Scalable modeling of multi-spin ensembles in SABRE hyperpolarization: a symmetry-based framework for zero and ultralow fields Authors: Danil Markelov, Alexander Snadin, Alexey Kiryutin, Danila Barskiy, Alexandra Yurkovskaya Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractThis work presents a theoretical framework for quantitative, scalable modeling of signal amplification by reversible exchange (SABRE) experiments under zero- and ultralow-field (ZULF) conditions. SABRE exploits the singlet spin order of parahydrogen to hyperpolarize nuclear spins of substrates without chemical modification, enhancing NMR signals. In the ZULF SABRE method, polarization transfer occurs in ultralow magnetic fields where Zeeman interactions are comparable to or weaker than scalar couplings, enabling coherent mixing of spin states and revealing interactions often suppressed at high fields. Our approach captures the full quantum dynamics of SABRE, including coherent evolution, chemical exchange, and relaxation, within a Liouville space formalism. We demonstrate that the Hamiltonian, relaxation, and exchange superoperators possess symmetry with respect to the total spin, allowing the dynamics to be rigorously restricted to the zero-quantum coherence subspace. This symmetry-based reduction yields a scalable framework for efficient simulation of multi-spin SABRE systems, allowing the treatment of arbitrary spin ensembles, including those containing 15N , 13C , 1H , and other nuclei. The approach is validated against full Liouville space calculations for small systems and is further applied to a 14-spin SABRE complex, demonstrating its ability to treat spin systems of a complexity well beyond the reach of conventional full Liouville space simulations. The framework thus provides a predictive tool for optimal polarization fields, ZULF NMR spectra, and the design of novel hyperpolarization experiments. Introduction Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) is a powerful spectroscopic technique that provides detailed information about molecular structure and dynamics. Its sensitivity, however, is fundamentally limited by the low thermal polarization of nuclear spins, a limitation that is particularly severe for heteronuclei whose low gyromagnetic ratios and natural abundances result in intrinsically weak NMR signals (Levitt, 2008). Enhancing the polarization levels, i.e. hyperpolarization, of the magnetic nuclei is therefore of central importance for extending the applicability of NMR to chemically and biologically relevant systems (Eills et al., 2023; Petersen et al., 2025; McBride et al., 2025; Kuhn et al., 2023; Zachrdla et al., 2025; Cavallari et al., 2018; Angelovski et al., 2023; Keshari and Wilson, 2014; Boutin et al., 2011). Among the available hyperpolarization techniques, signal amplification by reversible exchange (SABRE) has emerged as a versatile and experimentally accessible method for boosting NMR sensitivity (Adams et al., 2009; Rayner and Duckett, 2018; Buntkowsky et al., 2022; Pravdivtsev et al., 2021; Atkinson et al., 2009). In SABRE, the spin order of parahydrogen is transferred to a target substrate through reversible binding to a transient metal–ligand complex, without permanent chemical modification of the molecule, as shown in Fig. 1A (Barskiy et al., 2019; Pravdivtsev et al., 2013; Shchepin et al., 2019). Importantly, SABRE has been shown to efficiently hyperpolarize a variety of heteronuclear spin systems, including 13C -, 15N -, 19F -, 31P -, and 77Se -containing compounds (Kozinenko et al., 2025; Vaneeckhaute et al., 2023; Svyatova et al., 2019; Schmidt et al., 2023; Kiryutin et al., 2025; Markelov et al., 2024; Kiryutin et al., 2018; Burns et al., 2015; Olaru et al., 2018; Markelov et al., 2025; TomHon et al., 2025; Zheng et al., 2026). In biological NMR, heteronuclear detection is especially advantageous, as proton-based experiments are limited by the strong water background and short relaxation times (Mishra et al., 2016; Cho et al., 2019; Kim et al., 2025; Dey et al., 2020; Park and Wang, 2022). Conceptual overview of the symmetry-based framework for SABRE under zero- and ultralow-field (ZULF) NMR conditions. (A) The full Liouville space has a dimension of 4N , where N is the number of spins, rendering simulations of SABRE that include coherent spin evolution, relaxation, and chemical exchange computationally demanding. (B) Two symmetry reductions are employed: (1) permutation symmetry of equivalent spins, which is exploited via the introduction of effective spins K , and (2) conservation of the total spin projection Fz , which allows the dynamics to be rigorously restricted to the zero-quantum coherence (ZQC) subspace. (C) As a result, the problem is reduced to a substantially smaller ZQC Liouville space representation that still fully captures the relevant spin dynamics, thereby enabling quantitative simulations of multi-spin SABRE systems. Importantly, the efficiency of SABRE hyperpolarization is governed by the coherent spin dynamics within the coupled spin network formed by the parahydrogen-derived hydrides and the nuclear spins of the substrate in the transient metal complex (Pravdivtsev et al., 2013; Pravdivtsev et al., 2015; Ivanov et al., 2014; Pravdivtsev et al., 2014; Pravdivtsev et al., 2014; Pravdivtsev et al., 2014; Kiryutin et al., 2013). Despite growing experimental interest in SABRE, the number of rigorous theoretical models describing its spin dynamics remains relatively limited. In the present work, we adopt a fully rigorous description of SABRE spin dynamics based on a Liouville space formulation, in which coherent evolution, relaxation, and chemical exchange are treated on equal footing through a master equation. Although alternative approaches exist (Lindale et al., 2020), our focus here is specifically on a framework that captures the complete quantum dynamics of the system (Knecht et al., 2020; Knecht and Ivanov, 2019; Knecht et al., 2016). This approach is firmly rooted in the standard theory of NMR spin dynamics (Limbach, 1991; Abergel and Palmer, 2005; Cuperlovic et al., 2000; Zaiss and Bachert, 2013; Schwartz et al., 1982; Jameson and Bruschweiler, 2021) and provides a conceptually transparent description of SABRE polarization transfer. However, the dimensionality of Liouville space grows exponentially with the number of spins involved, making direct simulations computationally intractable for large heteronuclear SABRE systems; see Fig. 1A. Consequently, the development of a general and scalable framework for such multi-spin ensembles remains a significant challenge. Motivated by this, we present in this work a complementary approach to recent efforts (Mamone et al., 2025) that leverages symmetry to render the full Liouville space treatment computationally tractable for complex SABRE systems. In parallel with the development of hyperpolarization methods, zero- and ultralow-field (ZULF) NMR has been gaining increasing attention as a rapidly developing complement to conventional high-field NMR that enables access to spin dynamics and interactions inaccessible at high magnetic fields (Blanchard and Budker, 2016; Blanchard et al., 2020; Ledbetter et al., 2011; Ledbetter et al., 2009; Put et al., 2021; Kiryutin et al., 2021; Barskiy et al., 2025; Barskiy et al., 2019; Xu et al., 2026; Sheberstov et al., 2021). In this regime, experiments are performed in magnetic fields where Zeeman interactions are comparable to or weaker than scalar J couplings. ZULF NMR therefore offers several distinctive advantages that have driven its increasing adoption. The absence of a strong static magnetic field eliminates line broadening due to magnetic field inhomogeneities and enables exceptionally high spectral resolution (Blanchard et al., 2013; Picazo-Frutos et al., 2024; Sjolander et al., 2020). Moreover, ZULF NMR is inherently compatible with compact, magnetically shielded setups and non-inductive detection schemes based on optically pumped magnetometers, allowing high sensitivity without the need for superconducting magnets (Ledbetter et al., 2009; Jiang et al., 2019; Hong et al., 2025). For heteronuclear systems in particular, ZULF NMR provides access to spin interactions and dynamical effects that are strongly suppressed or effectively truncated at high magnetic fields (Blanchard et al., 2015; Teleanu et al., 2025; Pravdivtsev et al., 2013). In the ZULF regime, heteronuclear spin evolution is governed by the full, non-secular spin Hamiltonian, allowing otherwise negligible coupling terms and coherent mixing of spin states to influence the observed spectra (Kiryutin et al., 2021; Zhukov et al., 2020; Zhukov et al., 2021). This makes ZULF NMR especially well-suited for probing heteronuclear spin dynamics beyond the high-field approximation. The combination of the parahydrogen-based hyperpolarization with zero- and ultralow-field NMR provides a powerful approach for enhancing the sensitivity of NMR detection (Theis et al., 2012; Theis et al., 2011; Buckenmaier et al., 2025; Rodriguez et al., 2025; Van Dyke et al., 2022; Put et al., 2023). By leveraging hyperpolarization in the ultralow-field regime, enhanced signals can be observed from collective spin states comprising 1H , 13C , 15N , and other nuclei. The theoretical consideration of SABRE under the ZULF conditions, or ZULF SABRE, is helpful for guiding the design of experiments, estimating optimal fields for polarization buildup, and predicting ZULF NMR spectra, thereby supporting the development of new polarization transfer strategies and their adaptation to the unique conditions of SABRE systems. Theoretical and computational studies of SABRE spin dynamics have attracted significant attention in recent years. In a number of works, it has been shown that the key contributions to polarization transfer in SABRE can be understood in terms of zero-quantum operators, highlighting the central role of the zero-quantum coherence (ZQC) subspace (Eriksson et al., 2022; Snadin et al., 2024; Markelov et al., 2021; Li et al., 2022). In Liouville space, this subspace is defined by operators with zero eigenvalue of the superoperator of the z projection of the total spin, F^^z , where the quantization axis is set by the direction of the ultralow external magnetic field. In particular, Mamone et al. (2025) demonstrated that the description in terms of zero-quantum operators, including exchange and relaxation, successfully captures SABRE dynamics while reducing the dimensionality of the problem. Here, we place these observations on a rigorous footing. We formally show (Fig. 1B) that the Hamiltonian, relaxation, and chemical exchange superoperators in Liouville space possess a well-defined symmetry with respect to F^^z . This symmetry guarantees that the dynamics is restricted to the ZQC subspace and that only these components contribute to polarization transfer in ZULF SABRE. Exploiting this symmetry, we develop a general and scalable computational framework based on systematic restriction to the ZQC subspace (Fig. 1C). The approach is validated against full Liouville space simulations for small spin systems, reproducing exact results while providing computational speedups of 30–50 times. For larger systems, such as a 14-spin SABRE complex, the method enables simulations that would be computationally infeasible in the full Liouville space. Theory Block-diagonal decomposition of Hilbert space We begin by considering the low-field spin Hamiltonian governing the coherent dynamics of a coupled N -spin system (in units of ℏ ): where N is the total number of nuclei in the spin system, B0(t) is an external magnetic field, γl is the gyromagnetic ratio of nucleus l , Jlm is the J -coupling constant between nuclei l and m , and (I^l⋅I^m) denotes the scalar product of the corresponding spin operators. At ultralow magnetic fields, chemical shift terms are neglected. However, the framework presented below is not limited to this regime; chemical shifts can be incorporated straightforwardly without modifying the theoretical description. In this section, we analyze the symmetry properties of the Hamiltonian in Eq. (1) and show that they give rise to a block-diagonal structure in an appropriate basis. As a result, the spin dynamics can be rigorously restricted to invariant subspaces of reduced dimensionality. This symmetry-based reduction provides a practical route for treating large, coupled spin systems and underpins the SABRE applications presented in the subsequent sections. Importantly, throughout this work we treat the general and experimentally relevant case of a non-zero magnetic field, B0≠0 . In practice, a strictly zero field is never realized due to residual magnetic fields, which makes the present approach directly applicable to SABRE polarization transfer at ultralow fields and to the simulation of ZULF NMR spectra across different coupling regimes, ranging from the J -coupling-dominated to the Zeeman-dominated limit (Buckenmaier et al., 2025). A separate and careful symmetry analysis would be required only in the idealized limit B0=0 , which lies beyond the scope of the present study. The group of magnetically equivalent nuclei Assume that we have a group GP of P magnetically equivalent spins, reflecting the underlying molecular symmetry, for instance, the three protons of a methyl ( CH3 ) group or the two protons of a methylene ( CH2 ) group. Therefore, for each external nucleus m∉GP , the J coupling between m and any spin p∈GP is the same: Jmp=JmGP . Thus, the J -coupling constant is independent of the index of the nucleus within GP and depends only on the outer nucleus m . The magnetic equivalence enables us to treat the group GP as a pseudo-nucleus with total spin K . The Hilbert space of P identical spin- 1/2 nuclei can be decomposed into invariant subspaces corresponding to definite total spin (Messiah, 1962): where D1/2i denotes the spin- 1/2 representation for spin i , DK is the irreducible representation of the collective spin system corresponding to total spin K , and is the multiplicity of spin K , where nk=n!/[(n-k)!k!] is the binomial coefficient. This commutation relation, [K^2,H^(t)]=0 , allows the Hamiltonian in Eq. (1) to be block diagonalized according to the total spin K of the group GP (Barskiy and Pravdivtsev, 2025): where Similarly, when the density matrix of the full spin ensemble commutes with the total spin operator, [K^2,ρ^(t)]=0 , it can be decomposed into the corresponding invariant subspaces: where is a statistical weight of the K subspace with ∑K=Kmin⁡P/2gK=1 . Each block of the density matrix is normalized in the usual way, Tr{ρ^K(t)}=1 . For an observable O^ that commutes with the total spin operator, [K^2,O^]=0 , the expectation value can be calculated block-wise. First, the operator is decomposed into the following corresponding blocks: and then the ensemble average is obtained as The z projection of total spin Each block H^K(t) corresponding to the total spin K of the group GP can be further decomposed according to the z projection of the total spin. Specifically, consider a single K block: where γP is the gyromagnetic ratio of a nucleus in the group GP of P magnetically equivalent nuclei, and JlGP denotes the J -coupling constant between an external nucleus l∉GP and the nuclei within the group GP . J couplings within the group GP are omitted as they do not affect the dynamics within the K block. The Hamiltonian H^K(t) commutes with the z projection of the total spin of all nuclei, [F^z,H^K(t)]=0 , where and the first sum runs over a set of non-equivalent spin- 1/2 nuclei outside the group GP . Consequently, H^K(t) is block diagonal with respect to the eigenvalues of F^z , which takes values Fz∈N-P2+K,N-P2+K-1,…,-N-P2-K . In other words, H^K(t) can be decomposed as (2K+1+N-P) blocks: with each block H^K,Fz(t) corresponding to specific values of K and Fz . Coherent spin dynamics The time evolution of the density matrix ρ^(t) is governed by the Liouville–von Neumann (LvN) equation: with an initial state ρ^(0) . If the initial state commutes with the symmetry operators, [K^2,ρ^(0)]=[F^z,ρ^(0)]=0 , then the block-diagonal decomposition of ρ^(0) is valid: where we introduced the reduced density matrices ρ^K,Fz(t) . The dimension of the Fz block in the Hilbert space H , denoted as dim(HFz) , is given by Moreover, if the Hamiltonian commutes with the same symmetry operators, This means that the block-diagonal structure of the density matrix is conserved for all instants of time: The reduced density matrices ρ^K,Fz(t) obey the LvN equation independently within each block: Thus, the block-diagonal decomposition reduces the computational complexity by considering smaller blocks with fixed values of K and Fz independently. Block-diagonal decomposition of Liouville space Coherent spin dynamics In Liouville space, an operator A^ from Hilbert space is mapped to a commutation superoperator A^^ acting on an operator O^ according to At the same time, the density matrix in Liouville space is represented as a vector; see Fig. 2A. Throughout this paper, operators are denoted by hatted symbols, whereas superoperators are denoted by bold double-hatted symbols. Under this mapping, the Hamiltonian H^(t) is represented by the Liouville space superoperator H^^(t) , and similarly, the effective-spin operator K^2 is mapped to the superoperator K^^2 . In Liouville space, the coherent spin dynamics is described by the LvN equation: If the initial density matrix commutes with the effective-spin operator K^2 , i.e., Moreover, Liouville space conserves commutation relations so that Consequently, the block-diagonal structure of the density matrix is conserved during the evolution Therefore, the blocks corresponding to different total spin values K remain uncoupled. Analogous to the Hilbert space treatment, in Liouville space we can also treat the group GP of P magnetically equivalent nuclear spins as a pseudo-nucleus with total spin K∈P2,P2-1,…,Kmin⁡. Schematic illustration of the zero-quantum coherence (ZQC) reduction in Liouville space. (A) Transformation of the density matrix ρ^(t) from Hilbert space to Liouville space. (B) Decomposition of the Hamiltonian and the relaxation superoperators according to the coherence order, i.e., the eigenvalues of F^^z : + 2 (double-quantum coherence, + DQC), + 1 (single-quantum coherence, + SQC), 0 (zero-quantum coherence, ZQC), and the corresponding negative coherence orders. (C) The initial state of the system is assumed to satisfy F^^zρ^(0)=0 so that only ZQC operators are initially populated. (D) Only the ZQC subspace is relevant for spin evolution under the total Liouvillian L^^=-iH^^+Γ^^ , implying that F^^zρ^(t)=0 , and ρ^(t) has no components outside the ZQC subspace. Consequently, all other coherence order subspaces can be omitted without affecting the spin dynamics. Consequently, the dynamics can be considered independently for each K subspace, and the expectation value of an observable is obtained by averaging over the blocks according to Eqs. (8) and (9), as in Hilbert space. The time evolution of the reduced density matrix ρ^K(t) in Liouville space is then given by where we introduced the Hamiltonian superoperator reduced onto the K subspace as H^^K(t)•=[H^K(t),•] , and the density matrix is normalized as Tr{ρ^K(t)}=1 . The symmetry associated with F^z in Hilbert space, see Eq. (11), is directly inherited in Liouville space. To analyze this, the operator F^z is mapped to the corresponding superoperator F^^z using Eq. (19). The eigenvalues of F^^z are commonly referred to as the coherence orders, which are well-known in standard high-field NMR; see Appendix A for details. A key property of the Liouville space evolution of Eq. (24) is Equation (25) is schematically illustrated in Fig. 2B–D. In other words, the coherent dynamics in Liouville space conserves evolution strictly within the subspace of zero eigenvalue of F^^z , i.e., the zero-quantum coherence (ZQC) block. The ZQC subspace is spanned by operators of the following form, as discussed in Appendix A: with Fz∈N-P2+K,N-P2+K-1,…,-N-P2-K and ξ,λ run over all possible magnetic quantum numbers of the individual nuclear spins for a given value of the z projection of total spin Fz . The coherent evolution within the ZQC block is then governed by the standard LvN equation; see Eq. (24): where the dynamics is restricted to the ZQC subspace, as illustrated in Fig. 2D. Here, we also introduced H^^KZQC(t) as the Hamiltonian superoperator projected onto the ZQC subspace. The subscript ZQC of the density matrix is omitted since ρ^K(t)≡0 outside the ZQC subspace; see Fig. 2D. We also emphasize that the consideration of the ZQC subspace drastically reduces the dimensionality of the problem. The full Liouville space has a dimension of 4N , whereas the ZQC subspace with the effective-spin reduction has a smaller dimension: where Eq. (15) was used to calculate dim(HFz) . This restriction to the ZQC subspace allows efficient treatment of spin dynamics by working with a smaller independent block rather than the full Liouville space. Relaxational spin dynamics Relaxational spin dynamics is described within the Redfield formalism, which leads to the following equation of motion for the density matrix ρ^(t) : where H^^(t) is the coherent Hamiltonian superoperator, Γ^^ is the relaxational superoperator describing stochastically modulated dynamics, and L^^(t)=-iH^^(t)+Γ^^ is the total Liouvillian. In this work, we used the random fluctuating field (RFF) mechanism in the fast-motion limit, also known as the extreme narrowing regime. Within this approximation, the relaxation superoperator takes the following form (Pileio, 2010): where we assumed that the local fields are isotropic and introduced the following quantities: T1n is the longitudinal T1 -relaxation time of the nucleus n , Cnl∈[0,1] is a correlation constant between the local fluctuating magnetic fields at the spatial positions of nuclear spins n and l (Freeman et al., 1970), and T^^1,mn•=[T^1,mn,•] is the rank-1 irreducible spherical superoperator acting on nucleus n . The corresponding spherical tensor operators are defined as For the spin systems containing a group GP of P magnetically equivalent nuclei (e.g. CH2 or CH3 groups), Eq. (30) can be rewritten in a more convenient form by separating contributions from equivalent and non-equivalent spins: where we have explicitly accounted for the equivalence of the nuclei in group GP . Specifically, all nuclei in GP are assumed to have identical longitudinal relaxation times T1P , and the local fluctuating magnetic fields at their spatial positions are taken to be fully correlated, such that Cnl=1 for n,l∈GP . All other local fields are assumed to be uncorrelated; i.e., Cnl=0 if either n∉GP or l∉GP . The second term in Eq. (32), and therefore the full relaxation superoperator Γ^^ , commutes with the superoperator of the total spin of the group GP , K^^2 . This follows from the identity which represents a scalar product of rank-1 spherical superoperators in Liouville space (Pyper, 1971). This is fully analogous to the Hilbert space, where the scalar product of equivalent nuclear spins, ∑n,l∈GP(I^n⋅I^l) , commutes with K^2 . As a consequence, [K^^2,Γ^^]=0 , and the relaxation superoperator can be decomposed into independent blocks corresponding to different values of K^^2 . Importantly, we are interested only in the zero-eigenvalue subspace of K^^2 since Therefore, relaxational dynamics also conserves the density matrix ρ^(t) within the zero-eigenvalue subspace of K^^2 ; i.e. K^^2ρ^(t)=[K^2,ρ^(t)]=0 . As a consequence, the blocks of the density matrix corresponding to different values of the total spin K of the magnetically equivalent nuclei in the group GP are not mixed by relaxation. This allows us to treat relaxation independently for each value of the nuclear spin K∈P2,P2-1,…,Kmin⁡ of the group GP (Doronin et al., 2011) and introduce the reduced relaxation superoperator where T^^1(K),m is a rank-1 irreducible spherical superoperator constructed for a spin K according to Eq. (31). A crucial property of the superoperator Γ^^K is that it commutes with the superoperator F^^z : This follows from the identities which represent scalar products of rank-1 spherical superoperators in Liouville space. Such scalar products are rotationally invariant and therefore commute with F^^z (this can also be verified by direct evaluation of the commutators). Combining Eqs. (25) and (36), we obtain F^^zρ^K(t)=0 for any t . Thus, relaxational dynamics driven by Γ^^K and, therefore, the full Liouville space dynamics governed by Eq. (29) conserve the evolution within the ZQC subspace; see Fig. 2B–D. Therefore, the evolution equation takes the following form: where we introduced L^^KZQC(t) as the Liouvillian superoperator projected onto the ZQC subspace. We emphasize that all components of the density matrix outside the ZQC subspace are identically zero, as shown in Fig. 2C and D. It should be noted that a wide class of relaxation mechanisms possesses the same symmetry properties: the effective-spin reduction and conservation of a coherence order (Kowalewski and Mäler, 2006): including dipole–dipole relaxation, chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) with axial symmetry, and cross-correlated relaxation between these mechanisms. Nevertheless, for the majority of SABRE experiments, the random fluctuating field (RFF) model provides a sufficiently accurate description of relaxation. Block-diagonal decomposition of SABRE master equations The SABRE hyperpolarization process arises from an intricate interplay between spin and chemical exchange dynamics. Polarization is transferred from a parahydrogen molecule to the substrate during its transient binding within the Ir-based polarization transfer complex, as illustrated in Fig. 3. Inside the complex, the nuclear spins of the parahydrogen-derived hydrides and the nuclear spins of the substrate become strongly coupled, leading to the formation of entangled spin states. This coherent spin evolution enables efficient transfer of spin order from parahydrogen to the substrate nuclei. Upon dissociation of the substrate from the metal complex, the accumulated spin polarization is released into the free substrate, resulting in its observable hyperpolarization of the nuclear spins. Schematic representation of the SABRE polarization transfer process from parahydrogen (pH2) to the substrate (S) mediated by the transient polarization transfer complex (C). Spin dynamics within the complex is governed by the Liouvillian superoperator L^^C , while spin evolution in the pool of free substrate molecules is described by L^^S . In our model, parahydrogen supply and exchange with the complex are assumed to be fast such that the overall exchange is effectively determined by the substrate dissociation rate constant kd and association rate Wa . Here, L and S1 denote the axial and equatorial ligand of the complex, respectively, and IMes is a heterocyclic carbene ligand (1,3-bis(2,4,6-trimethylphenyl)-1,3-dihydro-2H-imidazol-2-ylidene). Thus, spin dynamics governs the polarization transfer processes occurring within the metal complex, whereas chemical dynamics determines how this polarization is transferred to and accumulated in the ensemble of free substrate molecules. Both coherent spin evolution and stochastic chemical exchange are therefore essential ingredients of the SABRE mechanism. To rigorously consider this sophisticated SABRE dynamics, we used the SABRE master equation (Knecht et al., 2016): where we introduced the following quantities: ρ^S,C(t) values are the density matrices of the free substrate and the SABRE complex, respectively; ρ^pH2 is the density matrix of parahydrogen (singlet spin state of two nuclei); L^^S,C(t)=-iH^^S,C(t)+Γ^^S,C values are the Liouvillian superoperators of the substrate and the complex; kd is the substrate dissociation rate constant; and Wa=kd[C]/[S] is the substrate association rate constant. Importantly, in Eq. (40) the density matrices are normalized by the following concentrations: Tr{ρ^S(t)}=[S]/([C]+[S]) and Tr{ρ^C(t)}=[C]/([C]+[S]) . Equation (40) arises as the rigorous Markovian limit of the integral encounter theory, a first-principle approach to chemical kinetics in the condensed phase (Doktorov et al., 2002; Feskov et al., 2005; Ivanov et al., 2004). SABRE Eq. (40) is linear and valid in the regime of fast parahydrogen supply and fast dihydrogen exchange with the complex. Although the full SABRE kinetics is generally non-linear (Pravdivtsev and Hövener, 2019), the linear approximation is adequate for most practical purposes. Equation (40) can be transformed to the superoperator form Here, we introduce the following auxiliary superoperators: where 1^^S,C values are the identity superoperators acting on the density matrices according to 1^^Sρ^S(t)=ρ^S(t) and 1^^Cρ^C(t)=ρ^C(t) , S^^TrH2ρ^C(t)=TrH2{ρ^C(t)} is the partial trace superoperator over the states of the hydrides in the complex, and S^^Kronρ^S(t)={ρ^S(t)⊗ρ^pH2} is the Kronecker product superoperator. The initial state of the complex and the free substrate is typically assumed to be completely non-polarized: where 1^S,C values are the identity operators, and dim(HS,C) values are the dimensions of the Hilbert spaces of the free substrate and the complex, respectively. The group of magnetically equivalent nuclei In what follows, we demonstrate how block-diagonal decomposition can be employed to reduce the dimensionality of Eq. (41). We note that the initial density matrices in Eq. (43) commute with any operator in the Hilbert space, as they are proportional to the identity operator. Consequently, if the substrate contains a group of magnetically equivalent nuclei GP , it can be treated as a single effective nucleus with total spin K ; see Eqs. (4) and (5). This reduction is justified because Eq. (34) holds for both the free substrate and the SABRE complex. In this case, where the magnetic equivalence is conserved in the free substrate and in the complex, the chemical exchange superoperators do not mix subspaces with different values of K . As a consequence, the first step in the dimensionality reduction is to solve Eq. (41) independently for each value of the total spin K of the group of magnetically equivalent nuclei. To avoid unnecessary notational complexity, the index K will be omitted in what follows, with the understanding that the density matrices ρ^S(t) and ρ^C(t) correspond to a fixed value of K . The z projection of total spin The next step is to exploit the symmetry associated with the z projection of the total spin of the substrate, F^^Sz , and of the complex, F^^Cz . In particular, the following relations hold: The last two identities follow from the fact that the relaxation and coherent dynamics conserve the coherence order: and the definition of the auxiliary superoperators; see Eq. (42) ( 1^^S,C commutes with any superoperator). As a result, the first terms in Eq. (41), governed by the auxiliary superoperators A^^S,C , conserve the dynamics within the zero-quantum coherence (ZQC) subspaces of the Liouville spaces of the complex and the free substrate. These subspaces are denoted as ZQCC and ZQCS , respectively. Additionally, in SABRE the situation is significantly complicated by the presence of reversible chemical exchange. Special attention must therefore be paid to the exchange superoperators S^^TrH2 and S^^Kron , introduced in Eq. (41), since they explicitly couple the Liouville spaces of the complex and the free substrate. In Appendices B and C, we demonstrate that these chemical exchange superoperators conserve the zero coherence order. Consequently, S^^Kron:ZQCS→ZQCC,S^^TrH2:ZQCC→ZQCS , and the following relations hold: Thus, the dynamics can be rigorously restricted to the ZQCS and ZQCC subspaces, as illustrated in Fig. 4. Importantly, all other coherence order subspaces can be omitted without affecting the description of SABRE spin dynamics, since the density matrices are identically zero outside the ZQC subspaces (Fig. 4). Block-diagonal decomposition for SABRE master equations. Only zero-quantum coherence (ZQC) subspaces of the free substrate ( ZQCS ) and the complex ( ZQCC ) are relevant in the SABRE matrix. Chemical exchange superoperators S^^TrH2 and S^^Kron couple these ZQC subspaces. Outside the ZQC subspaces, the density matrices of the free substrate ρ^S and the complex ρ^C are zero. The density matrices are represented in Liouville space as vectors. Thus, the dimensionality of the problem is significantly reduced by considering that Eq. (41) is projected onto the ZQC subspaces instead of the full Liouville spaces: where A^^SZQC(t) and A^^CZQC(t) are the superoperators A^^S(t) and A^^C(t) reduced onto the ZQCS and ZQCC subspaces, respectively, and S^^TrH2ZQC and S^^KronZQC are the exchange superoperators calculated between the corresponding ZQC blocks. Importantly, these equations provide a rigorous, complete description of the full SABRE dynamics without any additional approximations while fully exploiting the block-diagonal structure of the density matrices to reduce computational complexity. In our notation, the ZQC subscript for the density matrices in Eq. (47) is omitted, as they are identically zero outside the zero-quantum coherence subspaces. The dimension of the SABRE matrix In this work, we introduce three different SABRE matrices for comparison: the full SABRE matrix (without any reduction), the K-SABRE matrix (with effective-spin reduction for the magnetically equivalent nuclei), and the ZQC SABRE matrix (with both effective-spin and ZQC reductions). The dimensions of the matrices are simply the sum of the dimensions of the Liouville spaces for the free substrate and the complex: where N is the number of substrate spins, N+2 is the number of spins in the complex (see Fig. 4), N-P is the number of magnetically non-equivalent nuclear spins in the substrate, N-P+2 is the number of magnetically non-equivalent nuclear spins in the complex, and K is the total spin of the group GP of magnetically equivalent nuclei. In turn, the dimension of the ZQC SABRE matrix of Eq. (47) is given by the sum of dimensions of the ZQC subspaces: where we used Eq. (28). The dimension of the ZQC-reduced SABRE matrix is significantly smaller than the dimension of the K-SABRE and the full SABRE matrices. The asymptotic behavior at N-P≫K gives the following result (see Eq. 48 and Appendix D): Thus, the K-SABRE matrix only uses reduction based on the effective-spin treatment, which allows us to reduce the dimension by the factor 4P(2K+1)2 . The following application of the ZQC reduction allows us to achieve better asymptotics for large spin systems since the dimension of the matrix is reduced by a greater factor of dim(Full SABRE)dim(ZQC SABRE)=π(N-P)4P(2K+1)2 ≫ 1. On the validity of the zero-quantum coherence reduction Our framework with the ZQC reduction is valid if the following conditions are met. The Hamiltonian The Hamiltonian of the spin system H^(t) is assumed to commute with the z projection of the total spin F^z . This assumption holds as long as no transverse ( x or y ) radiofrequency (RF) pulses are applied. Consequently, the proposed framework is particularly valuable for low and ultralow fields, where nontrivial spin dynamics occurs “spontaneously”, i.e., in the absence of RF pulses. Specialized state-space reduction techniques are also employed in high-field NMR simulations, notably in the Spinach software framework, which enables large-scale simulations of spin dynamics under arbitrary RF pulse sequences (Kuprov et al., 2007; Kuprov, 2018; Hogben et al., 2011). The Hamiltonian The Hamiltonian of the spin system H^(t) is assumed to commute with the z projection of the total spin F^z . This assumption holds as long as no transverse ( x or y ) radiofrequency (RF) pulses are applied. Consequently, the proposed framework is particularly valuable for low and ultralow fields, where nontrivial spin dynamics occurs “spontaneously”, i.e., in the absence of RF pulses. Specialized state-space reduction techniques are also employed in high-field NMR simulations, notably in the Spinach software framework, which enables large-scale simulations of spin dynamics under arbitrary RF pulse sequences (Kuprov et al., 2007; Kuprov, 2018; Hogben et al., 2011). The relaxation superoperator The relaxation superoperator Γ^^ is assumed to commute with F^^z . This approximation is valid for a variety of relevant NMR relaxation mechanisms in the extreme narrowing regime, including dipolar relaxation, chemical shift anisotropy, and their cross-correlations. A possible exception is chemical shift anisotropy in the absence of axial symmetry, which represents a rather uncommon case. The relaxation superoperator The relaxation superoperator Γ^^ is assumed to commute with F^^z . This approximation is valid for a variety of relevant NMR relaxation mechanisms in the extreme narrowing regime, including dipolar relaxation, chemical shift anisotropy, and their cross-correlations. A possible exception is chemical shift anisotropy in the absence of axial symmetry, which represents a rather uncommon case. The initial condition The initial density matrices of the free substrate, ρ^S(0) , and the SABRE complex, ρ^C(0) , are assumed to commute with their respective z projection of total spin operators; i.e., [F^Sz,ρ^S(0)]=0 and [F^Cz,ρ^C(0)]=0 . This condition is satisfied for the standard SABRE initial condition given by Eq. (43). The initial condition The initial density matrices of the free substrate, ρ^S(0) , and the SABRE complex, ρ^C(0) , are assumed to commute with their respective z projection of total spin operators; i.e., [F^Sz,ρ^S(0)]=0 and [F^Cz,ρ^C(0)]=0 . This condition is satisfied for the standard SABRE initial condition given by Eq. (43). It should be noted that, if only relaxation and coherent evolution are considered without chemical exchange, the dynamics can be reduced onto subspaces with fixed magnetic quantum numbers FC and FS without invoking the full ZQC subspaces. Strictly speaking, Eq. (46) ensures that the density matrices ρ^C(t) and ρ^S(t) commute with F^Cz and F^Sz , implying their block-diagonal structure in FC and FS , respectively. However, the chemical exchange superoperator S^^TrH2 , which describes the decay of correlations between the substrate and hydrides in the complex, couples the subspaces of the free substrate and the complex with different quantum numbers. Consequently, although the density matrices remain block diagonal in magnetic quantum numbers FC and FS , the SABRE equations themselves are not block diagonal in FC and FS , meaning that they cannot be reduced to a single block with fixed FC and FS . Therefore, in SABRE, the full ZQC subspaces of the substrate and the complex must be considered. Methods The algorithm for numerical simulations This section summarizes the theoretical framework and outlines the complete algorithm for numerical simulation. Identify permutation-equivalent spin groups. Determine the group GP of magnetically equivalent spin- 1/2 nuclei within the substrate molecule. This typically includes protons in chemically equivalent groups, such as -CH2- or -CH3 . If the molecule contains several distinct sets of magnetically equivalent nuclei, each is treated separately as groups GP1,GP2,… , containing P1,P2,… nuclei, respectively. Identify permutation-equivalent spin groups. Determine the group GP of magnetically equivalent spin- 1/2 nuclei within the substrate molecule. This typically includes protons in chemically equivalent groups, such as -CH2- or -CH3 . If the molecule contains several distinct sets of magnetically equivalent nuclei, each is treated separately as groups GP1,GP2,… , containing P1,P2,… nuclei, respectively. Replace each equivalent group with an effective spin. Each group GPi of magnetically equivalent spins is replaced by a single effective spin Ki , whose quantum number can take values in the range 51Ki∈[Ki,min,Pi/2], where Ki,min=0 if Pi is even, and Ki,min=1/2 if Pi is odd. Replace each equivalent group with an effective spin. Each group GPi of magnetically equivalent spins is replaced by a single effective spin Ki , whose quantum number can take values in the range 51Ki∈[Ki,min,Pi/2], where Ki,min=0 if Pi is even, and Ki,min=1/2 if Pi is odd. Construct the effective spin system. The original system of N nuclei is thereby reduced to a system consisting of the following: the (N-P1-P2-…) non-equivalent spin- 1/2 nuclei,a single effective spin K1 (representing group GP1 ),a single effective spin K2 (representing group GP2 ), and so on. Construct the effective spin system. The original system of N nuclei is thereby reduced to a system consisting of the following: the (N-P1-P2-…) non-equivalent spin- 1/2 nuclei,a single effective spin K1 (representing group GP1 ),a single effective spin K2 (representing group GP2 ), and so on. the (N-P1-P2-…) non-equivalent spin- 1/2 nuclei, the (N-P1-P2-…) non-equivalent spin- 1/2 nuclei, a single effective spin K1 (representing group GP1 ), a single effective spin K1 (representing group GP1 ), a single effective spin K2 (representing group GP2 ), and so on. a single effective spin K2 (representing group GP2 ), and so on. Build the Hamiltonian superoperators for the complex and free substrate. The Hamiltonian operator for the effective-spin system reads as follows (see Eq. 10): 52H^K1,K2,…(t)=-B0(t)∑l=1N-P1-P2-…γlI^zl+γP1K^1z+γP2K^2z+…+2π∑l0 both binomial coefficients are defined if tbinom∈[0,N-P-Δ] . In turn, the sum itself is taken over tsum∈[-K-mk,N-P+K-mk] . Fortunately, for all Δ we have tbinom⊂tsum , and the summation interval always covers tbinom . In this case, Vandermonde's identity is valid: Thus, we have If N-P≫K , the Gauss asymptotics is valid for the binomial coefficient Therefore, the total sum is The total dimension of the ZQC SABRE matrix is Simulation parameters The J -coupling constants for the SABRE complex with acetonitrile were taken from Mewis et al. (2015); see Table E1. The J -coupling constants for [ 15N , 13C4 ]butyronitrile (Table E2) are based on our experimental measurements. These data will be discussed comprehensively in a subsequent paper (Kiryutin et al., 2026). For simplicity, in all cases we assumed that the J -coupling network between the nuclei within the substrates remains unchanged upon binding to the complex. Table E1Simulation NMR parameters used for [15N,13C2] acetonitrile. J , HzHaHb1- 15N 2- 13C 3- 13C CH3 T1 , sHa -7.6 -25 -5 -2 -0.5 1Hb 100011- 15N -18 1 -1.6 3 (30)2- 13C 58 -9 3 (30)3- 13C 1363 (30) CH3 1 (1)Ha, Hb denote the hydride ligands.The values of T1 in brackets correspond to the free substrate. Simulation NMR parameters used for [15N,13C2] acetonitrile. Ha, Hb denote the hydride ligands.The values of T1 in brackets correspond to the free substrate. Table E2Simulation NMR parameters used for [ 15N , 13C4 ]butyronitrile. J , HzHaHb1- 15N 2- 13C 3- 13C 4- 13C 5- 13C 3- CH2 4- CH2 CH3 T1 , sHa -7.6 -25.6 120000001Hb 1.5000000011- 15N 17.4 -2.9 0.60.0051.70.03 -0.005 3 (30)2- 13C 55.2 -2.8 3.5 -9.6 6.4 -0.03 3 (30)3- 13C 33.0 -1.0 135.2 -4.1 6.43 (30)4- 13C 34.8 -5.1 130.6 -4.5 3 (30)5- 13C 4.8 -4.2 126.13 (30)3- CH2 7.0 -0.04 1 (1)4- CH2 7.41 (1) CH3 1 (1)Ha, Hb denote the hydride ligands.The values of T1 in brackets correspond to the free substrate.3-CH2/4-CH2 are the methylene protons at the 3-13C/4-13C positions. Simulation NMR parameters used for [ 15N , 13C4 ]butyronitrile. Ha, Hb denote the hydride ligands.The values of T1 in brackets correspond to the free substrate.3-CH2/4-CH2 are the methylene protons at the 3-13C/4-13C positions. Disclaimer Publisher's note: Copernicus Publications remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims made in the text, published maps, institutional affiliations, or any other geographical representation in this paper. The authors bear the ultimate responsibility for providing appropriate place names. Views expressed in the text are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher. Funding Statement This research has been supported by the Russian Science Foundation (grant no. 25-23-00607). Publisher’s note: the article processing charges for this publication were not paid by a Russian or Belarusian institution. Contributor Information Danil Markelov, Email: d.markelov@tomo.nsc.ru. Alexandra Yurkovskaya, Email: yurk@tomo.nsc.ru. Code availability The Python scripts used for SABRE simulations with the zero-quantum coherence reduction is available at 10.5281/zenodo.18083297 (Markelov, 2025). Data availability All data presented in this study were generated by the accompanying code, as described in the main text. No external or observational datasets were used. The generated datasets can be fully reproduced using the code provided in the “Code availability” section. Author contributions DM – conceptualization (lead), writing the paper (lead), formal analysis (lead), data analysis (lead), code writing (lead), data visualization (lead); AS – data analysis (supporting), formal analysis (supporting), code writing (supporting); AK – conceptualization (supporting), data analysis (supporting), data visualization (supporting), project administration (equal); DB – writing the paper (supporting), formal analysis (supporting), project administration (equal); AY – writing the paper (supporting), project administration (equal). Competing interests At least one of the (co-)authors is a member of the editorial board of Magnetic Resonance. The peer-review process was guided by an independent editor, and the authors also have no other competing interests to declare. Review statement This paper was edited by Malcolm Levitt and reviewed by two anonymous referees. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement All data presented in this study were generated by the accompanying code, as described in the main text. No external or observational datasets were used. The generated datasets can be fully reproduced using the code provided in the “Code availability” section.