Simulation-Based Preparation for the American Board of Emergency Medicine Certifying Exam: A Comprehensive Curriculum for Residents Authors: Kimberly Sokol, Alaa Aldalati, Michelle Hughes, Stephanie Stapleton, Charles Lei Published: 2025 ABSTRACT Audience and type of curriculumThis curriculum is designed for junior and senior emergency medicine (EM) residents who are preparing for the new American Board of Emergency Medicine (ABEM) Certifying Exam.Length of curriculumThis curriculum can be completed over the course of an EM residency program to prepare junior residents for the individual content areas encountered on the new Certifying Exam. Alternatively, it can be implemented during a single session to simulate the actual exam for senior residents.IntroductionWith ABEM transitioning to a new format for its Certifying Exam, there is a critical need for targeted preparatory materials that reflect these changes.Educational GoalsThe goal of this curriculum is to equip residents with the knowledge and skills needed to succeed on the ABEM Certifying Exam. It includes a comprehensive set of case types expected to appear on the Certifying Exam, with a focus on assessing competencies not currently evaluated by the existing written Qualifying Exam and retiring Oral Exam. The curriculum is designed to be delivered to current residents in a single-day exam format to closely replicate the structure and experience of the new Certifying Exam.Educational MethodsThe educational strategy used in this curriculum consists of a set of eight simulation scenarios written in an Observed Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) format. Each scenario targets a distinct area of the recently introduced ABEM Certifying Exam. These content areas include clinical decision-making, prioritization, reassessment, difficult conversations, managing conflict, ultrasound, procedural skills, and patient-centered communications. The OSCE structure intentionally reflects that of the ABEM Certifying Exam to enhance realism, ensure consistency, and maintain educational relevance.Research MethodsThis eight-case simulation curriculum focuses on core EM competencies, including decision-making, communication, conflict resolution, prioritization, procedural skills, and ultrasound. Initially developed by experts in simulation and medical education, each case was subsequently refined through a structured peer review process. This process involved written evaluations by external reviewers followed by pilot testing across multiple EM residency programs and at the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine Annual Meeting. Faculty facilitators and resident learners provided targeted feedback using the Simulation Scenario Evaluation Tool1 and modified usability surveys, assessing factors such as case realism, scenario flow, clarity of learning objectives, alignment of assessment criteria, and practical feasibility for implementation.ResultsPilot testing across multiple institutions and at a national academic meeting demonstrated the curriculum’s strong educational value, clarity, and usability. Feedback from both facilitators and residents was overwhelmingly positive, highlighting the simulation scenarios’ realism, clinical relevance, and effectiveness in exam preparation.DiscussionThis comprehensive simulation-based curriculum, designed to align with the ABEM Certifying Exam, proved to be feasible, effective, and well-received by both learners and facilitators. Key insights from its implementation emphasized the importance of thorough faculty preparation, flexibility in adapting to available resources, and the use of structured debriefing to support learning. Thoughtfully designed simulation experiences can significantly enhance EM resident preparedness for high-stakes assessments.TopicsCertifying Exam, simulation, board certification, American Board of Emergency Medicine, residency. USER GUIDE List of Resources: Abstract1 User Guide3 Didactics and Hands on Curriculum Chart7 Overview of the American Board of Emergency Medicine Certifying Exam15 Learner Audience: This curriculum is designed for interns and junior and senior residents in preparation for the ABEM Certifying Exam. Length of Curriculum: This curriculum can be delivered longitudinally over the course of an emergency medicine (EM) residency to prepare junior residents for the specific content areas encountered on the new American Board of Emergency Medicine (ABEM) Certifying Exam. Alternatively, it can be administered during a single session to simulate the full exam for senior residents. Topics: Certifying Exam, simulation, board certification, American Board of Emergency Medicine, residency. Objectives: Upon completion of the curriculum, learners should be able to: List the eight content categories of the ABEM Certifying Exam and describe the overall exam structure List the eight content categories of the ABEM Certifying Exam and describe the overall exam structure Summarize the key clinical concepts and examination strategies for each of the eight content categories of the ABEM Certifying Exam Summarize the key clinical concepts and examination strategies for each of the eight content categories of the ABEM Certifying Exam Apply clinical decision-making, ultrasound, and procedural skills by successfully completing all eight simulation scenarios Apply clinical decision-making, ultrasound, and procedural skills by successfully completing all eight simulation scenarios Demonstrate clear, structured, and empathetic communication with patients, family members, and team members during simulated encounters Demonstrate clear, structured, and empathetic communication with patients, family members, and team members during simulated encounters Report increased confidence in and readiness for the ABEM Certifying Exam. Report increased confidence in and readiness for the ABEM Certifying Exam. Brief introduction ABEM recently announced that it will transition to a new format for its oral certification exam. This shift underscores the need for a comprehensive, simulation-based curriculum to prepare EM residents for board certification. This eight-case curriculum also focuses on a wide variety of core EM competencies critical to EM residency training,2 including clinical decision-making, task switching, delivering difficult information, conflict resolution, procedural skills, and ultrasound. Problem identification, general and targeted needs assessment In 2026, ABEM will retire its Oral Exam and replace it with the Certifying Exam as part of the testing required for EM physicians to become board-certified.3 While ABEM has provided sample case summaries and videos demonstrating each of the eight content areas of the exam on its webpage,4 to our knowledge there are no other resources that specifically exist to aid in the preparation for the Certifying Exam. To adequately prepare their trainees for the Certifying Exam, EM residency programs would benefit from a comprehensive simulation-based curriculum that includes an overview of the exam structure, a sample case for each content area, scripts for examiners and standardized participants (SPs), scoring rubrics, debriefing guides, and a list of necessary personnel and equipment. We selected simulation as the primary educational modality for the curriculum based on its demonstrated effectiveness in EM residency training and its alignment with the goals of the ABEM Certifying Exam. High-fidelity simulation enables deliberate practice of both cognitive and procedural skills, which is essential for preparing residents for high-stakes assessments like the ABEM Certifying Exam.5 Additionally, simulation offers a safe, controlled environment where learners can engage in complex, high-acuity scenarios without risk to patients, while receiving structured feedback to guide improvement.6 A structured simulation-based curriculum provides flexibility, allowing for both longitudinal skill development in junior residents and high-fidelity mock exam preparation for senior residents, while mirroring the format and expectations of the ABEM Certifying Exam. This curriculum was developed using a structured, expert-driven approach to ensure educational quality, clinical relevance, and alignment with EM residency training objectives. The final curriculum includes eight simulation cases, each focused on a distinct module corresponding to the new ABEM Certifying Exam. Each case was designed by a team of faculty experts in EM and simulation-based medical education. Those experts were selected based on years of simulation teaching across diverse institutions and active engagement in national simulation collaboratives, including the CORD Simulation Community of Practice. The case development process incorporated principles of instructional design and evidence-based simulation methodology to maximize learner engagement and skill acquisition. To ensure accuracy, realism, and educational value, each case underwent independent peer review by three or four additional experts. Reviewers applied the Simulation Scenario Evaluation Tool (SSET)1 to systematically assess clinical fidelity, scenario flow, and alignment with learning objectives. Revisions were made through an iterative process based on reviewer feedback to enhance clarity, feasibility, and educational impact. Following expert review, the cases were pilot-tested across multiple academic institutions, encompassing a variety of EM residency programs with diverse training environments. Faculty facilitators and resident learners at each site engaged with the simulation scenarios and provided structured feedback via the SSET and a modified usability survey, evaluating case realism, implementation logistics, and learner experience. In addition to institutional pilots, the curriculum was also implemented and evaluated at the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine Annual Meeting in May 2025 (Philadelphia, PA). This broader testing environment allowed for comprehensive feedback on scenario clarity, usability, and relevance to exam preparation. Feedback from these multi-institutional and national pilots informed further revisions to enhance the curriculum’s adaptability, scalability, and readiness for widespread implementation. Goals of the curriculum The goal of this curriculum is to provide a comprehensive, simulation-based case collection designed to prepare EM residents for the new ABEM Certifying Exam. It includes an overview of exam structure, sample cases representing each content area, examiner and standardized patient (SP) scripts, scoring rubrics, debriefing guides, and additional resources to promote consistent, high-quality training. This curriculum serves as a centralized, ready-to-implement resource for EM residency programs, offering peer-reviewed cases that closely replicate the anticipated exam format and reducing the need for programs to develop their own materials. Objectives of the curriculum Upon completion of the curriculum, learners should be able to: List the eight content categories of the ABEM Certifying Exam and describe the overall exam structure List the eight content categories of the ABEM Certifying Exam and describe the overall exam structure summarize the key clinical concepts and examination strategies for each of the eight content categories of the ABEM Certifying Exam summarize the key clinical concepts and examination strategies for each of the eight content categories of the ABEM Certifying Exam apply clinical decision-making, ultrasound, and procedural skills by successfully completing all eight simulation scenarios apply clinical decision-making, ultrasound, and procedural skills by successfully completing all eight simulation scenarios demonstrate clear, structured, and empathetic communication with patients, family members, and team members during simulated encounters demonstrate clear, structured, and empathetic communication with patients, family members, and team members during simulated encounters report increased confidence in and readiness for the ABEM Certifying Exam. report increased confidence in and readiness for the ABEM Certifying Exam. Educational Strategies All modules are simulation based. Please see the curriculum chart for more details. Associated Content Appendix A: Curriculum Chart Appendix A: Curriculum Chart Appendix B: Overview of the American Board of Emergency Medicine Certifying Exam Appendix B: Overview of the American Board of Emergency Medicine Certifying Exam Results and tips for successful implementation This curriculum is designed to be delivered as a simulation of the ABEM Certifying Exam, with each curriculum module representing a case type, thus providing residents with a realistic testing experience. Alternatively, individual cases can be implemented to provide targeted practice of specific exam domains based on learner needs. For the most authentic experience, we recommend administering the curriculum in a one-on-one format, allowing learners to engage fully in the simulation and receive personalized, structured feedback. In certain educational contexts, small-group sessions or the use of a senior resident as a mock facilitator can also be effective, particularly for reinforcing group learning or providing insight into examiner perspectives. To maximize engagement and realism, we recommend conducting the simulations in a setting that closely resembles a typical emergency department (ED) environment. Whenever possible, SPs should be incorporated to portray patient and family member roles, with flexibility to adapt character demographics as needed. When SPs are not available, facilitators can assume character roles, or the cases can be delivered in an oral board format with learners verbalizing their clinical reasoning and planned actions. Facilitators should be well-versed with both the individual case objectives and the overall structure of the ABEM Certifying Exam (Appendix A) to ensure consistent and effective delivery. Facilitators and SPs should adhere to case scripts to provide learners with a standardized and equitable experience. For cases involving technical skills (eg, ultrasound, procedures), we recommend incorporating appropriate equipment, including functional ultrasound machines and commercially available task trainers, to enhance realism and allow for accurate assessment of procedural competence. In resource-limited settings, homemade procedural models or oral board-style assessments focused on verbalization of procedural steps can serve as effective alternatives. In alignment with the ABEM Certifying Exam structure, Clinical Care cases (eg, Clinical Decision-Making, Prioritization) should be allocated 15 minutes, while Communication and Procedural cases (eg, Reassessment, Difficult Conversations, Managing Conflict, Ultrasound, Procedures, Patient-Centered Communications) should be allotted 10 minutes. Each case includes a debriefing guide to support facilitators in conducting structured, reflective debriefing sessions, ensuring educational objectives are reinforced following each scenario. We received feedback on the overarching curriculum from four reviewers (Table 1), who appreciated the work but requested a less dense chart. A total of 91 people provided feedback on the eight cases (Table 2); 22 were facilitators and 69 were learners. Facilitator feedback was consistently positive across all eight simulation cases (Table 3), with high ratings for the clarity of learning objectives, scenario flow, material integration, ease of use, and overall quality. Facilitators reported confidence in the cases and expressed interest in using them for ABEM Certifying Exam preparation. Resident evaluations reflected these positive findings, with learners rating the cases highly for quality, clarity, and educational value. Residents specifically emphasized the realism of the scenarios and their applicability to clinical decision-making, communication, and procedural skills. Detailed feedback data for each scenario can be found within the individual case materials. Evaluation and Feedback Based on multi-institutional pilot-testing and comprehensive feedback from facilitators and learners, several targeted revisions were made to improve the clarity, consistency, and usability of the curriculum. Examiner scripts were standardized to ensure consistent delivery of prompts and interactions across learners. Similarly, SP scripts were expanded to include detailed, scenario-specific prompts designed to elicit the intended learner responses and support reliable assessment. Critical action checklists were revised to include more specific, observable behaviors and clearer criteria for satisfactory performance while accommodating variations in clinical practice. To enhance the educational value of the simulation experience, debriefing guides were revised for each case to include structured frameworks and suggested discussion points aligned with learning objectives. Additional guidance was provided for setting up the simulation environment, allowing for flexibility based on institutional resources. Collectively, these changes ensure that the curriculum supports a standardized yet adaptable experience that is both educationally rigorous and practical for diverse EM residency training settings.