Grooves in forereefs act as transport channels to deliver coral rubble during tropical cyclones Authors: Ana Vila-Concejo, Lachlan A. Perris, Ana Paula da Silva, Kate Whitton, Liav Meoded-Stern, Wan-Yi Steilberg-Liu, Ruby Holmes, Heinrich Breuer, Maria Byrne, Thomas E. Fellowes, Tristan Salles, Bradley D. Morris, Eleanor Bruce, Emma Ryan, Hironobu Kan Published: 2025 Impact statement This study documents a rare and consequential sediment transport event following a sequence of climate-related disturbances on the Great Barrier Reef. In the early months (Austral summer) of 2024, the reef experienced the ninth global bleaching event, with catastrophic impacts at One Tree Reef, a site of long-standing significance in Geoscience. One year later, in March 2025, Tropical Cyclone Alfred remobilised the resulting rubble and transported it onto the reef flat. While grooves (the channels of spur and groove systems) have long been suspected to play a role in sediment dynamics, the prevailing view has been that it is “impossible” for rubble to move upslope through them to the reef flat. Our study shows the first evidence that large volumes of coral rubble are delivered to the reef flat through these grooves. We present qualitative and quantitative drone surveys and field measurements of topography and bathymetry to document this process. These findings carry implications for sediment budgets, interpretations of past reef-building processes and forecasts of reef and shingle island evolution under climate change. These insights are especially timely given their relevance to increasingly used restoration strategies (e.g., rubble stabilisation) and to global sustainability efforts, particularly United Nations Sustainable Development Goals related to Small Island Developing States, such as SDG13 (Climate action), SDG14 (Life below water) and SDG 11 (Sustainable cities and communities). These insights are important given the relevance to millions of people globally whose livelihoods are inextricably linked to coral reef ecosystems. Introduction Coral reef islands are dynamic environments that, by adjusting to the environmental conditions (Masselink et al., 2020), remain among the most climate-vulnerable ecosystems on Earth. Physical modelling of gravel islands has demonstrated that islands could build up and adapt to sea level rise (Tuck et al., 2019; Masselink et al., 2020). However, the pathways and rates of sediment supply, without which build-up cannot happen, are event-driven and remain poorly constrained (de Bakker et al., 2025). Islands composed of biogenic carbonate materials are built from sediments derived from the surrounding forereefs and reef flats. Consequently, the sediment supply is threatened by climate change disruptions such as increased marine heatwaves and intense tropical cyclones, which reduce overall reef productivity (de Bakker et al., 2025). Here, we present new evidence of the pathways of sediment delivery from a bleached coral reef during a tropical storm. Spurs and grooves (SAGs) act as living breakwaters (Munk and Sargent, 1948) on the forereef of coral reefs. Spurs are parallel ridges of living carbonate material (coral and algae) separated by regularly spaced channels (grooves) (Duce et al., 2016). SAGs are usually oriented perpendicular to the reef crest and/or the incoming waves. They form a “comb-tooth” pattern (6–8 m wide) extending from the reef crest to depths of 20 m (Gischler, 2010). SAGs show considerable variations in morphology predominantly driven by the prevailing hydrodynamic energy (Duce et al., 2020). SAG morphology has been documented across different reef morphologies, including fringing reefs, barrier reefs and atolls through coral-rich seas (Duce et al., 2016). While they have been studied since the mid twentieth century (Munk and Sargent, 1948), recent years have seen an increased focus on SAG research, including remote sensing (Duce et al., 2016), numerical modelling (Rogers et al., 2013; da Silva et al., 2020; Watanabe et al., 2023; Perris et al., 2024) and field measurements (Storlazzi et al., 2004; Monismith et al., 2013; Rogers et al., 2015; Duce et al., 2020, 2022; Acevedo-Ramirez et al., 2021; Sartori et al., 2025). These studies have confirmed that SAG morphology and hydrodynamics are linked to wave climate, from incident short waves to infragravity. They are important wave dissipaters protecting the areas behind reefs (Monismith et al., 2013; Duce et al., 2022; Watanabe et al., 2023; Perris et al., 2024). SAGs exist under a broad range of wave energy settings and associated water flows (Duce et al., 2016, 2020). It is mostly through modelling that water flows in the SAG zone have been investigated, with research indicating the existence of counter-rotating Lagrangian circulation cells in the grooves (Rogers et al., 2013; da Silva et al., 2020). However, it is unclear whether the flows that occur in the grooves drive sediment transport onshore (towards the reef flat) or offshore. While numerical modelling studies (Rogers et al., 2013) mostly found gentle offshore flow over the shallow part of the grooves, others (da Silva et al., 2020) showed a gentle onshore current in most of their simulations. More recently, field measurements have shown offshore flow in shallow grooves under low wave energy conditions (Perris et al., 2025; Sartori et al., 2025). While Rogers (2013) posits that under strong wave forcing, the offshore transport on the grooves would be reduced or potentially reversed, such conditions have never been measured or observed. A study using tracers of the effects of Category 4 Typhoon Robyn in 1993 in Kume Island (Ryukyus, Southern Japan) showed that coral clasts could be transported from the forereef (up to 12 m depth) onto the reef flat, but those clasts were not located on the grooves (Kan, 1995). Other indications of onshore transport result from personal observations by the authors of the current manuscript of onshore imbrication of coral clasts witnessed while deploying instruments in the Maldives and the Great Barrier Reef. One Tree Reef (OTR) is a wave-exposed mesotidal platform reef located on the southern Great Barrier Reef (GBR, Figure 1). Its eastern margin comprises a rubble-dominated reef flat containing an estimated 14 million tons of rubble derived from the reef front (Thornborough and Davies, 2011). It is one of the few reefs in the GBR containing a shingle island on its exposed margin. Coral rubble is the generic term used to denote sediments resulting from the fragmentation of calcifying organisms, including coral and molluscs. It refers to sediment larger than sand (>2 mm) and typically up to boulder size in the Udden-Wentworth scale (>256 mm), with a variety of morphologies ranging from branching to tabular (Rasser and Riegl, 2002). The coral rubble is dumped on the reef flat during a large, high-energy event and is then reworked (Thornborough and Davies, 2011) with some of it forming rubble spits or tracts (Shannon et al., 2013) that deliver rubble to the shingle island (Talavera et al., 2021). The SAGs on the eastern forereef of OTR (Figure 2) have spurs with ~90% coral cover and grooves with a “U”-shaped cross-section, and at the base have a variable amount of large rubble clasts with occasional pockets of coarse sand (Duce et al., 2016). Rubble environments are ubiquitous in coral reefs (Blanchon et al., 1997; Thornborough and Davies, 2011), and previous ecosystem restoration studies have highlighted that rubble mobility hinders coral growth (Ceccarelli et al., 2020). On the other hand, recent studies suggest that rubble fields are important ecosystems that serve as potential targets for coral settlement (Heyward et al., 2024).Figure 1.(A) Location of One Tree Island on the southern Great Barrier Reef off the coast of NE Australia and track and Saffir-Simpson category for Tropical Cyclone Alfred in March 2025, note in the legend, TD= Tropical Depression and TS= Tropical Storm (Source IBTrACS (Knapp et al. 2010)); (B) LiDAR Digital Elevation Model (Vertical datum is mean sea level, MSL) with 25 cm resolution of One Tree Reef (OTR) measured in 2018 (Harris et al. 2023) showing the location of the Spotter wave buoy; (C) Wave power from the southern One Tree Island Research Station (OTIRS) wave buoy on the east flank of One Tree Reef (see B for location) during TC Alfred. Figure 2.Orthomosaics of One Tree Island with adjacent rubble reef flat in November 2022 (A) and post TC Alfred in March 2025 (B); the grooves off the SE of One Tree Reef are clear of sediment in November 2024 (photo by Lachlan Perris, C) and infilled with coral rubble fans spilling sediment as SAG Fans onto the reef flat post TC Alfred in March 2025 (photo by One Tree Island Research Station, OTIRS, D); Orthomosaic of the SAG at One Tree Reef post TC Alfred (March 2025), showing the sediment fans delivered through the groove channels, and the locations of T1 and T2, the SAG bathymetry corresponds to data obtained with LiDAR in 2018(E); T1 shows a cross-section of the edges of the rubble fans extracted from the drone data (F); and, T2 demonstrates infilling of the grooves by comparing a LiDAR bathymetry from 2018 with a single beam bathymetry (T2) measured in 2025 post TC Alfred (G). (A) Location of One Tree Island on the southern Great Barrier Reef off the coast of NE Australia and track and Saffir-Simpson category for Tropical Cyclone Alfred in March 2025, note in the legend, TD= Tropical Depression and TS= Tropical Storm (Source IBTrACS (Knapp et al. 2010)); (B) LiDAR Digital Elevation Model (Vertical datum is mean sea level, MSL) with 25 cm resolution of One Tree Reef (OTR) measured in 2018 (Harris et al. 2023) showing the location of the Spotter wave buoy; (C) Wave power from the southern One Tree Island Research Station (OTIRS) wave buoy on the east flank of One Tree Reef (see B for location) during TC Alfred. Orthomosaics of One Tree Island with adjacent rubble reef flat in November 2022 (A) and post TC Alfred in March 2025 (B); the grooves off the SE of One Tree Reef are clear of sediment in November 2024 (photo by Lachlan Perris, C) and infilled with coral rubble fans spilling sediment as SAG Fans onto the reef flat post TC Alfred in March 2025 (photo by One Tree Island Research Station, OTIRS, D); Orthomosaic of the SAG at One Tree Reef post TC Alfred (March 2025), showing the sediment fans delivered through the groove channels, and the locations of T1 and T2, the SAG bathymetry corresponds to data obtained with LiDAR in 2018(E); T1 shows a cross-section of the edges of the rubble fans extracted from the drone data (F); and, T2 demonstrates infilling of the grooves by comparing a LiDAR bathymetry from 2018 with a single beam bathymetry (T2) measured in 2025 post TC Alfred (G). In February–March 2024, OTR underwent the worst bleaching in its history, causing up to 53% coral mortality (Byrne et al., 2025), more acute in areas of low hydrodynamic energy (Meoded-Stern et al., 2025). This event generated large amounts of coral rubble resulting from the dead coral collapse. One year after the bleaching, on 1 March 2025, Tropical Cyclone (TC) Alfred passed 340 km east of One Tree Island (Figure 1A). It was a slow-moving Category 1–2 cyclone (Saffir-Simpson Scale) that downgraded to Tropical Storm later that day, still sustaining strong winds. Our wave Spotter Buoy located on the SE off the reef (Figure 1B) recorded Significant Wave Heights (H s) up to 7 m with associated Peak Periods (T p) of 12 s. This led to wave power exceeding 250 kW/m sustained over nearly 12 h (Figure 1C). Fortunately, for One Tree Island Research Station, the largest waves occurred during the astronomical low tides. As expected, TC Alfred delivered large volumes of rubble to the reef flat, modifying the overall morphology of the island (Figure 2A,B; see white rubble in 2B over the reef flat and on the northern tip). The mechanisms acting during these event-driven stochastic occurrences are not well established/studied, and scientists have debated for years whether SAGs could act as channels to deliver sediments to the reef flat under high-energy conditions. In March 2025, immediately after the passage of TC Alfred, we captured a photo showing grooves that are normally relatively empty of sediment (Figure 2C) were completely infilled with sediment and had newly formed sedimentary fans of rubble extending out from each groove on the eastern margin of OTR (Figure 2D). This is the first evidence showing the grooves acting as channels for rubble delivery onto the reef flat from decades of SAG research worldwide. Measurements from drone surveys post-Alfred show the distinct one-to-one spatial alignment between the rubble fans and the grooves, with each groove producing a single fan (Figure 2E). Bathymetric measurements show over 1 m of rubble infilling on the previously mostly bare grooves (Figure 2F). Our observations and measurements establish, for the first time, grooves as channels transporting coral rubble onto the reef flat during high-energy conditions. This contrasts with the commonly accepted paradigm that rubble on the reef flats is transported from the spurs during high-energy conditions, and that rubble in the grooves remains trapped there or, under the right conditions, moves down the groove (Kan et al., 1997; Hubbard and Dullo, 2016; Duce et al., 2020; Sartori et al., 2025). The observed groove onshore transport occurred during extreme high-energy conditions, with TC Alfred being in the top 99th percentile of TC-generated waves for the study area. The threshold at which this onshore transport initiates is likely location dependent and deserves further investigation, as onshore rubble transport is crucial for the persistence of rubble islands, and TCs are expected to become more intense and less frequent in the Southern Hemisphere (Knutson et al., 2020). Finally, our observations highlight that the function of SAGs is not limited to the dissipation of wave energy but enables onshore rubble transport and contributes to coral environment dynamics essential for reef ecosystem health. While we have shown that rubble delivery plays an important role in the island stability of shingle islands, it has also been shown to influence sandy islands such as the Maldives (Gea-Neuhaus et al., 2025). Reef building is more than coral growth; it is a complex interplay of carbonate production, destruction and transport, as well as the reincorporation of sediment into the reef framework (Hubbard and Dullo, 2016). In the face of a changing climate, there is an urgent need to understand natural coral reef systems (Streit et al., 2024). Understanding rubble dynamics must precede rubble restoration as a management tool in natural systems. This is an extremely interesting and novel piece of work that should be published. It details for the first time field evidence of the role of spurs and grooves in delivering sediment to the reef flats during cyclones. This finding has implications for understanding the processes of sediment delivery to reef flats and ultimately eventually to islands. Some minor suggested amendments are provided below. Suggest to reference Tuck et al. 2019 in reference to physical models – line 59. (Megan E. Tuck, Paul S. Kench, Murray R. Ford, Gerd Masselink; Physical modelling of the response of reef islands to sea-level rise. Geology 2019;; 47 (9): 803–806. doi: https://doi.org/10.1130/G46362.1) Line 62 – suggest change ‘forereefs’ to ‘reefs’ or ‘forereefs and reef flats’ as it is not just the forereefs that produce sediment. Line 63 – be specific about climate change disruptions – increased sea surface temps, and maybe increased intensity of tropical cyclones? Line 86 – are these circulation cells located in grooves? Line 95 – please indicate where this study was undertaken Line 98 – do you mean Kan? Or the authors of this current manuscript – please clarify who these authors are Line 111/112 – is the presence of large rubble clasts covering the bottom of the grooves? Does it build up in these grooves for example? Or is it a fine veneer? Figure 1 – Very nice figure, but its not clear what TD and TS stand for (depression and storm?). Please include in the caption, and also add (OTR) to the caption after One Tree Reef (change from Island to match figure) Line 126 – add month of bleaching Line 161 – ‘reef building is more than coral growth’ – this needs further explanation. I think you need to explain the role that rubble plays in reef building as well Figure 2 – Great pictures – but do you have an equivalent picture to D) that you could use for C) instead or as well? C shows the SAG clearly but does not show the landward section of reef so you cannot get an idea of how ‘new’ these rubble fans are (are they all rubble, or a mixture of sand too?) . The description of E) needs some additional information – this is a combo of LiDAR from 2018? Plus orthomosaic? Its not clear what data are from 2018 and what are from 2025?. In (G) suggest changing key to LiDAR bathy and drone bathy. It would be interesting to overlay the location of grooves upon E) to determine if the location of these fans are directly landward or slightly angled relative to the centre of the grooves (does one groove produce one fan, or multiple grooves?). This is an exceptionally valuable report on phenomena occurring at the reef edge of coral reefs during heavy swells, based on data and observations from the period around intense, infrequent tropical cyclones. Unlike sand cays, the seafloor where coral rubble accumulates and the islets composed of coral rubble are difficult to observe continuously as they change. Observations during major events like Tropical Cyclone Alfred provide a realistic and reliable opportunity to obtain evidence. The authors' initiative in successfully seizing this extremely valuable chance is commendable. The text is concise yet contains important points and is commendable. However, Figure 2 contains many unclear points and should be improved. Figure 2 1) Is it possible to describe where changes occurred by comparing (A) and (B)? For example, the shape of the spite on the reef northeast of OTI has also changed (the elongated spite seaward has disappeared, and sedimentation is progressing near the island). The vegetated spite northwest has become narrower (has erosion progressed?). 2) Are (C) and (D) photographs from the same viewpoint? (C) appears to be a vertical photograph, while (D) seems to be an oblique photograph. It is unclear what “the grooves off the SE of One Tree Reef” refers to; please indicate this with arrow(s) on the figure or add an explanatory note. Please also add arrow(s) to photograph (D) for the description “infilled with coral rubble fans spilling sediment onto the reef flat”. Regarding wave conditions at the reef edge during tropical cyclones, there is a paper by Watanabe et al. 2023. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2023.115632 Note that the filling of grooves with coral gravel is also evident from observations of cross-sections of cutting through coral reefs (Kan et al. 1995, 1997). These papers are for your information. They can be viewed at the following sites. Kan, H., Hori, N., Nakashima,Y. and Ichikawa,K. (1995) The evolution of narrow reef flats at high-latitude in the Ryukyu Islands. Coral Reefs, Vol.14, p.123-130. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF00367229 Kan,H., Hori,N., Kawana,T., Kaigara,T. and Ichikawa,K. (1997) The evolution of a Holocene fringing reef and island: reefal environmental sequence and sea level change in Tonaki Island, the central Ryukyus. Atoll Research Bulletin, No.443, p.1-20. https://d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/84708123/Kan_et_al_1997_Atoll_Res_Bull_Smithsonian_-libre.pdf?1650678660=&response-content-disposition=inline%3B+filename%3DThe_evolution_of_a_Holocene_fringing_ree.pdf&Expires=1758677739&Signature=Uvej7851~vkFT59z~0CisQaRbadJd0~8n1IG7jTapPqo1udvy6G-eU0LuYXVGL0xnUMvypX6FUluUOCLAcYhLD7DFsCVw~DLdMKfG1PHKKKvUyNE-Oc7JcKifog2bpHUC04TwUWv0mBEfds3lXaBIUaWrNmjExCU0CkGof~UEjKqbZH4TVQXfQV~WHk94S0D~dfn90clRP9-M3-Gm4HAUXap8-XGRM-rnNV92VCStnEZQYfEj5fwgtik2NMtbu1cJ19iFCGjszHN-xHueRjrpGXdy5-2NndYParJJ~RsFTUyDLfUT6Kf5x9uJujJ-v8oavg7SBHp2AEr4QBBcmJ4zQ__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAJLOHF5GGSLRBV4ZA Since I can’t seem to attach the file, I’ll provide the website instead. The two reviewers provide very positive examinations of your manuscript. I agree that this work should be published with some minor / moderate revisions. These all seem relatively straightforward and think this team of authors will have no problem making the necessary revisions. I do have some queries and confusion about the way this research is framed. It seems as though spur and groove outer reef morphologies are being described as an avenue for sediment transport for building reef islands. My understanding of reef islands comes from the GBR / Seychelles / Malaysia and for those sites, reef islands tend to build up on the leeward, rather than the windward, side of a reef platform. There are no SaGs on the leeward side of these platforms. The study site of this paper, One Tree Island, is a shingle (rather than sand), island and a rather anomalous case for the Capricorn Bunker Group, and indeed the wider GBR as the island has formed on the windward side of the reef. To make a direct linkage between the SnG sediment stores and islands, and to claim that this work has significance for low lying island communities elsewhere seems a stretch. The authors should either reframe, or explicitly name some reef islands (i.e. sand cays of the sort that may be populated in the Pacific, where islanders are seeing the impacts of sea-level rise) that have actually formed or been nourished through sediment transport adjacent to spur and grooves. There has been a tendency in recent years to identify sediment in any part of the reef system as an immediate saviour of reef islands. Most have no credible foundation. Funafuti could be an example where windward islands have formed through coral rubble accumulation. The reef flats are narrow (<100m). While there is little doubt the coral rubble must have been derived from the forereef (which does have SnG), the mechanisms could be storm removal of coral and gravel along the entire forereef as opposed to SnG being the conveyor. A broader question is why they make this link? The work is significant without leveraging off the discussion around island susceptibility to change, and is this necessary? Perhaps the article could be framed around the storage and potential flux of gravel to reef flats more generally? Finally, in the acknowledgements section you acknowledge the first nations TOs for OTI, can you name and/ or list the groups? No accompanying comment. This manuscript has been much improved by the revisions - I am happy to accept without it going out to a further review, subject to a few minor amendments, as outlined in the attached version. Well done to this research team for this valuable paper! No accompanying comment. No accompanying comment. No accompanying comment.