Analog photography enhances identity, well-being, and social connection, in Southeastern China Authors: Yiyuchen Zhu Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractThe resurgence of analog photography within our hyper-digitized landscape presents a unique and compelling intersection of technology, culture, and human psychology. This study offers an in-depth investigation into the multifaceted role of analog photography in shaping identity formation, fostering psychological well-being, and nurturing social capital development within the specific socio-cultural milieu of Southeastern China. Employing a concurrent mixed-methods design with a robust sample of 600 participants (N=600), we integrated quantitative surveys assessing psychological constructs and engagement levels with qualitative interviews exploring lived experiences. We applied advanced statistical techniques, including Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), to test a theoretically-grounded model. This model hypothesized that engagement in analog photography predicts enhanced well-being (manifested as higher self-esteem and lower perceived stress) through the crucial mediating roles of psychologically potent nostalgia and cultivated mindfulness. Furthermore, Latent Class Analysis (LCA) was utilized to move beyond a monolithic view and identify distinct, meaningful subgroups of analog photographers based on their underlying motivations and engagement patterns. SEM results indicated a strong model fit with the data, confirming the significant mediating pathways through both nostalgia and mindfulness, suggesting these psychological processes are key to understanding the benefits derived from analog practice. LCA successfully identified four distinct and interpretable classes: The tradition-focused ‘Nostalgic Purists,’ the aesthetically driven ‘Aesthetic Explorers’, the community-oriented ‘Social Connectors,’ and the process-centered ‘Mindful Contemplatives’. These quantitative findings were substantially enriched and contextualized by our qualitative data. Interviews revealed intricate details of how the material (film, cameras, prints), temporal (slowness, anticipation), and social (clubs, sharing) dimensions of analog practice are woven into personal self-narratives, facilitate emotional regulation strategies, and solidify enduring community bonds. Collectively, these findings provide a nuanced, multi-layered understanding of how seemingly ‘retro’ or traditional, tangible practices can serve vital, contemporary psychological and social functions, particularly in a rapidly digitizing, non-Western context like Southeastern China. This research extends existing theories of identity (Erikson, 1970; McAdams in Rev. Gen. Psychol. 5(2): 100-122, 2001), psychological well-being (Ryan & Deci in Am. Psychol. 55(1): 68–78, 2000)), social capital (Putnam in Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community, Touchstone Books/Simon & Schuster, 2000), and cultural memory (Assmann in Cultural memory and early civilization: Writing, remembrance, and political imagination, 1-319, 2011), offering valuable insights for both academic discourse and practical applications in mental health and cultural preservation.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1038/s41598-025-32663-x.Keywords: Psychological Flourishing, Identity Negotiation , Mnemonic Affect, Mindfulness, Social Affiliation, Cultural psychologySubject terms: Psychology, Human behaviour Introduction The analog resurgence in a digital world: More than just retro In an era defined by the instantaneous and the intangible—where digital images proliferate across screens with fleeting permanence—the global renaissance of analog photography stands as a fascinating counter-narrative1. This revival is not merely a fleeting trend or a simple exercise in ‘retro’ aesthetics,rather, it signifies a deeper engagement with material culture and potentially reflects profound psychological and sociological underpinnings. Scholars frequently interpret this phenomenon as a conscious or subconscious reaction against the perceived ephemerality, placelessness, and overwhelming immediacy characteristic of digital media2,3. There appears to be a growing yearning for tangibility, permanence, and the unique ‘aura’4that a physical photograph or negative possesses – a sense of unique existence in time and space that digital copies often lack. This desire for the ‘real’ challenges the very nature of representation in the digital age5. The very process of analog photography—the manual operation of mechanical cameras, the deliberate selection and handling of film, the anticipation during development, and the eventual creation of a physical print—offers a rich, multi-sensory experience. This tactile engagement starkly contrasts with the often-disembodied nature of screen-based interactions, potentially fostering a renewed sense of embodiment, physical presence, and connection to the material world. This involvement with the physical demands a different kind of attention, a slowing down that runs counter to the digital flow. Within the dynamic context of Southeastern China, a region navigating a complex and often-turbulent negotiation between its deeply rooted cultural traditions and the relentless pace of modernization and digitalization, analog photography acquires a particularly potent significance. Here, it functions not merely as an artistic choice but also as a vehicle for cultural preservation, a platform for intergenerational dialogue, and a crucial site for individuals to construct and negotiate their modern identities in a landscape of flux6. It becomes a practice where personal history and collective heritage can be physically inscribed and re-examined. Psychological dimensions: Unpacking nostalgia, mindfulness, identity, and flow The allure of analog photography resonates powerfully with fundamental human psychological needs and processes. Nostalgia, frequently evoked by the distinct aesthetics (grain, colour palettes) and the ritualistic processes of film photography, serves as a primary motivator for many practitioners7. This is not merely a passive, bittersweet longing,psychological research increasingly demonstrates that nostalgia serves adaptive functions. It can act as a psychological resource, bolstering social connectedness, enhancing self-continuity by linking past and present selves, providing a sense of existential meaning, and even increasing positive affect8,9. The act of using older cameras or recreating past aesthetics can be a direct pathway to these psychologically beneficial nostalgic states. Furthermore, the inherently deliberate, often slow, and methodical nature of analog photography can be a potent catalyst for inducing states of mindfulness—a non-judgmental, present-moment awareness10. The constraints of the medium (limited exposures, delayed gratification) necessitate a more considered approach to composition and a heightened attention to the environment and the photographic process itself. This ‘slow photography’ movement can be viewed as an intentional counter-practice to the pervasive ‘culture of speed’ and digital fatigue, offering a respite from information overload and constant connectivity11. It aligns with broader ‘slow living’ concepts that question the relentless pace of modern life, advocating for deeper engagement and exploring sustainable community models12. Such mindful engagement may contribute to attention restoration – the recovery of directed attention fatigued by digital overload13 – and has been robustly linked to enhanced subjective well-being and greater emotional regulation14. Closely related to mindfulness is the concept of ‘flow’ – the state of complete absorption in an activity, characterized by energized focus, full involvement, and enjoyment in the process15. The challenges (mastering exposure, developing film) and skills involved in analog photography can readily facilitate these intrinsically rewarding flow states, which are crucial for psychological growth and a sense of competence. Above all, engaging in meaningful creative practices like photography is deeply intertwined with identity work – the ongoing process of constructing, negotiating, and expressing one’s sense of self16, (Erikson, 1970). Analog photography provides a rich medium for individuals to craft and communicate their personal narratives17. Through the choices they make (subject matter, style) and the images they create, individuals can explore various self-concepts18, process life experiences, and solidify a coherent sense of identity, a task particularly salient during periods of transition such as emerging adulthood19. The creation of tangible artifacts – prints, negatives, albums – transforms fleeting moments into ‘memory objects’20. These objects serve as physical anchors for personal and collective history, facilitating self-reflection, storytelling, and the intergenerational transmission of memories21. They become part of the ‘material self’, extensions of one’s identity embedded in physical form22. Social and cultural dimensions: Weaving community and preserving heritage The impact of analog photography extends significantly beyond the individual psyche. It frequently acts as a catalyst for building social capital – the networks, norms, and trust that facilitate coordination and cooperation for mutual benefit23. Photography clubs, shared darkrooms, university societies, online forums (like specific groups on Douban or WeChat), and print-swapping events create vital ‘third places’24. These spaces, distinct from home and work, foster social interaction, shared learning, and the development of strong community bonds based on a common passion, a form of cultural capital25. This fulfills the fundamental human need for relatedness, a cornerstone of well-being as outlined by Self-Determination Theory26. Crucially, the practice often becomes a conduit for intergenerational knowledge transfer. As younger enthusiasts seek out the expertise of older, more experienced photographers, valuable dialogue and mentorship relationships are formed. This process not only preserves technical skills but also connects participants with local history and cultural heritage, reinforcing collective memory and shared identities27,28. In an era marked by concerns about cultural homogenization due to globalization and the dominance of digital platforms, such acts of preservation and intergenerational connection can be seen as subtle yet significant forms of cultural resistance and continuity29. It fosters a sense of rootedness and belonging within a specific cultural lineage. While previous studies have often explored the analog revival from a cultural or phenomenological perspective, and psychological research has examined constructs like nostalgia and mindfulness in isolation, a significant knowledge gap exists at their intersection. There is a scarcity of research that empirically tests the precise psychological pathways linking the practice of analog photography to well-being outcomes. Furthermore, few studies have adopted a mixed-methods approach to integrate robust quantitative modeling with deep qualitative exploration in this domain. The existing literature also tends to focus on Western contexts, leaving the unique socio-cultural dynamics of a region like Southeastern China—where tradition and modernity are in intense dialogue—underexplored. This study aims to fill these gaps. Its primary novelty lies in three areas: (1) it proposes and tests a specific mediational model using SEM, moving beyond correlation to explain how analog photography enhances well-being; (2) it employs Latent Class Analysis to reveal the heterogeneity within the analog community, offering a more nuanced view than prior monolithic treatments; and (3) it grounds this empirical investigation in the rich, under-examined context of Southeastern China, integrating qualitative insights to explain the cultural specificity of these psychological and social processes. Research aim and hypotheses This study aims to quantitatively model and qualitatively explore analog photography’s impacts in Southeastern China. We test the following hypotheses: H1: Higher engagement in analog photography will positively predict psychological well-being (higher self-esteem, lower stress). H1: Higher engagement in analog photography will positively predict psychological well-being (higher self-esteem, lower stress). H2: Nostalgia mediates the relationship between analog photography engagement and well-being. H2: Nostalgia mediates the relationship between analog photography engagement and well-being. H3: Mindfulness mediates the relationship between analog photography engagement and well-being. H3: Mindfulness mediates the relationship between analog photography engagement and well-being. H4: Analog photography engagement positively predicts community belonging. H4: Analog photography engagement positively predicts community belonging. H5: Distinct profiles (latent classes) of analog photographers exist, differing in motivations and outcomes. H5: Distinct profiles (latent classes) of analog photographers exist, differing in motivations and outcomes. Methods Participants and recruitment strategy A total of 600 participants (N=600), aged between 18 and 50 years, were recruited from various urban centers (e.g., Fuzhou, Xiamen, Hangzhou) and surrounding rural areas in Southeastern China (primarily Fujian and Zhejiang provinces). This region was selected due to its unique blend of rapid economic development and strong traditional cultural roots. We employed a multi-pronged recruitment strategy to capture a diverse sample: Photography Clubs & Societies: Collaborated with leaders of local camera clubs and university photography groups to reach established enthusiasts. Photography Clubs & Societies: Collaborated with leaders of local camera clubs and university photography groups to reach established enthusiasts. Online Forums: Posted recruitment notices on popular Chinese social media platforms and forums known for analog photography discussions (e.g., Douban groups, specific WeChat public accounts, Weibo topics). Online Forums: Posted recruitment notices on popular Chinese social media platforms and forums known for analog photography discussions (e.g., Douban groups, specific WeChat public accounts, Weibo topics). Workshops & Exhibitions: Set up recruitment stands and distributed flyers at local photography workshops, gallery openings, and camera fairs. Workshops & Exhibitions: Set up recruitment stands and distributed flyers at local photography workshops, gallery openings, and camera fairs. Snowball Sampling: Encouraged initial participants to refer other eligible individuals within their networks. Snowball Sampling: Encouraged initial participants to refer other eligible individuals within their networks. A stratified sampling approach was initially aimed for, but practical constraints led to a convenience sample with efforts to ensure breadth. The resulting 70:30 male-to-female ratio, while imbalanced, accurately reflects the observed demographics within many formal photography clubs in the region. The sample composition (Table 1) provides a good cross-section of engagement levels, from professionals deeply embedded in the field to hobbyists exploring its creative potential. Table 1Demographic characteristics of participants (N=600).VariableFrequencyPercentageGenderMale42070%Female18030%Age group 18–3025041.7% 31–4022036.7% 41–5013021.6%OccupationProfessional photographer20033.3%Hobbyist photographer25041.7%Other creative work8013.3%Other7011.7% Demographic characteristics of participants (N=600). Research design: A concurrent mixed-methods approach To achieve a holistic understanding of the phenomenon, we adopted a concurrent mixed-methods design30. This approach allows for the simultaneous collection and analysis of quantitative (QUAN) and qualitative (QUAL) data. The rationale is that quantitative data can identify broad patterns, relationships, and typologies across a large sample, while qualitative data can provide rich, contextualized insights into the subjective experiences, meanings, and nuances underlying those patterns. The QUAN and QUAL strands were conducted in parallel and then integrated during the interpretation phase, allowing for both confirmation (triangulation) and expansion of findings. Data collection tools: Measuring and exploring Survey instrument A comprehensive, bilingual (Mandarin Chinese and English, back-translated for accuracy) questionnaire was developed, comprising 75 items. It was administered both online (via Wenjuanxing/SurveyStar) and in-person (for club meetings/events). It included established and custom scales: oAnalog Photography Engagement Scale: A custom-developed 10-item scale assessing behavioral frequency, financial investment, and time involvement. Analog Photography Engagement Scale: A custom-developed 10-item scale assessing behavioral frequency, financial investment, and time involvement. oSouthampton Nostalgia Scale:8 – A well-validated 7-item scale. Southampton Nostalgia Scale:8 – A well-validated 7-item scale. oMindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS):10 – A 15-item scale. Mindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS):10 – A 15-item scale. oRosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSES):31 – A 10-item scale. Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSES):31 – A 10-item scale. oPerceived Stress Scale (PSS):32 – A 10-item scale. Perceived Stress Scale (PSS):32 – A 10-item scale. oCommunity Cohesion Scale (Adapted): An 8-item scale measuring belonging and connection. Community Cohesion Scale (Adapted): An 8-item scale measuring belonging and connection. oMotivational Items: Custom items assessing motivations. Motivational Items: Custom items assessing motivations. oDemographic questions. Demographic questions. Interview guide A semi-structured interview guide was developed to facilitate in-depth conversations with a purposively selected subsample (n=30). Selection aimed for maximum variation. Interviews lasted 45–90 minutes, were audio-recorded (with consent), and conducted in Mandarin Chinese. Data analysis: Integrating QUAN and QUAL Quantitative analysis: oPreprocessing: Data were screened for outliers and missing values.oDescriptive Statistics: Frequencies, means, and standard deviations were calculated using SPSS v28.oScale Validation: Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) was conducted in AMOS v28.oStructural Equation Modeling (SEM): We tested the hypothesized mediation model using AMOS v28, using Maximum Likelihood estimation and standard fit indices33,34. Bootstrapping (5000 samples) tested indirect effects.oLatent Class Analysis (LCA): Performed using Mplus v8.6 to identify subgroups, using BIC, aBIC, LMR-LRT, and entropy35. Quantitative analysis: oPreprocessing: Data were screened for outliers and missing values.oDescriptive Statistics: Frequencies, means, and standard deviations were calculated using SPSS v28.oScale Validation: Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) was conducted in AMOS v28.oStructural Equation Modeling (SEM): We tested the hypothesized mediation model using AMOS v28, using Maximum Likelihood estimation and standard fit indices33,34. Bootstrapping (5000 samples) tested indirect effects.oLatent Class Analysis (LCA): Performed using Mplus v8.6 to identify subgroups, using BIC, aBIC, LMR-LRT, and entropy35. oPreprocessing: Data were screened for outliers and missing values. Preprocessing: Data were screened for outliers and missing values. oDescriptive Statistics: Frequencies, means, and standard deviations were calculated using SPSS v28. Descriptive Statistics: Frequencies, means, and standard deviations were calculated using SPSS v28. oScale Validation: Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) was conducted in AMOS v28. Scale Validation: Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) was conducted in AMOS v28. oStructural Equation Modeling (SEM): We tested the hypothesized mediation model using AMOS v28, using Maximum Likelihood estimation and standard fit indices33,34. Bootstrapping (5000 samples) tested indirect effects. Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): We tested the hypothesized mediation model using AMOS v28, using Maximum Likelihood estimation and standard fit indices33,34. Bootstrapping (5000 samples) tested indirect effects. oLatent Class Analysis (LCA): Performed using Mplus v8.6 to identify subgroups, using BIC, aBIC, LMR-LRT, and entropy35. Latent Class Analysis (LCA): Performed using Mplus v8.6 to identify subgroups, using BIC, aBIC, LMR-LRT, and entropy35. Qualitative analysis: oTranscription & Translation: Interviews were transcribed and translated.oThematic Analysis: We employed the six-phase approach36using NVivo 12. Inter-coder reliability was established. Qualitative analysis: oTranscription & Translation: Interviews were transcribed and translated.oThematic Analysis: We employed the six-phase approach36using NVivo 12. Inter-coder reliability was established. oTranscription & Translation: Interviews were transcribed and translated. Transcription & Translation: Interviews were transcribed and translated. oThematic Analysis: We employed the six-phase approach36using NVivo 12. Inter-coder reliability was established. Thematic Analysis: We employed the six-phase approach36using NVivo 12. Inter-coder reliability was established. Integration: Integration: In the final discussion section, we employed a narrative integration approach, weaving together the QUAN and QUAL findings. In the final discussion section, we employed a narrative integration approach, weaving together the QUAN and QUAL findings. Ethics statement This study employed a fully anonymous online survey to investigate identity formation through analog photography in Southeastern China. No personally identifiable information was collected, and all responses were recorded without linking to any specific individual. The study posed no risk to participants and did not involve any intervention or manipulation. As this study solely involved anonymous survey data collection without any personally identifiable information, ethical approval was not required. According to China’s “Regulations on Human-Related Biomedical Research” (2023), research based on anonymized survey data that does not include sensitive personal information or medical interventions is explicitly exempt from formal ethics review. This study adhered to all relevant national regulations and international ethical standards, including the Declaration of Helsinki. All participants voluntarily provided informed consent before participating in the survey. Results Quantitative findings: Patterns and relationships Descriptive statistics (Table 2) revealed moderate-to-high levels of positive constructs and low-to-moderate stress. All measurement scales demonstrated good to excellent internal consistency (alpha > 0.85). Table 2Summary of key variables (N=600).VariableMeanSDCronbach’s alphaAnalog engagement3.550.950.89Nostalgia scale4.280.720.90MAAS (Mindfulness)3.650.800.91Community belonging3.920.780.87Self-esteem (RSES)4.010.760.86Stress levels (PSS)2.450.840.88 Summary of key variables (N=600). Structural equation model (SEM): Testing the mediational pathways Prior to testing the structural model, the measurement model was assessed using Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA). The model demonstrated a strong fit to the data, meeting established criteria (χ2= 285.4, df=145, p<.001; CFI=.97; TLI=.96; RMSEA=.045; SRMR=.05). Furthermore, as detailed in Table A1, the reliability and convergent validity of the latent constructs were confirmed. All constructs exceeded the required thresholds, with Composite Reliability (CR) values greater than 0.6 and Average Variance Extracted (AVE) values greater than 0.5, providing a solid foundation for interpreting the path analysis results. Bootstrapping confirmed significant indirect effects for Self-Esteem (via Nostalgia: β = 0.154; via Mindfulness: β = 0.168) and Stress (via Nostalgia: β = −0.083; via Mindfulness: β = −0.120). The non-significant direct paths confirmed full mediation (Table 3). Table 3Standardized path coefficients for the SEM model.PathCoefficient (β)SEp-valueEngagement -> Nostalgia0.550.04.001Engagement -> Mindfulness0.480.05.001Engagement -> Community0.400.04.001Nostalgia -> Self-esteem0.280.06.005Mindfulness -> Self-esteem0.350.05.001Nostalgia -> Stress (Inv)0.150.07.045Mindfulness -> Stress (Inv)0.250.06.002Engagement -> Self-esteem0.120.08.134 (ns)Engagement -> Stress (Inv)0.080.09.210 (ns)Note: Stress (Inv) indicates stress levels are inversely related; higher values mean lower stress. Standardized path coefficients for the SEM model. Note: Stress (Inv) indicates stress levels are inversely related; higher values mean lower stress. Latent class analysis (LCA): Identifying photographer profiles (Table 4) Table 4Latent class profile summary.VariableClass 1 (Purists)Class 2 (Explorers)Class 3 (Connectors)Class 4 (Contemplatives)Nostalgia4.83.94.14.3Mindfulness3.23.53.44.5Community3.53.84.63.7Stress (Low)2.62.32.52.8Motivation: Nostalgic HighModModMod-High Aesthetic ModHighModMod Social LowModHighLow Process HighModLowHigh Latent class profile summary. LCA identified a four-class solution as optimal (Entropy = 0.88): Nostalgic Purists (20%): Older, high nostalgia, value tradition/culture, focus on darkroom. Nostalgic Purists (20%): Older, high nostalgia, value tradition/culture, focus on darkroom. Aesthetic Explorers (35%): Younger, high engagement, seek unique visuals, experimental. Aesthetic Explorers (35%): Younger, high engagement, seek unique visuals, experimental. Social Connectors (25%): High community scores, value sharing and interaction. Social Connectors (25%): High community scores, value sharing and interaction. Mindful Contemplatives (20%): High mindfulness, lowest stress, value process/reflection. Mindful Contemplatives (20%): High mindfulness, lowest stress, value process/reflection. Qualitative insights: Voices from the community Thematic analysis deepened these findings, revealing the lived experiences behind the profiles: The ‘Magic’ and ‘Flow’ of Process: "The anticipation... it’s an indescribable feeling when the image finally appears in the developer," shared a ‘Nostalgic Purist’. An ‘Aesthetic Explorer’ added, "You have to be totally focused... hours just vanish. It’s pure flow"37. This highlights the intrinsic rewards and deep engagement. The ‘Magic’ and ‘Flow’ of Process: "The anticipation... it’s an indescribable feeling when the image finally appears in the developer," shared a ‘Nostalgic Purist’. An ‘Aesthetic Explorer’ added, "You have to be totally focused... hours just vanish. It’s pure flow"37. This highlights the intrinsic rewards and deep engagement. Embodied connection, slowness, and grounding: "Holding a solid metal camera, feeling its weight, turning the dials – it connects you to reality," explained a ‘Mindful Contemplative’. "Digital is too fast. Film makes you slow down, breathe, and really look. It’s my way to fight the modern rush"12. This emphasizes the sensory and temporal aspects as psychological anchors. Embodied connection, slowness, and grounding: "Holding a solid metal camera, feeling its weight, turning the dials – it connects you to reality," explained a ‘Mindful Contemplative’. "Digital is too fast. Film makes you slow down, breathe, and really look. It’s my way to fight the modern rush"12. This emphasizes the sensory and temporal aspects as psychological anchors. Narrating self through tangible objects: "These prints aren’t just pictures; they are chapters of my life," said a participant17. "They prove I was here, I felt this. They are part of my identity"22,21. This theme underscores how physical artifacts stabilize self-narratives. Narrating self through tangible objects: "These prints aren’t just pictures; they are chapters of my life," said a participant17. "They prove I was here, I felt this. They are part of my identity"22,21. This theme underscores how physical artifacts stabilize self-narratives. Building ‘Real’ communities: "Online is good for quick questions, but meeting up, sharing prints, talking for hours... that’s where the real bonds are formed," noted a ‘Social Connector’. This points to the importance of shared spaces24 and practices in fostering strong social capital23. Building ‘Real’ communities: "Online is good for quick questions, but meeting up, sharing prints, talking for hours... that’s where the real bonds are formed," noted a ‘Social Connector’. This points to the importance of shared spaces24 and practices in fostering strong social capital23. Aesthetic distinction and imperfection: "I love the grain, the unpredictable colours. It feels more ‘alive’ than digital. It has a soul," expressed an ‘Aesthetic Explorer’. This embrace of imperfection challenges digital norms and values authenticity5. Aesthetic distinction and imperfection: "I love the grain, the unpredictable colours. It feels more ‘alive’ than digital. It has a soul," expressed an ‘Aesthetic Explorer’. This embrace of imperfection challenges digital norms and values authenticity5. Discussion Integrating findings: A psycho-socio-cultural tapestry This study directly addressed a critical gap in the literature by moving beyond descriptive accounts of the analog revival to empirically model its psycho-social impact within the unique context of Southeastern China. The primary contribution of this research is the elucidation of the mechanisms through which engagement in analog photography enhances well-being. Our SEM results provide robust, novel evidence that nostalgia and mindfulness fully mediate the relationship between the practice and its positive outcomes (higher self-esteem, lower stress). This finding is innovative because it suggests that the practice’s benefits are not automatic but are channeled through the cultivation of specific psychological states: A reflective connection to the past and a deep awareness of the present. Furthermore, by employing LCA, this work makes a second significant contribution by quantitatively demonstrating that the “analog community” is not a monolith but a vibrant ecosystem of distinct subgroups. Identifying the ‘Nostalgic Purists,’ ‘Aesthetic Explorers,’ ‘Social Connectors,’ and ‘Mindful Contemplatives’ provides a data-driven typology that enriches our understanding of the varied motivations driving the phenomenon. This nuanced perspective, which was then given voice through our qualitative findings, directly answers the call for a more sophisticated analysis of this contemporary practice. The integration of these two methodological approaches allows us to see not only the overarching patterns but also the lived realities that animate them, providing a holistic psycho-socio-cultural tapestry of meaning. Cultural context and the negotiation of modern chinese identity The findings are deeply embedded in the Chinese context. The emphasis on intergenerational connection speaks to enduring cultural values. Analog photography becomes a tool for ‘dialogical memory’ (Bakhtin, 1981), allowing individuals to engage in a tangible conversation with their past and cultural heritage28,27. In a society undergoing immense transformation, such practices provide crucial psychological anchoring16. It allows individuals to perform and negotiate complex ‘hybrid’ identities (Chen & Qiu, 2020). Broader implications: Mind, society, and culture These findings support arts-based interventions for mental health and highlight how niche communities build social capital. It underscores the value of ‘slow’12 and tangible practices in a digital age11, offering pathways to combat digital fatigue and foster deeper engagement. Limitations and future research avenues While this study provides valuable insights, its limitations must be acknowledged. First, the cross-sectional design prevents us from drawing causal conclusions; while our model posits that engagement fosters well-being through mindfulness and nostalgia, it is equally plausible that individuals with higher pre-existing levels of well-being are more drawn to such reflective hobbies. Second, our reliance on a convenience sample, though diverse, may over-represent highly engaged enthusiasts active in clubs and online forums, potentially limiting the generalizability of our findings to more casual practitioners. The observed 70:30 male-to-female ratio, while reflective of organized clubs, also points to the need for future research to specifically explore gender dynamics and potential barriers to entry for women. Third, the use of self-report measures for all constructs introduces the possibility of common method bias and social desirability effects, where participants might present themselves in a more positive light. Future research would benefit from a longitudinal approach to track the development of these relationships over time, helping to establish causality. Additionally, incorporating objective or behavioral measures (e.g., physiological stress indicators, analysis of photographic content) could corroborate the self-reported findings. Finally, while our LCA profiles are statistically robust, they represent snapshots; a deeper longitudinal ethnographic study following individuals from each class would provide invaluable insight into how these identities and motivations evolve over a photographer’s journey. Conclusion Analog photography thrives in Southeastern China, acting as a potent force for psychological well-being and social connection. It facilitates identity exploration, enhances well-being via nostalgia and mindfulness, and builds communities. This study reveals how its slow, tangible nature offers a meaningful way to navigate modern complexities, craft identities, and connect with past and present. In our digital world, the analog’s appeal underscores fundamental human needs for connection, meaning, and tangibility, offering vital lessons for enhancing human flourishing. Supplementary Information Supplementary Information. Acknowledgements I would like to express my sincere gratitude to Mr. Dudu for his essential contributions to this study. His support in survey design and distribution played a crucial role in securing high levels of participant engagement. Additionally, his encouragement and thoughtful feedback provided invaluable motivation during the research and writing process. Author contributions Y.Z. conducted the research, designed the study, analyzed the data, and prepared all figures and tables. Y.Z. also wrote the main manuscript text and approved the final version of the manuscript. Data availability Data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. Declarations Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Ethics This study adheres to the ethical guidelines outlined in the relevant regulations of the People’s Republic of China. All data utilized in this research are fully anonymized, do not contain sensitive personal information, and involve no interventions that could affect participants. In accordance with the “Regulations on Human-Related Biomedical Research” jointly issued in February 2023 by the National Health Commission, Ministry of Education, Ministry of Science and Technology, and the State Administration of Traditional Chinese Medicine of China, research using anonymized data that does not involve sensitive information or affect participants is exempt from ethical review. Based on these criteria, this study qualifies for an exemption from ethical review. Consent to participate All participants provided informed consent before participating in the study, ensuring their full understanding of the study’s purpose and requirements. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Information. Data Availability Statement Data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.