Active bridging hydride species in ZnO nanorods originated from hydroxyl and oxygen vacancy Authors: Benteng Song, Zhonghan Feng, Xin-Ping Wu, Ye Gu, Linghai Xie, Qin Zhu, Luming Peng Published: 2025 ABSTRACT The bridging hydride species (Zn-H-Zn) formed via H2 dissociation on ZnO surface play crucial roles in hydrogenation of unsaturated hydrocarbon to industrial production. Here, we find that the migration of surface hydroxyl in ZnO nanorods to nearby oxygen vacancy can also lead to the formation of this Zn-H-Zn species that are reactive to CO2 hydrogenation to methanol using solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Below 100 °C, bridging Zn-H-Zn species show no activity toward CO2 activation, while formate species are formed via the reaction of CO2 with surface hydroxyl groups. At 150-200 °C, Zn-H-Zn species hydrogenate formate to methoxy species. At 250 °C, methanol is produced and desorbs from the ZnO surface. These results confirm the methanol formation mechanism via formate and methoxy intermediates in the presence of active bridging Zn-H-Zn species. This work reveals a new source of active hydrogen species in ZnO nanorods without introducing H2, which is highly significant for heterogeneous hydrogenation reactions. Introduction ZnO (zinc oxide), one of the most important wide-band gap semiconductors, has great potential applications in the field of solar cells1, sensors2,3, light emissions4–6, and catalysts7,8. For catalytic applications, ZnO is an essential component in composite catalysts, playing a key role in H2 activation and hydrogenation reactions, such as methanol and light-olefins synthesis from H2/CO/CO29–12. For catalytic hydrogenation reaction over ZnO catalyst, the hydride species (Zn-H) formed from the dissociation of H2 on ZnO surface are usually recognized as the active species responsible for relevant hydrogenation processes13,14. Yang et al. showed that H2 can dissociate heterolytically at the ZnO surface and the generated Zn-H species hydrogenate CO/CO2 to formate15. Moreover, most studies have demonstrated that a bridging Zn-H-Zn structure originated from H2 dissociation at an oxygen vacancy exhibits reactivity toward hydrogenation of unsaturated hydrocarbon species by both computational and experimental studies. For example, previous calculation studies have shown that the Zn-H-Zn species at oxygen vacancies formed from H2 cleavage facilitate the reduction of CO to formyl in the methanol synthesis process16. Gong et al. also investigated the catalytic activity and selectivity of this bridging hydride generated via H2 dissociation at ZnO defect sites for CO2 hydrogenation using theoretical methods17. By applying various characterization methods (e.g., XPS, H2-TPD, H/D exchange, and in situ IR), Li et al. studied the hydrogenation of CO2 to methanol over composite ZnO catalysts and found that the Zn-H-Zn species formed upon H2 introduction participated in CO2 activation and enhanced catalytic performance18, which is in agreement with the findings of Polarz et al19. Despite of these advancements, the effects of different conditions on the active sites on the surfaces of ZnO require further investigation. Solid-state NMR spectroscopy is a powerful technique that has been widely used in studying the local environments of solid materials20,21. For ZnO, previous studies have shown that surface hydrogen species, interstitial hydrogen (Hi) and oxygen-substitutional H (HO) species in ZnO nanoparticles can be distinguished by their 1H NMR shifts22,23, while the assignments of 1H resonances are still under debate24–26. More recently, 1H solid-state NMR has also been applied to study the H2 activation and catalytic properties of H species on ZnO27,28. Here, we apply 1H solid-state NMR spectroscopy combined with DFT calculations to study the hydrogen species of ZnO nanorods at different conditions. In addition to H2 homolysis at oxygen vacancy, which is a widely recognized pathway for the generation of active hydride species, the migration of surface hydroxyl to nearby oxygen vacancy also leads to the formation of a bridging hydride species in the form of Zn-H-Zn, which are active toward CO2 hydrogenation. This finding shows the importance of hydroxyl species combined with oxygen vacancy for heterogeneous catalysis. Results Morphology of the ZnO sample Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) were used to characterize the morphologies and structure. The XRD pattern confirms that the prepared ZnO nanorods have a wurtzite structure (Supplementary Fig. S1a), which are highly crystalline and predominately covered by nonpolar (10\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\bar{1}$$\end{document}1¯0) facets based on the TEM/HRTEM images (Supplementary Figs. S1b, S1c). Different surface hydrogen species investigated with 1H NMR The 1H NMR spectra of ZnO nanorods before and after exposing to vacuum at room temperature are given in Supplementary Fig. S2. According to our previous study27, the peaks at 4.8 and 0–3 ppm are assigned to physisorbed water, and surface hydroxyl and/or water, respectively. As obtained ZnO nanorods exposed to vacuum at room temperature and high temperatures (X °C) are denoted as “ZnO-RT-vac” and “ZnO-X-vac”, respectively, and Fig. 1a shows that the spectral intensity of ZnO nanorods decreases gradually with the increase of heating temperature under vacuum. It is necessary to point out that the center of the broad peak at 0–3 ppm gradually shifts to lower frequencies (1.5 and 0.9 ppm for ZnO-100-vac and ZnO-300-vac, respectively) upon dehydration and dehydroxylation, indicating that these species may be distinguished by their 1H NMR shifts. For ZnO-400-vac, the spectral intensity further decreases in comparison with ZnO-300-vac, while a relatively small change is observed after being heated at 500 °C (ZnO-500-vac) (Fig. 1a and Supplementary Fig. S3). The H/D exchange experiment shown in Supplementary Fig. S4 suggests that the residual resonances in ZnO-400-vac/ZnO-500-vac can be mainly ascribed to bulk hydrogen species of ZnO nanorods (e.g., H impurity), while a large fraction of surface hydrogen species is present on ZnO nanorods heated below 300 °C.Fig. 11H NMR spectra of ZnO nanorods and the structure models of ZnO used in the DFT calculations.a 1H NMR spectra of ZnO nanorods after being heated at different temperatures under vacuum. An optimized recycle delay of 5 s was used, while 64 acquisitions were collected for all spectra. b 1H-17O TRAPDOR NMR spectra of ZnO-RT-vac. 17O irradiation time: 0.2 ms; MAS rate: 5 kHz; recycle delay: 2 s; 17O irradiation radio frequency (RF) field strength: 64 kHz. The difference spectrum is obtained by subtracting the double resonance spectrum from the control spectrum. Asterisks denotes spinning sidebands. c The structure models of ZnO nanorods used for DFT calculations. Top: the optimized ZnO(10\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\bar{1}$$\end{document}1¯0) surface with a monolayer of water molecules (1 ML) in which half of the water molecules are dissociatively adsorbed while the other half molecularly adsorbed (model M1D1); bottom: ZnO(10\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\bar{1}$$\end{document}1¯0) surface with 1 ML water molecules in which all of the water molecules are molecularly adsorbed (model M2, also see Supplementary Fig. S6 for the structure). Gray and white spheres represent Zn and H atoms, red and blue spheres represent O atoms. 1H NMR spectra of ZnO nanorods and the structure models of ZnO used in the DFT calculations. a 1H NMR spectra of ZnO nanorods after being heated at different temperatures under vacuum. An optimized recycle delay of 5 s was used, while 64 acquisitions were collected for all spectra. b 1H-17O TRAPDOR NMR spectra of ZnO-RT-vac. 17O irradiation time: 0.2 ms; MAS rate: 5 kHz; recycle delay: 2 s; 17O irradiation radio frequency (RF) field strength: 64 kHz. The difference spectrum is obtained by subtracting the double resonance spectrum from the control spectrum. Asterisks denotes spinning sidebands. c The structure models of ZnO nanorods used for DFT calculations. Top: the optimized ZnO(10\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\bar{1}$$\end{document}1¯0) surface with a monolayer of water molecules (1 ML) in which half of the water molecules are dissociatively adsorbed while the other half molecularly adsorbed (model M1D1); bottom: ZnO(10\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\bar{1}$$\end{document}1¯0) surface with 1 ML water molecules in which all of the water molecules are molecularly adsorbed (model M2, also see Supplementary Fig. S6 for the structure). Gray and white spheres represent Zn and H atoms, red and blue spheres represent O atoms. To confirm the spectral assignments, we further investigated the H-O proximity of ZnO-RT-vac by 1H-17O transfer of population in the Double Resonance (TRAPDOR) NMR method29. Typical TRAPDOR NMR spectra obtained with a rather short 17O irradiation time of about 0.2 ms, in which only the 17O ions in the first coordination shell (i.e., 17O directly bound to H) are close enough to have an impact, show that the intensity of the resonance at 0.9 ppm decreases significantly in the double resonance experiment (Fig. 1b). Hence, the 1H resonance centered at 0.9 ppm can be assigned to surface hydroxyl groups, while the relatively high-frequency signals centered at 1.5 ppm (in the range of 0–3 ppm) arise from adsorbed water (Fig. 1a and Supplementary Fig. S3), which is consistent with the trend that the center of the peak in the double resonance experiment gradually shifts to higher frequency from 0.9 ppm with the increase of 17O irradiation time (Supplementary Fig. S5). DFT calculations of 1H chemical shifts were performed for the two most energetically favorable ZnO structural models identified in previous literature30,31 to help spectral assignments (Fig. 1c). In model M1D1, the calculated δH of surface OH is close to 0.9 ppm, which is the observed shift of the major peak in the spectrum of ZnO-300-vac (Fig. 1a). The calculated δH values of two H species in one water molecule are very different. However, due to rapid motion, an average value is expected in experimental observations. The average value of calculated δHs of water is 2.6, similar to the resonances at 0–3 ppm in 1H NMR spectrum of ZnO-RT-vac and ZnO-100-vac. In model M2, the average values of δHs for water molecules are in a range of 2.2–3.2 (Fig. 1c), which also agree with the frequency of the peaks at 0–3 ppm in ZnO-RT-vac and ZnO-100-vac. Therefore, the signals at 0–3 ppm (centered at 1.5 ppm) can be ascribed to surface-adsorbed water. Notably, a high-frequency peak centered at 8.4 ppm emerges in 1H NMR spectrum of ZnO nanorods after being heated at 100–250 °C under vacuum, with the strongest signal observed at 200 °C (ZnO-200-vac) (Fig. 1a and Supplementary Fig. S7). This peak disappears in ZnO-300-vac, suggesting that the corresponding species is dependent on the temperature. Given the strong resonance at 8.4 ppm observed after vacuum treatment at 200 °C, the following investigations of this peak were mainly carried out using ZnO-200-vac samples. After exposing ZnO-200-vac to water vapor for 3 h and 3 days (Supplementary Fig. S8), only a slight decrease in intensity for the 8.4 ppm peak is observed, suggesting that the hydrogen species responsible for this signal are stable at ambient temperature. Supplementary Fig. S9 shows that hydrogen atoms contributing to this high-frequency peak can be exchanged by D2, indicating that this peak arises from hydrogen species close to the ZnO surface. A peak at 8.4 ppm has been observed in our previous work in H2 activation on ZnO nanorods27, which originates from homolytic H2 dissociation at an oxygen vacancy, leading to the formation of a bridging Zn-H-Zn hydride species. Therefore, the same hydride structure is expected in this situation. For this purpose, 1H-17O TRAPDOR NMR experiments for ZnO-200-vac were performed (Supplementary Fig. S10). The intensity of the peak at 8.4 ppm remains the same in the double resonance experiment, indicating that this hydrogen species is far away from O ions, thus the 1H resonance can be assigned to H bound to Zn ions and/or trapped in defect sites such as O vacancy. Considering the fact that the peak at 8.4 ppm in spectrum of ZnO-200-vac is the most intense among the samples treated at different temperatures, 1H NMR experiments for ZnO-300-vac after being heated at 200 °C in a sealed glass tube under near-vacuum conditions (~50 Pa) ((ZnO-300-vac)−200, see experimental section for details) were carried out to further explore the nature of this peak. The deceased intensity of the peak at 0.9 ppm due to surface OH is observed along with the increase of the resonance at 8.4 ppm (Fig. 2a). On the whole, Table S1 shows that the increase of the high-frequency signal (8.4 ppm) in NMR spectrum during thermal treatment for ZnO-300-vac is comparable to the decrease of the signal at 0.9 ppm, implying that the peak at 8.4 ppm may arise from the conversion of surface OH sites during thermal treatment at 200 °C. At the same time, the peak attributed to oxygen vacancies (g = 2.00) becomes weaker in (ZnO-300-vac)-200 than in ZnO-300-vac, as observed in the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra (Fig. 2b). Therefore, the high-frequency peak at 8.4 ppm can be ascribed to Zn-H-Zn formed by the migration of surface hydroxyl groups to oxygen vacancies, which is further supported by DFT calculations of chemical shifts (Fig. 2c and Supplementary Fig. S11). In addition, the peak at 8.4 ppm observed in (ZnO-300-vac)−200 in Fig. 2a is relatively weak, which may be relevant to the distributions of surface hydroxyl and oxygen vacancy on the ZnO surface. Since the concentration of oxygen vacancy is expected to be much lower than surface hydroxyls, most hydroxyls are far away from oxygen vacancy, and only the hydroxyl close to oxygen vacancy can be transformed to Zn-H-Zn successfully.Fig. 2Characterization and calculation for the conversion of surface OH to nearby O vacancy.a 1H NMR spectra of ZnO-300-vac and the ZnO-300-vac sample after being heated at 200 °C in a sealed glass tube under near-vacuum conditions (~50 Pa) (denoted as (ZnO-300-vac)−200) for 3 h. The 1H NMR spectrum of (ZnO-300-vac)-100 is also shown in Supplementary Fig. S12, together with those of ZnO-300-vac and (ZnO-300-vac)-200, in which a weaker resonance at 8.4 ppm is observed due to the lower extent of hydrogen migration at 100 °C compared to 200 °C. Note that the ZnO-300-vac was used to exclude the effects of water desorption on the origin of the resonance at 8.4 ppm during the heating process at 200 °C. Recycle delays of 5 s were used, and 64 scans were accumulated for the two spectra. b EPR spectra of ZnO-300-vac and (ZnO-300-vac)−200. The signal at g = 2.00 arises from unpaired electrons trapped in oxygen vacancies, the signal at g = 1.96 represents unpaired electrons trapped from the conductive band (CB) by shallow donors or impurities32. c The calculated models of ZnO nanorods used for the conversion of surface OH to nearby oxygen vacancy. Gray, red, and white spheres represent Zn, O, and H atoms, respectively. The dashed circles represent an oxygen vacancy. Characterization and calculation for the conversion of surface OH to nearby O vacancy. a 1H NMR spectra of ZnO-300-vac and the ZnO-300-vac sample after being heated at 200 °C in a sealed glass tube under near-vacuum conditions (~50 Pa) (denoted as (ZnO-300-vac)−200) for 3 h. The 1H NMR spectrum of (ZnO-300-vac)-100 is also shown in Supplementary Fig. S12, together with those of ZnO-300-vac and (ZnO-300-vac)-200, in which a weaker resonance at 8.4 ppm is observed due to the lower extent of hydrogen migration at 100 °C compared to 200 °C. Note that the ZnO-300-vac was used to exclude the effects of water desorption on the origin of the resonance at 8.4 ppm during the heating process at 200 °C. Recycle delays of 5 s were used, and 64 scans were accumulated for the two spectra. b EPR spectra of ZnO-300-vac and (ZnO-300-vac)−200. The signal at g = 2.00 arises from unpaired electrons trapped in oxygen vacancies, the signal at g = 1.96 represents unpaired electrons trapped from the conductive band (CB) by shallow donors or impurities32. c The calculated models of ZnO nanorods used for the conversion of surface OH to nearby oxygen vacancy. Gray, red, and white spheres represent Zn, O, and H atoms, respectively. The dashed circles represent an oxygen vacancy. 1H NMR experiments were further carried out to explore the effects of oxygen vacancy concentrations in ZnO nanorods on the resonance at 8.4 ppm. Figure 3a shows the 1H NMR spectra of ZnO nanorods after being heated at 200 °C with (ZnO-200-vac) and without (ZnO-200) exposing to vacuum in comparison to ZnO-RT-vac (detailed experimental conditions can be found in the experimental sections), in which the high-frequency signal at 8.4 ppm emerges in the NMR spectrum of ZnO-200-vac, while this peak is absent in ZnO-200. ZnO-200-vac contains more oxygen vacancies than ZnO-200, as indicated by the stronger peak at g = 2.00 in the EPR spectrum of the former (Fig. 3b), further supporting that the resonance at 8.4 ppm is associated with oxygen vacancies.Fig. 31H NMR and EPR spectra to explore the effect of oxygen vacancy of ZnO nanorods on the 1H resonance at 8.4 ppm.a 1H NMR spectra of ZnO nanorods with different heating conditions to study the effect of oxygen vacancy concentration on the spectral intensity at 8.4 ppm. b EPR spectra of ZnO-200-vac and ZnO-200 samples. c The corresponding EPR spectra of ZnO nanorods used in d before 200 °C thermal treatment under vacuum. d 1H NMR spectra of ZnO nanorods with different initial oxygen vacancy concentration, then being heated at 200 °C, to study the effect of different concentration of oxygen vacancy before 200 °C vacuum on the spectral intensity at 8.4 ppm. “(ZnO-300-vac)-SW-200-vac)” represents the sample of ZnO-300-vac after being exposed to a small amount of water, then being heated at 200 °C under vacuum. “(ZnO-300-vac)-LW−200-vac” corresponds to ZnO-300-vac after being exposed to saturated water, then being heated at 200 °C under vacuum. For each NMR spectrum, recycle delays of 5 s were used, and 64 scans were collected. 1H NMR and EPR spectra to explore the effect of oxygen vacancy of ZnO nanorods on the 1H resonance at 8.4 ppm. a 1H NMR spectra of ZnO nanorods with different heating conditions to study the effect of oxygen vacancy concentration on the spectral intensity at 8.4 ppm. b EPR spectra of ZnO-200-vac and ZnO-200 samples. c The corresponding EPR spectra of ZnO nanorods used in d before 200 °C thermal treatment under vacuum. d 1H NMR spectra of ZnO nanorods with different initial oxygen vacancy concentration, then being heated at 200 °C, to study the effect of different concentration of oxygen vacancy before 200 °C vacuum on the spectral intensity at 8.4 ppm. “(ZnO-300-vac)-SW-200-vac)” represents the sample of ZnO-300-vac after being exposed to a small amount of water, then being heated at 200 °C under vacuum. “(ZnO-300-vac)-LW−200-vac” corresponds to ZnO-300-vac after being exposed to saturated water, then being heated at 200 °C under vacuum. For each NMR spectrum, recycle delays of 5 s were used, and 64 scans were collected. In addition, the relationship between the signal intensity at 8.4 ppm and the initial concentration of oxygen vacancies in ZnO nanorods was investigated. Supplementary Fig. S13 shows that the peak ascribed to oxygen vacancies increases significantly in intensities in the EPR spectrum after thermal treatment at 300 °C under vacuum, suggesting that ZnO nanorods with a high concentration of oxygen vacancies (ZnO-300-vac) can be prepared. Subsequently, ZnO-300-vac samples were exposed to varying amounts of water, as summarized in Supplementary Fig. S14. After exposing ZnO-300-vac to a small amount of water (denoted as (ZnO-300-vac)-SW), the EPR data show a decrease in the concentration of oxygen vacancies (Supplementary Fig. S15). For (ZnO-300-vac)-LW sample, obtained by exposing ZnO-300-vac to saturated water vapor, the oxygen vacancy concentration decreases further and becomes even lower than ZnO-RT-vac, as shown in the EPR data. The samples were heated at 200 °C under vacuum to generate bridging Zn-H-Zn species. With increasing initial oxygen vacancy concentration ((ZnO-300-vac)-LW