Perceived competence and cognitive bias in nurses' assessment of intimate partner violence: a cross-sectional study Authors: David Casero-Benavente, Natalia Mudarra-García, Guillermo Charneco-Salguero, Francisco Lencina-Navarro, Diego Pérez-Iglesias, Cecilia Castillo-Gallardo, Raquel Vázquez-Royo, Paula Panadero-Puente, Francisco Javier García-Sánchez, José Miguel Cárdenas-Rebollo Published: 2026 ABSTRACT IntroductionIntimate partner violence (IPV) represents a complex social and health problem that requires multidisciplinary responses. Healthcare professionals, particularly nurses, play a key role in the identification and management of IPV cases. However, limited training and potential cognitive biases may affect professional assessment and intervention.MethodsA cross-sectional descriptive study was conducted among 202 nursing professionals in Spain. Perceived competence in IPV management was evaluated using the validated Intimate Partner Violence Competency Scale for Nurses (ECVPE), which assesses four dimensions: intervention and referral, detection and assessment of abuse, documentation and record-keeping, and psychosocial support. Descriptive statistics, Student's t-tests, and one-way ANOVA were used to analyze differences according to sociodemographic variables.ResultsThe lowest levels of perceived competence were observed in the intervention and referral dimension (M = 2.45), while the highest scores were found in psychosocial support (M = 3.36). Professional experience was the only variable significantly associated with perceived competence in the dimensions of detection and documentation of abuse. Additionally, most participants conceptualized IPV primarily as violence against women in heterosexual relationships, indicating the presence of perceptual biases that may influence professional assessment.ConclusionsNursing professionals reported heterogeneous levels of perceived competence in IPV management, with notable gaps in intervention and referral processes. The results highlight the need for training strategies that strengthen professional competencies while addressing implicit biases in the interpretation of violence within intimate relationships. Introduction Intimate partner violence (IPV) is recognized as a complex social and health problem with significant psychological, physical, and social consequences for individuals and families. IPV occurs within the context of intimate relationships and may affect individuals regardless of gender, sexual orientation, or relationship structure. In recent decades, research on violence within intimate relationships has expanded considerably; however, much of the literature has traditionally focused on gender-based violence against women. While this perspective has been crucial for advancing awareness and protection policies, it may also contribute to conceptual ambiguities that affect the recognition of other forms of violence within intimate relationships (1, 2). Healthcare professionals frequently encounter victims of intimate partner violence, often before the situation becomes visible to legal or social services. For this reason, healthcare settings represent an important opportunity for early detection and intervention. Among healthcare professionals, nurses are in a particularly significant position due to their continuous contact with patients and their role in holistic care. Their responsibilities may include identifying potential signs of abuse, documenting clinical findings, providing emotional support, and referring victims to appropriate services. Nevertheless, previous research indicates that many healthcare professionals feel insufficiently prepared to address IPV situations in clinical practice, often reporting uncertainty, lack of training, and difficulties in managing sensitive conversations with patients (3–5). The emotional impact of caring for victims of violence and the lack of institutional support may also influence professionals' willingness to intervene, further complicating the clinical management of these situations (6). The conceptual framework adopted in this study considers intimate partner violence as part of the broader spectrum of intrafamily violence. The main categories of intrafamily violence considered in this framework are summarized in Figure 1. Main types of intrafamily violence considered within the conceptual framework of the study. Another important challenge in the professional assessment of intimate partner violence relates to the presence of stereotypes and cognitive biases regarding the typical profiles of victims and perpetrators. The traditional representation of IPV frequently assumes a heterosexual relationship in which the man is the aggressor and the woman is the victim (7). Although this pattern is highly prevalent and well documented, it does not fully reflect the diversity of violence dynamics that may occur within intimate relationships (8–10). Studies exploring violence perpetrated by women toward male partners suggest that motivational patterns and psychological characteristics may be comparable to those found in male perpetrators, although certain forms of violence, such as sexual violence, remain less frequent (11, 12). Furthermore, the increasing recognition of diverse family structures and sexual orientations highlights the importance of adopting inclusive perspectives when assessing IPV situations (13, 14). The increasing diversity of family and relationship structures reinforces the need for inclusive approaches to the assessment of intimate partner violence. A conceptual overview of family structures relevant to this perspective is provided in Figure 2. Overview of family structures and relationship configurations considered relevant to the conceptual understanding of intimate partner violence. The presence of stereotypes or conceptual confusion in the interpretation of IPV may have important implications for professional practice. If healthcare professionals approach IPV situations based on preconceived models of violence, certain cases may remain undetected or be incorrectly interpreted. In addition, inadequate documentation of suspected abuse may have relevant legal implications, particularly when medical records are later used in judicial or forensic contexts (15, 16). Previous frameworks have attempted to systematize nursing care in cases of violence. For example, the SATELLITE model provides a structured approach to assessment and intervention in cases of sexual violence, emphasizing the importance of systematic evaluation and professional preparedness. These approaches highlight the need for standardized tools and training to improve nurses' competence in addressing violence-related cases (17, 18). Despite the relevance of healthcare professionals in the identification and management of IPV, research evaluating their perceived competencies and preparedness remains limited, particularly in the Spanish context. Understanding how nurses perceive their own training and abilities in key areas such as detection, intervention, documentation, and psychosocial support may help identify gaps in professional preparation and inform the development of targeted training strategies. Therefore, the aim of this study was to assess perceived competence in the management of intimate partner violence and to explore perceptual biases in its conceptualization among nursing rofessionals. Methods Study design A cross-sectional, descriptive pilot study with a quantitative approach was conducted to evaluate nursing professionals' perceived competence in the management of intimate partner violence (IPV). The study used a structured questionnaire based on a validated scale designed to assess professional competencies related to IPV management within the nursing process. Participants The target population consisted of registered nurses working in clinical care settings in the Community of Madrid (Spain). A total of 202 nursing professionals participated in the study. The sample size was calculated to achieve a 95% confidence level with a margin of error below 5%. Participants were recruited from different healthcare settings, including hospital and primary care services, using a non-probabilistic convenience sampling approach through online dissemination channels. Inclusion criteria Active nurses working in clinical care settings in the Community of Madrid.Official nursing qualifications and professional registration in Spain.Voluntary participation in the study. Active nurses working in clinical care settings in the Community of Madrid. Active nurses working in clinical care settings in the Community of Madrid. Official nursing qualifications and professional registration in Spain. Official nursing qualifications and professional registration in Spain. Voluntary participation in the study. Voluntary participation in the study. Exclusion criteria Nurses not currently engaged in clinical practice.Professionals without official professional registration.Nursing students who had not yet completed their degree. Nurses not currently engaged in clinical practice. Nurses not currently engaged in clinical practice. Professionals without official professional registration. Professionals without official professional registration. Nursing students who had not yet completed their degree. Nursing students who had not yet completed their degree. Measures Perceived competence in the management of intimate partner violence (IPV) was assessed using the ECVPE scale (Escala de Competencia en Violencia de Pareja en Enfermería). This instrument evaluates perceived competence through items reflecting routine clinical activities related to IPV management. The ECVPE scale was conceptually informed by the Nursing Intervention Classification (NIC), particularly intervention 6,403: Intimate Partner Violence, which served as a framework for item development. However, the ECVPE constitutes a distinct measurement instrument. The scale includes 26 items grouped into four dimensions: (1) Intervention and Referral, (2) Detection and Assessment of Abuse, (3) Documentation and Record-Keeping, and (4) Psychosocial Support. Responses were recorded on a five-point Likert scale (1 = never to 5 = always), where higher scores indicate greater perceived competence. The internal consistency of the scale demonstrated excellent reliability, with a Cronbach's alpha of 0.97, while the adequacy of the data for factor analysis was confirmed by a Kaiser–Meyer–Olkin (KMO) value of 0.947 and Bartlett's test of sphericity (p < 0.001), supporting the proposed factorial structure of the instrument. Additionally, three complementary items were included to explore potential perceptual biases regarding the conceptualization of intimate partner violence among healthcare professionals. Procedure Data collection was conducted between June 2024 and May 2025 using an anonymous online questionnaire distributed through Microsoft Forms. The survey was disseminated through professional networks, healthcare institutions, professional associations, and social media platforms, providing participants with a direct link and QR code to access the questionnaire. Participation was voluntary and anonymous. Before accessing the questionnaire, participants received information about the study objectives and were required to provide informed consent electronically. Instruments The ECVPE scale includes items derived from standardized nursing activities described in the Nursing Intervention Classification (NIC), ensuring content validity and alignment with clinical practice. Participants were provided with a definition of intimate partner violence prior to completing the questionnaire to ensure conceptual consistency and reduce potential bias. These items were specifically adapted to assess perceived competence rather than merely the frequency of task performance. Additionally, three complementary items were included to explore perceptual biases related to the conceptualization of intimate partner violence, including representations of victims, aggressors, and relationship contexts. The questionnaire was administered in Spanish and the full questionnaire used in this study is provided in Supplementary Appendix A. Statistical analysis Data were coded and analyzed using IBM SPSS Statistics version 29.0. Descriptive statistics were calculated to summarize the sociodemographic characteristics of the sample, including sex, age, years of professional experience, workplace setting, and academic level. For the four dimensions of perceived competence, means, standard deviations, and medians were calculated. To evaluate differences according to sex, Student's t-test for independent samples was applied. Differences across other sociodemographic variables were analyzed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). Prior to conducting ANOVA, the assumption of homogeneity of variances was tested using Levene's test. When statistically significant differences were identified, post-hoc comparisons (Tukey HSD or Games–Howell) were planned to determine which groups differed significantly. Statistical significance was established at p < 0.05. Assumptions for parametric testing were assessed, including normality and homogeneity of variance. Effect sizes were calculated where appropriate. Ethical considerations The study was approved by the Bioethics Committee of CEU San Pablo University (approval code 843/24/104). Participation was voluntary, anonymous, and confidential. All participants provided informed consent prior to completing the questionnaire. The study followed the ethical principles established in the Declaration of Helsinki for research involving human participants. Results Sample characteristics The study included a total of 202 nursing professionals. The sample was predominantly female, with 165 women (81.7%) and 34 men (16.8%). Regarding professional experience, 24.3% (n = 49) had less than five years of experience, 14.9% (n = 30) had between six and ten years, 23.8% (n = 48) had between eleven and fifteen years, and 37.1% (n = 75) had more than sixteen years of professional experience. In terms of workplace setting, the majority of participants worked in hospital settings (49.0%, n = 99) or primary care services (37.1%, n = 75). Regarding academic level, 36.6% (n = 74) held a nursing diploma, 38.6% (n = 78) had a bachelor's degree, 21.8% (n = 44) had postgraduate training, and 3% (n = 6) held a doctoral degree. Age distribution showed that 34.2% (n = 69) of participants were between 31 and 40 years, followed by 26.7% (n = 54) aged 20–30 years, 25.2% (n = 51) aged 41–50 years, and 13.9% (n = 28) aged over 51 years. The internal consistency of the scale in the present sample was high (Cronbach's α = 0.92). Descriptive statistics of perceived competence Perceived competence in intimate partner violence management was evaluated across four dimensions. Descriptive statistics are presented in Table 1. Table 1Descriptive statistics of the study dimensions.DimensionNMeanStandard deviationMedianD1 – Intervention and referral2022.450.962.33D2 – Detection and assessment of abuse2023.070.833.00D3 – Documentation and record-keeping2023.100.833.00D4 – Psychosocial support2023.360.843.33 Descriptive statistics of the study dimensions. The results indicate that the dimension with the lowest perceived competence was Intervention and Referral (D1), with a mean score of 2.45 (SD = 0.96). In contrast, the highest perceived competence was observed in the Psychosocial Support (D4) dimension, with a mean score of 3.36 (SD = 0.84). In terms of specific interventions, activities related to psychosocial support were the most frequently reported, while actions involving formal referral and coordination with external resources were less commonly performed. Detection and assessment activities showed moderate frequency, indicating variability in clinical practice. The dimensions Detection and Assessment of Abuse (D2) and Documentation and Record-Keeping (D3) showed intermediate levels of perceived competence, with mean scores of 3.07 (SD = 0.83) and 3.10 (SD = 0.83), respectively. These results suggest that nursing professionals perceive themselves as more competent in providing emotional and psychosocial support than in performing direct interventions or referrals in cases of intimate partner violence. The questionnaire included perceived competence grouped into four dimensions: intervention and referral, detection and assessment of abuse, documentation and record-keeping, and psychosocial support (see Table 2 and Supplementary Appendix A). Table 2Items included in the nursing activities assessment scale.ItemDimensionDescription of nursing activity1Detection and assessment of abuseAssess the patient's safety and risk of further violence.2Detection and assessment of abuseIdentify signs and symptoms compatible with intimate partner violence.3Detection and assessment of abuseExplore the patient's perception of their situation and possible abuse.4Psychosocial supportProvide emotional support to the patient experiencing violence.5Psychosocial supportEncourage the patient to express concerns and fears.6Intervention and referralInform the patient about available resources and support services.7Intervention and referralFacilitate referral to specialized services when necessary.8Documentation and record-keepingDocument findings related to suspected or confirmed abuse.9Documentation and record-keepingMaintain confidentiality and privacy when addressing violence-related issues.10Intervention and referralCollaborate with other healthcare professionals in case management.11Psychosocial supportProvide guidance on safety planning when appropriate.12Intervention and referralOffer information about legal and social support resources.13Psychosocial supportSupport the patient in decision-making related to safety and wellbeing. Items included in the nursing activities assessment scale. Differences in perceived competence based on activity-related items by sex Differences in perceived competence based on activity-related items between male and female participants were analyzed using Student's t-test for independent samples. The results are summarized in Table 3. Table 3Comparison of study dimensions by sex.DimensionSexNMeanSDtp-valueD1 – Intervention and referralWomen1652.47680.962880.7710.442Men342.34310.96220D2 – Detection and assessment of abuseWomen1653.06670.823270.0460.963Men343.07350.91673D3 – Documentation and record-keepingWomen1653.13410.841650.8870.376Men342.98160.77858D4 – Psychosocial supportWomen1653.41620.816211.9440.053Men343.09310.93851 Comparison of study dimensions by sex. No statistically significant differences were observed between men and women in any of the four competence dimensions (p > 0.05). Mean scores were comparable across both groups in the dimensions of intervention and referral, detection and assessment, documentation and record-keeping, and psychosocial support. These findings suggest that perceived competence in IPV management among nurses does not appear to differ according to sex. Differences according to professional experience A one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was conducted to examine potential differences in perceived competence according to years of professional experience. Statistically significant differences were observed in the dimensions Detection and Assessment of Abuse (D2) (p = 0.020) and Documentation and Record-Keeping (D3) (p = 0.032). No significant differences were found for the dimensions Intervention and Referral (D1) or Psychosocial Support (D4). Mean scores for the Detection and Assessment of Abuse dimension were 2.84 for professionals with less than 5 years of experience, 3.35 for those with 6 to 10 years, 2.94 for those with 11 to 15 years, and 3.18 for those with more than 16 years of experience. Similarly, in the Documentation and Record-Keeping dimension, mean scores were 2.87 for professionals with less than 5 years of experience, 3.42 for those with 6 to 10 years, 2.96 for those with 11 to 15 years, and 3.20 for those with more than 16 years of experience. These results indicate that nurses with six to ten years of professional experience reported the highest levels of perceived competence in both detection and documentation of IPV cases (Table 4). Table 4Associations between study dimensions and sociodemographic and professional variables.DimensionYears of experienceAgeWorkplace settingAcademic levelD1 – Intervention and referralNot significantNot significantNot significantNot significantD2 – Detection and assessment of AbuseSignificant (p = 0.020)Not significantNot significantNot significantD3 – Documentation and record-keepingSignificant (p = 0.032)Not significantNot significantNot significantD4 – Psychosocial supportNot significantNot significantNot significantNot significant Associations between study dimensions and sociodemographic and professional variables. Perceptual bias in the conceptualization of intimate partner violence Additional items included in the questionnaire explored potential perceptual biases regarding the conceptualization of intimate partner violence among participants. Most respondents reported that, when completing the scale, they had primarily imagined a female victim (83%) and a heterosexual relationship with a male aggressor (82%). Furthermore, when asked about the main barriers to performing nursing interventions in IPV situations, 47% of participants identified difficulties in patient interaction and interviewing skills as the primary obstacle, followed by lack of time (34%). These findings suggest that stereotypical representations of IPV may influence how healthcare professionals conceptualize violence within intimate relationships. Discussion This study examined perceived competence in IPV management using the ECVPE scale, a multidimensional instrument grounded in clinically relevant nursing activities. Although the ECVPE scale includes items reflecting clinical activities, it is designed to assess perceived competence as a multidimensional construct. Therefore, the use of activity-based items should not be interpreted as a direct measure of frequency alone, but as an operationalization of competence through practice-oriented behaviors. These results are consistent with previous studies indicating that healthcare professionals often feel more comfortable providing emotional support to victims than performing direct interventions or initiating referral processes in cases of violence (4, 5). The complexity of IPV situations, combined with the potential legal and ethical implications of intervention, may contribute to professional uncertainty and hesitation when addressing these cases in clinical settings. Additionally, the lack of specific training and standardized protocols has been identified as a significant barrier to effective intervention among healthcare professionals (3). In contrast, the dimension related to psychosocial support showed the highest levels of perceived competence. This finding may be explained by the traditional emphasis of nursing education on holistic care and emotional support, which may provide professionals with greater confidence in these aspects of patient care. Similar patterns have been observed in previous research examining healthcare professionals' attitudes and competencies regarding violence within intimate relationships (1). Another relevant finding of the present study was the influence of professional experience on perceived competence in the dimensions of detection and documentation of abuse. Nurses with six to ten years of professional experience reported the highest levels of perceived competence in these areas. This pattern may reflect the progressive acquisition of clinical experience and the consolidation of professional judgment during the early stages of professional development. Previous research has suggested that professional exposure to complex clinical situations contributes to the development of more refined observational and documentation skills among healthcare professionals (19). These findings are consistent with previous studies highlighting similar patterns in nursing competence and preparedness in IPV management (5, 20). Interestingly, other sociodemographic variables, including sex, age, workplace setting, and academic level, did not show significant differences in perceived competence. This suggests that the gaps identified in the management of IPV may be structural rather than individual, affecting healthcare professionals across different demographic and professional contexts. Similar findings have been reported in studies analyzing the involvement of healthcare professionals in the detection and management of gender-based violence (21). Beyond the differences in perceived competence, the results of the additional survey items revealed the presence of perceptual biases in how participants conceptualized IPV. A large proportion of respondents reported that when answering the questionnaire, they had primarily imagined a female victim and a male aggressor in a heterosexual relationship. While this representation corresponds to one of the most prevalent forms of intimate partner violence, it does not fully capture the diversity of violence dynamics that may occur within intimate relationships. These findings are consistent with previous studies highlighting the importance of structured frameworks and training in improving nurses' competence and confidence in managing violence-related cases. Recent evidence suggests that targeted educational interventions can significantly enhance nurses' preparedness and decision-making in these contexts (22). Previous research has highlighted that violence within intimate relationships may also occur in same-sex couples or involve male victims, although these situations are often less visible in both research and professional practice (12, 23). The persistence of stereotypical representations of IPV may limit professionals' ability to recognize less visible forms of violence and may contribute to under-detection in certain populations. An inclusive approach that considers diverse family structures and sexual orientations is essential to ensure accurate identification and management of IPV cases (13, 14). The findings related to perceived barriers to intervention further reinforce these interpretations. Nearly half of the participants identified difficulties in patient interaction and interviewing skills as the main obstacle when addressing IPV cases. These results are consistent with previous studies suggesting that communication challenges and emotional discomfort may hinder professionals' ability to initiate conversations about violence with patients (6). Furthermore, lack of time was identified as another important barrier, reflecting structural limitations within healthcare systems that may restrict opportunities for in-depth patient assessment. From a professional perspective, the findings of this study highlight the need for structured training programs focused on IPV detection, documentation, and intervention strategies. Training initiatives should not only address clinical competencies but also incorporate components aimed at recognizing and overcoming implicit biases that may influence professional judgment. Previous literature has emphasized that effective training programs combine theoretical knowledge with practical skills and reflective approaches that allow professionals to critically examine their own assumptions and attitudes toward violence (15, 16). Accurate documentation of suspected IPV cases represents another critical aspect of professional practice. Clinical records may later play an important role in legal or forensic proceedings, making it essential for healthcare professionals to document cases of violence carefully and systematically. Inadequate documentation may not only compromise patient care but also affect the legal protection of victims (15). Despite the relevance of the findings, several limitations should be considered. First, the sample size of 202 participants, while sufficient for exploratory analysis, may limit the generalizability of the results to other healthcare contexts or regions. Second, the study relied on self-reported perceptions of competence, which may not necessarily reflect actual professional performance in real clinical situations. Finally, the cross-sectional design of the study does not allow causal relationships to be established between professional characteristics and perceived competence. Future research should consider larger and more diverse samples, including professionals from different healthcare systems and geographical contexts. In addition, mixed-method approaches combining quantitative and qualitative data may provide a deeper understanding of the factors that influence healthcare professionals' responses to IPV. Exploring the effectiveness of specific training interventions may also contribute to improving professional preparedness and strengthening healthcare responses to intimate partner violence. Conclusion The findings of this study indicate that nursing professionals perceive heterogeneous levels of competence in the management of intimate partner violence (IPV). The lowest levels of perceived competence were observed in the dimension related to intervention and referral, suggesting that nurses may feel less prepared to take direct action or initiate referral processes when encountering situations of violence within intimate relationships. In contrast, higher levels of perceived competence were reported in the psychosocial support dimension, reflecting the traditional emphasis of nursing practice on emotional care and patient support. Professional experience emerged as the only sociodemographic variable significantly associated with perceived competence in certain areas, specifically in the detection and documentation of abuse. Nurses with intermediate levels of professional experience reported higher levels of perceived competence in these dimensions, suggesting that clinical exposure may contribute to the development of these skills over time. The study also identified the presence of perceptual biases in how healthcare professionals conceptualize intimate partner violence. A large proportion of participants associated IPV primarily with female victims and heterosexual relationships, indicating the persistence of stereotypical representations that may influence professional assessment and potentially limit the identification of other forms of violence within intimate relationships. Overall, these findings highlight the need for comprehensive training strategies aimed at improving healthcare professionals' preparedness in the detection, documentation, and management of IPV. Addressing both technical competencies and implicit biases may contribute to more effective and inclusive responses to violence within intimate relationships in healthcare settings. In addition to continuing professional development, integrating training on intimate partner violence into undergraduate nursing education may be essential to ensure early acquisition of competencies in this area. Limitations Several limitations should be considered when interpreting the results of this study. First, the sample was limited to nursing professionals working in the Community of Madrid, which may restrict the generalizability of the findings to other geographical regions or healthcare systems. Second, the study relied on self-reported perceptions of competence, which may not necessarily reflect actual professional behavior in real clinical situations. Third, the cross-sectional design prevents the establishment of causal relationships between professional characteristics and perceived competence. The use of self-reported measures and online recruitment may introduce self-selection bias. Additionally, the extended data collection period may have introduced temporal variability. Despite these limitations, the study provides valuable insights into healthcare professionals' perceptions of IPV management and highlights important areas for improvement in professional training. Practical implications The results of this study have important implications for both clinical practice and professional education. Healthcare institutions should consider incorporating structured training programs on intimate partner violence into continuing education initiatives for nursing professionals. Such programs should address not only clinical skills related to detection and intervention but also communication strategies for conducting sensitive interviews with patients. Additionally, training initiatives should include awareness of potential cognitive biases and stereotypes that may influence the professional interpretation of IPV situations. Promoting inclusive perspectives and improving documentation practices may contribute to better identification of violence cases and more effective coordination with legal and social support services.