The use of research evidence in blood collection policy and practice: a qualitative study with frontline staff, middle managers and senior managers Authors: Amanda Thijsen, Barbara Masser, Tanya E Davison, Abigail R-A Edwards, Gabriel Moore, Anna Williamson Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundThere is a known disconnect between scientific knowledge and its application in routine practice, known as the research–practice gap. A potential strategy to encourage research engagement among end-users is embedding researchers within an organization. This study set out to understand the views and experiences of senior managers, middle managers, and frontline staff in one department accessing and using research in a large organization with embedded researchers. We also investigated staff capacity to engage with research to identify opportunities to strengthen the use of research-based evidence in practice.MethodsWe conducted 14 semi-structured in-depth interviews between November 2022 and April 2023 with senior managers, middle managers, and frontline staff working in the blood collection department at Australian Red Cross Lifeblood. Directed qualitative content analysis and the SPIRIT Action Framework were used to interpret the data.ResultsCapacity to engage with and use research varied greatly between participants and appeared to be affected by their role, training, and prior work experience. Participants valued research highly. However, only a few felt confident in their knowledge and skills to engage with research. Participants described a lack of visibility of research within the organization as well as systems and structures to access research. Experiences with accessing research, generating research, and interacting with researchers were mostly limited to senior managers. Research was chiefly used by senior managers to support changes, followed by understanding blood collection issues, and informing policy development. Although present, research use was often not visible to frontline staff.ConclusionsTo increase research engagement and use, organizations should invest in strengthening their tools and systems, providing opportunities to increase individual knowledge and skills to engage with research, and increase the visibility of research and how it has been used.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12961-025-01428-3.Keywords: Research use, Research engagement, SPIRIT action framework, Blood, Evidence-informed policy making, Frontline staff, Middle managers, Senior managers, Policy makers Background Research is a source of knowledge that can help organizations improve their policies and procedures as well as overcome potential challenges. However, there is a known disconnect between scientific knowledge and its application in routine practice, known as the research–practice gap [1, 2]. Consequently, policies and procedures may not be aligned with current evidence, leading to high costs, inappropriate practices, and waste of resources [3]. To facilitate knowledge translation (KT), it is essential for end users to not only be able to access, understand and apply research evidence but also to be motivated to embed research into practice [4]. However, end users at various levels within an organization may experience barriers to engaging with research. Frontline staff often have insufficient time to engage with research owing to heavy workloads, lack of relevant skills, negative views on benefits of research to practice and their roles often being task-oriented without authority to change practice [5, 6]. Middle managers have been identified as instrumental in summarizing research and disseminating this knowledge with their frontline teams [7]. However, they may also have limited knowledge of how to access, interpret and appraise research. Further, research engagement of frontline staff and middle managers is affected by how it is supported and valued within the organization (i.e. the implementation climate) [4, 7]. A potential strategy to overcome the research–practice gap and encourage research engagement is to embed researchers within nonacademic organizations. This strategy can increase the likelihood that research activities and the knowledge needs of policy-makers and practitioners (i.e. end users) are aligned [2, 8, 9]. Further, it can build the capacity of end users through exposure to research activities and provide opportunities to collaborate on finding solutions to organizational issues [2, 8]. Embedding researchers in organizations has been shown to increase end users’ access to research-based evidence, which can be used to address organizational challenges and create positive change [10]. Using the SPIRIT Action framework, we conducted a qualitative study to explore research engagement among staff at an organization with embedded researchers. This framework was selected because it was designed to identify determinants of research use in health policy which are potentially modifiable for intervention [11]. The SPIRIT Action framework [11] has three domains (Fig. 1). The first, individual and organizational capacity, focuses on potential determinants of research use, including (a) the value the individual places on using research, (b) the confidence the individual has in their knowledge and skills for engaging with research, (c) the perceived value their organization places on using research and (d) the tools and systems their organization has to support research use. The second, research engagement actions, focuses on potential actions that can be taken to engage with research and researchers. These include (a) accessing research, (b) appraising research for relevance and quality, (c) generating or commissioning research and analyses and (d) interacting with researchers. The last domain, research use, captures the way in which research informs policy or practice. This domain captures (a) conceptual use – where research is used to clarify understanding about a policy or practice issue, (b) instrumental use – where research evidence directly informs policy or practice, (c) tactical use – where research evidence is used to help justify or persuade others to support a predetermined decision and (d) imposed use – where research evidence is used owing to organizational requirements [11, 12]. The aims of the current study are to: (1) provide insight into how research is engaged with and used at an organization with a dedicated research department from the perspectives of people working at various levels in policy and practice; and (2) identify opportunities to strengthen KT. The SPIRIT Action framework. Source: Redman et al. [11] Methods The study was conducted at Australian Red Cross Lifeblood (Lifeblood), which is the sole collector and provider of blood and blood components in Australia, collecting blood from voluntary and nonremunerated donors. Lifeblood is unique through its hybrid focus on manufacturing and supply of blood and blood-related products to the health sector, ensuring appropriate care and health of blood donors, and encouraging continued volunteerism of donors. It has an internal Research and Development (R&D) department which conducts basic and applied research to address problems faced by Lifeblood as well as gaps in knowledge in broader transfusion medicine. Our study population included members of the department focusing on blood collection, which has a great potential for research engagement owing to the applied nature of the research engaged in and R&D’s strong focus on solving blood collection problems [13]. We interviewed three groups of participants: (1) senior managers – responsible for policy development, (2) middle managers – donor centre managers and area managers who manage blood collection centres and (3) frontline staff – registered nurses and non-medically trained nursing assistants who collect blood. Data collection The study was approved by the University of Sydney Human Research Ethics Committee (reference no. 2020/254) and the Australian Red Cross Lifeblood Ethics Committee (2020#14). Semistructured interviews were conducted by the first author from November 2022 to April 2023. A purposive sampling strategy [14] was adopted to ensure participants were diverse in their professional roles and locations. We invited five senior managers and five area managers (i.e. middle managers) to participate in the study via email. One of the senior managers, responsible for overseeing research activities in blood collection centres, then identified centres available to be contacted for our study. We first invited the centre manager (i.e. middle manager) to participate in an interview and they assisted in selecting frontline staff to participate in the study on the basis of their workload and availability. In total, 14 staff members participated in this study: 5 senior managers, 6 middle managers and 3 frontline staff members from different centres. This sample size was deemed adequate to answer our research question while working within our constraints of available research participants and time [15]. Data collection occurred at a time when there were frontline staff shortages, making it difficult for staff to leave their daily tasks, such as collecting blood, to participate in interviews. Participants had worked at the organization between 3 years and 31 years. Topic guides were tailored specifically for each participant group (see Supplementary Material). With written consent, interviews were conducted via Microsoft (MS) Teams, and each interview lasted 26–57 min. All interviews were recorded and transcribed verbatim. The researchers The first author has worked as a researcher in the R&D department for 11 years. The second author holds a joint research position with the University of Queensland and R&D at Lifeblood and has worked in blood donation research for 23 years. The third author has previously worked as an internal researcher within R&D at Lifeblood for 5 years. These experiences and knowledge of the area informed the study approach, including study design, participant recruitment, data collection, analysis of data, and interpretation of the findings. Further, the researchers’ insider perspective may have resulted in more appropriate interpretation of the data owing to a better understanding of the organizational context. The use of a coding framework and a second external coder, as well as adherence to ethical and professional standards, minimized the risk of potential bias. Data analysis Directed qualitative content analysis [16] was used to analyse the data. Guided by the SPIRIT Action framework [11], a predetermined coding framework was developed, including the following domains: capacity, research engagement actions, type of research use and purpose of research use. First, transcripts were checked against the audio files, which simultaneously allowed for familiarization with the data. Second, the predetermined codes were pilot tested by two authors (A.T. and A.E.) independently applying them to two transcripts in MS Word with model fit subsequently discussed. Third, all transcripts were uploaded to NVivo (QSR International) for coding and analysis. The first author then applied the coding framework to all transcripts. Relevant data that did not fit into the predetermined coding framework were inductively coded. Finally, descriptions were written for each SPIRIT domain by examining the categories, codes, and coded data. Results Capacity for research use Research is valued All participants felt that research was “important” and of “interest” to their work facilitating blood collection. In particular, health-related research was valued highly by participants because they perceive that they work in health and often had a background in nursing. Data and research I think are fundamentals for anyone who’s playing in the healthcare space. (senior manager) However, some participants, in particular frontline staff, felt that it was unclear how research was used to inform blood collection policies and practices. For there to be an understanding that the changes we make and the things that we do are driven by research …we would have a lot of people that would not even know that. What is research? We would have a lot of people that don’t understand where that sits with us in an organisation. (middle manager) Knowledge and skills Participants reported a mixed level of knowledge and skills to engage with research, influenced by their educational background and prior work environments as opposed to their current position. For example, one senior manager felt confident engaging with research evidence through their previous work experience. When asked if they found it easy to apply research evidence, their response was: Personally, I think it is, because I’ve been in roles in the past in healthcare, or in government, or in the universities. I don’t know if everyone at Lifeblood, who I work with has that know-how though… But that’s because I’ve been trained in that, and I’ve done it before. (senior manager) Other participants expressed less confidence in appraising, interpreting and applying research owing to a lack of education and/or training. I see a lot of research papers come through and it’s just way over my head, because I don’t come from that… The research papers that I like to see are the ones that are a bit more basic for want of a better word, in terms of you don’t need that clinical expertise or scientific expertise. (senior manager) Tools and systems The most frequently reported mechanism for accessing research was the inclusion of a plain language summary in a department newsletter. In particular, this was viewed as the only method for frontline staff to learn about research. I think that would probably be the only thing that I can think of that I would know about there being research being conducted and what the outcome was. (frontline staff) Another reported mechanism for sharing research evidence was the internal library service. However, only two participants – from the same team – mentioned using the internal library service to access research. Many other participants did not know about it or believed it no longer existed. We’ve had a really good library, and you used to get an email out to say, ‘Oh, there’s an article on whatever it was’. And you could often request the article. But we obviously don’t have a library anymore, or we do, but no one sends anything out. (middle manager) Being a member of a committee was another mechanism for senior managers to learn about research and interact with researchers: “We’ve got the committee, so we can hear what’s coming up and papers and things we can see in that committee” (senior manager). However, this was limited to senior managers; frontline staff and middle managers reported an absence of formal structures where they could hear about or interact with research: “I don’t think there’s any set way that we share the information” (middle manager). Other avenues mentioned by senior managers included webinars hosted by researchers, ad hoc meetings with researchers, and receiving a copy of the R&D annual report. In general, many participants felt that there was a lack of a formal organizational structures or systems in place for them to access research. A few middle managers and frontline staff could not recall receiving any information about research. As one participant explained: It isn’t something that is easily accessed. If I currently was like, I’m really interested in X, I wouldn’t know where to go… you’d have to go through people and hope that they know where to look. There’s no ease of access. I would say that is a problem. (middle manager) A few participants who were relatively new to the organization also highlighted that accessing and learning about research is not included in training for new staff. I don’t believe it sits alongside our training program at all …We do a lot of virtual learning and training now, and most of it’s about compliance and stuff. But there isn’t really a lot of research in any of that. (middle manager) Research engagement actions Accessing research Some senior managers had actively searched for research to support their work, in particular those with a clinical background. However, they mentioned preferring to receive information rather than searching for it owing to time constraints. I love being pushed for information, I’m not great at trying to find it myself. That’s probably more reflective of my workload and time. (senior manager) This experience was shared among middle managers and frontline staff. Most had not actively searched for research because of time constraints or not knowing where to look. As one participant explained: You just don’t know where to look. Like, you don’t have time to learn where all that stuff is. It’s hard enough just learning where the [blood collection] resources are, let alone anything else to be honest. (frontline staff) Appraising research Of those who had accessed research, most did not indicate appraising its relevance and quality. This may be attributed to a lack of understanding of the content and methods of the research: I would read, but a lot of the data goes over my head unless it’s in a graph form that I can easily understand or a pie chart or something. But a lot of it’s interesting, really interesting. (frontline staff) Generating research or analysis Some senior managers indicated that they had partnered with researchers to conduct research. Two participants in particular highlighted collaborating with researchers to develop questionnaires and perform statistical analysis to evaluate an initiative. I do work with researchers, and including researchers’ help really and even statistical help and understanding the analysis and the reports. We’ve worked with researchers to set up survey questions and to get it done correctly. (senior manager) The other senior managers rarely commissioned research activities and were often informed of research evidence without playing an active role in generating it. When asked about any barriers to generating research, one participant mentioned a lack of motivation in the department: “I don’t think there’s a barrier. I think there needs to be more of an appetite for it” (senior manager). However, a potential method to overcome this barrier is to have someone actively championing the research: If you put it on Connect [internal website], you put it on the R&D page or whatever, no one’s gonna see it, no one’s gonna talk about it. The only time that you’ll get investment from probably most of the businesses is if someone was leading and driving and communicating it. (senior manager) Interacting with researchers Experiences of interacting with researchers was limited to senior managers and a few middle managers. All of the senior managers had regular interactions with researchers via meetings which would inform them about current research activities and findings. This exposure was seen as beneficial to be able to identify sources of information at a later date: …we can see what people are doing the research into, we can see the papers. And I think we know who to go to if we need more information. (senior manager) However, one of the participants also highlighted that the timing of when the research is shared by the researcher and when it is needed by the end user do not always align, demonstrating the need for other engagement strategies. We will go looking for it, maybe not when you want to tell us but there’ll be a time where we’ll think, ‘Oh, yeah. We heard about that. Let’s go back and see what happened and what information we can find’. (senior manager) One middle manager mentioned being part of a steering committee of a research project because she was interested in the topic and reached out to the research team to be involved. Other middle managers talked about facilitating research activities in their centres such as collecting extra blood samples. We were taking extra blood sample tubes for someone to collect. I was across that. But if it wasn’t my centre, I may not necessarily know that research is happening in the background. (middle manager) Research use Tactical The most frequently reported use of research among senior managers was to support changes being made to policies and procedures. Senior managers reported that they used research evidence to prepare papers for internal meetings to support a decision they would like to be made. They also indicated sharing this evidence in their communications to blood collection teams to encourage uptake of the change. For me, in my teams and our delivery of change or delivery of any program is there is science behind it, and you have to tell the people that. That’s how you get their buy in. (senior manager) However, the use of research in policy decisions was not always visible to middle managers and frontline staff. They expressed the desire to learn more about the research evidence that either informed or supported proposed changes. For example, when asked how important it was that changes were supported by research evidence, one participant responded: “To me it’s very important, because that’s how I function, evidence-based practice. I want to know all that to make sure that I’m operating with integrity.” But when asked if the evidence behind a change is often shared, she responded: “No, not as much. If a change is implemented, it’s just like, ‘heads up, this change is happening’. Often there’s no why. So, people just go, ‘Oh, another change. What’s happening?’ Whereas maybe if you had a why…” (frontline staff). Conceptual Senior managers recalled having used research conceptually to provide insights into issues the organization was facing and using that research to inform policy changes. For example, one participant explained his view on the role of research: Research is like the engine at the forefront of, like finding out why and then bring it to us and go well, this is what donors are saying or non-donors or lapsed donors are saying... Then we need to change it into ways our team can understand that research, turn into an operational BAU, and ensure that we communicate it to the team. (senior manager) Similarly, interventional research that was seen as too complicated and not fit for purpose had been used as inspiration for new procedures. For example, one senior manager described using a research study as inspiration to develop a new tool to improve collection success: [The research] was a little bit complicated and it didn’t work. But that was a springboard for me. (senior manager) Instrumental To a lesser extent, research was also reported to directly inform policy or practice changes. Participants mentioned using research evidence to inform changes to clinical practice such as donor selection criteria. As one participant explained: The research that’s happening and what we’re seeing out there does cascade through into changes to [standard operating procedures] or instructions or how we go about doing our work. (senior manager) Imposed None of the participants indicated that the organization required them to use research. Discussion This study examined the capacity and extent of research engagement of frontline staff, middle managers and senior managers in one department within a blood collection agency with a separate internal research department. Capacity to engage with research varied between senior managers and the other levels. While research evidence was highly valued by all participants, middle managers and frontline staff described a lack of visibility of research within the organization. Further, participants reported mixed knowledge and skills around engaging with research, influenced by their educational background and prior work settings. Senior managers most often reported more awareness of organizational tools and systems. They also reported more experiences engaging with research, such as accessing research evidence and interacting with researchers. However, almost all participants engaged with research evidence passively owing to time and workload constraints. Research was mostly used by senior managers as evidence to support a predetermined decision, provide insights or generate ideas to manage blood collection issues, or to inform changes to blood collection policies. However, this use was often not visible to middle managers and frontline staff who expressed a desire to see more research evidence in communications about changes made to policies, procedures and guidelines to increase their understanding of the change and motivate uptake. To our knowledge, this was the first study to examine research engagement among end users in a blood donation setting. The experiences reported here, however, are similar to those noted in other health-related fields [17–19]. Barriers to research engagement, such as lack of time, poor access to research evidence and perceived lack of relevant research evidence, were also found in our study. Our recent review of the literature indicated that blood donor research literature is in the early stages of KT [20], which may affect the availability of relevant research evidence to end users. Further, research has shown that transfusion medicine researchers typically engage in traditional diffusion strategies and consult with end users but to a lesser extent use tailored dissemination strategies and actively engage end users in their research [21, 22]. These actions by researchers may have affected the engagement actions and research use observed in our study. A closer examination of determinants in the Capacity domain shows opportunities to strengthen research engagement as these determinants are potentially modifiable [12]. At an individual level, research was valued. However, the confidence of participants to engage with research appeared to be dependent on their education and prior work experience regardless of their managerial level. Individual capacity can be built through training, or individual or team-based mentoring with a KT specialist or researcher, both of which have been shown to increase research engagement [23–25]. At the organizational level, how research was used lacked visibility, and gaps were identified around tools and systems to support research engagement. Research infrastructure might be improved through increasing awareness of and access to the internal library, an accessible research evidence database and/or regular meetings highlighting relevant research accessible to all staff [25–27]. Further, how research has informed new policies or practices or changes to existing policies or practices should be highlighted to increase visibility of research and encourage uptake among middle managers and frontline staff [27]. Finally, dedicated KT positions, such as a senior leadership position for KT, could be introduced to champion research engagement and use through facilitating relationships between researchers and end users, summarizing relevant research and providing research expertise to business priorities [24, 26]. Limitations It is important to note the limitations of this study when considering the findings. First, our sample size was limited to 14 participants. We achieved good representation of senior and middle managers within the single department targeted. However, we were only able to recruit three frontline staff from different centres owing to recruitment occurring during frontline staff shortages. Further, we were limited in our recruitment to select blood collection centres owing to organizational procedures. While our participants provided great insights, a future survey study with a shorter time commitment could further explore some of these experiences among frontline staff. Second, owing to the qualitative nature of this study, the information provided was subjective. The organization could have more tools and systems in place to support research engagement than reported. Third, the interviewer’s position within the organization’s research department may have influenced what participants disclosed in the interviews and introduced researcher bias. Finally, the study was conducted within a single department of an organization, and additional work is needed to understand research engagement in other areas of the organization and other blood collection agencies. Despite these limitations, this study provides insights into research engagement capacity, actions and use of research of end users working in a department within an organization – which has a separate internal research department – and identified opportunities to further strengthen the visibility and use of research evidence in practice. Supplementary Information Additional file 1 Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank all the participants for participating in this study. Abbreviations Knowledge Translation Research & Development Author contributions AT, BM, TD and AW designed and planned the study. AT was responsible for the study conduct, including data collection. AT and AE analysed the data under guidance of AW. AT wrote the first draft of the manuscript. All authors have been involved in drafting the manuscript and approved the final manuscript. Funding Australian governments fund the Australian Red Cross Lifeblood for the provision of blood, blood products and services to the Australian community. Data availability The data generated and/or analysed during the current study are not publicly available owing privacy restrictions, but anonymized copies of original transcripts may be available from the corresponding author on reasonable request, subject to ethics and institutional approval. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate This project has been approved by the University of Sydney Human Research Committee (2020/254) and the Australian Red Cross Lifeblood Ethics Committee (2020#14). Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Additional file 1 Data Availability Statement The data generated and/or analysed during the current study are not publicly available owing privacy restrictions, but anonymized copies of original transcripts may be available from the corresponding author on reasonable request, subject to ethics and institutional approval.