Comparison of purse-string technique versus linear suture for skin closure after stoma reversal: a meta-analysis of high-quality studies Authors: Filippo Carannante, Guglielmo Niccolò Piozzi, Gianluca Costa, Valentina Miacci, Gianfranco Bianco, Vincenzo Schiavone, Jim S. Khan, Marco Caricato, Gabriella Teresa Capolupo Published: 2025 ABSTRACT PurposeStoma reversal is associated with notable postoperative morbidity. Several techniques exist for skin closure after stoma reversal, with linear primary closure (LC) and purse-string closure (PS) being the most common. This systematic review and meta-analysis aim to compare LC and PS skin closure after stoma reversal in terms of surgical site infection (SSI) rates, wound healing, and cosmesis.MethodsIn accordance with the PRISMA statement, a systematic review of skin closure after stoma reversal was conducted using MEDLINE (PubMed), Embase, Web of Science, and Scopus.ResultsEleven studies, enrolling 1,052 patients (PS, n=534; LC, n=518), published between 2006 and 2024, were included. The overall quality of the studies was considered acceptable, with a mean Jadad scale score of 4 (range, 3–5). Patients underwent ileostomy or ileostomy/colostomy in 6 and 5 studies, respectively. No differences were observed between groups in operative time, length of hospital stay, intestinal obstruction, or incisional hernia. However, SSI and overall infection rates were higher in the LC group, with a statistically significant difference for SSI.ConclusionSkin closure following stoma reversal using the PS technique may offer advantages over LC. PS is associated with significantly lower SSI rates compared to LC. Although a large randomized controlled trial with long-term follow-up is still required, current findings suggest that PS could be considered the standard of care for wound closure after ileostomy reversal. INTRODUCTION The use of a protective stoma during rectal surgery reduces the rates of symptomatic anastomotic leakage, reoperation, and severity of complications [1–4]. However, stoma reversal carries postoperative morbidity rates ranging from 17% to 40% [1–4]. Surgical site infection (SSI) is the most frequent complication after stoma reversal, with rates reported as high as 40% [1, 2]. SSIs contribute to prolonged hospital stays and increased costs due to medication use and outpatient wound care. At present, there is no gold standard for skin closure after stoma reversal. Multiple techniques have been described, including antibiotic skin implants [1], subcutaneous drains, iodine irrigation, and various closure methods [1–4]. The main surgical techniques are linear primary closure (LC), open-wound healing with secondary closure, delayed primary closure, and purse-string closure (PS). The PS technique, first described by Banerjee [5], involves circumferential partial approximation of the skin without complete wound closure, leaving a small defect to heal by secondary intention. This approach permits drainage and typically results in a small round scar with potentially improved cosmetic outcomes. Despite its widespread adoption, evidence remains inconclusive regarding whether LC or PS is superior in terms of SSI rates, wound healing, and cosmetic results. This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to compare LC and PS skin closure after stoma reversal with respect to SSI, healing, and cosmesis. METHODS Literature search strategy This systematic review was conducted in accordance with the 2020 PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines [6] to identify studies comparing surgical outcomes of LC and PS skin closure after stoma reversal. All PRISMA steps were performed independently by 2 authors (FC and GC). Any discrepancies or final decisions on study eligibility were resolved by consensus. Identification and screening This study was registered in PROSPERO (No. CRD42024568601). A systematic search was conducted in MEDLINE (PubMed), Embase, Web of Science, and Scopus to identify studies comparing outcomes of PS versus LC for wound closure following ileostomy or colostomy reversal. The following search terms were applied: (purse string OR purse-string OR purse) AND (stoma OR ileostomy OR colostomy), without restrictions on sex or language. Restrictions were applied to include only human studies, published in English, up to August 20, 2024. Titles of the retrieved studies were screened, and duplicates were removed. Titles and abstracts were then reviewed manually using predetermined inclusion and exclusion criteria. For studies meeting the initial screening criteria, full-text articles were retrieved and evaluated for relevance. Nonretrievable studies were excluded. A supplementary manual search was also performed in Google Scholar, and reference lists of retrieved manuscripts were reviewed to identify additional relevant studies. Records were managed using Mendeley Desktop ver. 1.19.4 (Elsevier) and Covidence (Covidence). Eligibility criteria Studies were selected according to the PICOS (population, intervention, comparison, outcomes, and study design) framework [7]. Only randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing PS with LC after stoma reversal were included. At least one perioperative outcome of interest was required, regardless of follow-up duration. Studies were excluded from the quantitative analysis if the number of patients or outcomes of interest in each group could not be extracted. Case series with retrospective designs, case reports, technical notes, and video reports were also excluded. When multiple papers were published by the same group of authors over time, all were reviewed, but only the most recent, informative, or highest-quality study was included. Data extraction and quality assessment Following the eligibility criteria, 2 reviewers (FC and GC) independently assessed each study to minimize selection bias. Study quality was evaluated using the Jadad scale for RCTs [8], and data extraction was performed in parallel. Disagreements were resolved through consensus with a third reviewer (GTC). The following demographic variables were collected when available: age, sex distribution, body mass index, American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) physical status, indication for surgery, diabetes mellitus, renal failure, smoking status, and preoperative immunosuppression. Surgical outcomes assessed included operative time, hospital length of stay (LOS), prolonged ileus and/or intestinal obstruction, SSI, and overall infection rate. Intraoperative and postoperative complications were reported quantitatively and qualitatively whenever possible. Statistical analysis The analysis followed the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions [9]. Continuous variables were analyzed using the weighted mean difference (WMD) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs). Categorical variables were assessed using odds ratios (OR) with 95% CI. For variables reported as median with range or interquartile range, values were converted to mean and standard deviation, according to Hozo et al. [10]. Subgroup analyses were conducted for studies limited to ileostomy closure and for mixed series where colostomy and ileostomy reversal were not separately reported. Heterogeneity was assessed using the I2 statistic. An I2 value of ≤40% was considered trivial or unimportant, and ≥75% was considered considerable heterogeneity. When I2 exceeded 50%, pooled estimates were generated using a random-effects model. For the Q index (chi-square test of heterogeneity), P<0.10 was considered significant; otherwise, P<0.05 was regarded as statistically significant. Publication bias was assessed using funnel plot asymmetry, with the Egger test [11] for continuous outcomes and with the Harbord test [12] for binary outcomes. Statistical analysis was carried out using Stata ver. 16 (Stata Corp). RESULTS Literature search and general review A total of 334 studies were identified. After duplicate removal and title and abstract screening, 57 full-text papers were evaluated. Thirteen studies were deemed eligible (Fig. 1), and 11 studies were included [13–23], enrolling 1,052 patients (PS, n=534; LC, n=518). The studies were conducted in Australia (n=1), Germany (n=1), Mexico (n=1), Switzerland and the United States (n=1), the Philippines (n=1), Iran (n=1), Japan (n=2), Ireland (n=1), India (n=1), and Italy (n=1). Ten studies were prospective RCTs, and one included a propensity score matching analysis. All but one was single-center studies, with one having a multicenter design. Patient recruitment occurred between 2006 and 2021, and publications ranged from 2010 to 2024. The overall quality of the included studies was considered acceptable, with a mean Jadad scale score of 4 (range, 3 to 5). In 6 studies, only patients with ileostomies were included, while 5 studies included patients with either ileostomy or colostomy. All studies examined patients with colorectal cancer or benign conditions (diverticular disease or inflammatory bowel disease) who underwent bowel resection with stoma creation and subsequently required stoma reversal. Patient characteristics and surgical details are summarized in Tables 1 and 2 [13–23]. Comparison of outcomes of interest Because patient satisfaction (both aesthetic and overall) was assessed using different methods across studies, only qualitative descriptions of these outcomes are presented in Table 2 [13–23]. Operative time Eight studies with 734 patients (PS, n=375; LC, n=359) reported operative time [14–17, 19–22]. Pooled analysis showed no difference between groups (WMD, 1.046; 95% CI, –2.462 to 4.555; P=0.559) (Fig. 2A) [14–17, 19–22]. No heterogeneity was observed (I2=0%, P=0.518) (Fig. 3A). Publication bias assessment using the Egger linear regression test showed no asymmetry (Y intercept, –0.83; P=0.408). Length of stay Seven studies including 630 patients (PS, n=321; LC, n=309) analyzed postoperative LOS [14–17, 20, 22, 23]. No statistically significant difference in LOS was found (WMD, –0.874; 95% CI, –2.207 to 0.459; P=0.199) (Fig. 2B) [14–17, 20, 22, 23]. Considerable heterogeneity was observed (I2=81.24%, P<0.001), mainly due to the findings of Yamamoto et al. [20]. Therefore, a random-effects model was applied. Funnel plot analysis showed asymmetry, with Egger regression test significant at Y intercept –4.04 (P<0.001) (Fig. 3B). Surgical site infection All studies reported SSI outcomes, involving 950 participants (PS, n=534; LC, n=416) [13–23]. Pooled analysis demonstrated a statistically significant lower risk of SSI in the PS group (logOR, –1.819; 95% CI, –2.281 to –1.358; P<0.001). No heterogeneity was detected (I2=0%, P=0.624) (Fig. 2C) [13–23]. The Harbord test for funnel plot asymmetry was not significant (Y intercept, –0.68; P=0.493) (Fig. 3C). Overall infection Two studies with 230 participants (PS, n=116; LC, n=114) reported overall infection rates [14, 23]. A statistically significant lower risk was observed in the PS group (logOR, –0.837; 95% CI, –1.480 to –0.194; P=0.011). No heterogeneity was observed (I2=0.00%, P=0.719) (Fig. 2D) [14, 23]. The Harbord test for funnel plot asymmetry was not significant (Y intercept, 0.34; P=0.736) (Fig. 3D). Intestinal obstruction Three studies including 262 patients (PS, n=132; LC, n=130) reported intestinal obstruction as an outcome [16, 21, 23]. No significant difference between groups was found (logOR, 0.176; 95% CI, –0.746 to 1.089; P=0.708). No heterogeneity was detected (I2=0%; P=0.757) (Fig. 2E) [16, 21, 23]. The Harbord test for funnel plot asymmetry was not significant (Y intercept, 1.03; P=0.303) (Fig. 3E). Incisional hernia Five studies including 474 patients (PS, n=239; LC, n=235) analyzed incisional hernia rates [13, 16, 18, 20, 21]. Pooled analysis showed a nonsignificant trend toward lower hernia risk in the PS group (logOR, –0.656; 95% CI, –1.341 to 0.029; P=0.061). No heterogeneity was detected (I2=0.00%; P=0.510) (Fig. 2F) [13, 16, 18, 20, 21]. The Harbord test for funnel plot asymmetry was not significant (Y intercept, –1.56; P=0.118) (Fig. 3F). DISCUSSION This meta-analysis included 11 high-quality studies [13, 16–23] comparing surgical outcomes between PS and LC closure techniques following stoma reversal. The available evidence demonstrates that PS significantly reduces SSI rates without affecting operative duration, LOS, incisional hernia rates, or postoperative obstruction. PS closure offers advantages in SSI prevention. Stoma reversal carries a high risk of SSI due to skin contamination around the stoma site and potential exposure to intestinal contents [24, 25]. The PS technique leaves a central opening of 0.5 to 1 cm, which prevents fluid accumulation and allows continuous drainage of exudate [26]. The wound heals secondarily through granulation and may provide superior cosmetic results. In contrast, LC involves complete closure of the wound; trapped subcutaneous exudate may not drain effectively, increasing the risk of abscess formation from bacterial contamination [27]. Higher SSI rates are linked with increased risk of incisional hernia, prolonged LOS, and greater medical costs. Although this analysis did not reveal a statistically significant difference in LOS, a correlation between SSI and incisional hernia incidence suggests that inadequate drainage may play a role. A meta-analysis by Li et al. [28] similarly found PS to be the most effective closure method for preventing SSI, outperforming closure with drains, secondary closure, loose primary closure, and delayed primary closure. The most recent systematic review prior to this analysis was conducted by Rondelli et al. [29] in 2018. They identified PS as the best closure technique for reducing SSI, based on 5 RCTs, but found no significant differences between PS and LC in operative time, LOS, incisional hernia, or intestinal obstruction. Unlike Rondelli et al. [29], which considered only RCTs, the strength of our analysis lies in the inclusion of the latest high-quality studies, 10 RCTs and 1 propensity score–matched study, while excluding observational designs. The total sample size increased to 1,052 patients, with 534 in the PS group and 518 in the LC group. Six outcomes were analyzed, providing more robust and less biased evidence. Although 6 studies reported cosmetic outcomes, the considerable heterogeneity in study design and outcome assessment precluded a reliable meta-analysis of cosmesis. Limitations This study has several limitations. First, the included trials involved relatively small sample sizes, limiting statistical power to detect small differences in outcomes. Second, none of the trials provided long-term follow-up data. Incisional hernia, which typically occurs an average of 9 months after stoma reversal, was reported in only 5 studies [25]. Third, this meta-analysis did not evaluate cost-effectiveness. SSI represents a significant economic burden through prolonged LOS, additional medications, and higher treatment costs [30]. However, because healthcare costs differ across countries, each health system requires its own cost-effectiveness analysis to support decision-making. Conclusions Skin closure following stoma reversal with the PS technique appears more advantageous than LC. PS is associated with significantly lower rates of SSI compared with LC. Although a large RCT with long-term follow-up is still needed, current evidence suggests that PS closure could be considered the standard of care for wound closure after ileostomy reversal.