Strain-Dependent Variability in Ochratoxin A Production by Aspergillus spp. Under Different In Vitro Cultivation Conditions Authors: Zuzana Barboráková, Dana Tančinová, Juraj Medo, Silvia Jakabová, Georg Häubl, Günther Jaunecker, Zuzana Mašková, Roman Labuda Published: 2025 ABSTRACT The aim of this study was to investigate differences in the dynamics of ochratoxin A (OTA) production by various Aspergillus isolates under different cultivation conditions. Nine strains representing A. westerdijkiae, A. ochraceus, A. sulphureus, A. carbonarius, and A. albertensis were tested on malt extract agar (MEA), Czapek yeast extract agar (CYA), potato dextrose agar (PDA), and yeast extract sucrose agar (YES). Cultivations were performed at 18 °C, 22 °C, 25 °C, and 30 °C, and OTA production was monitored on the 6th, 10th, 14th, 21st, and 30th days using HPLC analysis. OTA yields strongly depended on the producing strain, with significant variability even among isolates of the same species. The most productive strain was A. ochraceus from cereals with a maximum concentration of 848 µg g−1 OTA, followed by two isolates of A. westerdijkiae from grapes of Slovak origin (591 and 479 µg g−1), and A. sulphureus from soil (546 µg g−1). In contrast, A. carbonarius strains showed the weakest OTA production. Across media, YES supported the highest toxin levels, whereas the most favourable cultivation temperatures were 18 °C and 25 °C. Each strain reached its production maximum at different time points, highlighting the strain-specific nature of OTA biosynthesis. 1. Introduction Mycotoxin contamination of food and feed represents a high risk for human and animal health [1] and is considered one of the most dangerous contaminants of food and feed [2]. Ochratoxin A (OTA) is one of the most important mycotoxins. OTA was first described by Van der Merwe et al. in 1965 (in [3]) as a toxic metabolite of the fungus Aspergillus ochraceus in a corn meal in South Africa [4]. Since it was discovered, it has been ubiquitous as a natural contaminant of moldy food and feed [5]. Biosynthetically, it is a pentaketide derived from the dihydrocoumarin family coupled with β-phenylalanine [6]. OTA is an immunosuppressant fungal compound, produced by a toxigenic species of Aspergillus and Penicillium fungi in a wide variety of climates and geographical regions [6,7]. OTA is produced in foodstuffs by Aspergillus section Circumdati (e.g., A. ochraceus, A. westerdijkiae, A. steynii), A. section Nigri (e.g., A. carbonarius, A. foetidus, A. niger, A. lacticoffeatus, A. schlerotioniger, A. tubingensis), and A. section Flavi (e.g., A. albertensis) [8], mostly in subtropical and tropical areas. It can also be produced by Penicillium verrucosum and P. nordicum, notably in temperate and colder zones [9]. P. verrucosum and A. ochraceus are able to synthesize OTA at lower temperatures than A. niger and A. carbonarius [10]. Higher amounts of OTA were produced on wheat than on other substrates, including maize, peanuts, rapeseeds, and soybeans [11]. OTA is frequently found in foodstuffs of both plant origin (e.g., cereal products, coffee, vegetables, licorice, raisins, wine, beer, wine and grape juice, dried vine fruits, nuts, cacao products, spices) and animal origin (e.g., pork/poultry) [9,12]. Dietary exposure to OTA represents a serious health issue and has been associated with several human and animal diseases, including poultry ochratoxicosis, porcine nephropathy, human endemic nephropathies, and urinary tract tumors in humans [3]. Many experimental studies have shown that the ingestion of OTA can have several consequences, such as nephrotoxic, hepatotoxic, neurotoxic, teratogenic, and immunotoxic effects [13]. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classified OTA as a possible human carcinogen—Group 2B [14]. The main factor affecting fungal growth and OTA production is water activity (aw) followed by temperature, although the effect of substrate should not be disregarded. All these factors are continuously interacting in the environment; therefore, fungal ability to grow and produce mycotoxins is affected by a complex combination of parameters. Moreover, optimum conditions for fungal growth are usually different from those for mycotoxin production [15]. The influence of these factors has been studied by culturing fungi under different environmental conditions in suitable growing substrates, or native or sterilized foodstuffs, with a significant impact on OTA-producing fungi growth and mycotoxin production [10]. Despite the effects of environmental conditions being well studied, variability between strains within the same species group has received less attention [16,17]. In particular, the dynamics of OTA production over time and its dependence on specific cultural conditions remain poorly understood, limiting effective strategies to mitigate food contamination. These gaps prevent accurate assessment of the risks associated with OTA in commodities such as grapes and cereals. Recent studies [16,17] suggest that individual isolates may differ markedly in their ochratoxigenic potential, even when belonging to the same species. However, comprehensive comparisons of multiple Aspergillus isolates cultivated under strictly identical conditions remain limited. Furthermore, time-resolved analyses following OTA formation over extended incubation periods are scarce, although available evidence indicates that OTA accumulation, degradation, or metabolic downregulation may vary significantly over time. Integrating both maximum OTA concentrations and cumulative toxin production across the cultivation period may therefore provide a more complete understanding of OTA biosynthesis dynamics under controlled conditions. Importantly, although many studies have examined the influence of temperature, aw, substrate composition, or fungal species on OTA production, comparative analyses of multiple isolates cultivated under fully standardized conditions remain scarce. Moreover, strain-level differences in long-term OTA production dynamics (e.g., cumulative toxin output) are not well characterized, despite evidence that such differences may substantially affect contamination risk. This gap highlights the need to systematically evaluate strain-dependent variability in OTA biosynthesis under controlled conditions. The aim of this study was to quantify the variability of OTA production by nine Aspergillus strains (sections Circumdati, Nigri, and Flavi) on four culture media (YES, CYA, PDA, and MEA) at different temperatures (18, 22, 25, and 30 °C) and to monitor its dynamics over 30 days in order to identify high-risk strains and optimal conditions for OTA biosynthesis. This approach provides comprehensive data to improve risk assessment strategies and prevent OTA contamination in the food chain. It should also be noted that the present study was performed exclusively under controlled laboratory conditions using pure fungal cultures. While this strictly in vitro approach allows precise comparison of strains and environmental parameters, it does not simulate biological interactions occurring in natural substrates, such as competition with other microorganisms, substrate-specific stressors, or ecological factors that may influence OTA production. 2. Materials and Methods 2.1. Strains of the Genus Aspergillus Nine strains of the genus Aspergillus were used in this study (Table 1). The isolates were identified based on macroscopic and micromorphological characteristics following the taxonomic frameworks of Samson et al. [18], Frisvad et al. [19], Pitt and Hocking [20], and Visagie et al. [21] (Table 2). Although molecular identification provides higher resolution within certain Aspergillus complexes, it was not performed in this study, as the primary aim was to compare OTA production dynamics among food-associated isolates rather than to resolve fine-scale taxonomy. Furthermore, additional molecular analyses cannot be conducted retrospectively, as several of the original isolates are no longer available in our laboratory collection. This limitation is further addressed in the Discussion. 2.2. Cultivation Media and Conditions The strains of the genus Aspergillus were cultivated on Czapek yeast extract agar (CYA; [22]), malt extract agar (MEA; Himedia, India), potato dextrose agar (PDA; Himedia, India), and on yeast extract sucrose agar (YES; [23]). Petri dishes (plates) with a 90 mm diameter were used for cultivation. The plates were inoculated at the center with 10 µL of spore suspension prepared from Aspergillus strains grown on MEA at 25 °C for 7 days, in darkness. Spores were collected by rinsing the colony with physiological saline solution supplemented with Tween 80 (0.5%). For each Aspergillus strain a conidial suspension was prepared with a concentration of 105 spores/mL. The number of spores was determined using an EVETM automatic cell counter (NanoEnTek, Seoul, Republic of Korea). Inoculated media were cultivated at 18 °C, 22 °C, 25 °C, and 30 °C in the dark conditions. Production of OTA was observed on the 6th, 10th, 14th, 21st, and 30th day of cultivation. 2.3. Sample Preparation and HPLC Analysis A total of three agar plugs (0.5 g), were taken off by the cork borer (9 mm in diameter) from central and subcentral area (representing zones 1 to 3 according to Levin et al. [24]) of a culture of Aspergillus. Plugs were added into microtubes (2.0 mL, Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany) and extracted in 1000 µL of ethyl acetate solution with 0.1% acetic acid. Extracts were mixed for five minutes by using an IKA MS 3 digital vortex and filtered through a 13 mm syringe filter 0.2 μL PTFE (VWR International, Radnor, PA, USA) into microtubes. 100 µL of prepared extracts were added into vials (2 ml, Agilent, Santa Clara, CA, USA) and then dried. Samples were reconstituted before HPLC (high performance liquid chromatography) analysis by adding 500 µL of acetonitrile solution: 0.1% H3PO4 (20:80, v:v). The analysis was performed in three replications. HPLC was realized on the Dionex Ultimate 3000 system with a DAD detector by using a column Luna C18 (II), 250 × 3 mm, 5 μm (Phenomenex, Aschaffenburg, Germany). The solvents used were 0.1% H3PO4 in water (A) and acetonitrile (B) with a flow rate of 500 μL.min−1: 0 min 45% B; 1.5 min 45–60% B; 11.5 min 65% B; 14.5 min 65–45% B; 14.6 min 45% B. The limit of detection (LOD) was 0.01 µg g−1. Limit of quantification (LOQ) was defined as three times the LOD (0.03 µg g−1). As a reference standard, used BiopureTM ochratoxin A solid standards with a purity of 97.6 ± 2.4% were used (Romer Labs, Getzersdorf, Austria). 2.4. Statistical Analysis Statistical analysis was carried out in the R statistical suite version 4.4.3 [25]. The general linear model (GLM) was used to determine the effect of factors on OTA concentration in media. Average concentration of OTA was analysed in the model Strain*Media*Temperature*Day with full interactions. The Shapiro-Wilk test was used for data normality evaluation. As the residues did not meet these criteria, logarithmic transformation (log10(OTA + LOD/2)) was used. The maximum concentration of OTA in time for each Strain*Media*Temperature was analysed in the same way. Area under the time curve (AUTC) was used to evaluate total OTA load during 30 days as the strains showed more or less rapid degradation of OTA. The AUTC values were calculated using the trapezoidal method, which approximates the integral of the measured variable over time. For a series of OTA concentration measurements yi taken at time points ti (i = 0, 1, …, n), AUTC was computed using the following equation. Tukey HSD test on a significance level of α = 0.05 was used for evaluation of the difference between average values. 3. Results 3.1. The Contribution of Factors Affecting OTA Productions The OTA concentration significantly varied, as shown in Figure 1. GLM analysis (Table S1) of actual OTA concentration showed the highest effect of strain (R2 = 0.438), followed by an effect of cultivation media (R2 = 0.159) while temperature and timepoint were of substantially lower importance (R2 = 0.002 and 0.009) despite their strong significance. All interactions (2, 3, and 4 factors) included in the model were highly significant, explaining a considerable amount of variability (e.g., Strain*temperature, R2 = 0.086, η2 = 0.739). Despite low R2 values of temperature and timepoint, their interactions with other factors explained most of the remaining variability. As visible from Figure 1, the OTA concentration changed over time non-simultaneously for all strains and culturing conditions; moreover, OTA concentration declined in many cases. This led us to a comparison of maximum OTA concentrations during the incubation period instead of average concentration. In addition to the maximum OTA concentrations, we assessed the overall OTA accumulation during cultivation using the AUTC. This approach provides a cumulative indicator of OTA production throughout the entire incubation period rather than focusing only on peak values. 3.2. The Effect of Strain on OTA Production Based on the results presented in Table 3 and Table 4, the ability to produce OTA varied considerably among the tested strains of the Aspergillus genus. The strains with the highest maximum OTA concentrations were not those with the largest AUTC values. The highest AUTC value (9123) was achieved by the A. westerdijkiae (no. 9) with a maximum concentration of 591 µg g−1 on YES medium. A. sulphureus strain CBS 550.65 (no. 7), confirming its potential as a strong OTA producer with AUTC value 8348. Strain A. ochraceus (no. 2) also achieved the best peak concentration of 848 µg g−1; however, production started late, and the AUTC value was not the highest one. Other strains maintained OTA synthesis over a longer period of time, resulting in a higher OTA load. Among the A. ochraceus strains, isolate no. 2 (Biomin, Tulln an der Donau, Austria) was substantially more productive, reaching its maximum on the 30th day of cultivation, whereas isolate no. 1 (IFA, Vienna, Austria) produced only low OTA amounts. The A. albertensis strain (no. 3) produced moderate OTA amounts. In contrast, the A. carbonarius strains (nos. 4–6) were the weakest OTA producers. The AUTC area and the average maximum OTA production showed a similar pattern in some isolates, whereas in others they differed. A clear difference was observed in the isolate A. westerdijkiae (no. 8). The highest average OTA concentration was recorded on day 10 of cultivation on YES medium at 18 °C (479.73 µg g−1), while the highest AUTC value was obtained on YES at 30 °C. This was due to an earlier onset of toxin production at 30 °C—by day 6 it was more than fourfold higher compared to 18 °C (38.12 µg g−1 vs. 169.66 µg g−1)—and the OTA concentration remained detectable even on day 30 at 30 °C (162.66 µg g−1), whereas at 18 °C it dropped below the detection limit. 3.3. The Effect of Media and Temperature on OTA Production A detailed comparison of AUTC values for the studied Aspergillus strains in response to media and temperature is shown in Figure 2. Overall comparisons of the maximum OTA concentrations together with the day when the peak was achieved are in Supplementary Table S2. OTA production was strongly influenced by both the cultivation medium and temperature. Among the tested media, YES proved to be the most suitable for the majority of Aspergillus strains, except for A. carbonarius, which produced the highest OTA levels on CYA. On YES, A. ochraceus strains were particularly productive, with strain no. 2 reaching 848.34 µg g−1 and strain no. 1 producing 92.36 µg g−1, both at 18 °C. A. sulphureus (no. 7) also reached its maximum on YES, producing 545.86 µg g−1 on day 21 at 18 °C. High OTA levels were also recorded for A. westerdijkiae, with strain no. 8 producing 479.74 µg g−1 on day 10 at 18 °C, and strain no. 9 reaching 591.28 µg g−1 on day 10 at 25 °C. A. albertensis (no. 3) yielded 197.45 µg g−1 on YES on day 21 at 30 °C. In contrast, A. carbonarius strains (nos. 4, 5, 6) were weak OTA producers overall, with the highest value being 19.90 µg g−1 for strain 4 on day 6 at 18 °C. On PDA, the highest OTA concentration was again recorded for A. sulphureus (7), with 551.94 µg g−1 on day 21 at 25 °C and 518.93 µg g−1 at 22˚C. A. westerdijkiae strains also showed strong production on PDA, with strain 8 reaching 311.58 µg g−1 and strain 9 producing 137.26 µg g−1 on day 10 at 25 °C. A. albertensis (no. 3) achieved 70.04 µg g−1 on day 6 at 30 °C, while A. ochraceus strains produced only low levels (5.66 and 38.65 µg g−1). A. carbonarius strains remained poor producers on PDA, with concentrations ranging from