Core competencies and qualifications of health sciences school managers: a multi-method qualitative study Authors: Leila Doshmangir, Masoumeh Jorjani, Alireza Khoshdel, Neda Kabiri, Abbas Haghparast, Saeed Semnanian, Jamil Sadeghifar, Mohammad Mahboubi, AliAkbar Haghdoost, Mohammad Hossein Somi, Saeid Aslanabadi, Ramin Rezapour Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundThe selection and appointment of qualified managers in health sciences schools are critically important due to their substantial impact on the performance of faculties and medical universities. Accordingly, the selection process should be based on criteria that effectively assess candidates’ competencies and experiences in alignment with the principles of meritocracy and academic excellence. Unlike previous studies that have mainly focused on general academic leadership traits, this study introduces a comprehensive, merit-based competency framework specifically tailored to health sciences school management. This study aims to identify and define the essential competencies and qualifications required for managers of health sciences schools, including educational department heads and school deans, with an emphasis on a merit-based approach.MethodsThis study employed a multi-method qualitative design, incorporating a scoping review, document analysis, semi-structured interviews, expert panel discussions, and the Delphi technique. The scoping review was conducted to identify key competencies and indicators relevant to the selection and appointment of medical school managers. We conducted a document analysis to examine national and governmental reports related to the Iranian medical universities. Also, we used semi-structured interviews and focus group discussions to explore stakeholders’ perspectives on existing processes, selection criteria, and influencing factors. A manager selection framework was developed based on the findings. The Delphi technique was subsequently employed to validate and finalize the proposed process for appointing Educational Department Heads (EDHs) and Health Sciences School Deans (HSSDs).ResultsWe identified a total of 18 criteria for the selection of EDHs and HSSDs which were categorized into five main domains of personal and character competencies, organizational and environmental knowledge, professionalism, educational background and expertise, and organizational role and engagement. In addition, the final checklist for selecting HSDs contains 16 specific criteria. This study also proposed a structured, seven-step process for the selection of EDHs.ConclusionThe findings of this study contribute to a paradigm shift in the traditional approach to appointing managers in health sciences schools. Our results indicated that EDHs and HSSDs should have expertise as well as a balanced combination of managerial competencies, human resource development capabilities, knowledge of organizational behavior, change management skills, and performance support strategies, which can significantly enhance their effectiveness and success in their leadership roles.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12909-025-08295-0.Keywords: Health facility administrators, Health professions, Leadership, Professional competence Introduction Medical sciences universities represent one of the most critical elements of both higher education and national health system. These institutions are responsible for educating the next generation of healthcare professionals, advancing knowledge, and delivering healthcare services [1, 2]. Within this complex environment, leadership and management at different organizational levels including departments, faculties, and schools, play a decisive role in shaping institutional effectiveness and outcomes [3, 4]. Among academic leaders, Educational Department Heads (EDHs) and Health Sciences School Deans (HSSDs) hold critical positions, as they are responsible for steering educational, research, and developmental processes at both departmental and school levels. To fulfill their responsibilities, they must possess a set of core competencies and qualifications that go beyond general management skills [5, 6]. Research has shown that strong academic leadership enhances organizational learning, staff motivation, and institutional adaptability. However, the majority of research in this area has focused on hospital managers or general university leaders, rather than leaders of health sciences schools and departments. These academic units face unique challenges, such as bringing together different disciplines, balancing academic and clinical training, and keeping up with fast changes in health systems. Because of this, understanding managerial competencies required for these positions is an important issue that isn’t covered comprehensively in the literature [1]. Despite the importance of leadership at departmental and school levels, evidences revealed that medical sciences universities in developing countries such as Iran have faced substantial challenges in developing qualified educational leaders in recent years [7]. Managing large and diverse academic communities requires strong leadership and effective governance structures. However, most of the universities face with challenges such as limited managerial competencies, unclear role expectations, difficulties in faculty recruitment and retention, and insufficient professional development opportunities for academic leaders [2]. These challenges can lead to posing pressure on faculty deans and department heads. Also, there can appear inefficiencies that may have negative effect on the quality of education, research productivity, and the country’s health system. It is obvious that, the current process of appointing educational leaders in Iranian universities is mainly based on the academic and scientific achievements, instead of considering managerial competencies such as change leadership, educational governance, communication skills, and strategic leadership abilities [8]. Both the experience of researchers and the existing literature suggest that no study has yet been conducted to identify managerial competencies required for EDHs and HSSDs in the Iran. To address this gap, this study aims to identify, categorize, and validate the managerial competencies required for EDHs and HSSDs in Iranian medical universities. By integrating scoping review, document review, qualitative study, Delphi technique, expert panel, and brainstorming, the study aims to develop a context-specific competency framework that can inform recruitment, promotion, and professional development policies for academic leaders in health sciences education. The structure of this paper is organized as follows: Methods section outlines the research design, data collection, and analytical procedures. In the results section we have presented the key findings, including final criteria for selection of educational department heads with prioritized and weighted scores. The next section discusses the main findings with international evidence, and then we conclude with practical recommendations and insights for future research. Methods This study employed a multi-method qualitative approach, integrating literature and document reviews to provide formal criteria, semi-structured interviews and focus group discussions to capture experiences and insights from the key stakeholders, and expert panel discussions and the Delphi technique to ensure expert consensus (Fig. 1). The rationale for using multiple methods was to triangulate data sources and enhance the validity and depth of the findings and ensure that the framework is both theoretically sound and practically applicable in the context of Iranian medical universities. A multi-method qualitative study to define the essential competencies and qualifications of medical sciences school managers Phase 1: scoping review We used instructions from the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) [9, 10] for conducting the scoping review, and followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension (PRISMA-ScR) [11]. The inclusion criteria were defined as follows: P (Population): medical schools’ deans, chairmen, and supervisors; C (Concept): recruitment criteria and competencies for these population; and C (Context): publications related to medical schools, colleges, faculties, and institutes worldwide. We conducted a systematic search using both free-text keywords and controlled vocabularies across the following databases without any limitations in language and publication date: PubMed, ISI Web of Knowledge, Scopus, and PsycINFO (via Ebsco). A PubMed search strategy is as below: (faculty[Title/Abstract]) OR (school[Title/Abstract]) OR (college[Title/Abstract]) OR (institute[Title/Abstract]) OR (department[Title/Abstract])) AND (select*[Title/Abstract]) OR (recruitment[Title/Abstract]) OR (appointment[Title/Abstract]) (dean[Title/Abstract]) OR (chair[Title/Abstract]) OR (chairperson[Title/Abstract]) OR (chief[Title/Abstract]) OR (director[Title/Abstract]) OR (executive[Title/Abstract]) OR (head[Title/Abstract]) OR (leader*[Title/Abstract]) OR (supervisor[Title/Abstract]) AND (competenc*[Title/Abstract]) OR (skill[Title/Abstract]) OR (criteri*[Title/Abstract]) OR (qualification*[Title/Abstract]) OR (factor[Title/Abstract]) OR (indicator[Title/Abstract]) AND (medical[Title/Abstract]) OR (health[Title/Abstract]). Also, we searched Google Scholar for further relevant literature. The first 100 results were screened. Search was conducted in January 10, 2025. We used Systematic Review-Accelerator for developing search strategies in the other databases. The search results were imported into EndNote X.20 (Clarivate Analytics, PA, USA) for study selection, which was carried out by two independent reviewers based on the preliminary inclusion and exclusion criteria. Data extraction was also performed by two independent reviewers. A standardized data extraction tool was developed aligned with the recommendations from the JBI methodology group for scoping reviews. For summarizing data and categorizing the deans’ competencies, we employed qualitative content analysis [12, 13]. Phase 2: documents review, semi-structured interviews and focus group discussions This study employed a multi-phase qualitative approach integrating document review, semi-structured interviews, a focus group discussion (FGD), brainstorming sessions, and a Delphi technique to identify and validate key criteria for selecting EDHs and HSSDs within medical sciences universities. Document review A comprehensive review of official and policy documents was conducted to extract formal selection criteria and procedural guidelines. Sources included Ministry of Health and Medical Education regulations, university management bylaws, guidelines for faculty leadership appointments, performance evaluation reports, and protocols from previous appointment interviews. These documents were analyzed to identify explicit requirements and implicit norms guiding leadership selection. Semi-structured interviews We conducted 19 semi-structured interviews using purposive sampling of experts. The inclusion criteria for these experts were involvement in leadership appointment processes or having a minimum of 10 years of academic leadership experience. The participants included a diverse group of key stakeholders such as senior faculty members, heads of clinical departments, directors of educational groups, and deans of medical schools. In addition, experts from the Ministry of Health and Medical Education (MoHME), especially from the Deputy for Education, participated in both interviews and FGD. Interviews continued until thematic saturation was achieved. Each interview lasted between 40 and 90 min. Interviews were conducted face-to-face or in telephone or using virtual communications. The primary interviewer, a health policy researcher with extensive qualitative experience and no direct stake in the study outcomes, facilitated all interviews using a standardized interview guide (see Supplementary File 1). Focus group discussion We conducted one FGD with seven participants (two former faculty deans, two former university presidents, two senior faculty members with more than 15 years of experience, and one senior expert from Ministry of Health). The FGD session lasted about 110 min, moderated by a trained facilitator, and was audio-recorded and fully transcribed with participants’ informed consent. Data analysis and trustworthiness Data from interviews and the FGD were analyzed using thematic analysis in MAXQDA software version 2020. Two researchers coded transcripts using deductive and inductive approaches. To ensure credibility, we shared findings with selected participants (member checking). We ensured dependability by a comprehensive documentation of the research process. Also, we ensured confirmability with peer debriefing and reflexivity. We triangulated our data collection sources to ensure the validity of the results. Phase 3: brainstorming and expert panel Outputs from Phases 1 and 2 helped us to develop a comprehensive matrix of selection criteria and responsibilities. This matrix was reviewed in four structured brainstorming sessions facilitated by a moderator. According to the results of the brainstorming sessions, we developed a questionnaire and distributed to 47 experts, 32 of whom including faculty members, previous department chairs, faculty deans, heads of clinical divisions, previous vice chancellors for education or research, and several graduate students responded and returned our questionnaires. Participants scored each criterion on a 5-point Likert scale, and criteria scoring less than 2 were excluded. The final list included 18 criteria with a scale of 1 to 10. Phase 4: Delphi technique A two-round Delphi process was conducted to validate and prioritize the criteria developed in the previous phase. Twenty seven experts independently rated each criterion on a 1 to 10 scale. Median scores and interquartile ranges were calculated after each Delphi round. We defined reaching consensus before the start of this phase to be as equal or more than 75% agreement within an interquartile range of 2 or less. Results Phase 1: scoping review The initial search yielded 4565 results, 1312 of which removed due to duplication. Thirty-seven full texts were assessed, of which nine studies were included in this scoping review (Fig. 2). PRISMA flow diagram of study selection in the scoping review phase Table 1 shows the main characteristics of included studies. Among the nine studies, five were conducted in the United States of America [14–18], other were conducted in Iran [19], Uganda [20], Korea [21], and India [22]. Studies were conducted between 1992 and 2022. Based on the findings, the leadership qualities and skills for faculty deans and department chairs can be classified into five categories of communication skills, administrative competence, change management skills, disciplinary and domain knowledge, and decisive and ethical personality attributes. These findings provided the conceptual foundation for the next phases. Table 1Main characteristics of included studiesAuthor, YearCountryStudy designParticipants (N)Leadership qualities and skillsBates, 1992 [14]USASurvey(Questionnaire)Obstetrics and gynecology department chairmen(98 current and acting department chairman of United States medical schools with residency training programs in obstetrics and gynecology)− Interpersonal skills− Knowledge of specialty− Administrative skills− Respect in specialty− Vision− Teaching skills− Communications skills− Research experience− Political awareness− Financial management− Social skills− Grant writing skills Buckley, 2014 [15]USANarrative review/commentaryChairs of US medical schools’ departments− Scholarship− Administrative acumen− Skill in recruitment− Effectiveness as a departmental and institutional administrator− Visionary perspective− Integrity− Trust− Vision− Financial savvy− Decisiveness− Group leadership skills− Communication− Interpretative− Emotional intelligence Rich, 2008 [16]North AmericaNarrative reviewNorth American medical school executives− Management skills (Institutional assessment, Strategic planning, financial stewardship, Recruitment and retention of talent)− Leadership skills (Visioning, maximizing values, Building constituency)− Content knowledge (Academic medical center governance, Expectations of clinicians and scientists, Process of medical education)− Certain attitudes (Commitment to the success of others, Appreciation of institutional culture) Hromas, 2018 [17]USASurvey(Questionnaire)491 Clinical and basic science chairs at 41 medical schools− Strategic vision− Integrity between words and deeds− Explaining the reasons behind decisions− Providing good feedback− Admitting errors− Open discussion of complex or awkward topics− Skill in improving relations with the teaching hospital− Financial acumen Jadhav, 2017 [18]USA- MichiganCross-sectional(Questionnaire)50 Public health professionals serving in leadership and management positions in 3 local health departments− Ethical standards− Interaction with interrelated systems− Create opportunities− Collaborate for development− Minimize barriers− Ensure availability of opportunities− Ensure use of opportunities− Ensure management− Ensure continuous improvement− Advocate for role of public health Kohan, 2020 [19]IranMulti‑Method(Focus group discussions)8–12 participants who had expertise in academic management and experiences in administrative through university− General and special criteria (Academic rank of at least as associate professor, Minimum experience of 5 years as faculty member, Maximum age of 65 years at the start of appointment, Lack of employment outside the university for holding executive positions)− Expected qualifications (Adherence to the principles and supreme objectives of Iran, Professional commitment, Executive experiences, managerial responsibilities. and leadership in academic settings, Efficient communicative skills, Spirit of change and innovation in academic and administrative activities, Inter-sectoral communication skills within the university and with external institutions, International academic communication skills)Kyamanywa, 2021 [20]UgandaQualitative cross-sectional study drawing on Grounded theory(Semi-structured interviews)13 Deans (9 of the 12 current deans and 4 former deans)− Personality characteristics (Open to Learning and self- improvement)− Education/training (Medical expert, medical educator, Research skills)− Organizational skills (People management, Work ethics)− Financial and resources management− Communication and collaboration− Change management Lee, 2010 [21]KoreaCross-sectional study (Interview with open-ended questionnaires)207 Medical school faculties (54 subjects (faculties, residents, nurses) in41 faculties)− Professional ability− Ethics/morality− Self-management− Self-development− Passion− Public interest− Networking− Social participation− Active service− Motivating, caring, promoting teamwork, nurturing− Conflict management and directing− Performance management− Systems thinking− Organizational orientation− Collaboration− Voluntary participation− Cost-benefit orientation Palmer, 2015 [22]IndiaQualitativeDepartment chairs at their institution in the Indiana University School of Medicine (IUSM)− Leadership and team development (Engages in succession planning, creates leadership opportunities for others, serves as a mentor and/or sponsor, Sets the tone of an equitable and supportive climate for all)− Performance and talent management (Encourages faculty development, effectively recruits and supports faculty and learners, provides ongoing feedback, Empowers others)− Vision and strategic planning (Establish a shared vision, inspires others toward a common goal, encourages innovation, Is fiscally responsible)− Emotional intelligence (Is self-reflective, serves as a role model, Welcomes the views of others, commits to enhancing diversity)− Communication skills (Articulates a vision, negotiates for resources and support, actively listens, engages others in decision making)− Commitment to the tripartite mission (Insists that the department advance all three missions, integrates department goals with stakeholder goals, Advances communities of scholars across mission areas, Adapts to a changing environment) Main characteristics of included studies Survey (Questionnaire) Obstetrics and gynecology department chairmen (98 current and acting department chairman of United States medical schools with residency training programs in obstetrics and gynecology) − Interpersonal skills − Knowledge of specialty − Administrative skills − Respect in specialty − Vision − Teaching skills − Communications skills − Research experience − Political awareness − Financial management − Social skills − Grant writing skills − Scholarship − Administrative acumen − Skill in recruitment − Effectiveness as a departmental and institutional administrator − Visionary perspective − Integrity − Trust − Vision − Financial savvy − Decisiveness − Group leadership skills − Communication − Interpretative − Emotional intelligence − Management skills (Institutional assessment, Strategic planning, financial stewardship, Recruitment and retention of talent) − Leadership skills (Visioning, maximizing values, Building constituency) − Content knowledge (Academic medical center governance, Expectations of clinicians and scientists, Process of medical education) − Certain attitudes (Commitment to the success of others, Appreciation of institutional culture) Survey (Questionnaire) − Strategic vision − Integrity between words and deeds − Explaining the reasons behind decisions − Providing good feedback − Admitting errors − Open discussion of complex or awkward topics − Skill in improving relations with the teaching hospital − Financial acumen Cross-sectional (Questionnaire) − Ethical standards − Interaction with interrelated systems − Create opportunities − Collaborate for development − Minimize barriers − Ensure availability of opportunities − Ensure use of opportunities − Ensure management − Ensure continuous improvement − Advocate for role of public health Multi‑Method (Focus group discussions) − General and special criteria (Academic rank of at least as associate professor, Minimum experience of 5 years as faculty member, Maximum age of 65 years at the start of appointment, Lack of employment outside the university for holding executive positions) − Expected qualifications (Adherence to the principles and supreme objectives of Iran, Professional commitment, Executive experiences, managerial responsibilities. and leadership in academic settings, Efficient communicative skills, Spirit of change and innovation in academic and administrative activities, Inter-sectoral communication skills within the university and with external institutions, International academic communication skills) Qualitative cross-sectional study drawing on Grounded theory (Semi-structured interviews) − Personality characteristics (Open to Learning and self- improvement) − Education/training (Medical expert, medical educator, Research skills) − Organizational skills (People management, Work ethics) − Financial and resources management − Communication and collaboration − Change management 207 Medical school faculties (54 subjects (faculties, residents, nurses) in 41 faculties) − Professional ability − Ethics/morality − Self-management − Self-development − Passion − Public interest − Networking − Social participation − Active service − Motivating, caring, promoting teamwork, nurturing − Conflict management and directing − Performance management − Systems thinking − Organizational orientation − Collaboration − Voluntary participation − Cost-benefit orientation − Leadership and team development (Engages in succession planning, creates leadership opportunities for others, serves as a mentor and/or sponsor, Sets the tone of an equitable and supportive climate for all) − Performance and talent management (Encourages faculty development, effectively recruits and supports faculty and learners, provides ongoing feedback, Empowers others) − Vision and strategic planning (Establish a shared vision, inspires others toward a common goal, encourages innovation, Is fiscally responsible) − Emotional intelligence (Is self-reflective, serves as a role model, Welcomes the views of others, commits to enhancing diversity) − Communication skills (Articulates a vision, negotiates for resources and support, actively listens, engages others in decision making) − Commitment to the tripartite mission (Insists that the department advance all three missions, integrates department goals with stakeholder goals, Advances communities of scholars across mission areas, Adapts to a changing environment) Phase 2: document review, semi-structured interviews, and focus group discussion Document review (n = 41 documents), semi-structured interviews (n = 19 participants), and one FGD (n = 7 experts) resulted in developing four themes including human resource management and development, organizational behavior development, change management, and performance monitoring and evaluation. Also, 13 subthemes, and 46 specific managerial tasks were extracted in this phase (Table 2). Table 2Themes and Subthemes Related to The Tasks and Performance Criteria of Managers in Medical Sciences UniversitiesThemesSubthemesTasksHuman Resource Management and DevelopmentOrganizational structure and functions- Balancing authority and responsibility - Developing job descriptions- Clarifying organizational roles and processes- Revising structures based on defined responsibilitiesHuman resource optimization- Effective staff selection and deployment- Succession planningPerformance evaluation- Defining and specifying performance indicators- Monitoring performance based on strategic plans- Ensuring goal orientationOrganizational Behavior DevelopmentOrganizational culture enhancement- Promoting accountability and responsibility- Fostering core values (e.g., organizational commitment, justice orientation)- Encouraging teamwork- Ensuring stakeholder engagement and participatory approaches- Supporting merit-based selection- Promoting openness to feedback and constructive criticism- Reinforcing organizational normsLeadership styles- Practicing participative leadership- Applying trust-based leadership- Utilizing transformational leadershipOrganizational communication- Disseminating information effectively- Delivering feedback- Managing stakeholder interactions- Enhancing internal and external communicationOrganizational motivation- Promoting shared organizational ownership- Sharing benefits with organizational members- Strengthening perceptions of leadership support- Cultivating a climate of empathy- Encouraging participation- Building intra-organizational trustChange ManagementComparative management- Conducting needs assessments- Structuring based on contextual requirements- Optimally utilizing available capacities- Planning realistically- Applying participatory planning approachesTransformational leadership- Defining vision, goals, and mission- Optimizing organizational capacities- Managing stakeholder relationships- Implementing targeted marketing- Supporting innovative development- Ensuring balanced development of organizational rolesCommitment-based leadership- Applying systems thinking- Enhancing commitment and job satisfaction- Fostering innovation and flexibility- Promoting a sense of belonging and accountabilityPerformance Monitoring and EvaluationEducational performance- Conducting continuous evaluation of educational needs- Providing counseling and guidance- Aligning educational activities with organizational goals- Cultivating a culture of continuous learningNon-educational (administrative or operational) performance- Documenting job requirements and performance standards- Enhancing managerial skills- Developing performance evaluation systems- Establishing reward and incentive systems Themes and Subthemes Related to The Tasks and Performance Criteria of Managers in Medical Sciences Universities - Balancing authority and responsibility - Developing job descriptions- Clarifying organizational roles and processes - Revising structures based on defined responsibilities - Effective staff selection and deployment - Succession planning - Defining and specifying performance indicators - Monitoring performance based on strategic plans - Ensuring goal orientation - Promoting accountability and responsibility - Fostering core values (e.g., organizational commitment, justice orientation) - Encouraging teamwork - Ensuring stakeholder engagement and participatory approaches - Supporting merit-based selection - Promoting openness to feedback and constructive criticism - Reinforcing organizational norms - Practicing participative leadership - Applying trust-based leadership - Utilizing transformational leadership - Disseminating information effectively - Delivering feedback - Managing stakeholder interactions - Enhancing internal and external communication - Promoting shared organizational ownership - Sharing benefits with organizational members - Strengthening perceptions of leadership support - Cultivating a climate of empathy - Encouraging participation - Building intra-organizational trust - Conducting needs assessments - Structuring based on contextual requirements - Optimally utilizing available capacities - Planning realistically - Applying participatory planning approaches - Defining vision, goals, and mission - Optimizing organizational capacities - Managing stakeholder relationships - Implementing targeted marketing - Supporting innovative development - Ensuring balanced development of organizational roles - Applying systems thinking - Enhancing commitment and job satisfaction - Fostering innovation and flexibility - Promoting a sense of belonging and accountability - Conducting continuous evaluation of educational needs - Providing counseling and guidance - Aligning educational activities with organizational goals - Cultivating a culture of continuous learning - Documenting job requirements and performance standards - Enhancing managerial skills - Developing performance evaluation systems - Establishing reward and incentive systems Theme 1: human resource management and development This theme has three sub-themes including organizational structure and functions, human resource optimization, and performance evaluation. Participants highlighted existing challenges regarding this theme such as the discrepancies between the delegated authority and assigned responsibilities, the need to separate academic and administrative duties, and the prohibition of dual managerial positions. In addition, adhering to a participatory planning in selecting university level managers and the training of young professionals for future leadership roles were identified as strategies to enhance organizational performance. Effective performance evaluation requires the development of valid, reliable, and measurable indicators as well as predetermined program objectives. Also, participants declared that performance assessments should be based on the implementation and achievement of operational plans. “Human resource development hinges on the establishment of transparent evaluation criteria, a balanced distribution of authority and responsibility, and the creation of a dynamic organizational structure. These elements, when coupled with talent identification and development, serve as the foundation for sustainable organizational transformation” (P 21). One interviewee criticized the Comprehensive Bylaw for the Management of Universities and Higher Education, Research, and Technology Institutes (P 4), stating: “According to the bylaw, educational department heads are appointed for a two-year term upon the recommendation of the faculty dean and the approval of the university president, to carry out assigned duties. However, the bylaw fails to explicitly define the criteria required for such nominations by either the dean or the president. This lack of clarity has been overlooked in many universities to date” (P 11). Theme 2: organizational behavior development Sub-themes in the organizational behavior development included organizational culture enhancement, leadership styles, organizational communication, and organizational motivation. An effective organizational culture was defined in terms of having accountability, support and empathy, teamwork, adherence to regulations, and customer orientation. Organizational communication, plays a significant role in the implementation of major initiatives such as four-year strategic plans. According to participants, the success of these initiatives depends on vertical coordination across managerial levels (university, faculty, and department) and effective knowledge-sharing through technology. One study participant noted: “Strengthening organizational behavior requires a combination of trust-based culture, flexible delegation of authority, staff participation, and transparent communication to align organizational interests” (P 21). Theme 3: change management Comparative management, transformational leadership, and commitment-based leadership were three sub-themes emerged in change management theme. Many experts emphasized that effective change leadership requires a context-specific approach based on available resources, organizational capacities, and environmental conditions. Due to the transformational leadership in medical universities, there is a need for clear visions, missions, and specific objectives based on the roles and differences of each department and faculty. The success of such leadership depends on activities being in line with the university’s roadmap as well as considering legal and financial capacities. Participants declared that for achieving these goals there is a need for autonomous departments as “mini-faculties”, which fosters the internal innovation. Programs should be supported by legal and financial mechanisms, and must align with higher-level strategic documents (such as the university’s four-year development plan). In this regard, expert panels were proposed to facilitate the distribution of responsibilities and to reinforce practical, mission-oriented approaches. “Sustainable change in the educational system can only be achieved through a combination of structural flexibility, alignment with resource realities, and vertical coordination across managerial levels. A competent leader must possess the capacity to drive such transformation” (P 5). Another participant commented: “We do not fully utilize the full potential and responsibilities assigned to department chairs as outlined in the management bylaws for educational institutions. We must assess the existing infrastructure and actual needs to determine what organizational structure each department should have” (P 14). Systemic thinking, alignment in planning, integration of human resource strategies with the organization’s overall strategy, and root cause analysis were also identified as critical factors in fostering effective change leadership. Theme 4: performance monitoring and evaluation Performance monitoring and evaluating for educational, administrative, and operational staff is an important component of managerial accountability. Personnel empowerment and the promotion of organizational learning were highlighted as essential goals, supported through skill development, and provision of educational resources. Additionally, non-instructional supports such as financial and physical resources, clarification of roles and responsibilities, and staff guidance were identified as facilitators of effective performance. One interviewee noted: “Behavioral and interpersonal skills, personality traits and attitudes, and domain-specific knowledge and expertise are among the core competencies required of faculty managers. While knowledge and technical skills can be acquired over time, changing attitudes and personality traits is more difficult and requires carefully planned interventions. These dimensions must be evaluated during the managerial selection process, and behavioral and cognitive skills, in particular, can often be enhanced through targeted training” (P 19). Phase 3: brain storming and expert panel Based on the findings from the previous phases, an initial checklist of 18 criteria for selection of university managers was developed and categorized in five domains: Personality competencies Personality competencies Organizational and environmental knowledge Organizational and environmental knowledge Professionalism Professionalism Education and expertise Education and expertise Organizational role and activity Organizational role and activity This checklist was the basis for our brainstorming sessions and the expert panel. Participants reached consensus on the need for role differentiation, departmental autonomy, and mandatory leadership training for appointed heads. The checklist is detailed in Additional File 2. Phase 4: Delphi technique: final prioritization and weighting The 18 criteria and structural model were prioritized and weighted using the Delphi technique in Phase 4. At this phase, the approach to selecting EDHs in medical schools was defined as follows: Educational and research departments are distinct entities, each with specific roles and responsibilities that must be clearly defined. Educational and research departments are distinct entities, each with specific roles and responsibilities that must be clearly defined. The roles and required competencies of department heads should be differentiated to ensure clarity in expectations and performance. The roles and required competencies of department heads should be differentiated to ensure clarity in expectations and performance. An educational department is an autonomous unit that must possess the necessary competencies within its scope of duties and be granted appropriate authority. The intervention of the faculty and university in the department’s activities should be limited, allowing the department and its members to operate with sufficient independence. An educational department is an autonomous unit that must possess the necessary competencies within its scope of duties and be granted appropriate authority. The intervention of the faculty and university in the department’s activities should be limited, allowing the department and its members to operate with sufficient independence. The proposed model for selecting department heads is applicable across all educational departments in universities of medical sciences throughout the country. The proposed model for selecting department heads is applicable across all educational departments in universities of medical sciences throughout the country. Since the department head serves as the representative of the department members, selection should be conducted through consultation with the members and based on a majority vote. Since the department head serves as the representative of the department members, selection should be conducted through consultation with the members and based on a majority vote. Selected or nominated candidates for the position of department head must participate in relevant training programs (including self-management, communication management, team building, change management, systems thinking and problem solving, negotiation skills, stakeholder engagement and advocacy, conflict of interest management, human resource management, and planning) during the transition period and no later than six months after appointment. Selected or nominated candidates for the position of department head must participate in relevant training programs (including self-management, communication management, team building, change management, systems thinking and problem solving, negotiation skills, stakeholder engagement and advocacy, conflict of interest management, human resource management, and planning) during the transition period and no later than six months after appointment. Two Delphi rounds were conducted with 27 experts and achieved consensus (≥ 75% agreement, IQR ≤ 2) on the relative importance of each criterion. Using normalized scores (1–10 scale), the final 16 criteria were prioritized as shown in Table 3. Table 3Final 16 criteria for selection of educational department heads (EDHs), prioritized and weighted scoresDomainCriterionWeight (Mean ± SD)Personality competencies1. Age appropriateness7.8 ± 1.12. Consistent personal commitment and social responsibility9.2 ± 0.63. Demonstrated ability for collaboration and teamwork8.8 ± 0.7Organizational and environmental knowledge4. Minimum of 3 years of university work experience8.6 ± 0.95. Administrative and employment affiliation with the department or faculty8.4 ± 0.8Professionalism6. Absence of conflict of interest (personal, professional, and social)9.0 ± 0.57. Ethical conduct (personal, professional, and social)9.1 ± 0.48. Professional independence8.7 ± 0.6Education and expertise9. Relevant academic qualifications8.9 ± 0.610. Academic rank8.5 ± 0.811. Educational credibility and reputation8.4 ± 0.712. Research and technological credibility8.3 ± 0.7Organizational role and activity13. Holding one or more influential positions within the university7.9 ± 1.014. Holding influential positions outside the university7.7 ± 1.115. Full-time and active presence in the educational department8.3 ± 0.816. Availability of a clear management plan for the term of office8.5 ± 0.7 Final 16 criteria for selection of educational department heads (EDHs), prioritized and weighted scores Selection process flowchart is provided in Additional File 3. Discussion In this study we aimed to develop and validate a framework for selecting EDHs and HSSDs in Iranian medical universities. A multi-method qualitative approach of scoping review, document review, semi-structured interviews, FGD, brainstorming, expert panels, and the Delphi technique was used to identify key competencies, examine current appointment practices, and build consensus on proposed criteria. As a result, 16 final selection criteria were prioritized and grouped into five domains: personal and character competencies, organizational and environmental knowledge, professionalism, educational background and expertise, and organizational role and engagement. The outputs include a validated checklist and a seven-step selection process for EDHs, and offer a structured and competency-based model aligned with institutional priorities. This framework addresses the need for transparency and fairness in academic leadership appointments, which has long been a policy concern in Iranian higher education. Faculty deans, as integral members of the university system, play a critical role in institutional advancement [23]. Previous studies emphasize the importance of enhancing efficiency, strengthening leadership, reducing financial costs, and improving teaching and managerial skills in academic administrators [16, 22, 24]. Our findings are consistent with these studies in emphasizing leadership and managerial competences as major element for effective medical school deanship. However, this study extends the literature by embedding these general qualities within a structured and transparent selection framework that has measurable criteria rather than relying on informal or seniority-based criteria. The selection of EDHs and medical faculty deans has often drawn the attention of policymakers because of its implications for academic governance and broader social systems [25, 26]. Having a transparent set of appointment criteria is essential for ensuring credibility and reducing political influence. In line with previous studies which emphasize the importance of structured human resource management in academic leadership positions, our findings reinforces human resource management as a core competency, including clear job descriptions, succession planning, and accountability mechanisms. However, this study differs the literature by arguing that such competencies must be demonstrated prior to appointment, rather than assuming they can develop during tenure. This difference in findings indicate development of an evidence-based leadership selection, which can fill the gap of the current selection process and make it with considering prior competency assessment. In addition, while research by Buckley et al. [15] and Palmer et al. [22]., has viewed organizational culture as fundamental to managerial success, our findings integrate these behavioral competencies as core evaluative criteria within the selection framework. By considering competencies such as trust-based culture, participatory decision-making, and effective communication, as non-negotiable prerequisites for leadership selection, the current study emphasize on these as formal requirements for strengthening the selection process. Davenport et al. [27] argue that without targeted leadership training, assigning faculty to managerial positions is counterproductive. Our findings support this view and operationalize it through a policy recommendation: mandatory leadership development programs for appointed heads within six months of selection, covering domains such as systems thinking, negotiation, and conflict management. This study adds to what others have found by linking fair, competency-based selection to university policies and giving a practical guide for training academic leaders. Change management emerged as another critical leadership competency in our study. Its importance has been noted in prior studies, such as Kyamanywa [20] but these studies often describe it generally rather than linking it to formal selection processes. Our research advances the discourse by integrating change management capabilities into formal selection criteria for academic leaders. In a rapidly evolving academic environment shaped by technological advances, policy shifts, and resource constraints, leaders must possess adaptive and strategic thinking skills. Unlike studies situated in low-resource contexts [28], which focus on coping with the shortage of resources, this study addresses change management within highly competitive systems where innovation and rapid adaptation are essential. By considering change management as a major and assessable requirement for an academic leader, this study provides new insights for selection process of leaders who can effectively manage complex and dynamic academic setting. The inclusion of professionalism and ethics as top-weighted criteria aligns with Jadhav’s findings [18] and Mohammadi et al. [28], reinforcing the global trend toward ethical governance. Our contribution lies in translating these values into actionable selection standards such as documented absence of conflicts of interest and adherence to ethical norms within a formalized checklist. Previous research has described a wide range of leadership competencies, including cultural, political, educational, and technological dimensions [29–31]. However, the present study goes further by synthesizing these elements into a consensus-driven, context-sensitive model and validating it through a rigorous Delphi process. The outcome is not merely descriptive but provides a standardized, scalable tool for academic leadership selection. The findings suggest that replacing traditional, informal selection processes with structured, transparent models can increase candidate motivation, improve organizational performance, and enhance accountability. Compared to earlier studies [8, 20, 24], this research offers greater depth by combining international evidence with local insights and by linking identified competencies to a formalized selection process and evaluation mechanism. Strengths and limitations of the study To the best of our knowledge, this is the first comprehensive and multi-method study in Iran to develop and validate a framework for selecting EDHs and HSSDs. Other academic institutions can use this framework for their leadership selection. The study has some limitations. First, it was conducted in Iranian medical universities, which may limit generalizability to international higher education systems. While expert consensus strengthened the internal validity of our framework, some criteria reflect priorities which are specific for the Iranian context. Finally, the framework’s effectiveness in improving leadership performance should be examined in practice, so there is a need for future implementation studies [32]. Conclusion Theoretical implications The findings of this study underscore the necessity of moving beyond traditional, informal approaches to appointing medical school managers by adopting a structured, evidence-informed framework. This research contributes theoretically by highlighting that effective leadership in health sciences education cannot rely solely on academic or scientific credentials. Instead, it must incorporate a balanced set of managerial and behavioral competencies, including leadership, human resource development, organizational behavior, change management, and professionalism. By identifying 16 key criteria across five core domains, the study enriches the theoretical understanding of academic leadership and bridges the gap between formal qualifications and behavioral competencies, an area previously underexplored in the literature. This integration offers a more comprehensive conceptualization of leadership effectiveness within medical universities. Managerial or policy implications From a managerial and policy perspective, the model presented here offers a pragmatic and unambiguous framework for selecting EDHs and HSSDs. The integration of such competencies into the hiring process has the potential to enhance the alignment between managerial positions and institutional goals, encourage ethical and responsible leadership, and increase the overall performance of academic health institutions. The seven-step selection process and empirically tested checklist developed through this research can serve as a guiding tool for university leaders and policymakers, enhancing merit-based appointment as well as consistent, competency-based decision-making in leadership recruitment and development. Ideas for future research A further investigation is necessary to determine the functionality of the proposed competency-based selection framework under various institutional and policy settings, and its impact on the governance quality, performance, and sustainability of leadership in academic health systems. In contemplating future prospects, a comprehensive evaluation of the implementation’s outcomes will elucidate the correlation between the structured undertaking and enhanced transparency, organizational efficacy, and sustained leadership stability. The execution of such studies would provide essential evidence regarding the framework and clarify the conceptual and practical dimensions of leadership and its evolution in health professional education on a global scale. Supplementary Information Supplementary Material 1. Supplementary Material 2. Supplementary Material 3. Acknowledgements We would like to express our sincere gratitude to all those who supported this research. We extend our deepest appreciation to Prof. Mohammad Taghi Joghataei and Prof. Gholamreza Hassanzadeh for their valuable insights in advancing this study. Abbreviations Educational Department Heads Health Sciences School Deans Joanna Briggs Institute Focus Group Discussion Authors’ contributions Conceptualization: LD; Methodology: LD and MJ; Software: Not applicable; Validation: MS and AH; Formal Analysis: RR; Investigation: LD, AKh, NK, JS; Resources: MS and SA; Data Curation: SS Writing – Original Draft: LD, MJ, NK, and RR; Writing – Review & Editing: AKh, MS, AH, SS, JS, and SA; Visualization: not applicable; Supervision: LD and MJ; Project Administration: MS; Funding Acquisition: Not applicable. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Funding This study was financially supported by Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran and Academy of Medical Sciences of Islamic Republic of Iran Data availability All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article and its supplementary information files. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate This was approved by the ethical committee of Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran (approval number: IR.TBZMED.REC.1403.621) . Also, informed consent was obtained from all participants and they were confirmed for anonymity. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Contributor Information Leila Doshmangir, Email: Doshmangirl@tbzmed.ac.ir. Masoumeh Jorjani, Email: msjorjani@sbmu.ac.ir. Neda Kabiri, Email: ne.kabiry@gmail.com. Ramin Rezapour, Email: rezapour2012@yahoo.com. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1. Supplementary Material 2. Supplementary Material 3. Data Availability Statement All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article and its supplementary information files.