Investigating the effect of runoff characteristics on fatigue cracking in HMA modified with nano-hydrated lime using mechanical and thermodynamic approaches Authors: Zahra Rasouli, Mehdi Mehdinazar, Gholam Hossein Hamedi Published: 2025 ABSTRACT Moisture from surface runoff significantly accelerates fatigue cracking in asphalt by damaging bitumen cohesion and its bond with aggregates. This effect is worsened when surface contaminants like dust and soot change the pH of the runoff water. Accordingly, the influence of pH on fatigue cracking in asphalt mixtures was investigated using two aggregate types, two performance grade bitumen types, and nano-hydrated lime (NHL) at two dosage levels as a bitumen modifier. For this purpose, mechanical evaluations were conducted at intermediate temperatures, including Dynamic Shear Rheometer (DSR) tests on bitumen and Semi-Circular Bending (SCB) tests on HMA samples. Furthermore, surface free energy (SFE) tests, such as Wilhelmy plate (WP) and Universal Sorption Device (USD), were conducted to determine the thermodynamic interactions between bitumen, aggregate, modifier, and acidic/basic runoff. Results showed that applying environmental conditions, particularly acidic conditions, lowered the debonding energy of bitumen-aggregate samples by an average of 10%. This phenomenon was more evident in the mixture’s performance, which showed an average 20% reduction in fracture toughness (FT) under acidic/basic wet conditions. This was attributed to diminished bitumen-aggregate adhesion, which reduces resistance to crack growth in the presence of moisture. Acidic and basic conditions increased bitumen’s complex modulus and phase angle, raising the fatigue parameter (\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document}) and cracking probability. Consequently, the fracture energy (FE) of the HMAs under acidic/basic moisture conditions decreased by an average of 17%. In contrast, the application of NHL was found to increase the basic elements while reducing the acidic elements of bitumen’s SFE. According to SFE theory, this resulted in stronger intrinsic bitumen-aggregate adhesion, which was reflected in the mixture as a 24% increase in FT. NHL also improved the nonpolar elements of SFE, positively affecting both cohesive and adhesive strength. The influence of this factor on the performance of the bitumen and mixture also included a reduction in the \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document} and an increase in FE. For instance, the PG 58 − 22 bitumen modified with 0.4% NHL exhibited a fatigue parameter of 1078 kPa under acidic conditions (pH = 5), which was even lower than that of the base bitumen. Overall, the combination of PG 58 − 22 modified with 0.4% NHL and limestone demonstrated the greatest resistance to fatigue under acidic/basic moisture conditions. Introduction Advancements in transportation infrastructure have created a growing demand for innovative asphalt technologies. Simultaneously, intensified socio-economic development has resulted in heavier traffic loads and increased vehicle weights, highlighting the critical need to improve the performance characteristics of asphalt mixtures1–3. A fundamental approach to improving asphalt performance involves incorporating specialized additives. These materials enhance crack resistance, increase flexibility, and improve thermal and moisture stability, thereby strengthening pavement durability under high traffic loads. Widely used additives—such as polymers, fibers, and waterproofing agents—are selected based on the unique requirements of each project. Using different additives to enhance various properties of the hot-mix asphalt (HMA) increases its resistance to different types of distress4,5. One of the most prevalent types of distress observed in HMA is the phenomenon of fatigue cracking. When a vehicle wheel is placed at a certain point on the pavement surface, a deformation occurs in the HMA layer, which generates tensile stress beneath that point. As the vehicle passes that point, the HMA layer tends to return to its original state. With the repetition of this process, even if the tensile stress beneath the HMA layer does not exceed its permissible tensile stress, fatigue cracks develop in the HMA layer6. The intrusion of water and air into existing fatigue cracks not only exacerbates their severity but also leads to the development of other forms of damage on the pavement surface. Moisture and air entering the HMA can cause stripping and accelerate the aging process, respectively7–9. Water infiltration undermines the longevity of HMA by penetrating either the bitumen film or the interface between bitumen and aggregate. A reduction in bitumen strength or in the bonding integrity between bitumen and aggregate heightens the risk of fatigue cracking—occurring either as cohesive failure within the mastic or as adhesive failure at the bitumen–aggregate10,11. The intensity of moisture’s effect also depends on the properties of HMA ingredients, environmental conditions, design and construction methods, and traffic volume. The properties of moisture infiltrating an HMA pavement can be altered by various environmental conditions, which in turn changes its effects on the mixture. Surface runoff is recognized as a primary source of this moisture ingress. The pH level of runoff is influenced by the dissolution of surface pollutants such as dust and soot on the pavement, leading to acidic or basic conditions. Additionally, air pollution contributes to fluctuations in the pH of incoming runoff12,13. The chemical and mechanical mechanisms investigated, across micro and macro scales, revealed that acidic/alkaline moisture primarily degrades the bitumen-aggregate adhesion and the cohesive strength of the bitumen. The weakening of these two properties causes cracks to propagate either through the bitumen phase (cohesive failure) or along the bitumen-aggregate interface (adhesive failure) Given that fatigue in pavements manifests as cracking, it is evident that the adhesive and cohesive properties of the mixture significantly govern its fatigue performance. In conclusion, assessing the fatigue performance of HMAs under acidic and alkaline moisture conditions provides a highly realistic perspective on mixture behavior in the field. This understanding is a crucial prerequisite for developing optimal mix designs or effective mitigation strategies against these detrimental effects12,14. Literature review The literature reviewed in this section is divided into two main parts. The first part examines studies on the impact of impure water on HMA performance. The second part evaluates previous research on the use of HL and its derived nanomaterial in pavement applications. SFE studies Hughes et al.15 showed that an increase in water acidity levels weakens the adhesion between the bitumen-aggregate. Yoon and Tarrer16 evaluated the effect of physical, chemical, and electrochemical attributes of aggregates on the moisture sensitivity of HMAs. They concluded that water’s contact with the aggregate changes the pH of the water and decreases the bitumen’s coverage on the aggregate by dissolving functional groups. The stripping level of HMA increased at higher pH levels. This was attributed to the sensitivity of various bonds formed between the bitumen-aggregate to pH fluctuations. Furthermore, the high percentage of CaO in limestone formed potent bonds with the acidic elements of bitumen, such as carboxylic acids, which resisted decomposition in water with varying acidity levels, thereby enhancing resistance to moisture damage. Pang et al.17 showed that the content of saturates, aromatics, and resins in the bitumen decreased after exposing to aqueous solutions while the asphaltene content increased. In other words, the salts present in the water contributed to the oxidation-induced aging of bitumen, thereby increasing its potential for stripping. Based on surface free energy (SFE) concepts, Arabani et al.18 revealed that surface pollutants—specifically dust and soot—impact the acidity of runoff water and increase the vulnerability of HMA to moisture damage. In a separate study, Arabani et al.19 showed that incorporating zeolite into bitumen enhanced the tensile performance of HMA when subjected to water with different acidity or alkalinity levels. Zeolite modification contributed positively to both the cohesion free energy (CFE) of bitumen and the adhesion free energy (AFE) between bitumen and aggregates. Hamedi et al.21 assessed the impact of graphene nano-oxide to mitigate the negative effects of pH changes in runoff. According to SFE method, Graphene nano-oxide reduced the debonding energy (DE) in HMAs. Besides, the DE variations were minimal in neutral environments but became more pronounced as the environmental conditions polarized, especially under basic conditions. Lamothe et al.22 indicated that wet samples exhibited reduced fatigue strength compared to dry samples. Additionally, the HMA stiffness was inversely related to the duration of sample saturation. Yang et al.23 revealed that following the ionization or dissolution of specific polar and ionic groups within bitumen, the aqueous solutions (acidic, alkaline, and saline) increased the elastic component, thereby enhancing the stiffness and rutting performance. Conversely, this increase in stiffness due to aging impaired the fatigue cracking performance by reducing the number of cycles to failure. Moreover, Fakhri et al.24 examined the impact of moisture content on the fracture toughness (FT) across four failure modes. The FT significantly was lowered with a raising number of freeze-thaw cycles. Mehdinazar et al.14 found that acidic and basic conditions weaken AFE, increasing the risk of fatigue cracking. To counter this, they added calcined dolomite to bitumen, which significantly improved both AFE and mechanical performance under moisture exposure. Zarrinfam et al.25 examined the effects of acidic and alkaline runoff on the fatigue performance of HMA and proposed the use of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) and nano-graphene oxide (NGO) as modifiers. Their study demonstrated that moisture with altered pH significantly deteriorates the rheological and mechanical properties of bitumen and asphalt mixtures. However, incorporating CNTs and NGO—particularly NGO at 0.6% by bitumen weight—substantially improved fracture energy, toughness, and fatigue resistance under various moisture conditions, highlighting their potential as effective additives for enhancing HMA durability against moisture-induced cracking. Zou et al.20 indicated that the acidic solution with pH = 3 had the most significant effect on the bitumen’s morphology, ultimately leading to the formation of cracks. A study by Azarhoosh et al.26 found that acidic and alkaline moisture conditions severely degrade HMA performance by reducing fatigue life and weakening the bitumen-aggregate DE. The most significant loss of AFE and CFE was reported at a pH of 6, with acidic environments causing the most severe fatigue damage. According to Mehdinazar et al.27, the fracture energy (FE), FT, and fatigue parameter (\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document}) of HMAs, as well as the AFE of the bitumen-aggregate bond, are all compromised by acidic and alkaline waters at intermediate temperatures. The detrimental impact of extreme pH levels on asphalt materials was highlighted in work by Asadi et al.12,28. Their SFE testing demonstrated that acidic and alkaline waters aggressively reduce the DE of bitumen-aggregate system, leading to premature cracking. At low temperatures, this weakness promotes failure either within the mastic or along the aggregate interface. Moreover, these aggressive environments were found to inflict significantly greater damage on fracture-related parameters (FE and FT) and rheological properties than exposure to distilled water. A subsequent study by Mehdinazar et al.29 found that acidic/alkaline exposure raises the low-temperature cracking potential of HMAs by up to 32%. This increased susceptibility is a direct consequence of a 12% loss in DE, which facilitates the stripping of bitumen from aggregate surfaces. In summary, the review of this section demonstrates that altering water pH in laboratory conditions and studying its effect through moisture application on mixture and material samples leads to a severe decline in bitumen-aggregate adhesion and bitumen cohesion. These two factors significantly increase the likelihood of various cracking types, including fatigue cracking, regardless of the failure mechanism—whether it propagates through the bitumen itself or along the bitumen-aggregate interface. NHL in asphalt mixture Recent findings across various studies indicate that incorporating nanomaterials leads to considerable improvements in the physical, microstructural, and rheological properties of bitumen30–32. Also, nanoparticles are able to enhance the adhesive attributes of bitumen-aggregates system30,33. Numerous studies have explored the beneficial effects of nano-hydrate lime (NHL) on minimizing damage in HMA mixtures. NHL has been shown to improve the durability and performance of HMA by addressing some of its critical weaknesses, particularly under environmental and loading stresses. The inclusion of NHL has been found to enhance the moisture sensitivity of HMAs by improving the adhesion of the bitumen-aggregate, thereby reducing the likelihood of stripping and water-induced damage. Furthermore, the use of NHL contributes to mitigating oxidative aging in bitumen, which can otherwise result in increased stiffness and reduced flexibility, leading to premature cracking34,35. Behbahani et al.36 studied the influence of NHL on HMA’s moisture sensitivity, focusing on its mechanism of action on the aggregate-bitumen adhesion. The use of NHL resulted in an increase in the tensile strength ratio (TSR). Mohammad et al.37 also evaluated the rheological and adhesive characteristics of bitumens with different percentages of NHL. Adding 4% NHL effectively improved the properties of bitumen. In a comprehensive study, Amjad et al.38 demonstrated a significant enhancement in bitumen stiffness, particularly at 6% NHL. Dynamic shear rheometer (DSR) testing revealed that NHL provided greater stability at high temperatures and substantial resistance to rutting. Additionally, the elastic modulus of the HMA increased through adding NHL to the bitumen. Moisture sensitivity testing further showed that NHL significantly enhanced moisture resistance. Yarahmadi et al.39 evaluated the synergistic effects of Parafiber, Micro-silica, and Hydrated Lime in HMA to identify the most effective composite. Laboratory testing—including Marshall stability, indirect tensile strength (ITS), and semi-circular bending (SCB)—revealed that the sample incorporating all three additives consistently outperformed others, showing peak resistance to moisture-induced damage, low-temperature cracking, and plastic flow. A review of the literature in this section indicates that NHL is an effective bitumen additive, significantly enhancing mechanical properties and, in particular, improving bitumen-aggregate adhesion. This capability has established NHL as a popular material for mitigating moisture-induced damage. Problems and objectives Moisture and changes in its acidity are significant factors in the occurrence and intensification of various HMA failures. One material that has demonstrated excellent performance in the presence of moisture in prior studies is hydrated lime. Due to its strong hydrophobic properties, it has established itself as an effective anti-stripping agent. A review of the existing literature indicated that NHL performance as a modifier for bitumen’s fatigue-related properties under acidic/alkaline moisture conditions had not yet been investigated. Therefore, this study investigated the effect of acidic, basic, and distilled water moisture conditions on the fatigue properties of bitumen and HMA modified with NHL using mechanical and SFE methods. The SFE method has been widely and successfully used to evaluate various failure modes related to cohesive and adhesive breakdown based on the fundamental properties of materials. Furthermore, this approach can compensate for a key weakness of mechanical methods: their inability to adequately describe the chemical interactions between materials based on their fundamental properties. Therefore, the SFE method was utilized as a powerful analytical tool specifically for validation and for providing a better explanation of the underlying mechanisms. This research aimed to achieve the following objectives: Analyzing how the acidic nature of runoff affects the rheological and structural behavior of bitumen and HMA at intermediate temperatures.Applying the SFE approach to examine the process by which fatigue cracking develops in HMA under differing moisture environments.Investigating how variations in bitumen and aggregate types influence the mechanical and thermodynamic responses of HMA exposed to acidic/basic environments at intermediate service temperature.Studying the effect of NHL as a bitumen modifier on the mechanical resilience and thermodynamic characteristics of bitumen and HMA at intermediate temperature. Analyzing how the acidic nature of runoff affects the rheological and structural behavior of bitumen and HMA at intermediate temperatures. Analyzing how the acidic nature of runoff affects the rheological and structural behavior of bitumen and HMA at intermediate temperatures. Applying the SFE approach to examine the process by which fatigue cracking develops in HMA under differing moisture environments. Applying the SFE approach to examine the process by which fatigue cracking develops in HMA under differing moisture environments. Investigating how variations in bitumen and aggregate types influence the mechanical and thermodynamic responses of HMA exposed to acidic/basic environments at intermediate service temperature. Investigating how variations in bitumen and aggregate types influence the mechanical and thermodynamic responses of HMA exposed to acidic/basic environments at intermediate service temperature. Studying the effect of NHL as a bitumen modifier on the mechanical resilience and thermodynamic characteristics of bitumen and HMA at intermediate temperature. Studying the effect of NHL as a bitumen modifier on the mechanical resilience and thermodynamic characteristics of bitumen and HMA at intermediate temperature. Experimental design In Fig. 1, the experimental program design utilized in this study is illustrated. In this study, materials including aggregates such as siliceous and limestone, bitumens such as PG 58 − 22 and PG 64 − 16, and NHL at dosages of 0.2% and 0.4% by the weight of bitumen were selected and prepared. The gradation of aggregates was determined, and the bitumen was modified by incorporating the NHL. Subsequently, various samples were prepared: HMA specimens for SCB test, bitumen samples for DSR test, aqueous solutions with NaOH and HCl to simulate acidic runoff conditions, and samples for SFE analysis, comprising bitumens, aggregates, and solutions. The experimental phase included mechanical and thermodynamic testing. The mechanical evaluations involved SCB tests conducted at intermediate temperatures to measure the fatigue performance of HMA under different moisture conditions and DSR tests to evaluate the fatigue characteristics of modified bitumen under varying moisture exposure. Thermodynamic tests were conducted to measure the SFE elements of the solutions and to determine the SFE properties of bitumen and aggregates, for which the wilhelmy plate (WP) method and the universal sorption device (USD) were employed. Fig. 1Laboratory program. Laboratory program. Table 1 illustrates the different mixtures of bitumen, aggregates, and environmental conditions used in the various tests conducted in this study. In the experimental program, various tests were conducted to analyze the performance of bitumens and asphalt mixtures under different conditions. The first set of tests utilized the WP to determine the SFE elements of bitumens. A total of 72 samples were prepared, considering three probe liquids and four test repetitions for each condition. In another series of tests, the WP was used to evaluate the SFE of solutions at 5 different pH levels. A total of 48 samples were tested, including three probe liquids and four repetitions. The USD method was employed to identify the elements of the SFE of siliceous and limestone aggregates. For this analysis, three probe liquids were used, resulting in a total of six samples. Marshall mix design tests were performed using siliceous and limestone aggregates combined with PG 64 − 16 and PG 58 − 22 bitumens to determine the optimal bitumen content (OBC) of HMA. Seven different bitumen content levels were considered, with three repetitions for each, leading to a total of 84 samples. The SCB test was carried out to evaluate the fatigue performance of HMA under both dry and moisture-conditioned states at 5 different pH levels. This test aimed to determine FE and FT, with three test repetitions for each condition. A total of 216 samples were analyzed. Finally, the DSR test was conducted on both control and modified bitumens, under dry and moisture-conditioned states at 5 different pH levels. This test assessed rheological properties, including phase angle, complex modulus, and fatigue parameter, with three test repetitions, resulting in a total of 108 samples. Table 1Details and number of laboratory samples.RowAggregateBitumenAdditiveTestRunoffObjectiveNumber of samples1-PG 64 − 16-WP-Determining the SFE elements of the bitumensNumber of probe liquid: 3Number of test repetitions: 4Total number of samples: 7220.2% NHL30.4% NHL4PG 58 − 22-50.2% NHL60.4% NHL7---WPDrypH = 5pH = 6pH = 7pH = 8pH = 9Determining the SFE elements of solutionsNumber of probe liquid: 3Number of test repetitions: 4Total number of samples: 4889101112Siliceous--USD-Determining the SFE elements of aggregatesNumber of probe liquid: 3Total number of samples: 613Limestone14SiliceousPG 64 − 16-Marshall mix designDryDetermining the OBC of HMANumber of bitumen content: 7Number of repetitions: 3Total number of samples: 8415Limestone16SiliceousPG 58 − 2217Limestone18SiliceousPG 64 − 16-SCBDrypH = 5pH = 6pH = 7pH = 8pH = 9Evaluating HMA’s performance against fatigue by determining:1. Fracture energy2. Fracture toughnessNumber of test repetitions: 3Total number of samples: 216190.2% NHL200.4% NHL21Limestone-220.2% NHL230.4% NHL24SiliceousPG 58 − 22-250.2% NHL260.4% NHL27Limestone280.2% NHL290.4% NHL30-PG 64 − 16-DSRDrypH = 5pH = 6pH = 7pH = 8pH = 9Determining the rheological properties of bitumen at intermediate temperature:1. Phase angle2. Complex modulus3. Fatigue parameterNumber of test repetitions: 3Total number of samples: 108310.2% NHL320.4% NHL33PG 58 − 22-340.2% NHL350.4% NHL Table 1Details and number of laboratory samples.RowAggregateBitumenAdditiveTestRunoffObjectiveNumber of samples1-PG 64 − 16-WP-Determining the SFE elements of the bitumensNumber of probe liquid: 3Number of test repetitions: 4Total number of samples: 7220.2% NHL30.4% NHL4PG 58 − 22-50.2% NHL60.4% NHL7---WPDrypH = 5pH = 6pH = 7pH = 8pH = 9Determining the SFE elements of solutionsNumber of probe liquid: 3Number of test repetitions: 4Total number of samples: 4889101112Siliceous--USD-Determining the SFE elements of aggregatesNumber of probe liquid: 3Total number of samples: 613Limestone14SiliceousPG 64 − 16-Marshall mix designDryDetermining the OBC of HMANumber of bitumen content: 7Number of repetitions: 3Total number of samples: 8415Limestone16SiliceousPG 58 − 2217Limestone18SiliceousPG 64 − 16-SCBDrypH = 5pH = 6pH = 7pH = 8pH = 9Evaluating HMA’s performance against fatigue by determining:1. Fracture energy2. Fracture toughnessNumber of test repetitions: 3Total number of samples: 216190.2% NHL200.4% NHL21Limestone-220.2% NHL230.4% NHL24SiliceousPG 58 − 22-250.2% NHL260.4% NHL27Limestone280.2% NHL290.4% NHL30-PG 64 − 16-DSRDrypH = 5pH = 6pH = 7pH = 8pH = 9Determining the rheological properties of bitumen at intermediate temperature:1. Phase angle2. Complex modulus3. Fatigue parameterNumber of test repetitions: 3Total number of samples: 108310.2% NHL320.4% NHL33PG 58 − 22-340.2% NHL350.4% NHL Details and number of laboratory samples. Number of probe liquid: 3 Number of test repetitions: 4 Total number of samples: 72 Dry pH = 5 pH = 6 pH = 7 pH = 8 pH = 9 Number of probe liquid: 3 Number of test repetitions: 4 Total number of samples: 48 Number of probe liquid: 3 Total number of samples: 6 Number of bitumen content: 7 Number of repetitions: 3 Total number of samples: 84 Dry pH = 5 pH = 6 pH = 7 pH = 8 pH = 9 Evaluating HMA’s performance against fatigue by determining: 1. Fracture energy 2. Fracture toughness Number of test repetitions: 3 Total number of samples: 216 Dry pH = 5 pH = 6 pH = 7 pH = 8 pH = 9 Determining the rheological properties of bitumen at intermediate temperature: 1. Phase angle 2. Complex modulus 3. Fatigue parameter Number of test repetitions: 3 Total number of samples: 108 Materials Aggregate The study used two aggregate types: limestone and siliceous. Limestone is classified as a basic aggregate due to its high CaO content, while siliceous is categorized as an acidic aggregate because of its high SiO₂ content. These aggregates were chosen because of their different performances under moisture conditions41–43. Their mineralogical properties are shown in Table 2. Table 2Mineralogical characteristics of the aggregates.AggregatesMineral Type and Percentages (%)K₂ONa₂OCaOMgOFe₂O₃Al₂O₃SiO₂Limestone0.60.372.61.80.30.94.8Siliceous3.31.24.70.82.713.354.1 Table 2Mineralogical characteristics of the aggregates.AggregatesMineral Type and Percentages (%)K₂ONa₂OCaOMgOFe₂O₃Al₂O₃SiO₂Limestone0.60.372.61.80.30.94.8Siliceous3.31.24.70.82.713.354.1 Mineralogical characteristics of the aggregates. The aggregate gradation used herein followed the ASTM D3515 standard (Fig. 2). In this study, a conventional gradation for surface layers was employed uniformly for both types of aggregates to ensure that the gradation type does not affect the analysis of the results. Additionally, the physical attributes of the aggregates are summarized in Table 3. Siliceous, as coarse and fine aggregate, has slightly higher bulk specific gravity compared to limestone. It also demonstrates superior resistance to abrasion with a Los Angeles Abrasion value of 23%, which is lower than limestone’s 21%. Siliceous shows lower water absorption compared to limestone, indicating its denser structure. The sodium sulfate weight loss in siliceous is notably less than limestone, showing better durability under sulfate exposure. Siliceous also has a higher sand equivalent compared to limestone, signifying better cleanliness. Additionally, siliceous exhibits lower plasticity, being classified as non-plastic. However, both meet ASTM standards for HMA applications. By comparing the two types of aggregates used in this study, it can be concluded that siliceous aggregates exhibit superior physical and mechanical properties compared to limestone aggregates. However, limestone aggregates demonstrate better resistance to moisture and environmental conditions due to their mineralogical structure. Fig. 2Grain size distribution of the aggregates. Grain size distribution of the aggregates. Table 3Physical properties of the aggregates.Physical propertiesCoarse LimestoneFine LimestoneCoarse SiliceousFine SiliceousBulk Specific Gravity2.512.552.562.61Effective Unit Weight2.552.512.602.58Bulk Unit Weight2.572.532.622.61Los Angeles Abrasion (%)16-19-Weight Loss Due to Sodium Sulfate (%)5432Water Absorption (%)2.31.22.01.2Needle-Like and Flaky Particles (%)9-7-Fracture Characteristics of Aggregate (%)100-100-Plasticity Index (%)-Non-plastic-Non-plasticSand Equivalent (%)-68-57Angularity (%)-54-47 Table 3Physical properties of the aggregates.Physical propertiesCoarse LimestoneFine LimestoneCoarse SiliceousFine SiliceousBulk Specific Gravity2.512.552.562.61Effective Unit Weight2.552.512.602.58Bulk Unit Weight2.572.532.622.61Los Angeles Abrasion (%)16-19-Weight Loss Due to Sodium Sulfate (%)5432Water Absorption (%)2.31.22.01.2Needle-Like and Flaky Particles (%)9-7-Fracture Characteristics of Aggregate (%)100-100-Plasticity Index (%)-Non-plastic-Non-plasticSand Equivalent (%)-68-57Angularity (%)-54-47 Physical properties of the aggregates. Bitumen In bitumen, temperature has a direct impact on its viscosity. Higher temperatures reduce viscosity, which makes the bitumen more fluid and easier to mix with aggregates and compact during construction. In contrast, lower temperatures increase viscosity, causing bitumen to become stiffer, which can lead to cracking under mechanical stress. Additionally, prolonged exposure to high temperatures during production or storage accelerates the aging of bitumen, making it less flexible and durable over time. The rheological properties of bitumen, including the phase angle and complex modulus, are also temperature-dependent, affecting its resistance to deformation and fatigue. In HMA, temperature plays a critical role in compaction and performance. Elevated temperatures enhance the workability of the mix, facilitating better compaction and reducing air voids. However, excessively high temperatures can cause segregation or oxidation of the mix. At high service temperatures, HMA may soften, resulting in rutting under traffic loads, whereas at low service temperatures, it becomes brittle, increasing the risk of thermal cracking. Furthermore, temperature fluctuations exacerbate moisture damage in HMA, as they influence the adhesion between bitumen and aggregates, making the mix more susceptible to stripping and weakening over time44,45. Accordingly, the selection of the appropriate bitumen type is highly effective in the performance of bitumen and, consequently, the asphalt mixture. In this study, two bitumens, PG 64 − 16 and PG 58 − 22, were chosen, both commonly used in temperate and cold climates. The two bitumen types, PG 58 − 22 and PG 64 − 16, exhibit differences in their performance properties tailored to specific temperature and environmental conditions. PG 64 − 16, designed for higher temperature ranges, demonstrates better resistance to deformation at elevated temperatures compared to PG 58 − 22. This indicates its suitability for regions with hotter climates or high traffic loads. However, PG 58 − 22, with its lower temperature grade, offers improved flexibility and resistance to cracking at colder temperatures, making it more appropriate for areas experiencing lower temperatures. PG 64 − 16, with its higher resistance to aging under heat, might offer better durability, especially in hotter environments. In general, PG 64 − 16 demonstrates greater resistance to high temperatures, making it less prone to softening or rutting under extreme heat and heavy loads. Conversely, PG 58 − 22 is engineered to maintain flexibility in colder temperatures, reducing the likelihood of thermal cracking. From an economic perspective, bitumens such as the two types used in this study, which are designed for moderate climatic conditions, are typically produced without the need for polymer additives or specialized bitumen modification processes. This simplicity in production not only reduces manufacturing complexities but also contributes to lower costs compared to bitumens formulated for extreme climatic conditions. Table 4 lists the performance characteristics of these two bitumens. Both bitumen types meet the ASTM standards for flash point, viscosity, and performance under aging conditions, including tests with the rolling film oven test (RTFO) and pressure aging vessel (PAV). While both demonstrate excellent thermal and aging resistance, minor differences in weight loss and rheological properties reflect their respective design for different climatic conditions. Additionally, both types exhibit acceptable creep stiffness and m-values, indicating their compliance with cold temperature performance requirements, although each is optimized for distinct temperature thresholds. Table 4Rheological properties of the PG 58 − 22 and PG 64 − 16.PropertyTest Temp (°C)Standard Limits (Min/Max)PG 58 − 22PG 64 − 16Flash point (°C)—≥ 230279291Viscosity (Pa·s)135≤ 30.450.57G*/sinδ (Original) (kPa)58/64≥ 11.692.04RTFO weight loss (%)163≤ 10.840.56G*/sinδ after RTFO (kPa)58/64≥ 2.24.034.53PAV temperature (°C)100———G*.sinδ after PAV (kPa)22/28≤ 500011722162Creep stiffness (MPa)–12/− 6≤ 300145.3185.4m-value–12/− 6≥ 0.30.3650.316 Table 4Rheological properties of the PG 58 − 22 and PG 64 − 16.PropertyTest Temp (°C)Standard Limits (Min/Max)PG 58 − 22PG 64 − 16Flash point (°C)—≥ 230279291Viscosity (Pa·s)135≤ 30.450.57G*/sinδ (Original) (kPa)58/64≥ 11.692.04RTFO weight loss (%)163≤ 10.840.56G*/sinδ after RTFO (kPa)58/64≥ 2.24.034.53PAV temperature (°C)100———G*.sinδ after PAV (kPa)22/28≤ 500011722162Creep stiffness (MPa)–12/− 6≤ 300145.3185.4m-value–12/− 6≥ 0.30.3650.316 Rheological properties of the PG 58 − 22 and PG 64 − 16. Additive NHL, with two weight percentages of 0.2% and 0.4% by weight of the bitumen, was used. NHL (Ca(OH)₂) appears as a colorless crystal or white powder and is produced when CaO is mixed with water. Table 5 presents the characteristics of NHL. Given that increasing the percentage of nanomaterials results in increased bitumen stiffness, and this increased stiffness can reduce fatigue life in thin HMA layer susceptible to fatigue cracking under dry conditions, this study has aimed to utilize lower percentages of nanomaterials. Using lower percentages ensures that the fatigue life under dry conditions is not reduced, while also making the implementation more cost-effective. Table 5Specifications of NHL.PropertyValuesUnitPurity99.9%Particle Size< 100NmMolecular Weight74.092g/molColorWhite---Density2.213g/cm3Melting Point581°CBoiling Point2851°CSolubilitySlightly Soluble in Water--- Table 5Specifications of NHL.PropertyValuesUnitPurity99.9%Particle Size< 100NmMolecular Weight74.092g/molColorWhite---Density2.213g/cm3Melting Point581°CBoiling Point2851°CSolubilitySlightly Soluble in Water--- Specifications of NHL. Bitumen modification A high-shear mixer, capable of rotating up to 14,000 rpm, was used to mix the bitumens and NHL. The maximum rotational capacity of the mixer was utilized. NHL was progressively mixed into the bitumen once it reached 160 °C. Two amounts of NHL (0.2% and 0.4% by weight of the bitumen) were used. The mixing continued for 20 min to ensure the homogeneous distribution of NHL particles within the bitumen. The same procedure was applied to control samples to simulate similar conditions and avoid aging effects. Applying moisture conditions In compliance with the literature, solutions with pH values ranging from 2 to 13 were utilized to apply different moisture conditions. By sampling and measuring the pH values of surface runoff, Arabani et al.18 reported that urban and suburban areas exhibit basic and acidic surface runoff, respectively. In general, the pH range measured in these areas was found to be between 5.98 and 8.06. This research employed five distinct pH solutions to replicate both acidic and alkaline moisture environments. Distilled water, along with weak acids and bases (HCl and NaOH), was utilized to adjust the pH to the desired level. For acidic conditions, HCl was added incrementally to distilled water until the required pH was attained. Similarly, NaOH was used to create alkaline conditions, as detailed in Table 6. Table 6Type and pH of water solutions.Type of Water SolutionMoisture ConditionspHHydrochloric acid with distilled waterAcidic5Hydrochloric acid with distilled waterAcidic6Distilled waterNeutral7Sodium hydroxide with distilled waterBasic8Sodium hydroxide with distilled waterBasic9 Table 6Type and pH of water solutions.Type of Water SolutionMoisture ConditionspHHydrochloric acid with distilled waterAcidic5Hydrochloric acid with distilled waterAcidic6Distilled waterNeutral7Sodium hydroxide with distilled waterBasic8Sodium hydroxide with distilled waterBasic9 Type and pH of water solutions. Moisture conditions were applied to HMA samples by the AASHTO T283 standard. First, the samples were saturated in the desired solution under partial vacuum conditions for 5 min. Their mass was then measured. After that, the saturated samples were placed in plastic bags, and 10 ml of the desired solution was added to them. The samples were kept in a freezer at −18 °C for 16 h. Subsequently, they were placed in a hot solution bath at 60 °C for 24 h (Fig. 3). For bitumen samples conditioning was implemented by immersing the samples in the desired solutions for 1 h at 60 °C. Fig. 3Subjecting HMA samples before testing to different moisture conditions. Subjecting HMA samples before testing to different moisture conditions. Experimental techniques Mechanical tests DSR This test is conducted according to the AASHTO T315. Two key parameters in this test is G* and δ which are calculated using Eqs. (1) and (2):1\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}=\frac{{\tau\:}_{max}}{{\gamma\:}_{max}}$$\end{document}2\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{\updelta\:}=\left(\mathrm{t}\mathrm{i}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{e}\:\mathrm{l}\mathrm{a}\mathrm{g}\right)\times\:360\times\:\mathrm{f}$$\end{document} The energy dissipated in each loading cycle at a constant strain is calculated using Eq. (3) to assess the fatigue resistance of bitumen:3\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{W}_{c}=\pi\:{\epsilon\:}_{0}^{2}\times\:({G}^{*}\cdot\:Sin\delta\:)$$\end{document} SCB test The SCB test assesses HMA’s cracking resistance, focusing on the relationship between the elastoplastic and viscoelastic properties of HMA and fracture mechanics. The AASHTO TP105 standard was employed to conduct the SCB test at intermediate temperatures. After compacting the mixture, semi-circular samples were prepared. Also, a notch measuring 15 mm in length and 1.5 mm in width was introduced at the center of each samples (Fig. 4). Fig. 4SCB specimens and test apparatus. SCB specimens and test apparatus. A temperature of 25 °C was selected to conduct the test. Loading continued until the sample failed. The crack mouth opening displacement was maintained at a constant 0.03 mm/min. After failure, the fracture energy (FE) and fracture toughness (FT) were calculated using Eqs. (4) and (7), respectively46.4\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}_{f}=\frac{{W}_{f}}{{A}_{lig}}$$\end{document} The fracture work is calculated using Eq. (5).5\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{W}_{f}=\int\:Pdu$$\end{document} The ligament area is determined using Eq. (6):6\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{A}_{lig}=\left(r-a\right)t$$\end{document} Equation (7) can be used to calculate the FT.7\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{K}_{1c}=\frac{{\sigma\:}_{0}\sqrt{\pi\:a}}{{Y}_{1\left(0.8\right)}}$$\end{document} \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{Y}_{1\left(0.8\right)}$$\end{document} is the normalized stress intensity factor which is determined based on the geometric characteristics of the samples, as expressed in Eq. (8).8\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{Y}_{1\left(0.8\right)}=4.782+1.219\left(\frac{a}{r}\right)+0.063{e}^{\left(7.045\left(\frac{a}{r}\right)\right)}$$\end{document} Thermodynamic techniques WP test Thermodynamic tests were conducted to measure the SFE elements of the solutions and to determine the SFE properties of bitumen and aggregates, for which the WP method and the USD were employed. The dynamic contact angle (θ) of a bitumen and a probe liquid (a liquid with known SFE elements) was obtained using the WP method. From simple force equilibrium considerations, the difference between weight of a plate measured in air and partially submerged in a probe liquid (ΔF) is expressed in terms of buoyancy of the liquid, liquid surface energy, contact angle, and geometry of the plate. The contact angle between the liquid and surface of the plate is calculated from this equilibrium as: 9\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:F={W}_{plate}+{W}_{asphalt}-(V\cdot\:{\rho\:}_{air}\cdot\:g)$$\end{document} When the bitumen-coated slide was immersed in a probe liquid, Eq. (9) became Eq. (10):10\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:F={W}_{plate}+{W}_{asphalt}+{P}_{t}{\varGamma\:}_{L}cos\theta\:-({V}_{im}\cdot\:{\rho\:}_{l}\cdot\:g)-\left[\left(V-{V}_{im}\right)\cdot\:{\rho\:}_{air}\cdot\:g\right]$$\end{document} The θ parameter was calculated from the algebraic difference of Eqs. (9) and (10):11\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{cos}\theta\:=\frac{\varDelta\:F+{V}_{im}({\rho\:}_{L}-{\rho\:}_{air})g}{{P}_{t}{\varGamma\:}_{L}}$$\end{document} By neglecting the equilibrium spreading pressure, Eq. (12) was used:12\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{\varGamma\:}_{L}(1+{cos}\theta\:)=2(\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{b}^{LW}{\varGamma\:}_{L}^{LW}}+\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{b}^{+}{\varGamma\:}_{L}^{-}}+\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{b}^{-}{\varGamma\:}_{L}^{+}}$$\end{document} Where, index b refers to bitumen. In Eq. (12), the total and the three SFE components of the probe liquid are known from the literature, the contact angle is measured using the Wilhelmy plate method, and the three surface energy components of the asphalt binder are unknown. Therefore, contact angles of the asphalt binder with at least three different probe liquids must be measured to generate a set of three equations that can be solved for the three unknown surface energy components. Apparatus. This device comprises a microbalance with a motor controlled stage that can be raised or lowered at desired speed to immerse a slide with asphalt binder in the probe liquid in advancing mode and to withdraw the slide from the probe liquid in receding mode. This device also comprises an analysis software to collect the data and determine the contact angles. An oven capable of heating up to 150 °C is required to heat asphalt binders for sample preparation. Microscope glass slides (24 mm x 60 mm no. 1.5) are required to serve as substrates for the asphalt binder and a vernier caliper to measure the dimensions of the slide. A heating plate with temperature control is required for maintaining the temperature of the asphalt binder during the sample preparation process. The tests are conducted at 25 ± 1 °C. If the room temperature is significantly different from the test temperature, then an appropriate environmental chamber may be required to house the apparatus47. Sampling. A representative sample of the bitumen according to procedure AASHTO T40 is obtained. Approximately 50 g of bitumen stored in a small metallic container is required for this test. The container with bitumen is heated in an oven for about 1 h. The slide is diped into the molten bitumen to a depth of approximately 15 mm until a very thin (0.18 to 0.35 mm) and uniform layer remains on the plate. The thickness of bitumen must be uniform on both sides of the slide throughout its width and for at least 10 mm from the edge that will be immersed in the probe liquid. A thin coating is required to reduce variability of the results. The binder-coated plates are placed in a desiccator overnight47. Procedure. The glass slide coated with bitumen are suspended from the microbalance using a crocodile clip. A clean glass beaker is filled with the probe liquid to a depth of at least 10 mm. During the test, the stage is raised or lowered at the desired rate via a stepper motor controlled by the accompanying software. A rate of 40 microns per second is recommended to achieve the quasi-static equilibrium conditions for contact angle measurement. The depth to which the sample is immersed in the probe liquid is set to 8 mm. The weight of the slide measured by the microbalance is recorded continuously by the software accompanying the device during the advancing (stage is raised to dip the slide) and receding (stage is lowered to retract the slide from the liquid) process. At least three liquid probes were needed to measure the bitumen’s SFE components. The material used as the probe liquid should be homogeneous and not chemically react with bitumen. Also, all probe liquids must be high-purity grade (> 99%). Accordingly, formamide, glycerol, and distilled water were utilized as probe liquids. Contact angles must be measured for at least three replicates with each probe liquid for each bitumen47. USD test In this approach, the SFE elements of aggregates are quantified by calculating the adhesion work between the aggregate surface and the vapor phase of a probe liquid. In other words, the USD is used to obtain adsorption isotherms of various probe vapors with high energy solids such as aggregates. An adsorption isotherm is the relationship between the equilibrium mass of the vapor adsorbed on the solid surface and partial vapor pressure of the probe vapor. Equation (13) correlates the adhesive interaction to the SFE parameters of the aggregate.13\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{W}_{S.V}^{a}=2\left(\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{S}^{LW}{\varGamma\:}_{V}^{LW}}\right)+2\left(\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{S}^{+}{\varGamma\:}_{V}^{-}}\right)+2\left(\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{S}^{-}{\varGamma\:}_{V}^{+}}\right)$$\end{document} Indices V and S are related to the probe liquid and the aggregate, respectively. The spreading pressure between the probe vapor and the solid is related to the surface energy components of the two materials and the total surface energy of the probe vapor using the Good-van Oss-Chaudhury (GVOC) theory40 for the work of adhesion, as follows:14\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{W}_{S.V}^{a}=2{\varGamma\:}_{V}^{Total}+{\pi\:}_{e}$$\end{document} \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{\pi\:}_{e}$$\end{document}is the equilibrium spreading pressure of the probe liquid vapor on the aggregate surface which is determined by Eq. (15):15\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{\pi\:}_{e}=\frac{RT}{MA}{\int\:}_{0}^{{p}_{n}}\frac{n}{p}dp$$\end{document} In Eq. 14, the three surface energy components of the solid are unknown, the total and three surface energy components of the liquid are known from the existing literature or handbooks, and the spreading pressure between the liquid vapor and solid is measured with the USD. Analogous to the Wilhelmy plate method, the spreading pressure of the aggregate with at least three different probe vapors must be measured in order to compute the three surface energy components of the aggregate using equation. The value of SSA of the aggregates is determined from the adsorption isotherm with n-hexane, which is used as the standard to compute spreading pressures with all three probe vapors. Apparatus. A sorption device is needed with the following specifications: integrated with the SEMS comprising an air-tight adsorption cell, a magnetic suspension balance that measures the mass of the sample in the sorption cell in non contact mode, a manifold with vacuum pump, temperature control, probe liquid containers with appropriate valves and controls to regulate the flow of vapors into the sorption cell, and associated software for test control and analysis Temperature of the sorption cell, piping that carries vapors, and a buffer tank is maintained using a water bath that is automatically controlled by the SEMS software. Also, an oven capable of heating up to 150 °C is required to prepare aggregate samples before testing47. Sampling. A representative sample of the aggregate is obtained according to AASHTO T2. the sample is sieved to obtain about 100 g of aggregates passing a 4.75 mm sieve (#4) and retained on a 2.36 mm sieve (#8). About 25 g of the aggregate is washed in a 2.36 mm sieve with deionized or distilled water. Then the clean aggregate sample is placed in an oven at 150 °C for 8 h, and thereafter is transfered to a desiccator at room temperature for at least 8 h before testing47. Procedure. The samples are held in a wire mesh basket during the test. The aggregate sample is transfered to the basket and is suspended the basket from the hook underneath the suspension balance. The sample and the test manifold is degased by drawing vacuum from the system using a mechanical vacuum pump. After the first 2 h of degassing at 70 °C, the temperature of the manifold is reduced to 25 °C (test temperature) and continue degassing for another 4 h. The pressure in the cell must be maintained below 20 millitorr during the last 4 h of degassing. The mass of the sample is monitored for the last 1 h of the degassing time to ensure that it is stable. If the mass continues to decrease it indicates that the sample is still loosing physically adsorbed particles from its surface and more degassing time is required. The Adsorption Test module of the SEMS software is activated to control and execute the adsorption test. The necessary inputs are provided to the software, such as volume of aggregate (computed by dividing the mass of the aggregate by its density) and probe vapor to execute the test. A minimum time of 15 min for equilibrium of each increment is recommended. The software regulates valves to dose probe vapors into the system in 10 steps to achieve an increment of 0.1 in the relative pressure with each step. The mass of the sample is continuously acquired during this process by the SEMS software. The software computes the mass of vapor adsorbed in real time as the difference in the mass of sample at any time from the mass of the sample in vacuum after applying for corrections due to buoyancy. Each increment of relative pressure is applied by the software after the mass of the sample comes into equilibrium due to adsorption of vapors from the previous increment, or after the minimum time for equilibrium is achieved, whichever is later. The test is complete after the saturation vapor pressure of the probe liquid is achieved in 10 increments and the equilibrium mass of vapor adsorbed is recorded for each increment. Three probe vapors are recommended for this test. The three materials used as probe liquids should have polar, semi-polar, and non-polar properties. Accordingly, distilled water (polar), formamide (semi-polar), and glycerol (non-polar) were utilized as probe liquids. All reagents must be high-purity grade (> 99%)47. SFE theory The acid-basic theory is a widely utilized framework for determining the SFE elements of various materials40. The total SFE of a substance has three main elements which is obtained by Eq. (16):16\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{\varGamma\:}^{Total}={\varGamma\:}^{Dispersive}+{\varGamma\:}^{Specific}=\:{\varGamma\:}^{LW}+{\varGamma\:}^{AB}={\varGamma\:}^{LW}+{\varGamma\:}^{\pm\:}={\varGamma\:}^{LW}+2\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}^{+}{\varGamma\:}^{-}}$$\end{document} Thermodynamically, CFE is defined as the energy essential to create a new crack surface of a unit area within a material. The CFE is the energy for the growth of very fine cracks within HMA’s mastic phase. The CFE of a material can be expressed as Eq. (17):17\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{\varDelta\:G}^{c}=2{\varGamma\:}^{Total}=2{\varGamma\:}^{LW}+4\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}^{+}{\varGamma\:}^{-}}$$\end{document} Where, \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{\varDelta\:G}^{c}$$\end{document} is the CFE. The other parameters have been introduced previously. From a phenomenological viewpoint, AFE corresponds to the work essential to detached two substances at their shared interface. For an asphalt mixture, AFE is defined as the energy necessary for debonding bitumen from the aggregate surface.18\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{\varDelta\:G}^{a}=-2\left[\left(\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{2}^{lw}{\varGamma\:}_{1}^{lw}}\right)+\left(\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{2}^{+}{\varGamma\:}_{1}^{-}}\right)+\left(\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{2}^{-}{\varGamma\:}_{1}^{+}}\right)\right]$$\end{document} Where, \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{\varDelta\:G}^{a}$$\end{document} is the AFE between materials 1 and 2. The other parameters have been previously introduced, and indices 1 and 2 represent bitumen and aggregate, respectively. To compute the AFE in a wet environment, known as the DE, Eq. (19) is used. Bitumen, aggregate, and water are denoted by the numbers 1, 2, and 3, in sequence. A negative value for DE signifies that the process of bitumen-aggregate separation is a spontaneous phenomenon in the presence of water.\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{\varDelta\:G}_{123}^{a}={{\varDelta\:G}^{a}}_{12}-{{\varDelta\:G}^{a}}_{13}-{{\varDelta\:G}^{a}}_{23}$$\end{document}19\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:=-\left[\begin{array}{c}\left(2{\varGamma\:}_{3}^{LW}\right)+\left(4\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{3}^{+}{\varGamma\:}_{3}^{-}}\right)-\left(2\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{1}^{LW}{\varGamma\:}_{3}^{LW}}\right)\\\:-\left(2\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{3}^{+}{\varGamma\:}_{1}^{-}}\right)-\left(2\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{1}^{+}{\varGamma\:}_{3}^{-}}\right)-\left(2\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{2}^{LW}{\varGamma\:}_{3}^{LW}}\right)\\\:-\left(2\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{3}^{+}{\varGamma\:}_{2}^{-}}\right)-\left(2\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{2}^{+}{\varGamma\:}_{3}^{-}}\right)+\left(2\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{1}^{LW}{\varGamma\:}_{2}^{LW}}\right)\\\:+\left(2\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{1}^{+}{\varGamma\:}_{2}^{-}}\right)+\left(2\sqrt{{\varGamma\:}_{2}^{+}{\varGamma\:}_{2}^{-}}\right)\end{array}\right]$$\end{document} All the parameters in the above equation have been previously defined. Results and discussion Thermodynamic analysis SFE elements of materials Based on Table 7, aggregates exhibited more polar characteristics than non-polar. This characteristic promoted a stronger adhesive bond between the bitumen and the aggregates. Despite their low values, the non-polar elements of the aggregates played a role in creating a more stable adhesive bond in the presence of water. Moreover, the basic element of aggregates was higher than their acidic element, particularly in limestone. These aggregates exhibited a greater basic-to-acidic ratio than siliceous, resulting in more basic properties in limestone. Table 7 shows that the acidic elements of control bitumens were greater than their basic elements. The addition of NHL raised the basic element, thereby improving its adhesion to acidic aggregates like siliceous, which are known to be susceptible to moisture. Furthermore, the bitumen’s non-polar SFE was larger than its polar, resulting in the formation of more durable bonds in moist environments. NHL significantly raised the polar element of bitumen, which improved the bonding between bitumen and aggregates. Additionally, the incorporation of NHL increased the total SFE of the bitumen, leading to an improved resistance against cohesive failure. PG 58 − 22 had larger SFE elements than PG 64 − 16. Accordingly, more energy was essential to create a crack in PG 58 − 22, and the mastic made by PG 58 − 22 was more resistant to cohesive failure. The primary reason aggregates are more polar lies in their atomic composition and the types of chemical bonds they contain. Aggregates (e.g., limestone and siliceous) are primarily composed of ionic and covalent network solids. Siliceous Aggregates (Acidic): Mainly consist of silicon dioxide (SiO₂). The Si-O bond is a highly polar covalent bond because of the significant difference in electronegativity between silicon (1.9) and oxygen (3.44). This creates a surface covered with partially negative oxygen atoms.Limestone Aggregates (Basic): Mainly consist of calcium carbonate (CaCO₃). This is an ionic compound, formed by the strong electrostatic attraction between Ca²⁺ cations and CO₃²⁻ anions. Siliceous Aggregates (Acidic): Mainly consist of silicon dioxide (SiO₂). The Si-O bond is a highly polar covalent bond because of the significant difference in electronegativity between silicon (1.9) and oxygen (3.44). This creates a surface covered with partially negative oxygen atoms. Siliceous Aggregates (Acidic): Mainly consist of silicon dioxide (SiO₂). The Si-O bond is a highly polar covalent bond because of the significant difference in electronegativity between silicon (1.9) and oxygen (3.44). This creates a surface covered with partially negative oxygen atoms. Limestone Aggregates (Basic): Mainly consist of calcium carbonate (CaCO₃). This is an ionic compound, formed by the strong electrostatic attraction between Ca²⁺ cations and CO₃²⁻ anions. Limestone Aggregates (Basic): Mainly consist of calcium carbonate (CaCO₃). This is an ionic compound, formed by the strong electrostatic attraction between Ca²⁺ cations and CO₃²⁻ anions. Bitumen, in contrast, is a complex mixture of hydrocarbons (asphaltenes, maltenes, resins, oils). Its molecules are held together primarily by non-polar covalent bonds (C-C and C-H) and weaker forces like van der Waals interactions. While bitumen does have some polar components (mainly in the asphaltenes and resins), its overall character is non-polar or weakly polar48. Table 7SFE elements of materials.MaterialTypeSFE elements (ergs/cm2)Γ−Γ+ΓABΓLWΓTotalΓ−/Γ+Waters with different pH levelspH = 515.1031.8043.8326.2070.030.47pH = 621.7029.1050.2624.5074.760.75pH = 725.5025.5051.0021.8072.801.00pH = 826.4023.9050.2428.4078.641.10pH = 928.1021.4049.0432.2081.241.31AggregatesSiliceous583.2056.40362.7067.80430.5010.30Limestone487.3035.20261.9057.70319.6013.80BitumensPG 58 − 220.621.732.0713.5615.630.36PG 64 − 160.540.931.4211.1912.610.72PG 58 − 22 + 0.2% NHL1.442.013.4027.4430.821.44PG 58 − 22 + 0.4% NHL2.851.984.7532.0236.520.58PG 64 − 16 + 0.2% NHL1.221.092.3127.4330.231.12PG 64 − 16 + 0.4% NHL1.371.122.4832.1634.971.22 Table 7SFE elements of materials.MaterialTypeSFE elements (ergs/cm2)Γ−Γ+ΓABΓLWΓTotalΓ−/Γ+Waters with different pH levelspH = 515.1031.8043.8326.2070.030.47pH = 621.7029.1050.2624.5074.760.75pH = 725.5025.5051.0021.8072.801.00pH = 826.4023.9050.2428.4078.641.10pH = 928.1021.4049.0432.2081.241.31AggregatesSiliceous583.2056.40362.7067.80430.5010.30Limestone487.3035.20261.9057.70319.6013.80BitumensPG 58 − 220.621.732.0713.5615.630.36PG 64 − 160.540.931.4211.1912.610.72PG 58 − 22 + 0.2% NHL1.442.013.4027.4430.821.44PG 58 − 22 + 0.4% NHL2.851.984.7532.0236.520.58PG 64 − 16 + 0.2% NHL1.221.092.3127.4330.231.12PG 64 − 16 + 0.4% NHL1.371.122.4832.1634.971.22 SFE elements of materials. CFE of bitumen CFE is a fundamental measure of the energy required to disrupt the internal molecular or structural bonds within the bitumen. This energy reflects the intrinsic cohesion within the bitumen and its ability to maintain integrity under external stresses. A higher CFE indicates stronger intermolecular interactions, meaning the material has a greater capacity to resist the initiation and growth of cracks when subjected to mechanical loads, and environmental variations. Based on Table 7, adding NHL at 0.2% by weight of the bitumen and increasing its percentage to 0.4% elevated the bitumen’s total SFE and, consequently, its CFE. NHL raised the energy needed to create a crack with a unit area in the bitumen. Accordingly, modifying bitumen using NHL raised its strength to cohesive failure. In addition, PG 58 − 22 exhibited greater CFE than PG 64 − 16; that is a higher amount of energy was required to initiate fracture in the mastic composed of PG 58 − 22. NHL particles are highly polar and basic. They have a strong affinity for the acidic, polar components in the bitumen (like asphaltenes). By preventing asphaltene flocculation, NHL maintains a more stable and homogeneous colloidal structure. This stabilized system has a higher resistance to internal degradation, which is measured as an increase in CFE. Bitumen-aggregate AFE AFE is vital for understanding how well the bitumen adheres to the aggregates, particularly in the presence of moisture or other environmental stressors. High AFE indicates strong interfacial adhesion, reducing the risk of debonding and enhancing the mixture’s durability. The AFE values are presented in Fig. 5. The AFE of mixtures made with siliceous was meaningly higher than in those made with limestone. This difference can primarily be related to the higher non-polar SFE element of siliceous than limestone. Conversely, non-modified bitumens had acidic properties and exhibited better adhesion to limestone, which had basic properties. PG 58 − 22 exhibited superior adhesion to aggregates compared to PG 64 − 16 due to its higher content of both polar and non-polar SFE elements. The inclusion of NHL further improved the bonding between bitumen and aggregates. As presented in Table 8, NHL enhanced the non-polar SFE attributes in both bitumen grades, reinforcing non-polar interactions. Additionally, NHL helped neutralize bitumen’s acidity (by increasing the alkaline element), enhancing its bonding capability with acidic aggregates. Fig. 5AFE in the bitumen–aggregate system. AFE in the bitumen–aggregate system. DE From a thermodynamic perspective, DE is closely linked to the fundamental principles of energy balance and interfacial interactions in asphalt mixtures. It represents the work done to overcome cohesive and adhesive forces within the mixture’s elements, such as the bitumen, aggregates, and their interfaces. This energy quantifies the amount of external energy required to disrupt these bonds, causing a separation or fracture under applied loads. DE is influenced by the Gibbs free energy changes within the system. The Gibbs free energy, which combines the effects of enthalpy (bonding energy) and entropy (disorder), governs the stability of bonds in the mixture. When separation occurs, the system undergoes a transition from a bonded state to a separated state. A lower Gibbs free energy (more negative DE) change during separation suggests that the material requires less work to fail, indicating weaker interfacial and cohesive bonds. Conversely, a higher DE (close to zero) implies stronger and more thermodynamically stable bonds that resist cracking and failure. Figures 6 and 7 illustrate the DE values under neutral, acidic, and basic conditions. The incorporation of NHL increased DE in the modified samples, resulting in enhanced bitumen–aggregate stability and a reduced tendency for debonding. This suggests that NHL mitigated adhesive failure by strengthening the interfacial adhesion between bitumen and aggregates. Furthermore, adding 0.2% NHL significantly increased the DE, while using 0.4% NHL had no considerable effect on increasing the DE. Previous research has observed that various additives—including CNTs, NGO, Zeolite, and calcined dolomite—improve bitumen-aggregate adhesion in the presence of acidic/alkaline runoff12,14,21,27. However, a comparison of the improvement trends indicates that NHL outperformed these additives. The maximum DE values were observed under wet conditions with neutral pH (7). A reduction in pH below this level led to a marked decrease in DE. Exposing the system to acidic environments elevated the energy released, thereby increasing the probability of cracking. On the other hand, increasing pH also decreased DE, but the rate of this reduction was less pronounced than decreasing pH. The acidity or alkalinity of water reduced the adhesion. Limestone exhibited higher DE values compared to siliceous aggregates, indicating a stronger adhesive interaction. Consequently, mixtures containing siliceous aggregates demonstrated a greater propensity for bitumen detachment. This trend suggests that HMAs incorporating acidic aggregates are more vulnerable to bitumen–aggregate separation under moisture exposure across different pH conditions. This increased the probability of HMA cracking, which is attributed to the adhesive properties of bitumen-aggregates. Arabani et al.18 demonstrated that acidic moisture conditions have the most significant impact on reducing DE. Consequently, the stress field around the bitumen-aggregate interface will be more severe under acidic moisture conditions. The reduction in DE under both acidic and alkaline moisture conditions has been confirmed in the studies by Asadi et al.12 and Hamedi et al.21. Fig. 6DE of control and modified bitumens for limestone under various pH levels. DE of control and modified bitumens for limestone under various pH levels. Fig. 7DE of control and modified bitumens for siliceous under various pH levels. DE of control and modified bitumens for siliceous under various pH levels. A t-test statistically determines whether there is a considerable difference between the two comparing groups. The t-test assists in hypothesis testing by comparing the sample mean to a specified value (one-sample t-test) or by comparing the means of two samples (independent or paired t-test). The null hypothesis in the t-test indicates that there is no considerable difference between the means. In other words, the null hypothesis assumes that any observed difference between the group means is due to chance and not the real effect of the studied variable. The t-test is used to determine whether the sample data provide strong statistical grounds to challenge the null hypothesis. A rejection of the null hypothesis implies a meaningful gap between the group means, potentially attributable to the influence of the independent variable. However, if the null hypothesis is retained, any apparent difference in group means is likely minor and could be attributed to random fluctuations within the experimental framework. Table 8 presents the results of t-tests conducted to examine the impact of NHL on the DE values. In the case of limestone, for both PG 58 − 22 and PG 64 − 16, 0.2% NHL significantly lowered the DE compared to the control group (without NHL). The t-values were high, and the p-values (sig.) were less than 0.001, indicating a statistically significant difference. Comparing 0.2% with 0.4% NHL shows that the mean difference was not statistically significant for PG 58 − 22 (p = 0.166), suggesting that increasing the percentage of NHL did not significantly reduce the DE. For PG 64 − 16, the difference between 0.2% and 0.4% NHL was also statistically significant (p < 0.001), indicating that increasing NHL from 0.2% to 0.4% led to a measurable change in DE. Similar trends were observed with siliceous. Adding 0.2% NHL to both PG 58 − 22 and PG 64 − 16 significantly decreased DE compared to the control sample (p < 0.001). Comparing 0.2% and 0.4% NHL demonstrated significant differences for both bitumen types, indicating that the higher NHL content continued to influence DE positively. In summary, the results in Table 8 indicate that adding NHL significantly lowered the DE for both types of aggregates and bitumens, suggesting stronger bonding and possibly better performance of HMA under moisture conditions that could lead to debonding. Increasing the amount of NHL maintained or improved the adhesion between bitumen and aggregates under the influence of waters with various pH levels, although this impact might vary based on the specific bitumen type used. Table 8Results of t-tests to examine the impact of NHL on DE values.AggregateBitumenCompared GroupsPaired DifferencestdfSig.(2-tailed)MeanStd. DeviationStd. Error Mean95% Confidence Interval of the DifferenceLowerUpperLimestonePG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−1.13E11.120.502−12.73−9.94−22.6040.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL−1.39E11.440.646−15.67−12.08−21.4840.000PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−1.26E11.440.64312−14.43−10.85−19.6540.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL2.720.350.156202.293.1517.4140.000SiliceousPG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−1.56E11.190.53160−17.04−14.08−29.2740.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL4.600.340.151664.185.0230.3340.000PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−1.65E11.440.64218−18.30−14.74−25.7340.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL3.560.340.150333.143.9823.6840.000 Table 8Results of t-tests to examine the impact of NHL on DE values.AggregateBitumenCompared GroupsPaired DifferencestdfSig.(2-tailed)MeanStd. DeviationStd. Error Mean95% Confidence Interval of the DifferenceLowerUpperLimestonePG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−1.13E11.120.502−12.73−9.94−22.6040.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL−1.39E11.440.646−15.67−12.08−21.4840.000PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−1.26E11.440.64312−14.43−10.85−19.6540.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL2.720.350.156202.293.1517.4140.000SiliceousPG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−1.56E11.190.53160−17.04−14.08−29.2740.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL4.600.340.151664.185.0230.3340.000PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−1.65E11.440.64218−18.30−14.74−25.7340.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL3.560.340.150333.143.9823.6840.000 Results of t-tests to examine the impact of NHL on DE values. Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Results of the DSR test Figures 8 and 9 depict the G* and δ values ​​of the non-modified and modified bitumens, respectively. In bitumens with higher G*, the bitumen was stiffer, and deformation occurred with the accumulation of large stresses. However, with increasing the δ value, the elastic property of the bitumen decreased and caused it to recover its initial conditions (deformation) later. Therefore, small G* and δ values ​​were desirable for fatigue resistance. Evidently, applying acidic and basic moisture conditions increased the G* and δ values ​​in all base and modified bitumen samples. Since the work wasted in each loading cycle rose with increasing G* and δ, it can be concluded that non-neutral conditions weakened the bitumen’s intermediate-temperature performance under loading. Therefore, the pH of water is known as a factor which increases the HMA’s potential for fatigue cracking. Moreover, according to Figs. 8 and 9, it is observed that using NHL reduced G* and δ. NHL lowered the stiffness of bitumen, and the bitumen could deform without accumulating large stresses. Also, NHL raised the elastic property of bitumen by reducing δ and caused the modified bitumen to recover the deformations more quickly and regain its original conditions faster. Accordingly, lowering G* and δ due to the addition of NHL improved the bitumen’s performance against cracking at intermediate temperatures. Based on Figs. 5 and 6, the bitumens containing 0.4% NHL demonstrated the best performance under intermediate-temperature cracking and, consequently, the best resistance to fatigue. Comparative analysis revealed PG 58 − 22 exhibited reduced G* and δ values relative to PG 64 − 16, reflecting its lower stiffness characteristics. These rheological properties suggest superior performance of PG 58 − 22 at intermediate temperature ranges because it could deform without generating high cumulative stresses under repeated loading cycles. Moreover, it retained its elastic properties at intermediate temperatures and recovered the deformations faster. Accordingly, PG 58 − 22 was more resistant to fatigue cracking. Fig. 8G* values of non-modified and modified bitumens under different pH levels. G* values of non-modified and modified bitumens under different pH levels. Fig. 9δ values of non-modified and modified bitumens under different pH levels. δ values of non-modified and modified bitumens under different pH levels. Figure 10 presents the fatigue parameter (\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document}) under different conditions. Among these, dry samples exhibited the lowest fatigue parameter, reflecting superior resistance to fatigue cracking. Moisture exposure at neutral pH (7) led to a reduction in both \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}$$\end{document} and the phase angle, while acidic and basic conditions further diminished stiffness and increased the phase angle—indicative of reduced elasticity. The simultaneous rise in \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}$$\end{document} and phase angle under extreme pH conditions elevated the fatigue parameter, thereby weakening the fatigue resistance of the bitumen samples. The average values in Fig. 10 highlight the rate of change in \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document} relative to pH fluctuations, with decreased pH in distilled water amplifying \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document} and consequently impairing fatigue performance. According to Eq. 3, This parameter represents the viscous (or lost) component of the stiffness. In fatigue analysis, this lost energy is converted into heat and micro-damage. Therefore, a higher \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document} means the binder is stiffer and more elastic in a way that is detrimental to fatigue life, as it is less able to dissipate stress through flow, making it more prone to cracking. Variations in pH, particularly towards acidic or alkaline conditions, increase \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document} by damaging the internal structure of the bitumen. The high pH (alkaline) water reacts with acidic components in the bitumen, creating soap-like compounds (salt of a fatty acid). This process breaks down the heavier, more structured molecular fractions (like asphaltenes) that give bitumen its strength and cohesion. The low pH (acidic) water can attack and break certain chemical bonds within the bitumen, a process known as hydrolysis. This also leads to a loss of the material’s cohesive integrity. This damage reduces the binder’s ability to dissipate energy (reduces its viscous response), forcing a greater proportion of the applied stress to be carried elastically, which is reflected in a higher \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document} value. As a result, the bitumen dissipates energy through the formation of cracks within itself. Fig. 10Fatigue parameter for control and modified bituminous samples under different pH levels. Fatigue parameter for control and modified bituminous samples under different pH levels. Table 9 presents the results of t-tests conducted to assess the effect of NHL on the fatigue parameters of bitumens. Adding 0.2% NHL significantly decreased the fatigue parameter compared to the control, as indicated by the very low p-values (all < 0.001). Comparing 0.2% and 0.4% NHL showed that increasing the percentage of NHL significantly affected the fatigue parameters. NHL particles have an extremely high surface area-to-volume ratio. When dispersed in the bitumen, they act as a micro-filler that occupies empty spaces and creates a denser, continuous matrix. This reinforced structure distributes mechanical stresses more evenly throughout the binder. Instead of stress concentrating and leading to micro-cracks (an elastic failure), the energy is dissipated as heat through the viscous flow of the bitumen around the rigid particles. This enhances the viscous component, which lowers the \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document} value. As the results of the SFE method also showed, NHL is highly effective at absorbing and neutralizing the polar compounds and acids in the bitumen that are responsible for age-hardening (oxidation). A binder that remains less brittle with aging retains a higher viscous component (higher phase angle, \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:\delta\:$$\end{document}). Since a primary cause of high \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document} is age-hardening, NHL’s ability to mitigate this directly helps maintain a lower, better \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document} over the long term. Table 9Results of t-tests examining the impact of NHL on the fatigue parameters.BitumenCompared GroupsPaired DifferencestdfSig.(2-tailed)MeanStd. DeviationStd. Error Mean95% Confidence Interval of the DifferenceLowerUpperPG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL2.16E223.0609.41191.63240.0322.9350.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL−8.05E130.4712.44−112.48−48.52−6.4750.001PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL4.71E274.5430.43392.28548.7215.4650.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL−1.97E242.1117.19−240.69−152.31−11.4350.000 Table 9Results of t-tests examining the impact of NHL on the fatigue parameters.BitumenCompared GroupsPaired DifferencestdfSig.(2-tailed)MeanStd. DeviationStd. Error Mean95% Confidence Interval of the DifferenceLowerUpperPG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL2.16E223.0609.41191.63240.0322.9350.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL−8.05E130.4712.44−112.48−48.52−6.4750.001PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL4.71E274.5430.43392.28548.7215.4650.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL−1.97E242.1117.19−240.69−152.31−11.4350.000 Results of t-tests examining the impact of NHL on the fatigue parameters. Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Results of the SCB test FE FE is the energy required to change a unit surface of a material from its initial state to a failure state. This definition demonstrates that CFE and AFE influence the value of FE under dry conditions, while DE significantly affects FE under wet conditions. Figures 11 and 12 depict the FE of HMAs made with limestone and siliceous. Applying moisture conditions on HMA samples significantly reduced FE. This means that the samples failed in less time and absorbed less energy until failure. When HMA samples were placed under moisture conditions with pH = 7, they had higher FE compared to other samples. The pavement surface contaminants that change the chemical properties of runoff have a greater destructive effect than clean pavement surfaces. Based on the discussion in the section “Results of the DSR test”, the bitumen mastic (bitumen + fine aggregates) is weaker and a compromised matrix when exposed to acidic/alkaline moisture condition. The mixture loses its ability to deform plastically and absorb energy. It behaves in a more brittle manner, failing with little deformation. Using NHL increased FE by decreasing the stiffness of the bitumen and improving its ability to absorb energy from loading to failure. Dry samples containing PG 58 − 22 exhibited higher FE than those with PG 64 − 16, mainly due to the reduced stiffness of the HMA and enhanced energy absorption capacity under load. NHL particles are extremely small (nano-scale), giving them a very high surface area. They act as a superior filler, densely packing into the micro-voids and cavities within the bitumen mastic. This creates a more homogeneous, continuous, and denser matrix. When a load is applied, stress is distributed more evenly throughout this reinforced matrix. Instead of stress concentrating and creating a crack, the energy is absorbed by the system, requiring more force to initiate and propagate a crack. This directly increases the energy required for fracture. Also, when a micro-crack starts to grow, its path is interrupted by these nanoparticles. The crack must either: Forced to travel around the particle, creating a longer, more tortuous path.Its tip is anchored by the particle, halting its progress.Bypassed the particle which requires additional energy to debond the particle from the matrix. Forced to travel around the particle, creating a longer, more tortuous path. Forced to travel around the particle, creating a longer, more tortuous path. Its tip is anchored by the particle, halting its progress. Its tip is anchored by the particle, halting its progress. Bypassed the particle which requires additional energy to debond the particle from the matrix. Bypassed the particle which requires additional energy to debond the particle from the matrix. Each of these processes consumes a significant amount of additional energy, thereby increasing the overall FE. Due to the high percentage of CaO in their chemical structure, samples made with limestone created better adhesion with bitumen, and this improved the FE. On the other hand, CaO created hydrophobic properties in samples made with limestone. This made the samples containing limestone perform better under moisture conditions. Fig. 11FE for control and modified HMAs containing limestone aggregates. FE for control and modified HMAs containing limestone aggregates. Fig. 12FE for control and modified HMAs containing siliceous aggregates. FE for control and modified HMAs containing siliceous aggregates. Table 10 presents the t-test results showing the impact of NHL on the FE of HMAs containing different types of bitumen and aggregates. For both bitumen types, 0.2% NHL significantly reduced FE compared to the control samples. The mean differences indicate that FE decreased by approximately 17.6, 12.6, and 7.8 J/m² for different comparisons, with p-values less than 0.001 indicating strong statistical significance. Increasing the NHL content to 0.4% further reduced the FE for both bitumen types, with a mean difference of 30.0 J/m² for PG 58 − 22 and 16.1 J/m² for PG 64 − 16. The significance levels remained very low (p < 0.001), confirming that these changes were statistically significant. The data shows that the type of aggregate also played a crucial role in the impact of NHL on FE. For limestone, the reduction in FE was notable, indicating that the interaction between NHL and the aggregate affected HMA’s overall performance. The differences in mean values for the two types of aggregates suggest that limestone exhibited more significant reductions in FE when modified with NHL. Table 10Results of t-tests examining the impact of NHL on FE.AggregateBitumenCompared GroupsPaired DifferencestdfSig.(2-tailed)MeanStd. DeviationStd. Error Mean95% Confidence Interval of the DifferenceLowerUpperLimestonePG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−1.76E238.8515.863−216.6−135.1−11.0850.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL3.00E145.3034218.495−17.5477.51.6250.166PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−7.80E114.737716.017−93.4−62.5−12.9650.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL8.17E121.388478.73259.2104.19.3550.000SiliceousPG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−1.45E230.5117512.456−176.8−112.8−11.6250.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL8.17E125.4453710.38854.9108.37.8650.001PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−5.58E115.276346.237−71.8−39.8−8.9550.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL6.61E124.7500810.10440.1992.16.5450.001 Table 10Results of t-tests examining the impact of NHL on FE.AggregateBitumenCompared GroupsPaired DifferencestdfSig.(2-tailed)MeanStd. DeviationStd. Error Mean95% Confidence Interval of the DifferenceLowerUpperLimestonePG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−1.76E238.8515.863−216.6−135.1−11.0850.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL3.00E145.3034218.495−17.5477.51.6250.166PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−7.80E114.737716.017−93.4−62.5−12.9650.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL8.17E121.388478.73259.2104.19.3550.000SiliceousPG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−1.45E230.5117512.456−176.8−112.8−11.6250.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL8.17E125.4453710.38854.9108.37.8650.001PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−5.58E115.276346.237−71.8−39.8−8.9550.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL6.61E124.7500810.10440.1992.16.5450.001 Results of t-tests examining the impact of NHL on FE. Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL FT Figures 13 and 14 show the results of FT in different mixtures. Placing HMA samples under moisture conditions caused their resistance to decrease at the critical moment of failure. Various moisture conditions increased the tendency of bitumen to separate from the aggregate surface, and the greater this tendency, the lower the resistance at the critical moment to prevent crack growth. Among the wet samples, FT was higher for samples placed in distilled water. On the other hand, acidic or basic moisture conditions lowered the FT. The bitumen itself is a complex hydrocarbon with polar components. Extreme pH values trigger chemical reactions that break it down. The high pH (OH⁻ ions) reacts with acidic compounds in the bitumen (like carboxylic acids) to form soap-like compounds. This reaction breaks down the larger, structurally important molecules (asphaltenes) that give bitumen its stiffness and strength12,16. The bitumen becomes softer, less cohesive, and loses its glue-like properties. These observations were evident in the reduction of the DE. As the results from the section “Thermodynamic analysis”, indicated, acidic and alkaline waters disrupted the balance of the polar and non-polar components governing bitumen-aggregate adhesion, leading to a lower DE within the system. The H⁺ ions in acidic water can attack and break certain chemical bonds (e.g., ester or sulfide linkages) in a process called hydrolysis. This is often accompanied by accelerated oxidation. This breaks the long polymer-like chains in the bitumen, leading to a loss of flexibility and an increase in brittleness28. The bitumen cannot stretch or deform as much before breaking (cohesive failure). FT indicates a mixture’s resistance to crack propagation. Consequently, when a mixture has higher adhesive and cohesive strength, incipient cracks cannot easily find a path to grow through the bitumen phase or along the bitumen-aggregate interface, meeting greater resistance. In summary, the loss of adhesion and cohesion due to the presence of acidic/alkaline water causes cracks to propagate through the bitumen or along the interface more rapidly than under dry conditions. HMA’s performance was better in modified samples. This is due to the use of NHL, which raised the non-polar bonds of bitumen and aggregate. The addition of NHL enhanced the alkaline characteristics while diminishing the acidic components in bitumen, consequently decreasing its reactivity with various aqueous media. The well-dispersed, hard NHL particles act as physical obstacles within the bitumen matrix. When a micro-crack starts to propagate, it encounters these nanoparticles. The particles force the crack to change direction, pin its tip, or require additional energy to bypass them. This process absorbs energy and slows down crack growth. By resisting crack propagation, the binder maintains its integrity and ability to relax stress, thereby preventing a decrease in FT. This simple mechanism has also proven effective in preserving the mixture’s adhesion and cohesion. NHL creates a stronger mastic and a superior bond with the aggregate. As a result, micro-cracks propagating through the bitumen are forced to contend with the resistance offered by the NHL at the adhesive/cohesive interface, which significantly impedes crack propagation. The combination of PG 58 − 22 and limestone provided the highest FT. Accordingly, this combination had the highest resistance to cracking at intermediate temperatures and, consequently, the best fatigue performance. Fig. 13FT values of control and modified HMAs containing limestone aggregates. FT values of control and modified HMAs containing limestone aggregates. Fig. 14FT values of control and modified HMAs containing siliceous aggregates. FT values of control and modified HMAs containing siliceous aggregates. Table 11 presents the results of t-tests examining the impact of NHL on the FT of HMAs. The mean differences in FT between control samples and those with 0.2% NHL were negative, indicating that NHL generally raised the FT. The significance values (Sig.) for all the comparisons were less than 0.05, indicating that the differences observed were statistically significant. This means that incorporating NHL significantly improved the FT of the HMAs. The findings were consistent across different types of bitumens, suggesting that both 0.2% and 0.4% NHL yielded effective results in FT. In summary, Table 11 demonstrates that modifying bitumen with NHL significantly enhanced the FT of HMAs, with statistical evidence supporting the effectiveness of this modification. Table 11Results of t-tests examining the impact of NHL on FT.AggregateBitumenCompared GroupsPaired DifferencestdfSig.(2-tailed)MeanStd. DeviationStd. Error Mean95% Confidence Interval of the DifferenceLowerUpperLimestonePG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−4.33E13.781.54−47.30−39.37−28.1050.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL1.48E11.600.6513.1516.5122.6750.000PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−2.22E16.182.52−28.65−15.68−8.7850.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL1.68E15.562.2710.9922.677.4150.001SiliceousPG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−3.90E14.471.83−43.69−34.31−21.3650.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL1.98E16.152.5113.3826.287.9050.001PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−1.45E14.761.95−19.50−9.50−7.4550.0010.2% NHL0.4% NHL1.75E110.254.196.7428.264.1850.009 Table 11Results of t-tests examining the impact of NHL on FT.AggregateBitumenCompared GroupsPaired DifferencestdfSig.(2-tailed)MeanStd. DeviationStd. Error Mean95% Confidence Interval of the DifferenceLowerUpperLimestonePG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−4.33E13.781.54−47.30−39.37−28.1050.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL1.48E11.600.6513.1516.5122.6750.000PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−2.22E16.182.52−28.65−15.68−8.7850.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL1.68E15.562.2710.9922.677.4150.001SiliceousPG 58 − 22Control0.2% NHL−3.90E14.471.83−43.69−34.31−21.3650.0000.2% NHL0.4% NHL1.98E16.152.5113.3826.287.9050.001PG 64 − 16Control0.2% NHL−1.45E14.761.95−19.50−9.50−7.4550.0010.2% NHL0.4% NHL1.75E110.254.196.7428.264.1850.009 Results of t-tests examining the impact of NHL on FT. Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Control 0.2% NHL 0.2% NHL 0.4% NHL Conclusions Understanding the influence of environmental factors and material modifications on HMA behavior is essential for improving pavement durability and ensuring reliable performance under variable field conditions. This study investigated the influence of environmental factors and bitumen modification with nano-NHL on the mechanical and thermodynamic behavior of HMA at intermediate temperatures. Through a series of rheological, thermodynamic, and moisture-sensitivity evaluations, critical insights were obtained regarding the role of pH variation, aggregate and bitumen type, and the use of NHL as a performance-enhancing additive. The most important results were: Bitumen–aggregate adhesion declined under acidic and basic moisture environments relative to neutral conditions. Poor bitumen-aggregate adhesion reduced the FE of the mixture. Furthermore, due to this inherent weakness and the resultant stress concentration at the bitumen-aggregate interface, the crack propagation rate (FT) increased. Also, pH changes of water elevated the fatigue parameter in bitumens exposed to acidic or basic conditions.Utilizing NHL and increasing its weight% from 0.2% to 0.4% increased the basic properties and the nonpolar element of bitumen. This increased the total SFE by 31%, resulting in an improvement in the CFE. Furthermore, the increase in the bitumen’s basic component due to NHL addition created strong adhesion with aggregates, particularly acidic (siliceous) ones. This enhanced the DE by up to 11% in the presence of acidic/alkaline water.By enhancing the CFE and flexibility, NHL reduced energy dissipation in the form of cracking (represented by \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document}) within the mixture. This resulted in an increase in the FE required for the mixture to fail. Furthermore, the improved adhesion and cohesion in the NHL-modified mixtures obstructed potential paths for crack propagation in the HMA, thereby increasing its fatigue resistance.An evaluation of the various base combinations examined in this study revealed that the blend of PG 58 − 22 bitumen and limestone aggregate demonstrated the best mechanical and thermodynamic performance. In contrast, for weaker combinations such as PG 64 − 16 bitumen and siliceous aggregate, it was shown that modification with 0.4% NHL can enhance the mixture’s fatigue performance, bringing it close to the level of higher-quality materials like PG 58 − 22 with limestone aggregate. Bitumen–aggregate adhesion declined under acidic and basic moisture environments relative to neutral conditions. Poor bitumen-aggregate adhesion reduced the FE of the mixture. Furthermore, due to this inherent weakness and the resultant stress concentration at the bitumen-aggregate interface, the crack propagation rate (FT) increased. Also, pH changes of water elevated the fatigue parameter in bitumens exposed to acidic or basic conditions. Bitumen–aggregate adhesion declined under acidic and basic moisture environments relative to neutral conditions. Poor bitumen-aggregate adhesion reduced the FE of the mixture. Furthermore, due to this inherent weakness and the resultant stress concentration at the bitumen-aggregate interface, the crack propagation rate (FT) increased. Also, pH changes of water elevated the fatigue parameter in bitumens exposed to acidic or basic conditions. Utilizing NHL and increasing its weight% from 0.2% to 0.4% increased the basic properties and the nonpolar element of bitumen. This increased the total SFE by 31%, resulting in an improvement in the CFE. Furthermore, the increase in the bitumen’s basic component due to NHL addition created strong adhesion with aggregates, particularly acidic (siliceous) ones. This enhanced the DE by up to 11% in the presence of acidic/alkaline water. Utilizing NHL and increasing its weight% from 0.2% to 0.4% increased the basic properties and the nonpolar element of bitumen. This increased the total SFE by 31%, resulting in an improvement in the CFE. Furthermore, the increase in the bitumen’s basic component due to NHL addition created strong adhesion with aggregates, particularly acidic (siliceous) ones. This enhanced the DE by up to 11% in the presence of acidic/alkaline water. By enhancing the CFE and flexibility, NHL reduced energy dissipation in the form of cracking (represented by \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document}) within the mixture. This resulted in an increase in the FE required for the mixture to fail. Furthermore, the improved adhesion and cohesion in the NHL-modified mixtures obstructed potential paths for crack propagation in the HMA, thereby increasing its fatigue resistance. By enhancing the CFE and flexibility, NHL reduced energy dissipation in the form of cracking (represented by \documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \usepackage{amsmath} \usepackage{wasysym} \usepackage{amsfonts} \usepackage{amssymb} \usepackage{amsbsy} \usepackage{mathrsfs} \usepackage{upgreek} \setlength{\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \begin{document}$$\:{G}^{*}\times\:\mathrm{sin}\delta\:$$\end{document}) within the mixture. This resulted in an increase in the FE required for the mixture to fail. Furthermore, the improved adhesion and cohesion in the NHL-modified mixtures obstructed potential paths for crack propagation in the HMA, thereby increasing its fatigue resistance. An evaluation of the various base combinations examined in this study revealed that the blend of PG 58 − 22 bitumen and limestone aggregate demonstrated the best mechanical and thermodynamic performance. In contrast, for weaker combinations such as PG 64 − 16 bitumen and siliceous aggregate, it was shown that modification with 0.4% NHL can enhance the mixture’s fatigue performance, bringing it close to the level of higher-quality materials like PG 58 − 22 with limestone aggregate. An evaluation of the various base combinations examined in this study revealed that the blend of PG 58 − 22 bitumen and limestone aggregate demonstrated the best mechanical and thermodynamic performance. In contrast, for weaker combinations such as PG 64 − 16 bitumen and siliceous aggregate, it was shown that modification with 0.4% NHL can enhance the mixture’s fatigue performance, bringing it close to the level of higher-quality materials like PG 58 − 22 with limestone aggregate. Future research directions NHL modification offers a life-cycle economic benefit for asphalt pavements in corrosive environments. By enhancing resistance to adhesive and cohesive failure, NHL reduces damage, leading to less frequent maintenance and significant long-term cost savings. This study found that 0.2% and 0.4% NHL significantly improve key performance parameters (e.g., AFE, CFE, FE, FT, G^*×sin⁡δ) under acidic/alkaline conditions, thereby reducing fatigue cracking—a common failure requiring costly mitigation. While the initial cost of NHL and plant modifications are economic barriers, a full Life Cycle Cost Analysis (LCCA) would likely reveal net savings from reduced maintenance. Combining LCCA with a Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) is recommended for future research to holistically evaluate economic and environmental impacts. Furthermore, while a PG 58 − 22 and limestone blend showed superior performance, modifying weaker mixes (e.g., PG 64 − 16 with siliceous aggregate) with 0.4% NHL brought their fatigue performance close to that of higher-quality mixes, justifying its use where premium materials are unavailable. This demonstrates that by developing mathematical models based on a sufficient volume of experimental data, mathematical representations of various pavement distresses could be created that account for moisture conditions, different additives, and base material combinations - ultimately enabling the development of optimized mix designs for specific environmental conditions.