Willingness-to-pay for community-based health insurance among formal and informal doctors in Dhaka, Bangladesh: a comparative cross-sectional study Authors: Md Fuad Al Fidah, Syeda Sumaiya Efa, Md Ziaul Islam Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractIntroductionHealth insurance enables financial protection and reduces medical burdens. Currently, less than 1% of Bangladeshi citizens have health insurance coverage. We aimed to assess the willingness-to-pay for community-based health insurance and explore associated factors among formal and informal doctors in Bangladesh.MethodsThis comparative cross-sectional study was conducted on Bangladeshi doctors with formal and informal employment. For each group, 116 doctors were selected via purposive sampling, as no national register of doctors was available, indicating their current employment status and purposive selection ensured equal inclusion of formal and informal doctors. Separate binomial logistic regression models were fitted for each independent variable, adjusting for age and sex. The mean willingness-to-pay (95% CI) was measured using the double-bounded dichotomous choice approach of the contingent valuation method.ResultsThe median (IQR) age of the doctors was 34 (31.75–36.0) years, and 53.0% were male. Most (79.7%; 95% CI 74.0% to 84.7%) doctors exhibited willingness-to-pay for community-based health insurance with higher proportion among formal (85.3%) than informal (74.1%) doctors. The overall mean (95% CI) willingness-to-pay was 5.6% (5.1% to 6.2%) of monthly personal income and was higher among informal (5.8%; 5.0% to 6.6%) than formal (5.4%; 4.6% to 6.1%) doctors. Doctors seeking healthcare (adjusted OR (AOR): 0.28; 95% CI 0.08 to 0.99; p value=0.048) and having a middle career (AOR: 0.32; 95% CI 0.11 to 0.90; p value=0.031) were associated with lower odds of being willing-to-pay. Despite having lower mean willingness-to-pay, formal doctors showed higher odds (AOR: 2.02; 95% CI 1.01 to 4.07; p value=0.048) of accepting community-based health insurance.ConclusionsBoth formal and informal doctors showed high willingness-to-pay for community-based health insurance. Formal doctors were likely to contribute, while informal doctors expressed higher mean payments. Communication campaigns, tiered premiums and better healthcare quality could enhance participation. These findings offer insights for designing provider-supported community-based health insurance models that foster trust, include low-income groups and support universal health coverage in Bangladesh.Keywords: economics, Health Personnel, Public Health WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC Less than 1% of Bangladeshi citizens have health coverage. Less than 1% of Bangladeshi citizens have health coverage. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS 79.7% of doctors were willing-to-pay (WTP) for community-based health insurance (CBHI). 79.7% of doctors were willing-to-pay (WTP) for community-based health insurance (CBHI). The mean (95% CI) WTP was 5.6% (5.1% to 6.2%) of monthly personal income. The mean (95% CI) WTP was 5.6% (5.1% to 6.2%) of monthly personal income. Seeking healthcare, having a middle career and being formal doctors were predictors of WTP for CBHI. Seeking healthcare, having a middle career and being formal doctors were predictors of WTP for CBHI. HOW THIS STUDY MIGHT AFFECT RESEARCH, PRACTICE OR POLICY Designing CBHI policies tailored to formal and informal doctors’ needs. Designing CBHI policies tailored to formal and informal doctors’ needs. Flexible plans based on career stages can boost CBHI uptake, especially for informal and mid-career doctors. Flexible plans based on career stages can boost CBHI uptake, especially for informal and mid-career doctors. Introduction Individuals in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) face greater barriers to healthcare access than wealthier nations. An efficiently planned healthcare system is crucial for protecting the public from illness-related financial distress. However, rapidly rising healthcare costs, due to factors like ageing population and growing chronic diseases, pose a significant challenge.1 Approximately 800 million individuals allocate over 10% of their household income exclusively for medical care. According to the WHO, catastrophic health expenditures (CHE) have forced 100 million people worldwide into acute poverty.2 Access to affordable healthcare remains a profound challenge in Bangladesh. Existing research shows that approximately 26% of households experience CHE during hospitalisation each year.3 Examination into Bangladesh’s healthcare financial landscape makes it evident that the burden of out-of-pocket (OOP) medical costs is considerable. Research from 2015 revealed that Bangladeshi households collectively spend approximately US$1.49 billion annually on OOP medical expenses, accounting for 64.3% of the nation’s total health expenditures.4 Bangladesh has a large informal sector (85.1% of total workforce) that encompasses economic activities occurring outside formal systems.5 Unfortunately, most of the informal sector workers have limited or no access to health insurance (HI), which increases their risk of financial hardships. On the other hand, only less than 1% of the country’s total population, that too primarily those who are working in the formal sector, have the privilege of social health protection.6 In other words, the majority of both the formally and informally employed workforce lacks healthcare coverage and social protection. While the country aims to achieve universal coverage in coming decades, HI currently reaches a small portion of the population. There are two main options—standalone policies or policies bundled with life plans. Around 90 000 total life insurance policies for over 160 million people suggest an extremely low HI penetration.7 A pivotal concept in insurance is the willingness-to-pay (WTP), representing the maximum amount one will spend on a good or service. Health economists argue that WTP effectively develops strong insurance schemes and is an effective approach for developing robust HI schemes.8 The current projections in Bangladesh indicate that the number of doctors will be 125 000 by 2026, exceeding healthcare needs.9 Even now, annual medical graduates far exceed available job openings. Many must take informal jobs with precarious incomes and irregular work, rendering them uniquely vulnerable to financial crises if healthcare is needed. Due to the additional health and financial risks associated with their profession, not to mention the occupational hazards, HI is crucial for doctors to manage emergencies, support families and fulfil patient care duties without financial concerns. Additionally, doctors play a key role in service delivery, and their acceptance and participation are important for establishing any successful HI programme. Theories like Supplier-Induced Demand indicate that patients’ choice is often significantly impacted by the physicians’ views.10 It has also been suggested that healthcare reform prospects can be influenced by the physician’s opinion.11 Given the current extent of insurance coverage in Bangladesh, it is imperative to explore the doctors’ WTP for community-based health insurance (CBHI) to promote its uptake and reform policies. Doctors’ participation in CBHI has implications beyond their own protection. As trusted providers, their acceptance of such schemes can shape patients’ perceptions and willingness to enrol, thereby influencing broader community adoption of HI.12 Although several studies have assessed WTP for HI in Bangladesh, most focused on households, informal workers or mixed employee groups, with none specifically investigating doctors.13,16 Doctors constitute a distinct group due to their medical knowledge, occupational exposure and influence on patients’ health-seeking behaviour. Evidence from LMICs shows wide variation in WTP, largely shaped by income, occupation and healthcare experience. In Ethiopia, only 17% of health workers were WTP for social HI, rising to 29% among formal providers.17 18 By contrast, 54% of informal healthcare providers in Uganda expressed WTP.19 Despite these international findings, provider-level data from Bangladesh remain unavailable. This study, therefore, aimed to quantify doctors’ WTP for CBHI and identify factors associated with it. Methods Study design This was a comparative cross-sectional study conducted on formal and informal doctors in Dhaka city, Bangladesh. Study setting This study was conducted in Dhaka city, the capital and largest metropolitan area of Bangladesh. Dhaka is the country’s main hub for medical education and healthcare delivery, hosting government hospitals, private clinics and research centres. Both formally and informally employed doctors practice here across diverse service settings.9 The high density of medical institutions and mixed employment structures made Dhaka an appropriate site to compare doctors’ WTP for CBHI. Data were collected from different areas of the city to capture variation in workplace types and practice arrangements. Study period, population and sample size The study period was 1 July 2022 to 30 June 2023. The sample size was calculated using the following formula:20 n= (Zα+Zβ)2 ×[{P11-P1}+{P21-P2}](P2-P1)2. Here, P1=proportion of formal workers WTP for HI=0.80.15 P2=proportion of informal workers WTP for HI=0.93.16 Considering a 95% CI, 80% power and 10% non-responsive rate, the sample size for each group was 116. So, a total of 232 doctors working formally or informally at private chambers, government and non-government organisations like medical colleges and research centres of Dhaka city were purposively included in the study. Purposive sampling was chosen because doctors constitute a specific and often hard-to-reach professional group. Additionally, there is no up-to-date national register of doctors indicating their current employment status in Bangladesh that could serve as a sampling frame, and purposive selection allowed us to ensure equal representation of both formal and informal doctors. Data collection Data were collected using a semi-structured, interviewer-administered questionnaire developed following a comprehensive literature review.13,19 The tool covered socio-demographic, occupational and health-related characteristics, including healthcare use and expenditure. It also included the double-bounded dichotomous choice questions for estimating WTP for CBHI. The questionnaire was pre-tested among 30 doctors (15 formal, 15 informal) to assess clarity and timing. Necessary wording adjustments were made based on feedback. Data collection was performed by the authors between July 2022 and June 2023 after obtaining written informed consent from all participants. The complete questionnaire is provided as ‘online supplemental annexure’. Outcome variables Willingness-to-pay for community-based health insurance WTP for CBHI was the dependent variable. It was measured using the double-bounded dichotomous choice approach within the contingent valuation method. Each participant was asked whether they would pay a proposed percentage of their monthly personal income as a premium for the insurance scheme. A ‘yes’ response was followed by a higher bid, and a ‘no’ response by a lower bid. Four starting bids (6%, 4%, 2% and 1% of monthly income) were selected after a pre-test among 30 doctors to identify realistic payment ranges. The final outcome was categorised as ‘willing’ or ‘not willing’ to pay any positive amount for enrolment. The mean WTP was calculated as a percentage of monthly personal income. The CBHI model presented to doctors was adapted from studies conducted in Addis Ababa, which identified OOP expenses and limited coverage as major barriers to participation.17 21 In this scheme, participants would pay a monthly premium entitling themselves, their spouses and dependants under 18 years to free healthcare and prescribed medicines. All levels of care would be fully covered through an independently managed health fund. Independent variables The independent variables of this study included the type of doctors,22 age (in years), sex, religion, marital status, postgraduate, monthly personal income (MPI) in Bangladeshi Taka (BDT), monthly family income (MFI) in BDT, number of family members, number of under 5 children, number of elderly, service years,23 clinical attachment, workdays per week, work hours per day, history of illness, sought healthcare and healthcare expenditure. A detailed definition of these variables is provided in online supplemental table 1. Data analysis The study employed the double-bounded dichotomous choice (DBDC) method within the contingent valuation framework to estimate the mean WTP. Each participant was first asked whether they would pay a proposed percentage of their monthly personal income as a premium for CBHI. A ‘yes’ response triggered a higher follow-up bid, and a ‘no’ response triggered a lower bid, producing two data points per respondent. This method increases statistical efficiency and improves precision compared with single-bounded formats.24 There are four possible outcomes: (1) yes-yes (WTP>second higher bid), (2) yes-no (first bid>WTP>second higher bid), (3) no-yes (first bid