Novel Filter-Based Excitation Method for Pulse Compression in Ultrasonic Sensory Systems Authors: Álvaro Cortés, María Carmen Pérez-Rubio, Álvaro Hernández Published: 2025 ABSTRACT Location-based services (LBSs) and positioning systems have spread worldwide due to the emergence of Internet of Things (IoT) and other application domains that require real-time estimation of the position of a person, tag, or asset in general in order to provide users with services and apps with added value. Whereas Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSSs) are well-established solutions outdoors, positioning is still an open challenge indoors, where different sensory technologies may be considered for that purpose, such as radio frequency, infrared, or ultrasounds, among others. With regard to ultrasonic systems, previous works have already developed indoor positioning systems capable of achieving accuracies in the range of centimeters but limited to a few square meters of coverage and severely affected by the Doppler effect coming from moving targets, which significantly degrades the overall positioning performance. Furthermore, the actual bandwidth available in commercial transducers often constrains the ultrasonic transmission, thus reducing the position accuracy as well. In this context, this work proposes a novel excitation and processing method for an ultrasonic positioning system, which significantly improves the transmission capabilities between an emitter and a receiver. The proposal employs a superheterodyne approach, enabling simultaneous transmission and reception of signals across multiple channels. It also adapts the bandwidths and central frequencies of the transmitted signals to the specific bandwidth characteristics of available transducers, thus optimizing the system performance. Binary spread spectrum sequences are utilized within a multicarrier modulation framework to ensure robust signal transmission. The ultrasonic signals received are then processed using filter banks and matched filtering techniques to determine the Time Differences of Arrival (TDoA) for every transmission, which are subsequently used to estimate the target position. The proposal has been modeled and successfully validated using a digital twin. Furthermore, experimental tests on the prototype have also been conducted to evaluate the system’s performance in real scenarios, comparing it against classical approaches in terms of ranging distance, signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), or multipath effects. Experimental validation demonstrates that the proposed narrowband scheme reliably operates at distances up to 40 m, compared to the 34 m limit of conventional wideband approaches. Ranging errors remain below 3 cm at 40 m, whereas the wideband scheme exhibits errors exceeding 8 cm. Furthermore, simulation results show that the narrowband scheme maintains stable operation at SNR as low as −32 dB, whereas the wideband one only achieves up to −17 dB, highlighting the significant performance advantages of the proposed approach in both experimental and simulated scenarios. 1. Introduction The evolution experienced over the past few decades in localization systems has been remarkable, transforming multiple aspects of our daily lives. From smartphone navigation apps [1] and autonomous driving [2] to the Internet of Things (IoT), augmented reality, healthcare monitoring, logistic or emergency response, and the ability to determine the exact position of objects, people, and devices is vital for operational efficiency, safety, and convenience. These ongoing advances in localization technology are driven by the growing demands of an increasingly interconnected and dynamic world [3]. The development of Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSSs), such as GPS (Global Positioning System) [4] and Galileo, has enhanced outdoor positioning capabilities, revolutionizing our ability to navigate and determine locations in open environments. However, these technologies face significant limitations indoors, where satellite signals are often obstructed or heavily attenuated by physical structures. Consequently, indoor localization technologies have evolved to address these challenges using different types of technologies, each with unique advantages and drawbacks [5,6]. Radiofrequency (RF)-based methods, such as Bluetooth [7] or Wi-Fi [8], are broadly used since smartphones are widely available today, and most buildings are Wi-Fi-enabled or can be easily provided with BLE (Bluetooth Low Energy) tags. Although effective in certain situations, these methods often deal with challenges in terms of precision, coverage, high dependence on the distribution of access points, or fluctuation of Received Signal Strength Indicators (RSSIs) [9]. Optical technologies, including image recognition and infrared (IR) light [10], offer accurate localization, but can be affected by lighting conditions, large computational load, or limitations regarding privacy issues in the case of cameras. Inertial Navigation Systems (INSs) [11] provide relative positioning with low-cost sensors; however, the noise is cumulative, so the estimated position will drift after a short time. Therefore, they are normally used in combination with other technologies [12]. Acoustic technology, which is the focus of this work, provides a low-cost solution with centimeter-level precision [13] over short distances [14,15]. This is due to the low propagation speed and high attenuation of sound through the air. It is usually preferred for the ultrasonic range to avoid audible discomfort. Distance estimation with acoustic or ultrasonic signals [16] fundamentally depends on the accurate extraction of Time-of-Arrival (ToA) [17] when transmitter-receiver synchronization is available, or Time-Difference-of-Arrival (TDoA) otherwise. In indoor positioning systems, pulse compression, and matched filtering are widely adopted to enhance detection robustness under noise and multipath conditions, by maximizing the correlation between the received signal and a predefined reference waveform. Spread spectrum sequences such as Zadoff-Chu [18], LS codes [19], and Kasami codes [20] are commonly employed due to their suitable autocorrelation and cross-correlation characteristics. Thus, the precise estimation of ToA or TDoA is critical, as it directly determines the accuracy of the subsequent trilateration phase, where spatial coordinates are estimated from the derived propagation times. 1.1. Related Works In recent years, research on Acoustic Local Positioning Systems (ALPSs) has mainly focused on wideband signals and advanced coding schemes to improve the accuracy in the determination of ToAs or TDoAs and the robustness against noise and multipath propagation, as shown in [21,22,23]. In addition, different modulation and encoding techniques based on Zadoff-Chu codes [24], Kasami sequences [25], and chirp signals have been evaluated to improve positioning performance under realistic conditions [26,27]. Experimental platforms and simulation tools have also been developed to facilitate the validation and adjustment of these systems [28]. However, wideband approaches usually require a processing with a bandwidth that exceeds the one available in commercial ultrasonic transducers. This aspect often degrades the encoding properties and limits the reachable ranging distances [29], thus affecting the resulting performance, together with other factors such as the strong attenuation and high directivity of the transducers [30]. Doppler and multipath effects are also key aspects, since they deteriorate the correlation functions from most sequences [31], thus degrading the resulting performance. In contrast to this dominant trend, this work proposes a narrowband-oriented architecture that applies spread-spectrum techniques to concentrate the useful energy inside the existing bandwidth and reduce the impact of noise and interference outside it, while still maintaining high accuracy and availability comparable to other previous wideband systems. Complementary to these developments, recent research on MIMO (Multiple-Input Multiple-Output) ultrasonic systems has shown promising results for high-resolution imaging and indoor localization, including both active and device-free approaches [32,33,34]. By exploiting multiple transmitters and receivers, MIMO architectures can generate extended virtual apertures and improve spatial diversity, thereby enhancing localization accuracy and robustness against multipath propagation. Nevertheless, such systems still face significant challenges, including the limited bandwidth of practical ultrasonic transducers, reduced signal-to-noise ratio in weak or reverberant conditions, and degradation under target motion. The narrowband excitation architecture proposed in this work can help mitigate these limitations by concentrating the transmitted energy within a reduced frequency band while preserving favorable correlation properties. In addition to the waveform design and system architecture aspects discussed above, medium access is also a critical consideration in acoustic positioning systems. Depending on the application requirements and system topology, various multiple-access techniques, such as Time Division Multiplexing (TDM) [35], Frequency Division Multiplexing (FDM) [36], and Code Division Multiplexing (CDM) [37], have been employed to enable concurrent transmissions while minimizing interference. These strategies determine how multiple emitters share the available acoustic resources and directly influence system scalability and positioning accuracy. For instance, in [38], a CDMA-based acoustic local positioning system is proposed, demonstrating robust performance in mitigating multipath propagation effects through the use of a Matching Pursuit algorithm. On the other hand, in [36], FDM and TDM techniques are integrated to improve the positioning update rate and reduce errors in acoustic indoor localization of moving targets. In terms of modulation, schemes, such as Binary Phase Shift Keying (BPSK) or Quadrature Phase Shift Keying (QPSK), are often employed [29,39]. BPSK is appreciated for its simplicity and robustness in noisy environments, whereas QPSK allows higher data rates by encoding more bits per symbol, albeit at the cost of increased noise susceptibility. The choice of the modulation scheme affects the balance between the data rate, the reliability, and the system complexity in indoor localization systems. 1.2. Novelty and Contributions In this context, this work defines a novel multi-carrier modulation method for ultrasonic-based localization systems [40] dealing with narrowband spectrum. For that purpose, the signal processing for ultrasonic transmitters and receivers is defined and modeled. The proposed modulation scheme allows them to efficiently and adaptively fit the ultrasonic transmissions into the practical bandwidth available in commercial transducers [41], rendering it highly versatile and suitable for a variety of applications. By focusing the ultrasonic signals on a narrowband range, this proposal offers significant advantages in terms of the estimation of TDoAs, improving precision, reliability, and robustness, while addressing challenges associated with interference in complex environments. The main challenges addressed by this proposal are the noise distributed across the entire spectrum in conventional modulation schemes, the lack of adaptation of the transmitted signals to the frequency response of commercial transducers, resulting in poor signal quality, and the subsequent issues in processing the frequency spectrum, particularly regarding phase detection, where the coded information to be retrieved is embedded. Summing it up, the main contributions of the proposed method are as follows:A novel modulation scheme consisting of multiple subcarriers and a division of the available bandwidth into several subchannels has been defined for ultrasonic systems allowing multiple channel generation.The proposed modulation provides a significant frequency flexibility and adaptability, which facilitates its use and integration with different commercial transmitters and receivers that typically have a narrow frequency response.The proposed modulation is defined together with encoding techniques for each frequency subchannel, which supports the implementation of matched filtering with high robustness against noise and over long ranges.The proposed modulation scheme has been successfully validated in experimental tests, providing improvements in terms of range and accuracy when compared with other previous approaches, common in the literature. A novel modulation scheme consisting of multiple subcarriers and a division of the available bandwidth into several subchannels has been defined for ultrasonic systems allowing multiple channel generation. A novel modulation scheme consisting of multiple subcarriers and a division of the available bandwidth into several subchannels has been defined for ultrasonic systems allowing multiple channel generation. The proposed modulation provides a significant frequency flexibility and adaptability, which facilitates its use and integration with different commercial transmitters and receivers that typically have a narrow frequency response. The proposed modulation provides a significant frequency flexibility and adaptability, which facilitates its use and integration with different commercial transmitters and receivers that typically have a narrow frequency response. The proposed modulation is defined together with encoding techniques for each frequency subchannel, which supports the implementation of matched filtering with high robustness against noise and over long ranges. The proposed modulation is defined together with encoding techniques for each frequency subchannel, which supports the implementation of matched filtering with high robustness against noise and over long ranges. The proposed modulation scheme has been successfully validated in experimental tests, providing improvements in terms of range and accuracy when compared with other previous approaches, common in the literature. The proposed modulation scheme has been successfully validated in experimental tests, providing improvements in terms of range and accuracy when compared with other previous approaches, common in the literature. The rest of the manuscript is organized as follows: Section 2 describes the signal processing proposed for the ultrasonic transmitter; similarly, Section 3 details the signal processing associated with the ultrasonic receiver; Section 4 shows some experimental results; and, finally, conclusions are discussed in Section 5. 2. Transmitter Architecture The internal architecture of the transmitter has been designed considering the need to simultaneously use multiple ultrasonic transducers that are often involved in sensory systems, such as in positioning systems. A transmission scheme has been defined to generate the signal to be transmitted by every ultrasonic transducer k, 0≤k≤K−1, with K≥3 in the particular case of localization purposes. The proposed design is flexible enough to allow varying the number of transmitters or to facilitate the configuration of the system if necessary. Figure 1a shows the general block diagram of the architecture proposed for the transmitter. It starts with the selection of an identification (ID) binary code Ck for every transmitter k that modulates a baseband complex carrier. The resulting baseband signal is shifted in frequency by means of an intermediate-frequency mixer, and then, it is processed by the intermediate-frequency filter, thus reducing noise and shaping the desired bandwidth. Finally, this intermediate-frequency signal is shifted again to the final transmission frequency, suitable for the ultrasonic transmission channel. A final positioning system will require a unique identification (ID) of the signal transmitted by every ultrasonic transducer k. This requirement implies a module that stores the different ID codes for every transducer. These ID codes Ck should be selected due to their suitable correlation properties, with high auto-correlation functions and low cross-correlation functions with other codes from the same family. In this proposal, 255-bit Kasami sequences have been used, which meet the above-mentioned characteristics. They make it possible to determine the TDoA for every transmitter k at the receiver, even if their emissions overlap in the transmission channel. 2.1. Baseband Modulator The baseband modulator applies the ID binary code Ck to modulate a complex carrier in BPSK (Binary Phase Shift Keying) at a frequency fb. This element is designed to be highly configurable and flexible, allowing the bandwidth of the resulting modulated signal xbk(t) for transmitter k to match the bandwidth available in the ultrasonic transducer. This module multiplies the carrier by a variant phasor ϕCk(t) that depends on the bits from the code Ck for the k-th emitter, as shown in (1). It is worth mentioning that the modulated signal xbk(t) concentrates its energy within the desired bandwidth, instead of being symmetrically distributed across the frequency spectrum. This behavior corresponds to a Single Sideband (SSB) modulation, which suppresses one of the spectral sidebands. As a result, the transmitted signal fits better the frequency response of the ultrasonic transducer, avoiding spectral replicas outside its useful bandwidth and improving the transmission efficiency.(1)xbk(t)=cos(2π·fb·t+ϕCk(t))+j·sin(2π·fb·t+ϕCk(t))=ej·(2π·fb·t+ϕCk(t)) Figure 1b shows that the signal energy is placed asymmetrically in the spectrum, centered at fb=1 kHz in this case. For clarity’s sake, the initial phase of the carrier is assumed to be zero. Although complex signal processing demands more computational resources, it plays a crucial role due to the frequency-domain behavior of the transmitted spectrum. This method helps prevent the dispersion of spectral components when combining multiple tones, eliminating the need for intermediate filtering stages in the transmitter and, thus, reducing the computational load that would be required when using real-valued signals. 2.2. Intermediate-Frequency Mixer The intermediate-frequency mixer implements the frequency shifting of the input modulated signal xbk(t), centered at fb, to the intermediate frequency fi=6 kHz, thus providing the signal xik(t), without modifying the rest of the spectral characteristics of the input signal (bandwidth, power or modulation scheme). The frequency shifting is carried out by multiplying in the time domain the input xbk(t) with an internal complex tone at the desired frequency, in this case fi0=5 kHz. The system works in the first Nyquist window with a positive tone to increase the intermediate frequency of the signals according to (2), thus obtaining the intermediate-frequency signal xik(t). Note that fi=fb+fi0=6 kHz.(2)xik(t)=xbk(t)·ej·2π·fi0·t=ej·(2π·fb·t+ϕCk(t))·ej·2π·fi0·t where(3)xik(t)=ej·2π·fb·t+j·2π·fi0·t+j·ϕCk(t)=ej·2π·(fb+fi0)·t+j·ϕCk(t)=ej·(2π·fi·t+ϕCk(t)) Figure 1b shows the resulting intermediate-frequency signal xik(t) in the frequency domain. It can be observed that the module maintains the bandwidth signal and how the central frequency is shifted from fb to fi. 2.3. Spectral Filter This filter and its corresponding coefficients have been selected to discard information outside the selected bandwidth. This selection allows the spectral efficiency of the system to be increased by eliminating irrelevant information and concentrating the energy to be transmitted in the desired bandwidth. The ideal response Hi(f) of the filter is shown in (4) and (5). It is a bandpass filter centered at fi, whose bandwidth corresponds to that of the baseband signal xbk(t).(4)Hi(f)=1⟶∀5kHz⩽f⩽7kHz(5)Hi(f)=0⟶∀f<5kHz|7kHz