An approach to the QHE in 3D electron systems Authors: M A Hidalgo Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractWe present a theoretical framework for describing the integer quantum Hall effect (IQHE) in three-dimensional (3D) electron systems. This work extends our previous single-electron approach, originally applied to two-dimensional (2D) systems such as quantum wells and graphene. Starting from the graphene model—where the unconventional Hall plateau sequence arises from Landau quantization—we generalize the formulation to 3D semimetals with low carrier density and high mobility. Using the Poisson summation method, we derive the density of states in a magnetic field, incorporating Gaussian Landau-level broadening, spin splitting, and thermal damping. The model captures both Shubnikov–de Haas oscillations and quantized Hall conductivities. The resulting Hall conductivity shows quantized values proportional to , consistent with experimental reports of 3D quantum Hall states. These results offer a unified description of quantum magnetotransport across dimensions and identify key parameters governing the IQHE in 3D semimetals.Subject terms: Materials science, Nanoscience and technology, Physics Introduction The integer quantum Hall effect (IQHE), discovered in 1980 by von Klitzing1, marked a milestone in condensed matter physics. The quantization of the Hall conductivity at low temperatures and strong magnetic fields, expressed in integer multiples of , was found to be remarkably robust against impurities and disorder. At the same magnetic field intervals where Hall plateaux appear, minima in the diagonal conductivity occur, corresponding to Shubnikov–de Haas (SdH) oscillations. The observation of the fractional QHE followed shortly thereafter2. The present work introduces the extension of our single-particle framework from 2D systems to genuinely three-dimensional semimetals. Unlike the 2D case–where quantized transport may be understood in terms of topological band invariants3,4 or through semiclassical Landau quantization–3D systems require the explicit incorporation of anisotropic Fermi surfaces, longitudinal dispersion, and material-dependent corrections to the cyclotron frequency. The key novel result of this work is that the proposed 3D extension naturally reproduces the quantization scale predicted for 3D systems and validated experimentally in several semimetals, including , , and 5–10. This establishes the proposed model as a physically grounded and generalizable theoretical framework for describing quantized Hall states in 3D electron systems. The IQHE can be observed in many two-dimensional electron systems (2DESs), including quantum wells (QWs) and MOSFETs. Decades later, both IQHE and FQHE were also observed in graphene11–13. In conventional QWs, plateaux appear at (or 2n if spin degeneracy is present), whereas graphene exhibits the unconventional sequence , i.e. 12–17. Positive Hall conductance corresponds to hole carriers and negative to electrons. From a theoretical perspective, the IQHE is considered a manifestation of electron localization in the quantum limit. A major conceptual advance came with the topological interpretation by Thouless et al.3, showing that the Hall conductance in a 2D periodic system is a topological invariant (Chern number). By contrast, the FQHE is associated with strong electron–electron correlations, as shown by Laughlin’s theory18. Thus, while the IQHE and FQHE remain deeply connected, they are described within different theoretical frameworks: electron localization and topological invariants in the first case, correlated quantum liquids in the second. Nonetheless, an alternative single-particle approach unifying IQHE and FQHE has been proposed by Hidalgo19. Traditionally, the QHE has been viewed as a purely 2D phenomenon. However, whether intrinsically 3D systems can host quantized Hall responses has been debated for decades. Halperin20 first suggested that quantized Hall conductance in 3D could arise from field-induced instabilities (e.g., charge-density waves). Later theoretical work proposed multiple routes to a 3D QHE, including stacked 2D layers, Fermi-surface instabilities, and topological mechanisms involving surface Fermi arcs in Weyl/Dirac semimetals21. Electron–phonon coupling was also shown to induce the required instability22. Clear experimental evidence for a 3D QHE appeared only recently in 5,6. Quantized Hall plateaux and vanishing longitudinal resistivity were observed, with values depending on the Fermi wavelength along the field direction. Similar behavior has been reported in nanostructures, attributed to Weyl-orbit physics7,8. Other topological semimetals exhibit related quantized transport signatures. A common characteristic of all 3D systems showing QHE signatures is their semimetallic nature: low carrier density, high mobility, and small Fermi surfaces enable the extreme quantum limit under experimentally accessible fields. The purpose of the present work is to extend our previous model for 2DESs and graphene19,23 to 3D electron systems. Section 2 reviews the graphene model; Section 3 develops the 3D formulation; Section 4 presents the conclusions. Quantum Hall and Shubnikov–de Haas effects in graphene Graphene is a single layer of carbon atoms arranged in a honeycomb lattice, exhibiting a linear electronic dispersion near the Dirac points and a vanishing density of states at the charge neutrality point. Because of its semimetallic nature and exceptionally high mobility, graphene serves as an ideal starting point for our approach to 3D semimetals. The unconventional integer quantum Hall effect (IQHE), with plateaux at , has been experimentally observed even at room temperature11,14,15. Our model for graphene extends the single-electron framework developed originally for quantum wells, successfully reproducing both diagonal and Hall magnetoconductivities as functions of gate voltage and magnetic field19,23. The characteristic plateau sequence arises naturally from Landau quantization in this formulation. Density of states in graphene under magnetic field The six corners of the first Brillouin zone reduce to two nonequivalent Dirac points, K and . Each point hosts symmetric valence and conduction bands, which we assume to share the same effective mass . Under an applied magnetic field B, we construct the Hilbert space as a tensor product of the dynamical spaces associated with the valence and conduction bands. The resulting quantized energy spectrum resembles that of a 2D harmonic oscillator and is written as where is the cyclotron frequency. Equation (1) is used as an effective Landau quantization condition rather than a strict solution of the Dirac equation; its purpose is to reproduce the discrete structure of the Landau levels needed for quantum transport19,23. The density of states (DOS) for each Dirac point is obtained using the Poisson summation formula: where , the summation index corresponding to the harmonic, and The Gaussian Landau-level broadening factor is that accounts for the interaction of electrons with defects and impurities. For simplicity, we assume a width independent of the magnetic field. And the spin-splitting factor, the Zeeman term, is with the effective g-factor, and the free electron mass. The total DOS is the sum of the contributions from K and : The corresponding carrier density for each Dirac point is with is the Fermi energy and the Fermi–Dirac distribution function. The quantity denotes the electron density at zero magnetic field (or zero gate voltage) for each Dirac point, while represents the oscillatory variation in the electron density arising from the quantized density of states. This oscillatory part includes a thermal damping factor where k is the Boltzmann constant and T the temperature. Therefore, from Eq. (7), the total carrier density in graphene can be written as On the other hand, at low temperatures the electron population near the Fermi level may be approximated by the step function , where is the Heaviside function and the Fermi energy. At low temperature, electrons near the Fermi level satisfy yielding the correct oscillatory modulation needed for SdH and QHE simulation, and where is given by Eq. (2), evaluated at the Fermi level, with Additional details can be found in Hidalgo’s treatments of graphene and QWs19,23. Model for magnetoconductivities in graphene The diagonal conductivity for each Dirac point follows the semiclassical expression where is the electron relaxation time, and with The Hall conductivity is which at high magnetic field reduces to The total conductivities are the sums of K and contributions: The resistivities then follow from the tensor inversion: Figures 1 and 2 show simulated graphene magnetotransport under typical conditions, reproducing the expected Hall plateaux and SdH oscillations. The values of the physical parameters used in the simulations are detailed in the captions of each figure. Figure 1 shows the simulations as a function of gate voltage, including the Hall magnetoconductivity (panel a) and both magnetoresistivities: the diagonal (Shubnikov–de Haas) and the Hall components. Figure 2 presents the same quantities as in Fig. 1, but now as a function of the applied magnetic field. Hall magnetoconductivity (a) and longitudinal and Hall magnetoresistivities (b) of monolayer graphene as functions of the gate voltage . Simulations were performed at and using , , a Gaussian Landau-level broadening , and a relaxation time . Integers in panel (a) indicate the Hall plateaux. Hall magnetoconductivity (a) and longitudinal magnetoresistivity (b) of monolayer graphene as functions of the magnetic field. Parameters are the same as in Fig. 1, except for a carrier density . Integers in panel (a) denote the Hall plateaux. Quantum Hall and Shubnikov–de Haas effects in 3D electron systems Clear experimental signatures of the three-dimensional quantum Hall effect have been reported in a variety of semimetallic systems. These include bulk materials such as and , as well as thin-film or microstructured Dirac and Weyl semimetals like . Although these systems differ in composition and electronic structure, they share two essential properties—low carrier density and high mobility—which enable them to reach the extreme quantum limit under experimentally accessible magnetic fields. In this regime, the characteristic quantized Hall response and accompanying magneto-oscillations become observable. Density of states of a 3D electron system under magnetic field To extend our graphene-based formulation to 3D systems, we first consider the zero-field density of states (DOS) for a 3D electron gas: where is the effective mass. Under a magnetic field, we assume that the transverse motion of electrons is quantized by an effective 2D harmonic-oscillator spectrum, analogous to the graphene case. Thus, the DOS under magnetic field becomes with The Gaussian Landau-level broadening is identical to the 2D case: and the Zeeman factor is The electron density is obtained as where is the zero-field carrier density. Additionally, a thermal damping factor is included. At low temperature, the Fermi-level DOS is approximated as and the Fermi energy follows the standard 3D relation Two parameters require special attention in 3D semimetals: Effective g-factor: Many 3D semimetals exhibit extremely large values (up to ), as reported in and 24–26. Effective g-factor: Many 3D semimetals exhibit extremely large values (up to ), as reported in and 24–26. Cyclotron frequency correction: Due to strong band anisotropy in 3D semimetals, we introduce a phenomenological correction 28 where is chosen to match experimental plateau positions (e.g., for ). Cyclotron frequency correction: Due to strong band anisotropy in 3D semimetals, we introduce a phenomenological correction 28 where is chosen to match experimental plateau positions (e.g., for ). To model realistic materials, we adopt typical effective masses in the range , consistent with experimental values27–29. Model for the magnetoconductivity tensor in 3D The semiclassical diagonal conductivity in 3D follows: with Similarly, the Hall conductivity is which in the high-field limit simplifies to A key quantity for 3D QHE is the fundamental Hall plateau predicted by Halperin20: where the Fermi wavelength along the field direction is The full resistivity tensor is obtained by inversion: Figures 3, 4 and 5 illustrate the simulated Hall conductivity and resistivity for representative 3D semimetals. The model reproduces the sequence of Hall plateaux and the corresponding Shubnikov–de Haas oscillations, matching experimental observations in 5,6, 7,8, and 9. Hall magnetoconductivity (a) and longitudinal and Hall magnetoresistivities (b) for a 3D semimetal representative of ZrTe. Simulations use , , , , a cyclotron-frequency correction , a Landau-level broadening , and a relaxation time . Integers in panel (a) indicate the Hall plateaux; panel (b) shows the Shubnikov–de Haas oscillations. Hall magnetoconductivity (a) and magnetoresistivities (b) for a semimetal with parameters corresponding to CdAs. Simulations use , , , , a cyclotron-frequency correction , a Landau-level broadening , and a relaxation time . Integers in panel (a) indicate the Hall plateaux; panel (b) displays the Shubnikov–de Haas oscillations. Hall magnetoconductivity (a) and longitudinal and Hall magnetoresistivities (b) for a 3D semimetal with parameters characteristic of HfTe. Simulations use , , , , a cyclotron-frequency correction , a Gaussian broadening , and a relaxation time . Integers in panel (a) indicate the Hall plateaux; panel (b) shows the Shubnikov–de Haas oscillations. Discussion and conclusion We have presented a unified theoretical framework for describing the integer quantum Hall effect (IQHE) in both two-dimensional and three-dimensional electron systems. The model builds on a single-electron Landau quantization scheme that successfully reproduces the magnetotransport properties of quantum wells, graphene, and 3D semimetals. In 2D systems such as monolayer graphene, the unconventional Hall plateau sequence emerges naturally from the structure of the density of states and the single-particle quantization conditions19,23. The model captures both the Hall and diagonal magnetoconductivities as functions of magnetic field and gate voltage, in agreement with experimental observations11,14,15. A major contribution of this work is the extension of the 2D framework to fully three-dimensional semimetals. While the 2D formalism is summarized briefly for completeness, the theoretical advances and validation presented here pertain specifically to the 3D case. The mechanism underlying the 3D quantization is universal: Landau-level discretization of the transverse motion, combined with a free longitudinal dispersion along the magnetic-field direction, produces the characteristic 3D quantization scale . This behaviour, originally anticipated in theoretical analyses of quantized transport in periodic systems4, has been observed experimentally in , , and 5–10. By demonstrating quantitative agreement with these measurements using material-specific parameters, the present model shows that the proposed approach constitutes a general and versatile framework for describing 3D quantum Hall states in low-density, high-mobility semimetals. The present approach, based solely on single-particle physics, demonstrates that many features of both 2D and 3D quantum Hall phenomena can be described without invoking strong interaction effects. In fact, our simulations confirm this scaling and show that the plateau positions follow the expected quantization when the system enters the extreme quantum limit. This complements traditional topological and many-body perspectives, providing an alternative framework for understanding quantized magnetotransport in semimetals. Future work should investigate the microscopic origin of the cyclotron correction factor and its connection with the anisotropic effective mass tensor. Overall, the model provides a unified description of quantum Hall physics across dimensions. It agrees with experimental observations in both 2D and 3D systems and may offer a useful tool for exploring quantum magnetotransport in novel semimetals. Furthermore, following our thermodynamic analysis of 2D systems30, the framework opens avenues for studying thermodynamic and transport properties in 3D quantum Hall regimes. Author contributions I am the unique author. All the work depicted in this manuscript has been developed by me. Data availability All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article and its supplementary information files. Declarations Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article and its supplementary information files.