Managing Conflict Case: The Difficult Consultant Authors: Amrita Vempati, Suzanne Bentley, Anita Rohra, Daniela Ortiz, David Fernandez, Shagun Berry, Colleen Donovan, Nicole Novotny, Stephanie Cohen, Stephanie Stapleton, Tiffany Moadel Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AudienceThis communication case is intended for emergency medicine (EM) resident physicians and junior faculty preparing for the ABEM Certifying Exam.IntroductionConflict management is a common and significant challenge in the emergency department (ED), with potential negative impact on both physicians and patients. At the individual level, hospital-based conflicts can lead to emotional stress, impaired concentration, decreased trust among providers, and feelings of dehumanization.1 For patients, conflicts between physicians can compromise the quality of care and contribute to delays in treatment.1 In the ED, conflict often arises between emergency physicians (EPs) and various stakeholders, including patients, family members, nursing staff, hospitalists, and consultants.2 Recognizing its importance, the American Board of Emergency Medicine (ABEM) has identified conflict management as a core competency for emergency medicine residents and has incorporated it into the oral certification examination.3 This oral examination case was developed to help train EM residents in managing conflict—specifically between an emergency physician and a consultant—in a structured environment.Educational ObjectivesBy the end of the session, the learner should be able to: 1) review format and have become familiar with an ABEM Certifying Exam conflict management communication case, 2) demonstrate the ability to initiate the consultation call, establish rapport, and present a concise, evidence-based summary of the patient’s STEMI findings, 3) recognize concerns raised by the cardiologist and respond with an empathetic acknowledgment (eg, validating workload, uncertainty, or resource constraints) to support a collaborative tone, 4) articulate differing viewpoint by referencing objective clinical data (eg, ST-segment elevations, ongoing chest pain, risk from delays) when conflict is encountered and justify why urgent catheterization lab activation is indicated, and 5) identify shared goals in optimizing patient care (reducing myocardial damage and preventing deterioration) and use these to negotiate a mutually acceptable plan.Educational MethodsThis is a standardized patient scenario in alignment with the expected Managing Conflict case format of the ABEM Certifying Exam. The benefits of this educational modality are that it allows for direct observation and assessment of a learner’s ability to communicate with a consultant and to observe the use of conflict resolution strategies.Research MethodsWe used an iterative case trialing process with a convenience sample of EM residents. Feedback from each site was used to make iterative changes to the case material. Facilitators completed a Simulation Scenario Evaluation Tool4 (SSET) survey during the written and alpha trials to evaluate the quality of key simulation elements. Facilitators and learners used modified usability surveys to evaluate cases during the beta trials. All surveys were completed anonymously using 5-point Likert scales and free text responses. All data were collected using Qualtrics (https://www.qualtrics.com) and analyzed using Excel (Microsoft, Redmond, WA). The Boston University Institutional Review Board reviewed the project and deemed it exempt.ResultsA total of 14 senior resident learners and 4 facilitators evaluated the case. The SSET data were largely positive; case objectives, key actions and materials were clear. The facilitators found the case was easy to use, and thought others would feel similarly. They felt confident using the case and would like to use this case for ABEM certifying exam practice. Over 90% of residents found both the written and verbal case materials to be clear. Ninety percent of residents reported that the experience was helpful practice for the ABEM certifying exam.DiscussionThe case was well-received by both learners and facilitators due to its realism and similarity to real-life encounters and appears to be a useful preparatory tool for the ABEM Certifying Exam’s Managing Conflict case because it allows learners to practice conflict resolution skills.TopicsConflict resolution, communication, ABEM Certifying Exam. USER GUIDE List of Resources: Abstract43 User Guide45 For Examiner Only47 Certifying Exam Assessment52 Stimulus54 Debriefing and Evaluation Pearls56 Learner Audience: This case is appropriate for interns, junior and senior residents, and junior EM Attendings preparing for ABEM Certifying Exams. Time Required for Implementation: Case: 10 minutes Debriefing: 10 minutes Recommended number of learners per instructor: Ideally one learner per instructor; however, another learner may be able to learn by observing the simulation and participating in the debriefing. Topics: Conflict management, communication, ABEM Certifying Exam Objectives: By the end of the session, the learner should be able to: Review format and become familiar with an ABEM Certifying Exam conflict management communication case. Review format and become familiar with an ABEM Certifying Exam conflict management communication case. Demonstrate the ability to initiate the consultation call, establish rapport, and present a concise, evidence-based summary of the patient’s STEMI findings. Demonstrate the ability to initiate the consultation call, establish rapport, and present a concise, evidence-based summary of the patient’s STEMI findings. Recognize concerns raised by the cardiologist and respond with an empathetic acknowledgment (eg, validating workload, uncertainty, or resource constraints) to support a collaborative tone. Recognize concerns raised by the cardiologist and respond with an empathetic acknowledgment (eg, validating workload, uncertainty, or resource constraints) to support a collaborative tone. Articulate differing viewpoint by referencing objective clinical data (eg, ST-segment elevations, ongoing chest pain, risk from delays) when conflict is encountered and justify why urgent catheterization lab activation is indicated. Articulate differing viewpoint by referencing objective clinical data (eg, ST-segment elevations, ongoing chest pain, risk from delays) when conflict is encountered and justify why urgent catheterization lab activation is indicated. Linked objectives, methods and results These objectives were selected to align with the ABEM Certifying Exam Managing Conflict case type. In this standardized patient case, the participant receives clinical information about a patient presenting with substernal chest pain, diaphoresis, and an EKG demonstrating clear ST-segment elevations in the anterior leads. The participant is instructed to speak with the on-call cardiologist to request emergent cardiac catheterization. At the start of the interaction, the learner is expected to open the consultation professionally, establish rapport, and deliver a concise, evidence-based presentation of the patient’s condition (Objective 2). During the scenario, the cardiologist responds with skepticism, questioning the participant’s ability to interpret the EKG, minimizing the patient’s symptoms, and suggesting alternative explanations for the patient’s condition. During this phase, the participant must recognize the consultant’s concerns, acknowledge them empathetically, and validate their viewpoint to maintain a collaborative tone (Objective 3). As the consultation progresses, the cardiologist challenges the need for emergent catheterization, asserting that the EKG changes are nonspecific or that the patient could be managed medically. At this point, the participant must clearly and respectfully articulate their differing clinical opinion by citing objective findings such as ongoing chest pain, dynamic ST-segment elevation, hemodynamic risk, and the dangers of delayed re-perfusion (Objective 4). To resolve the conflict, the participant must then identify shared goals such as preventing myocardial injury and ensuring patient safety and use those mutual priorities to negotiate a unified management approach (Objective 5). The scenario concludes when the participant successfully guides the cardiologist towards agreement on activating the catheterization lab or reaches a mutually accepted plan towards STEMI best practices. Recommended pre-reading for instructor Westafter L. Why Can’t We Be Friends – Conflict in Emergency Medicine. SGEM#445. Podcast: The Skeptics Guide to Emergency Medicine. Published July 6, 2024. Accessed December 3, 2025. https://thesgem.com/2024/07/sgem445-why-cant-we-be-friends-conflict-in-emergency-medicine/ Westafter L. Why Can’t We Be Friends – Conflict in Emergency Medicine. SGEM#445. Podcast: The Skeptics Guide to Emergency Medicine. Published July 6, 2024. Accessed December 3, 2025. https://thesgem.com/2024/07/sgem445-why-cant-we-be-friends-conflict-in-emergency-medicine/ Garmel GM. Conflict resolution in emergency medicine. In: Adams, JG, editor. Emergency Medicine: Clinical Essentials. (2nd Ed. Philadelphia: Saunders/Elsevier, 2013:2171–2185. Garmel GM. Conflict resolution in emergency medicine. In: Adams, JG, editor. Emergency Medicine: Clinical Essentials. (2nd Ed. Philadelphia: Saunders/Elsevier, 2013:2171–2185. Back AL, Arnold RM. Dealing with conflict in caring for the seriously ill: “it was just out of the question.” JAMA. 2005;293(11):1374–81. doi:10.1001/jama.293.11.1374. PMID: 15769971 Back AL, Arnold RM. Dealing with conflict in caring for the seriously ill: “it was just out of the question.” JAMA. 2005;293(11):1374–81. doi:10.1001/jama.293.11.1374. PMID: 15769971 Results and tips for successful implementation The case was tested on a total of 14 senior resident learners and four EM faculty facilitators using an iterative case trialing process at multiple sites with a convenience sample of EM residents. Learners and facilitators provided experience feedback on the quality of case elements via anonymous surveys using Likert scale items and free form comments. We used a modified SSET to evaluate the written and alpha round of cases. We used modified usability surveys for the two beta trialing rounds. Likert scale items were evaluated on a range of 1 to 5, where 1 = strongly disagree, 2 = disagree, 3 = neutral, 4 = agree, and 5 = strongly agree. All data were collected using Qualtrics (https://www.qualtrics.com) and analyzed using Excel (Microsoft, Redmond, WA). The Boston University Medical Center Institutional Review Board reviewed the project and deemed it exempt. Data from the surveys demonstrated favorable marks among both learners and facilitators regarding the quality and usability of the case materials. Among the four senior resident learners, three indicated agreement or strong agreement that the written materials were clear and the case was helpful practice for the ABEM Certifying Exam. Regarding clarity, one learner felt that the case should specify that there is no other nearby ST-elevation MI (STEMI) center that the patient can be transported to. The Task Statement section of the Candidate Task Sheet was updated to reflect this pertinent point in response to this feedback. One EM faculty facilitator strongly agreed that the case was easy to use, its materials were well integrated, and thought others would feel similar. They also felt confident using the case and would like to use this case for ABEM Certifying Exam practice. The alpha round of case trialing was performed at an academic EM residency program, where one facilitator (the same facilitator as in round one) and one resident completed surveys. During the first round of beta trialing the case, a simulation-trained EM faculty member at the 2025 Society for Academic Emergency Medicine (SAEM) Annual Meeting in Philadelphia, PA, tested the case with three EM senior resident learners. A second round of beta trialing was performed at an additional academic EM residency program, where three facilitators and 11 residents completed modified usability surveys. Beta trialing evaluation scores were generally positive; SAEM mean of 4.5 and second beta site mean 4.9. This case is best implemented in a private room devoid of distractions with one participant, one standardized patient, and the facilitator present.