Specific Cultural Myths Impacting Antipsychotic Drug Adherence: Reclaiming Healthy Thinking Through Emotional Recovery Authors: Sarah Merritt Ryan Published: 2026 To understand why taking antipsychotics and staying on them is difficult, the stigma behind the medicine, similar to psychosis itself and hospitalization, must be considered.1 While anosognosia and the negotiating of side effects with antipsychotics are two established reasons why taking antipsychotics is difficult,2,3 there exists an array of cultural myths based on stigma that assign profound, yet unfounded meanings to antipsychotic drugs that are almost impossible to escape and resist. These myths can feel as real as the illness itself. No other type of pharmaceutical pill on the market bears such deep, yet illogical meanings. How Emotional Recovery Helps Cut Through Stigma that Produces Illogical Reasoning In my recent Schizophrenia Bulletin Open piece, I mention that tending to specific emotional concerns in early recovery from psychosis strengthens the likelihood of staying on antipsychotics. I define emotional recovery as trusting and believing in yourself again and wanting to be you.4 These components of emotional recovery are related to “self-esteem,” identified previously as a determinant of adherence to antipsychotic medication.5 Being able to identify stigma and navigate cultural beliefs about antipsychotic use stems directly from the confidence and motivation a patient cultivates through being able to trust and believe in themselves again. Only once they can do so again are they capable of truly thinking for themselves, undoing logical fallacies, and making decisions based on self-care and self-preservation, versus merely worrying what others might think and accepting what common culture tells them to think. My Lived Experience and Background with Peers I am a survivor of schizophrenia who has made a full cognitive and emotional recovery. My insight on these cultural myths based on stigma is through making many of these mistakes myself, even as a well-educated, responsible, and conscientious person. The first time I wanted to go off my antipsychotic, my counselor tried to reason with me based on explaining to me what anosognosia is, and how once I’m psychotic, I won’t understand what is happening or have any control. That compelling, logical explanation did not stop me. While I had a serious side effect that was a legitimate factor, so much of my concern was not logical—it was an emotionally charged decision based on stigma. I went off the drug and eventually had my first major psychotic break and then two more. I learned the hard way that I need to stay on an antipsychotic for life. I saw taking an antipsychotic as holding me back from the rest of my life where I could not move on, but the reality was the complete opposite. I could not move forward in life without an antipsychotic. Once recovered and on medication for life, I have gotten married, given birth to a son, have rebuilt a new career, enjoy a supportive community of good friends, fellow parents, and colleagues, and now have actually accomplished more post-illness than I had in mind for myself pre-illness. In addition to a Master of Science degree in Communication, I am a Certified Peer Support Specialist through the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Social Work. I have a Personal Perspectives blog with Psychology Today, and I write for Nami.org and Writer’s Digest on topics related to stigma and emotional recovery from psychosis. My insights on cultural myths are confirmed through more than 3 years as lead facilitator for a local, weekly National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) support group, working with people living with chronic mental health condition, most of whom take antipsychotics. In addition to the myths that influenced me, I have learned of additional cultural myths from my peers as well. Seven Cultural Myths Perpetuated by Stigma A deeper awareness and understanding of specific cultural myths by mental health professionals and how to unravel them can help support patients and prevent them from going off antipsychotics for wrong, untimely reasons, leading to relapse. Non-adherence is the greatest predictor of relapse for psychosis in seven long-term studies, increasing chance of relapse by 400%.6 On the most basic level, stigma translates to going off antipsychotics equating to: exoneration; starting over with a clean slate where I have nothing to hide; there was nothing ever really wrong with me; and I can be “normal” just like everyone else now. Diving deeper though, I identify seven cultural myths that produce reverse logic on why to go off an antipsychotic, along with the reason for non-adherence associated with each myth. I also provide healthy rationales, which I have formed personally, that navigate these myths now that I can identify stigma for what it is. Myth 1: Only if I keep taking an antipsychotic does it mean I have a serious mental illness. Reason: Going off an antipsychotic to prove I am not ill. Reason: Going off an antipsychotic to prove I am not ill. New rationale: Not taking a medicine does not make an illness go away. I have a medical condition whether I take medicine for it or not. I wouldn’t be prescribed an antipsychotic if I did not first demonstrate a psychotic symptom. New rationale: Not taking a medicine does not make an illness go away. I have a medical condition whether I take medicine for it or not. I wouldn’t be prescribed an antipsychotic if I did not first demonstrate a psychotic symptom. Myth 2: My life is over if I have to stay on an antipsychotic. Reason: Going off an antipsychotic so I have nothing embarrassing to hide. Reason: Going off an antipsychotic so I have nothing embarrassing to hide. New rationale: My life may only be over if I don’t take an antipsychotic. I may not be able to move forward with my life goals and achieve them without medical intervention. I can date and meet someone while taking an antipsychotic. It is far more embarrassing to have a psychotic break than to take an antipsychotic. New rationale: My life may only be over if I don’t take an antipsychotic. I may not be able to move forward with my life goals and achieve them without medical intervention. I can date and meet someone while taking an antipsychotic. It is far more embarrassing to have a psychotic break than to take an antipsychotic. Myth 3: If I agree to take an antipsychotic, it will lead to getting a stigmatized diagnosis, the worst being schizophrenia. Reason: Refusing to try an antipsychotic in the first place, like taking one marks me for life in a way that is irreversible. Reason: Refusing to try an antipsychotic in the first place, like taking one marks me for life in a way that is irreversible. New rationale: I cannot make my medical condition go away by not addressing it. It is not worth going untreated for a medical illness that could become catastrophic to avoid a stigmatized diagnosis. It is more important to be safe and well than avoid a medical diagnosis. New rationale: I cannot make my medical condition go away by not addressing it. It is not worth going untreated for a medical illness that could become catastrophic to avoid a stigmatized diagnosis. It is more important to be safe and well than avoid a medical diagnosis. Myth 4: I’m not the kind of person who needs to take an antipsychotic. Reason: Refusing antipsychotics to prove that I am not the “type” of person who gets serious mental illness (SMI). Reason: Refusing antipsychotics to prove that I am not the “type” of person who gets serious mental illness (SMI). New rationale: It could be that the only things “wrong” with me could be resolved by the antipsychotic. If the antipsychotic makes the problems go away, that is proof that whatever problem or “flaw” I had was purely medical and has nothing to do with me as a person. New rationale: It could be that the only things “wrong” with me could be resolved by the antipsychotic. If the antipsychotic makes the problems go away, that is proof that whatever problem or “flaw” I had was purely medical and has nothing to do with me as a person. Myth 5: My partner says I don’t need to be on an antipsychotic—we’re getting serious and they believe in me. Reason: Going off the antipsychotic is the next step forward in our relationship getting serious and leading somewhere. Reason: Going off the antipsychotic is the next step forward in our relationship getting serious and leading somewhere. New rationale: Someone telling me I should go off an antipsychotic can be a well-intended token of faith, like they have confidence and trust in me as a person. But whether I take an antipsychotic or not has nothing to do with how reliable and responsible I am and if I am capable and worthy of being in a successful relationship. New rationale: Someone telling me I should go off an antipsychotic can be a well-intended token of faith, like they have confidence and trust in me as a person. But whether I take an antipsychotic or not has nothing to do with how reliable and responsible I am and if I am capable and worthy of being in a successful relationship. Myth 6: The goal is to go off antipsychotics as soon as I don’t need them anymore. Reason: Going off an antipsychotic as soon as I stabilize. Reason: Going off an antipsychotic as soon as I stabilize. New rationale: I have no way of knowing that it is not the antipsychotics keeping me well. Is it really worth risking my recovery and potentially having another break to find out? If I have another break, I will have to start out all over again. New rationale: I have no way of knowing that it is not the antipsychotics keeping me well. Is it really worth risking my recovery and potentially having another break to find out? If I have another break, I will have to start out all over again. Myth 7: I shouldn’t stay on antipsychotics because they cause side effects. Reason: Going off antipsychotics because they are “bad” for me, it is “pseudo-science,” and I know best. Reason: Going off antipsychotics because they are “bad” for me, it is “pseudo-science,” and I know best. New rationale: All drugs have side effects, but sometimes the benefits outweigh the risks. Are the side effects worse than having another break? Side effects from antipsychotics can be serious, but I need to remember what the drug is doing to prevent illness at the same time, even if just observable through an absence of symptoms. New rationale: All drugs have side effects, but sometimes the benefits outweigh the risks. Are the side effects worse than having another break? Side effects from antipsychotics can be serious, but I need to remember what the drug is doing to prevent illness at the same time, even if just observable through an absence of symptoms. Conclusion I believe that understanding the value of emotional recovery, understanding stigma-produced cultural myths, and learning how to address them as mental health professionals with patients would improve medicine adherence and relapse prevention. While I do not provide medical advice to peers and do not use these rationales with them, I do believe there could be a beneficial way to incorporate these healthy rationales in a therapeutic setting that promotes better decision making.