Reforming nursing reimbursement: direct payment models under Iran’s Nursing Service Act in a global context Authors: Nasim Hatefimoadab, Maliheh Talebi Jaghargh, Abbas Abbaszadeh, Simin Sharafi, Toktam Kianian, Milad Rezaiye, Abbas Ebadi Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundIn conventional healthcare systems, nursing services are often integrated into broader institutional or physician billing, limiting visibility of nursing contributions. Direct reimbursement provides itemized compensation, potentially increasing recognition. Iran’s 2007 Nursing Services Tariff and Adjustment of Nursing Fees Act introduced a tariff-based direct reimbursement model. This study explores its observed effects, comparing it to systems in the US, UK, Australia, Canada, Denmark, Japan, and Norway (selected by Beveridge vs. Bismarck typologies).MethodsA mixed qualitative-comparative design used the PRISM framework for implementation evaluation. Semi-structured interviews with 12 Iranian stakeholders (6 experts, 6 frontline nurses; snowball recruitment; guide on request) underwent reflexive thematic analysis, achieving saturation after 9 interviews. Cross-national analysis applied Walt and Gilson’s Policy Triangle to barriers, with scoping reviews, SWOT, and quantitative triangulation (e.g., salary/satisfaction metrics).ResultsIran’s tariff-based model appears to increase visibility and recognition of nursing work compared with bundled payment or salaried systems. Two primary themes emerged: Professional Development (identity, satisfaction, sense of justice) and Health System Implementation Considerations (observed resource allocation and service organization). These findings are descriptive and contextual, without implying causal effects or universal generalizability.ConclusionThe Iranian model provides context-specific insights on itemized nursing reimbursement and observed implementation experiences. Future research may explore longitudinal workforce outcomes, cost implications, and potential adaptation in diverse healthcare systems, while remaining within the limits of the study’s qualitative and secondary-source evidence.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12962-025-00690-0.Keywords: Direct payment models, Health policy, Nursing reimbursement, Nursing service act, Professional development Background The absence of a distinct reimbursement model for direct payment to nurses obscures their critical role in delivering safe, high-quality, and cost-effective healthcare [1]. Direct reimbursement refers to a payment mechanism where nursing services are compensated independently and itemized, bypassing integration with physician or institutional billing to enhance visibility and accountability (Welton & Harris, 2007). In many systems, nursing costs are embedded within generalized patient room charges, and care is often billed under physician identifiers—a practice known as bundled payments, wherein multiple healthcare services (e.g., diagnostics, nursing, and procedures) are aggregated into a single fixed reimbursement amount, obscuring individual contributions and undervaluing nursing inputs [2]. In many systems, nursing costs are embedded within generalized patient room charges, and care is often billed under physician identifiers, diminishing recognition of nurses’ contributions [3]. This lack of visibility may contribute to demotivation among nursing professionals, impacting retention and morale [4]. Several studies suggest that direct payment pathways for nursing care could expand nurses’ roles in healthcare delivery, thereby enhancing patient access [5–7]. Iran’s nursing profession originated in the early 20th century with missionary-driven training, starting with untrained caregivers amid cultural barriers and limited enrollment support. By mid-century, formal programs emerged in cities like Tehran, Tabriz, and Mashhad, culminating in the Ministry of Health’s 1952 recognition and integration into national healthcare. The 1979 Islamic Revolution restructured education under the Ministry of Health and Medical Education, centralizing training with a focus on gender-appropriate care, boosting female participation and public perception. The 1980–1988 Iran-Iraq War spurred rebirth via frontline roles, enabling male entry and shifting curricula toward associate degrees for wartime needs, enhancing clinical expertise and workforce integration. Economically, despite resource constraints relative to global benchmarks, Iran’s system advances health outcomes through professionalization, expanded education, and adaptive policies [8]. Globally, data on nursing compensation are limited, with few countries employing standardized reimbursement models specific to nursing services [9]. Instead, nurse salaries typically reflect local economic conditions, leaving the true value of their care unquantified [10]. Iran’s Nursing Services Tariff and Adjustment of Nursing Fees Act (Nursing Service Act), enacted on June 27, 2007, under Article 123 of the constitution, introduces a pioneering direct reimbursement framework—potentially the first of its kind globally [11]. Here, “tariff” denotes a government-regulated schedule of standardized prices for predefined nursing services (e.g., vital signs monitoring or wound care), distinct from pure fee-for-service (FFS) models, which reimburse providers on a per-service basis driven by market negotiations and potentially incentivizing overutilization without caps or equity safeguards [12]. Iran’s tariff model, while service-specific like FFS, incorporates fixed rates and quality metrics to promote cost containment and fairness in a resource-constrained context. Its implementation, however, faced significant delays, spanning nearly 15 years until recent efforts by the Deputy of Nursing operationalized the model [13]. This study aimed to compare nursing reimbursement models across different countries and to introduce the Nursing Service Act as a unique direct nursing reimbursement model from Islamic Republic of Iran (IRI). Method Research design This study utilized a mixed qualitative-comparative design to examine direct nursing reimbursement models, with Iran’s Nursing Services Tariff and Adjustment of Nursing Fees Act (Nursing Service Act) as the central case study, contextualized within a cross-national comparison. To ensure systematic rigor, the comparative component adopts the PRISM (Practical, Robust Implementation and Sustainability Model) framework, which evaluates interventions across organizational, environmental, and individual contexts, intervention design, and implementation/promotion processes, facilitating reproducible assessment of sustainability and scalability in diverse settings [14]. This paradigm shift emphasizes performance outcomes over descriptive listing, aligning with health policy evaluation standards. This approach integrates an in-depth exploration of policy implementation with a systematic evaluation of global reimbursement frameworks, enabling the identification of innovative practices and challenges. The research was approved by the Research Ethics Committees of Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, under ethics code IR.KUMS.REC.1401.379, specifically for the interview component of the study involving human participants in Iran; the secondary data analysis and comparative synthesis, being non-human subjects research, fell outside this scope but adhered to ethical standards for data use and confidentiality. adhering to ethical standards for participant confidentiality and informed consent. Study components Case study: Iran’s Nursing Service Act The primary focus was an in-depth qualitative case study of Iran’s Nursing Service Act, a pioneering direct reimbursement model enacted in 2007. This component investigated its legislative origins, implementation trajectory, and outcomes over a 15-year period. Comparative analysis A comparative analysis evaluated nursing reimbursement systems in seven additional countries—the United States, United Kingdom, Australia, Canada, Denmark, Japan, and Norway—selected for their diverse healthcare financing structures and approaches to nursing compensation (e.g., bundled payments in the US vs. salaried models in the UK, as defined in the Background). Data collection Data were collected through a multi-source strategy to ensure depth and breadth of evidence. Primary data collection Semi-structured interviews In Iran, 12 semi-structured interviews were conducted with purposively selected policymakers, nursing administrators, and health system experts involved in the Nursing Service Act’s development and rollout. Interviews, lasting 45–60 min, explored policy design, barriers, and perceived impacts, using an iteratively refined guide. Interview guide A semi-structured guide was developed iteratively, piloted with 2 non-participants, and refined for clarity. Core domains included: (1) Policy origins and design (e.g., “How did legislative contexts shape the Act’s tariff structure?“); (2) Implementation barriers/enablers (e.g., “What actor dynamics influenced rollout delays?“); (3) Perceived impacts (e.g., “In what ways has direct reimbursement affected nurse morale and care delivery?“). Probes encouraged elaboration (e.g., “Can you provide examples?“). The guide (available upon request) ensured thematic consistency across 45–60-minute audio-recorded sessions, transcribed verbatim in Persian and translated to English for analysis. Secondary data collection Policy documents Legislative texts, government reports, and implementation guidelines were reviewed, including Iran’s Nursing Service Act (2007) and supplementary directives from the Deputy of Nursing. Global literature A scoping review synthesized peer-reviewed studies, policy briefs, and reports from databases (PubMed, Scopus, WHO Global Health Observatory) and professional bodies (e.g., American Nurses Association, Royal College of Nursing), focusing on reimbursement mechanisms, nursing workforce policies, and empirical impacts such as cost metrics, satisfaction scores, and staffing ratios [15]. Search terms included “nursing tariff Iran impact” combined with “cost efficiency,” “patient satisfaction,” and “nurse retention,” yielding 15 relevant Iranian studies for quantitative triangulation. The literature search was conducted in September 2024–2025. Inclusion/exclusion criteria Included English-language publications (2000–2024) on nursing reimbursement in the selected countries (Iran, US, UK, Australia, Canada, Denmark, Japan, Norway); peer-reviewed articles, policy reports, or guidelines reporting mechanisms, outcomes, or barriers; no study design restrictions. Excluded Non-English publications; pre-2000 works; non-nursing-specific payments (e.g., physician-only); irrelevant geographies. This yielded targeted evidence on diverse typologies (Beveridge/Bismarck). Selection process Two reviewers independently screened titles/abstracts (n = 1,256 records identified), with full-text review of 184 for eligibility, resolving discrepancies via discussion (kappa = 0.87). The process is summarized in Table 1 (PRISMA-ScR flow diagram). Table 1PRISMA-ScR flow diagram for scoping reviewStageDescriptionNumber of RecordsIdentificationRecords identified from databases (PubMed n = 512; Scopus n = 456; WHO n = 98) and other sources (n = 190)1,256ScreeningRecords after duplicates removed (n = 342 excluded)914EligibilityFull-texts assessed for eligibility (n = 730 excluded: irrelevant n = 512; non-English/date n = 148; non-selected countries n = 70)184IncludedStudies/reports included in synthesis (n = 52: 28 peer-reviewed; 24 grey literature)52 PRISMA-ScR flow diagram for scoping review Sampling Countries Iran was the focal case; comparator countries were chosen based on healthcare system typologies to maximize variance in financing and delivery models: Beveridge (tax-funded, single-payer; e.g., UK, Norway, Denmark) for equitable, salaried emphases; Bismarck (social insurance-based; e.g., Japan) for contributory, fee-oriented structures; and mixed/private hybrids (e.g., US, Australia, Canada) for bundled/market-driven approaches [16]. This typology-driven selection (n = 7 comparators from an initial pool of 20 nations) ensures representation of global diversity while prioritizing data availability on nursing payments, as per PRISM’s environmental context domain. Participants The final qualitative sample consisted of 12 participants, selected to ensure diversity in role, expertise, and experience. A multi-stage purposive–snowball strategy was used. First, policymakers and administrative experts involved in the development or implementation of Iran’s Nursing Tariff and Productivity Adjustment Law were recruited through professional networks (e.g., Iranian Nursing Organization). These experts then nominated frontline nurses directly engaged in tariff implementation or service delivery. The final sample included 6 policy/administrative experts and 6 bedside nurses (5–15 years of experience), with balanced gender representation (6 women, 6 men).Inclusion criteria: Direct involvement in tariff implementation or delivery; exclusion: Conflicts of interest. Response rate: 80% (12/15 invited). This approach mitigated elite bias while aligning with case study norms [17]. Interviewees were selected via purposive sampling, targeting individuals with direct expertise in Iran’s reimbursement reform, ensuring rich, context-specific insights. Data analysis Qualitative case study analysis Interview transcripts and Iranian policy documents were analyzed using reflexive thematic analysis, following Braun and Clarke’s six-phase framework, to identify themes such as policy intent, implementation delays, and stakeholder perspectives [18]. Data saturation was monitored iteratively throughout the analysis. By the ninth interview, no new codes or subthemes emerged, and the remaining three interviews confirmed redundancy. Saturation tracking was documented through analytic memos and codebook iteration logs. To ensure analytical rigor, two independent external coders (health policy academics not involved in the study and blinded to the research aims) double-coded 50% of the transcripts. Inter-coder agreement reached 92%, and discrepancies were resolved through facilitated consensus meetings, which were held without author involvement to minimize interpretive bias [19]. Comparative analysis A custom-designed comparative framework assessed three dimensions across all countries: (1) legislative and policy foundations (2), reimbursement mechanisms (direct vs. bundled payments), and (3) implementation outcomes (e.g., nurse satisfaction, cost-effectiveness). Implementation barriers in Iran were further analyzed using Walt and Gilson’s Health Policy Triangle [20], dissecting context (e.g., economic sanctions), content (tariff design), actors (nursing vs. physician lobbies), and process (15-year delays), to elucidate systemic influences. Data were synthesized using matrix-based comparisons (Table 2). Table 2Dimensions of the custom-designed comparative frameworkDimensionDescriptionKey Elements AssessedData Sources1. Legislative and Policy FoundationsHistorical and regulatory context shaping reimbursementEnactment dates, constitutional bases, policy drivers (e.g., equity mandates)Policy documents, WHO reports2. Reimbursement MechanismsPayment structures and modalitiesDirect tariffs vs. bundled/salaried; fee-for-service distinctionsLiterature scoping, grey literature3. Implementation OutcomesSystemic and professional impactsSatisfaction metrics, cost savings, scalability threatsInterviews, secondary metrics (e.g., earnings trends) Dimensions of the custom-designed comparative framework SWOT Analysis: Each country’s model underwent a Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats analysis to distill best practices and reform opportunities. The SWOT analysis was conducted by two researchers who independently evaluated secondary data (e.g., policy reports, literature) from each country, coding emergent factors into categories, then met to discuss and agree on common themes via consensus, resolving discrepancies through reference to triangulated evidence (inter-rater agreement: 90%). This process reinforced analytical credibility and minimized subjectivity [21]. Rigor and trustworthiness Triangulation: Converging evidence from interviews, documents, and literature mitigated bias and enriched findings. Triangulation: Converging evidence from interviews, documents, and literature mitigated bias and enriched findings. Reflexivity: The research team documented assumptions and decisions throughout the analysis to enhance transparency. Reflexivity: The research team documented assumptions and decisions throughout the analysis to enhance transparency. Validation: Findings were validated through member checking with interview participants and peer debriefing with two external experts in health policy and nursing economics [22]. Validation: Findings were validated through member checking with interview participants and peer debriefing with two external experts in health policy and nursing economics [22]. Results Comparative analysis of nursing reimbursement models The comparative analysis evaluated nursing reimbursement systems across eight countries: Iran, the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia, Canada, Denmark, Japan, and Norway, focusing on legislative foundations, reimbursement mechanisms (e.g., direct reimbursement via tariffs in Iran versus bundled payments or salaried structures elsewhere), and implementation outcomes. A SWOT analysis complemented the framework, highlighting strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats for each model (Table 3). SWOT elements for Iran were derived from both semi-structured interviews and legal documents, whereas for other countries, the analysis relied primarily on legal documents and secondary literature. All findings are the result of qualitative analysis by two independent researchers, ensuring consistency and traceability to data sources. A consolidated SWOT analysis was conducted for all countries included in the comparative study, integrating primary interview data (for Iran) and secondary sources (for other countries). Each SWOT element is coded by type (Strength, Weakness, Opportunity, Threat), source (interview, legal document, literature), and a simple weight indicating relative importance: 1 = low, 2 = moderate, 3 = high. For a detailed overview of all SWOT elements and their origins, see Table 4. Table 3Cross-national comparison of nursing reimbursement models using PRISM frameworkCountry/TypologyOrganizational Context (e.g., Financing)Reimbursement MechanismSustainability (PRISM)Iran (Mixed/Bismarck hybrid)Hybrid insurance-tax; sanctions-constrainedDirect tariffs (itemized)Moderate (funding threats)US (Private hybrid)Market-driven DRGsBundled (physician-led)Low (fragmented)UK (Beveridge)Tax-funded NHSSalariedHigh (budget cuts threat) Cross-national comparison of nursing reimbursement models using PRISM framework Table 4Consolidated SWOT analysis of nursing reimbursement modelsCountrySWOT ElementDescriptionData SourceQualitative Weight (1–3)IranStrengthEnhanced professional recognition of nursesInterviews + Legal Documents3WeaknessSlow rollout and resource constraintsInterviews + Legal Documents3OpportunityScalability of direct reimbursementInterviews + Legal Documents2ThreatEconomic instability affecting fundingInterviews + Legal Documents3USStrengthSystem simplicity with DRG-based paymentsLiterature2WeaknessLack of nurse-specific valuationLiterature3OpportunityValue-based payment reformsLiterature2ThreatResistance from hospital lobbiesLiterature2UKStrengthEquitable pay via salaried positionsLiterature2WeaknessLimited recognition of specialized careLiterature3OpportunityPotential integration of nursing tariffsLiterature2ThreatBudget cutsLiterature3AustraliaStrengthWorkforce stability under salaried + partial FFSLiterature2WeaknessUnderfunding of public nursingLiterature3OpportunityExpanding private reimbursementsLiterature2ThreatSectoral disparitiesLiterature2CanadaStrengthUniversal coverageLiterature3WeaknessInvisibility of nursing contributionsLiterature3OpportunityPilot reimbursement programsLiterature2ThreatProvincial funding variabilityLiterature2DenmarkStrengthHigh nurse satisfactionLiterature3WeaknessSlow policy innovationLiterature2OpportunityScaling pilot direct payment programsLiterature2ThreatFiscal conservatismLiterature2JapanStrengthStructured pay scalesLiterature2WeaknessLimited direct reimbursementLiterature3OpportunityExpanding nurse-led billingLiterature2ThreatAging population costsLiterature3NorwayStrengthRobust welfare supportLiterature2WeaknessLack of service-specific valuationLiterature3OpportunityIntegrating performance-based payLiterature2ThreatEconomic pressuresLiterature3 Consolidated SWOT analysis of nursing reimbursement models Iran: Under the Nursing Services Tariff and Adjustment of Nursing Fees Act (2007), Iran introduced a direct reimbursement model, shifting from bundled hospital payments to tariffs for specific nursing services. Implementation, delayed until approximately 2022, increased nurse visibility but faced challenges in funding allocation and administrative capacity [11]. Strengths include enhanced professional recognition; weaknesses include slow rollout and resource constraints; opportunities lie in scalability; threats include economic instability. Iran: Under the Nursing Services Tariff and Adjustment of Nursing Fees Act (2007), Iran introduced a direct reimbursement model, shifting from bundled hospital payments to tariffs for specific nursing services. Implementation, delayed until approximately 2022, increased nurse visibility but faced challenges in funding allocation and administrative capacity [11]. Strengths include enhanced professional recognition; weaknesses include slow rollout and resource constraints; opportunities lie in scalability; threats include economic instability. United States: Nursing costs are predominantly bundled into hospital Diagnosis-Related Group (DRG) payments under Medicare, with no direct reimbursement for nursing services [3]. Private insurers follow suit, obscuring nurses’ financial contributions. Strengths include system simplicity; weaknesses include a lack of nurse-specific valuation; opportunities exist in value-based payment reforms; threats include resistance from hospital lobbies. United States: Nursing costs are predominantly bundled into hospital Diagnosis-Related Group (DRG) payments under Medicare, with no direct reimbursement for nursing services [3]. Private insurers follow suit, obscuring nurses’ financial contributions. Strengths include system simplicity; weaknesses include a lack of nurse-specific valuation; opportunities exist in value-based payment reforms; threats include resistance from hospital lobbies. United Kingdom: The National Health Service (NHS) funds nursing through salaried positions within a single-payer system, with no separate reimbursement for individual services [23]. Strengths include equitable pay; weaknesses include limited recognition of specialized care; opportunities lie in integrating nursing tariffs; threats include budget cuts. United Kingdom: The National Health Service (NHS) funds nursing through salaried positions within a single-payer system, with no separate reimbursement for individual services [23]. Strengths include equitable pay; weaknesses include limited recognition of specialized care; opportunities lie in integrating nursing tariffs; threats include budget cuts. Australia: Nurses are compensated via salaried roles under Medicare’s public system, supplemented by fee-for-service payments in the private sectors, though rarely nurse-specific [24]. Strengths include workforce stability; weaknesses include underfunding of public nursing; opportunities exist in expanding private reimbursements; threats include disparities between sectors. Australia: Nurses are compensated via salaried roles under Medicare’s public system, supplemented by fee-for-service payments in the private sectors, though rarely nurse-specific [24]. Strengths include workforce stability; weaknesses include underfunding of public nursing; opportunities exist in expanding private reimbursements; threats include disparities between sectors. Canada: Similar to the UK, Canada’s single-payer system embeds nursing costs in hospital budgets, with no direct payment model [25]. Strengths include universal coverage; weaknesses include the invisibility of nursing contributions; opportunities lie in pilot reimbursement programs; threats include provincial funding variability. Canada: Similar to the UK, Canada’s single-payer system embeds nursing costs in hospital budgets, with no direct payment model [25]. Strengths include universal coverage; weaknesses include the invisibility of nursing contributions; opportunities lie in pilot reimbursement programs; threats include provincial funding variability. Denmark: Nurses receive salaries within a tax-funded healthcare system, with recent experimental direct payment pilots for home care services emerging [26]. Strengths include high nurse satisfaction; weaknesses include slow policy innovation; opportunities lie in scaling pilots; threats include fiscal conservatism. Denmark: Nurses receive salaries within a tax-funded healthcare system, with recent experimental direct payment pilots for home care services emerging [26]. Strengths include high nurse satisfaction; weaknesses include slow policy innovation; opportunities lie in scaling pilots; threats include fiscal conservatism. Japan: Nursing costs are bundled into hospital fees under the national insurance system, with some fee-for-service elements for advanced practice nurses [27]. Strengths include structured pay scales; weaknesses include limited direct reimbursement; opportunities exist in expanding nurse-led billing; threats include aging population costs. Japan: Nursing costs are bundled into hospital fees under the national insurance system, with some fee-for-service elements for advanced practice nurses [27]. Strengths include structured pay scales; weaknesses include limited direct reimbursement; opportunities exist in expanding nurse-led billing; threats include aging population costs. Norway: A tax-funded system compensates nurses via salaries, with no distinct service reimbursement [28]. Strengths include robust welfare support; weaknesses include a lack of service-specific valuation; opportunities lie in integrating performance-based pay; threats include economic pressures. Norway: A tax-funded system compensates nurses via salaries, with no distinct service reimbursement [28]. Strengths include robust welfare support; weaknesses include a lack of service-specific valuation; opportunities lie in integrating performance-based pay; threats include economic pressures. Synthesis Iran’s model stands out as the only fully implemented direct reimbursement system among the studied countries, contrasting with the predominant bundled or salaried approaches elsewhere. While Iran’s approach enhances nurse visibility, its delayed execution underscores implementation challenges absent in salaried systems like Denmark or Norway, though the latter sacrifice granular recognition of nursing value. All SWOT elements presented are traceable to the primary and secondary data sources and were analyzed independently by two researchers to ensure credibility and consistency. Qualitative case study results: Iran’s Nursing Service Act The qualitative case study explored stakeholder perspectives on Iran’s Nursing Service Act through semi-structured interviews with twelve key informants: six experts and six frontline nurses, aged 30–60 years. Participants included a mix of roles, providing balanced representation across policy, administration, and practice levels. Participants included five PhD holders in nursing and seven with MSc/BSN, with roles spanning a member of the Islamic Consultative Assembly, the Deputy Director of Education and Technology of the Nursing System Organization, the Director of the Nursing System Organization, the Deputy Director of Support of the Nursing System Organization, and a nursing school director, plus practicing nurses from public and rural settings. Their work experience averaged over 15 years, providing deep insights into policy reform. Reflexive thematic analysis identified two overarching themes: Professional Development and Health System Productivity, derived from six subthemes. Professional development Strengthening Professional Identity and Social Status: Interviewees emphasized that direct reimbursement elevated nurses’ recognition as autonomous professionals, shifting perceptions from ancillary staff to essential providers. One policymaker noted, “Tariffs gave nurses a voice in the system.” Strengthening Professional Identity and Social Status: Interviewees emphasized that direct reimbursement elevated nurses’ recognition as autonomous professionals, shifting perceptions from ancillary staff to essential providers. One policymaker noted, “Tariffs gave nurses a voice in the system.” Increasing Nurses’ Job Satisfaction: Participants reported heightened morale as payments reflected their workload, with a nursing leader stating, “Nurses feel valued for the first time in decades.” Increasing Nurses’ Job Satisfaction: Participants reported heightened morale as payments reflected their workload, with a nursing leader stating, “Nurses feel valued for the first time in decades.” Adjusting Perceived Justice: The model addressed pay inequities, aligning compensation with effort and expertise, as a director highlighted: “It’s about fairness—nurses see their worth acknowledged.” Adjusting Perceived Justice: The model addressed pay inequities, aligning compensation with effort and expertise, as a director highlighted: “It’s about fairness—nurses see their worth acknowledged.” Health system productivity Optimizing Health System Costs: Stakeholders observed that tariffing reduced over-reliance on physicians for billable tasks, streamlining resource use. A participant remarked, “We’re cutting inefficiencies by paying for what nurses already do.” Optimizing Health System Costs: Stakeholders observed that tariffing reduced over-reliance on physicians for billable tasks, streamlining resource use. A participant remarked, “We’re cutting inefficiencies by paying for what nurses already do.” Increasing Patient Satisfaction: Participants reported a perception that direct payments were associated with improved care quality, as nurses prioritized patient needs over administrative burdens, per an administrator: “Patients notice the difference when nurses are empowered.” Increasing Patient Satisfaction: Participants reported a perception that direct payments were associated with improved care quality, as nurses prioritized patient needs over administrative burdens, per an administrator: “Patients notice the difference when nurses are empowered.” Improving Quality of Nursing Care: Enhanced funding supported training and staffing, with one interviewee noting, “Better pay means better skills, and that lifts care standards.” Improving Quality of Nursing Care: Enhanced funding supported training and staffing, with one interviewee noting, “Better pay means better skills, and that lifts care standards.” The qualitative findings underscore the Nursing Service Act’s dual impact: fostering professional growth among nurses and enhancing systemic efficiency. These themes align with Iran’s comparative uniqueness, reinforcing its potential as a model for direct reimbursement reform. Discussion This study illuminates Iran’s Nursing Services Tariff and Adjustment of Nursing Fees Act (Nursing Service Act) as a pioneering direct reimbursement model, contrasting it with predominantly bundled or salaried nursing payment systems in the United States, United Kingdom, Australia, Canada, Denmark, Japan, and Norway. The tariff model’s distinction from pure fee-for-service (FFS) lies in its regulatory standardization, mitigating FFS risks like service proliferation while retaining direct, per-act compensation [12]. The findings reveal dual impacts: professionally, direct payments enhance nurses’ identity, satisfaction, and perceived justice; systemically, they optimize costs, elevate patient satisfaction, and improve care quality. These outcomes position Iran’s model as a potential blueprint for reforming nursing reimbursement globally, addressing a critical gap in recognizing nurses’ economic value. By aligning with recent nurse-led billing innovations in advanced practice (e.g., NPI-enabled APRN reimbursements; American Nurses Association, 2023), Iran’s tariffs offer scalable lessons for integrating such models into value-based care frameworks worldwide, particularly in under-resourced systems [9]. The comparative analysis underscores a global reliance on indirect payment structures, where nursing costs are subsumed within hospital budgets or physician-led billing [29]. In the United States, for instance, Diagnosis-Related Group (DRG) payments obscure nurses’ contributions, a practice linked to understaffing and burnout [4]. Similarly, salaried systems in the UK, Canada, and Norway ensure workforce stability but fail to tie compensation to service-specific outputs, potentially undervaluing specialized care [30]. Iran’s tariff-based approach, despite implementation delays, counters this trend by assigning monetary value to individual nursing acts, aligning with calls for value-based healthcare reforms [11]. However, its challenges, funding constraints, and administrative bottlenecks mirror those in Denmark’s pilot programs, suggesting that direct reimbursement requires robust infrastructure. Qualitatively, the Professional Development and Health System Productivity themes resonate with prior research. Strengthening professional identity through direct payments echoes findings that financial recognition boosts nurses’ autonomy and societal standing [1]. Increased job satisfaction and perceived justice align with studies linking equitable pay to reduced turnover and improved morale [31]. Systemically, optimizing costs via nurse-led billing supports evidence that reallocating resources from physician-centric models enhances efficiency [32]. Enhanced patient satisfaction and care quality corroborate the positive correlation between nurse empowerment and clinical outcomes [33]. Iran’s model thus bridges a theoretical gap: while direct reimbursement is advocated in policy discourse [13], few countries have operationalized it at scale. These findings have significant implications. For policymakers, Iran’s model suggests that direct reimbursement can elevate nursing’s status and system efficiency, though success hinges on sustained investment and administrative capacity. For nursing leaders globally, it offers a framework to advocate for payment reform, challenging entrenched bundled systems. Future research should explore longitudinal outcomes of Iran’s tariffs on nurse retention and patient health metrics, alongside pilot studies in salaried systems (e.g., UK, Canada) to test direct payment feasibility. Comparative cost-effectiveness analyses could further quantify the model’s economic impact, addressing a gap in current literature. Strengths and limitations The study’s strengths lie in its multi-method design, triangulating comparative data with stakeholder insights to offer a nuanced view of reimbursement reform. Iran’s case exemplifies how context-specific policies can address universal challenges, such as nurse invisibility, identified across diverse healthcare systems. However, several limitations should be acknowledged. First, although the qualitative sample was expanded to n = 12, the size remains modest and may limit transferability beyond similar health-system contexts. Second, the comparative component relied partly on secondary data from other countries, which may lack granularity and consistency across sources. Finally, Iran’s 15-year implementation lag raises questions about scalability in settings without economic stability, a challenge similarly reflected in the SWOT analysis. Conclusion This comparative study highlights Iran’s Nursing Services Tariff and Adjustment of Nursing Fees Act as a groundbreaking and unique fully-implemented initiative in direct nursing reimbursement among the major global systems studied (e.g., bundled models in the US or salaried structures in the UK and Norway). By itemizing nursing services and standardizing tariffs, the act appears to have increased visibility and recognition of nursing work compared with indirect payment approaches. The analysis identifies observed strengths and challenges in implementation, without inferring causality or universal generalizability. Findings provide contextual insights that may be informative for policymakers considering adjustments to nursing reimbursement in settings with similar structural features. Observed outcomes relate to professional recognition, administrative feasibility, and resource allocation rather than proven effects on workforce retention or cost-effectiveness. Future research directions include: (1) longitudinal qualitative and quantitative assessments of professional experiences before and after tariff adoption; (2) context-specific evaluation of financial and operational sustainability; (3) exploratory studies of model adaptation in different healthcare financing systems; and (4) mixed-methods investigation of patient care indicators potentially linked to nursing service organization. These efforts aim to support evidence-informed discussion of nursing reimbursement approaches while remaining within the bounds of observed data. Supplementary Information Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material. Supplementary Material 1 Abbreviations Islamic Republic of Iran United States United Kingdom Author contributions N.H. Conceptualized the study, conducted semi-structured interviews. M.T.J. Performed thematic analysis and contributed to the cross-national comparison. A.A. Provided expertise on Iran’s Nursing Services Tariff Act and reviewed the manuscript. S.S. Conducted interviews and contributed to the SWOT framework analysis. T.K. Analyzed secondary data and assisted in drafting the manuscript. M.R wrote the main manuscript text and supported data collection and contributed to the qualitative comparative design, and A.E. Supervised the study, provided critical revisions, and finalized the manuscript. All authors reviewed and approved the final manuscript. Funding No funding. Data availability The dataset supporting this study is available from the corresponding authors upon reasonable request. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate The research was approved by the Research Ethics Committees of Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, under ethics code IR.KUMS.REC.1401.379, adhering to ethical standards for participant confidentiality and informed consent. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Contributor Information Milad Rezaiye, Email: miladrezaiye73m@gmail.com, Email: miladrezaiye@bmsu.ac.ir. Abbas Ebadi, Email: ebadi1347@bmsu.ac.ir, Email: ebadi1347@yahoo.com. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1 Data Availability Statement The dataset supporting this study is available from the corresponding authors upon reasonable request.