Robotic tubular pyeloureteroplasty using flap and lingual mucosal graft: a case report and literature review Authors: Kangxiang Xu, Chaoqi Liang, Yuancheng Zhou, Shuaishuai Chai, Jianjun Fang, Xingyuan Xiao, Bing Li Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundRecurrent ureteropelvic junction obstruction (UPJO) accompanied by long proximal ureteral obliteration presents significant challenges for conventional pyeloplasty, primarily due to the elevated tension at the surgical site. Additionally, previous surgeries often lead to scar tissue formation, complicating both the identification of healthy tissue and the success of reconstruction.Case DescriptionA 38-year-old patient with right UPJO successfully underwent robotic tubular pyeloureteroplasty using a flap and lingual mucosal graft (LMG). The surgical technique involved using the flap to form the posterior plate of the anastomosis, with the LMG serving as the anterior plate, resulting in a wide, tubularized, and well-vascularized ureteropelvic junction. Intraoperative blood loss was about 50 mL, and operative time was about 220 minutes. Follow-up ultrasound demonstrated sustained reduction in hydronephrosis, which was further confirmed by improved findings on computed tomography urography. Antegrade urography confirmed the absence of ureteral obstruction following removal of the Double-J stent, with no complications observed. During follow-up assessments, the patient reported no symptoms after surgery. By sixteen months postoperatively, the glomerular filtration rate of the right renal increased from 25.03 to 28.03 mL/min, and split renal function improved from 33.00% to 37.56%.ConclusionsRobotic tubular pyeloureteroplasty using a flap and LMG is a safe and effective surgical option, offering a promising treatment for selected patients with UPJO. This technique serves as an alternative for those with complex anatomical challenges typically encountered in pyeloplasty.Keywords: Renal pelvis flap, lingual mucosal graft (LMG), pyeloureteroplasty, ureteropelvic junction obstruction (UPJO), case report Highlight box Key findings • We documented a novel combined technique for robotic tubular pyeloureteroplasty using a renal pelvis flap and lingual mucosal graft (LMG) to address recurrent ureteropelvic junction obstruction (UPJO). What is known and what is new? • Recurrent UPJO with long ureteral obliteration poses significant challenges for conventional pyeloplasty due to high tension and scarring from prior surgeries. • We present a novel, minimally invasive technique of robotic tubular pyeloureteroplasty using flap and LMG for selected patients with recurrent UPJO accompanied by long proximal ureteral obliteration. What is the implication, and what should change now? • Our novel combined technique is a feasible option for selected patients with UPJO, and various combinations of autologous tissues can be considered for complex ureteral reconstruction. Introduction Ureteropelvic junction obstruction (UPJO) is a prevalent urological condition that can arise from various factors, including vascular compression or the formation of calculi (1). The Anderson-Hynes pyeloplasty remains the standard surgical approach for UPJO, demonstrating a high success rate exceeding 90% in adult patients (2). However, initial surgical intervention for UPJO may lead to recurrent obstruction due to factors such as scar tissue formation and fibrosis, crossing vessels, or technical failures (3-5). Pyeloplasty is generally indicated for patients with localized UPJO, preserved renal function, and no significant anatomical distortion (6). Recurrent UPJO complicated by long-segment obliterative strictures, extensive periureteral fibrosis, aberrant vascular anatomy, or severe renal atrophy presents substantial challenges to native ureteral reconstruction, complicating the execution of conventional pyeloplasty (6). Flap pyeloplasty reconstructs the ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) by utilizing the enlarged renal pelvis, ensuring adequate blood supply and a tension-free anastomosis (7). However, in cases where UPJO is associated with long proximal ureteral obliteration, the dilated renal pelvis may be insufficient for effective reconstruction. In cases of long-segment proximal ureteral strictures or obliteration, the traditional treatment options for recurrent UPJO include renal autotransplantation and ileal ureteral replacement, which are frequently associated with a high incidence of long-term complications, particularly those related to bowel substitution and vascular anastomosis (8-10). In recent years, many urologists have increasingly turned to oral mucosal graft, such as buccal mucosal graft (BMG) and lingual mucosal grafts (LMGs), to aid in the management of complex proximal ureteral strictures (11,12). Our previous studies have demonstrated that lingual mucosal graft ureteroplasty (LMGU) is both safe and effective for reconstructing long proximal ureteral strictures, and it has successfully repaired strictures up to 11.5 cm in length (12,13). Herein, we present a novel, minimally invasive technique: robotic tubular pyeloureteroplasty using flap and LMG for selected patients with recurrent UPJO. This article summarizes the details of the technique and reports our initial experience. We present this article in accordance with the CARE reporting checklist (available at https://tau.amegroups.com/article/view/10.21037/tau-2025-646/rc). Case presentation All procedures performed in this study were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee(s), and with the Declaration of Helsinki and its subsequent amendments. Written informed consent was obtained from the patient for the publication of this case report and accompanying images. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the editorial office of this journal. A 38-year-old male was diagnosed with right-sided UPJO during a routine physical examination, with computed tomography (CT) imaging confirming the diagnosis, without any symptoms. The patient had a history of hyperuricemia and, despite being classified as American Society of Anesthesiology (ASA) class II preoperatively, did not have comorbidities such as diabetes, hypertension, or chronic kidney disease. He underwent an initial Anderson-Hynes pyeloplasty at another medical center due to progressively worsening hydronephrosis detected during a routine examination, along with renal function impairment. A Double-J stent was inserted and removed after six weeks. However, follow-up examinations three months later revealed recurrent stricture and severe hydronephrosis. One month before the second reconstructive surgery, our center performed percutaneous nephrostomy to ensure ureteral rest and protect renal function (14). Preoperative CT urography showed right-sided UPJO with tissue adhesions and moderate hydronephrosis (Figure 1A). Postoperative CT urography demonstrated patency of the right ureter and marked improvement in hydronephrosis (Figure 1B). Antegrade and retrograde urography revealed a right-sided proximal ureteral stricture with an approximately 3.0 cm stricture at the L3 level (Figure 1C). At eight weeks post-surgery, urography revealed a reconstructed ureteral segment that was free from obstruction (Figure 1D). Imaging findings prior to and following surgical intervention. (A) One-month post-nephrostomy, CT urography demonstrated moderate right renal hydronephrosis (red arrow). (B) CT urography conducted 16 months post-surgery revealed mild right renal hydronephrosis (red arrow). (C) Antegrade and retrograde urography revealed right-sided proximal ureteral stricture with an approximately 3.0 cm stricture at the L3 level (yellow arrow). (D) At 8 weeks postoperatively, antegrade urography revealed no obstruction in the reconstructed ureter segment (yellow arrow). CT, computed tomography. At the start of the procedure, the nephrostomy tube was clamped, causing dilation of the renal pelvis. After inducing general anesthesia via nasotracheal intubation, the patient was positioned in the left lateral decubitus position at 70°, with the waist elevated. Port placement was performed as described in previous reports (13). The lateral peritoneum was incised along the colon to mobilize the ascending colon towards the midline. Careful dissection separated the diseased ureter and enlarged renal pelvis from surrounding fibrous tissue. The diagnosis of right-sided UPJO was confirmed, with renal pelvis dilation (Figure 2A). Intraoperative steps of surgery. (A) Approximately 3.0 cm of right-sided UPJO with renal pelvic dilation. (B) The atretic ureteral segment was resected, preserving the dorsal adventitia, and the renal pelvis was mobilized to align with the normal-caliber ureter for suturing. (C) A 3.0 cm × 1.5 cm flap was harvested, flipped, and inverted, then sutured to the posterior ureteral incision after longitudinal dissection of the ventral ureter for approximately 0.8 cm. (D) A 5 Fr Double-J stent was inserted across the ureteral defect. (E) A 3.8 cm × 1.5 cm lingual mucosal graft was harvested and sutured at both ends to the ventral ureteral and renal pelvic incisions, with continuous suturing along the middle portion. (F) The repaired ureter is covered with omentum. UPJO, ureteropelvic junction obstruction. During the resection of the atretic segment of the ureter, meticulous care was taken to preserve its dorsal adventitia. This was done while mobilizing the renal pelvis to ensure proper alignment with the surrounding normal-caliber ureteral tissue for subsequent suturing (Figure 2B). We performed an incision in the ureter and utilized a 10 Fr catheter to investigate both the proximal and distal ends of the ureteral stricture, continuing until the catheter could traverse the ureter without encountering resistance. Additionally, a 5 Fr calibrated catheter was used to measure the distance from the designated base to the inferior corner of the ureterotomy, ensuring accurate flap length determination. A flap measuring 3.0 cm in length and 1.5 cm in width was harvested, flipped, and inverted. The normal ureter was then longitudinally dissected from the ventral side for approximately 0.8 cm. The flap was intermittently sutured to the posterior ureteral incision using 5-0 Monocryl sutures, achieving posterior ureteral reconstruction (Figure 2C). Finally, a 5 Fr Double-J stent was inserted through the newly formed ureteral defect (Figure 2D). Details regarding the harvesting procedures for LMG are outlined in our previous publication (4). An LMG, measuring approximately 3.8 cm in length and 1.5 cm in width, was positioned ventrally to the defective ureter. The LMG was secured using 5-0 Monocryl sutures, with both ends first attached to the ventral incision of the ureter and the renal pelvic incision. Subsequently, the middle portion of the flap and LMG were sutured consecutively to facilitate tubularization (Figure 2E). The reconstructed ureteral segment was covered with an omental flap to ensure adequate blood supply (Figure 2F). Finally, a drainage tube was placed into the pararenal space before closing all incisions in multiple layers. A schematic diagram of the surgical model is presented in Figure 3. Schematic diagram of the surgical model. (A,B) Resection of ureteral obliteration. (C,D) A flap is harvested, flipped and inverted, then sutured to the dorsal ureteral incision. (E) A lingual mucosal graft is harvested and sutured at both ends to the ventral ureteral and renal pelvic incisions, with continuous suturing along the middle. (F) The repaired ureter is covered with omentum. The surgery was successfully conducted on the robotic platform without intraoperative complications. The surgical time was 220 minutes, with an intraoperative blood loss of 50 mL. Postoperatively, the patient experienced slurred speech for three days but could eat normally by day five. Two weeks following the surgery, the donor site exhibited no pain, and tongue mobility and dietary intake were satisfactory. The drainage tube was removed on postoperative day four, and the Double-J stent was removed 6 weeks later. At eight weeks postoperatively, the nephrostomy tube was removed. Ultrasound imaging indicated a significant reduction in hydronephrosis three months after surgery. During follow-up assessments, the patient reported no lower back discomfort after surgery. By sixteen months postoperatively, the glomerular filtration rate of the right renal increased from 25.03 to 28.03 mL/min, while split renal function improved from 33.00% to 37.56%. Discussion UPJO is a condition caused by various factors that obstruct urine flow from the renal pelvis to the ureter. While Anderson-Hynes pyeloplasty has a success rate exceeding 90%, surgical failure still occurs relatively frequently (2,15). Factors contributing to these failures include inadequate blood supply to ureteral tissues, urine extravasation leading to inflammatory fibrosis, unaddressed crossing vessels, and complex strictures or infections (3-5). Consequently, recurrent UPJO presents significant pathophysiological challenges for management. Current evidence indicates that endoscopic management does not offer comparable success rates when compared to open, laparoscopic, or robot-assisted pyeloplasty as primary treatments (16). Studies have shown that robot-assisted pyeloplasty is safe and effective in recurrent UPJO, offering advantages such as magnification, three-dimensional visualization, smaller incisions, and precise suturing (17). Recurrent UPJO with long proximal ureteral obliteration poses a significant clinical challenge. In revision surgeries, scar tissue from previous surgeries often complicates repair success (6). High tension at the anastomosis site further diminishes the effectiveness of traditional pyeloplasty and may even contraindicate the procedure in some cases. Conventional surgical options for long-segment proximal ureteral strictures or obliteration include ileal ureteral replacement and renal autotransplantation. However, their use is often limited due to potentially severe complications, including gastrointestinal issues (such as mucous secretion, absorption of metabolites from ileal mucosa, and the large cross-sectional diameter of the ileal lumen) and vascular complications (8-10). Previous research has shown that ureterocalicostomy is a safe and feasible option for patients with recurrent UPJO, particularly in cases where the renal pelvis is intrarenal, severely scarred, or too small to permit tension-free anastomosis (18). However, the patient in this case did not fully meet the criteria for this surgical approach. A promising alternative for urinary tract reconstruction involves utilizing the enlarged renal pelvis and urothelium, which has gained attention recently. The non-dismembered flap pyeloplasty technique incorporates the fibrotic, peristaltically impaired segment into the reconstructed ureter but presents challenges, especially with atrophic ureters. Conversely, dismembered repair remains widely used and can be adapted to most UPJs. Dismembered flap pyeloplasty requires complete excision of the fibrotic segment and replaces it with a tubular flap (19). However, the effectiveness of this method is limited by the width of the flap used to determine UPJ diameter, potentially leading to a narrower ureter. In recent years, several studies have confirmed the feasibility and efficacy of oral mucosal graft pyeloplasty compared to traditional pyeloplasty in the treatment of recurrent UPJO, particularly in cases of long-segment ureteral strictures, dense periureteral fibrosis, or complete obliteration of the ureteral lumen, as well as when local tissue is insufficient for a tension-free primary anastomosis (11,12). The choice between BMG and LMG for grafting remains controversial. Lumen et al. found that complications following LMG harvesting, such as difficulty opening the mouth and persistent numbness, were significantly fewer than those after BMG harvesting (20). Patients who smoke or chew betel quid often have poor oral hygiene, which can compromise the quality of the BMG (21,22). For patients with longer strictures, LMG can replace BMG for graft reconstruction (23). The benefits of LMG include their constant availability, ease of harvesting, strong infection resistance, and favorable tissue properties such as thick epithelium, thin lamina propria, good elasticity, resilience, and rich vascularization (24). Our team’s research confirms that LMGU is a safe, feasible, and effective long-term method for managing long proximal ureteral strictures (12). Table 1 presents a summary of the literature on non-dismembered flap pyeloplasty and LMGU. Table 1Literature review of previous reports on non-dismembered flap pyeloplasty and lingual mucosal graft ureteroplastyTechniqueAuthors [year]ApproachCasesLength of stricture (cm)Follow-up (months)Major complicationsSuccess rate (%)Non-dismembered flap pyeloplastyScardino et al. [1953] (25)Open6NA3–14None100Culp et al. [1954] (26)Open27NA6–24Severe and extensive ureteritis and periureteritis in 2; intrarenal hemorrhage in 1; urinary fistula in 292.6Oesterwitz et al. [1987] (27)Laparoscopic11NA6–30Complete loss of kidney function in 1; dislocation of thenephrostomy tube and urinoma formation in 1NABasiri et al. [2007] (28)Laparoscopic10NA4–25.5None100Symons et al. [2009] (29)Laparoscopic5NA3–60NoneNALingual mucosal graft ureteroplastyLi et al. [2016] (30)Laparoscopic13.09None100Fan et al. [2021] (31)Laparoscopic and robotic103.0–5.02–7None100Yang et al. [2022] (32)Robotic123.0–6.513–27Chronic intermittent low back pain in 192Liang et al. [2022] (12)Laparoscopic and robotic412.0–8.013–80Severe postoperative urinary tract infection in 197.6Chai et al. [2025] (13)Robotic762.0–11.513–48Postoperative hemostasis required reoperation in 1100NA, not available. Literature review of previous reports on non-dismembered flap pyeloplasty and lingual mucosal graft ureteroplasty NA, not available. The arterial plexus in the adventitia of the ureter gives rise to branches that form a finer network in the submucosa, from which capillaries drain into a venous plexus that re-enters the adventitia, following the arterial pathways (33). During surgery, a non-dismembered, vascularized renal pelvis flap with a length-to-width ratio of less than 3:1, along with preservation of the ureteral adventitia, is essential for maintaining blood supply, and the omentum is used to provide a vascular bed for the graft (27). It is imperative that the anastomosis ensures a tension-free, watertight connection that is both smooth and broad, facilitating proper alignment of the mucosa-to-mucosa interface. Nguyen et al. reported a novel technique for the treatment of complex ureteral strictures, involving the creation of a U-shaped renal pelvis flap as the posterior plate, with a BMG serving as the anterior plate (34). This technique aligns closely with our proposed approach. In cases of long proximal ureteral obliteration, approaches typically involve excising the stenotic segment, spatulating the dorsal ureter, performing anastomosis at both ends of the dorsal ureter, and conducting onlay ureteroplasty using the LMG (12). However, in cases where LMGU is not feasible due to long stricture length or immobility of the proximal ureter resulting from infection, scarring, or fibrosis, the technique we propose offers a potential solution to achieve a sufficiently wide and long ureteral lumen. In this study, we propose a novel technique of robotic tubular pyeloureteroplasty using a flap and LMG, where the flap forms a posterior plate and the LMG serves as the anterior plate. This technique aims to create a new, wide, and tubularized UPJ with adequate blood supply and tension-free anastomosis. Our approach combines the benefits of non-dismembered flap pyeloplasty and LMGU, making it suitable for patients with UPJO. This technique can potentially obviate the need for renal autotransplantation, ureterocalicostomy, or ileal ureteral replacement. Based on our experience, this combined technique may be considered for UPJO patients presenting with: (I) a long stricture length or immobility of the proximal ureter, resulting from infection, scarring, or fibrosis, which causes high tension at the anastomotic site or compromised blood supply, potentially precluding pyeloplasty; (II) a long segment of proximal ureteral obliteration or obstruction, which further complicates the technical feasibility of redo pyeloplasty. This study is based on a single case, which limits the broader applicability of the findings. Additionally, the 16-month follow-up period is relatively short, restricting long-term outcome evaluation and potential complications assessment. Furthermore, potential limitations such as graft contracture, ischemia, or concerns regarding long-term patency need to be carefully considered. Therefore, further large-scale, long-term prospective studies are needed to evaluate this novel technique. Conclusions Robotic tubular pyeloureteroplasty using a flap and LMG is a safe and effective surgical option, offering a promising treatment for selected patients with UPJO. This technique serves as an alternative for those with complex anatomical challenges typically encountered in pyeloplasty. Supplementary The article’s supplementary files as Acknowledgments None. Ethical Statement: The authors are accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved. All procedures performed in this study were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee(s), and with the Declaration of Helsinki and its subsequent amendments. Written informed consent was obtained from the patient for the publication of this case report and accompanying images. A copy of the written consent is available for review by the editorial office of this journal. Footnotes Reporting Checklist: The authors have completed the CARE reporting checklist. Available at https://tau.amegroups.com/article/view/10.21037/tau-2025-646/rc Funding: This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (grant No. 82470724); Zhongnan Hospital of Wuhan University (grant No. rcyj20230102) to B.L.; and the Institute of Urology, Wuhan University (No. ZLYNXM20200204) to C.L. Conflicts of Interest: All authors have completed the ICMJE uniform disclosure form (available at https://tau.amegroups.com/article/view/10.21037/tau-2025-646/coif). The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare. References Available at https://tau.amegroups.com/article/view/10.21037/tau-2025-646/prf Supplementary Materials The article’s supplementary files as