Obstetricians’ attitudes towards instrumental vaginal delivery in Egypt Authors: Omima T Taha, Mostafa A Hamdy, Amal A Ahmed, Tamer Yehia M Ali, Mohamed F Ibrahim, Asmaa M Elgedawy Published: 2026 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundInstrumental delivery is a dying art, that needs proper training and practice to revive it and help decrease cesarean delivery rates. This study aimed to declare the obstetricians’ attitude towards instrumental delivery and to elaborate the its possible causes.MethodsA descriptive cross- sectional study was conducted via an online survey between January 1and April 1, 2025. It was distributed to obstetricians in Egypt. The questionnaire included two main sectors: sector (one) inquired about the sociodemographic characteristics of the participants; sector (two) included the physicians’ attitudes and practices towards instrumental delivery in Egypt.ResultsSeventy-three (52.5%) of the obstetricians never tried ID before. Eighty-nine (64%) of the obstetricians declined encouraging ID if in a situation that indicated the use of ID. Possible reasons for abandoning ID included reduction of training (116/139, 83.5%), lack of senior supervision (99/139, 71.2%), fear of litigation (125/139, 89.9%), lack of consultant supervision in acute situations (108/139, 77.7%), and lack of modern equipment (108/139, 77.7%).ConclusionInstrumental delivery is not widely practiced in Egypt. A great proportion of the obstetricians declined to perform/try instrumental delivery in urgent situations.Keywords: Instrumental delivery, Attitude, Obstetricians, Vaginal delivery Background Instrumental delivery (ID), also called assisted vaginal delivery, is considered one of six essential skills in basic obstetric emergencies [1]. It has been applied as a management option for obstructed or prolonged labor, maternal exhaustion, poor maternal pushing with epidural anesthesia, or soft tissue obstruction [2]. Recent reports mentioned declined rates of ID in most countries [3]. Rate of ID in Egypt was 2%, while the rates of cesarean section (CS) increased to 52% [4]. A previous study reported that 49% of the Egyptian obstetricians declined to try ID, without exploring possible causes. It also mentioned that the majority of Egyptian obstetricians declined to perform any procedure that would decrease CS rates including ID [5]. Scarce studies reported on the rates of forceps or vacuum delivery in Egypt. One study reported the use of forceps in 8/200 (4%) and vacuum 4/200 (2%) of primiparous women who delivered vaginally [6]. The rate of ID is influenced by many factors as the experience of the operator, the clinical situation, and the availability of these tools [7]. Other reported factors included old/lack of instruments, and restricted training to the old physicians [3]. In a study performed in Latin America, forceps delivery rates were far below those for cesarean delivery, with a continued decline in forceps use over time [8]. Another survey including African countries, vacuum extraction was noted to be superior than forceps, while ID rates remained low and ranged from 1 to 3% [9]. Higher rates of ID delivery were observed in the United States, Canada, and Australia [10]. However; there has been a noticeable decline in ID rates over the last two decades [11]. Possible reasons for declined ID rates, is the rejection of the procedure by both obstetricians and pediatricians. Additionally, cesarean delivery is more feasible and acceptable [12], which lead to increased cesarean delivery rates in Egypt [4]. other reported causes included reluctance of trained physicians to perform ID, lack of training for the younger ones, some countries do not endorse ID use, lack of modern tools, financial gains associated with cesarean delivery, and convinced mothers about the increased safety with cesarean delivery rather than ID [8]. This study was conducted to determine possible causes associated with declined use of ID among obstetricians in Egypt. Methods A descriptive cross- sectional study was conducted via an online survey between January 1and April 1, 2025. The survey was directed to obstetricians in Egypt and the sample was collected as a convenience sampling. After literature review [13], an English questionnaire was constructed and distributed electronically (via emails and social groups) to the participants for collection of their responses. The questionnaire was tested on 10 participants and then published and distributed electronically. The questionnaire was then validated statistically through principal component analysis and the calculation of Cronbach’s alpha for the whole questionnaire and for each section. The questionnaire included two main sectors: sector 1 inquired about the sociodemographic characteristics of the participants; sector 2 included the physicians’ attitudes and practices towards instrumental delivery in Egypt. This included either encouraging or refusing practicing instrumental delivery, and possible reasons for their attitude. A panel of three expert obstetricians (professors) revised the questionnaire and determined whether the included items were comprehensive, understandable, clear, and suitable to achieve the aim of the study. The primary outcome measure was the physicians’ attitude towards ID in Egypt. Secondary outcome measure included possible reasons for avoiding ID among Egyptian obstetricians. The sample size was calculated at a significance level of 95%and an error level of 20% with the proportion of physicians accepted trial of instrumental delivery in theatre = 60% [14]. A drop-out proportion of 10% was added to the raw result giving a final count of 95 physicians. Statistical analysis Data were fed to the computer and analyzed using IBM SPSS software package version 26.0. (Armonk, NY: IBM Corp). Categorical data were represented as numbers and percentages. Quantitative data were expressed as mean and standard deviation. Results The questionnaire was left open for 3 months, collecting 139 responses. It was distributed electronically to a number of 423 obstetricians, with 139 obstetricians responded. The mean age of the responders was 40.42 ± 9.96. A greater proportion of them were females (89/139, 64%) and specialists (63/139, 45.3%). The mean length of experience was 13.91 ± 9.84 years (Table 1). Table 1Basic demographic data of the participantsAge (years) (Mean ± SD)40.42 ± 9.96SexFemale89 (64.0%)Male50 (36.0%)StatusConsultant54 (38.8%)Specialist63 (45.3%)Resident22 (15.8%)Residency trainingGovernmental hospital87 (62.6%)Private hospital6 (4.3%)University hospital46 (33.1%)Current practiceGovernmental hospital30 (21.6%)Private hospital28 (20.1%)University hospital21 (15.1%)Governmental and private hospitals39 (28.1%)University and private hospitals21 (15.1%)Years of experience (years) (Mean ± SD)13.91 ± 9.84 Basic demographic data of the participants Seventy-three (52.5%) of the obstetricians never tried ID before. Even those who practiced ID (45/139, 32.4%), had less experience, as they practiced it for few times (1–5 times) (Table 2). Table 2Physicians’ experience regarding IDHave you ever tried instrumental deliveryYes66 (47.5%)No73 (52.5%)If yes, how many times0 times73 (52.5%)1–5 times45 32.4%)6– 15 times10 (7.2%)> 15 times11 (7.9%) Physicians’ experience regarding ID A great proportion of the physicians had a neutral attitude towards encouraging ID (59/139, 42.4%), although agreeing to present it as an option (64/139, 46%). They presented average knowledge about ID indications and safety (Tables 3 and 4). Table 3Physicians’ knowledge about IDID should be actively encouragedAgree or strongly agree35 (25.2%)Neither agree nor disagree59 (42.4%)Disagree or strongly disagree45 (32.4%)ID should be presented as an optionAgree or strongly agree64 (46.0%)Neither agree nor disagree46 (33.1%)Disagree or strongly disagree29 (20.9%)ID should be Offered when there is excessive maternal weight gain, high BMI or gestational diabetesAgree or strongly agree18 (12.9%)Neither agree nor disagree30 (21.6%)Disagree or strongly disagree91 (65.5%)ID should be Offered when the fetal head is more than one-fifth palpable above the pelvic brimAgree or strongly agree21 (15.1%)Neither agree nor disagree32 (23.0%)Disagree or strongly disagree86 (61.9%)ID should be Offered with maternal exhaustion in the second stageAgree or strongly agree92 (66.2%)Neither agree nor disagree20 (14.4%)Disagree or strongly disagree27 (19.4%)ID should be Offered if the fetal head is in the occipitoposterior positionAgree or strongly agree55 (39.6%)Neither agree nor disagree38 (27.3%)Disagree or strongly disagree46 (33.1%)ID should be Offered with Fetal skull moulding +++Agree or strongly agree22 (15.8%)Neither agree nor disagree37 (26.6%)Disagree or strongly disagree80 (57.6%) Physicians’ knowledge about ID Table 4Physicians’ knowledge about IDThe risk of shoulder dystocia increases with instrumental deliveryYes71 (51.1%)No19 (13.7%)Unsure49 (35.3%)Sequential use of instruments is safeYes24 (17.3%)No72 (51.8%)Unsure43 (30.9%)If there is no progress following three traction attempts, caesarean section should be consideredYes121 (87.1%)No5 (3.6%)Unsure13 (9.4%)Rotational forceps has been abandonedYes67 (48.2%)No26 (18.7%)Unsure46 (33.1%)ventouse delivery has a lower success rate than forceps deliveryYes42 (30.2%)No53 (38.1%)Unsure44 (31.7%)ventouse delivery is safer than forceps deliveryYes68 (48.9%)No34 (24.5%)Unsure37 (26.6%) Physicians’ knowledge about ID Eighty-nine (64%) of the obstetricians declined encouraging ID if in a situation that indicated the use of ID. Possible reasons for abandoning ID included reduction of training (116/139, 83.5%), lack of senior supervision (99/139, 71.2%), fear of litigation (125/139, 89.9%), their convenience that emergency CS in the second stage is safer than ID (86/139, 61.9%), lack of consultant supervision in acute situations (108/139, 77.7%), lack of modern equipment (108/139, 77.7%), and financial gains with performing CS (77/139, 55.4%) (Table 5). Table 5Possible reasons for not recommending IDA reduction in trainingYes116 (83.5%)No23 (16.5%)Lack of senior supervisionYes99 (71.2%)No40 (28.8%)Fear of litigationYes125 (89.9%)No14 (10.1%)Emergency caesarean section in the second stage is safer than instrumental vaginal deliveryYes86 (61.9%)No53 (38.1%)Instrumental vaginal delivery is not associated with spontaneous vaginal delivery in a subsequent pregnancyYes46 (33.1%)No93 (66.9%)Consultant supervision and teaching is not always possible in acute situationsYes108 (77.7%)No31 (22.3%)It is not recommended by the ministry of healthYes74 (53.2%)No65 (46.8%)Lack of modern equipmentYes108 (77.7%)No31 (22.3%)Financial gains may accompany the performance of CSYes77 (55.4%)No62 (44.6%) Possible reasons for not recommending ID Discussion A great proportion of the obstetricians never tried ID before. Even those who practiced ID had less experience, although it is documented by the WHO as one of six fundamental skills in critical obstetric care [1]. A recent report mentioned that ID was the least performed skill in basic institutions [3]. Other countries reported lack of ID education in many medical schools [8]. A great proportion of the physicians had a neutral attitude towards encouraging ID, although agreeing to present it as an option. More than half of the obstetricians declined encouraging ID if in a situation that indicated the use of ID. An earlier study evaluating the national attitudes of physicians towards vacuum delivery in 121 developing countries, and reported varied rates of ID. In Latin America, 74% of the countries never used ID. In Sub-Saharan Africa and Asia, 40% and 30% of countries, respectively never used ID [15]. Another report declared refusal of a great number of Egyptian obstetricians to perform any procedure that might decrease the CS rate as ID [5]. Possible reasons for abandoning ID included reduction of training, lack of senior supervision, fear of litigation, their convenience that emergency CS in the second stage is safer than ID, lack of consultant supervision in acute situations, lack of modern equipment, and financial gains with performing CS. Limited resources A previous report mentioned outdated equipment as a main finding when analysis possible causes for disappearing ID art [6]. Other causes for low ID especially in low resource countries were increased parity, lack of epidural analgesia, and lack of electronic fetal monitoring [16]. Deficient training Other contributing factors were lack of training, reluctance of trained obstetricians to perform ID, lack of endorsement in institutional policies, and financial gains with performing CS [8]. A recent study reported one of the reasons for declined ID rates was lack of ID training in residency training programs [17]. Easily accessible and harmless CS Other causes included increased accessibility of CS in the second stage [12]. There is no evidence that CS would improve maternal or fetal outcomes. Extremely elevated rates of CS are unjustified [18]. Another study reported refusal of ID by the obstetricians and pediatricians because of its possible fetal harm [12]. Other contributing factors Other reasons included the absence of national or institutional guidelines in the Egyptian healthcare sector [19]. In addition, antenatal care programs do not include teaching classes about ID [20]. Also, increased financial gains with CS than vaginal delivery played a paramount role in the declined rates of ID [21]. Strengths and limitations Scarce studies reported on obstetricians’ attitude towards ID in Egypt. This study elaborated possible causes for abandoning ID among Egyptian obstetricians. However; the sample size is a limitation. It has been estimated that a sample size of about 300 participants would be representative for a population of about 6000 for categorical data [22]. Unfortunately, we do not have an accurate estimate for the number of obstetricians in Egypt, with approximated estimates of about 6700 obstetricians in the governmental sector only. Accordingly, this sample size would limit the generalizability of the results. Research implications ID in Egypt is considered a vanished art, accompanied with a tremendous increase in CS rates. Proper training of the obstetricians is a must. Setting definitive institutional guidelines concerned with ID would help in decreasing CS rates and encouraging the obstetricians to practice ID when indicated. Conclusions ID is not widely practiced in Egypt. Great effort should be directed towards increased physicians’ awareness and experience regarding ID, although the chances for training would be in emergency situations, limiting opportunities for training. Acknowledgements Not applicable. Abbreviations Instrumental delivery World health organization Cesarean section Authors’ contributions OTT: Data collection, and analysis, manuscript writing, and editing. MAH: Data collection and management, Manuscript writing/editing. AME: Protocol/project development, Data analysis, Manuscript writing/editing. MFI: Data collection, and analysis, manuscript writing, and editing. TYMA: Protocol/project development, Data collection, Manuscript writing/revision. AAA: Protocol/project development, Data analysis, Manuscript writing/editing. All authors have read and approved the manuscript. Funding Open access funding provided by The Science, Technology & Innovation Funding Authority (STDF) in cooperation with The Egyptian Knowledge Bank (EKB). Self-funded research. Data availability The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate This study was conducted after approval of the research ethics committee of the faculty of medicine, Suez Canal University, on 23/12/2024, with a reference number of 5879#. All procedures performed in the study were following the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards. This article does not contain any studies with animals performed by any of the authors. Informed written consent was obtained from all participants before enrollment in the study. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article.