Orientational Structure and Electro-Optical Properties of Chiral Nematic Droplets with Conical Anchoring Authors: Kristina A. Feizer, Mikhail N. Krakhalev, Vladimir Yu. Rudyak, Victor Ya. Zyryanov Published: 2025 ABSTRACT The polymer dispersed liquid crystals (PDLCs) with conical boundary conditions are considered. PDLC films with different values of the relative chirality parameter N0 of chiral nematic droplets ranging from 0 to 1.32 are studied experimentally and theoretically. In flattened spheroid-shaped chiral nematic droplets, a twisted axial-bipolar structure is formed whose twist angle increases with rising N0 value. Two stable states of the structure are revealed: one with the bipolar axis oriented perpendicular to the short axis of the spheroid and another with the bipolar axis oriented parallel to it. Applying a small voltage causes the bipolar axes of the chiral nematic droplets to reorient parallel to the electric field. The structure is unwound in strong electric fields, and the droplet order parameter reaches a high value of nearly 0.95. These features of the voltage-induced reorientation of the axial-bipolar structure explain the experimentally observed characteristic electro-optical properties of PDLC cells: high transmittance Tmax≅0.90 in the on-state and low control voltages of less than 35 V. The minimum transmittance of the PDLC cells decreases as the value of N0 increases; for samples with N0≥0.60, the contrast ratio exceeds 145. 1. Introduction Polymer dispersed liquid crystal (PDLC) is a composite material consisting of liquid crystal (LC) droplets randomly distributed within a polymer film [1]. The optical characteristics of the PDLC film depend on the ratio of the refractive indices of the polymer and liquid crystal, as well as the orientational structure formed in the LC droplets. The orientational structure is determined by the LC cavity size and shape, the boundary conditions, the LC material parameters, and the applied electric (or magnetic) field. An electric field applied to the PDLC film results in a variation of the LC orientation structure (Frederiks transitions), which leads to a change in the optical parameters of the entire film. This allows, for example, switching of the PDLC film from an initially light-scattering to a transparent state (Figure 1) [2,3,4], or vice versa [5,6]. This makes PDLC films ideal candidates for use in smart glasses [7,8], projection displays [9], dynamic three-dimensional (3D) holographic display [10], light-shaping films [11,12], micro-lenses [13], lasers [14], etc. Recently, PDLC films have been investigated to improve their electro-optical characteristics, in particular, to reduce control voltages and response time, to increase contrast ratio (CR) and maximum transmittance value Tmax, and to improve their manufacturability. The enhancement of the electro-optical characteristics of PDLC can be accomplished through the selection of the most suitable film morphology or the optimal optical and dielectric parameters of the LC and polymer. For this purpose, the composition and fabrication conditions of the PDLC films are varied [15,16,17], the polymer matrix is modified with additives [18,19], and the PDLC is doped with nanoparticles [20,21,22], quantum dots [23] or dichroic dye [24,25]. The orientational structure formed in the LC droplets has a significant effect on the electro-optical parameters of the PDLC films. As a consequence, setting certain boundary conditions allows improving the electro-optical response of PDLC films. Numerous experimental and theoretical studies have been conducted on PDLC films with homeotropic [26,27] or tangential [28,29,30,31] boundary conditions in which the director is oriented perpendicular (θ=0) or parallel (θ=90∘) to the droplet interface, respectively. Here, θ is the angle between the director and normal to the droplet surface at the polymer-LC interface. The radial structure transforms into an axial one when an electric field is applied to nematic droplets under homeotropic anchoring. This transformation increases the droplet order parameter Sd=123Ndn2−1, which characterizes the orientation of the local LC director n relative to the symmetry axis of the droplet Nd. This results in the refractive indices of the LC droplets and the polymer matrix matching, causing the PDLC film to switch from an opaque to a transparent state. The PDLC films with homeotropic boundary conditions are characterized by low control voltages and low contrast ratio (CR). The bipolar orientational structure is formed in nematic droplets under tangential anchoring. The symmetry axis of the nematic droplets is reoriented parallel to the applied electric field. This increases the sampling order parameter Sf=12(3cos2α−1), which characterizes the orientation of the droplets’ bipolar axes relative to the direction of the incident light, and α is the angle between the droplet bipolar axis Nd and the incident light direction (Figure 1). This results in switching the PDLC film from a light-scattering to transparent state. The PDLC films with tangential boundary conditions are characterized by high contrast ratio and high control voltages. The axial-bipolar configuration is formed in nematic droplets under conical anchoring (θ=40∘). The application of a voltage leads to the orientation of the structure bipolar axis parallel to the electric field, resulting in the PDLC film switching from a light scattering to a transparent state [32]. Such PDLCs are characterized by low control voltage, high contrast ratio and high transmittance in the voltage-on state. However, after the switching off voltage, the PDLC film remains in the transparent state for a long time, which makes it difficult to use practically. Chiral nematic liquid crystals (CLCs) are characterized by a helical director configuration in the free state. A twisted orientational structure is formed in CLC droplets, the type of which depends on the value of the relative chirality parameter N0=2d/p0, where d is the droplet diameter, and p0 is the intrinsic helix pitch (the distance over which the director rotates by 2π in the free state) [33]. A twisted axial-bipolar structure is formed in CLC droplets under conical anchoring at N0<2.9 [34]. Twisting of the orientational structure affects the droplet order parameter Sd, and consequently, the light scattering properties of the PDLC film. As a result, the switching-off time of the PDLC film containing the twisted axial-bipolar droplets with N0=0.32 decreased to a few tens of milliseconds [35]. To date, the dependence of the electro-optical properties of PDLC films with conical anchoring on the N0 value has not been performed. In this work, the electro-optical properties of PDLC films based on CLC droplets under conical anchoring are studied experimentally and by numerical modeling. We examine PDLC films with five N0 values ranging from 0 to 1.32. The electro-optical response of PDLC films is considered for the first and subsequent voltage turn-on and turn-off. The dependencies of the CLC orientational structures, the control voltages, CR, transmittance T(U), and the response times on the N0 value are obtained and analyzed (see Table 1). 2. Results 2.1. CLC Droplets Structures A twisted axial-bipolar structure characterized by two surface point defects located at the opposite poles of the droplet and a surface linear defect is formed in the CLC droplets in the form of a flattened spheroid at all studied values N0 (Figure 2). The surface linear defect has a shape close to a ring and is located symmetrically relative to the point defects. Therefore, the structure can be considered axisymmetric, with the symmetry axis coinciding with the bipolar axis that connects the point defects. The calculation shows two stable states of the twisted axial-bipolar structure in an initial state, one with the bipolar axis oriented perpendicular to the short axis of the spheroid (marked with the index ⊥ in Figure 2a,b) and one with the bipolar axis oriented parallel to it (marked with the index ‖ in Figure 2a,b). Applying an electric field along the short spheroid axis leads to the reorientation of the bipolar axis parallel to it, and the unwinding of the structure up to a nearly homogeneous state in the strong fields. After switching off the electric field, only one stable state with a bipolar axis parallel to the short axis of the spheroid is realized. These changes in the orientational structure lead to variations in the transmittance T(U) of the PDLC film. 2.2. The Electro-Optical Response of PDLC Cells In the experiment, the electro-optical properties of PDLC films during the first application of voltage differ from those at subsequent switching on–off of an electric field. Initially, all samples strongly scatter light, and the transmittance of the PDLC cells is Tmeas0≅0.003 (Figure 3a, Table 2). When an electric field is first applied to samples with N0≤0.32, the transmittance of PDLC cells rises sharply from Tmeas0≅0.003 to Tmeasmax≅0.910 as the applied voltage increases from 0 to U≅8.5 V (Figure 3a). For samples with N0≥0.6, the slopes of the transmittance Tmeas versus the applied voltage U dependencies are shallower. The maximum value of Tmeasmax≅0.90 is achieved at voltages of U=27 V and U=35 V for PDLC cells with N0=0.60 and N0=1.32, respectively. When the voltage is turned off, the PDLC cells do not return to their initial scattering state (Figure 3a). The minimum value of transmittance Tmeasmin after switching off the voltage depends on the N0 value and decreases from 0.84 to 0.003 as N0 increases from 0 to 1.32 (Table 2). At subsequent voltage applications, the maximum transmittance value of CLC cells is achieved at the same voltage as when the electric field is first switched on (Figure 3a). Samples with N0≤0.32 have high Tmeasmin values, which lead to low working contrast ratios CR=TmeasmaxTmeasmin (Table 2). CR values are 148 and 303 for samples with N0=0.6 and N0=1.32, respectively. The control voltages of the studied PDLC cells are close to those of low-voltage PDLC cells based on fluorinated polymers [36] or polyacrylates with different alkyl chain structures [37,38]. Meanwhile, PDLC cells with conical anchoring exhibit higher Tmax and CR values. High values of Tmax≅90% and CR>100 were achieved for the PDLC films doped with functionalized mesoporous silica materials, but higher voltages of U>50 V were used for this purpose [39]. High Tmax≅90% values and low control voltages of U≅15 V were achieved for PDLC cells with low contrast ratios of CR<40 [40,41]. The switching time of PDLC cells from opaque to transparent (τon) state, and vice versa (τoff) decreases with increasing N0. The switching times of PDLC cells with N≥0.32 were measured for subsequent voltage turn-ons and turn-offs. As the N0 value increases from 0.32 to 1.32, the turn-on time τon decreases slightly from 70±6 ms to 60±5 ms, while the turn-off time τoff is significantly reduced from 80±2 ms to 12±1 ms (Table 2). Figure 3b shows the calculated dependencies of transmittance Tcalc on the applied dimensionless field e. The short axes of the LC droplets are mainly perpendicular to the PDLC film plane, and therefore the direction of the incident light beam is mainly parallel to the short axis of the spheroids [42]. The Tcalc(e) values were calculated for this case of the orientation of the incident beam relative to the short axis of the CLC droplets. If the initial bipolar axes of the droplets are oriented perpendicular to the short axis of the spheroid, then the dependence of Tcalc on the applied field e is threshold-type. The threshold field value increases with N0. For droplets with N0≤0.32, the transmittance of PDLC cells rises sharply from Tcalcmin=0.0005 to Tcalcmax≅0.91 as the field e increases from 0 to 2. Further increases in field e practically do not change the value of Tcalc. For the PDLC cell with N0≥0.6, the transmittance of the PDLC film rises sharply from Tcalcmin=0.014 to Tcalc=0.41 (at N0=0.60), and from Tcalcmin=0.020 to Tcalc=0.25 (at N0=1.32). A further increase in the applied field e leads to a gradual rise in Tcalc due to changes in the Sd value. In high fields, the transmittance of PDLC cells reaches a value of Tcalcmax≅0.91. When the bipolar axis of the CLC droplets is initially oriented along the short axis of the spheroid, the dependence of transmittance Tcalc on the applied field e is nonthreshold (Figure 3b). The minimum transmittance Tcalcmin decreases from 0.90 to 0.12 as the N0 value increases from 0 to 1.32. In high fields, the transmittance of PDLC cells reaches a value of Tcalcmax≅0.91 for all studied values of N0. The calculated dependencies Tcalc(e) show that the electro-optical properties of PDLC films are determined by the initial orientation of the symmetry axes of the CLC droplets with a twisted axial-bipolar structure. This explains the difference observed in the electro-optical responses of PDLC cells measured at the first and subsequent voltage on–off cycles (Figure 3a). Let us consider in detail the electrically induced changes in the orientation of the droplets’ symmetry axes, as characterized by the sampling order parameter Sf, as well as the changes in orientation structure, as characterized by the droplet order parameter Sd. 3. Discussion 3.1. The Calculated Dependencies Tcalc(e) If the initial bipolar axes of all droplets are oriented perpendicular to the short axis of the spheroid, then the sampling order parameter is equal to Sf=−1/2. The orientation of the bipolar axis remains practically unchanged at small values of the field e (Figure 4a). The threshold value of the field eth corresponding to the beginning of the change in Sf rises with the increasing value of N0. For example, the threshold field for CLC droplets with N0=0 is eth≅0.32, and it rises to eth≅0.63 for droplets with N0=1.32. The bipolar axis reorientation process rapidly reaches saturation, at which Sf=1. The saturation field strength rises from eSf=1=0.60 to eSf=1=1.00 as N0 increases from 0 to 1.32. As N0 increases, the twist angle of the axial-bipolar structure rises, which consequently decreases the Sd value (Figure 4b (solid lines)). In the off-state of an electric field, the value of Sd decreases from 0.95 to 0.31 as N0 increases from 0 to 1.32. The value of Sd rises as the applied field e increases. The dependence of Sd on the field e is nonthreshold. However, in the applied fields eeSf=1. In strong fields, the value of Sd is practically independent of N0 and reaches a high value of Sd≳0.95 at e=15. The threshold-type of the electro-optical response of PDLC cells results from the existence of the threshold field eth, and as the field value increases from eth to eSf=1, the transmittance of the PDLC films rises sharply (Figure 3b, solid lines). For PDLC cells with N≤0.32, the primary change in transmittance Tcalc(e) leads from the increase in Sf (reorientation of the bipolar axis), while the change in Sd slightly affects the Tcalc(e) value. For PDLC cells with N0≥0.6, the increase in Tcalc induced by the electric field e is due to changes in both Sf and Sd. When the bipolar axis of the CLC droplets is initially oriented along the short axis of the spheroid (i.e., parallel to the direction of the incident beam), the sampling order parameter is Sf=1. In this case, the electro-optical response of the PDLC cells is due only to changes in Sd (Figure 4b (dotted lines with circles)). The dependence of Sd and, consequently, the transmittance Tcalc on the applied field e is nonthreshold. The minimum Sd value obtained at e=0 decreases from 0.95 to 0.21 as the N0 increases from 0 to 1.32. Accordingly, the minimum transmittance Tcalcmin decreases from 0.90 to 0.12 as the N0 value increases from 0 to 1.32. For all studied values of N0, the droplet order parameter reaches Sd≳0.95 under strong field e=15, leading to an increase in transmittance up to Tcalcmax≅0.91. 3.2. The Measured Dependencies Tmeas(U) The observed electro-optical response of PDLC films can be explained by the features of the orientation of the bipolar axis of the CLC droplets. The shape of CLC droplets in PDLC films is known to be spheroids with a short axis oriented mainly perpendicular to the film plane [42]. Because the twisted axial-bipolar configuration has two stable states, a significant fraction of the droplets initially have their bipolar axis oriented parallel to the PDLC film. This leads to the opaque state of the PDLC cells in the initial state (Figure 3a). The high electric field applied to the sample orients the CLC droplets perpendicular to the film plane, resulting in a transparent state of PDLC cells with a high transmittance value Tmeasmax≅0.90. Conical boundary conditions allow for the easy azimuthal “gliding” of the director at the interface under the influence of external factors [43,44]. As a result, the initial orientation of the bipolar axis of the CLC droplets is memory-free, and after the voltage is turned off, most of the CLC droplets remain oriented perpendicular to the PDLC film plane (see Figure 2). This leads to an increase in transmittance of the PDLC films in the off state (Figure 3a). The lower experimental transmittance Tmeasmin (Figure 3a) compared to the transmittance Tcalcmin (Figure 3b) calculated for the case of orientation of the droplets’ bipolar axis perpendicular to the PDLC film is due to the fact that in experimental samples the CLC droplets are not an ideal spheroid shape [1]. As a result, the bipolar axis of some droplets is not perpendicular to the PDLC film (Sf<1) when it is in an off state. This leads to a decrease in transmittance Tmeasmin that depends strongly on the Sd value and decreases as the N0 value increases. The investigated PDLC cells are characterized by a high transmittance Tmeasmax≅0.90 in the switched-on state. The PDLC cell can be adjusted to the required parameters by selecting an appropriate N0 value without changing the composition and/or morphology of the film. For example, an increase in the N0 value results in a higher contrast ratio and a lower slope of the T(U) curve. If control voltages need to be reduced, then PDLC films with smaller N0 values should be used. The studied PDLC cells are characterized by a 40-degree director tilt angle at the polymer-LC interface. A wide range of director tilt angles is available under conical boundary conditions. This provides an opportunity to improve the electro-optical properties of PDLC films by choosing the tilt angle, for example, by varying the polymer composition [45]. The variation in the N0 value allows for control of the electro-optical parameters of the PDLC cell, including the minimum light transmittance, the control voltages, and the slope of the dependence T(U). As a result, it is possible to produce thermo- and/or photo-controlled PDLC films using thermosensitive or photosensitive cholesteric materials [46,47]. In this case, the value of N0 and consequently the light transmittance T can be controlled by changes in temperature or exposure to light. It can lead to the expansion of practical application and functionality of PDLC films. 4. Materials and Methods 4.1. Samples Fabrication Experimental studies were carried out for PDLC films based on polymer poly(isobutyl methacrylate) (PiBMA) (Sigma Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, USA) and nematic LN-396 (Belarusian State Technological University, Minsk, Belarus) doped with cholesteryl acetate (Sigma Aldrich). Five PDLC cells were investigated. The concentrations of cholesteryl acetate in LN-396 were 0%, 0.5%, 1.0%, 2.0%, and 4.0% (Table 3). The CLC:PiBMA weight ratio was 60:40. The thickness of the PDLC films was determined by 20 μm Teflon spacers. PDLC cells were manufactured using combined solvent-induced phase separation (SIPS) and thermal-induced phase separation (TIPS) technology [48]. The average diameter of the CLC droplets was 2.3 ± 0.1 μm. This corresponds to the average values of the relative chirality parameter of 0, 0.15±0.01, 0.32±0.02, 0.60±0.03, and 1.32±0.05 (Table 3). To study the orientation structures of the LC droplets and their response to an electric field, PDLC cells with an average droplet diameter of 10 μm were manufactured. 4.2. Electro-Optical Measurement A standard technique for measuring the intensity of a forward-transmitted He-Ne (λ=632 nm) laser (Linos, Feldkirchen, Germany) beam was used to study the electro-optical response of PDLC cells [1]. The intensity of the laser beam passed through the PDLC cell was measured using a PDA100A-EC silicon detector (Thorlabs, Newton, NJ, USA). The detector was equipped with an iris stop that had an angular size of 50 min, which corresponded to the angular size of the unscattered laser beam. A digital multimeter 34465A (Keysight, Santa Rosa, CA, USA) was used to measure the detector’s signal. The transmittance was equal to Tmeas=I/I0, where I is the intensity of light passed through the PDLC cell and I0 is the intensity of the incident beam (measured without the PDLC cell). An AC voltage of 1 kHz frequency and variable amplitude was applied to the PDLC cell by the signal generator AFG-72225 (Instek, New Taipei City, Taiwan) combined with the amplitude amplifier AVA-1810 (Aktakom, Moscow, Russia). The Tmeas(U) dependencies measured for several cycles of applying voltage to the PDLC cell differ by less than 0.001·Tmeas(U). The CLC droplet structures were analyzed using the Axio Imager.M1m (Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany) polarizing optical microscope (POM). 4.3. Calculating Droplets Structures The droplet structures were calculated using Frank’s extended elastic continuum approach with annealing optimization using the Monte-Carlo method [49]. The shape of the CLC droplets was taken in the form of a flattened spheroid with an aspect ratio of x:y:z = 1:1:0.8 [42]. The ratio between the elasticity constants was K11:K22:K33 = 1:0.48:1.63. The linear energy density of the disclination core was taken to be fcoreline=2.75K11. The dimensionless polar anchoring energy was μ=WD2K11=7.92, where D=(d·d·0.8d)13=2.16 μm is the effective diameter of the droplet, W=6.5·10−5 J m−2 is the surface anchoring energy, measured experimentally by the electric field method [50]. Conical boundary conditions with an angle of 40∘ between the director and the droplet surface normal were used in the CLC droplet calculation [32]. The dimensionless field e=EapplD(ε0Δε/8K11)1/2 was used to model the effect of an electric field on the orientational structure of the CLC [49], where Eappl is the applied electric field strength, and Δε=10.2 is the dielectric permittivity anisotropy of the LC, ε0 is the electric constant. The values of the relative chirality parameter of the CLC droplet were N0=0, N0=0.15, N0=0.32, N0=0.6, and N0=1.32. The color POM textures of CLC droplets were generated by merging textures calculated using the Jones matrix technique for ten wavelengths ranging from 400 to 700 nm, with an interval of 33.33 nm between each wavelength. The calculations were made taking into account the emission spectrum of the halogen microscope lamp used (see insert in Figure 2a). 4.4. Calculating Light Transmittance Since πd/λ>>1, the transmittance of the PDLC cell was calculated using the anomalous diffraction approach, taking into account the light reflection on the glass substrates as follows [51,52,53]:(1)Tcalc=(1−0.04)2exp(−Nνσh), where the number of droplets per unit volume Nν=0.12 μm−3 is calculated based on the parameters of the studied CLC cells, σ is the total cross-section of the droplet, h=20 μm is the thickness the studied PDLC film. The total droplet cross-section value is determined by the ordinary ndo and extraordinary nde refractive indices of the CLC droplet and the sampling order parameter Sf. The refractive indices of the CLC droplet depend on the droplet order parameter Sd, as well as on the refractive indices of the polymer np and the LC n⊥, n‖ (indices ⊥ and ‖ correspond to the polarization of light perpendicular and parallel to the director, respectively). The values of Lagrange polynomials of the second kind Sf and Sd were determined based on the calculated structures of the CLC in the droplets. The parameter Sf=12(3cos2α−1) characterizes the orientation of the bipolar axis of the droplets relative to the direction of incident light. Here, α is the angle between the droplet bipolar axis Nd and the incident light direction. The transmittance Tcalc was calculated by approximating that all CLC droplets in the film respond to the electric field in the same way. In other words, the angle α(e) is the same for all CLC droplets in the film. If the bipolar axes of the CLC droplets lie in the film plane, the sampling order parameter is Sf=−0.5 (Figure 1a). When a voltage is applied, the CLC droplets tend to align their bipolar axes with the electric field [32]. This increases the Sf value, which is equal to 1 in a strong electric field (Figure 1b,c). The parameter Sd=123Ndn2−1 characterizes the orientation of the local LC director n relative to the symmetry axis of the droplet Nd. When the LC director is randomly oriented within the droplet, the droplet order parameter is Sd=0. It is Sd=1 when the director is parallel to Nd throughout the entire CLC droplet. The refractive indices of the nematic LN-396 (n⊥=1.520 and n‖=1.720) [54] and the polymer matrix (np=1.518) [32] were used to calculate the Sd values. 5. Conclusions PDLC cells with different values of the relative chirality parameter N0 of chiral nematic droplets with conical boundary conditions have been studied. It has been shown that an axisymmetric twisted axial-bipolar structure is formed in the flattened spheroid-shaped CLC droplets. Two stable states of the twisted axial-bipolar structure have been revealed: one with the bipolar axis oriented perpendicular to the short axis of the spheroid and another with the bipolar axis oriented parallel to it. As the N0 value rises, the twist angle of the structure increases, leading to a decrease in the order parameter Sd of the droplets. Applying a small voltage causes the bipolar axes of the CLC droplets to reorient along the electric field. Increasing the voltage further results in the unwinding of the structure, and Sd reaches a high value of nearly 0.95 in strong applied electric fields. This allows switching the PDLC cells from an opaque state to a transparent state with a high transmittance Tmax≅0.90. The minimum transmittance of the PDLC cells decreases as the value of N0 increases. The studied PDLC cells are characterized by low control voltages of less than 35 V, and for samples with N0=0.60 and N0=1.32, the contrast ratio is more than 145. The obtained results can be used to expand the range of applications and improve the functionality of PDLC films.