Background optic flow modulates responses of multiple descending interneurons to object motion in locusts Authors: Sinan Zhang, John R. Gray, Tudor Badea, Tudor Badea, Teddy Lazebnik, Teddy Lazebnik, Teddy Lazebnik Published: 2025 ABSTRACT Animals flying within natural environments are constantly challenged with complex visual information. Therefore, it is necessary to understand the impact of the visual background on the motion detection system. Locusts possess a well-identified looming detection pathway, comprising the lobula giant movement detector (LGMD) and the descending contralateral movement detector (DCMD). The LGMD/DCMD pathway responds preferably to objects on a collision course, and the response of this pathway is affected by the background complexity. However, multiple other neurons are also responsive to looming stimuli. In this study, we presented looming stimuli against different visual backgrounds to a rigidly-tethered locust, and simultaneously recorded the neural activity with a multichannel electrode. We found that the number of spike-sorted units that responded to looms was not affected by the visual background. However, the peak times of these units were delayed, and the rise phase was shortened in the presence of a flow field background. Dynamic factor analysis (DFA) revealed that fewer types of common trends were present among the units responding to looming stimuli against the flow field background, and the response begin time was delayed among the common trends as well. These results suggest that background complexity affects the response of multiple motion-sensitive neurons, yet the animal is still capable of responding to potentially hazardous visual stimuli. Introduction Successful navigation in the natural environment requires animals to rapidly perceive and extract important sensory cues, usually from a complex, “noisy” background. For example, the self-motion of animals generates optic flow, which is defined as the pattern of image shifts caused by the motion of the observer [1]. Although animals can use optic flow to control locomotion speed and correct for deviations in flight orientation [2–6], the presence of optic flow also makes it more difficult to observe other moving objects, such as an approaching predator. Successful detection and discrimination between different types of visual motion are critical to an animal’s survival. In the mouse retina, four subtypes of direction-sensitive ganglion cells (DSGC) are involved in the encoding of optic flow [7]. Each subtype of DSGC is selectively sensitive to optic flow along a specific translatory orientation, including forward, backward, up, and down. Combinations of these subtypes can also encode rotatory degrees of freedom. Flying animals, however, manoeuvre in additional degrees of freedom, including but not limited to vertical translation and roll, neither of which is commonly executed by land animals. Therefore, flying animals need to process more complicated optic flow parameters. With a relatively tractable nervous system and the capability to perform complex behaviours, insects are ideal subjects to study the neural coding of complex visual backgrounds. In flies, six types of direction-sensitive neurons are involved in the computation of the optic flow direction [8]. The migratory locust, Locusta migratoria, is another classic subject for studying visual processing. Migratory locusts are polyphenic, transitioning between solitary and gregarious states. In the gregarious state, locusts can form large swarms, comprised of thousands of individuals, and fly ~ 3 meters·s-1 [9]. With conspecifics moving around at various velocities from different angles, along with the flow field generated from self-motion, locusts flying in a swarm can still avoid collision with conspecifics [10] and predatory birds [11]. In locusts, an established neural pathway, including the lobula giant movement detector (LGMD) and its postsynaptic partner, the descending contralateral movement detector (DCMD), has been identified to respond preferably to objects on a collision course [12–15]. The LGMD/DCMD pathway is considered to play an important role in generating collision avoidance behaviours. Each LGMD receives input from an entire compound eye [16]. When presented with an approaching object, the LGMD responds with increased firing rate, which peaks near the projected time of collision (TOC) and then decays [17–22]. Each LGMD spike generates a spike in the DCMD [23], which synapses with the motor center related to avoidance behaviours [24]. Different phases of responses recorded in the LGMD/DCMD pathway have been associated with critical timing of avoidance behaviours, such as jumping [25] and flight steering [26]. The addition of a visual background affects the response of the LGMD/DCMD pathway to looming objects. In the LGMD, the number of spikes evoked by small looming objects is inhibited by the presence of large-field optic flow [14,27,28]. In the DCMD, although the general peak response is largely invariant between background types, the flow field still caused a lower peak firing rate, delayed peak time, shorter rise phase, and longer fall phase [29]. Previously, we investigated putative population coding of motion-sensitive neurons in response to objects moving against a simple white background [30]. To further understand how motion-sensitive neural ensembles behave in an environment that emulates elements of a more natural environment, we presented a looming stimulus approaching against one of three different backgrounds: solid white, solid grey in the lower visual field, and a grey and white flow field that represented forward motion through space at an average locust flight speed of 3 m·s-1. These stimuli were presented to rigidly-tethered locusts to allow recording the simultaneous activity of multiple descending interneurons. Based on previous reports, we tested the following hypotheses: 1) Responses of sorted units can be categorized based on their firing rate properties, 2) The distribution of response categories differs in the presence of different backgrounds, and 3) The firing rate properties of units within response categories are affected by the background. Overall, most spike-sorted units responded to looming stimuli regardless of background types, but the distribution of different types of responses was affected. For individual units that peaked near TOC, as well as common trends that peaked near TOC, the peak time and/or the response begin time was delayed by the flow field background. Materials and methods Animals Twenty-one adult male locusts (Locusta migratoria) were chosen from a colony maintained at the University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada, ensuring that they were at least 3 weeks past the imaginal moult. These locusts were fed with a diet consisting of wheat grass and bran and were subjected to a regular light-dark cycle of 12 hours of light and 12 hours of darkness at an approximate temperature of 30 °C. To maintain the gregarious state, the locust colony was kept in a crowded condition [31]. Preparation During the light cycle, the locusts were carefully removed from the colony and transferred to a wire mesh container. To provide both light and warmth, an incandescent lamp was placed on top of the container. The experiments were conducted at a controlled room temperature of approximately 25 °C. To prepare the locust for the experiments, the legs were first removed, and a rigid tether was then securely attached to the ventral surface of the thorax using melted beeswax. A small portion of the ventral cervical cuticle was removed to expose the paired connectives of the ventral nerve anterior to the prothoracic ganglion. The prepared locust was then transferred to the stimulus arena [32] (Fig 1A). A silver wire hook electrode was used to lift and stabilize the left ventral nerve cord. Subsequently, a sharp glass electrode was carefully inserted into the protective sheath surrounding the left nerve cord, creating a small opening. A twisted wire tetrode, fabricated following an established protocol [33], was then inserted into the left nerve cord anterior to the hook electrode (Fig 1B). The tetrode consisted of four wires (diameter = 12.7 μm) (Model R0800, Sandvik-Kanthal Precision Technology, Hallstahammar, Sweden) that were twisted together and fused at one end, while the other end was separated and soldered to four channels of an adapter. The fused end of the tetrode was secured within a capillary tube for stability. A micromanipulator was used to maneuver the capillary tube, lowering the fused end of the tetrode into the nerve cord, while the other end (adapter) was connected to a differential amplifier (Model 1700, A-M Systems, United States). Finally, a 0.5-mm silver ground wire (MilliporeSigma Canada, Oakville, ON, Canada) was inserted into the abdomen. We used two tetrodes for the entire dataset. Therefore, tetrodes were reused between preparations. At the time of fabrication, the impedance was measured for both tetrodes. The impedance within each channel was < 3 megaohm, and the impedance between channels was > 5 megaohms. The tip that was inserted into the nerve cord was trimmed before each prep. Since the tip was not coated, the trimming would not have affected the impedance. Experimental setup and visual stimuli. (A) The stimulus arena with the dome screen closed. (B) The locust preparation with tetrode inserted (inset). (C) Diagram of the experimental setup. Visual stimuli were rendered and projected onto the dome screen while neural activity was recorded simultaneously. A 5-V pulse was used to align the neural recordings with stimulus timing. 0° represents the orientation relative to the head of the locust (locust not to scale). (D) Visual stimuli used in the experiment. The first three visual stimuli included a 7-cm-diameter black disc approaching at 300 cm·s-1 from the bottom right at a 45° angle, against three visual backgrounds: white (LW), half-white and half-grey (LG), and flow field (LF). The last visual stimulus was composed of a flow field only (F). Yellow arrows within F indicate the direction of flow field motion, which was the same for LF. The thickness of the arrows and grey arches increased as the flow field expanded. Each visual stimulus was presented 5 times, and the order of all 20 visual stimuli was randomized for each locust. Neural responses were observed while waving a hand to verify a high signal-to-noise ratio. A mixture of mineral oil and Vaseline was then applied around the electrodes and nerve cords to insulate the recordings from the hemolymph and prevent desiccation. The entire setup was rotated 180°, placing the locust in a dorsal-side-up position at the center of the rear projection dome screen (Fig 1C). The longitudinal axis of the locust was aligned parallel to the apex of the dome, with a distance of 12 cm between the locust’s eye and the screen. In this orientation, 0° represented the front of the locust, 180° represented the direction directly behind, and +90° represented a perpendicular angle to the right longitudinal axis of the locust’s body. Negative perpendicular angles were to the left of the locust. Visual stimulus Visual stimuli were generated using a Python-based program EVSG [34] and incorporated correctional factors to account for the curvature of the dome screen. The resolution of the stimuli was set at 1024 × 768 pixels. Each pixel on the screen corresponded to approximately 0.7 mm, resulting in a subtense angle of approximately 0.4°, which is well below the angular resolution of locusts’ eyes (1°) [35]. Real-time rendering of the images was performed using a GeForce RTX 3080 video card (NVIDIA Corporation, Santa Clara, United States), achieving a frame rate of over 150 frames per second. The images were then projected onto the dome screen using an InFocus DepthQ projector (InFocus, Portland, United States) with the colour wheel removed. The frame rate of the projections exceeded the flicker fusion frequency of locusts’ eyes, which is around 66 Hz [36]. A 5V pulse was generated at the projected time of collision (TOC), which was automatically calculated based on the motion trajectory of the visual stimuli. This pulse was used to align different trials. Given the curvature of the dome screen and the position of the locust relative to the apex, we were able to render the final frame such that the visual subtense angle of the object was 180°, which is the point of collision. In all visual stimuli, the backgrounds were divided vertically into two equal halves, simulating a horizon line positioned at 0° elevation. The top half was rendered in solid white (R = 0, G = 0, B = 0), while the bottom half was either solid white (LW), solid grey (LG, R = 100, G = 100, B = 100), or a flow field (LF), composed of grey concentric arches (R = 100, G = 100, B = 100) expanding outward from the center of the dome below the horizon line. The solid grey background was designed to test the putative effects of contrast between the lower and upper visual fields. The arches expanded at ~40.5°·s-1 across the surface of the dome, which represented forward motion of 300 cm·s-1, which is the average flight speed of a locust. At the center of the dome, the arch subtended 6.8° of the visual field, and at the periphery it subtended ~13.5°. The Michelson contrast ratio between the grey and the white backgrounds was 0.87 (Fig 1D). Against each background, a 7-cm diameter black disc (R = 255, G = 255, B = 255) approached the locust at a velocity of 300 cm·s-1 (looming) from the bottom right at 45° azimuth and −45° elevation. The trajectory of the looming disc was designed so that it remained within the lower half of the dome screen for the majority of its motion. Additionally, a fourth visual stimulus (F) consisted of only the flow field below the horizon line. Previous studies used flow field backgrounds that consisted of vertical bars that expanded across the entire visual field [29,37], or squares expanding from the center of the screen [20]. The type of flow field used here was designed to emulate the natural visual environment when the locust is flying. Since flying animals are closer to the ground than the sky, the objects on the ground would appear faster and more conspicuous. Therefore, the optic flow in the lower half of the visual field is more prominent than that in the top half. By dividing the visual background vertically into two halves and showing the flow field in the bottom half only, we presented a simplified background that simulates a horizon line. Preliminary testing indicated that there was no effect of a flow field on looming responses when the object approached from 45° azimuth at 0° elevation. For this trajectory, the top half of the object approached within the white background, which likely attenuated any putative effects of a flow field [29], regardless of flow field contrast or velocity. Therefore, we chose a looming stimulus that moved upwards from −45° elevation to ensure the disc was within the flow field except for the final 20.2 ms of each approach. When presented with looming stimuli approaching within different areas across the receptive field, some parameters of the DCMD response are different, yet the shapes of the PSTH remain largely unaffected [38,39]. We found a similar effect among the other motion-sensitive units and common trends extracted from these units. We collected similar multichannel data in an independent dataset that tested different hypotheses with respect to object motion at different elevation angles (manuscript in review). From this data, we observed that the number of responsive units and the number of common trends, representing the types of responses among all responsive units, were consistent between looming at 0° elevation and −45° elevation. Locusts display motion dazzle. When presented with a two-tone looming object, in which the top half is darker than the background while the bottom half is lighter, the DCMD responds less than the top (dark) half alone [40]. However, the flow field we used here was composed of white and grey circles, both lighter than the black object (Michelson contrast ratio between black and white = 0.98, Michelson contrast ratio between black and grey = 0.80). Therefore, the motion dazzle was likely not present in our stimuli. Each visual stimulus was presented 5 times, resulting in a total of 20 presentations, the order of which was randomized for each locust. To prevent neural habituation, the visual stimuli were presented with a 3-minute interval between each presentation. Additionally, a direct loom was presented before and after the sequence of the 20 presentations to ensure that no attenuation of the neural responses occurred during the length of the experiment. Data acquisition The neural signals from all 5 channels, including 1 channel from the silver hook electrode and 4 channels from the twisted wire tetrode, were amplified using a differential amplifier (Model 1700, A-M Systems, Sequim, United States) with a high pass filter at 300 Hz, a low pass filter at 5 kHz, and a gain of 100 × . These amplified neural signals, along with the stimulus pulse, were then digitized using a USB data acquisition board (DT9818-OEM, TechmaTron Instrument Inc., Laval, Canada) and recorded at a sampling rate of 25 kHz per channel using DataView version 11 (W.J. Heitler, University of St Andrews, St Andrews, Scotland). Spike sorting For each locust, all 20 raw recordings were merged chronologically into a single file and then filtered using a Finite Impulse Response (FIR) filter with a bandpass range of 500–2000 Hz and a Blackman window type using DataView. The filtered data from the four channels of the tetrode were exported to Offline Sorter version 4.6 (Plexon Inc., Dallas, United States) for waveform detection and spike sorting. The waveform detection threshold was set to three times the standard deviation over the mean of each channel. The detection time was set such that each waveform was contained within a 2-ms window and then aligned to the largest peak on either side. Spike sorting was performed using a semi-automatic method based on the T-Dist E-M algorithm [41]. The degree-of-freedom (DOF) multiplier was set to 3, and the initial number of units was set to 26. Subsequently, manual discrimination was based on the shape and amplitude of the waveforms for final unit sorting. A Multivariate Analysis of Variance (MANOVA) was used to compare the distribution of the sorted units in the 3D principal component (PC) space. We used the built-in MANOVA test provided by the Offline Sorter software to statistically validate the separation of our sorted units. This test compares the distributions of spike data points in the 3D feature space, defined by the first three principal components. The independent variable for the test is the assigned unit (cluster), and the dependent variables are the feature vectors (i.e., the PC scores) for each individual waveform within those units. Fig 2A shows raw recordings and sorted units from one trial of an object approaching against a white background, whereas Fig 2B and 2C show PC clusters and overlapping waveforms from units sorted from the merged file that contains all 20 stimulus trials for the same locust. Spike sorting and identification of responsive units. (A) Raw recording and sorted units from one trial of an object approaching against a white background. The top 6 channels show raw recordings from the hook electrode, the stimulus event pulse (stim), and each channel of the tetrode. Waveforms (bottom) were detected using average plus three times the standard deviation as the threshold, and sorted based on the cluster variance in the 3D principal component (PC) space. Spike sorting results from the same recording time window (tetrode sorted) are shown underneath the raw recordings. Each colour represents a different unit. (B) The distribution of all 20 spike-sorted units in the 3D PC space, with (B.i) showing all units, and (B.ii) showing a zoomed-in view of the unit clusters close to the center, as labeled by the dashed white box in (i). The colour coding of each sorted unit is the same as in A. (C) Overlapped waveforms of all 20 units from the same locust, recorded from all four channels of the tetrode, as numbered on the top right corner of each panel. The colour coding of each sorted unit is the same as in A and B. (D) Identification of responsive units. For each spike-sorted unit, the peristimulus time histogram (PSTH), representing the change of firing rate during the stimulus presentation, is shown at the bottom of each block. The cumulative sum and 99% confidence level (represented by the dark orange ellipses) are plotted on the top half of each block. If the cumulative sum (represented by the black line inside the ellipse) touched or extended outside the ellipse (plots with a light orange background), the unit was determined to have responded to the stimulus. If the cumulative sum remained within the ellipse for the entire duration (plots with a light blue background), the unit was determined to have not responded. Note that not all units generated spikes during this stimulus presentation. Inactive and non-responsive units were removed from subsequent analyses. Spike train analysis The spike times of spike-sorted units were exported to NeuroExplorer Version 5 (Plexon, Dallas, United States) for further analysis. Peristimulus time histograms (PSTHs) were generated using a 1-ms bin width and smoothed with a 50-ms Gaussian filter. All trials were aligned to the projected time of collision (TOC). For trials involving a looming disc, a 2.2-second window was used, starting 2 seconds before TOC, and ending 0.2 seconds after TOC. For trials with the flow field only, a 10-second window was employed, spanning 5 seconds before the flow field onset and ending 5 seconds after. To evaluate the responsiveness of individual units, cumulative sum plots were created along with an ellipse representing the 99% confidence level (Fig 2D) [42,43]. The cumulative sum was calculated in NeuroExplorer using the following algorithm: In this algorithm, cs(n) represents the cumulative sum of the n-th bin, bc(n) represents the spike bin count of the n-th bin, and A represents the average of all bin counts. If the cumulative sum remained within the 99% confidence level ellipse, it indicated that the firing rate of the corresponding unit did not exhibit a significant change during the stimulus presentation, implying that the unit did not respond to the visual stimulus. Conversely, if the cumulative sum touched or extended beyond the ellipse, it was considered responsive to the visual stimuli [42–44]. Units that did not exhibit a response were excluded from subsequent analyses. Dimensionality reduction The responses of individual units were first examined to determine how many types of visual stimuli each unit responded to. Between different animals, the same neuron could have been recorded multiple times. Therefore, we pooled the responsive units across all animals based on the visual stimulus. For each stimulus, the response types were initially categorized by observing the peristimulus time histogram (PSTHs) of individual units. The categorization was adopted from previous studies [42,44]. Firing parameters, including the peak time relative to TOC (Pt), peak firing rate amplitude (Pa), rise phase (from the time when the unit firing rate exceeded the upper 95% confidence interval to the peak time), and decay phase (from the peak time to when the firing rate decayed below 15% of the peak firing rate) [21,45], were measured from the PSTHs of those units that displayed a clear peak, and compared between different backgrounds. Due to the nature of multichannel recording, it was not possible to record unambiguously from the same neurons in each locust and, therefore, it was necessary to reduce the dimensionality of the data to identify putative trends across the entire dataset [42]. Dynamic Factor Analysis (DFA) was then used to extract common trends from the responsive units for each visual stimulus [42,46]. In this model, a set of n observed time series (y) (units) is explained by a set of m hidden random walks (x) (common trends) through linear combination, represented by factor loadings (Z) and offsets (a). The model equations can be written as follows: In the model, the error terms of hidden processes (x) (common trends) and observations (y) (units) were represented by wt and vt, respectively. Both wt and vt follow a multivariate normal distribution (MVN), with a mean of 0 and covariate matrices of R and Q, respectively. To identify the model, certain constraints were applied: the first m elements of a were set to 0, zi,j was set to 0 if j > i for the first m-1 rows of Z, and Q was set to the identity matrix Im. DFA was performed using the MARSS package v3.11.4 [47] in R 4.1.3 (R Core Team, 2022), using the Broyden–Fletcher–Goldfarb–Shanno (BFGS) method. The model quality was evaluated using the Akaike Information Criterion with a correction for small sample size (AICc) [48]. For each visual stimulus, DFA was iteratively performed, starting with one common trend. The number of common trends gradually increased until AICc began to increase, and the model with the lowest AICc was selected as the optimal model. The extracted common trends were further analyzed. The factor loadings (Z) of each common trend were used to rectify any potentially reversed trends and scale the common trends. According to the DFA model, yt = Z × xt + a + vt, for the i-th common trend ((xT)i) and the corresponding factor loadings (Zi), if (xT)i was multiplied by a scale factor, while Zi was divided by the same scale factor, the overall model is not affected. The sign of the scale factor was determined by the average of Zi, while the value was determined by the largest absolute value among all elements within Zi. If the average of Zi was negative, it indicates that the common trend contributes negatively to most unit responses (observations), and therefore, reversing the sign would make the common trend consistent with the majority of units. The value was chosen to scale all factor loadings to (−1, 1), and therefore, to make the scale of all common trends comparable to each other. For common trends showing clear peaks, various parameters, such as peak time, rise phase, and decay phase, were measured from the PSTHs. These parameters were then compared between different backgrounds. Statistical analysis Statistical analyses were executed using SigmaPlot version 12.5 (Systat Software, San Jose, USA) or R 4.1.3 (R Core Team, 2022), and plotted using SigmaPlot. Prior to applying specific tests, datasets were preliminarily assessed for normal distribution (Shapiro-Wilk test) and homoscedasticity. Parametric data was articulated through arithmetic mean and standard deviation, and plotted with a column graph. Nonparametric data was articulated through median and quartiles, and plotted with a box plot. Response parameters were compared through either one-way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) (for parametric data) or Kruskal-Wallis One Way Analysis of Variance on Ranks (for nonparametric data). Variables with an inherent relationship were compared using either one-way repeated measure (RM) ANOVA (for parametric data) or Friedman Repeated Measures Analysis of Variance on Ranks (for nonparametric data). Two-way comparisons were executed utilizing two-way RM ANOVA and Holm-Sidak post-hoc test. All statistical examinations were two-tailed, and the significance level (α) was determined to be 0.05. Power analysis for ANOVA used data from previous studies to estimate the minimal detectable difference in means, the expected standard deviation of residuals, the number of groups, and group size. The power was > 0.8 for ANOVA and Chi-square tests. Results Unit discrimination All twenty trials from each animal were chronologically merged for spike discrimination and unit sorting. Utilizing a positive threshold of three times the standard deviation above the mean, we detected 571,515 spikes across all twenty-one animals (median = 25,637 spikes per locust, 1st quartile = 23,692 spikes per locust, 3rd quartile = 29,090.5 spikes per locust). From these spikes, we spike-sorted 352 distinct units (mean = 16.8 units per locust, standard deviation = 3.4 units per locust). Multivariate Analysis of Variance (MANOVA) verified the statistical distinctiveness of these units in three-dimensional PC space (p < 0.001). A comprehensive summary of the spike-sorted spikes and units for all animals is provided in S1 Table. Unit responses S2 Table summarizes the number of units that responded to each stimulus type. Out of the total 352 spike-sorted units, 248 units (70%) exhibited responses to looming stimuli against a white background (LW), 238 units (68%) responded to looming stimuli against a half-white-half-grey background (LG), 242 units (69%) responded to looming stimuli against a flow field background (LF), 222 units (63%) responded to the flow field only (F), and 28 units (8%) did not respond to any of the visual stimuli. One-way ANOVA revealed that there was no significant difference in the number of units responding to looming stimuli against different backgrounds (F2 = 0.14, p = 0.87), nor was there a significant difference in the percentage of responsive units from each animal (One-way ANOVA, F2 = 0.49, p = 0.61) (Fig 3). Percent of units that responded to each type of visual stimulus. Within each box, the red horizontal line represents the median, while the lower and upper boundaries, the whiskers, and the dots represent the 25/75%, 10/90%, and 5/95% percentiles, respectively. Grey symbols to the left of each box are the individual data points, each from one locust (N = 21). One-way repeated measure (RM) ANOVA revealed that there was no statistical difference between the number of units that responded to different types of visual stimuli. LW = looming against a white background, LG = looming against a half-white and half-grey background, LF = looming against a flow field, F = flow field only. However, it is worth noting that the responses of these units were not exclusive to a single background. A unit could respond to looming stimuli against one or more visual backgrounds. Fig 4 illustrates the distribution of the percentage of different types of looming stimuli that the units responded to. Among the total 352 units, 63 units (15%) responded to only one type of looming stimulus (1 Loom), among which 20 units responded to LW, 18 units responded to LG, and 25 units responded to LF. 42 units (12%) responded to two out of the three looming stimuli (2 Looms), among which 19 units responded to LW & LG, 15 units responded to LW & LF, and 8 units responded to LG & LF. 194 units (55%) responded to looming stimuli against all three backgrounds (3 Looms). Additionally, 25 units responded exclusively to the flow field (F) and none of the looming stimuli, and 28 units did not respond to any stimuli (NR). Percentage of responsive units based on stimulus properties. Each column represents the number of units (n) that responded to looming stimuli flow field only, or none. Out of all 352 spike-sorted units, 63 units (18%) responded to looming stimuli against only one background (1 Loom), 42 units (12%) responded to looming stimuli against two backgrounds (2 Looms), and 194 units (55%) responded to looming stimuli against all three backgrounds (3 Looms). See text for details. Overall, the background type did not affect how many units responded to the looming stimulus. NR = no response. Overall, the number of units responding to looming stimuli was relatively similar across all three backgrounds, suggesting that the visual background did not affect the number of units responding within a putative population. Categorization of unit response Previous studies showed the classification of units based on firing rate properties [42,44]. We identified similar categories based on the trends of firing rate changes over time in response to a similar stimulus (looming object approaching against a white background). Fig 5 illustrates the average PSTH and 95% confidence interval of the five categories of responses to LW: 1) firing rate peaked near the projected time of collision (TOC); 2) firing rate showed a valley near TOC; 3) firing rate gradually increased over time; 4) slow firing rate increase with no distinct peak; 5) firing rate remained constant during the looming and increased near the end of the recording, after TOC. S3 Table provides a summary of the distribution of response categories for looming against different visual backgrounds. The distribution of response categories was similar between LW and LG. However, when presented with LF, only 5 units, compared to 21 for LW and 27 for LG, displayed a gradual increase (category 3). Additionally, more units showed a constant firing rate that increased near the end (category 5). It is likely that some units in categories 1 and 3 exhibited a delayed response to LF, leading to their placement in category 5. Categorization of units responding to a looming stimulus against a white background (LW). All peristimulus time histograms (PSTHs), represented by the grey lines, were aligned to the projected time of collision (TOC), represented by the red vertical line. The black solid lines represent the average PSTH, while the black dotted lines represent the 95% confidence intervals. Category 1 included units that showed a peak near TOC. Category 2 included units that showed a valley near TOC. Category 3 included units that showed a gradual increase during the stimulus presentation. Category 4 included units that showed a slow firing rate increase with no distinct peak. Category 5 included units that showed an increase towards the end of the displayed window, after TOC. Fig 6 shows the responses of units from one locust that were classified into the corresponding response category. In general, units in each category were affected by the background. However, we did not find units from each category in all locusts, which precludes a detailed analysis of all individual units. Therefore, it was necessary to plot the data pooled from all animals. Recent studies using multichannel recordings revealed different and variable categories of responses to looming stimuli against a white background [42]. Because of the variable responses, there are no a priori response parameters of multiple units responding in the presence of a flow field. Therefore, we did not attempt to measure specific parameters from responses in categories 2–5. Indeed, the intent of this study is to examine responses from putative neural ensembles. Responses of spike-sorted units from each response category in one locust. Peristimulus time histograms show responses of units in each category (columns) to the four stimuli (rows). LW represents a loom against a white background, LG is a loom against a lower grey background, LF is a loom against a lower flow field, and F is a lower field with no approaching object. The red vertical line is the time of collision (TOC). The same time window axes for F were selected after the flow field began moving. The PSTHs of the unit in category 1 was enlarged to show the shape of the peak near TOC. For response category 1, which peaked near TOC, various parameters were calculated, including the peak firing rate, peak time (relative to TOC), rise phase, and decay phase [21,44,45] (Fig 7). Analysis of units in category 1 was based on the resemblance of firing rate modulation properties to those from previous studies that focused specifically on DCMD [20]. The rise phase was defined as the time from when the unit’s firing rate last exceeded the upper 95% confidence interval (t95), i.e., the response start time, to the peak time (Pt), while the decay phase was measured from the peak time to when the firing rate decayed to 15% of the peak firing rate (t15). Among the 194 units that responded to looming against all three backgrounds, 135 units (70%) exhibited a category 1 response to all three looming stimuli. Across different backgrounds, there were significant differences in peak time (Friedman Repeated Measures Analysis of Variance on Ranks, χ22 = 44.236, p < 0.001), the length of the rise phase (Friedman Repeated Measures Analysis of Variance on Ranks, χ22 = 70.673, p < 0.001), and t95 (One Way Repeated Measures ANOVA, F2, 134 = 166.393, p < 0.001). However, no significant differences were found in peak firing rate (Friedman Repeated Measures Analysis of Variance on Ranks, χ22 = 4.326, p = 0.115) or the length of the decay phase (Friedman Repeated Measures Analysis of Variance on Ranks, χ22 = 3.318, p = 0.190). Tukey post-hoc tests indicated that all pairwise comparisons were significantly different for peak time (LW vs LG: q = 4.088, p < 0.05; LW vs LF: q = 9.338, p < 0.05; LG vs LF: q = 5.250, p < 0.05), although the difference in peak time between LW and LG was relatively small. For the rise phase, there was no statistical difference between LW and LG (Tukey post-hoc test, q = 2.711, p > 0.05), while both LW and LG showed significantly higher values than LF (LW vs LF: q = 8.650, p < 0.05; LG vs LF: q = 11.361, p < 0.05). Similarly, for t95, there was no statistical difference between LW and LG (Holm-Sidak post-hoc test, t = 1.166, p = 0.245), while LF showed significantly delayed t95 than both LW and LG (LW vs LF: Holm-Sidak post-hoc test, t = 15.183, p < 0.001; LG vs LF: Holm-Sidak post-hoc test, t = 16.349, p < 0.001). It is important to note that, as peak times were delayed in LF, the selected trial length (−2 to 0.2 seconds relative to TOC) did not always include a full decay phase, i.e., firing rate did not fall below 15% of the peak firing rate by the end of the trial. Consequently, the sample size for the decay phase comparison (N = 78 units) was smaller than that of the other parameters, making it more difficult to find a significant difference. Comparison of response parameters of units in Category 1 (peak near TOC) between background types. (A) Sample PSTH of a Category 1 unit in response to a looming stimulus. The red vertical line represents the time of collision (TOC), while the grey dashed line represents the upper 95% confidence interval of the histogram. The last time the instantaneous firing rate exceeded the upper 95% confidence interval (t95) was defined as the beginning of the response, while the time when the firing rate decayed below 15% of the peak firing rate (t15) was defined as the end of the response. The duration from t95 to the peak was defined as the rise phase, and the duration from the peak to t15 was defined as the decay phase. (B) The peak time relative to TOC (Pt), (C) peak firing rate amplitude (Pa), (D) rise phase, (E) decay phase, and (F) response start time (t95) of each PSTH were measured and compared using one-way repeated measure (RM) ANOVA. Different letters above the boxes represent statistically significant differences. The white and grey backgrounds evoked similar peak times (grey being slightly later), while the flow field evoked a significant peak delay. The flow field also resulted in delayed response initiation and shortened rise phases. N = 135 for B-D and 78 for E. Within each box, the red horizontal line represents the median, while the lower and upper boundaries, the whiskers, and the dots represent the 25/75%, 10/90%, and 5/95% percentiles, respectively. In summary, among individual responsive units within response category 1, LW and LG elicited similar responses, while the addition of a flow field background (LF) resulted in delayed peak firing and a shorter rise phase for units in category 1, indicating a delayed and more brief response. Common trends Dynamic factor analysis (DFA) was conducted using the MARSS package in R 4.1.3 to extract common trends from all responsive units. Initial attempts to perform DFA on Gaussian-smoothed 1-ms-binned data resulted in consistent crashes of R due to the model’s complexity. Consequently, the firing rate was recalculated using a 50-ms bin width without smoothing. Although temporal resolution was reduced, the 50-ms-binned data captured the dynamic modulation of firing rate while significantly reducing computational complexity by a factor of fifty [44]. For each of the 4 visual stimuli, DFA was iteratively performed with an increasing number of common trends, starting from 1. The Akaike information criterion with a correction for small sample sizes (AICc) was used to monitor the performance of each model. When the AICc began to increase, the iteration was halted, and the model with the lowest AICc was deemed the optimal model. S4 Table shows that the optimal models for LW and LG both included 7 common trends. This consistency with the optimal model for looming at 0° elevation against a white background [30] indicates that neither the looming trajectory (45° upwards) nor the half-white-half-grey background influenced the level of variability in the locust’s response to a black looming stimulus. In contrast, despite evoking a similar number of responsive units, the optimal model for LF only contained 5 common trends, suggesting less variation among unit responses. This indicates a more stereotyped and temporally shifted population code in the presence of optic flow. Fig 8 depicts the activity of all the extracted common trends in response to each stimulus. In response to a looming stimulus, irrespective of background types, most common trends exhibited a positive peak near the time of collision (TOC). Though individual unit categorization included responses that generated a negative peak or no clear peak (Fig 5), most units (~70% - see S3 Table) generated a distinct positive peak near TOC. The data reduction methods would have given more weight to these units when calculating the common trends. Therefore, it is not surprising that most common trends showed a positive peak. Against all three backgrounds, only one common trend did not show a peak, and instead, continuously increased until the end of the stimulus presentation (CT5 for LW, CT7 LG, and CT4 LF). When presented with the flow field background only (F), without the looming stimulus, the primary type of response was a brief peak right after the time when the flow field started (Tff), followed by a gradual decrease, suggesting adaptation to the flow field. Although the best DFA model contained 6 CTs, the first three CTs all showed this type of response, while the other CTs remained at a relatively stable level with no clear change near Tff. Common trends (CTs) responses to all four types of visual stimuli. In each column, peristimulus time histograms (PSTHs) of the CTs from a stimulus type were plotted, aligned to either the projected time of collision (TOC) or the time when the flow field started displaying (Tff). The bin width was 50 ms. In DFA models, the order of CTs was randomized, i.e., CT1 from the first and second columns are not necessarily the same. The factor loadings of constituent spike-sorted units in each CT are shown next to the PSTH in a heatmap. Within a heatmap, each horizontal line represents the correlation of one spike-sorted unit and the corresponding common trend. The order of units in the heatmap is also consistent within a column. Irrespective of background types, most CTs responded to a looming stimulus with a peak near TOC, similar to a DCMD response. The remaining common trend from each background (CT5 in the white background, CT7 in the half-white-half-grey background, and CT4 in the flow field background) continuously increased until the end of stimulus presentation. For the last visual stimulus, flow field only, CT 1-3 displayed a peak at Tff, when the flow field started, while CT 4-6 remained at a relatively constant level without a clear change near Tff. Among the common trends displaying clear peaks, the peak times occurred before or after TOC in response to LW and LG, while in response to LF, only one common trend (CT 3) had a peak time before TOC, and all other common trends had peaks after TOC. The median peak time of LF common trends was the highest (i.e., latest) among all three looming stimuli, and the rise phase for LF was the shortest. These findings aligned with the peak times observed in category 1 unit responses, although the comparisons of peak time and rise phase were not statistically significant (One-way ANOVA; peak time, F2 = 0.507, p = 0.618; rise phase, F2 = 0.798, p = 0.480) (Fig 9), likely due to small sample size (N = 4 (LW), 5 (LG), and 3 (F)) and low statistical power. However, it is worth noting that the response start time (t95), defined as when the unit firing rate exceeded the upper 95% confidence interval, was significantly influenced by the type of visual background (Kruskal-Wallis One-Way Analysis of Variance on Ranks, H2 = 7.096, p = 0.014). The response began later in response to LF, compared to LG (Dunn’s post-hoc test, p < 0.05). Since the firing rate did not decay below 15% of the peak firing rate before the end of stimulus presentation in some common trends (e.g., CT 1, 3, and 4), the sample size of t15 and decay phase was too small (≤ 3 for each background) to derive meaningful comparisons. Comparison of response parameters of common trends (CTs) that peaked near TOC. (A) Sample PSTH of a common trend in response to a looming stimulus. The red vertical line represents the time of collision (TOC), while the grey dashed line represents the upper 95% confidence interval. The last time the instantaneous firing rate exceeded the upper 95% confidence interval (t95) was defined as the start of the response. We defined the duration from t95 to the peak as the rise phase. (B–D) Box plots comparing CT firing parameters. The peak time relative to collision (B), rise phase (C), and response begin time (D) of each PSTH were measured and compared using one-way repeated measure (RM) ANOVA. Similar to Fig 7, the flow field background resulted in a later peak and shortened rise phase in the CTs, but the difference was not statistically significant. The response start, however, was significantly later in the flow field background, compared to the white and grey backgrounds. Within each box, the red horizontal line represents the median, while the lower and upper boundaries and the whiskers represent the 25/75% and 10/90% percentiles, respectively. Different letters above boxes represent statistically significant differences. Discussion During flight, optic flow is a main source of spatial information that an animal can acquire. Components of the optic flow can be used to calculate the distance and trajectory of nearby objects. This is the first study to investigate the effect of a flow field background on looming responses of multiple interneurons in the locust visual system. We found that multiple units were responsive to a looming disc approaching upwards from the bottom right at 45° azimuth and −45° elevation, yet displaying various types of responses. Compared to looming against the white background (LW) and half-white-half-grey background (LG), looming against the flow field background (LF) affected the distribution of different response categories among responsive units. Common trends (CTs) were extracted and compared between background types. Both LW and LG evoked 7 CTs, the same as loom from 90° azimuth at 0° elevation, while LF evoked 5 CTs, suggesting that the flow field background reduced the variability among unit responses. In both individual units and common trends, the flow field background caused the responses to be delayed. Technical considerations The experiments conducted here were, by necessity, in open-loop conditions with recordings from a locust on a fixed tether. Therefore, we were not able to record motor responses to the stimuli, and responses to the motion stimuli did not feed back into the stimulus generation. While it is important to study neural responses and subsequent motor behaviour in closed-loop, it was not the focus of the experiments reported and was beyond the scope of the setup that we used. Nevertheless, this work builds on earlier studies that also used open-loop conditions and, therefore, the data contribute further to our understanding of this system. A modified setup is currently being used to study DCMD responses to object motion against various backgrounds in tethered locusts that can flap their wings and provide feedback to the stimulus parameters in real time. The number of sorted units that we report here is consistent with previous work using the same semi-automatic sorting method [42]. That study used 8 channels from a 2 x 2 tetrode array positioned along the long axis of the nerve cord. Here, we used a single twisted wire tetrode array that was inserted into the nerve cord, which was supported by a silver hook electrode. Our design provided increased stability to the cord and ensured the placement of all recording sites within the sheath surrounding the cord. Given that the cord between the subesophageal and prothoracic ganglia contains ~60 axons with diameters >5 μm [49], we likely sampled from a high percentage of descending sensory neurons at the recording site. Effect of the flow field on collision detection When an animal moves through its environment, optic flow is generated as a translational or rotational pattern that is perceived by the eye [50]. Animals use optic flow to assess self-motion and stabilize trajectory. For example, honeybees use optic flow to maintain flight height [51], while bumblebees use optic flow in the frontal visual field to control position, flight height, and flight speed [52–54]. In locusts, a flow field consisting of white and grey vertical bars can elicit excitatory postsynaptic potentials (EPSPs) in the LGMD, quickly followed by inhibitory postsynaptic potentials (IPSPs) [45] via activation of lateral and feed-forward inhibition [14,55]. Therefore, LGMD response to small looming objects is inhibited by large-field optic flow, represented by fewer spikes and shorter rise phases [14,20]. In the DCMD, it was found that compared to a white background, a more complex visual background, such as the flow field, caused reduced peak firing rate, delayed peaks, and shorter rise phases as well [29,37]. We found that flow-field-induced peak time delay and rise phase shortening were common among multiple motion-sensitive neurons, although the peak firing rate was not statistically affected. The compass cells [56] found in the central complex (CX) of locusts can use polarized light to determine the orientation of the animal [57] and also respond to approaching and translating objects [58,59]. On average, the peak time of the compass cells was delayed in the presence of a flow field. However, the response of most compass cells to looming objects was inhibited by the presence of large-field motion, while some were enhanced [60]. This suggests that a group of neurons is only responsive to looming when optic flow is present, i.e., when the animal is moving. This is similar to recent findings in the monarch butterfly, which show that heading-direction neurons in the central complex change their tuning from sun-bearing coding to a global sun compass during flight [61]. Here we spike-sorted units (n = 25) that responded to LF only, but not to LW or LG (Fig 4). It is possible that these units can enhance motion detection during flight, and play an important role in proper flight manoeuvres within a large swarm. Units that responded to the flow field only We found that a group of units (n = 25) responded to the flow field only, but not to any of the looming stimuli. Despite not directly responding to looming objects, these units can potentially use the flow field to access the self-motion of the animal, and thus factor into the execution of successful collision avoidance behaviours. Neurons that are exclusively sensitive to large-field motion have been identified in multiple species, such as flies [62], moths [63], praying mantis [64], and crabs [65,66]. In hawkmoths, two types of large-field motion-sensitive neurons, the horizontal cells and the vertical cells, were identified in the lobula plate [67]. In honeybees, horizontal regressive- and progressive motion-sensitive neurons were found to be selectively sensitive to regression or progression motion, respectively [68]. In locusts, although the DCMD does not respond to the initiation of large-field grating stimuli [69], large-field motion-sensitive neurons have been identified in the optic lobe [70–72] and ventral nerve cord [73]. The two lobula directionally selective motion-detecting neurons (LDSMD) respond preferably to flow field moving forwards or backwards, respectively, and one of them synapses with the protocerebral descending directionally selective motion-detecting neuron (PDDSMD) [72,73]. Those neurons found in the medulla, however, did not display directional selectivity [71]. It is worth noting that although the axon of the PDDSMD extends in the ventral nerve cord towards the metathoracic ganglion, it is ipsilateral to the cell body, while we recorded from the contralateral nerve cord. In our study, only one type of flow field was presented, and thus we could not test for directional sensitivity. Based on previous findings, we assume that some of these units, as well as neural ensembles, will display directional preference, while others do not. This can be tested in future studies using various flow field backgrounds and larger-scale multichannel recordings. Population coding of motion-sensitive neurons The response of individual neurons is often “noisy”, displaying large variability over repeated stimuli. Compared to individual neurons, functional groups of neurons, i.e., neural ensembles, can represent complicated information and convey robust guides to generate appropriate behavioural responses. In the rat gustatory cortex, neural ensembles progress through reliable and stimulus-specific sequences of states, although the timing of transitions varies between trials [74]. In the locust antennal lobe, multiple projection neurons encode different odorants, while the ensemble activity displays complex patterns over repeated presentation [75]. We found that despite variability among individual neuron responses, the extracted common trends, which represent ensemble activity, remain largely stable. The dominant types of common trends match the response of previously identified motion-sensitive interneurons, providing a reliable interpretation of the given stimuli. While repeated co-activation of the same neurons can strengthen their synaptic connections and increase the likelihood of the same neural ensemble reoccurring, mechanisms like changes in short-term synaptic dynamics enable flexible reconfiguration of ensemble composition to meet varying computational needs [76]. In the rat anterior cingulate cortex, ensemble activity during a reward-searching task is affected by previous behavioural history [77]. Physiological states can also determine the level of synchronization among neuron populations [78]. In Drosophila, previous experience and hunger state affect the ensemble coding during the determination of the food value [79]. Here, we showed that when presented with identical looming stimuli against different backgrounds, individual unit responses and common trends were both affected. Since the units were generally from the same pool, changes in common trends, both the total number and the peristimulus time histogram, reflect the fluidity of the contribution from individual units. This fluidity could have implications for collision avoidance behaviour. While it is known that the timing of DCMD activity relates to the initiation of avoidance behaviours [25,26], it is not clear how the effects of a flow field on the timing of DCMD spikes would affect the putative triggering of avoidance. While delay in peak firing and change in the decay slope could delay the behaviour, this likely represents an adaptive trade-off. In conditions containing self-generated optic flow, the nervous system may adopt a more conservative triggering policy, delaying responses to prevent false alarms, while producing a more consistent output once activation occurs. Through fluidity of putative neural ensembles, as suggested here, the collision avoidance system could be imparted with the ability to dynamically alter the initiation and magnitude of responses in the face of behavioural activity states and complex visual environments that include optic flow. Therefore, future studies could incorporate closed-loop experiments to determine how individual unit and ensemble responses relate to changes in the animal’s motor output when successfully avoiding collision. Our results provide neural grounding for models that treat visual motion cues as drivers of group coordination and selective responses in crowded environments [80–82]. Supporting information Summary of spike detection and unit discrimination. On average, 27215 spikes (waveforms) were detected, and 16.8 units were spike-sorted. The MANOVA results show that the spike-sorted units were statistically distinct from each other. (TIF) Summary of the number of units that responded to each type of visual stimulus. LW represents loom against the white background, LG represents loom against the grey background, and LF represents loom against the flow field background. (TIF) Distribution of units in different categories when presented with looming against different visual backgrounds (LW, white; LG, half-white-half-grey; LF, flow field). The distribution was similar between LW and LG. However, in response to LF, the proportion of Category 3 decreased, while the proportion of Category 5 increased. (TIF) Summary of dynamic factor analysis (DFA) models. For each stimulus type, the DFA model was performed iteratively, starting with 1 common trend (CT). The Akaike information criterion (AIC) and AIC corrected for small sample size (AICc) of each model are shown above. Since AICc can prevent over-fitting, it was used to determine the best-fit approximating model. For looming against both white and white/grey backgrounds, the best models contained 7 common trends. For looming against the flow field background, the best model contained 5 common trends. For flow field only, the best model contained 6 common trends. (TIF) 24 Apr 2025 Dear Dr. Zhang, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS ONE’s publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. ============================== While the reviewers have found merit in your work, they raised significant concerns regarding the illustration of the data (e.g. unclear images, not enough raw data), the methodologies employed, data processing steps, etc. Please address all concerns raised by reviewers before resubmitting your manuscript. ============================== Please submit your revised manuscript by Jun 08 2025 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org . When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'.A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'.An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If you would like to make changes to your financial disclosure, please include your updated statement in your cover letter. Guidelines for resubmitting your figure files are available below the reviewer comments at the end of this letter. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols . Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols . We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Tudor C. Badea, M.D., M.A., Ph.D. Academic Editor PLOS ONE Journal Requirements: When submitting your revision, we need you to address these additional requirements. 1. Please ensure that your manuscript meets PLOS ONE's style requirements, including those for file naming. The PLOS ONE style templates can be found at https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=wjVg/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_main_body.pdf and https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=ba62/PLOSOne_formatting_sample_title_authors_affiliations.pdf 2. Thank you for stating the following financial disclosure: “Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (Award RGPIN-2019-03983)” Please state what role the funders took in the study. If the funders had no role, please state: "The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript." If this statement is not correct you must amend it as needed. Please include this amended Role of Funder statement in your cover letter; we will change the online submission form on your behalf. 3. We note that Figure 1 in your submission contain copyrighted images. All PLOS content is published under the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which means that the manuscript, images, and Supporting Information files will be freely available online, and any third party is permitted to access, download, copy, distribute, and use these materials in any way, even commercially, with proper attribution. For more information, see our copyright guidelines: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/licenses-and-copyright. We require you to either (1) present written permission from the copyright holder to publish these figures specifically under the CC BY 4.0 license, or (2) remove the figures from your submission: a. You may seek permission from the original copyright holder of Figure 1 to publish the content specifically under the CC BY 4.0 license. We recommend that you contact the original copyright holder with the Content Permission Form (http://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/file?id=7c09/content-permission-form.pdf) and the following text: “I request permission for the open-access journal PLOS ONE to publish XXX under the Creative Commons Attribution License (CCAL) CC BY 4.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Please be aware that this license allows unrestricted use and distribution, even commercially, by third parties. Please reply and provide explicit written permission to publish XXX under a CC BY license and complete the attached form.” Please upload the completed Content Permission Form or other proof of granted permissions as an "Other" file with your submission. In the figure caption of the copyrighted figure, please include the following text: “Reprinted from [ref] under a CC BY license, with permission from [name of publisher], original copyright [original copyright year].” b. If you are unable to obtain permission from the original copyright holder to publish these figures under the CC BY 4.0 license or if the copyright holder’s requirements are incompatible with the CC BY 4.0 license, please either i) remove the figure or ii) supply a replacement figure that complies with the CC BY 4.0 license. Please check copyright information on all replacement figures and update the figure caption with source information. If applicable, please specify in the figure caption text when a figure is similar but not identical to the original image and is therefore for illustrative purposes only. Additional Editor Comments: While the reviewers have found merit in your work, they raised significant concerns regarding the illustration of the data (e.g. unclear images, not enough raw data), the methodologies employed, data processing steps, etc. Please address all concerns raised by reviewers before resubmitting your manuscript. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author 1. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions? Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Partly ********** 2. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously? -->?> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: No ********** 3. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available??> The PLOS Data policy Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: No Reviewer #3: No ********** 4. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English??> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** Reviewer #1: The paper by Zhang et al. represents yet another contribution to our extensive and growing knowledge related to the response of motion-sensitive descending interneurons in the locust. This well-characterized system has successfully served for many years as a model for the study of visual responses in complex, dynamic environments. In this report, the authors present a statistically extensive analysis of the multi-unit response to looming stimuli over different visual backgrounds, including a flow-field background. The major finding is that, while background complexity has some effect on the temporal aspects of the multi-unit response, the basic looming response remains intact. While somewhat difficult to follow due to the nature of the work, I find that, overall, the paper is well-written and the findings are well-presented. Below, I list some minor as well as more major comments (in order of appearance in the text rather than importance): 1. L 66: Density dependent phase in locusts is much more than a morphological state. 2. Figure 1: I suggest adding an indication of the direction of motion of the wide-field stimulus background (LF and F) to enhance clarity. 3. L 166: The rationale behind the decision to maintain both the looming stimulus and the flow field within the lower half of the dome screen is not trivial as a locust flying within a dense swarm of conspecifics encounters an extremely complex visual background also in the sky or in its entire visual field. This may thus bother the reader throughout, until it is explained only in the Discussion (paragraph starting at line 514). Consider adding a few words of explanation already at a much earlier point (Intro or Methods). 4. Unfortunately, the low resolution of the figures in the PDF file hampered their review. 5. Figure 4: The figure legend is not clear enough. Please better explain the "1-3 looms" naming of the different columns. Also, what is the meaning of FF and NR? 6. Figure 6B: The peak time appears to be measured relative to the TOC, which would explain the negative values. I suggest clarifying this in the plot axes. 7. 6. The " Common trends " paragraph, starting on line 424 contains many technical details that would be more appropriate in the Methods section. 8. In the Discussion section, the authors explain in length all the details of their findings, including all minor temporal aspects of the multi-unit electrophysiological response. However, what is very much missing is the behavioral significance of all this, i.e., what is the effect of a slight delay in peak amplitude, or a minor change in the decay slope of the firing rate diagram on the behavioral motor response of the locust, on its ability to escape collision or avoid predators! Reviewer #2: In the manuscript ‘Background optic flow modulates responses of multiple descending interneurons to object motion in locusts’, Zhang and Gray conducted multichannel extracellular recordings from descending neurons of Locusta migratoria. Many of the recorded neurons were sensitive to a looming stimulus that mimics a sudden approach of a large object, e.g., a predator. The present study explicitly tested how the presence of optic flow cues in the background affects the neural response to a looming stimulus presented in the foreground. Optic flow cues are visual stimuli induced through self-motion and therefore omnipresent when an insect flies. In other words, testing the neural response to a looming stimulus in the presence of optic flow cues in the background represents a more naturalistic stimulus scenario and hence makes the study’s rationale highly attractive to a huge neuroscientific community. In addition to minor concerns, I have only a few major concerns. Unfortunately, the authors presented mostly grouped data, e.g., figure 5, which makes it difficult for the reader to evaluate the results objectively. More specifically, the reader cannot assess how the response characteristics change with different backgrounds within a unit. As all units were stimulated with all four stimuli, the strength of the author’s experimental approach is to show changes in the response profile within a unit. To appreciate the authors’ findings, it is important to present response profiles of single units in response to the four different visual stimuli. Another major point is that the recordings had been conducted in tethered, non-flying locusts. This means that the presented optic flow cues were uncoupled with the locusts’ state of locomotion (open loop). The authors must at least discuss the study’s technical drawback of recording from a stationary insect. I can imagine that a motor efference copy that closes the loop between the insect’s flight movement and the optic flow cues in the background would make the neurons more sensitive to stimuli that mismatch with the motor efference copy, i.e., a looming stimulus that approaches faster than predicted from the insect’s flight speed. Major points: • Line 144-174: At which velocity was the flow field (background) presented? If it was static, it is critical to call it ‘flow’. Based on the introduction, I would suspect to present a looming stimulus in the presence of optic flow that mimics a biologically plausible flight speed of the locust. • Why did the authors not analyze changes in the response profile induced by different backgrounds for the remaining unit categories (category 2-5)? Minor points: Line 52: Please also add a citation of Martin Egelhaaf’s group who studied the influence of optic flow on flight control for decades. Line 64: But, see the recent work of Marion Sillies who revealed six types of direction-sensitive neurons in Drosophila. (DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.abi7112) Line 89-91: Please add a sentence about the nature of your used backgrounds. What were you presenting making them ‘naturalistic’? Line 90: Typo: rigidly-tethered Line 119: Please specify how the tetrode was fabricated. Which electrodes were used to built the tetrode? Did you measure the electrode resistance before each experiment? Line 139-140: It might be helpful to add the ‘orientation °’ in Figure 1C. And please increase the size of the schematized locust in the figure. Line 165-167: Please explain why you decided to present the looming stimulus from below and not from above? Line 185-197: How large was the time window for spike detection? Maybe you could add a time scale in Figure 2B. Line 206: Instead of using the term 3D feature space, I prefer using terms like PCA. Especially, when you are using the abbreviation ‘PC’ in the figure which has not been introduced in the legend. Line 213: ‘not nonresponded’ does not make sense Line 218: ‘discriminated units’. Terms like ‘single units’ or ‘spike-sorted units’ are more common. Line 307: A maximal number of 23 recorded units per animal sounds a lot. Also, the mean of 16.8 units per animal is high. I wonder how the entire PCA of one animal looks. In Figure 2, you are only presenting 3 example units that were relatively easily distinguishable by eye. Is this also the case for an entire PCA? Line 351-366: Category 4 (Tonic response): How does it differ from a non-responsive unit? Is the firing rate in Figure 5 for category 4 units above a background activity (of no visual stimulus)? Unfortunately, I can´t evaluate this based on the figure. Line 376: How long does it take until the post-TOC response decays for category 5 units? In Figure 5, it is unfortunately clipped. Line 385-392: Instead of writing that you found significant differences, specify your effect. For example, for the LF condition the units reached their maximal firing rate later but showed a significant shorter rise phase which reflects a more sudden change in the firing rate than in response to looming stimuli presented in absence of a flow field (LW and LG). Line 399: You should specify the sample size for decay phase in the corresponding subfigure of figure 6. Line 400: Typo: ‘oof’ Line 424-451: Please specify the rationale for the ‘common trend’ analysis. Can I interpret it as a model-based categorization of different response profiles (instead of the five categories you manually selected beforehand)? Line 475: Again specify the sample size Line 522: Typo: ‘bbackground’ Line 522-526: Justifications for the used visual stimuli must be additionally mentioned in the method section. These questions I was asking myself the entire manuscript and had to wait for the answers until the discussion. Line 532: ‘number of common trends, representing the types of responses among all responsive units’. This info must appear in the result section about the common trends. Line 539: Missing punctuation mark. Line 585: ‘In our study’ Line 560-562: In line with this hypothesis, state-dependent central-complex neurons have been recently described in monarch butterflies (doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2021.11.009). Figure 2: • As you are using two different color codes (one for discriminating the signal from each electrode and one for each sorted unit) I needed some time to understand which color stands for what. I suggest keeping the raw Tetrode signal in grayscale and using the color code only for the sorted units. • Maybe you could rotate the PCA a little so that the distinction between the green and yellow unit becomes clearer. You could also zoom in a little. • Please color code the ellipses in C so that they can be clearly distinguished from the cumulative response. • Please indicate from your 20 example units which ones were declared as responsive. Figure 3: • For a better comparison across animals, I would plot on the y-axis the percentage of responsive neurons from the recorded neurons rather the absolute number. • Please add individual data points into your boxplots. Figure 4: • Please explain all abbreviations used in the figure in the legend (this comment should be considered for all figures) • Typo: I assume, on the x-axis it should say ‘F’ instead of ‘FF’? Figure 5: • Please indicate the number of neurons presented in each category. Figure 6: • Please indicate the number of neurons presented in the boxplots (based on the results I suspect N = 135). • Please divide the subfigure B into four subfigures (B-E). This makes it much more easier to connect the written results directly to the right subfigure. Also rearrange the boxplot figures so that they fit with the order mentioned in the results (‘peak time’, ‘rise phase’, ‘peak firing rate’, ‘decay phase’). Reviewer #3: The manuscript describes the analysis of electrophysiological recordings of locust 'looming detector' neurons under semi-naturalistic conditions. The animals are immersed in a type of virtual reality that allows the presentation of sky/ground simulations and a looming object in the shape of a black disc. While the looming detector has been described before, the combination with a non-uniform background is novel and worth investigating. A fairly large number of looming-responsive cells are found, many of which show peak responses in the temporal vicinity of an impending collision. The manuscript is written fairly clearly, and the conclusions seem warranted. However, I have a number of concerns regarding the statistical methods and the data availability -- in its current form, I could not reproduce the results based on the (lack of) data provided. Major comments: Data availability: While the spike detection and sorting seem pretty straightforward, the spike train analyses consitute the most interesting part of the manuscript. To replicate these analyses, the spike train time series would have to be provided -- the summary statistics in the supplements are not sufficient. Especially the more exploratory parts of the analyses, such as the categorization into five response types, are impossible to confirm without access to the spiketrains. They should be provided before the manuscript can be considered for publication. Methods: please consult with a statisticial on the conditions under which significance tests provide meaningful results (power, test derived from hypothesis rather than post-hoc inspection of data etc.) and use them only under appropriate conditions. Details: Intro: line 89: "...more natural environment.." I agree that the simulated sky/ground is already more natural than previously used stimuli. But why not use the setup for the presentation of an actual sky/ground movie? The setup seems to allow for the necessary resolution etc. Methods: line 220: 1 ms bin width, 50ms filter. Why this choice? line 156: time of collision (TOC). How was that determined, i.e. how large was the disc when 'collision' happened and why is that a sensible choice? fig 2a: please put units on the time axis. line 221: "a 2.2-second window..." in fig 2C the window seems to start 1 second before TOC, and last for a fraction of a second afterwards. Why is the rest of the response not shown? fig 2C: please explain why the interval of 99% confidence (in a constant response?) is elliptic in shape. I understand why the confidence interval shrinks to size 0 at the end of the analysis interval, since then the cs(T) is equal to A (lines 228-230). But why should the confidence interval be equally small at the beginning of the interval? line 291: "no inherent relationship" please define what an inherent relationship is. line 308: "Multivariate Analysis of Variance (MANOVA) verified the statistical distinctiveness of these units in three-dimensional cluster space" Please describe the space in which this analysis was carried out, and what the (in)dependent variables were. 350-366: where do the categories come from? If the data were sorted according to visual inspection, then the chi-square test is misleading, because these categories were generated from the data rather than from a hypothesis, so this constitutes 'harking'. Please remove the tests and just describe your visual impression, if that is how you arrived at the five response types. lines 379-401: please also delete the misleading significance test results and just report the descriptive statistics -- at this point there seems to be no theory/hypothesis from which a statistically testable prediction could be derived? line 429: "Although temporal resolution was reduced, the 50-ms-binned data captured the dynamic modulation of firing rate while significantly reducing computational complexity by a factor of fifty." How was it determined that the 50-ms binning captures the rate modulation well? line 442-443:"In response to a looming stimulus, irrespective of background types, most common trends exhibited a positive peak near the time of collision (TOC)." This seems to contradict the 5 response types depicted in fig 5. E.g. how can a constant response be explained by a positive peak near TOC? Or a valley or a peak after TOC? line 492: the result of this ANOVA seem to hinge on the (arbitrary) choice of 'response start' (line 488). I recommend describing just the descriptive statistics in figure 8 and deleting the ANOVA results, which do not seem to be derived from a testable hypothesis? The discussion is adequate and interesting. ********** what does this mean? ). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy Reviewer #1: Yes: Amir Ayali Reviewer #2: No Reviewer #3: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] While revising your submission, please upload your figure files to the Preflight Analysis and Conversion Engine (PACE) digital diagnostic tool, https://pacev2.apexcovantage.com/ . PACE helps ensure that figures meet PLOS requirements. To use PACE, you must first register as a user. Registration is free. Then, login and navigate to the UPLOAD tab, where you will find detailed instructions on how to use the tool. If you encounter any issues or have any questions when using PACE, please email PLOS at figures@plos.org . Please note that Supporting Information files do not need this step. Submitted filename: Review.pdf 3 Jul 2025 We thank the reviewers for their carefully considered and constructive comments on the manuscript. We have made an effort to incorporate all suggestions and edits and provide a response to each comment below in red text. Reviewer #1: The paper by Zhang et al. represents yet another contribution to our extensive and growing knowledge related to the response of motion-sensitive descending interneurons in the locust. This well-characterized system has successfully served for many years as a model for the study of visual responses in complex, dynamic environments. In this report, the authors present a statistically extensive analysis of the multi-unit response to looming stimuli over different visual backgrounds, including a flow-field background. The major finding is that, while background complexity has some effect on the temporal aspects of the multi-unit response, the basic looming response remains intact. While somewhat difficult to follow due to the nature of the work, I find that, overall, the paper is well-written and the findings are well-presented. Below, I list some minor as well as more major comments (in order of appearance in the text rather than importance): 1. L 66: Density dependent phase in locusts is much more than a morphological state. We have changed this sentence to more accurately state that migratory locusts are polyphenic. 2. Figure 1: I suggest adding an indication of the direction of motion of the wide-field stimulus background (LF and F) to enhance clarity. We have modified Figure 1 D to indicate the direction of flow field motion. We have also changed the thickness of the grey arches to indicate that the lines increased in thickness and the flow field expanded. Therefore, we modified the text of the legend of Figure 1 and relevant description of the Visual Stimulus to match figure. 3. L 166: The rationale behind the decision to maintain both the looming stimulus and the flow field within the lower half of the dome screen is not trivial as a locust flying within a dense swarm of conspecifics encounters an extremely complex visual background also in the sky or in its entire visual field. This may thus bother the reader throughout, until it is explained only in the Discussion (paragraph starting at line 514). Consider adding a few words of explanation already at a much earlier point (Intro or Methods). This is a valid point. Therefore, we moved the relevant section with the discussion to the Visual Stimulus section of the Materials and Methods and modified the citation numbers. 4. Unfortunately, the low resolution of the figures in the PDF file hampered their review. The low resolution may be due to the download from the server. Our original files that were submitted were high resolution. 5. Figure 4: The figure legend is not clear enough. Please better explain the "1-3 looms" naming of the different columns. Also, what is the meaning of FF and NR? We have modified the legend and relevant section of the Results to clarify that 1,2, or 3 Looms refers the number of backgrounds that units responded to. FF was a typo. We have changed it to F to indicate flow field only. We have added text to the legend to indicate that NR refers to no response. 6. Figure 6B: The peak time appears to be measured relative to the TOC, which would explain the negative values. I suggest clarifying this in the plot axes. We have clarified in the figure legend that peak time is relative to TOC. Placing this description on the axis title would be too long for the dimensions of the panel. We have also clarified that the peak firing rate is denoted as peak amplitude (Pa). We also included these descriptions in the relevant sections of the Materials and Methods. 7. 6. The " Common trends " paragraph, starting on line 424 contains many technical details that would be more appropriate in the Methods section. Respectfully, we disagree. The Materials and methods section describes how dimensionality reduction was performed. The paragraph that the reviewer refers to is the result of that analysis and, therefore, is more appropriate in the results section. 8. In the Discussion section, the authors explain in length all the details of their findings, including all minor temporal aspects of the multi-unit electrophysiological response. However, what is very much missing is the behavioral significance of all this, i.e., what is the effect of a slight delay in peak amplitude, or a minor change in the decay slope of the firing rate diagram on the behavioral motor response of the locust, on its ability to escape collision or avoid predators! The reviewer raises an interesting point. We have added a paragraph at the end of the discussion to speculate on how optic flow effects on units and common trend responses could influence behaviour. Reviewer #2: In the manuscript ‘Background optic flow modulates responses of multiple descending interneurons to object motion in locusts’, Zhang and Gray conducted multichannel extracellular recordings from descending neurons of Locusta migratoria. Many of the recorded neurons were sensitive to a looming stimulus that mimics a sudden approach of a large object, e.g., a predator. The present study explicitly tested how the presence of optic flow cues in the background affects the neural response to a looming stimulus presented in the foreground. Optic flow cues are visual stimuli induced through self-motion and therefore omnipresent when an insect flies. In other words, testing the neural response to a looming stimulus in the presence of optic flow cues in the background represents a more naturalistic stimulus scenario and hence makes the study’s rationale highly attractive to a huge neuroscientific community. In addition to minor concerns, I have only a few major concerns. Unfortunately, the authors presented mostly grouped data, e.g., figure 5, which makes it difficult for the reader to evaluate the results objectively. More specifically, the reader cannot assess how the response characteristics change with different backgrounds within a unit. As all units were stimulated with all four stimuli, the strength of the author’s experimental approach is to show changes in the response profile within a unit. To appreciate the authors’ findings, it is important to present response profiles of single units in response to the four different visual stimuli. We have added a new supplementary figure (S1 Figure) that shows responses of units from one locust that fit into each of the 5 response categories described in Figure 5. We have also added text to the relevant section of the results to describe this figure. Another major point is that the recordings had been conducted in tethered, non-flying locusts. This means that the presented optic flow cues were uncoupled with the locusts’ state of locomotion (open loop). The authors must at least discuss the study’s technical drawback of recording from a stationary insect. I can imagine that a motor efference copy that closes the loop between the insect’s flight movement and the optic flow cues in the background would make the neurons more sensitive to stimuli that mismatch with the motor efference copy, i.e., a looming stimulus that approaches faster than predicted from the insect’s flight speed. The reviewer is correct and this is a longer term goal to further investigate the role of visual descending neurons in generation of flight escape behaviour. Currently, however, that goal was not the focus of this work and is beyond the scope of the setup we used. Nevertheless, we have added a section to the discussion to address this point. Major points: • Line 144-174: At which velocity was the flow field (background) presented? If it was static, it is critical to call it ‘flow’. Based on the introduction, I would suspect to present a looming stimulus in the presence of optic flow that mimics a biologically plausible flight speed of the locust. We have renamed “circles” to “arches” to better represent their shape. We added text to the Materials and methods that describes the flow field velocity and that it represents forward motion at 3 m s-1, which is the average flight speed of a locust. We have changed the graphic representation of the flow field in Figs. 1, 3, 4, and 7 to demonstrate that the width of the arches increased during expansion. • Why did the authors not analyze changes in the response profile induced by different backgrounds for the remaining unit categories (category 2-5)? We have added a section to the results to clarify why we did not measure specific parameters form the other response categories. Minor points: Line 52: Please also add a citation of Martin Egelhaaf’s group who studied the influence of optic flow on flight control for decades. We have added a citation for: 1. Egelhaaf M, Lindemann JP. Path integration and optic flow in flying insects: a review of current evidence. J Comp Physiol A. 2025;211: 375–401. doi:10.1007/s00359-025-01734-9 Line 64: But, see the recent work of Marion Sillies who revealed six types of direction-sensitive neurons in Drosophila. (DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.abi7112) We have updated this reference. Line 89-91: Please add a sentence about the nature of your used backgrounds. What were you presenting making them ‘naturalistic’? We have modified this sentence to to better represent the stimuli we presented. We also added additional text to the materials and methods to further describe the backgrounds. Line 90: Typo: rigidly-tethered We have made the change Line 119: Please specify how the tetrode was fabricated. Which electrodes were used to built the tetrode? Did you measure the electrode resistance before each experiment? We referenced the tetrode fabrication process that we followed. We have added further text to describe the tetrode impedance. Line 139-140: It might be helpful to add the ‘orientation °’ in Figure 1C. And please increase the size of the schematized locust in the figure. We have added this orientation and enlarged the size of the locust. We also added appropriate text to the figure legend. Line 165-167: Please explain why you decided to present the looming stimulus from below and not from above? Please see our response to a similar comment from Reviewer 1. Line 185-197: How large was the time window for spike detection? Maybe you could add a time scale in Figure 2B. We have added a time scale to Fig. 2B and added details to the relevant section of the text. Line 206: Instead of using the term 3D feature space, I prefer using terms like PCA. Especially, when you are using the abbreviation ‘PC’ in the figure which has not been introduced in the legend. We have changed “feature” to “principal component (PC)”. Line 213: ‘not nonresponded’ does not make sense This typo has been corrected to read “…not responded…” Line 218: ‘discriminated units’. Terms like ‘single units’ or ‘spike-sorted units’ are more common. We have changed “discriminated” to “spike sorted” throughout the document. Line 307: A maximal number of 23 recorded units per animal sounds a lot. Also, the mean of 16.8 units per animal is high. I wonder how the entire PCA of one animal looks. In Figure 2, you are only presenting 3 example units that were relatively easily distinguishable by eye. Is this also the case for an entire PCA? We have added text to the discussion to clarify the validity of the number of sorted units. For Figure 2B we have included all 20 units that were sorted from a merged file of 20 stimulus presentations to one locust. We have modified the text of the methods and caption for Figure 2 accordingly. Line 351-366: Category 4 (Tonic response): How does it differ from a non-responsive unit? Is the firing rate in Figure 5 for category 4 units above a background activity (of no visual stimulus)? Unfortunately, I can´t evaluate this based on the figure. We only categorized units that showed a statistical response to the stimulus as described in the methods. Therefore, units in category 4 were different from the non-responsive units. We have clarified in the description in the text of the firing rate trends for all categories and more correctly described the slow firing rate increase in category 4. We also added text to clarify that the categories are similar to those reported in previous studies. Line 376: How long does it take until the post-TOC response decays for category 5 units? In Figure 5, it is unfortunately clipped. The response for this category would typically decay within 500 ms after TOC. It appears to be clipped in the figure because we used the same time window as with the other categories (200 ms after TOC). We did not display data beyond this window because it is not behviourally relevant to collision avoidance. In the text of the results, we indicated that that for category 5, the firing rate increased after TOC. Line 385-392: Instead of writing that you found significant differences, specify your effect. For example, for the LF condition the units reached their maximal firing rate later but showed a significant shorter rise phase which reflects a more sudden change in the firing rate than in response to looming stimuli presented in absence of a flow field (LW and LG). This description is included in the summary paragraph at the end of this section. Line 399: You should specify the sample size for decay phase in the corresponding subfigure of figure 6. We have included the sample size in the text and figure caption. Line 400: Typo: ‘oof’ We have made the correction Line 424-451: Please specify the rationale for the ‘common trend’ analysis. Can I interpret it as a model-based categorization of different response profiles (instead of the five categories you manually selected beforehand)? We added a sentence in the Dimensionality Reduction section of materials and methods as well as a reference to rationalize the dynamic factor analysis, which is further described in detail. Line 475: Again specify the sample size We have added the sample sizes to the text Line 522: Typo: ‘bbackground’ We have made the correction Line 522-526: Justifications for the used visual stimuli must be additionally mentioned in the method section. These questions I was asking myself the entire manuscript and had to wait for the answers until the discussion. Please see our response to a similar comment from Reviewer 1. Line 532: ‘number of common trends, representing the types of responses among all responsive units’. This info must appear in the result section about the common trends. In response to a similar comment by Reviewer 1, we have moved a section of the discussion that described the flow field to the materials and methods. This section also included the line identified above. In the new section within the methods, we clarified that the common trends that are similar for approaches at 0° and -45° are actually from a separate dataset (originally included in a separate PhD thesis chapter) and not part of the results presented in this manuscript. This separate dataset is intended for a separate publication. The statement was made to further validate the flow field setup that required objects to approach from -45° elevation. Line 539: Missing punctuation mark. We have made the correction Line 585: ‘In our study’ We have changed “my” to “our” Line 560-562: In line with this hypothesis, state-dependent central-complex neurons have been recently described in monarch butterflies (doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2021.11.009). We have added this reference to support our suggestion. Figure 2: • As you are using two different color codes (one for discriminating the signal from each electrode and one for each sorted unit) I needed some time to understand which color stands for what. I suggest keeping the raw Tetrode signal in grayscale and using the color code only for the sorted units. We have changed the colour of the raw recording to grey scale and further modified Figure as described in the relevant comment above. The colour code of the sorted units is the same in A and B. • Maybe you could rotate the PCA a little so that the distinction between the green and yellow unit becomes clearer. You could also zoom in a little. The new P Submitted filename: Response to reviewers comments.docx 13 Aug 2025 Dear Dr. Zhang, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS ONE’s publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. ============================== ACADEMIC EDITOR: The reviewers comments have come in and they find your manuscript greatly improved. However several outstanding comments regarding data analysis and presentation have been provided. Of particular significance are the statistical handling of data and visualization of spike analysis output. I invite you to address them in the revised version of your manuscript. ============================== Please submit your revised manuscript by Sep 27 2025 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org . When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. Please include the following items when submitting your revised manuscript: A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'.A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'.An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols . Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols . We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Tudor C. Badea, M.D., M.A., Ph.D. Academic Editor PLOS ONE Journal Requirements: If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. Please review your reference list to ensure that it is complete and correct. If you have cited papers that have been retracted, please include the rationale for doing so in the manuscript text, or remove these references and replace them with relevant current references. Any changes to the reference list should be mentioned in the rebuttal letter that accompanies your revised manuscript. If you need to cite a retracted article, indicate the article’s retracted status in the References list and also include a citation and full reference for the retraction notice. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author Reviewer #1: All comments have been addressed Reviewer #2: (No Response) Reviewer #3: (No Response) ********** 2. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions??> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 3. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously? -->?> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: No ********** 4. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available??> The PLOS Data policy Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** 5. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English??> Reviewer #1: Yes Reviewer #2: Yes Reviewer #3: Yes ********** Reviewer #1: All my comments have been adequately addressed, and the paper may be accepted for publication in its current state Reviewer #2: The manuscript has substantially improved after the revision. My last major concern is about the spike-sorting approach which gets exemplified in figure 2. I appreciate the authors’ transparency by showing all 20 clusters in the PCA but unfortunately, I can`t distinguish the central clusters that are entirely overlapping in the current figure, e.g. magenta, white and yellow cluster. I strongly recommend showing the central clusters in a magnified view, so that the reader can assess the sorting. Similar problems with quality assessment of spike sorting appear in the spike shapes presented on top of B. Too many clusters are overlapping, making it impossible to see every cluster’s spike shape. In addition to this, colors are replicating, i.e., three clusters are shown in red, three in yellow … . This makes it impossible to assign each cluster to the corresponding spike shape. I therefore strongly recommend splitting the spike-shape images into multiple subimages. Figure 2: Please increase the size of Fig. 2A, the sorted units (especially the small amplitude ones) are barely visible. Line 63: After the revision, the term ‘similar to mice’ does not fit anymore as you were previously referring to four types of direction selective neurons in mice Line 132: Please give some specs about the silver ground wire (diameter, fabricate) Line 148: To me, the arrows appear yellow Line 248: What exactly did you statistically compare with the MANOVA? The distance between the clusters in the PCA, e.g., the centroids or the spike shapes between clusters? Please give a few more infos on that. Fig 3: “N” for data points is missing in the legend Line 390: Please specify individual data points (individual locusts?) Line 434-435: Please place this info to line 421 Category 5: To me it looks like that the firing rate first drops before TOC and increases afterwards Figure 6: Please highlight the median of the boxplots in red (especially for the LF condition it is difficult to see the median) Line 489-503: Please place this passage before line 448. It is more intuitive to read first about the different categories and then getting the explanation why you were focusing on category 1 for detailed analysis. Line 492-493: Do you suspect all units to be putative DCMD or only category 1 units? This is still unclear as it is written here. Figure S1: Please place this figure into the main paper. It is the only figure that presents raw data of the effect of the background on the looming response. Please also enlarge the region around TOC so that the reviewer can better see the effect for category 1. Line 523: Sometimes you write “fig” and sometimes you write “figures”. Please stay consistent. Figure 7 legend: To get it right: These PSTHs have a binsize of 50 ms? If this is the case please add this info in the legend. Line 543: What does the color gradient in the heatmap represents? Is there a reason why you did not compare t95 in figure 6? Line 576: Similar to figure 6? Not 5 Line 623: Also bumblebees estimate flight height by using optic flow (10.1242/jeb.249763). Please add this reference to your discussion Reviewer #3: Thank you for providing the data for result replication and additional analyses, I expect this will be useful for the scientific community. I assume the link to the data will be added to the final manuscript, too? Regarding the clustering analysis: I still strongly recommend removing the misleading chi-square tests, since (line 419ff) "We identified similar categories based on the trends of firing rate changes over time in response to a similar stimulus ..." i.e. the categories were defined by "eyeballing" the data, which makes significance tests un-applicable and constitutes 'harking'. If these clusters were devised by applying a statistical model to the data (e.g. Gaussian mixtures or similar), then a bayesian model evidence or BIC score could be used to identify the number of clusters. ********** what does this mean? ). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy Reviewer #1: Yes: Amir Ayali Reviewer #2: Yes: M. Jerome Beetz Reviewer #3: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] While revising your submission, please upload your figure files to the Preflight Analysis and Conversion Engine (PACE) digital diagnostic tool, https://pacev2.apexcovantage.com/ . PACE helps ensure that figures meet PLOS requirements. To use PACE, you must first register as a user. Registration is free. Then, login and navigate to the UPLOAD tab, where you will find detailed instructions on how to use the tool. If you encounter any issues or have any questions when using PACE, please email PLOS at figures@plos.org 22 Sep 2025 We thank the reviewers for their carefully considered and constructive comments on the manuscript. We have made an effort to incorporate all suggestions and edits and provide a response to each comment below. Reviewer #1: All my comments have been adequately addressed, and the paper may be accepted for publication in its current state We thank the reviewer for their positive feedback and support for our manuscript. Reviewer #2: The manuscript has substantially improved after the revision. My last major concern is about the spike-sorting approach which gets exemplified in figure 2. I appreciate the authors’ transparency by showing all 20 clusters in the PCA but unfortunately, I can`t distinguish the central clusters that are entirely overlapping in the current figure, e.g. magenta, white and yellow cluster. I strongly recommend showing the central clusters in a magnified view, so that the reader can assess the sorting. We have modified Fig 2b to show all unit clusters and enlarged central clusters. Similar problems with quality assessment of spike sorting appear in the spike shapes presented on top of B. Too many clusters are overlapping, making it impossible to see every cluster’s spike shape. In addition to this, colors are replicating, i.e., three clusters are shown in red, three in yellow … . This makes it impossible to assign each cluster to the corresponding spike shape. I therefore strongly recommend splitting the spike-shape images into multiple subimages. To address the reviewer's valid concerns, we have reorganized Figure 2. We added a new panel dedicated to the spike shapes of the central clusters, using a distinct and non-repeating color palette to ensure each waveform is clearly attributable to its cluster. We found this approach provides a more readable and effective visualization than a grid-style layout of all 20 units. Figure 2: Please increase the size of Fig. 2A, the sorted units (especially the small amplitude ones) are barely visible. We have enlarged the bottom section of Fig 2a. We have also changed the background of the bottom section from black to white, making the colour-coded units easier to see. Line 63: After the revision, the term ‘similar to mice’ does not fit anymore as you were previously referring to four types of direction selective neurons in mice Thank you for pointing this out. We have removed the phrase. Line 132: Please give some specs about the silver ground wire (diameter, fabricate) Thank you for pointing this out. We have added the required information. Line 148: To me, the arrows appear yellow That is a valid point. We have updated the figure legend. Line 248: What exactly did you statistically compare with the MANOVA? The distance between the clusters in the PCA, e.g., the centroids or the spike shapes between clusters? Please give a few more infos on that. We used the built-in MANOVA test provided by the Offline Sorter software to statistically validate the separation of our sorted units. This test compares the distributions of spike data points in the 3D feature space, defined by the first three principal components. The independent variable for the test is the assigned unit (cluster), and the dependent variables are the feature vectors (i.e., the PC scores) for each individual waveform within those units. These information have been added to the text too. Fig 3: “N” for data points is missing in the legend Thank you for pointing this out. We have updated the info. Line 390: Please specify individual data points (individual locusts?) Yes. Individual data points represent different animals. We have updated the info in the figure legend. Line 434-435: Please place this info to line 421 Thanks for the comment. We have made the change. Category 5: To me it looks like that the firing rate first drops before TOC and increases afterwards This is a valid point. However, this drop was also observed in Categories 2, 3, and 4. The distinct feature of Category 5 is the prominent increase after TOC, which resembles some common trends from the DFA (CT5 for LW, CT7 for LG, and CT4 for LF). Figure 6: Please highlight the median of the boxplots in red (especially for the LF condition it is difficult to see the median) We have updated figures 3, 6 and 8, highlighting the median line in red. The figure legends have been updated as well. Update: The previous Fig 6 and 8 are now Fig 7 and 9, respectively, since the previous Fig S1 was moved to Fig 6. Line 489-503: Please place this passage before line 448. It is more intuitive to read first about the different categories and then getting the explanation why you were focusing on category 1 for detailed analysis. This is a good point. We have modified the order of corresponding paragraphs to make the flow smoother. Line 492-493: Do you suspect all units to be putative DCMD or only category 1 units? This is still unclear as it is written here. Thanks for pointing it out, and the description can indeed cause confusion. Therefore, we have updated the text from “these categories” to “category 1”, since we were only talking about category 1 here. Figure S1: Please place this figure into the main paper. It is the only figure that presents raw data of the effect of the background on the looming response. Please also enlarge the region around TOC so that the reviewer can better see the effect for category 1. We appreciate this valuable suggestion. We have moved the figure into the main paper as the new Fig 6. Furthermore, to make the effect for category 1 easier to see, we have added an inset panel that shows a magnified view of the response around the time of collision (TOC). Line 523: Sometimes you write “fig” and sometimes you write “figures”. Please stay consistent. We have modified the corresponding texts to ensure consistency. Figure 7 legend: To get it right: These PSTHs have a binsize of 50 ms? If this is the case please add this info in the legend. We have added the information in the figure legend. Update: The previous Fig 7 is now Fig 8, since the previous Fig S1 was moved to Fig 6. Line 543: What does the color gradient in the heatmap represents? The heatmap represents the factor loadings of each unit to the specific common trend, i.e., the correlation of each unit to the common trend. We have added further clarification in the Fig 7 figure legend. Update: The previous Fig 7 is now Fig 8, since the previous Fig S1 was moved to Fig 6. Is there a reason why you did not compare t95 in figure 6? Thanks for pointing this out. Initially, we just compared the peak time, rise phase, and decay phase, as routinely done in previous studies. The rise phase was the period between t95 and peak, and we found significant differences in peak time and rise phase already. Since a delayed peak and shortened rise phase would naturally indicate a delayed t95, we did not compare t95. However, since we did compare t95 later in Fig 8, we agree that it is better to include t95 comparison in Fig 6 as well. Therefore, we have included the One-way RM ANOVA comparison of t95 in the corresponding results section, and added a section F in Fig 6 to show the result. Update: The previous Fig 6 and 8 are now Fig 7 and 9, respectively, since the previous Fig S1 was moved to Fig 6. Line 576: Similar to figure 6? Not 5 That is correct. Thanks for pointing it out. We have made this edit. Update: The previous Fig 6 is now Fig 7, since the previous Fig S1 was moved to Fig 6. Line 623: Also bumblebees estimate flight height by using optic flow (10.1242/jeb.249763). Please add this reference to your discussion Thanks for suggesting the reference. We have added it to the discussion. Reviewer #3: Thank you for providing the data for result replication and additional analyses, I expect this will be useful for the scientific community. I assume the link to the data will be added to the final manuscript, too? Thanks. We will include the link in the final manuscript. Regarding the clustering analysis: I still strongly recommend removing the misleading chi-square tests, since (line 419ff) "We identified similar categories based on the trends of firing rate changes over time in response to a similar stimulus ..." i.e. the categories were defined by "eyeballing" the data, which makes significance tests un-applicable and constitutes 'harking'. If these clusters were devised by applying a statistical model to the data (e.g. Gaussian mixtures or similar), then a bayesian model evidence or BIC score could be used to identify the number of clusters. We have removed the chi-squared test, and only kept the description of the distribution of units between different backgrounds. Submitted filename: Response to reviewers comments_2nd review.docx 9 Nov 2025 Dear Dr. Zhang, Thank you for submitting your manuscript to PLOS ONE. After careful consideration, we feel that it has merit but does not fully meet PLOS ONE’s publication criteria as it currently stands. Therefore, we invite you to submit a revised version of the manuscript that addresses the points raised during the review process. Please submit your revised manuscript by Dec 24 2025 11:59PM. If you will need more time than this to complete your revisions, please reply to this message or contact the journal office at plosone@plos.org . When you're ready to submit your revision, log on to https://www.editorialmanager.com/pone/ and select the 'Submissions Needing Revision' folder to locate your manuscript file. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'.A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'.An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A rebuttal letter that responds to each point raised by the academic editor and reviewer(s). You should upload this letter as a separate file labeled 'Response to Reviewers'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. A marked-up copy of your manuscript that highlights changes made to the original version. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Revised Manuscript with Track Changes'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. An unmarked version of your revised paper without tracked changes. You should upload this as a separate file labeled 'Manuscript'. If applicable, we recommend that you deposit your laboratory protocols in protocols.io to enhance the reproducibility of your results. Protocols.io assigns your protocol its own identifier (DOI) so that it can be cited independently in the future. For instructions see: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/submission-guidelines#loc-laboratory-protocols . Additionally, PLOS ONE offers an option for publishing peer-reviewed Lab Protocol articles, which describe protocols hosted on protocols.io. Read more information on sharing protocols at https://plos.org/protocols?utm_medium=editorial-email&utm_source=authorletters&utm_campaign=protocols . We look forward to receiving your revised manuscript. Kind regards, Teddy Lazebnik Academic Editor PLOS ONE Journal Requirements: If the reviewer comments include a recommendation to cite specific previously published works, please review and evaluate these publications to determine whether they are relevant and should be cited. There is no requirement to cite these works unless the editor has indicated otherwise. Please review your reference list to ensure that it is complete and correct. If you have cited papers that have been retracted, please include the rationale for doing so in the manuscript text, or remove these references and replace them with relevant current references. Any changes to the reference list should be mentioned in the rebuttal letter that accompanies your revised manuscript. If you need to cite a retracted article, indicate the article’s retracted status in the References list and also include a citation and full reference for the retraction notice. Additional Editor Comments: All reviewers are positive overall. I invite the authors to address the final comments of the reviewers before acceptance. [Note: HTML markup is below. Please do not edit.] Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author Reviewer #2: All comments have been addressed Reviewer #4: (No Response) ********** 2. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions??> Reviewer #2: (No Response) Reviewer #4: Yes ********** 3. Has the statistical analysis been performed appropriately and rigorously? -->?> Reviewer #2: (No Response) Reviewer #4: (No Response) ********** 4. Have the authors made all data underlying the findings in their manuscript fully available??> The PLOS Data policy Reviewer #2: (No Response) Reviewer #4: Yes ********** 5. Is the manuscript presented in an intelligible fashion and written in standard English??> Reviewer #2: (No Response) Reviewer #4: Yes ********** Reviewer #2: Congratulations to the authors who did a good job in revising the manuscript. Thank you for addressing all my concerns and accepting my suggestions. From my side, the manuscript is ready for publication. Reviewer #4: This is a strong and carefully executed study. The authors examine how background optic flow, simulating self motion, influences neural processing of looming stimuli in locusts. Multi-channel electrophysiology shows that optic flow does not change how many neurons respond, but it shifts response timing later (for both onset and peak) and results in fewer common population trends. The analysis is solid and the work provides valuable insight into how collision detection operates in visually complex conditions. The manuscript is nearly ready for publication and would benefit from the following clarifications and contextual additions. A. Suggested theoretical context To strengthen the link between the neurophysiology and real-world behavior, the discussion could acknowledge recent work showing how vision guides collision avoidance and collective movement in locusts. Your results provide neural grounding for models that treat visual motion cues as drivers of group coordination and selective responses in crowded environments. Consider citing the following works near line 690 or in the final discussion paragraph: Bleichman I, Yitzhaki O, Bernat NM, et al. 2024. The visual stimuli attributes instrumental for collective-motion tuning in desert locusts. PNAS Nexus. https://doi.org/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae537 Krongauz DL, Lazebnik T. 2023. Collective evolution learning model for vision based collective motion with collision avoidance. PLOS ONE. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0270318 Egelhaaf M, et al. 2023. Optic flow based spatial vision in insects. J Comp Physiol A. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00359-022-01645-z These papers directly connect visual motion processing to group coordination, collision avoidance and naturalistic movement environments. B. Clarification in the discussion In the concluding paragraph, the authors suggest that delayed neural responses in the presence of optic flow may slow behavior or fine tune responses. This can be clarified as a likely adaptive trade-off. When optic flow signals self motion, the nervous system may increase its decision threshold to prevent unnecessary avoidance actions. At the same time, once the threshold is crossed, the reduced variability of population responses suggests a more stable and decisive motor command. Briefly stating this balance between avoiding false alarms and maintaining reliable escape behavior will help tie neural timing and population coding to ecological context. Suggested phrasing idea: In conditions containing self-generated optic flow, the system may adopt a more conservative triggering policy, delaying responses to avoid false alarms, while producing a more consistent output once activation occurs. C. Minor clarity suggestion in Results In the common trends results, two key findings are presented for the flow condition: fewer common trends and delayed rise time. To improve clarity, consider adding one sentence in the Results or early in the Discussion stating that this indicates a more stereotyped and temporally shifted population code under optic flow. This will help readers follow the logical step from analysis to behavioral interpretation. ********** what does this mean? ). If published, this will include your full peer review and any attached files. If you choose “no”, your identity will remain anonymous but your review may still be made public. Do you want your identity to be public for this peer review? For information about this choice, including consent withdrawal, please see our Privacy Policy Reviewer #2: No Reviewer #4: No ********** [NOTE: If reviewer comments were submitted as an attachment file, they will be attached to this email and accessible via the submission site. Please log into your account, locate the manuscript record, and check for the action link "View Attachments". If this link does not appear, there are no attachment files.] To ensure your figures meet our technical requirements, please review our figure guidelines: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures You may also use PLOS’s free figure tool, NAAS, to help you prepare publication quality figures: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/figures#loc-tools-for-figure-preparation. NAAS will assess whether your figures meet our technical requirements by comparing each figure against our figure specifications. 11 Dec 2025 We thank the reviewers for their carefully considered and constructive comments on the manuscript. We have made an effort to incorporate all suggestions and edits and provide a response to each comment below in red text. Reviewer #2: Congratulations to the authors who did a good job in revising the manuscript. Thank you for addressing all my concerns and accepting my suggestions. From my side, the manuscript is ready for publication. We thank the reviewer for their positive feedback and support for our manuscript. Reviewer #4: This is a strong and carefully executed study. The authors examine how background optic flow, simulating self motion, influences neural processing of looming stimuli in locusts. Multi-channel electrophysiology shows that optic flow does not change how many neurons respond, but it shifts response timing later (for both onset and peak) and results in fewer common population trends. The analysis is solid and the work provides valuable insight into how collision detection operates in visually complex conditions. The manuscript is nearly ready for publication and would benefit from the following clarifications and contextual additions. A. Suggested theoretical context To strengthen the link between the neurophysiology and real-world behavior, the discussion could acknowledge recent work showing how vision guides collision avoidance and collective movement in locusts. Your results provide neural grounding for models that treat visual motion cues as drivers of group coordination and selective responses in crowded environments. Consider citing the following works near line 690 or in the final discussion paragraph: Bleichman I, Yitzhaki O, Bernat NM, et al. 2024. The visual stimuli attributes instrumental for collective-motion tuning in desert locusts. PNAS Nexus. https://doi.org/10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae537 Krongauz DL, Lazebnik T. 2023. Collective evolution learning model for vision based collective motion with collision avoidance. PLOS ONE. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0270318 Egelhaaf M, et al. 2023. Optic flow based spatial vision in insects. J Comp Physiol A. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00359-022-01645-z These papers directly connect visual motion processing to group coordination, collision avoidance and naturalistic movement environments. We appreciate this suggestion to strengthen the ecological context of our findings. We have added the suggested text and citations to the final paragraph of the Discussion. We explicitly link our results to models that treat visual motion cues as drivers of group coordination and collision avoidance in crowded environments. B. Clarification in the discussion In the concluding paragraph, the authors suggest that delayed neural responses in the presence of optic flow may slow behavior or fine tune responses. This can be clarified as a likely adaptive trade-off. When optic flow signals self motion, the nervous system may increase its decision threshold to prevent unnecessary avoidance actions. At the same time, once the threshold is crossed, the reduced variability of population responses suggests a more stable and decisive motor command. Briefly stating this balance between avoiding false alarms and maintaining reliable escape behavior will help tie neural timing and population coding to ecological context. Suggested phrasing idea: In conditions containing self-generated optic flow, the system may adopt a more conservative triggering policy, delaying responses to avoid false alarms, while producing a more consistent output once activation occurs. We agree that framing this as an adaptive trade-off improves the interpretation. We have revised the concluding paragraph of the Discussion to clarify that in conditions containing self-generated optic flow, the system likely adopts a more conservative triggering policy—delaying responses to prevent false alarms while maintaining consistent output once activation occurs. C. Minor clarity suggestion in Results In the common trends results, two key findings are presented for the flow condition: fewer common trends and delayed rise time. To improve clarity, consider adding one sentence in the Results or early in the Discussion stating that this indicates a more stereotyped and temporally shifted population code under optic flow. This will help readers follow the logical step from analysis to behavioral interpretation. We have added a sentence to the "Common Trends" section of the Results to clarify this point. The text now explicitly states that the reduction to 5 common trends indicates a more stereotyped and temporally shifted population code in the presence of optic flow. Submitted filename: Responses to reviewers comments_3rd review.docx 14 Dec 2025 Background optic flow modulates responses of multiple descending interneurons to object motion in locusts PONE-D-24-45161R3 Dear Dr. Zhang, We’re pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been judged scientifically suitable for publication and will be formally accepted for publication once it meets all outstanding technical requirements. Within one week, you’ll receive an e-mail detailing the required amendments. When these have been addressed, you’ll receive a formal acceptance letter and your manuscript will be scheduled for publication. An invoice will be generated when your article is formally accepted. Please note, if your institution has a publishing partnership with PLOS and your article meets the relevant criteria, all or part of your publication costs will be covered. Please make sure your user information is up-to-date by logging into Editorial Manager at Editorial Manager® and clicking the ‘Update My Information' link at the top of the page. For questions related to billing, please contact billing support . If your institution or institutions have a press office, please notify them about your upcoming paper to help maximize its impact. If they’ll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team as soon as possible -- no later than 48 hours after receiving the formal acceptance. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. Kind regards, Teddy Lazebnik Academic Editor PLOS One Additional Editor Comments (optional): The authors addressed all reviewers' concerns and the manuscript can be accapted now Reviewers' comments: PONE-D-24-45161R3 PLOS One Dear Dr. Zhang, I'm pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been deemed suitable for publication in PLOS One. Congratulations! Your manuscript is now being handed over to our production team. At this stage, our production department will prepare your paper for publication. This includes ensuring the following: * All references, tables, and figures are properly cited * All relevant supporting information is included in the manuscript submission, * There are no issues that prevent the paper from being properly typeset You will receive further instructions from the production team, including instructions on how to review your proof when it is ready. Please keep in mind that we are working through a large volume of accepted articles, so please give us a few days to review your paper and let you know the next and final steps. Lastly, if your institution or institutions have a press office, please let them know about your upcoming paper now to help maximize its impact. If they'll be preparing press materials, please inform our press team within the next 48 hours. Your manuscript will remain under strict press embargo until 2 pm Eastern Time on the date of publication. For more information, please contact onepress@plos.org. You will receive an invoice from PLOS for your publication fee after your manuscript has reached the completed accept phase. If you receive an email requesting payment before acceptance or for any other service, this may be a phishing scheme. Learn how to identify phishing emails and protect your accounts at https://explore.plos.org/phishing. If we can help with anything else, please email us at customercare@plos.org. Thank you for submitting your work to PLOS ONE and supporting open access. Kind regards, PLOS ONE Editorial Office Staff on behalf of Dr. Teddy Lazebnik Academic Editor PLOS One