Begomoviral pre-coat protein boosts potato virus X in mixed infection through interfering with antiviral RNAi response Authors: Dibyendu Ghosh, M. Malavika, Pratibha Rawat, Supriya Chakraborty Published: 2025 ABSTRACT BackgroundPlant-infecting viruses cause severe crop losses throughout the world. The frequent occurrence of mixed infection (co-existence of multiple viruses in a single infected plant) in the field makes the situation more alarming. Mixed infection of two viruses often boosts the fitness of either of the viruses and thus increases disease severity. Maize lethal necrosis disease and rice tungro disease are some devastating examples. This study focused on the mixed viral infection between begomovirus, a ssDNA virus, and potato virus X (PVX), a ssRNA virus.ResultsV2 protein encoded by a monopartite begomovirus, pepper leaf curl Bangladesh virus (PepLCBV), promotes the accumulation of PVX. When Nicotiana benthamiana plants were infected with both PVX and PepLCBV, aggravated PVX-induced symptoms and increased PVX titre were detected compared to plants infected with PVX alone. This observation suggests that PepLCBV promotes the viral titre of PVX during mixed infection. Next, when PepLCBVΔV2 infectious clone was co-infiltrated with PVX, no increase in PVX-associated symptoms was observed in the plants, which confirmed that the V2 protein plays a pivotal role in mediating the interaction between these two viruses. PepLCBV-V2 was experimentally identified as a potent suppressor of post-transcriptional gene silencing. Its interaction with suppressor of gene silencing 3 (NbSGS3) was confirmed through yeast two-hybrid and BiFC. Silencing of NbSGS3 facilitated PVX pathogenesis. Next, specific amino acids responsible for the suppressor activity of the V2 protein were identified, and the silencing suppressor mutant V2 failed to boost the PVX titre. A similar observation was recorded when the association of PVX with a bipartite begomovirus, tomato leaf curl New Delhi virus, was checked in both N. benthamiana and tomato.ConclusionThe present study, for the first time, reports that begomoviruses promote the pathogenesis of potato virus X during mixed infection and identifies begomoviral pre-coat protein (V2/AV2) as a key player in mediating this virus-virus interaction. We further demonstrated that the silencing suppression activity of V2 is important for regulating PVX titre in mixed-infected plants.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12985-025-03005-0. Background Viruses can infect a wide range of economically important crops, vegetables and ornamental plants and are considered a global threat to agro-economy [1]. As per an estimate from 2014, plant diseases caused by viral pathogens cost almost USD30 billion a year [2]. Mixed viral infection, where more than one virus infects a plant, often makes the disease more severe [3] due to synergistic viral association, where one virus can positively influence replication, movement, tissue tropism, host range, and even transmission of another virus, leading to extensive yield losses and creating a serious threat to food security [4]. The association of maize chlorotic mottle virus (MCMV), a machlomovirus, with its potyvirus partner, such as sugarcane mosaic virus (SCMV), maize dwarf mosaic virus (MDMV), johnsongrass mosaic virus (JGMV), synergistically caused the severe pandemic of maize lethal necrosis disease (MLND). The total estimated annual loss due to MLND, in sub–Saharan East Africa alone, is about 20.5 million USD [5]. Rice tungro disease is another major pandemic that occurs in rice-growing countries due to mixed infection between two viruses, rice tungro bacilliform virus (RTBV) and rice tungro spherical virus (RTSV). The infected plants would appear stunted, yellowing and mottling of symptomatic leaves and decreased tillers with a reduction in grain quantity and the emergence of sterile grains. Estimated yield losses were up to 90% with annual production losses of 1.5 billion USD [6]. In this study, we have demonstrated a mixed viral association of potato virus X (PVX) and begomoviruses. PVX is a positive-sense ssRNA virus belonging to the genus potexvirus of the family Alphaflexiviridae. The genomic RNA of PVX is 6.4 kb in size, with a methyl guanosine cap at the 5’ end and a 3’-poly (A) tail. PVX can infect several economically important plants like potato, tobacco, tomato, pepper and can be transmitted via mechanical contact and vegetative propagation. PVX encodes only five proteins. The RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) of size 166 kDa is the first protein to be expressed from the viral genomic RNA, while the remaining four proteins are expressed from sub-genomic RNAs (sgRNA). The movement of PVX is carried out with the help of the triple gene block (TGB) proteins. The sgRNA1 codes for the TGB1 protein (also denoted as p25 because of its size of 25 kDa) while the other TGB2 (12 kDa) and TGB3 (8 kDa) are expressed from sgRNA2. The coat protein (CP) is expressed from sgRNA3 [7]. PVX-encoded TGB1 mediates 26 S proteasomal degradation of Argonaute 1 and thus acts as a viral suppressor of RNA silencing (VSR) [8]. On the other hand, begomoviruses are ssDNA viruses belonging to the largest family of plant-infecting viruses, Geminiviridae. They are transmitted by whiteflies (Bemisia tabaci) and can infect a wide range of weeds, crops and vegetables such as tomato, pepper, okra, beans, cucurbits, and radish [9]. Begomoviruses are classified into two groups based on their genome organization: monopartite begomoviruses, which consist of one ssDNA component as their genetic material, and bipartite begomoviruses, which include two genetic components, DNA-A and DNA-B, within their genome structure [10]. Begomoviruses encode a few multitasking proteins and newly identified small proteins, which mediate the infection cycle of these viruses [11, 12]. While the replication of begomoviruses is mediated by the replication initiator protein (Rep/C1/AC1) and replication enhancer protein (REn/C3/AC3) [13], the trans-activator protein (TrAP/C2/AC2) facilitates expression of some viral genes. C4/AC4 protein acts as a potent VSR and pathogenicity determinant [14]. Virion sense strand encodes two proteins, coat protein (V1/AV1) for encapsidation and pre-coat protein (V2/AV2). Begomoviral pre-coat protein is a multifunctional protein. In the case of tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV), the V2 protein interacts with SGS3 and inhibits post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) [15, 16]. Recently, V2 encoded by cotton leaf curl Multan virus has been reported to interact with calmodulin (CAM) 3 and breach the CAM3-CAMTA3 module of PTGS [17]. In addition, it also interacts and inhibits AGO4, which is involved in the RNA-dependent DNA methylation pathway [18]. V2 can also interact with histone deacetylase 6 (HDA6) to block transcriptional gene silencing (TGS) [19]. V2 plays a key role in the movement of monopartite begomovirus [20]. However, bipartite begomoviruses encode movement protein (BC1) and nuclear shuttle protein (BV1) for intra- and inter-cellular movement [21]. In this current study, we report the association of PVX and begomovirus, where the latter promotes the accumulation of PVX in mixed infection. In addition, we have also demonstrated the role of begomoviral pre-coat protein in mediating the interaction between PVX and begomoviruses such as pepper leaf curl Bangladesh virus (PepLCBV) and tomato leaf curl New Delhi virus (ToLCNDV). Material & methods Plant growth conditions and virus infection The seeds of Nicotiana benthamiana, Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi, and Solanum lycopersicum cv. Pusa Early Dwarf were germinated and grown in soil mix. The germinated seedlings were transferred to individual pots and maintained at a temperature of 25 ± 2 °C in 16 h photoperiod with 60% relative humidity in an insect-proof greenhouse. Four-week-old plants were used for virus infection. Infectious clones of potato virus X (GenBank accession no. AY297843), tomato leaf curl New Delhi virus DNA-A and DNA-B (ToLCNDV) (GenBank accession no. U15015 and U15017) and pepper leaf curl Bangladesh virus (GenBank accession no. JN663864) were used to infect plants through agro-infiltration method. Plasmid construction The coding sequence of V2 was amplified from PepLCBV DNA and initially cloned into the pJET1.2 vector (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Massachusetts, USA), followed by cloning into the pGR106 vector for developing PepLCBV-V2-PVX construct and into the pGADT7 vector for Yeast-two-hybrid (Y2H) assay. V2 was also cloned into pENTR/D TOPO (Invitrogen) vector, followed by into pSITE1648 and pGWB414 destination vectors for BiFC and silencing suppression study, respectively. For developing V2ΔVSR, the required mutations were introduced in primers (Table S1) and base overlapping extension PCR was performed. The mutation was confirmed by sequencing. The coding sequence of ToLCNDV encoded AV2 was amplified and initially cloned into the pJET1.2 vector, followed by cloning into the pRT101 vector and finally into the binary vector pCAMBIA2300 for developing transgenic lines. NbSGS3 was amplified from cDNA of N. benthamiana and cloned into pGBKT7 vector. NbSGS3 was also cloned into pENTR/D TOPO vector, followed by into the pSITE1651 destination vector for the BiFC study. Y2H assay Y2H assay was carried out using Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain AH109 having Gal4 system according to manufacturer’s protocol (CloneTech). After co-transformation of combinations of constructs, the transformed yeast colonies were allowed to grow in two drop-out (2DO) media plates [SD/-leu-trp] at 28 °C for 48 h. Random yeast colonies were selected from 2DO plate and serial dilutions were made using sterile double distilled water and dropped on 3DO (SD/-his-leu-trp) plates, 3DO plates supplemented with 1mM and 2.5mM 3-aminotriazole and allowed to grow for 48 h at 28 °C [22]. Bi-molecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC) assay A. tumefaciens strain EHA105 harbouring the confirmed clones of V2-pSITE1648 (V2-nYFP) and NbSGS3-pSITE1651 (SGS3-cYFP) (OD600 of 0.6 each) were agro-infiltrated on N. benthamiana leaves. Wet-mounted epidermal cells were visualized under a confocal microscope (Leica Microsystem, Wetzlar, Germany) 72 and 96 h post-infiltration (hpi) [23]. Leaves agro-infiltrated with (i) SGS3-cYFP and pSITE1648 empty vector (nYFP), (ii) V2-nYFP and pSITE1651 empty vector (cYFP), were also visualized as negative controls. Similarly, the interaction between V2ΔVSR-nYFP and SGS3-cYFP was also checked. Virus-induced gene Silencing (VIGS) assay Tobacco rattle virus (TRV) based VIGS was performed according to Singh, et al. [24]with minor modifications. Briefly, the 300 bp long specific coding sequence region of NbSGS3 was cloned into pTRV2 vector in anti-sense orientation to develop the pTRV2-NbSGS3 construct, followed by transformation into Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain GV3101. A. tumefaciens harboring either pTRV2 empty vector (OD600 of 0.4) or pTRV2- NbSGS3 construct (OD600 of 0.4) was agroinfiltrated along with pTRV1(OD600 of 0.4) to perform VIGS. PDS was silenced as a positive control to detect the onset of silencing. After seven days post-infiltration, photobleaching was observed in the PDS-silenced plants. Next, both non-silenced and NbSGS3-silenced plants were agro-infiltrated with an infectious clone of PVX (OD600 of 0.4). After 10 days post-infiltration, two uppermost symptomatic leaves were harvested for analyzing PVX titre. Silencing suppression assay For the silencing suppression assay, A. tumefaciens strain EHA105 harbouring V2 (35 S::V2, cloned in pGWB414 vector) was infiltrated along with 35 S::YFP (pSITE3CA empty vector). OD600 of 0.5 for each construct was used during agro-infiltration. For comparison, pGWB414 empty vector was agro-infiltrated along with 35 S::YFP. As a positive control, tombusviral silencing suppressor p19 was used. Agro-infiltrated leaf was visualised under UV lamp 72 h post-infiltration. Intense yellowish green patches (indicative of more YFP accumulation) suggest the silencing suppression activity of the protein [17]. Development of stable Transgenic tobacco plants overexpressing ToLCNDV-encoded AV2 protein The leaf explants of N. tabacum cv. Xanthi were transformed with A. tumefaciens EHA 105 strain carrying ToLCNDV encoded AV2 protein for 15 min following the procedure described by Horsch et al. 1985 [25]. The transformed explants were co-cultivated in Murashige Skoog media supplemented with benzyl amino purine (BAP) and indole acetic acid (IAA) with their stock concentrations as 100 mg/L. The explants were incubated for 48 h in the dark at 25 °C. Next, the explants were selected in MS media supplemented with Kanamycin (50 mg/L) and Cefotaxime (200 mg/L) and kept at 16 h photoperiod at 25 °C. After root development, the transgenic tobacco plants were transferred to soil for hardening. The plants expressing the AV2 protein were later confirmed by PCR. Transgenic plants were maintained in glass house at 16 h photoperiod at 25 ± 2 °C at 60% relative humidity until T2 seeds were collected. T2 generation plants were grown on soilrite, and expression of AV2 was confirmed by sqRT-PCR. Isolation of genomic DNA and RNA Genomic DNA and total RNA were isolated from upper most two systemic leaves as described previously [26]. The quality of isolated RNA was checked using a spectrophotometer (Model ND2000, Nano Drop, Thermo Fisher Scientific, Massachusetts, USA). Quantitative real-time (qRT) PCR, semi-quantitative reverse transcription (sqRT) PCR and quantitative PCR (qPCR) cDNA was prepared from one µg DNase-treated RNA using reverse transcriptase (M-MuLV RT RNase H-minus, Thermo Fisher Scientific, Massachusetts USA) and oligo (dT18) primer. cDNA was then diluted five times with nuclease-free water. This diluted cDNA has been used as a template for qRT-PCR and sqRT-PCR. Both qRT-PCR and sqRT-PCR were performed as mentioned previously [26]. Elongation factor 1α has been used as an internal control. For qRT-PCR, three independent biological replicates with three technical replicates have been used. qPCR was performed following the procedures described previously [26]. 25 S rRNA has been used as the internal control for normalization of qPCR data. Fold change was quantified using 2−ΔΔCt method during the analysis of qRT-PCR and qPCR data [27]. All the primers used for these studies are mentioned in Table S1. Statistical analysis Data obtained from qRT-PCR were denoted as mean ± standard deviation. Statistical significances were determined by student t-test using GraphPad Prism 8 (*P ≤ 0.05; **P ≤ 0.01; ***P ≤ 0.001, ****P ≤ 0.0001). Result PepLCBV and PVX influence each other’s pathogenesis during mixed infection To check the interaction between PepLCBV and PVX, we infected N. benthamiana plants with (i) PVX, (ii) PepLCBV and (iii) PVX & PepLCBV, and assayed their infectivity. PVX-associated symptoms (Fig S1) appeared on the systemic leaves on 4th days post infection (dpi) and symptom severity got maximized (severe mosaic and necrotic spots) on 7th −9th dpi. However, the severity of PVX-associated symptoms decreased gradually on/after 10 dpi, and plants almost recovered from PVX infection at 21 dpi. Interestingly, the plants co-infected with PVX and PepLCBV, failed to recover from PVX infection even at 21 dpi (Fig S2,1A, Table S2). Next, we quantified PVX titre and found a significant rise (~ 3.4 fold) in the accumulation of PVX in the presence of PepLCBV compared to only PVX-infected plants (Fig. 1B). Surprisingly, we observed an opposite phenomenon when we examined the impact of PVX on PepLCBV accumulation. PepLCBV-associated symptoms (upward leaf curling and severe stunting) were significantly less in the plants co-infected with PVX and PepLCBV as compared to only PepLCBV infected plants (Fig. 1A, S2A, S2C, Table S3). While analyzing viral titre through qPCR, a sharp decrease (~ 85%) in PepLCBV titre was recorded in the co-infected plants as compared to only PepLCBV-infected plants (Fig. 1C). However, we were keen to decipher how the presence of PepLCBV increases PVX titre during mixed infection. Fig. 1Characterization of interaction between PVX and PepLCBV during mixed infection. (A) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infected with (i) PVX, (ii) PVX & PepLCBV, and (iii) PepLCBV at 21 days post infection (from left to right), (B) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR, (C) Relative viral titre of PepLCBV in the infected systemic leaves measured through qPCR Characterization of interaction between PVX and PepLCBV during mixed infection. (A) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infected with (i) PVX, (ii) PVX & PepLCBV, and (iii) PepLCBV at 21 days post infection (from left to right), (B) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR, (C) Relative viral titre of PepLCBV in the infected systemic leaves measured through qPCR PepLCBV boosts PVX accumulation in mixed infection through its V2 protein Pre-coat protein (V2/AV2) is reported to play significant roles in the pathogenesis of several begomoviruses [15–20]. We previously reported the role of ToLCGV-encoded V2 protein in mediating asymmetric synergism between ToLCGV and ToLCNDV [28] and highlighted the involvement of ToLCNDV-AV2 protein in inhibiting symptom recovery in N. tabacum [29]. Keeping these observations in mind, we hypothesised the involvement of PepLCBV-encoded V2 in boosting PVX pathogenesis during mixed infection. To check this, PepLCBV- V2 was over-expressed through PVX-based expression vector, pGR106, in N. benthamiana, and we observed more severe PVX-associated mosaic symptoms on V2-pGR106 infiltrated-plants as compared to only pGR106 infiltrated plants (Fig. 2A, Table S4). We confirmed the presence of V2 transcripts in these over-expressed plants through sqRT-PCR (Fig. 2B). While quantifying the PVX titre through qRT-PCR we found that PVX accumulation gets almost two-fold increase in the presence of PepLCBV-V2 (Fig. 2C). This observation suggested that V2 could promote PVX accumulation. To further confirm the involvement of V2 protein in boosting PVX infection, PepLCBVΔV2, an infectious clone of PepLCBV having a premature stop codon in the open reading frame of V2 was used (Fig S3). Next, we co-infected N. benthamiana plants with (i) PVX & PepLCBV, (ii) PVX & PepLCBVΔV2, and (iii) PVX and empty vector pCAMBIA2300 and compared PVX infectivity. After 21days post-infection, we observed severe PVX-associated mosaic symptoms in plants co-infected with PVX and PepLCBV, while the plants (i) infiltrated with PVX along with pCAMBIA2300 and (ii) infiltrated with PVX and PepLCBVΔV2, showed mild PVX-associated symptoms (Fig. 2D). While analyzing the PVX titre through qRT-PCR, we observed a significant rise (~ 3.3 fold) in the accumulation of PVX in the presence of PepLCBV as compared to only PVX-infected plants (Fig. 2E). Interestingly, co-infection of PepLCBVΔV2 failed to boost PVX titre (Fig. 2E). This clearly suggests that PepLCBV promotes PVX accumulation through V2. Fig. 2PepLCBV promotes PVX accumulation through its V2 protein. (A) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infected with PVX (left panel) and PepLCBV-V2-PVX (right panel) at 10 days post infection, (B) sqRTPCR data showing the abundance of V2 transcripts in PepLCBV-V2-PVX infected plants, elongation factor 1α (NbEF1α) has been used as an internal control, (C) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR, (D) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infiltrated with PVX along with either (i) empty vector (pCAMBIA 2300) or (ii) PepLCBV or (iii) PepLCBVΔV2 at 21 days post infiltration (from left to right), (E) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR PepLCBV promotes PVX accumulation through its V2 protein. (A) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infected with PVX (left panel) and PepLCBV-V2-PVX (right panel) at 10 days post infection, (B) sqRTPCR data showing the abundance of V2 transcripts in PepLCBV-V2-PVX infected plants, elongation factor 1α (NbEF1α) has been used as an internal control, (C) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR, (D) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infiltrated with PVX along with either (i) empty vector (pCAMBIA 2300) or (ii) PepLCBV or (iii) PepLCBVΔV2 at 21 days post infiltration (from left to right), (E) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR PepLCBV encoded V2 protein interacts with NbSGS3 and acts as a VSR Pre-coat proteins encoded by begomoviruses such as tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV), tomato leaf curl New Delhi virus (ToLCNDV) and tomato leaf curl Gujarat virus (ToLCGV) have been reported as viral suppressors of RNAi (VSR) [15, 28]. TYLCV (Israeli isolate) encoded V2 interacts with AtSGS3 and blocks PTGS [15]. To check whether PepLCBV encoded V2 targets SGS3, N. benthamiana homolog of AtSGS3 was cloned and protein-protein interaction between PepLCBV-V2 and NbSGS3 was checked through a yeast two-hybrid assay. We found that yeast cells co-transformed with V2 and NbSGS3 can easily grow on three drop-out selection media (SD-LTH) supplemented with 1mM or even 2.5mM 3AT (Fig. 3A). Next, the interaction was confirmed in planta through BiFC, and we observed reconstitution of fluorescence in V2 and NbSGS3 over-expressed epidermal cells (Fig. 3B, S4). After that, the ability of V2 in suppressing PTGS was demonstrated through silencing suppression assay. When the leaves were seen under UV-light, we observed a more intense yellowish green patch in the presence of PepLCBV-V2 as compared to the empty vector control (Fig. 3C). Next, for relative quantification of YFP transcripts, sqRT-PCR was performed, and we detected more accumulation of YFP transcripts in the presence of PepLCBV-V2 compared to the empty vector control (Fig. 3D). P19 was used as a positive control. These observations demonstrate that PepLCBV-encoded V2 protein interacts with NbSGS3 and inhibits PTGS. Fig. 3PepLCBV encoded V2 binds with NbSGS3 and inhibits PTGS. (A) Yeast-two-hybrid assay showing the protein- protein interaction between PepLCBV- V2 and NbSGS3. Although yeast cells co-transformed with both the constructs were growing on three drop-out selection media (SD-LTH) supplemented with 1mM or even 2.5mM 3AT, however, all the negative controls failed to do so. P53 and large T-antigen (LT) were used as positive control in the study, (B) Bi molecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC) assay confirming the in-planta protein-protein interaction between PepLCBV-V2 (V2-nYFP) and NbSGS3 (SGS3-cYFP) at 72 h post infiltration, the combinations of (i) V2-nYFP & cYFP, and (ii) SGS3-cYFP & nYFP were taken as negative controls (C) Silencing suppression assay demonstrating the VSR activity of PepLCBV- V2 as brighter fluorescence patch was observed under UV light in presence of V2 as compared to only YFP infiltrated portion. P19 was taken as positive control, (D) sqRT-PCR showing the relative abundance of transcripts of YFP (upper panel), V2 (middle panel) and EF1α (lower panel) PepLCBV encoded V2 binds with NbSGS3 and inhibits PTGS. (A) Yeast-two-hybrid assay showing the protein- protein interaction between PepLCBV- V2 and NbSGS3. Although yeast cells co-transformed with both the constructs were growing on three drop-out selection media (SD-LTH) supplemented with 1mM or even 2.5mM 3AT, however, all the negative controls failed to do so. P53 and large T-antigen (LT) were used as positive control in the study, (B) Bi molecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC) assay confirming the in-planta protein-protein interaction between PepLCBV-V2 (V2-nYFP) and NbSGS3 (SGS3-cYFP) at 72 h post infiltration, the combinations of (i) V2-nYFP & cYFP, and (ii) SGS3-cYFP & nYFP were taken as negative controls (C) Silencing suppression assay demonstrating the VSR activity of PepLCBV- V2 as brighter fluorescence patch was observed under UV light in presence of V2 as compared to only YFP infiltrated portion. P19 was taken as positive control, (D) sqRT-PCR showing the relative abundance of transcripts of YFP (upper panel), V2 (middle panel) and EF1α (lower panel) NbSGS3 negatively regulates PVX pathogenesis SGS3 interacts with RDR6 [30] and SGS3-RDR6 complex mediates the production of secondary vsiRNA [31]. As the PepLCBV-V2 protein interacts with NbSGS3, we tested the impact of NbSGS3 on PVX pathogenesis. We opted for a TRV-based VIGS approach to silence NbSGS3 and infected both silenced and non-silenced plants with PVX. Interestingly, more PVX-associated symptoms (Fig. 4A, Table S5) and viral titre (~ 2 fold) (Fig. 4C) were recorded in NbSGS3-silenced plants as compared to non-silenced plants. Reduced accumulation of NbSGS3 transcripts was observed in the silenced plants (Fig. 4B). These observations emphasize the positive impact of NbSGS3 in regulating anti-viral response against PVX. Fig. 4Silencing of NbSGS3 aggravates PVX pathogenesis. (A) Representative photographs of PVX infected non-silenced (TRV) and NbSGS3-silenced (TRV-NbSGS3) N. benthamiana plants at 10 days post infection, the difference in PVX-associated symptoms was shown through red arrows, (B) sqRT-PCR data showing the relative expression of NbSGS3 in non-silenced (TRV) and NbSGS3-silenced (TRV-SGS3) plants, NbEF1α has been used as an internal control, (C) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR Silencing of NbSGS3 aggravates PVX pathogenesis. (A) Representative photographs of PVX infected non-silenced (TRV) and NbSGS3-silenced (TRV-NbSGS3) N. benthamiana plants at 10 days post infection, the difference in PVX-associated symptoms was shown through red arrows, (B) sqRT-PCR data showing the relative expression of NbSGS3 in non-silenced (TRV) and NbSGS3-silenced (TRV-SGS3) plants, NbEF1α has been used as an internal control, (C) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR Silencing suppression activity of V2 is important for boosting PVX titre Cysteine residues at 84th and 86th positions of TYLCV-V2 were mapped to be necessary for its interaction with AtSGS3 [15]. We analysed the amino acid sequences of pre-coat proteins encoded by begomoviruses and observed that ‘C84-X-C86’ motif is quite conserved among begomoviral pre-coat proteins (Fig S5A). We attempted to develop a V2 mutant that cannot interact with NbSGS3 and hence fails to act as a VSR. For this, we performed site-directed mutagenesis to replace C84 and C86 with S84 and S86. We developed the mutant and confirmed it through sequencing (Fig S5B, S6). We confirmed that the V2 mutant cannot interact with NbSGS3 through BiFC (Fig S5E). In addition, we also demonstrated that this mutant V2 failed to block PTGS through silencing suppression assay followed by relative quantification of YFP transcripts (Fig S5C, S5D) and hence named it as V2ΔVSR. Next, to check the impact of V2ΔVSR in PVX pathogenesis, we infected N. benthamiana plants with (i) PVX, (ii) V2-PVX, and (iii) V2ΔVSR-PVX. As noticed previously, more PVX-associated symptoms (Fig. 5A) and viral titre (almost two-fold increase) were recorded in V2-PVX-infected plants as compared to only PVX-infected plants (Fig. 5C). Interestingly, V2ΔVSR-PVX-infected plants showed mild mosaic symptoms comparable to only PVX-infected plants (Fig. 5A). Similarly, PVX accumulation was significantly reduced (~ 34%) in V2ΔVSR-PVX-infected plants when compared with V2-PVX-infected plants (Fig. 5C, Table S4). The presence of V2 transcripts were detected through sqRT-PCR (Fig. 5B). This suggests that the ability of V2 in suppressing PTGS is important for the observed interaction between PVX and PepLCBV. Fig. 5VSR activity of V2 is important for boosting PVX titre. (A) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infected with (i) PVX, (ii) PepLCBV-V2-PVX, and (iii) PepLCBV-V2ΔVSR -PVX at 10 days post infection, (B) sqRTPCR data showing the abundance of V2 transcripts in the afore-mentioned plants, elongation factor 1α (NbEF1α) has been used as an internal control, (C) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR VSR activity of V2 is important for boosting PVX titre. (A) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infected with (i) PVX, (ii) PepLCBV-V2-PVX, and (iii) PepLCBV-V2ΔVSR -PVX at 10 days post infection, (B) sqRTPCR data showing the abundance of V2 transcripts in the afore-mentioned plants, elongation factor 1α (NbEF1α) has been used as an internal control, (C) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR ToLCNDV boosts PVX accumulation in mixed infection through its AV2 protein We observed that a monopartite begomovirus, PepLCBV, promotes PVX accumulation in mixed infection. To validate whether similar phenomena occur in the case of bipartite begomoviruses or not, we took the tomato leaf curl New Delhi virus and co-infected N. benthamiana plants along with PVX (Fig. 6A, S7). An infectious ToLCNDVΔAV2 clone having a premature stop codon in the open reading frame of AV2 was also used [29]. We observed more PVX-associated symptoms (Fig. 6A) and higher accumulation of PVX in the presence of ToLCNDV as compared with only PVX-infected plants (Fig. 6B, Table S6). However, ToLCNDVΔAV2 failed to boost PVX accumulation (Fig. 6A and B). As tomato serves as a natural host for ToLCNDV, we co-infected tomato plants with PVX and ToLCNDV. Severe mosaic symptoms (Fig. 6C) and a significant, rise in PVX titre (Fig. 6D) were recorded in tomato plants co-infected with PVX and ToLCNDV as compared to only PVX-infected tomato plants. Next, to demonstrate the effect of ToLCNDV-AV2 in PVX pathogenesis, we overexpress ToLCNDV-AV2 (Fig. 6F) along with PVX and found that, similarly to PepLCBV-V2, ToLCNDV-AV2 also promotes PVX accumulation (Fig. 6E and G). To further confirm our observation, we raised stable transgenic tobacco plants overexpressing ToLCNDV-AV2. The transgenic plants were validated by detecting AV2 transcripts through sqRT-PCR (Fig. 7B). Two confirmed independent T2 lines, namely 14b and 50b (Fig S8), were challenged with PVX (Table S7). After 10 days post-infection, severe mosaic symptoms were observed in these PVX-infected transgenic lines compared to PVX-infected wild-type tobacco plants (Fig. 7A). While quantifying PVX accumulation, we found around 5.6- and 3.6-fold increase in PVX titre in 14b and 50b lines, respectively, compared to wild type plants (Fig. 7C). Along with the previous observations, hyper-susceptibility of ToLCNDV-AV2 overexpressing transgenic lines to PVX infection further reiterates that ToLCNDV promotes accumulation of PVX in mixed infection through its pre-coat protein. Fig. 6ToLCNDV promotes PVX accumulation through its AV2 protein. (A) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infected with (i) PVX, (ii) PVX & ToLCNDV, (iii) PVX & ToLCNDVΔAV2, (iv) ToLCNDV at 21 days post infiltration (from left to right), (B) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic N. benthamiana leaves measured through qRT PCR, (C) Representative photographs of tomato plants infiltrated with PVX along with either (i) empty vector (pCAMBIA 2300) or (ii) ToLCNDV at 21 days post infiltration, (D) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic tomato leaves measured through qRT PCR, (E) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infected with PVX (left panel) and ToLCNDV-AV2-PVX (right panel) at 10 days post infection, (F) sqRTPCR data showing the abundance of AV2 transcripts in ToLCNDV-AV2-PVX infected plants, elongation factor 1α (NbEF1α) has been used as an internal control, (G) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR ToLCNDV promotes PVX accumulation through its AV2 protein. (A) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infected with (i) PVX, (ii) PVX & ToLCNDV, (iii) PVX & ToLCNDVΔAV2, (iv) ToLCNDV at 21 days post infiltration (from left to right), (B) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic N. benthamiana leaves measured through qRT PCR, (C) Representative photographs of tomato plants infiltrated with PVX along with either (i) empty vector (pCAMBIA 2300) or (ii) ToLCNDV at 21 days post infiltration, (D) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic tomato leaves measured through qRT PCR, (E) Representative photographs of N. benthamiana plants infected with PVX (left panel) and ToLCNDV-AV2-PVX (right panel) at 10 days post infection, (F) sqRTPCR data showing the abundance of AV2 transcripts in ToLCNDV-AV2-PVX infected plants, elongation factor 1α (NbEF1α) has been used as an internal control, (G) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic leaves measured through qRT PCR Fig. 7ToLCNDV-AV2 overexpressing stable transgenic tobacco lines are hyper-susceptible to PVX infection. (A) Representative photographs of PVX infected (i) wildtype N. tabacum plants and (ii) ToLCNDV-AV2 overexpressing transgenic tobacco lines (both 14b and 50b) at 10 days post infection (from left to right), (B) sqRTPCR data showing the abundance of AV2 transcripts in the afore mentioned transgenic tobacco plants, elongation factor 1α (NtEF1α) has been used as an internal control, (C) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic tobacco leaves measured through qRT PCR ToLCNDV-AV2 overexpressing stable transgenic tobacco lines are hyper-susceptible to PVX infection. (A) Representative photographs of PVX infected (i) wildtype N. tabacum plants and (ii) ToLCNDV-AV2 overexpressing transgenic tobacco lines (both 14b and 50b) at 10 days post infection (from left to right), (B) sqRTPCR data showing the abundance of AV2 transcripts in the afore mentioned transgenic tobacco plants, elongation factor 1α (NtEF1α) has been used as an internal control, (C) Relative viral titre of PVX in the infected systemic tobacco leaves measured through qRT PCR Discussion When plant viruses infect a host, the plant cell recognises the presence of foreign viral genetic material and activates the gene silencing machinery to degrade the viral genome and prevent its spread in the neighbouring cell. Dicer-like (DCLs) proteins cleave the viral dsRNA intermediates into small interfering RNAs (siRNA). Argonaute (AGOs) proteins bind to these virus-derived siRNAs and mediate the formation of the RISC complex, which finally targets complementary viral mRNAs and cleaves them. Next, RNA-dependent RNA polymerases (RDRs) further form dsRNA, leading to the generation of secondary virus-derived siRNAs (2° vsiRNA) and thus amplify the host’s RNAi response [32]. SGS3 interacts with RDR6 and co-localises in SGS3/RDR6 cytoplasmic bodies [30]. This RNA-binding protein facilitates RDR6-mediated production of 2° vsiRNA with specificity. Different variants of DCLs, AGOs and RDRs have been reported to participate in anti-viral RNAi response against different plant-infecting viruses. In the case of PVX, silencing of DCL2 and DCL4 aggravates the viral pathogenesis in tomato [33]. AGO2 significantly hampers the infectivity of PVX in Arabidopsis thaliana and plays a key role in determining the host range [34, 35]. However, the role of host machineries involved in 2° vsiRNA production was not characterised in the case of PVX infection. Here, we have shown that silencing of SGS3, a co-factor of RDR6, significantly promotes the accumulation of PVX in N. benthamiana (Fig. 4A and C). Plant-infecting viruses encode effectors that interact with SGS3 and hamper the SGS3-RDR6 module of PTGS. Citrus tristeza virus encoded p20 protein, Sri Lankan cassava mosaic virus encoded AC4 protein, and turnip mosaic virus encoded VpG protein interact with SGS3 and promote its degradation through autophagy [36–38]. TYLCV-encoded V2 protein was also reported to interact with AtSGS3 [15]. In this study, we found that PepLCBV encoded V2 interacts with NbSGS3 and thus inhibits PTGS (Fig. 3). This observation reiterates the conserveness of V2-SGS3 interaction in different ‘host-begomovirus’ pathosystems. In addition, we have also demonstrated that the ability of V2 to act as a VSR is crucial for PVX-PepLCBV interaction (Fig. 5). The synergistic association of PVX with several potyviral partners like potato virus A (PVA), potato virus Y (PVY), tobacco etch virus, tobacco vein mottling virus, pepper mottle virus was already reported [39, 40]. In this association of potyvirus-PVX, both the viral titre and symptom severity of PVX get significantly increased, and potyviral silencing suppressor HC-Pro plays the pivotal role in mediating synergism [41]. While delineating the molecular mechanism of PVX-potyviral synergism, Gonzalez-Jara et al. further demonstrated that the VSR activity of HC-Pro is directly linked to its ability to boost PVX titre during the mixed infection [42]. Recently, De et al. further added that HC-Pro also reduced the glutathione accumulation in plant cells, which helps PVX to propagate [40]. In the case of other mixed viral associations, VSRs play the key roles in promoting synergism [4]. During the co-evolution of host and virus, viruses evolved to encode their VSRs to disarm the host’s antiviral RNAi response at different junctures. While a few targets AGOs or DCLS, others successfully block the production of 2° vsiRNA [32, 43]. During mixed infection, one VSR encoded by a virus weakens RNAi response, which may help another partner virus to propagate more efficiently, resulting in a synergistic mixed infection [4]. In the case of rice tungro disease, RTSV encoded polymerase and coat protein promote the VSR activity of RTBV encoded ORF-IV, leading to a synergism between RTSV and RTBV [44]. In the case of the begomovirus-betasatellite complex, betasatellite-encoded βC1 protein is a potent suppressor of both PTGS and TGS and thus promotes the accumulation of helper begomovirus [45, 46]. In the case of tomato leaf curl disease in India, asymmetric synergism is observed between tomato leaf curl Gujarat virus (ToLCGV) and ToLCNDV, where ToLCGV-encoded VSRs, such as TrAP and pre-coat proteins, play pivotal roles in mediating the interaction [28]. All the above-mentioned reports clearly emphasise the impact of VSRs in regulating virus-virus interactions. In this current study, we established V2 as a central player in promoting PVX accumulation in PVX-PepLCBV mixed infection through over-expression and mutant study. However, chances of other begomoviral protein/s having an ancillary role in boosting PVX titre during mixed infection cannot be overlooked. Another interesting finding of our study is that PVX inhibits the pathogenesis of PepLCBV in mixed infection (Fig. 1A and C, S2C). Similarly, the severity of ToLCNDV-associated leaf curling symptoms was less in N. benthamiana plants co-infected with PVX and ToLCNDV compared to only ToLCNDV-infected plants (Table S8). These observations clearly pinpoint that PVX negatively regulates begomovirus pathogenesis in mixed infection. A similar observation was recorded in PVX-PVA infected N. benthamiana plants, where PVA positively regulates the accumulation of PVX; however, PVX inhibits the propagation of PVA [40]. We are currently looking into the mechanism behind PVX-mediated inhibition of begomoviral pathogenesis. Conclusion In a nutshell, our study demonstrates that begomoviruses promote the pathogenesis of PVX during mixed infection in both N. benthamiana and tomato. We found that begomoviral pre-coat proteins (V2/AV2) play the pivotal role in mediating this begomovirus-potexvirus interaction. In addition, we have demonstrated that SGS3 negatively regulates PVX pathogenesis. Furthermore, begomoviral pre-coat protein interacts with SGS3 and inhibits the SGS3-RDR6 module of RNAi, which facilitates more PVX accumulation during mixed infection. Supplementary Information Supplementary Material 1. Supplementary Material 1. Supplementary Material 2. Supplementary Material 2.