Evaluation of readmissions following elective colorectal surgery: a quality improvement initiative Authors: Lakshay Singla, Mayank Mathur, Ramya Kalaiselvan Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractProblemHospital readmissions following elective colorectal resections remain a persistent challenge, affecting recovery, hospital efficiency and overall quality of surgical care. Readmissions increase morbidity, healthcare costs and may delay ongoing cancer treatment. Within our institution, the colorectal surgical team noted a rise in unplanned readmissions after discharge, prompting structured evaluation.BackgroundColorectal resections form a major component of elective surgical activity at our centre. During early 2024, local Model Health System dashboards showed readmission rates above regional medians for both colonic and rectal resections. These findings, together with governance discussions about potentially preventable readmissions, led to a quality improvement project. National benchmarking data from the Getting It Right First Time programme were used to contextualise performance. These benchmarks are now integrated within the NHS Model Health System, enabling ongoing data-driven monitoring across surgical specialties.AimTo evaluate 30-day readmission rates following elective colorectal resections, identify contributory factors, and propose targeted quality improvement measures.MethodsA retrospective observational review was conducted at Whiston Hospital for patients undergoing elective colorectal resections between July and September 2024. Data included demographics, procedure type, comorbidities, length of stay and 30-day readmissions. Causes of readmission were analysed and compared with national data.ResultsAmong 28 patients (mean age 61±14 years; 61% male), the median length of stay was 6 days. The 30-day readmission rate was 14.2%, exceeding national benchmarks. Common causes included urinary retention, intra-abdominal collections, port-site hernia and gastrointestinal symptoms. Readmissions were associated with shorter stays and comorbidities. Model Health System data indicated early improvement in rectal resections but a modest rise in colonic cases.ConclusionReadmissions exceeded national averages, emphasising the need for enhanced recovery compliance, prehabilitation, improved discharge planning and early post-discharge follow-up. Continuous benchmarking supports sustainable improvement in outcomes.Keywords: Quality improvement, Clinical Audit, Surgery, Patient safety WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC Unplanned 30-day readmissions are a recognised indicator of the quality and safety of elective colorectal surgery, with national Getting It Right First Time (GIRFT) benchmarks suggesting expected rates of 6.1% for colonic and 8.8% for rectal cancer resections. Reducing avoidable readmissions is a key priority within enhanced recovery pathways. Unplanned 30-day readmissions are a recognised indicator of the quality and safety of elective colorectal surgery, with national Getting It Right First Time (GIRFT) benchmarks suggesting expected rates of 6.1% for colonic and 8.8% for rectal cancer resections. Reducing avoidable readmissions is a key priority within enhanced recovery pathways. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS This project identified a 14.2% readmission rate at our National Health Service centre, with the most frequent causes being urinary catheter complications, port-site hernia, intra-abdominal collections and postoperative gastrointestinal symptoms. Readmissions occurred exclusively in patients discharged within 6 days, suggesting a possible relationship between early discharge and vulnerability to complications. This project identified a 14.2% readmission rate at our National Health Service centre, with the most frequent causes being urinary catheter complications, port-site hernia, intra-abdominal collections and postoperative gastrointestinal symptoms. Readmissions occurred exclusively in patients discharged within 6 days, suggesting a possible relationship between early discharge and vulnerability to complications. HOW THIS STUDY MIGHT AFFECT RESEARCH, PRACTICE OR POLICY The findings support strengthening perioperative optimisation—including improved Enhanced Recovery After Surgery compliance, targeted prehabilitation and structured virtual follow-up after discharge—to reduce potentially preventable readmissions. The work also illustrates how GIRFT and Model Health System benchmarking can be embedded into surgical governance to drive data-led improvements and inform risk-stratified discharge planning. The findings support strengthening perioperative optimisation—including improved Enhanced Recovery After Surgery compliance, targeted prehabilitation and structured virtual follow-up after discharge—to reduce potentially preventable readmissions. The work also illustrates how GIRFT and Model Health System benchmarking can be embedded into surgical governance to drive data-led improvements and inform risk-stratified discharge planning. Introduction Hospital readmission rates are increasingly recognised as a key indicator of healthcare quality and surgical outcomes. In the context of elective colorectal surgery, unplanned readmissions can result in increased healthcare costs, patient dissatisfaction and potential medicolegal consequences.1 The UK’s Getting It Right First Time (GIRFT) programme reports national 30-day readmission benchmarks of 6.1% for elective colonic resections and 8.8% for elective rectal cancer resections, emphasising the importance of monitoring postoperative outcomes and embedding continuous quality improvement within surgical practice.2 At Whiston Hospital, a tertiary National Health Service (NHS) Trust, elective colorectal resections represent a significant component of the surgical workload. During the 2024 surgical governance review, internal performance dashboards and NHS Model Health System (MHS) data suggested that the Trust’s readmission rates might be higher than national averages. In addition, feedback from ward teams and post-discharge reviews highlighted recurrent unplanned readmissions for potentially preventable complications such as urinary retention and wound-related issues. These findings raised concerns about perioperative optimisation, discharge processes and follow-up strategies, prompting a structured quality improvement initiative.3 4 This quality improvement project (QIP) aimed to evaluate the 30-day readmission rate following elective colorectal resections at our centre and to compare local outcomes with national benchmarks. Secondary aims included identifying common causes for readmission and suggesting system-level interventions to enhance perioperative care, patient safety and surgical outcomes. Methods Study design and setting This was a retrospective observational QIP conducted in the Department of General Surgery at Whiston Hospital, a tertiary care NHS Trust in the UK. The study aimed to evaluate 30-day readmissions following elective colorectal resections and benchmark local outcomes against national GIRFT metrics. Study period and population The study included all patients who underwent elective colorectal resections between July and September 2024. Patients were identified using operative theatre records and electronic admission logs. A total of 28 consecutive patients were included in the analysis. Inclusion criteria Adult patients undergoing elective colorectal resections, including right hemicolectomy, left hemicolectomy, high anterior resection and low anterior resection. Adult patients undergoing elective colorectal resections, including right hemicolectomy, left hemicolectomy, high anterior resection and low anterior resection. Exclusion criteria Patients admitted as emergencies and underwent emergency procedures. Patients admitted as emergencies and underwent emergency procedures. Patients undergoing non-resectional procedures (eg, stoma reversal alone). Patients undergoing non-resectional procedures (eg, stoma reversal alone). Data collection Patient data were collected from electronic case records and included: Demographics (age, gender). Demographics (age, gender). Type of procedure. Type of procedure. Length of hospital stay. Length of hospital stay. Presence of comorbidities. Presence of comorbidities. 30-day readmission status. 30-day readmission status. Reason for readmission. Reason for readmission. Readmission was defined as any unplanned hospital admission within 30 days of discharge following the index operation. Each readmission was reviewed in detail, with relevant clinical notes, imaging, microbiology and operative findings assessed to determine the underlying cause. Benchmarking and outcome measures The primary outcome was the 30-day readmission rate following elective colorectal resections. This was compared against the GIRFT national benchmarks of 6.1% for elective colonic resections and 8.8% for elective rectal cancer resections.2 Secondary outcomes included the identification of common causes for readmission and potential system-level interventions to reduce preventable postoperative readmissions. Patient and public involvement Patients and members of the public were not involved in the design, conduct, reporting or dissemination of this QIP. The project involved retrospective analysis of anonymised institutional data and was undertaken as part of ongoing service evaluation within the Trust. Results Study cohort Between July and September 2024 (Quarter 2, 2024–2025), a total of 28 patients underwent elective colorectal resections at Whiston Hospital. The mean age of the cohort was 61±14 years, with a male-to-female ratio of 17:11 (61% male). All procedures were performed electively under consultant supervision and included high anterior resections, low anterior resections and other segmental colorectal resections (Figure 1). This audit included all patients undergoing elective colorectal resections during the study period, regardless of underlying pathology. While national GIRFT and MHS benchmarks report readmissions following elective cancer resections only, local data encompassed both malignant and benign indications. This may account for minor differences when comparing local and national figures. This inclusion of both benign and malignant resections provides a realistic overview of local elective colorectal activity and serves as a baseline for future cancer-specific benchmarking. Gender distribution of study participants. Length of stay The median length of stay (LOS) during the index admission was 6 days (range: 3–12 days). There was no significant variation in LOS by gender or procedure type. Readmission rate Out of 28 patients, 4 were readmitted within 30 days of discharge, giving a 30-day readmission rate of 14.2%. This exceeded the GIRFT national benchmarks of 6.1% for elective colonic resections and 8.8% for rectal cancer resections. Figures2 3 illustrate our Trust’s Quarter 2 (July–September 2024) position within national distributions, showing performance in the third to fourth quartiles, above both the national benchmark and regional median. All readmissions were unplanned and required inpatient management or further intervention. Follow-up MHS data for Quarter 3 (October–December 2024) are presented in onlinesupplemental figures 4 5,online supplemental files 2; 2, online supplemental file 1 demonstrating sustained monitoring and stable readmission performance for both colonic and rectal resections. Model Health System national distribution of 30-day emergency readmission rates following elective colonic resections, Quarter 2 (2024–2025, July–September 2024). The provider value for Whiston Hospital is shown relative to the national benchmark (6.1%). mths, months; qtr, quarter. Model Health System national distribution of 30-day emergency readmission rates following elective rectal cancer resections, Quarter 2 (2024–2025, July–September 2024). The provider value for Whiston Hospital is shown relative to the national benchmark (8.8%). mths, months; qtr, quarter. Details of readmitted cases A case-by-case breakdown of the readmitted patients is as follows: Case 1: Patient underwent a robotic low anterior resection for a mid-rectal T3cN0M0 tumour post-neoadjuvant chemoradiotherapy. Readmitted with urinary retention due to a blocked catheter, which required catheter exchange. Case 1: Patient underwent a robotic low anterior resection for a mid-rectal T3cN0M0 tumour post-neoadjuvant chemoradiotherapy. Readmitted with urinary retention due to a blocked catheter, which required catheter exchange. Case 2: Robotic low anterior resection for low rectal cancer (T3N0M0). Readmitted with abdominal pain and port-site swelling. Diagnosed with a port-site hernia, which required operative repair. Case 2: Robotic low anterior resection for low rectal cancer (T3N0M0). Readmitted with abdominal pain and port-site swelling. Diagnosed with a port-site hernia, which required operative repair. Case 3: Robotic low anterior resection for a T2N0M0 mid-rectal tumour. Presented with abdominal pain and elevated C-reactive protein. Imaging revealed a collection adjacent to the anastomosis, raising suspicion for a possible anastomotic leak. Case 3: Robotic low anterior resection for a T2N0M0 mid-rectal tumour. Presented with abdominal pain and elevated C-reactive protein. Imaging revealed a collection adjacent to the anastomosis, raising suspicion for a possible anastomotic leak. Case 4: Robotic high anterior resection for complicated sigmoid diverticulitis. Presented with diarrhoea and fever. CT of the abdomen and pelvis ruled out leak; symptoms resolved with conservative management. Case 4: Robotic high anterior resection for complicated sigmoid diverticulitis. Presented with diarrhoea and fever. CT of the abdomen and pelvis ruled out leak; symptoms resolved with conservative management. The most frequent complications leading to readmission included postoperative collections, mechanical complications (hernia), catheter-related issues and non-infective gastrointestinal symptoms. Observations and trends All readmitted patients had LOS ≤6 days, suggesting that early discharge may be a contributing factor in vulnerable patients. All readmitted patients had LOS ≤6 days, suggesting that early discharge may be a contributing factor in vulnerable patients. Three out of four readmitted patients had significant comorbidities or recent neoadjuvant treatment. Three out of four readmitted patients had significant comorbidities or recent neoadjuvant treatment. All readmitted patients had undergone robotic anterior resections, though the sample size is too small to draw procedural inferences. All readmitted patients had undergone robotic anterior resections, though the sample size is too small to draw procedural inferences. These trends suggest that postoperative complications, comorbid status and possibly insufficient early recovery contribute to higher-than-expected readmission rates. MHS data for July–September 2024 reported 30-day emergency readmission rates of 12.6% for elective colonic cancer resections (benchmark 6.1%) and 17.5% for elective rectal cancer resections (benchmark 8.8%). These figures are broadly consistent with the locally audited 14.2% readmission rate across all elective colorectal resections. The variation between local audit and MHS data likely reflects differences in case definition and coding methodology. The MHS uses Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) data grouped under Healthcare Resource Group codes, which capture only elective cancer resections for national reporting, whereas the local audit included both benign and malignant indications. Subsequent monitoring through the MHS during October–December 2024 demonstrated readmission rates of 13.1% for colonic cancer and 17.6% for rectal cancer resections. While these rates remain above national benchmarks, the stability across consecutive quarters indicates a consistent baseline from which to evaluate the impact of ongoing quality improvement measures such as enhanced recovery pathway compliance, strengthened discharge planning and early post-discharge review. Continued use of the MHS as a monitoring tool will support sustainability and data-driven refinement of perioperative processes. Discussion This QIP identified a 30-day readmission rate of 14.2% following elective colorectal resections at our institution—higher than both the national GIRFT benchmarks (6.1% for colonic and 8.8% for rectal resections) and the optimal performance deciles for colon and rectal resections.2 This positions our Trust in the third to fourth quartile nationally, according to the current GIRFT distribution metrics (Figures2 3), reinforcing the need for targeted improvements in perioperative care. The most common causes of readmission in our cohort were urinary catheter complications, port-site hernia, abdominal collections suggestive of anastomotic leak, postoperative gastrointestinal symptoms without evidence of leak. These findings align with previous literature where infectious complications, anastomosis related issues and surgical site concerns remain leading contributors to early readmission.5 6 Importantly, all readmitted patients had a length of stay ≤6 days, highlighting a potential risk associated with early discharge protocols, particularly in higher-risk patients.7 Similar observations have been described in studies evaluating the balance between enhanced recovery targets and safe discharge criteria. The predominance of robotic anterior resections among readmitted cases may reflect the greater technical complexity of rectal cancer surgery, although the small cohort limits procedural inference. Impact of ERAS and prehabilitation Multiple studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) protocols in reducing complications and readmission.8 Our current ERAS adherence was variable, and standardised documentation (eg, an ERAS booklet) was not uniformly in place. Likewise, prehabilitation—encompassing nutritional, physical and psychological optimisation—has been shown to improve outcomes in colorectal surgery6 but was not routinely available during the study period. Addressing these gaps formed a key focus for subsequent improvement work.9 Benchmarking and quality monitoring GIRFT benchmarking provides a transparent and powerful tool for comparing institutional performance. Unlike GIRFT datasets, which include cancer resections only, our audit cohort included all elective colorectal resections. This broader inclusion may partially explain the higher readmission rate observed locally. As our rate surpasses peer and regional medians (15.0% for rectal cancer, 10.6% for colon), our findings warrant institutional reflection and action. MHS data for consecutive quarters (July–December 2024) demonstrated stable readmission rates—12.6% to 13.1% for colonic and 17.5% to 17.6% for rectal resections—indicating consistent baseline performance and providing a platform for ongoing quality monitoring. These trends are illustrated in figures2 3, which show our Trust’s comparative national performance across both quarters, demonstrating sustained oversight through the MHS framework. Interventions and changes introduced Following the findings of this QIP, several targeted interventions were proposed and/or initiated to address the modifiable risk factors associated with 30-day readmissions. Strengthening ERAS compliance Although ERAS protocols were in place, adherence was found to be inconsistent. To address this: Nursing staff and junior doctors received refresher training on ERAS pathways. Nursing staff and junior doctors received refresher training on ERAS pathways. Compliance audits were planned on a quarterly basis. Compliance audits were planned on a quarterly basis. Prehabilitation initiatives Prehabilitation has been shown to improve outcomes in elective colorectal surgery by enhancing patients’ physiological reserve.9 In collaboration with the anaesthetic and physiotherapy teams: A pilot prehabilitation pathway was introduced, focusing on high-risk patients (eg, frail, elderly or undergoing neoadjuvant treatment). A pilot prehabilitation pathway was introduced, focusing on high-risk patients (eg, frail, elderly or undergoing neoadjuvant treatment). Components included nutritional support, respiratory exercises and light physical conditioning. Components included nutritional support, respiratory exercises and light physical conditioning. Virtual post-discharge clinics To improve early identification of complications and reduce unnecessary emergency readmissions: A virtual telephone follow-up was proposed for all patients within 7 days of discharge. A virtual telephone follow-up was proposed for all patients within 7 days of discharge. Patients were risk-stratified, and high-risk individuals received more frequent calls from specialist nurses or surgical registrars. Patients were risk-stratified, and high-risk individuals received more frequent calls from specialist nurses or surgical registrars. Discharge and follow-up optimisation Discharge checklists were revised to include catheter care instructions, wound care red flags and emergency contact pathways. Discharge checklists were revised to include catheter care instructions, wound care red flags and emergency contact pathways. Patient education leaflets were updated with specific information on common postoperative symptoms and when to seek help. Patient education leaflets were updated with specific information on common postoperative symptoms and when to seek help. MDT feedback and learning The findings of this QIP were shared during the Colorectal Multidisciplinary Team and Surgical Governance Meetings. The findings of this QIP were shared during the Colorectal Multidisciplinary Team and Surgical Governance Meetings. Lessons and limitations This QIP has highlighted several important insights: Readmissions often reflect systemic issues rather than isolated clinical failures. In our cohort, early discharge, incomplete optimisation and inadequate patient education likely contributed to avoidable returns. Readmissions often reflect systemic issues rather than isolated clinical failures. In our cohort, early discharge, incomplete optimisation and inadequate patient education likely contributed to avoidable returns. Use of national benchmarking tools such as GIRFT and MHS provided a structured and objective method to evaluate performance relative to peer institutions, helping us identify where improvement was needed most.2 Use of national benchmarking tools such as GIRFT and MHS provided a structured and objective method to evaluate performance relative to peer institutions, helping us identify where improvement was needed most.2 The implementation of simple, low-resource interventions—such as virtual follow-up calls and standardised discharge documentation—may offer significant impact in reducing readmissions with minimal additional burden. The implementation of simple, low-resource interventions—such as virtual follow-up calls and standardised discharge documentation—may offer significant impact in reducing readmissions with minimal additional burden. Limitations This study also had several limitations: Small sample size: With only 28 patients included, statistical generalisability is limited. However, as a snapshot QIP, it provides valuable early signals. Small sample size: With only 28 patients included, statistical generalisability is limited. However, as a snapshot QIP, it provides valuable early signals. Single-centre design: Findings may not be representative of other hospitals or systems, though local benchmarking and learning remain valid. Single-centre design: Findings may not be representative of other hospitals or systems, though local benchmarking and learning remain valid. Lack of formal risk stratification tools: While comorbidities were noted, no validated frailty or risk score (eg, portsmouth physiological and operative severity score for the enumeration of mortality and morbidity [P-POSSUM], clinical frailty scale [CFS]) was used in this cycle. Lack of formal risk stratification tools: While comorbidities were noted, no validated frailty or risk score (eg, portsmouth physiological and operative severity score for the enumeration of mortality and morbidity [P-POSSUM], clinical frailty scale [CFS]) was used in this cycle. Retrospective nature: As with all retrospective reviews, there is a risk of data incompleteness or bias in interpretation. Retrospective nature: As with all retrospective reviews, there is a risk of data incompleteness or bias in interpretation. These limitations have been acknowledged in planning the next phase of the project, which includes expanding the dataset, using formal frailty assessment tools and implementing prospective data collection. Impact and sustainability Although a formal re-audit has not yet been completed, the interventions introduced following this QIP have been embedded into routine colorectal practice. ERAS compliance monitoring and discharge checklist audits are now performed quarterly as part of the Trust’s surgical governance programme. Preliminary MHS data for the subsequent quarter (October–December 2024) demonstrated stable readmission rates for both colonic and rectal resections, suggesting early consistency in performance. As shown in onlinesupplemental figures 4 5, readmission rates remained stable in Quarter 3 (October–December 2024), supporting early signs of sustained improvement and validating the impact of ongoing quality initiatives. The continuation of virtual post-discharge follow-up and prehabilitation pilot schemes will support sustainable improvement, with a full re-audit planned to assess long-term outcomes and effectiveness of these measures. Conclusion This QIP identified a 30-day readmission rate of 14.2% following elective colorectal resections at our institution—substantially higher than national GIRFT benchmarks (6.1% for colonic and 8.8% for rectal resections). Readmissions were primarily driven by postoperative complications including catheter-related problems, port-site hernias and intra-abdominal collections. Early discharge in high-risk patients may also have contributed to unplanned readmissions. In response, we introduced targeted interventions including enhanced ERAS adherence, prehabilitation pilot programmes and virtual post-discharge follow-up, alongside revised discharge protocols. These changes were low-cost and easily integrated into existing workflows, offering sustainable avenues for improvement. While limited by a small sample size and retrospective design, this QIP provides actionable insight into readmission drivers and reinforces the value of benchmarking against national datasets. Ongoing efforts will focus on expanding data collection, incorporating formal risk stratification and completing the audit cycle to assess the impact of implemented changes. Ultimately, this project demonstrates that even small-scale, local quality initiatives—when grounded in national data and focused on practical interventions—can serve as meaningful catalysts for improving surgical outcomes. Supplementary material Footnotes Funding: The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors. Provenance and peer review: Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed. Patient consent for publication: Not applicable. Data availability free text: All data relevant to the study are included within the article. This quality improvement project was based on retrospective analysis of anonymised hospital audit data and publicly available NHS Model Health System metrics. No additional datasets were generated. Patient and public involvement: Patients and/or the public were not involved in the design, or conduct, or reporting, or dissemination plans of this research. Ethics approval: This project was registered with the Clinical Governance Department at Whiston Hospital as a quality improvement initiative. In accordance with the UK Health Research Authority (HRA) guidance on service evaluations and quality improvement projects, formal ethical approval was not required. No patient-identifiable information was used, and all data were fully anonymised prior to analysis. Data availability statement Data are available upon reasonable request. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Data Availability Statement Data are available upon reasonable request.