeth are styliform and relatively high with a maximum height of 6.1 mm and a maximum diameter of 1.5 mm at the base. The attachment of teeth to the jaw is Type 1 (sensu Fink, 1891 [48]) characterized by complete ankylosis of the tooth to the jaw-bone, indicating a crushing mode of feeding. cf. Scheenstia sp. MPV 2022.1.15 and MPV 2022.1.22. Photographs (A1, B1) and drawings (A2, B2) of dentary MPV 2022.1.15 in left lateral view and MPV 2022.1.22 dentary fragment in labial view. t, teeth. Scales bars: 10 mm. The undetermined dentigerous fragment is 27 mm long and 11 mm high (Fig 5B). Eight teeth are visible, with two complete ones. They have a very typical acrodine cap at the top, resembling those of Scheenstia. The rest of the damaged teeth consists of dentine and a pulp cavity in the centre. incertae sedis incertae sedis Pycnodontiformes Berg, 1937 Pycnodontiformes Berg, 1937 Remarks At the Vaches Noires Cliffs, no articulated pycnodont skeleton has ever been found. Two families have been recognized on the basis of isolated elements, the pycnodont incertae sedis Athrodon sp. [21], and the Mesturidae with Mesturus [22]. Fragments of vomers, prearticular, premaxillary and isolated teeth have been regularly found in the upper Callovian of the Vaches Noires Cliffs. From this level two almost complete vomer (MPV 2014.2.183 and MPV 2010.6.1), a prearticular fragment (MPV 2010.6.2), an endocranium (MHNH.F.JRE46, identification from [22]) from the Nicollet collection and a dermal tesserae from the Pennetier collection in Paleospace are studied. incertae sedis incertae sedis Athrodon Sauvage, 1880 Athrodon Sauvage, 1880 Athrodon sp. Athrodon sp. Material Two vomer MPV 2010.6.1 and MPV 2014.2.183; two prearticulars MPV 2010.6.2 and MB f. 1337. Vomer The first vomer MPV 2010.6.1 (Fig 6 A1 and A2) has a maximum length of 19 mm long and is the most complete of the two vomers. There are seven rows with six teeth preserved on the Vomer Medial Row (V.M.R.). There are three rows per side with one V.P.L.R (Vomer Primary Lateral Row), one V.S.L.R (Vomer Second Lateral Row) and one V.T.L.R (Vomer Tertiary Lateral Row). The second vomer MPV 2014.2.183 (Fig 6 B1 and B2) has a maximum length of 17 mm long and maximum width of 10 mm. There are at least five rows with four teeth preserved on the Vomer Medial Row (V.M.R.). There are three rows on the left side with one V.P.L.R, one V.S.L.R and one V.T.L.R and two rows on the right side with one V.P.L.R and one V.S.L.R. Athrodon sp. vomers MPV 2010.6.1, MPV 2014.2.183 and prearticular MPV 2010.6.2. Photographs (up) and drawings (down). Vomer from display cases at Paleospace (A1, A2); MPV 2014.2.183 (B1, B2); prearticular fragment from display cases at Paleospace museum (C1, C2). Scale bar: 5 mm. A fragment of prearticular MPV 2010.6.2 (Fig 6C1 and C2) bearing four large teeth and three small ones, which are rather similar but less symmetrical than teeth from the vomers is present. We attribute these fragments to Athrodon sp. because the teeth are smooth, and uncrenulated unlike Mesturus and Gyrodus, which both exhibits strongly crenulated tooth. We also rule out Eomesodon and Proscinetes by comparison with Licht [49]. Both genera possess vomerine and prearticular teeth with an elliptical shape, which differs from the more rounded, circular teeth observed in all specimens. However, vomerines tooth rows are less numerous than in the vomer of Athrodon MB f. 7135 assigned to A. wittei with at least four lateral rows on each side of the V.M.R. as described by Kriwet (23). Moreover, the presence of Athrodon has been confirmed with the prearticular MB f. 1337 from the Vaches Noires cliffs described by Kriwet [21]. Mesturidae Nursall, 1996 Mesturidae Nursall, 1996 Mesturus Wagner, 1862 Mesturus Wagner, 1862 Mesturus sp. Mesturus sp. Material Endocranium MNHN.F.JRE46 (Nicollet collection); Dermal Tesserae MPV 2022.1.17. Endocranium A part of an endocranium referred as a large Mesturus skull described by Wenz [22] is redrawn here (Fig 7) and a fragment of dermal tesserae figured in Fig 8. The endocranium was described for the first time by Wenz [22]. The attribution to Mesturus is supported by the comparison between the ornamentation of the dermal bones and the dermal tesserae with the squamation pattern observed in Mesturus leedsi, Woodward, 1895, which shows a good match [50]. Moreover, the specimen falls within the appropriate temporal range for this genus (Callovian to Tithonian) [51]. Mesturus sp. MNHN.F.JRE46 endocranium in ventral view. eot, Epiotic; fhm, Facet for articulation of the Hyomandibula; fr, Frontal; prpo, Postorbital process; pSph, Parasphenoid; ptsph, Pterosphenoid; v.n.f, Vagus nerv foramen; VII, Facial nerve foramen. Scale bar: 20 mm. Mesturus sp. MPV 2022.1.17 fragment of dermal tesserae. Scale bar: 10 mm. Teleosteomorpha Arratia, 1999 Teleosteomorpha Arratia, 1999 Pachycormiformes Berg, 1937 Pachycormiformes Berg, 1937 Pachycormidae Woodward, 1895 Pachycormidae Woodward, 1895 Remarks The Pachycormidae are divided into two subfamilies: Hypsocorminae and Asthenocorminae [52], the latter comprising suspension feeding Pachycormidae. Recent phylogenetic analyses indicate that pachycormids are closely related to stem Teleostei, grouping them together within Teleosteomorpha. [53–56]. Asthenocorminae Cooper, Giles, Young, Maxwell, 2022 Asthenocorminae Cooper, Giles, Young, Maxwell, 2022 Leedsichthys Woodward, 1889 Leedsichthys Woodward, 1889 Leedsichthys problematicus Woodward, 1889 Leedsichthys problematicus Woodward, 1889 Material Nine specimens referred to L. problematicus MPV 2021.1.3 (Paleospace collections) (One nodule MPV 2021.1.3.1, four ceratobranchial parts MPV 2021.1.3.2 to 5 (with 2021.1.3.3 identified by Liston [27]), one hyomandibula? MPV 2021.1.3.6, one hypobranchial MPV 2021.1.3.7); one part of a dorsal fin or ceratobranchial IGR 153446 (Gendry collection); an undetermined opercular or cranial bone MPV 2024.3.2; ceratohyal MPV 2024.1.5; ceratobranchial-like element MPV 2024.2.1; three hypohyals MPV 2024.1.2, MPV 2024.1.3 and MPV 2024.1.4; stomachal content from a Metriorhynchus FBS 2012.4.67.30 (La Fabrique des Savoirs collections). Remarks For over 100 years, remains of L. problematicus have been found in the British Oxford Clay [3,27,57], the Vaches Noires cliffs [26], and also more recently in Chile (Atacama Desert) [26,58]. Leedsichthys problematicus, Woodward, 1889 [59] belongs to the Asthenocorminae, with other genera such as the Toarcian Pachycormus Agassiz, 1833 [60], Martillichthys Liston, 2008 (Upper Callovian), Asthenocormus Woodward, 1895 (Tithonian), Bonnerichthys Friedman et al., 2010 [61] and Rhinconichthys Friedman et al., 2010 [61] (Upper Cretaceous). Bones from this species have long been confused with parts of thyreophoran dinosaurs, including Lexovisaurus (parietals confused with parts of armor plates, and ceratobranchial confused with caudal spines) [27,62]. There is currently only one species of Leedsichthys, L. problematicus [27]. In Normandy, the genus Leedsichthys is reported from the late Bathonian (Bavent quarry) [63] to the Kimmeridgian (Cap de la Hève, Seine-Maritime) [27]. Gill rakers MPV 2021.1.3.1 is a nodule that measures 123 mm by 105 mm containing gill rakers of L. problematicus (Fig 9) (MPV 2021.1.3), as well as a tooth of the shark Notidanoides and on the back of the nodule, one ammonite Kosmoceras spinosum. The latter defines the Praelamberti Subzone in the Lamberti Zone. The nodule contains four fragments of gill rakers. Gill rakers 1 and 2 are the best preserved, measuring 62 mm and 60 mm maximum respectively. They consist of a base, a branch and fimbriations, fringes are inserted between the dental needles. FBS 2012.4.67.30 (Fig 10), corresponds to a stomachal content from a Metriorhynchus (Thalattosuchia) with two gill rakers, 37 mm and 58 mm in length. Gill rakers 3 and 4 are poorly preserved. As observed in FBS 2012.4.67.30 and MPV 2021.1.3, there is interfanuncular mesh fragments sensu Liston (2013a) and interfanuncular sensu Liston [26,64,65]. Structures like this linked gill rakers together to form a functional sieve [64]. This specimen has been recently described in a study on the diet of Metriorhynchus [35]. L. problematicus. MPV 2021.1.3.1. photograph (A) and drawing (B) of the gill rakers nodule. b, base; fim., fimbriation; g.r., gill raker; i.f.m, interfanuncular mesh fragment; s, shell fragment?, undetermined element. Scale bar: 20 mm. Metriorhynchidae stomachal content FBS 2012.4.67.30 (Fabrique des Savoirs). Photograph (A) and drawing (B) of stomachal content nodule of a thalattosuchian (Metriorhynchidae) containing gills rakers of L. problematicus. b, base; fim, fimbriations; g.r., gill rakers; i.f.m, interfanuncular mesh fragment; s, shell fragment. Scale bar: 20 mm. Ceratobranchials Ceratobranchial specimens MPV 2021.1.3.2 to 2021.1.3.5 are illustrated in Fig 11A–E, including a fragment cut in half used for making thin sections figured by Liston [27] (Fig 11A1 and A2). A second halved ceratobranchial fragment was analyzed to assess its uncrushed triangular shape. Several additional fragments are attributed to L. problematicus ceratobranchials based on their characteristic triangular cross-section. These bones served as attachment sites for gill rakers. Early Callovian occurrences have been documented by Liston & Gendry (2015) [63]. L. problematicus MPV 2021.1.3 batch and ceratobranchial fragment IGR 153446. A, MPV 2021.1.3.2. Ceratobranchial in transverse (A1) and lateral (A2) views (identified by Liston [27]); B. MPV 2021.1.3.3. Ceratobranchial in lateral view (identified by Liston [28]); C, MPV 2021.1.3.4. Ceratobranchial in lateral view (two parts); D, MPV 2021.1.3.5. Ceratobranchial in lateral view (two parts); E, MPV 2021.1.3.8. Hypobranchial in lateral view; F, MPV 2021.1.3.7. Hyomandibula fragment?; G, IGR 153446 Ceratobranchial?-like element. Scale bar: 5 cm. Hypobranchial A fragment of a right hypobranchial MPV 2021.1.3.6 (Fig 11E) from the anterior part of the gill basket (identified by comparison with NHMUK P. 10156 [27]). This 246 mm long bone is well ossified. The anterior part, more massive, is relatively well preserved. Skull roof elements? Probable cranial elements of L. problematicus. MPV 2021.1.3.7 (Fig 11F) and MPV 2024.3.2 (Fig 12). MPV 2021.1.3.7 is 145 mm in length, but more fragmentary than MPV 2024.3.2 which is 365 mm in length. The two bones have a central hump often observed in dermal bones of L. problematicus [27,66]. In each bone, striations radiate from the ossification center to the external peripheral shelf that is blade-like. This feature is more clearly visible in MPV 2024.3.2, which is significantly more complete, whereas in MPV 2021.1.3.7, the borders are fragmented. L. problematicus skull roof elements? MPV 2024.3.2. A, in dorsal view; B, in ventral view. Scale bar: 10 cm. Hypohyals Three hypohyals (Fig 13), one right MPV 2024.1.2 (Fig 13A1, B1), two left MPV 2024.1.3 (Fig 13A2, B2) and MPV 2024.1.4 (Fig 13A3, B3). They were identified by comparison with hypohyals of Leedsichthys described by Liston [66]. These bones are well-ossified. MPV 2024.1.2 is 190 mm in length, MPV 2024.1.3 is 182 mm in length, MPV 2024.1.4 is 113 mm in length. The ossification state of MPV 2024.1.2 is stronger than MPV 2024.1.3. MPV 2024.1.4 is broken but preserves the anterior part. The dorsal surface of all three specimens is highly ridged anteriorly, with a smooth ventral surface. Three characteristic medial indentations give rise to a shelf that extends antero-ventrally along part of the medial edge. L. problematicus right hypohyal MPV 2024.1.2, left hypohyal MPV 2024.1.3 and left hypohyal MPV 2024.1.4. MPV 2024.1.2 A1, in dorsal view; B1, in ventral view. MPV 2024.1.3 A2, in dorsal view; B2, in ventral view. MPV 2024.1.4 A3, in dorsal view; B3, in ventral view. I, Indentations. Scale bar: 5 cm. Ceratohyal An anterior ceratohyal (Fig 14) MPV 2024.1.5 identified based on its typical centrally narrowed shape and in comparison with material described by Liston [27,29,66]. MPV 2024.1.5 is 330 mm maximum length but broken at both anterior and posterior ends. It has a minimum width of 110 mm. The thickest border is the superior part of the bone, the inferior blade-like part runs longitudinally. The bone is rugose on both surfaces, due to the mesh-like ossification-type typical of Leedsichthys. A pattern of striations radiates from the center of the convexly curved outer surface. The internal surface is flat. The bone is teardrop-shaped in transverse view. L. problematicus right ceratohyal MPV 2024.1.5. A, in lateral view; B, in medial view. Scale bar: 10 cm. Ceratobranchial? Two ceratobranchial-like fragments (Fig 15), MPV 2024.2.1 and IGR 153446 (Fig 11G), have been identified as belonging to Leedsichthys problematicus based on comparative morphology with previously described material, particularly specimens SMC J46873 for MPV 2024.2.1 [29] and NHMUK P.6925 and NHMUK P.6928 [27,28,66] for IGR 153446. The fragment MPV 2024.2.1, which measures 440 mm in length, is conical, anteroposteriorly compressed, and exhibits a slight curvature. In contrast, IGR 153446 is notably shorter, 114 mm, and has a more circular cross-section. Both fragments display a rugose surface texture and a distinctive mesh-like ossification-type typical of Leedsichthys. L. problematicus ceratobranchial? MPV 2024.2.1. A, in lateral view; B, in medial view. Scale bar: 10 cm. Hypsocorminae Vetter 1881 sensu Cooper et al., 2022 Hypsocorminae Vetter 1881 sensu Cooper et al., 2022 Remarks The second pachycormid clade present in the assemblage is the one composed exclusively of macrocarnivorous fishes. This clade contains thunniform species, such as the Middle/Late Jurassic Hypsocormus Wagner, 1863 or the Late Cretaceous swordfish-like Protosphyraena Leidy, 1857 [67]. The rostrodermethmoid is a specific bone resulting either from the fusion of ethmoid and vomer [68–71], or from the fusion of rostral and dermethmoid [55]. Material Rostrodermethmoids MPV 2019.1.1 and 2023.2.1; Batch MPV 2022.1.23 comprising dentary part (MPV 2022.1.23.1), 5 coronoids fragments (MPV 2022.1.23.2 to 2022.1.23.5) (and one tooth not figured here MPV 2022.1.23.6) and one coronoid fragment (MPV 2022.1.23.7); One hypural bone MPV 2023.2.2. Hypsocorminae gen. et sp. indet. Hypsocorminae gen. et sp. indet. Rostrodermethmoid Specimen MPV 2019.1.1 (Fig 16) is identified as a rostrodermethmoid by comparison with NHMUK PV P.6916 (3) and NHMUK PV P.6913. The specimen measures 102 mm long and 71 mm wide maximum. A series of large teeth, of which only the tooth base or the corresponding empty sockets are preserved, extends on the lateral edge of the ossification. Traces of eight of these large teeth are visible on the right side and six on the left. They are arranged irregularly, with some teeth located offset mesially than the main alignment. The space left labially is occupied by smaller teeth, of variable size and irregularly arranged. Hypsocorminae gen. et sp. indet. rostrodermethmoid MPV 2019. Photograph (A) and drawing (B) of the cf. Hypsocormus rostrodermethmoid in ventral view. ant, antorbital; t, teeth; t.s., teeth sockets. Scale bar: 10 mm. A bony fragment located in the matrix that fills the specimen may be part of the left antorbital, as seen in a more complete three-dimensional specimen of Pachycormus from the Toarcian [60]. We attribute the rostrodermethmoid to Hypsocorminae gen. and sp. indet. because of the peculiar dentition composed of very robust but peculiarly arranged teeth. Martillichthys and L. problematicus are dismissed because of their edentulous nature. Hypural bone An almost complete compound hypural plate MPV 2023.2.2 (Fig 17), 18 mm long and 19 mm high at maximum, is identified by comparison with the hypural plate attributed to Hypsocormus posterodorsalis in Maxwell et al., 2020 and Maxwell et al., 2025 [72,73]. This plate-like triangular bone formed the central part of a caudal fin. MPV 2022.2.2 is identified as an indeterminate Pachycormidae. Fig 17 shows the groove for what we interpret as the arteria pinnalis (Fig 17B) [74] which runs on the upper front part of the hypural bone. The parhypural foramen opens at the level of fusion of the parhypural centrum with the compound hypural plate. Hypsocorminae gen. et sp. indet. hypural plate MPV 2023.2.2. In red, path of the arteria pinnalis. Scale bar: 5 mm. Hypsocormus Wagner 1863 Hypsocormus Wagner 1863 Hypsocormus cf. leedsi Woodward, 1889 Hypsocormus cf. leedsi Woodward, 1889 Rostrodermethmoid Specimen MPV 2023.2.1 (Fig 18) is identified as a rostrodermethmoid by comparison with NHMUK PV P.6916 (3) and NHMUK PV P.6913. This smaller rostrodermethmoid measures a maximum of 40 mm in length and 38 mm in width (Fig 18). Two proportionally large paramedial teeth profoundly anchored in bone are visible on both sides of the symmetry axis (Fig 18A1 and A2). There is a well-developed symphyseal tooth at the front, anteriorly oriented. Numerous small, staggered lateral marginal teeth are present, primarily along the right labial margin. The dorsal side bears an ornamentation made of small wrinkles (Fig 18B). We identify the specimen as Hypsocormus cf. leedsi, as it partly matches the NHMUK PV P.6913 specimen, but not fully, particularly with the medial tooth on MPV 2023.2.1. This fragment may represent a new species, but further material is required to test this hypothesis. Hypsocormus cf. leedsi rostrodermethmoid MPV 2023.2.1: photographs (A1 and B) and drawing (A2) of the cf. Hypsocormus cf. leedsi rostrodermethmoid in ventral view (A1, A2) and dorsal view (B). Scale bar: 5 mm. Orthocormus Weitzel 1930 Orthocormus Weitzel 1930 Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris [Woodward, 1889] Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris [Woodward, 1889] Jaw fragments Six fragments are available from MPV 2022.1.23.1 to 5 and MPV 2022.1.23.7 (Figs 19–21). We attribute them to Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris by comparison with NHMUK PV P.6916 [59] and by comparison with Cooper & Maxwell, 2025 [75]. Discovered close to each other, they probably belong to the same individual. MPV 2022.1.23.1 (Fig 19), identified as a fragment of dentary [70], is 73 mm long and 9 mm wide at its widest level. It is probably a left dentary, given the curvature of the bone and the way it refines in dorsal view. Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris dentary MPV 2022.1.23.1. Photograph (A) and drawing (B) of a Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris dentary in dorsal view. t, teeth sockets. Scale bar: 10 mm. Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris coronoids fragments MPV 2022.1.23.2 (A) to 2022.1.23.5 (D). Photograph in lingual view (1) and labial view (2). Scale bar: 5 mm. Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris coronoid fragment MPV 2022.1.23.7: Photograph (left) and drawing (right) in (probably left?) labial view (A), ventral view (B) and lateral view (C). Scale bar: 20 mm. 12 teeth and seven empty sockets are visible. Teeth seem to be almost fused with the bone. They are well spaced, more in the posterior part than in the anterior part of the ossification [70]. Five other fragments MPV 2022.1.23.2 to 5 (Fig 20) and MPV 2022.1.23.7 (Fig 21) are identified as pieces of coronoids that still bear teeth. Small, 2–4 mm high marginal teeth are visible on the labial edge of some of the coronoid fragments (Fig 20B, C and D and Fig 21). The main teeth are large, thick, and their crown is 10 mm to 20 mm high. In apical view, they have a sub-oval shape, and their base is funnel-like. The surface of all teeth is striated longitudinally. The most distal part of teeth seems truncated, a consequence of the acrodine cap departure. An enamel layer seems to have been eroded on MPV 2022.1.23.7, on the two bigger teeth. Actinopterygii indet. Actinopterygii indet. Material A batch of 31 vertebrae MPV 2022.1.13 (Pennetier collection); A batch of 33 vertebrae MPV 2014.2.183 (Charles collection); A batch of 47 vertebrae V176R (Ranson collection). Vertebrae Small amphicoelous vertebrae (concave anteriorly and posteriorly) are regularly found in Vaches Noires Cliffs. Three batches are housed in the Paléospace collection: V176R, MPV 2014.2.183 and MPV 2022.1.13. The first batch V176R contains 47 vertebrae, the second MPV 2014.2.183 contain 33 vertebrae and the third MPV 2022.1.13 contains 31 vertebrae. The centra are well ossified, lack a marked mid-length constriction, and range in maximum diameter from 2 to 20 mm. Their overall morphology is smooth, with no prominent grooves. We illustrate the general morphology of the centra using vertebrae from batch 2022.1.13 (Fig 22). The first centrum is shown in axial view (Fig 22A1), lateral view (Fig 22A2), and in either ventral or dorsal view (Fig 22A3). This type of morphology is typical for centra measuring 5 mm or less, characterized by a very smooth surface. Actinopterygii indet. representative vertebra centra from batch 2022.1.13 (Pennetier collection). Scale bar: 5 mm for A1–A3; 10 mm for B–F. The other centra (Fig 22B–E) exhibit variations in shape and coloration and are generally less smooth, although the overall morphology remains consistent. The figured centrum (Fig 22F), shown in lateral view, is partially broken in the presumed ventral region (lower part of the specimen). However, the upper part clearly displays the general shape seen in most of the specimens. One vertebra of particular interest is described in this section. It originates from the V176R batch and measures a maximum of 15 mm in height and 8.5 mm in width (Fig 23). The bases of the neural arches and parapophyses are preserved, with the latter serving as rib attachment sites. The centrum is marked by deep grooves on both sides. This morphology is reminiscent with most actinopterygians, who possess well-ossified vertebra, with strongly attached parapophysis. But the overall morphologies cannot allow further identification, with a lot of vertebrae eroded, lacking any diagnostic characteristics to decide between chondrichthyans and actinopterygians. For some of the vertebrae with deep lateral grooves, we cannot exclude Synechodontiformes Duffin and Ward, 1993 (Neoselachii Compagno, 1977), who possess those types of centra [76]. Further analysis involving thin section might be the way to differentiate between cartilaginous and bony structures, but this is not the goal of this paper. Actinopterygii indet. from Bacth V176R. Photograph (A1, B1) and drawing (A2, B2) of a Teleostei indet. vertebra from batch V176R. n.a.b, neural arch basis; p, parapophysis. Scale bar: 5 mm. Sarcopterygii Romer, 1955 Sarcopterygii Romer, 1955 Actinistia Cope, 1871 Actinistia Cope, 1871 Mawsoniidae Schultze, 1993 Mawsoniidae Schultze, 1993 Trachymetopon Hennig, 1951 Trachymetopon Hennig, 1951 Trachymetopon sp. Trachymetopon sp. Material Three pterygoids IGR 153441–153442 (Bara collection) and MPV 2023.2.3 (Paleospace collections); One palatoquadrate IGR 153443 (Gendry collection); Three basisphenoids IGR 153444, IGR 153445 (Bara – Gendry collection); Basisphenoid sutured to a partial parasphenoid MPV 2024.1.1 (Daumont collection). Remarks Based on Cavin et al. [24], all small coelacanths bones are attributed to young specimens of Trachymetopon for the following reasons: the basisphenoids present a notochord pit ventrally visible between the two processus connectens and an inner surface carved by ridges or cavities. Remains tend to have very coarse ridges, probably trabecular bones, visible due to weathering. Pterygoids The three pterygoids are from the left side, and only the posterior part corresponding to the strongest ossified part of theses bones is preserved (). All pterygoids present an acute angle between the posteroventral and the anteroventral edge (average: 57°) compared to larger specimens of Trachymetopon, such as MPV 2012.1.1, SMNS.95889 [23] and MJML K785 [77], in which this angle is much more opened (≈ 86°). Trachymetopon sp. IGR 153441 and IGR 153442. Photographs (left) and drawings (right) of coelacanth pterygoid IGR 153441 inleft lateral view (A1, A2), in labial view (B1, B2), and pterygoid IGR 153442 in left lateral view (C1, C2), in labial view (D1, D2). ant.rdg, anterior ridge; f.post.part.ptq, fossa for the insertion of the posterior cartilage plate of the palatoquadrate; post.rdg, posterior ridge; s.s.pt/q, suture surface of the pterygoid with the quadrate; s.s.mpt, suture surface of the metapterygoid. Scale bar: 5 mm. Trachymetopon sp. IGR 153443. Palatoquadrate IGR 153443; photograph (A1) and drawing (A2) of the palatoquadrate in posterior view. art.s.q, articular surface of the quadrate; pt, pterygoid; q, Quadrate; s.pt/q, suture of the pterygoid with the quadrate. Scale bar: 5 mm. Trachymetopon sp. MPV 2023.2.3. Pterygoid MPV 2023.2.3in left lateral view (A1, A2) and labial view (B1, B2) ant.rdg, anterior ridge; f.post.part.ptq, fossa for the insertion of the posterior cartilage plate of the palatoquadrate; post.rdg, posterior ridge; s.s.pt/q, suture surface of the pterygoid with the quadrate; s.s.mpt, suture surface of the metapterygoid; t.p, tooth plate. Scale bar: 5 mm. On IGR 153441–153442 (Fig 24) and MPV 2023.2.3 (Fig 26) a posterior ridge originates just dorsally to the quadrate insertion surface. This ridge delimits dorsally the posterior margin of the metapterygoid. Another ridge located anteriorly from the first delimits a pit. The latter is the insertion point for the jaw adductor muscles in coelacanths [78]. The bone surface of IGR 153441–153442 presents ridges. On IGR 153442 (Fig 24C and D) and MPV 2023.2.3 (Fig 26) a small surface bearing infra-millimetrical teeth is present on the lingual side. Basisphenoids The basisphenoid is a strongly ossified bone that is therefore easily preserved. In coelacanths, it forms the anterior element of the intracranial joint between the ethmosphenoid (anterior) and the otoccipital (posterior) parts. Specimens IGR 153444 and IGR 153445 (Figs 27 and 28) have well-developed sphenoidal condyles. They are triangular in IGR 153444 (Fig 27) and rather rounded in IGR 153445 (Fig 28). The condyles are separated from each other by a wide notch comparable to the one present in the large specimen MNH GEPI V5778 [24]. The antotic processes expand dorsolaterally with part of the sutural surface with the posterior parietal preserved. The left antotic process is preserved in IGR 153444 while the right one is preserved in IGR 153445. Trachymetopon sp. IGR 153444. Basisphenoid IGR 153444: photograph (left) and drawing (right) of basisphenoïd in left lateral view (A1, A2), dorsal view (B1, B2), postero-ventral view (C1, C2), antero-dorsal view (D1) and ventral view (E1, E2). ant.pr, antotic process; d.s, dorsum sellae; f.p, foramen for the profundus; not.pit, notochord pit; pit.fos, pituitary fossa; pr.con, processus connectens; sph.c, sphenoid condyles; s.s.p.pa, suture surface with post parietal, spt.foss, suprapterygoid fossa. Scale bar: 5 mm. Trachymetopon sp. IGR 153445. Basisphenoid IGR 153445: photograph (A) and drawing (B) of basisphenoid in posterior view. ant.pr, antotic process; d.s, dorsum sellae; sph.c, sphenoid condyles. Scale bar: 5 mm. The dorsum sellae forms a low wall that ventrally limits the opening of the cranial cavity. The processus connectens are elongated with parallel margins, and curve slightly antero-ventrally in their central part. They reach the ventral side of the bone where the parasphenoid was sutured, visible in specimen IGR 153444 (Fig 27). MPV 2024.1.1 (Fig 29) is the most complete of all specimens in which all previously described characters are visible, plus a part of the parasphenoid. A groove connected to the pituitary fossa runs along the dorsal part of the parasphenoid. On its ventral part, small teeth are present on the preserved part of the bone. The left lateral ascending wing is partially preserved but the part that connected to the lateral ethmoid is destroyed. Trachymetopon sp. mpv 2024.1.1. Basisphenoid MPV 2024.1.1: photograph (left) and drawing (right) of basisphenoid in antero-dorsal view (A1, A2), postero-ventral (B1, B2). ant.pr, antotic process; d.s, dorsum sellae; not.pit, notochord pit; pas: Parasphenoid; pas.t: parasphenoidal teeth; pit.fos, pituitary fossa; s.l.b/p, suture line between basisphenoid ans parasphenoid; pr.con, processus connectens; sph.c, sphenoid condyles. Scale bar: 5 mm. Diets and trophic web In this section, we separately analyze each taxon of bony fish recorded in the Callovian assemblage from the Vaches Noires cliffs to provide them with an estimate of their trophic level. This analysis aims to understand the ecological interactions between fishes and the diverse fauna of the Callovian sea of the Vaches Noires cliffs. The summary of fishes found in the Vaches Noires cliffs is provided in Table 2, with trophic values and occupied niches presented in Fig 30, and the trophic web reconstruction in Fig 31. 10.1371/journal.pone.0344519.t002Table 2Summary table of bony fish found in the Vaches Noires cliffs. F: Frequent; LF: Locally frequent; O: Occasional; VR: Very rare.Trophic levelsLife habitsDietAbundance Trachymetopon 4,4 (Based on Latimeria chalumnae)Pelagic?PiscivorousLF Leedsichthys 3,6 (Based on Rhincodon typus)PelagicFilter-feederO Hypsocormus 4,4 (Based on Thunnus albacares)PelagicPiscivorousO Lepidotidae indet. 4,1 (Based on Balistes capristus)NektobenthicDurophagousF ‘Eurypoma’ 3,8 (Based on Amia calva)PelagicPiscivorousVR Mesturus 3,8 (Based on Cheilinus trilobatus)NektobenthicDurophagousF Actinopterygii 3,1 (Based on Sardina pilchardus)PelagicFilter-feederF Summary table of bony fish found in the Vaches Noires cliffs. F: Frequent; LF: Locally frequent; O: Occasional; VR: Very rare. Schematic representation of the estimated trophic values (red numbers) and feeding habits (green, blue, light blue and orange) of the taxa studied. 1, Trachymetopon sp.; 2, Leedsichthys problematicus; 3, Hypsocorminae; 4, Lepidotidae; 5, Halecomorphes; 6, Mesturus sp.; 7, Actinopterygians indet.; 8, Actinopterygians indet. Scale bar: 1 m. Trophic web reconstruction of the Callovian sea including bony fishes and principals taxa related in the food web (not at scale). Fishes are in black, other taxa are in grey. Trophic relationships are reconstructed and inferred from bibliography, direct evidence and by actualism. This figure is a simplified model to understand the global ecological implication of the bony fish fauna among the Callovian sea of the Vaches Noires cliffs. 1, Actinopterygii indet.; 2, Pycnodontiformes; 3, Lepidotidae; 4, Chimaeriformes; 5, Leedsichthys; 6, Ammonoidea; 7, Teuthoidea; 8, Actinopterygians indet.; 9, Halecomorphi; 10, Hypsocorminae; 11, Hybodontiformes; 12, Trachymetopon; 13, Notidanoides; 14, Cryptoclidus; 15, Ophthalmosaurus; 16, Metriorhynchus; 17, Liopleurodon. Halecomorphs Halecomorphs are very scarce among the Vaches Noires cliffs. One specimen of ‘Eurypoma’ grande is known from the Nicolet collection. Based on the morphology of the jaws (Fig 2), we hypothesize that ‘Eurypoma’ was a generalist predator, feeding on small fishes, crustaceans, molluscs, carrions, and other food opportunities. It was likely preyed upon by mesopredators such as Cryptoclidus, thalattosuchians and pliosaurs. We suggest a trophic level of 3.8 based on the extant bowfin, Amia calva (Amiiformes). Lepidotidae Lepidotidae are widespread in the Callovian of the British Oxford Clay Formation. Martill [79] associated the crushing teeth structure of ‘Lepidotes’ macrocheirus to five arched incisions present on a damaged peristome of the ammonite Kosmoceras cf. obductum. This crescent bite-mark also corresponds to the arrangement of the teeth of specimen MPV 2022.1.15. of Lepidotidae indet. The body size of MPV 2022.1.15. was estimated using ganoid scales MPV 2022.1.16 (Fig 4) combined with the scales and body size ratio used by Cavin et al. (2015) [38] on Adrianaichthys pankowskii. The proportionality rule indicates a total length of about 75 cm, a body size in accordance with the size of the hyomandibula (MPV 2022.1.14, Fig 3). The jaw fragment (MPV 2022.1.22, Fig 5) bears teeth capped by acrodine caps typical of the genus Scheenstia. These fishes likely fed on ammonites, benthic crustaceans, and small fishes (small-sized actinopterygians). We suggest that they were essentially consumed by mesopredators and potentially by durophagous hybodontiform sharks, able to crush massive scales and/or thick bones. We do not know where they lived in the water column, but their robust body and massive skull probably indicate a more demersal than pelagic living environment. We assign a trophic level of 4.1 based on the modern gray triggerfish, Balistes capriscus (Tetraodontiformes). Pycnodontiformes Two distinct pycnodonts have been recognized in the Vaches Noires cliffs, the Pycnodontiformes incertae sedis Athrodon [21] and the Mesturidae Mesturus (24). Kriwet [21] figured an Athrodon sp. prearticular, but other occurrences are regularly found in the Callovian of Vaches Noires by fossil collectors. We follow Wenz (1967) [22] who referred a partial braincase to the genus Mesturus (Fig 7) and a dermal bone fragment (Fig 8). This genus is restricted to the Callovian and Late Jurassic of Central and Northern Europe [51] and is regularly found in the Oxford Clay. Similar to Lepidotidae, pycnodonts are believed to have lived relatively close to the seafloor, exhibiting a demersal lifestyle. More complete specimens of Athrodon and Mesturus have demonstrated a generalist way of swimming [80,81], not so closely related to manoeuvring swimming [82,83]. As stated by Kriwet [84], we suggest a monotypy of prey, likely gastropods and other molluscs. We assign a trophic level of 3.8 based on the living tripletail wrasse, Cheilinus trilobatus (Labriformes). Asthenocorminae The giant planktivorous ray-finned fish Leedsichthys could reach considerable lengths (16.5 metres maximum estimated) [28,65]. L. problematicus exploited an important resource located at the base of the food chain, the primary consumers. It could probably also feed on small fishes, as fin whales (Balaenoptera physalus), humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae) and whale sharks (Rhincodon typus) do today [85–87]. We assign for L. problematicus a trophic level of 3.6 identified for the living whale shark, Rhincodon typus (Orectolobiformes). We do not use Cetorhinus maximus since is common length is 700 cm with a maximum length of 1,590 cm [37], while R. typus common length is 1,000 cm with maximum length circa 2,000 cm [37], closer to Leedsichthys average size estimation (over 1,000 cm). Leedsichthys as food source: The Callovian sea was rich in mesopredators from medium to large-sized (sauropterygians, toothed pachycormids, thalattosuchians). Evidence of attacks on L. problematicus was recorded on dorsal fin rays (NHMUK PV P.6924) and on a caudal fin (NHMUK PV P.10000A) [65]. Injured bones have formed calluses, probably following an attack by a large pliosaur like Liopleurodon ferox [28]. The old or sick individuals of L. problematicus were probably to serve as food source to many taxa, such as thalattosuchians and sauropterygians. Scavenging evidence is known from specimen FBS 2012.4.67.30 with stomachal content of a thalattosuchian containing L. problematicus gill rakers [35]. Evidence of scavenging by Metriorhynchus on plesiosaur carcass has been documented, showing that they were opportunistic [88]. Moreover, the specimen MPV 2013.1.3 is preserved in association with a Notidanoides muensteri tooth, suggesting scavenging behaviour from many taxa on L. problematicus carcasses by pelagic fauna and on the bottom of the sea. After the mobile scavenging stage, carcasses may have served as deadfalls to provide nutritional enrichment to the sea floor, with some large fishes later becoming temporary reef environments prior to final burial (for instance on a piece of a large Trachymetopon braincase found in the Vaches Noires [24] and skeletons of marine reptiles from the Oxford Clay (Ophthalmosaurus) [11]). These taphonomic observations associated with L. problematicus fossils are reminiscent of what we observe today on whales falls [89,90]. Hypsocorminae Based on their general morphology and buccal apparatus, these pachycormids likely fed on fishes and crustaceans [10]. Sizes can be estimated by comparison with Orthocormus cornutus (holotype SenkM 1863) and Hypsocormus insignis (holotype SNSB-BSPG AS VI 4a) rostrodermethmoids, known by articulated skeletons from the Solnhofen Archipelago [68,73]. For MPV 2019.1.1, a standard size ranging between 100 cm and 150 cm is a reasonable estimate. However, since this estimation is based on isolated fragments, it should be considered only speculative. They are medium-sized predatory fishes that consumed small to medium-sized teleosteans, they were probably preyed upon by sharks, marine reptiles and other large predators. We assign a trophic level of 4.4 identified for the living yellowfin tuna, Thunnus albacares (Scombriformes). Actinopterygians indet Leptolepidae and Pholidophoridae are present in the Peterborough member [11] but there is no conclusive evidence of their occurrence in the Vaches Noires cliffs. However, the abundance of small, smoothly ossified vertebrae in the French assemblage suggests that small-sized fishes inhabited the Callovian sea of the Vaches Noires. These remains may represent small actinopterygians, represented by taxa such as Leptolepidae or Pholidophoridae, but current evidence is insufficient to assign them to a specific group. These fishes likely occupied lower trophic levels in the vertebrate food web. They would then have been microcarnivores (suction feeding), or planktonic/zooplanctivores hunting by sight [91,92] and maybe living in schools. By a size ratio of vertebrae from V176R (Fig 23) with the specimen of Thrissops cf. formosus JME-ETT74 [91] we roughly estimate the total body length of the individual at approximately 60 cm. This size suggests relatively large predator, capable of feeding on many of the inhabitants of the Vaches Noires cliffs’ sea. All vertebral centra in the assemblage are relatively large (few are less than 2 mm). This may reflect a taphonomic bias favoring the preservation of larger, well-ossified elements, while smaller, more fragile centra are more likely to be destroyed by post-mortem processes. Alternatively, it could result from a collecting bias. We also suspect that finer recovery methods, such as sediment sieving, may reveal the presence of smaller vertebrae that are currently underrepresented. Undetermined actinopterygians from the Callovian Vaches Noires vertebrate assemblage most likely formed the base of the trophic chain but were also occupying higher trophic levels with predators located in the middle level of the food chain. They might be represented either by halecomorph-like fishes as well as small teleosteomorph-like fishes. We assign a trophic level of 3.1 identified for the living sardine, Sardina pilchardus (Clupeiformes). Coelacanths All the new material described in this study is small, either suggesting that these specimens likely represent young individuals or represent another genus. Although Coccoderma has been identified in the Kimmeridge Clay [93,94], the Vaches Noires cliffs remain are too incomplete to refer to the genus level. Given that Trachymetopon has already been identified within the Vaches Noires cliffs, we consider all the coelacanths remains from the Vaches Noires under the genus Trachymetopon [23,24]. Body size estimation of specimens from the Vaches Noires have been previously made based on the reconstruction of Axelrodichthys araripensis, with an estimate length between 4 and 5 meters for large adults [95]. Extant Latimeria is ovoviviparous, meaning the young develop within the mother after hatching. The body size of extant Latimeria juveniles born from a 1.8-meter female is approximately 30–32 cm [96]. By size ratio, juveniles from females 4–5 meters long should measure between 60 cm and 75 cm respectively. The estimated sizes of the described individuals correspond to juveniles [24] if not neonates of large Trachymetopon individuals reported in the Vaches Noires [23-25]. There is little direct evidence of the diet of the extant Latimeria, supposed to feed on prey such as fishes, small sharks, skates and cephalopods for example [97]. We classify Trachymetopon as a piscivorous mesopredator. This animal has a high trophic level, with individuals up to 4–5 meters long likely feeding on small to medium size fishes (sharks, teleosteomorphs, lepidotids, pycnodonts) and cephalopods (ammonites, belemnites) [97]. We assign a trophic level of 4.4 identified for L. chalumnae, but this value is here considered with caution due to the differences between the living environments and body size of the compared species (although their general morphologies are quite similar on surface). Ecological continuity and comparison of the Vaches Noires cliffs during the Middle to Late Jurassic Here, we compare different localities from the Early (Sinemurian and Toarcian), Middle (Callovian), and Late (Kimmeridgian) Jurassic to illustrate the ecological continuum in the succession of bony fish assemblages (Fig 32). We exclude the sites of Cerin (late Kimmeridgian) and Solnhofen (Tithonian) because they correspond to more lagoonal settings with a deposit much less rich in organic matter. Instead, our objective is to examine Jurassic ecological trends by comparing similar open-pelagic environments characterized by pelletal clays (clays containing small, rounded aggregates known as pellets) [98] and rich shales (fine, laminated structures with 1–5% organic matter) found across Jurassic seas of Western Europe. Lower Lias assemblage is represented by the Hettangian and Sinemurian part of the Lyme Regis coast. Toarcian is represented by the assemblage from Holzmaden. Callovian is represented by the assemblage from the Vaches Noires cliffs and by the assemblage from the English Peterborough Member. Kimmeridgian assemblages are represented by the Kimmeridge Clay. Fig 32 is intended to show the ecological variations between Jurassic fish communities from different periods. Ecological ‘continuum’ of pelagic ichthyofauna in northwestern Europe during the Jurassic (England, Germany, France). See text for references, list of taxa is not exhaustive. Comparison between the Vaches Noires cliffs and the area of Lyme Regis (Dorset) The Blue Lias Formation ranges from Hettangian to Sinemurian. This locality represents shallow shelf paleoenvironment, composed of dark laminated shales and limestone [99]. Paleoniscimorpha (sensu Lund et al., 1995) [100] represent a large part of the fauna, with Centrolepis aspera Egerton, 1844; Coccolepis liassica Woodward, 1890; Ptycholepis spp. Agassiz 1833; Cosmolepis ornatus Egerton, 1854 and Platysiagum sclerocephalum Egerton, 1872 [70]. Acipenceriformes are represented by Chondrosteus acipenseroides Egerton, 1858. Halecomorphi are represented by Dapedium, Caturus, Osteorachis, Furo and Heterolepidotus [70]. Unsurprisingly Pycnodontiformes are absent, but so are Lepidotidae, an unusual feature from Jurassic locality that yielded several type species [101]. Pachycormiformes are absent, but the already diverse composition of this clade in the Toarcian may suggest the existence of ghost lineages in Lower Jurassic [75]. Saurichthyiformes are represented by Saurorhynchus and Belonorhynchus [102] and Teleostei by Pholidophoriformes. The formation yielded one coelacanth genus, Undina [59]. This assemblage is significantly different from the Vaches Noires cliffs, with reminiscences of Paleoniscimorpha, representatives of an older ichthyofauna. Comparison between the Vaches Noires cliffs and Holzmaden The Posidonienschiefer Formation, predominately quarried from the Holzmaden area near Stuttgart, is widely distributed across Baden-Württemberg. Unlike the Vaches Noires Cliffs, which corresponds to an environment close to the coast, Holzmaden represents a more open-sea environment. As a result, pycnodonts are almost completely absent from Holzmaden [103]. The Holzmaden Toarcian assemblage contains diverse halecomorphs, especially amiiforms [103], and pachycormids, with the early diverging genus Euthynotus, a possible Hypsocorminae “Sauropsis”, and four early-diverging basal representatives of Asthenocorminae with Pachycormus, Saurostomus, Germanostomus [52,104], and Ohmdenia as basal representant of the filter-feeder lineage [105]. In contrast, the Vaches Noires Cliffs exhibit more derived pachycormids, such as Hypsocormus sp., Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris, Leedsichthys problematicus. A small Latimeriid coelacanth has also been described in Holzmaden by Cooper (2025) [94] and both deposits have yielded the coelacanth Trachymetopon [23,106]. The durophagous fishes in Holzmaden are represented by Dapedium [107], Lepidotes gigas, Agassiz 1832 and Tetragonolepis semicincta Bronn, 1830. The Palaeoniscimorpha Toarcocephalus morlok Cooper et al. 2024 is presented in Holzmaden but absent in the Vaches Noires Cliffs [108]. In Holzmaden, Acipenseriformes are represented by the genus Strongylosteus Jaekel 1929 [109] and the locality also yielded the ptycholepidiform, Ptycholepis bollensis Agassiz, 1832 [110], two species of pholidophoriforms with ‘Pholidophorus’ germanicus Quenstedt, 1856 and ‘Pholidophorus’ hartmanni Woodward, 1895 [111], the leptolepidiform Leptolepis coryphaenoides Bronn, 1830 [112] and the Saurichthyiformes Saurorhynchus Reis, 1892 [102]. Comparison between the Vaches Noires cliffs and the Peterborough Member (Oxford Clay) (after [10,11]) Although the Peterborough Member and the Vaches Noires Cliffs are both Callovian in age and share similar paleoenvironmental conditions, their fish faunas display notable differences. The Peterborough Member hosts at least one genus of pycnodont (Mesturus and possibly Gyrodus), halecomorphs such as Caturus and Osteorachis, four genera of pachycormids (Leedsichthys, Hypsocormus, Orthocormus and ‘Sauropsis’), the aspidorhynchid Aspidorhynchus, and two genera of teleosteans (‘Pholidophorus’ and ‘Leptolepis’). The British locality contains several species that are absent from the Vaches Noires assemblage, including the palaeonisciform Coccolepis, the ginglymodian Lepidotes, and the dapediid Heterostrophus. Interestingly, no coelacanths are mentioned in the Peterborough Member, despite their presence in other localities and especially in the Vaches Noires cliffs. In contrast, the Vaches Noires Cliffs has yielded a single halecomorph, ‘Eurypoma’ grande (MNHN.F.JRE45) [22,32], but Caturus is absent, whereas the latter is common in the Peterborough Member [10]. Furthermore, the Vaches Noires assemblage includes three genera of pachycormids (Leedsichthys, Hypsocormus and Orthocormus). Despite these differences, the two localities likely belonged to the same Callovian Sea, and the differences in their fish assemblages are likely due to collecting biases. Comparison between the Vaches Noires cliffs and the Kimmeridge Clay The Kimmeridge Clay fish assemblage comprises Holosteans (Lepidotidae, Semionotiformes), Pycnodontiforms with three family: Mesturidae, Gyrodontidae and Pycnodontidae. In the Kimmeridge Clay, Halecomorphs are represented by the genera Eurypoma and by Caturidae such as Caturus andStrobilodus [113]. Ophiopsiformes are represented by Brachyichthys Winkler, 1862 [114]. Pachycormids are represented by three genera (Hypsocormus, Orthocormus and Asthenocormus). Actinistians present in the Kimmeridge Clay Formation are represented by the family Mawsoniidae (Mawsonia and/or Trachymetopon) [77] and by Coccoderma, the latter being absent in the Vaches Noires cliffs. The Kimmeridge Clay also contains a large indeterminate acipenceriform (Chondrostei) [115]. Teleosteomorpha is represented by Aspidorhnychus and Belonostomus, and by Teleostei [116], including the Ichthyodectiformes genera Thrissops and Pachythrissops [117]. Discussion The reconstruction of the bony fish assemblage of the Vaches Noires cliffs is reminiscent with that of the Peterborough Member whose food web was analysed by Martill et al. (1994) [10]. We consider both paleoecosystems to be very similar. The comparison of the Vaches Noires cliffs with four major Jurassic localities from Western Europe (Lyme Regis, Holzmaden, Peterborough Member and the Kimmeridge Clay) highlights a diversification after the Triassic-Jurassic mass extinction and a stabilization trend from the Lower (Toarcian) to the Middle Jurassic (Callovian), before the massive Upper Jurassic radiation. While there are some notable species-level differences, the broader ecological landscape remained relatively stable over time from Toarcian (Holzmaden) to Callovian (the Vaches Noires Cliffs, Peterborough Member). However, Sinemurian assemblage displays a more ‘primitive’ fauna, reminiscent of Triassic assemblages particularly with palaeoniscimorphs. Moreover, the variations in the abundance and diversity of certain genera across the localities (e.g., the apparent absence of coelacanths in the Peterborough Member or the limited representation of halecomorphs in the Vaches Noires Cliffs) may suggest localized adaptive radiation, driven by the availability of ecological niches or variations in environmental conditions. Differences can also be attributed to collecting bias. The comparison between the Vaches Noires Cliffs and the Kimmeridge Clay underscores a higher diversity for the latter, particularly of pycnodonts, and teleosts that represent the incipient Upper Jurassic radiation. Diversification is noticeable in pachycormids, illustrated by the split between hyspocormin and asthenocormin pachycormids during the Toarcian (with Ohmdenia from Ohmden). Their total range starts from the late Early Jurassic (Toarcian with Euthynotus) and ends at the terminal Cretaceous (Maastrichtian with Protosphyraena and Bonnerichthys) [118,119]. This makes them a very successful clade spanning almost 116 Ma. Durophages (predominately Pycnodontiformes) are present in the Kimmeridge Clay, the Peterborough Member and the Vaches Noires cliffs. We notice a diversification among this group of fishes after the Toarcian and Middle Jurassic, particularly by the Callovian times [120], with encountered families Mesturidae, Gyrodontidae and Pycnodontidae [33]. However, Pycnodontiformes remain extremely rare throughout the Early and Middle Jurassic, particularly before the Callovian [121]. There are three, maybe four levels of piscivores in the Vaches Noires Cliffs assemblages: small-sized actinopterygians?/Eurypoma/Hypsocormus/Trachymetopon (Leedsichthys is not incorporated since its size may prevent any predatory behaviour from other fishes) and three in the Peterborough member: Caturus/Hypsocormus/‘Sauropsis’. The Vaches Noires cliffs assemblage contributes to our understanding of fish diversification during the Jurassic. The abundance and completeness of individual fossils and assemblages are major factors in reconstructing past biodiversity. In this respect the Vaches Noires cliffs provide valuable insights through the quality and quantity of material they have yielded. Some old and recent discoveries by amateurs suggest that fish remains can be exceptionally well-preserved in these marl deposits. Recently, a private collector (P. Branger) deposited what we believe to be a small mawsoniid neurocranium from the Callovian, discovered 45 years ago at the Vaches Noires Cliffs. The specimen has been added to the public collections of the University of Rennes and will undergo CT scanning to analyze bone topology and, hopefully, reveal new features to estimate its age, size, and life habits. An almost complete head of a ‘Eurypoma’ grande-like fish, along with parts of its body, was discovered in 2023 on the rocky platform of the Vaches Noires cliffs, is currently in analysis. This new specimen tentatively assigned to ‘Eurypoma’ grande is currently under study. Its remarkable state of preservation makes it a key opportunity to refine our understanding of this taxon. Ongoing preparation and analysis may provide crucial data on its anatomy, phylogenetic position, and the role of this fish within the Callovian marine ecosystem. Supporting information Inclusivity in global research questionnaire. (DOCX) 22 Oct 2025 -->-->PONE-D-25-45591-->-->Composition and paleoecology of the mid-Jurassic bony fish assemblage of the Vaches Noires cliffs (Normandy, France).-->-->PLOS ONE Dear Dr. Beaufils, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS ONE’s publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process.-->--> -->-->Your manuscript has received two detailed, constructive peer reviews. Both reviewers are in agreement that your study would provide an important contribution to the field, but also question a substantial number of the taxonomic identifications made. Both reviewers provide detailed information regarding the identifications that they question, thereby providing you with a clear rationale for re-examining the specimens in question. Considering the substantial number of taxonomic assignments that need to be re-examined, changed, or provided with a stronger rationale, I am returning the manuscript to you as a major revision. We would welcome a substantially revised version of your manuscript, which clearly has merit for helping elucidate a major mid-Jurassic bony fish assembly. Please make sure to submit a detailed response to the reviewers comments with your revised manuscript, that provides a rationale for each of the highlighted taxonomic identifications and all other points raised by the reviewers. Please submit your revised manuscript by Dec 06 2025 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org . When you’re ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript:--> A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'.A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'.An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, please include your updated statement in your cover letter. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols . Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols . We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Leon Claessens, Ph.D. Academic Editor PLOS ONE Journal Requirements: When submitting your revision, we need you to address these additional requirements. 1. Please ensure that your manuscript meets PLOS ONE's style requirements, including those for file naming. The PLOS ONE style templates can be found at https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=wjVg/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_main_body.pdf and https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=ba62/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_title_authors_affiliations.pdf 2. Please include a complete copy of PLOS’ questionnaire on inclusivity in global research in your revised manuscript. Our policy for research in this area aims to improve transparency in the reporting of research performed outside of researchers’ own country or community. The policy applies to researchers who have travelled to a different country to conduct research, research with Indigenous populations or their lands, and research on cultural artefacts. The questionnaire can also be requested at the journal’s discretion for any other submissions, even if these conditions are not met. Please find more information on the policy and a link to download a blank copy of the questionnaire here: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/best-practices-in-research-reporting. Please upload a completed version of your questionnaire as Supporting Information when you resubmit your manuscript. 3. We note that your Data Availability Statement is currently as follows: All relevant data are within the manuscript and its Supporting Information files. Please confirm at this time whether or not your submission contains all raw data required to replicate the results of your study. Authors must share the “minimal data set” for their submission. PLOS defines the minimal data set to consist of the data required to replicate all study findings reported in the article, as well as related metadata and methods (https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/data-availability#loc-minimal-data-set-definition). For example, authors should submit the following data: - The values behind the means, standard deviations and other measures reported; - The values used to build graphs; - The points extracted from images for analysis. Authors do not need to submit their entire data set if only a portion of the data was used in the reported study. If your submission does not contain these data, please either upload them as Supporting Information files or deposit them to a stable, public repository and provide us with the relevant URLs, DOIs, or accession numbers. For a list of recommended repositories, please see https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/recommended-repositories. If there are ethical or legal restrictions on sharing a de-identified data set, please explain them in detail (e.g., data contain potentially sensitive information, data are owned by a third-party organization, etc.) and who has imposed them (e.g., an ethics committee). Please also provide contact information for a data access committee, ethics committee, or other institutional body to which data requests may be sent. If data are owned by a third party, please indicate how others may request data access. 4. We note that Figure 1 in your submission contain [map/satellite] images which may be copyrighted. All PLOS content is published under the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which means that the manuscript, images, and Supporting Information files will be freely available online, and any third party is permitted to access, download, copy, distribute, and use these materials in any way, even commercially, with proper attribution. For these reasons, we cannot publish previously copyrighted maps or satellite images created using proprietary data, such as Google software (Google Maps, Street View, and Earth). For more information, see our copyright guidelines: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/licenses-and-copyright. We require you to either (1) present written permission from the copyright holder to publish these figures specifically under the CC BY 4.0 license, or (2) remove the figures from your submission: 1. You may seek permission from the original copyright holder of Figure 1 to publish the content specifically under the CC BY 4.0 license. We recommend that you contact the original copyright holder with the Content Permission Form (http://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=7c09/content-permission-form.pdf) and the following text: “I request permission for the open-access journal PLOS ONE to publish XXX under the Creative Commons Attribution License (CCAL) CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Please be aware that this license allows unrestricted use and distribution, even commercially, by third parties. Please reply and provide explicit written permission to publish XXX under a CC BY license and complete the attached form.” Please upload the completed Content Permission Form or other proof of granted permissions as an ""Other"" file with your submission. In the figure caption of the copyrighted figure, please include the following text: “Reprinted from [ref] under a CC BY license, with permission from [name of publisher], original copyright [original copyright year].” 2. If you are unable to obtain permission from the original copyright holder to publish these figures under the CC BY 4.0 license or if the copyright holder’s requirements are incompatible with the CC BY 4.0 license, please either i) remove the figure or ii) supply a replacement figure that complies with the CC BY 4.0 license. Please check copyright information on all replacement figures and update the figure caption with source information. If applicable, please specify in the figure caption text when a figure is similar but not identical to the original image and is therefore for illustrative purposes only. The following resources for replacing copyrighted map figures may be helpful: USGS National Map Viewer (public domain): http://viewer.nationalmap.gov/viewer/ The Gateway to Astronaut Photography of Earth (public domain): http://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/sseop/clickmap/ Maps at the CIA (public domain): https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/index.html and https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/cia-maps-publications/index.html NASA Earth Observatory (public domain): http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/ Landsat: http://landsat.visibleearth.nasa.gov/ USGS EROS (Earth Resources Observatory and Science (EROS) Center) (public domain): http://eros.usgs.gov/# Natural Earth (public domain): http://www.naturalearthdata.com/ 5. Please ensure that you refer to Figure 14 in your text as, if accepted, production will need this reference to link the reader to the figure. 6. If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions -->Comments to the Author 1. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions? The manuscript must describe a technically sound piece of scientific research with data that supports the conclusions. Experiments must have been conducted rigorously, with appropriate controls, replication, and sample sizes. The conclusions must be drawn appropriately based on the data presented.--> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Partly ********** -->2. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously?--> Reviewer #1: N/A Reviewer #2: N/A ********** -->3. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available? The PLOS Data policy requires authors to make all data underlying the findings described in their manuscript fully available without restriction, with rare exception (please refer to the Data Availability Statement in the manuscript PDF file). The data should be provided as part of the manuscript or its supporting information, or deposited to a public repository. For example, in addition to summary statistics, the data points behind means, medians and variance measures should be available. If there are restrictions on publicly sharing data—e.g. participant privacy or use of data from a third party—those must be specified.--> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes ********** -->4. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English? PLOS ONE does not copyedit accepted manuscripts, so the language in submitted articles must be clear, correct, and unambiguous. Any typographical or grammatical errors should be corrected at revision, so please note any specific errors here.--> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes ********** -->5. Review Comments to the Author Please use the space provided to explain your answers to the questions above. You may also include additional comments for the author, including concerns about dual publication, research ethics, or publication ethics. (Please upload your review as an attachment if it exceeds 20,000 characters)--> Reviewer #1: Dear authors, I have thoroughly reviewed your submitted manuscript, titled “Composition and paleoecology of the Mid-Jurassic bony fish assemblage of the Vaches Noires cliffs (Normandy, France)” to the best of my knowledge on the subject. This work presents a comprehensive faunal description of the Callovian bony fish assemblage at Vaches Noires – an important but understudied Middle Jurassic marine locality with an interesting vertebrae assemblage. I wish to begin my review by congratulating the authors for their work. The bony fish assemblage of this region has not previously been reviewed in detail, and I believe that their contribution will serve as a very useful and widely cited publication in the future. For the most part, the anatomical descriptions are well written, concise, informative and nicely illustrated. With this being said, I am not fully convinced with some of the taxonomic and anatomical identifications made by the authors. Of course, I have not examined the materials in person and are only basing my judgments on the figures provided in the authors’ manuscript, but I strongly urge the authors to take a second look at some of their specimens. I have uploaded an annotated PDF of the manuscript with my detailed comments, most of which are grammatical/stylistic. My major concerns are as follows: Coelacanths – It is interesting to see that coelacanth remains are present in the French Callovian, as these are one of the major Jurassic fish groups strangely absent from the English Oxford Clay Formation. Based on my recent work on coelacanth pterygoids, The specimens illustrated by the authors, in my opinion, look to be closer in morphology to Coccoderma (Laugiidae) than they do to Trachymetopon (Mawsoniidae). Please see my comments in the manuscript for further details. If the authors believe these remains to belong to a young mawsoniid, then they should explain their justification for ruling out Latimeriidae and Laugiidae as plausible candidates. Pycnodonts – this section is fine, but see my comments on the manuscript. Also note that the specimen in Fig 25C is figured in the wrong orientation (anterior and posterior opposed relative to specimens in parts A and B). the wider medial teeth are usually always located at the posterior in pycnodontiforms vomers/prearticulars which have well organized tooth rows. Specimen in part B also appears to have some second-generation pathological teeth which have replaced a missing tooth on the left primary lateral row. The authors may wish to highlight this, but it is not all that important for the scope of the paper, more of an interesting observation which suggest it comes from an adult individual rather than a juvenile. Pachycormidae – the authors appear to give the youngest stratigraphic range for this group as ‘Hettangian’, listing Euthynotus and Pachycormus as present in the Sinemurian. However, there are no records of Pachycormidae prior to the Toarcian. Previous records of this family in the Sinemurian derive from Agassiz (1833-1844), although all of these pre-Toarcian occurrences have since been proven as invalid or highly dubious. I am also of the opinion that the authors’ hypsocormine sample is more diverse than is reported. Certainly, the rostrodermethmoid in Fig. 16 can, in my opinion, be referred with confidence to Hypsocormus leedsi Woodward, 1889, and the anterior coronoid in Fig. 19 with two enlarged coronoids tusks be referred to Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris (Woodward, 1889) (Hypsocormus tenuirostris in older literature. The authors also use outdated informal terminologies for the subfamilies (e.g., ‘toothed clade’ and ‘suspension-feeding clade’) please use formal clade names in the manuscript (Hypsocorminae + Asthenocorminae). The authors also make reference to a ‘Leedsichthys head’ in a private collection. This specimen is both intriguing and potentially significant. Is it possible for authors to figure this specimen, perhaps in the supplementary data? Lepidotidae – this section is sound, although I believe the specimen figured in Fig 21B-C is not a quadrate (also listed as a ceratohyal by the authors in the materials section), but instead the broken dorsal half of a hyomandibula. Please see my comments in the annotated manuscript for justification. Teleostei – Based on the size and gross morphology of the illustrated chordocentra, and given the groups present in the Callovian from neighboring sites, leptolepids are a plausible candidate, more so than pholidophoriforms which do not have these true chordocentra. Discussion – this section needs some work and in some areas is flawed. The taxonomic comparisons between the French Callovian and other Jurassic marine localities are interesting and ambitious, but there are many inaccuracies in the faunal assemblages given by the authors. Between the text and the comparative faunal lists provided in Fig. 32, many taxonomic groups are missing from localities where they are known to be present (e.g., Chondrosteidae, Saurichthyidae, Coccolepididae missing from Toarcian) and others misattributed, or attributed without evidence (e.g., Pachycormidae in Sinemurian; aspidorhynchids in Toarcian [perhaps conflated with saurichthyids?]). The authors do not provide a faunal description of the Sinemurian fauna (I assume based on the Lyme Regis + Charmouth Blue Lias Group?) as they do for the other localities included in Fig. 32. I have given some detailed comments on the faunal assemblages of these sites in the manuscript. Overall, this work is highly ambitious and very important for advancing our understanding of Middle Jurassic bony fish communities, and one which certainly is worthy of publication, following revision of the points I have highlighted above. Due to number of issues, I must unfortunately recommend major revisions are needed before this manuscript is fit for publication. If the authors can satisfactorily address these concerns, then I would be happy to see this work published in PLoS ONE. Thank you for inviting me to review this very interesting and important manuscript. I wish the authors well with the revision process and hope to see this work published in the near future. If the authors have any questions regarding my comments, then I welcome them to reach out to me via email (Samuel.cooper@smns-bw.de). Sincerely, Sam Cooper, Staatliches Museum für Naturkunde Stuttgart, Germany. Reviewer #2: Dear authors Composition and paleoecology of the mid-Jurassic bony fish assemblage of the Vaches Noires cliffs (Normandy, France) is an interesting topic. Unfortunately, little material of this locality is available, and what is there is usually so poorly preserved that it can hardly be identified. I have inserted my comments directly into the attached PDF. Here are just some of my main points where I think the manuscript needs to be updated: Eurypoma is not within Caturoidea (see for example López-Arbarello and Ebert 2023). Why do you think your specimens of Fig. 25 belong to the genus Athrodon? A label or a supposed identification by S. Wenz is not sufficient. Your “Teleostei” vertebra seem too large for Teleostei of the Middle Jurassic. The only teleost in the Middle to Upper Jurassic with completely ossified vertebra centra of this size (~5 mm) is the Ichthyodectiform Thrissops (see for example Nybelin 1964, Ebert 2025). But to me these vertebrae look completely different. To me the vertebrae in Fig 28A looks more like those in the halecomorph Amiopsis or Ionoscopus with the typical two deep depressions (see Grande & Bemis 1998). Fig. 28B-E: For me, the figured vertebrae look more like chondrichthyan vertebrae. These vertebrae are too large for teleost vertebrae of the Jurassic. The larges Thrissops vertebrae from the Upper Jurassic (Kimmeridgian/Tithonian) are approximately 7 mm wide und 8 mm high and they were very rare. Mid-Jurassic Ichthyodectiformes were presumably smaller and all other teleost with completely ossified vertebra centra at that time were not larger than 10 to 20 cm. Thrissops vertebrae have a small outer rim that immediately descends to the centre. Teleost are most probably present, but you should look for teleost vertebrae in the sizes <5 mm. These small vertebrae are often overlooked or simply not sampled. Do not use the taxon name Lepidotidae (see for example López-Arbarello 2012). Fig. 32: Lepidotidae Owen, 1860, was later added to Semionotidae by Woodward (junior synonym) and is no longer in use (see López-Arbarello 2012). Aspidorhynchiformes and Amiidae are not present in the Toarcian. Do you have any evidence for Orthogonikleithridae in the Callovium? I only know this Family from the Upper Jurassic. Ichthyodectidae are only present in the Cretaceous (see Cavin et al. 2013). The taxon name Pholidophoridae is no longer in use for the Middle and Upper Jurassic. Grimmenodus is only found in Northern Germany and not in Holzmaden. Your Sinemurian locality in Fig. 32 is probably Lyme Regis. Here, many taxa are missing (Ophiopsiformes like Furo, Heterolepidotus, Osteorhachis; Leptolepidae…). For Coccolepididae in Holzmaden see Cooper et al. 2024. For Latimeriidae in Holzmaden see Cooper 2025. The name Paraleptolepis Arratia & Thies, 2001 was preoccupied and was changed into Longileptolepis Arratia, 2003. Ophiopsiformes are missing in all localities. Change Dapedium into Dapediidae. For this reason, this manuscript is not publishable in its present form and I think major revisions are needed. I will send the PDF with additional minor corrections directly to Plosone since I cannot upload it here. ********** -->6. PLOS authors have the option to publish the peer review history of their article (what does this mean? ). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy .--> Reviewer #1: Yes: Dr Samuel Cooper Reviewer #2: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] To ensure your figures meet our technical requirements, please review our figure guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures You may also use PLOS’s free figure tool, NAAS, to help you prepare publication quality figures: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures#loc-tools-for-figure-preparation. NAAS will assess whether your figures meet our technical requirements by comparing each figure against our figure specifications. --> Submitted filename: PONE-D-25-45591_reviewer.pdf Submitted filename: PONE-D-25-45591 - Reviewer 2 additional edits.pdf 13 Jan 2026 Dear editor, Dear Reviewers We thank both reviewers for the very complete and constructive reviews. Supplementary comments in text have been addressed. The main text has been entirely restructured to fit systematics, with Actinopterygians first and Sarcopterygians at the end. Response to reviewer 1: - Coelacanths – It is interesting to see that coelacanth remains are present in the French Callovian, as these are one of the major Jurassic fish groups strangely absent from the English Oxford Clay Formation. Based on my recent work on coelacanth pterygoids, The specimens illustrated by the authors, in my opinion, look to be closer in morphology to Coccoderma (Laugiidae) than they do to Trachymetopon (Mawsoniidae). Please see my comments in the manuscript for further details. If the authors believe these remains to belong to a young mawsoniid, then they should explain their justification for ruling out Latimeriidae and Laugiidae as plausible candidates. Response : After discussion with Dr Cooper, we agree with him about coelacanths remain, but the very fragmentary nature of the Vaches Noires cliffs coelacanths make an identification to the genus Coccoderma very risky. Since Trachymetopon has already been found in the Vaches Noires cliffs, we prefer to keep our identification until more remains are found. - Pycnodonts – this section is fine, but see my comments on the manuscript. Also note that the specimen in Fig 25C is figured in the wrong orientation (anterior and posterior opposed relative to specimens in parts A and B). the wider medial teeth are usually always located at the posterior in pycnodontiforms vomers/prearticulars which have well organized tooth rows. Response : We modified the pycnodont Fig 25C in accordance with the comments (Prearticular reoriented) and it has been redescribed after discussion between authors. - Pachycormidae – the authors appear to give the youngest stratigraphic range for this group as ‘Hettangian’, listing Euthynotus and Pachycormus as present in the Sinemurian. However, there are no records of Pachycormidae prior to the Toarcian. Previous records of this family in the Sinemurian derive from Agassiz (1833-1844), although all of these pre-Toarcian occurrences have since been proven as invalid or highly dubious. I am also of the opinion that the authors’ hypsocormine sample is more diverse than is reported. Certainly, the rostrodermethmoid in Fig. 16 can, in my opinion, be referred with confidence to Hypsocormus leedsi Woodward, 1889, and the anterior coronoid in Fig. 19 with two enlarged coronoids tusks be referred to Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris (Woodward, 1889) (Hypsocormus tenuirostris in older literature. The authors also use outdated informal terminologies for the subfamilies (e.g., ‘toothed clade’ and ‘suspension-feeding clade’) please use formal clade names in the manuscript (Hypsocorminae + Asthenocorminae). The authors also make reference to a ‘Leedsichthys head’ in a private collection. This specimen is both intriguing and potentially significant. Is it possible for authors to figure this specimen, perhaps in the supplementary data? Response : After discussion with Dr Cooper, we agree with him about the Pachycormid issues, and we have changed some of our identification: Hypsocorminae from Sinemurian was a mistake, it has been removed. We refer the rostrodermethmoid to Hypsocormus cf. leedsi. We refer the coronoids fragments to Orthocormus cf. tenuirostris. Older terminology has been replaced by Hypsocorminae and Asthenocorminae. The Leedsichthys head will be discussed further in private with Dr Cooper, since the head is published, but it is in a private collection and is inaccessible. We removed this sentence from the text, since we haven’t heard from the specimen in many years, and it cannot be analyzed. - Lepidotidae – this section is sound, although I believe the specimen figured in Fig 21B-C is not a quadrate (also listed as a ceratohyal by the authors in the materials section), but instead the broken dorsal half of a hyomandibula. Please see my comments in the annotated manuscript for justification. Response : We reexamined the specimen Fig 21B-C, and we are not convinced by the Hypsocorminae identification. After careful examination, we concluded it corresponds more to a hyomandibula of Lepidotidae. It is reminiscent of Lepidotes gloriae. Since this specific fragment is very difficult to identify, we remained cautious in our determination. - Discussion – this section needs some work and in some areas is flawed. The taxonomic comparisons between the French Callovian and other Jurassic marine localities are interesting and ambitious, but there are many inaccuracies in the faunal assemblages given by the authors. Between the text and the comparative faunal lists provided in Fig. 32, many taxonomic groups are missing from localities where they are known to be present (e.g., Chondrosteidae, Saurichthyidae, Coccolepididae missing from Toarcian) and others misattributed, or attributed without evidence (e.g., Pachycormidae in Sinemurian; aspidorhynchids in Toarcian [perhaps conflated with saurichthyids?]). The authors do not provide a faunal description of the Sinemurian fauna (I assume based on the Lyme Regis + Charmouth Blue Lias Group?) as they do for the other localities included in Fig. 32. I have given some detailed comments on the faunal assemblages of these sites in the manuscript. Response : The discussion section and Fig 32 have been completely revised. We now include Lyme Regis locality, with a dedicated section in the text. All missing taxonomic identification have been added. To reviewer 2: - Eurypoma is not within Caturoidea (see for example López-Arbarello and Ebert 2023) Response : Eurypoma phylogeny placement has been corrected - Why do you think your specimens of Fig. 25 belong to the genus Athrodon? A label or a supposed identification by S. Wenz is not sufficient. Response : Pycnodont vomers are neither Gyrodus nor Mesturus due to uncrenulated nature of the teeths. Eomesodon and Proscinetes have ellipsoid teeth, where our specimens possess rounded teeth strikingly similar to Athrodon wittei and to the prearticular founded in the Marnes de Dives, both figured by Kriwet, 2008. - Do not use the taxon name Lepidotidae (see for example López-Arbarello 2012). Response : Lepidotidae is a valid taxon since Lopez-Arbarello and Wenckler, 2016 (Neopterygian phylogeny the merger assay) - Aspidorhynchiformes and Amiidae are not present in the Toarcian. Response : Aspidorhynchiformes and Amiidae in Toarcian has been removed - Do you have any evidence for Orthogonikleithridae in the Callovium? I only know this Family from the Upper Jurassic + Ichthyodectidae are only present in the Cretaceous (see Cavin et al. 2013) + The taxon name Pholidophoridae is no longer in use for the Middle and Upper Jurassic. Grimmenodus is only found in Northern Germany and not in Holzmaden. + The name Paraleptolepis Arratia & Thies, 2001 was preoccupied and was changed into Longileptolepis Arratia, 2003. Response : All concerns in Fig 32 have been addressed (Paraleptolepis into Longileptolepis, Orthogonikleithridae in Callovian and all the mentioned above). - Your Sinemurian locality in Fig. 32 is probably Lyme Regis. Here, many taxa are missing (Ophiopsiformes like Furo, Heterolepidotus, Osteorhachis; Leptolepidae…). Response : The Sinemurian locality has been added (Lyme Regis) with a description in the main text. - Ophiopsiformes are missing in all localities + For Latimeriidae in Holzmaden see Cooper 2025 + For Coccolepididae in Holzmaden see Cooper et al. 2024 + Dapedium into Dapediidae Response : The same comments have been made by the first reviewer for Coccolepididae and Latimeriidae in Holzmaden. These taxa have been added, just as Ophiopsiformes in all localities and Halecomorphi genera such as Heterolepidotus or Osteorachis. For Both reviewers: - From reviewer 1: Teleostei – Based on the size and gross morphology of the illustrated chordocentra and given the groups present in the Callovian from neighboring sites, leptolepids are a plausible candidate, more so than pholidophoriforms which do not have these true chordocentra. - From reviewer 2: Your “Teleostei” vertebra seem too large for Teleostei of the Middle Jurassic. The only teleost in the Middle to Upper Jurassic with completely ossified vertebra centra of this size (~5 mm) is the Ichthyodectiform Thrissops (see for example Nybelin 1964, Ebert 2025). But to me these vertebrae look completely different. To me the vertebrae in Fig 28A looks more like those in the halecomorph Amiopsis or Ionoscopus with the typical two deep depressions (see Grande & Bemis 1998). Fig. 28B-E: For me, the figured vertebrae look more like chondrichthyan vertebrae. These vertebrae are too large for teleost vertebrae of Jurassic. The larges Thrissops vertebrae from the Upper Jurassic (Kimmeridgian/Tithonian) are approximately 7 mm wide und 8 mm high and they were very rare. Mid-Jurassic Ichthyodectiformes were presumably smaller and all other teleost with completely ossified vertebra centra at that time were not larger than 10 to 20 cm. Thrissops vertebrae have a small outer rim that immediately descends to the centre. Teleosts are most probably present, but you should look for teleost vertebrae in the sizes <5 mm. These small vertebrae are often overlooked or simply not sampled. Response : Comments in the text about syntax have been considered and modified. Both comments about ‘Teleostei’ vertebrae are well founded and we thank the reviewers for the constructive review. Since both reviews were diverging on the identification, we asked another opinion from Gilles Cuny, expert in chondrichthyans. It seems that without thin section, it is practically impossible to determine whether the vertebrae are Chondrichthyans or Actinopterygians, but some of them, especially the one in Fig 29 is identified as Actinopterygian. We agree on the Amiopsis similarity, comments in text have been made on this point. We have agreed to identify most vertebrae as undetermined actinopterygians. We think this is not the core information of the article, and some vertebrae are small, indicating small fishes, the latter being eaten by larger fishes the same way if they were teleostean, halecomorphs or any other kind of actinopterygian, which is the main information to retain. To editor: - Fig 1 is a map remade entirely by S. Beaufils and is made by using free online and open access resources from BRGM., which have an open-science policy: https://www.brgm.fr/en/activities/knowledge-dissemination-open-science - Following the link https://infoterre.brgm.fr/page/conditions-dutilisation-donnees you can download the ETALAB licence ouverte pdf information https://www.etalab.gouv.fr/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/ETALAB-Licence-Ouverte-v2.0.pdf regarding BRGM copyright policies, which permit reuse and derivative works with attribution. - Fig 14 is properly cited - Reviewers’ recommendations about literature have been followed according to relevance and to our responses Submitted filename: Response to Reviewers.docx 11 Feb 2026 -->PONE-D-25-45591R1-->-->Composition and paleoecology of the mid-Jurassic bony fish assemblage of the Vaches Noires cliffs (Normandy, France).-->-->PLOS One Dear Dr. Beaufils, Thank you for submitting your revised manuscript to PLOS ONE. The revised manuscript has been re-evaluated by the same reviewers who examined the first version. We thank you for the careful amendments made to the original manuscript and find the revised document to be nearly ready for acceptance, pending some final and relatively straightforward minor corrections and clarifications. These last modifications should not take you long to implement.-->--> -->-->Below, a short list of last comments by Dr. Cooper are appended to the message. The other reviewer had only one minor comment, which I copy here: "In Fig. 32: Dapedium and Tetragonolepis are not Halecomorphi". -->-->Please review the comments made by both reviewers and implement these last corrections. In cases where you disagree with the proposed correction, please explain your rationale.-->--> -->-->Once I have received your revised manuscript, I look forward to helping move your paper toward publication.-->--> -->-->Please submit your revised manuscript by Mar 28 2026 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org . When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript:--> A letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'.A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'.An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. A letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. -->If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, please include your updated statement in your cover letter. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols . Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols . We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Leon Claessens, Ph.D. Academic Editor PLOS One Journal Requirements: If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. Please review your reference list to ensure that it is complete and correct. If you have cited papers that have been retracted, please include the rationale for doing so in the manuscript text, or remove these references and replace them with relevant current references. Any changes to the reference list should be mentioned in the rebuttal letter that accompanies your revised manuscript. If you need to cite a retracted article, indicate the article’s retracted status in the References list and also include a citation and full reference for the retraction notice. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions -->Comments to the Author 1. If the authors have adequately addressed your comments raised in a previous round of review and you feel that this manuscript is now acceptable for publication, you may indicate that here to bypass the “Comments to the Author” section, enter your conflict of interest statement in the “Confidential to Editor” section, and submit your "Accept" recommendation.--> Reviewer #1: (No Response) ********** -->2. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions? The manuscript must describe a technically sound piece of scientific research with data that supports the conclusions. Experiments must have been conducted rigorously, with appropriate controls, replication, and sample sizes. The conclusions must be drawn appropriately based on the data presented. --> Reviewer #1: Yes ********** -->3. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously? --> Reviewer #1: N/A ********** -->4. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available? The PLOS Data policy requires authors to make all data underlying the findings described in their manuscript fully available without restriction, with rare exception (please refer to the Data Availability Statement in the manuscript PDF file). The data should be provided as part of the manuscript or its supporting information, or deposited to a public repository. For example, in addition to summary statistics, the data points behind means, medians and variance measures should be available. If there are restrictions on publicly sharing data—e.g. participant privacy or use of data from a third party—those must be specified.--> Reviewer #1: Yes ********** -->5. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English? PLOS ONE does not copyedit accepted manuscripts, so the language in submitted articles must be clear, correct, and unambiguous. Any typographical or grammatical errors should be corrected at revision, so please note any specific errors here.--> Reviewer #1: Yes ********** -->6. Review Comments to the Author Please use the space provided to explain your answers to the questions above. You may also include additional comments for the author, including concerns about dual publication, research ethics, or publication ethics. (Please upload your review as an attachment if it exceeds 20,000 characters)--> Reviewer #1: Dear authors and editor, I am more than satisfied with the responses by the authors who have addressed all of my previous comments well. Again, I congratulate the authors on their work, for the formation and more importantly the age of the fossils they have presented are poorly documented in the literature on Mesozoic fishes. This study contributes an important wealth of knowledge on actinopterygian diversity and biogeography in the Middle Jurassic. I have noticed a few minor things that the authors should address below, most are related to grammar, but nothing major. Otherwise, I would be happy to see this manuscript published in its present form, pending these very minor corrections. sincerely, Samuel Cooper, Stuttgart Line 380 – do not need commas ‘,’ before word “in Normandy” as ‘in’ is a bridge word. Line 381 – Early (spelling). Line 522 – Orthocormus cf tenuirostris should have (Woodward, 1889) in brackets as he originally described this species as Hypsocormus tenuirostris Line 589 – lower case ‘a’ in “actinopterygians” – change “who” to ‘that’ chondrichthyians and actinopterygians should be lower case as they are informal taxonomic names, unless at the beginning of a sentence. 594 – Do the authors mean ‘centra’ (pleural)? 594 – change “ thin section: to ‘thin sectioning’ or ‘histology’ 595 – change “state” to ‘differentiate’ 758 – there are several large pliosaurs in the oxford clay that could have injured the tail fin specimen, perhaps edit slightly to say “following a probable attack by a large pliosaur, like Liopleurodon ferox.” 808 – change to “Halecomorphi-like” or “halecomorph-like” 809 – change to ‘teleosteomorph-like fishes’ or just ‘teleosteomorphs’. 813 – change to either “other genera” or “another genus”. 814 – Kimmeridge Clay Formation 814 – remains (pleural) – consider changing to say “…too incomplete to confidently refer to genus level” 819 – I do not know why previous authors have scaled up these Trachymetopon specimens based on Axelrodichthys when they refer them to Trachymetopon. Trachymetopon liassicum, the type and only species is based on a virtually complete and fully articulated specimen from Ohmden, housed in the University of Tubingen. 868 – Lyme Regis is the name for one small town along the Jurassic coast, it is not called the Lyme Regis coast. Change to just ‘…area of Lyme Regis (Dorset)’. 868 – change to ‘Holzmaden area’ as this incorporates a lot of the nearby localities where most of these taxa are found – e.g., Ohmden, Bad Boll. 876 – delete comma after ‘ranges’ ‘..represents a shallow…’ 879 – Ptycholepis spp. – present are Ptycholepis curta (curtus), P. monolifer, P. minor ect. 881 – specifically by Chondrosteus acipenseroides Egerton ex. Agassiz 882 – Tetragonolepis is (to my knowledge) not found in Lyme Regis – Tetragonolepis is a Toarcian genus named by Bronn (1830) which Agassiz used for describing his species that would later be moved to Dapedium Leach, including those from Lyme Regis. 884 – what do you mean by yielding more than 50 type species? 50 type species from Lyme Regis? 886 – change “at Toarcian” to “in the Toarcian” 893 – say “The Posidonienschiefer Formation, predominately quarried from the Holzmaden area near Stuttgart, is widely distributed across Baden-Württemberg. 889 – delete ‘basal’ 889 – also a true hypsocormine based on an isolated mandible, Sauropsis veruinalis may represent an additional hypsocormine 891 – delete “a” after Ohmdenia (Saurostomus and Germanostomus are also transitional forms, although less derived than Ohmdenia). 904 – ‘has also been described by Cooper (2025)’ 909 – Acipenseriformes 948 – consider revising as “The Kimmeridge Clay also contains a large indeterminate acipenseriform (Chondrostei)” 948 – Teleosteomorpha is represented by… 1004 – change “in analysis” to ‘under study’ and delete the following sentence, and change in the following sentence “this taxon” to “Eurypoma’ grande. ********** -->7. PLOS authors have the option to publish the peer review history of their article (what does this mean? ). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy .--> Reviewer #1: Yes: Samuel L. A. Cooper ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] To ensure your figures meet our technical requirements, please review our figure guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures You may also use PLOS’s free figure tool, NAAS, to help you prepare publication quality figures: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures#loc-tools-for-figure-preparation. NAAS will assess whether your figures meet our technical requirements by comparing each figure against our figure specifications. --> 19 Feb 2026 Dear editor, Dear Reviewers We thank both reviewers for the last comments Reviewer comments are in red, our responses are in black. Supplementary comments in text have been addressed. Last comments have all been implemented, from both reviewers. Comments from Dr Cooper : 819 – I do not know why previous authors have scaled up these Trachymetopon specimens based on Axelrodichthys when they refer them to Trachymetopon. Trachymetopon liassicum, the type and only species is based on a virtually complete and fully articulated specimen from Ohmden, housed in the University of Tubingen. It’s because we had a well-made reconstruction of the skeleton of A. araripensis at our disposal. Furthermore, all these coelacanths, especially Mawsoniids, have a pretty conservative morphology. We think that reconstructing size either with Trachymetopon or Axelrodichthys will give the same results. Line 380 – do not need commas ‘,’ before word “in Normandy” as ‘in’ is a bridge word. Line 381 – Early (spelling). Line 522 – Orthocormus cf tenuirostris should have (Woodward, 1889) in brackets as he originally described this species as Hypsocormus tenuirostris Line 589 – lower case ‘a’ in “actinopterygians” – change “who” to ‘that’ chondrichthyians and actinopterygians should be lower case as they are informal taxonomic names, unless at the beginning of a sentence. 594 – Do the authors mean ‘centra’ (pleural)? 594 – change “ thin section: to ‘thin sectioning’ or ‘histology’ 595 – change “state” to ‘differentiate’ 758 – there are several large pliosaurs in the oxford clay that could have injured the tail fin specimen, perhaps edit slightly to say “following a probable attack by a large pliosaur, like Liopleurodon ferox.” 808 – change to “Halecomorphi-like” or “halecomorph-like” 809 – change to ‘teleosteomorph-like fishes’ or just ‘teleosteomorphs’. 813 – change to either “other genera” or “another genus”. 814 – Kimmeridge Clay Formation 814 – remains (pleural) – consider changing to say “…too incomplete to confidently refer to genus level” 868 – Lyme Regis is the name for one small town along the Jurassic coast, it is not called the Lyme Regis coast. Change to just ‘…area of Lyme Regis (Dorset)’. 868 – change to ‘Holzmaden area’ as this incorporates a lot of the nearby localities where most of these taxa are found – e.g., Ohmden, Bad Boll. 876 – delete comma after ‘ranges’ ‘..represents a shallow…’ 879 – Ptycholepis spp. – present are Ptycholepis curta (curtus), P. monolifer, P. minor ect. 881 – specifically by Chondrosteus acipenseroides Egerton ex. Agassiz 882 – Tetragonolepis is (to my knowledge) not found in Lyme Regis – Tetragonolepis is a Toarcian genus named by Bronn (1830) which Agassiz used for describing his species that would later be moved to Dapedium Leach, including those from Lyme Regis. 886 – change “at Toarcian” to “in the Toarcian” 893 – say “The Posidonienschiefer Formation, predominately quarried from the Holzmaden area near Stuttgart, is widely distributed across Baden-Württemberg. 889 – delete ‘basal’ 889 – also a true hypsocormine based on an isolated mandible, Sauropsis veruinalis may represent an additional hypsocormine 891 – delete “a” after Ohmdenia (Saurostomus and Germanostomus are also transitional forms, although less derived than Ohmdenia). 904 – ‘has also been described by Cooper (2025)’ 909 – Acipenseriformes 948 – consider revising as “The Kimmeridge Clay also contains a large indeterminate acipenseriform (Chondrostei)” 948 – Teleosteomorpha is represented by… 1004 – change “in analysis” to ‘under study’ and delete the following sentence, and change in the following sentence “this taxon” to “Eurypoma’ grande. All these comments above about grammar have been taken into account and changed in both manuscript and manuscript with track changes 884 – what do you mean by yielding more than 50 type species? 50 type species from Lyme Regis? Yes. In Dineley and Metcalf, 1999, it is said, I quote “Lyme Regis is the type locality for 50 or more species of fish.” Comments from Reviewer 2 : In Fig. 32: Dapedium and Tetragonolepis are not Halecomorphi Fig 32 has been modified in accordance with this comment. Dapedium and Tetragonolepis have been moved to a line of their own, the Dapediidae. The figure has been downloaded and is replacing the old Fig 32. Submitted filename: Response_to_Reviewers_auresp_2.docx 22 Feb 2026 Composition and paleoecology of the mid-Jurassic bony fish assemblage of the Vaches Noires cliffs (Normandy, France). PONE-D-25-45591R2 Dear Dr. Beaufils, We’re pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been judged scientifically suitable for publication and will be formally accepted for publication once it meets all outstanding technical requirements. Within one week, you’ll receive an e-mail detailing the required amendments. When these have been addressed, you’ll receive a formal acceptance letter and your manuscript will be scheduled for publication. An invoice will be generated when your article is formally accepted. Please note, if your institution has a publishing partnership with PLOS and your article meets the relevant criteria, all or part of your publication costs will be covered. Please make sure your user information is up-to-date by logging into Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager® and clicking the ‘Update My Information' link at the top of the page. For questions related to billing, please contact billing support . If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming paper to help maximize its impact. If they’ll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team as soon as possible -- no later than 48 hours after receiving the formal acceptance. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. Kind regards, Leon Claessens, Ph.D. Academic Editor PLOS One Additional Editor Comments (optional): Reviewers' comments: PONE-D-25-45591R2 PLOS One Dear Dr. Beaufils, I'm pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been deemed suitable for publication in PLOS One. Congratulations! Your manuscript is now being handed over to our production team. At this stage, our production department will prepare your paper for publication. This includes ensuring the following: * All references, tables, and figures are properly cited * All relevant supporting information is included in the manuscript submission, * There are no issues that prevent the paper from being properly typeset You will receive further instructions from the production team, including instructions on how to review your proof when it is ready. Please keep in mind that we are working through a large volume of accepted articles, so please give us a few days to review your paper and let you know the next and final steps. Lastly, if your institution or institutions have a press office, please let them know about your upcoming paper now to help maximize its impact. If they'll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team within the next 48 hours. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. You will receive an invoice from PLOS for your publication fee after your manuscript has reached the completed accept phase. If you receive an email requesting payment before acceptance or for any other service, this may be a phishing scheme. Learn how to identify phishing emails and protect your accounts at https://explore.plos.org/phishing. If we can help with anything else, please email us at customercare@plos.org. Thank you for submitting your work to PLOS ONE and supporting open access. Kind regards, PLOS ONE Editorial Office Staff on behalf of Dr. Leon Claessens Academic Editor PLOS One