Clinical Decision-Making Case: Non-Accidental Trauma Authors: H Michelle Greene, Anne P Runkle, Jennifer M Mitzman, Christopher E San Miguel, Krystin N Miller, Simiao Li-Sauerwine, Geremiha Emerson, Sorabh Khandelwal, Kelsey H Jordan, Jennifer Yee Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AudienceThis clinical decision-making (CDM) case is intended for emergency medicine (EM) residents of all levels.IntroductionNon-accidental trauma (NAT) is a leading cause of morbidity and mortality in pediatrics. Every year in the United States, more than 656,000 children are found to be victims of NAT, causing over 1,800 deaths annually.1 Subtle abusive injuries are frequently missed in medical settings,1–3 and children may subsequently experience escalating or life-threatening abuse if interventions do not occur.2 Timely identification of abusive injuries in acute care settings is crucial to provide appropriate and potentially lifesaving care.Educational ObjectivesBy the end of this clinical decision-making case, learners will be able to: 1) demonstrate familiarity with the CDM case format and case play, 2) describe important historical information to obtain when suspecting non-accidental trauma, 3) recognize potential physical exam findings in non-accidental trauma, 4) justify appropriate diagnostic studies based on clinical findings and current evidence on occult injury in suspected pediatric abuse, and 5) propose an appropriate disposition plan for patients with non-accidental trauma.Educational MethodsThis is a clinical decision-making boards case as outlined by the American Board of Emergency Medicine (ABEM). Each learner was paired with one instructor for the case, a scoring checklist by the instructor was used, and learners were given the opportunity to provide feedback after the case.Research MethodsEach CDM case session lasted approximately 20 minutes, with 15 minutes for the case and 5 minutes for debriefing and feedback. A 25-point critical action checklist was developed to evaluate each learner’s performance. Learners then provided verbal feedback on the cases to the examiners at the conclusion of their assessments.ResultsThirty-nine emergency medicine residents participated as learners for this clinical decision-making session, including 10 third-year residents, 12 second-year residents, and 17 first-year residents. Scoring checklists had a possible score of 25 points, with each point reflecting an equally weighted item. The average overall score was 16.85 of 25 possible points. Performance with respect to post-graduate year (PGY) is as follows: 18.0 for PGY-3s, 18.9 for PGY-2s, and 14.7 for PGY-1s. One resident had a perfect score of 25/25. There was no threshold passing score; therefore, no one resident “failed” this mock structured interview.DiscussionPerformance of our learners varied and unexpectedly, our second-year residents outperformed our third-year residents. We believe this is due to our PGY-2 learners being responsible for the primary care of stroke patients in our department, which makes their identification of head bleed likely more recently retrievable. We reviewed outlier items (where residents all scored very high or if the score was lower compared to other items) to determine if this is an appropriately written item, and if so, we will use lower-scoring items as learning opportunities to emphasize within future didactics sessions. One of these items involved asking who the patients’ caregivers were, which may be attributed to being unaware of the relevance of this question to NAT, or, more likely, that NAT was not a top differential diagnosis in the early aspects of the case.Verbal feedback from our learners primarily focused on widening our accepted differential diagnoses for future iterations. We believe that this case is appropriate for all levels of learning, particularly when a formative approach (assessment for learning) is used. Given the feedback learners and instructors provided, we believe this case has high value impact in reviewing high-risk or high-acuity pediatric pathology.TopicsEmergency medicine, pediatrics, non-accidental trauma, pediatric head trauma, head bleed. USER GUIDE List of Resources: Abstract292 User Guide294 For Examiner Only296 Certifying Exam Assessment302 Stimulus304 Debriefing and Evaluation Pearls310 Learner Audience: Interns, Junior Residents, Senior Residents Time Required for Implementation: Case: Clinical Decision-Making cases are 15 minutes as directed by American Board of Emergency Medicine (ABEM). Debriefing: 5–10 minutes per case. Recommended number of learners per instructor: We recommend that the instructors facilitate the case one-on-one with learners. We had a mock exam day where multiple facilitators ran the same case repeatedly with different residents. Topics: Emergency medicine, pediatrics, non-accidental trauma, pediatric head trauma, head bleed. Objectives: By the end of this CDM case, learners will be able to: Demonstrate familiarity with the CDM case format and case play Demonstrate familiarity with the CDM case format and case play Describe important historical information to obtain when suspecting non-accidental trauma Describe important historical information to obtain when suspecting non-accidental trauma Recognize potential physical exam findings in non-accidental trauma Recognize potential physical exam findings in non-accidental trauma Justify appropriate diagnostic studies based on clinical findings and current evidence on occult injury in suspected pediatric abuse Justify appropriate diagnostic studies based on clinical findings and current evidence on occult injury in suspected pediatric abuse Propose an appropriate disposition plan for patients with non-accidental trauma Propose an appropriate disposition plan for patients with non-accidental trauma Linked objectives, methods and results By participating in this clinical decision-making case, residents have the opportunity to practice assessing a non-accidental trauma patient with critical physical exam findings (objectives 1–3). Residents will be evaluated on their appropriate management and disposition (objectives 4–5) of their patient. Additionally, a built-in debriefing session at the end of the case provided real-time feedback to learners to ensure an “assessment for learning” component to the exercise. Recommended pre-reading for instructor American Board of Emergency Medicine. Sample Case: Clinical Decision Making. YouTube. Published November 27, 2024. Accessed November 23, 2025. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dv_ga0Ei7oY American Board of Emergency Medicine. Sample Case: Clinical Decision Making. YouTube. Published November 27, 2024. Accessed November 23, 2025. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dv_ga0Ei7oY American Board of Emergency Medicine Certifying Exam Case Materials: Clinical Decision Making. Published November 2024. Accessed November 23, 2025. Case-Materials_Clinical-Decision-Making.pdf American Board of Emergency Medicine Certifying Exam Case Materials: Clinical Decision Making. Published November 2024. Accessed November 23, 2025. Case-Materials_Clinical-Decision-Making.pdf Christian CW. The evaluation of suspected child physical abuse. Pediatrics. 2015 May;135(5):e1337–54. doi:10.1542/peds.2015-0356. Erratum in: Pediatrics. 2015 Sep;136(3):583. doi:10.1542/peds.2015-2010 Christian CW. The evaluation of suspected child physical abuse. Pediatrics. 2015 May;135(5):e1337–54. doi:10.1542/peds.2015-0356. Erratum in: Pediatrics. 2015 Sep;136(3):583. doi:10.1542/peds.2015-2010 Letson MM, Cooper JN, Deans KJ, et al. Prior opportunities to identify abuse in children with abusive head trauma. Child Abuse Negl. 2016 Oct;60:36–45. Epub 2016 Sep 25. doi:10.1016/j.chiabu.2016.09.001 Letson MM, Cooper JN, Deans KJ, et al. Prior opportunities to identify abuse in children with abusive head trauma. Child Abuse Negl. 2016 Oct;60:36–45. Epub 2016 Sep 25. doi:10.1016/j.chiabu.2016.09.001 Harper NS, Feldman KW, Sugar NF, Anderst JD, Lindberg DM. Examining siblings to recognize abuse investigators. Additional injuries in young infants with concern for abuse and apparently isolated bruises. J Pediatr. 2014 Aug;165(2):383–388.e1. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpeds.2014.04.004 Harper NS, Feldman KW, Sugar NF, Anderst JD, Lindberg DM. Examining siblings to recognize abuse investigators. Additional injuries in young infants with concern for abuse and apparently isolated bruises. J Pediatr. 2014 Aug;165(2):383–388.e1. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpeds.2014.04.004 Haney S, Scherl S, DiMeglio L, Perez-Rossello J, Servaes S, Merchant N. Evaluating young children with fractures for child abuse: Clinical report. Pediatrics. 2025 Feb. 1;155(2):e2024070074. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2024-070074 Haney S, Scherl S, DiMeglio L, Perez-Rossello J, Servaes S, Merchant N. Evaluating young children with fractures for child abuse: Clinical report. Pediatrics. 2025 Feb. 1;155(2):e2024070074. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2024-070074 Lindberg D, Makoroff K, Harper N, et al. Utility of hepatic transaminases to recognize abuse in children. Pediatrics. 2009;124(2):509–516. doi:10.1542/peds.2008-2348 Lindberg D, Makoroff K, Harper N, et al. Utility of hepatic transaminases to recognize abuse in children. Pediatrics. 2009;124(2):509–516. doi:10.1542/peds.2008-2348 Results and tips for successful implementation This clinical decision-making case was created as a collaboration between Emergency Medicine (EM) faculty and Pediatric Emergency Medicine (PEM) faculty including one member who completed a Child Abuse Pediatrics Fellowship. Based on feedback provided by our learners and instructors, this case was best implemented as a CDM case (or what was formerly known as a structured interview). All 39 learners were EM residents (10 third-year residents, 12 second-year residents, and 17 first-year residents). Each learner was allotted 15 minutes for the case and 5 minutes for a debriefing afterwards. Instructors graded each learner on a 25-point grading sheet. Learners provided verbal feedback to their case facilitators during the debriefing period. Since original pilot data, the questions listed here were made more specific and updated to better reflect the new Certifying Exam based on evolving ABEM information. The average score for all learners was 16.85 out of 25 total items. The averages for each post graduate year (PGY) class were as follows: 18.0 for PGY-3s, 18.9 for PGY-2s, and 14.7 for PGY-1s. This numerical data represents our institutional iteration of our initial understanding of the Clinical Decision-making Cases; therefore, we only included one rationale prompt in the History section, and our Transition of Care section did not include “Provides sign-out.” We updated our initial 25-point grading sheet from our original assessment to include an additional rationale prompt for the History section and “sign out” action for Transition of Care section in this manuscript. Other changes made to this case for subsequent use included: expanded differential diagnoses, clarification edits to one historical question, and we added a social work consult as a potential mandated reporter under “treatment and other actions.” Feedback from our faculty prompted us to include an abdominal exam, pulse palpation and capillary refill to the total physical exam. We also found that resident differential diagnoses at times included both “non-accidental trauma” and “accidental trauma,” so if the resident stated “accidental trauma,” faculty were then prompted to ask the resident to be more specific. With respect to the computed tomography (CT) image linked to this case, a reading of subdural hematoma and/or subarachnoid hemorrhage was not provided, and instead residents were expected to interpret the image themselves. We noticed multiple residents struggled to identify these critical findings, many of which were first-year level of training. When incorporating this case at your institution, instructors may want to consider adding a radiology read for first year resident learners or finding an image that is less subtle. We included the liver function tests (LFTs) as an item on the grading sheet in order to highlight that this is a decision point to determine whether or not to obtain a CT of the abdomen/pelvis in pediatric non-accidental trauma. With elevated liver function tests or abdominal bruising, distention, or tenderness, a CT of the abdomen/pelvis should be considered.5