Functionality-Driven Optimization of Green Ultrasound-Assisted Extraction of Antioxidant Compounds from Edible Brown Algae Authors: Carolina Padrón-Sanz, Samanta García-Oms, Javier Pacheco-Juárez, Lorena Pasquali, Dolores Cejalvo-Lapeña, Alessandro Concas Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractThe extraction of antioxidant compounds from brown macroalgae is of growing industrial interest; however, the weak correlation often observed between polyphenol content and antioxidant activity challenges the conventional strategy of optimizing only extraction yield. This study introduces, for the first time in brown macroalgae, a functionality-driven optimization approach in which ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE) conditions are optimized based on antioxidant activity as the primary response variable, rather than compound concentration. A green UAE process was developed and optimized for four edible brown algae (Himanthalia elongata, Eisenia bicyclis, Sargassum fusiforme, and Laminaria ochroleuca), considering algae amount, solvent type and concentration, extraction time, ultrasound power, and temperature. The optimized extracts achieved 69.17–94.68% DPPH inhibition, together with high antioxidant capacity supported by ORAC (18.63–491.30 μmol TE g−1 DW) and FRAP (1.24–87.65 µmol Fe+2 g−1 DW) values, identifying E. bicyclis and H. elongata as the most promising species. Chromatographic analyses confirmed the presence of phlorotannins and carotenoid pigments such as fucoxanthin as the main contributors to antioxidant activity. Overall, this work validates a functionality-driven UAE optimization strategy for efficiently maximizing antioxidant activity in brown algal extracts.Keywords: antioxidants, ultrasound-assisted extraction, brown algae, polyphenols, pigments, UHPLC-MS/MS, HPLC-Fl 1. Introduction Research on compounds with antioxidant activity has experienced exponential growth in recent decades due to their beneficial properties and multiple applications in promising sectors such as the pharmaceutical, food, and cosmetic industries [1,2,3]. Moreover, the search for these compounds from natural sources has become particularly relevant, as natural extracts are generally more accepted by consumers and avoid the undesirable side effects associated with some synthetic antioxidants used in food products [4]. In this context, the development and optimization of extraction methods for antioxidant compounds from marine algae have attracted increasing attention, since these organisms have undergone adaptive processes that enable them to produce secondary metabolites with strong antioxidant potential. In particular, brown and red algae are among the richest sources of bioactive antioxidant compounds such as polyphenols, pigments, and carbohydrates [5,6,7]. Accordingly, several extraction methodologies have been proposed to maximize the recovery of these compounds, contributing not only to the isolation of high-value biomolecules but also to the sustainable valorization of algal biomass [8]. Traditional techniques, such as solid–liquid extraction, maceration, or cold percolation, have proven to be effective and easily scalable to the industrial level. However, they often require large volumes of toxic organic solvents, prolonged heating, or complex sequential procedures to recover different classes of bioactive compounds [9,10]. Consequently, the main current challenge is to develop extraction methods that minimize solvent consumption, reduce extraction time and energy demand, and streamline the extraction workflow, ultimately achieving environmentally sustainable approaches without compromising efficiency. One methodology that fulfills these criteria, and is therefore aligned with the principles of green chemistry, is ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE), which has been successfully applied for the recovery of bioactive compounds from various natural matrices [11]. UAE has gained wide acceptance for isolating algal bioactives because it is faster, more environmentally sustainable, scalable to pilot levels, and highly efficient in recovering compounds of interest such as polyphenols, carbohydrates, and pigments [12,13,14,15]. These properties make UAE a suitable green alternative to conventional extraction methods. However, as in other extraction approaches, optimization strategies are frequently oriented toward achieving the highest possible concentration of the target compounds. This assumes a direct correlation between compound concentration and biological activity. In the case of antioxidant activity, it is often presumed that higher concentrations of antioxidant molecules (e.g., polyphenols) lead to higher overall activity. Surprisingly, for brown algae this correlation is not always observed and may arise from multiple factors: As reported in previous studies, the antioxidant performance of algal polyphenols is strongly structure-dependent: the number and relative position of hydroxyl groups influence both radical-scavenging and metal-chelating ability [16,17,18]. Moreover, co-extracted bioactive molecules such as carotenoid pigments can contribute significantly to the overall activity [19]. In addition, antioxidant capacity may be driven by a few highly active but less abundant compounds rather than by total polyphenol concentration [20]. For all these reasons, unlike previous extraction optimization studies that primarily focused on maximizing yield or TPC, the present work systematically uses antioxidant activity as the response variable to guide the optimization of UAE conditions. The optimized extracts are subsequently subjected to detailed UHPLC-MS/MS and HPLC-FL analyses, enabling the identification of compounds contributing to the observed antioxidant activity. The functionality-driven optimization proposed here is not inherently linked to UAE; instead, it may be applied to any extraction technique, including UAE. To test this approach, a green ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE) process was developed for the edible brown algae Himanthalia elongata, Eisenia bicyclis, Sargassum fusiforme, and Laminaria ochroleuca, selected for their commercial relevance and widespread consumption. This study therefore establishes a functionality-driven extraction optimization strategy as a green and efficient approach for the valorization of these four edible brown algae. 2. Results 2.1. Optimization of the UAE Variables The experimental design for process optimization combined univariate and multivariate approaches. Variables related to the mass-to-solvent interaction (algae amount, solvent type, and solvent concentration) were evaluated through univariate analysis. Ultrasound-dependent parameters (time and power) were optimized using a multivariate approach. Finally, a univariate study was performed to assess the effect of extraction temperature on the antioxidant activity of the extracts. Initial extraction conditions were set at 20 mL of 50% ethanol, 5 min of sonication at 150 W, and 25 °C. These settings were initially used for a preliminary screening step, as commonly applied in the literature for brown macroalgae [12,15], to allow cross-species comparison before individual optimization. These parameters were subsequently adjusted according to the variable under study, based on the statistical evaluation of the antioxidant activity obtained, selecting the most effective and environmentally favourable conditions for the subsequent experiments. All assays were conducted in triplicate for each algal species. 2.1.1. Amount of Algae The effect of algae amount on antioxidant activity was evaluated between 1 and 9 g. As shown in Figure 1, all species except E. bicyclis displayed a similar trend: antioxidant activity increased as algae amount rose to 5–7 g, reaching approximately 54–95%, and then decreased at 9 g (46–78%). In contrast, E. bicyclis maintained high activity (80–85%) across 1–7 g, with no significant differences within this range (p > 0.05). The reduction in antioxidant activity at the highest biomass loading (9 g), observed in most species, may result from mass-transfer limitations and reduced cavitation efficiency when the suspension becomes too dense, hindering solvent penetration and slowing the diffusion of bioactive compounds. Based on these results and green extraction criteria, 1 g was selected as the optimal amount for E. bicyclis, 5 g for H. elongata, and 7 g for both S. fusiforme and L. ochroleuca. Effect of algae amount on antioxidant activity (RSA-DPPH). Mean ± SD, n = 3. Different letters (A–D) indicate significant differences (p < 0.05), Tukey’s HSD. 2.1.2. Type of Solvent The effect of solvent polarity on antioxidant activity was evaluated using 50% (v/v) ethanol, methanol, and acetone (Figure 2). E. bicyclis and H. elongata showed no significant differences among solvents (p > 0.05), and ethanol was selected for both species due to its lower toxicity and suitability for green extraction. In contrast, S. fusiforme and L. ochroleuca exhibited significantly higher antioxidant activity when acetone was used, which was therefore selected for these two species. Although acetone was selected due to its superior extraction performance for these species, its use in downstream applications (e.g., food or cosmetics) would require complete removal or substitution with greener solvents. Effect of solvent type on antioxidant activity (RSA-DPPH). Mean ± SD, n = 3. Different letters (A–C) indicate significant differences (p < 0.05), Tukey’s HSD. 2.1.3. Solvent Concentration The effect of solvent concentration on antioxidant activity was evaluated using the solvents selected in the previous step (ethanol for E. bicyclis and H. elongata, and acetone for S. fusiforme and L. ochroleuca), ranging from 40% to 100% (v/v). As shown in Figure 3, intermediate solvent concentrations (40–60%) resulted in the highest antioxidant activities for all species (53–96% RSA-DPPH), whereas higher concentrations substantially reduced activity, particularly at 100% solvent, where values dropped to 7–71% RSA-DPPH. Accordingly, and as part of our green extraction criteria, the less resource-demanding condition within the highest statistically equivalent group was selected. Therefore, 40% was selected for H. elongata and S. fusiforme, and 60% for E. bicyclis and L. ochroleuca. Effect of solvent concentration on antioxidant activity (RSA-DPPH). Mean ± SD, n = 3. Different letters (A–D) indicate significant differences (p < 0.05), Tukey’s HSD. 2.1.4. Ultrasound Extraction Time and Power To evaluate the combined effect of extraction time and ultrasound power on antioxidant activity, different combinations of both variables were tested simultaneously. The conditions assessed covered a range from 2.5 to 10 min for extraction time and 75 to 300 W for ultrasound power. The results obtained (Figure 4) revealed distinct response patterns depending on the algal species. In E. bicyclis and S. fusiforme, antioxidant activity was mainly influenced by ultrasonic power, with higher values at intermediate to high levels. In contrast, H. elongata was more affected by extraction time, showing increased activity at intermediate to longer treatments. For L. ochroleuca, neither variable introduced significant differences among the tested conditions (p > 0.05). Effect of ultrasound time and power on antioxidant activity (RSA-DPPH). Mean of triplicates. Different letters (A–D) indicate significant differences (p < 0.05), Tukey’s HSD. Following our green extraction criteria, the lowest time and power conditions among those yielding statistically equivalent antioxidant activity were selected. Accordingly, the optimal settings were: 150 W for 2 min 30 s in E. bicyclis; 75 W for 2 min 30 s in S. fusiforme; 75 W for 5 min in H. elongata; and 75 W for 2 min 30 s in L. ochroleuca. 2.1.5. Temperature The effect of temperature on the resulting antioxidant activity was evaluated at 25, 35, 45, and 55 °C. As shown in Figure 5, temperature did not significantly influence the antioxidant activity of E. bicyclis, S. fusiforme, or H. elongata (p > 0.05), which remained high within the range of approximately 87–98%. In contrast, L. ochroleuca exhibited a pronounced increase at 45 °C, reaching nearly 70% RSA-DPPH, while remaining below 60% at the other temperatures tested. Based on these results, the extraction temperature was set at 25 °C for all species except L. ochroleuca, for which 45 °C was selected as the optimal condition. Effect of temperature on antioxidant activity (RSA-DPPH). Mean of triplicates. Different letters (A–C) indicate significant differences (p < 0.05), Tukey’s HSD. 2.1.6. Validation of Antioxidant Activity After optimization of the extraction variables, the resulting antioxidant activities ranged from 69.17 ± 1.62 to 94.68 ± 0.06% RSA-DPPH (Table 1), with Himanthalia elongata showing the highest values, followed by Eisenia bicyclis and Sargassum fusiforme, while Laminaria ochroleuca exhibited the lowest activity. Table 1Antioxidant activity of the optimized extracts determined by DPPH, ORAC and FRAP tests.AlgaeDPPH(% ± σ)ORAC(μmol TE g−1 DW ± σ) 1 FRAP (µmol Fe+2 g−1 DW ± σ) 2 Eisenia bicyclis 87.43 ± 0.26491.30 ± 17.4287.65 ± 4.29 Sargassum fusiforme 86.97 ± 0.2720.75 ± 0.26 7.64 ± 0.47 Himanthalia elongata 94.68 ± 0.06114.39 ± 4.1536.2 ± 2.40 Laminaria ochroleuca 69.17 ± 1.6218.63 ± 1.511.24 ± 0.111 µmol Trolox Equivalents g−1 dry weight. 2 µmol Fe+2 Equivalents g−1 dry weight. Antioxidant activity of the optimized extracts determined by DPPH, ORAC and FRAP tests. 1 µmol Trolox Equivalents g−1 dry weight. 2 µmol Fe+2 Equivalents g−1 dry weight. To further validate these results, two additional antioxidant assays—ORAC and FRAP—were performed on the optimized extracts. These assays confirmed that E. bicyclis and H. elongata were the species with the highest antioxidant capacity. However, unlike RSA-DPPH, E. bicyclis showed the highest activity in both ORAC and FRAP. 2.2. Chemical Characterization of the Optimized Extracts 2.2.1. Determination of Polyphenols by UHPLC-MS/MS From the chromatographic analysis (Figure 6 and Table 2), clear differences in phenolic composition were observed. In Eisenia bicyclis, both phenolic acids and phlorotannins such as dieckol, eckol and 7-phloroeckol were detected, with the latter occurring at remarkably high concentrations compared to the other compounds identified. In the remaining algal species, these phlorotannins were absent, and only phenolic acids—mainly 2,3-dihydroxybenzoic acid, 2,4,6-trihydroxybenzoic acid, 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid, and 3,4-dihydroxybenzoic acid—were found, at concentrations that varied depending on the species. UHPLC-MS/MS chromatograms of the optimized extracts. Table 2Chromatographic analysis of polyphenols in the optimized extracts (n = 3).CompoundtR(min)E. bicyclis(ng g−1 DW)S. fusiforme(ng g−1 DW)H. elongata(ng g−1 DW)L. ochroleuca(ng g−1 DW)2,3,4-trihydroxybenzoic acid b5.57 0.05), applying arcsine square root transformation when required. Differences among groups were analyzed by one-way ANOVA followed by Tukey’s HSD test (p < 0.05). Statistical analyses were conducted using IBM SPSS Statistics 23.0 (Windows, version 2021). 5. Conclusions This study developed and optimized a green ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE) methodology for four edible brown algae, prioritizing the functional antioxidant response of the extracts rather than phenolic yield or total phenolic content. The process, based on mild and energy-efficient conditions and reduced solvent consumption, yielded highly active extracts (69.17–94.68% RSA-DPPH) while aligning with the principles of green chemistry. Complementary antioxidant assays (ORAC and FRAP) confirmed the robustness of the optimization strategy, consistently identifying Eisenia bicyclis and Himanthalia elongata as the most antioxidant species. Chromatographic analysis revealed that the strong antioxidant behavior observed in the optimized Eisenia bicyclis extract is mainly attributed to its high content of tannin-type phlorotannins, together with chlorophyll- and xanthophyll-type pigments (such as lutein), which provide complementary radical-scavenging mechanisms. Overall, this work highlights the relevance of a functionality-driven optimization strategy to maximize the bioactivity of marine algal extracts using a rapid, sustainable methodology. The optimized extracts, particularly from E. bicyclis and H. elongata, show potential for future valorization at the pilot scale. Further studies, including fractionation experiments, will be required to confirm the contribution and possible synergy of the main antioxidant components and to support future scale-up efforts. Acknowledgments The authors wish to thank Alice Gasperini and Carmen Martínez, students of the Double Degree in Marine Sciences and Biotechnology at the Catholic University of Valencia (Universidad Católica de Valencia), for their valuable collaboration in this research project. Abbreviations The following abbreviations are used in this manuscript: UAEUltrasound-Assisted ExtractionDPPH2,2-diphenyl, 1-picrylhydrazylORACOxygen Radical Absorbance CapacityFRAP Ferric Reducing Antioxidant PowerTPTZ2,4,6-tripyridyl-s-triazine Author Contributions Conceptualization, C.P.-S. and D.C.-L.; methodology, C.P.-S. and D.C.-L.; software, S.G.-O., J.P.-J. and L.P.; validation, S.G.-O.; formal analysis, S.G.-O., J.P.-J. and L.P.; investigation, S.G.-O., J.P.-J. and L.P.; resources C.P.-S. and D.C.-L.; data curation, C.P.-S. and D.C.-L.; writing—original draft preparation, C.P.-S.; writing—review and editing, C.P.-S.; supervision, C.P.-S. and D.C.-L.; funding acquisition, C.P.-S. and D.C.-L. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript. Institutional Review Board Statement Not applicable. Data Availability Statement Data are available on reasonable request from the corresponding author (carolina.padron@ucv.es). Conflicts of Interest Lorena Pasquali is employed by Primolab s.r.l., and the other authors declare that there are no potential conflicts of interest. Primolab s.r.l. had no role in the design of the study; in the collection, analyses, or interpretation of data; in the writing of the manuscript; or in the decision to publish the results. Funding Statement This research was funded by the Catholic University of Valencia (Universidad Católica de Valencia, Spain) [EXP.UCV.2022-159-001]. The University also covered the laboratory analysis costs performed at the IBMCP Metabolomics Platform (UPV–CSIC). Footnotes Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement Data are available on reasonable request from the corresponding author (carolina.padron@ucv.es).