Individualized indication for slope changing osteotomy in ACL insufficiency: the Avalanche Concept Authors: Philipp Schuster, Philipp Mayer, Janina Leiprecht, Karl-Friedrich Schüttler, Jörg Richter, Turgay Efe Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractThe management of increased posterior tibial slope (PTS) in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries and insufficiencies and especially the indication for slope changing osteotomies has evolved to a highly discussed topic. The majority of available studies refer to cut-off values for the PTS and the number of previous ACL reconstructions in their indications. However, ACL injuries are a complex multifactorial problem, and available recommendations mainly ignore these highly individual factors, in their presence, and also in their complexity. Actually, many of the known risk factors for ACL insufficiency are also directly or indirectly associated with PTS. Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to propose a whole new way of thinking about complex ACL treatment strategies by integrating the PTS in a comprehensive approach of individual risk assessment and decision making. It is inspired by an established risk stratification system in a completely different but also very comparable field: avalanches. It is ultimately based on the thorough analysis of individual risk factors and accompanying circumstances on the one hand, and the standardized measured PTS on the other hand. These then define a point on a heat map (in a coordinate system) which, through the underlying colour, reflects the strength of the recommendation for a slope correction. This is to introduce The Avalanche Concept.Keywords: ACL, Slope, Osteotomy, Reconstruction, Revision, Tibia Introduction In recent years, the management of increased posterior tibial slope (PTS) in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries and insufficiencies has evolved to a highly discussed topic. The reported influence of the PTS on the results and especially failure rates of ACL reconstructions makes it impossible to ignore this bony risk factor [1–4]. However, there is still only little evidence with regard to slope-changing osteotomies, especially regarding indications: Almost all available clinical studies are small case series without control groups; even fewer report on medium term results, and no long-term results have been reported yet [5–11]. Therefore, it is absolutely necessary to bridge the gap between harsh reality and lack of evidence with modern treatment concepts: Concepts that take the PTS into account as one relevant factor among others and that can be applied to the individual patient-specific case. Concepts that allow modifications to account for increasing evidence and future research. Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to propose a whole new way of thinking about complex ACL treatment strategies by integrating the PTS in a comprehensive approach of individual risk assessment and decision making. This concept has been applied regarding individualized therapy decisions at the authors' institutions for years but has not been comprehensively published yet [12, 13]. It is inspired by an established risk stratification system in a completely different but also very comparable field: avalanches. Therefore, this is to introduce The Avalanche Concept. Principle considerations Understanding the PTS: why threshold values are misleading Large parts of the literature available on slope changing surgery repeatedly refer to 12° as a ‘threshold value’, suggesting that there is an erratic increase in the risk of ACL re-injury from this value upwards [7, 8, 11, 14]. However, this interpretation does not reflect reality and is misleading: The proposed 12° originate from studies analyzing ACL failure rates and then defining a cut-off value in a purely mathematical model with the inherent aim to form two groups [3, 4, 15, 16]. But the reality is different on all levels: Biomechanically the forces acting on the ACL increase approximately linearly with increasing slope [17–19]. This is in line with basic physical considerations regarding ‘gravity on inclined planes’: the downhill slope force (corresponding to the force on the ACL) correlates with the degree of the inclination (= PTS). In physical calculation it is the product of the gravitational force and the sine of the angle ⍺ of the inclination (F = Fgrav × sin(⍺)). And within the range of 0° to 25° (typical PTS range) a sine curve is almost linear. In particular, even clinical studies have demonstrated an almost linear relationship between the PTS and ACL reconstruction failures [15, 20]. Additionally, regarding the practical interpretation of published case series, it must be noted that the very same supposed ‘cut-off value’ was frequently reported, even though different measurement methods were used. The difference of measured values is primarily related to the tibial axis that is used as reference, and it has been proven that these measurements differ significantly from one another [21]. So, how reasonable can a single threshold be for different measurement methods? It must be concluded that defining a single threshold value can neither be adequate nor sufficient. Conclusively, considerations must be based on a constant, approximately linear relationship between the PTS and the resulting risk. Understanding risk factors for ACL injury: many are related to the PTS ACL injures and even more re-injuries are complex multifactorial events with multiple other conditions and risk factors apart from the PTS [22–25]. Various factors are playing a key role in the strategy of every single ACL revision even without considering the PTS. Nevertheless, recent literature shows that many of these factors are either directly or indirectly related to the PTS—especially in the setting of ACL injury or insufficiency. Therefore, these factors must be comprehensively considered separately and additionally in relation to the PTS. The factors and conditions to be considered are not limited to actually measurable or determinable (yes/no) parameters, but include also specifical an individual evaluation of qualitative parameters, e.g. how the quality of previous reconstructions has been, how well and for how long an ACL reconstruction has actually worked, or factors like family history and intended sports levels. Table 1 provides an overview of reported individual factors that are related or connected to the PTS, and how these might be of relevance in the decision for or against a bony correction. It must be noted that there are conditions that ultimately necessitate even more individualized treatment strategies, e.g. medial or lateral instabilities in varus or valgus aligned knees. Therefore, these are deliberately excluded here. Table 1Factors and conditions influencing individual ACL insufficiency and their implication in the decision whether slope-decreasing osteotomy might be indicatedFactor or conditionInfluence and evidenceConsequenceHigh-grade instability with distinct anterior tibial translation (ATT)High degrees of instability, especially with excessive ATT and greater static anterior subluxation of the tibia have been shown to be associated with a high PTS [26, 27]. High-grade instabilities have been shown to have a higher failure rate in ACL reconstruction [2, 20, 25]. An increased risk of failure for revision ACL reconstructions has been shown in cases with pre-existing high-grade instabilities [28]The presence of additional anteromedial and/or anterolateral instabilities might additionally increase this effect.Osteotomy might rather be considered in the presence of pronounced instabilityMeniscus ramp lesions, medial and lateral root tears and meniscus deficiencyRamp lesions as well as medial and lateral posterior root tears have been shown to be associated with higher PTS [29–33]. It might be assumed that the extent and severity of the lesion also play a role. This should therefore also be taken into account. It is unclear if a change in PTS might influence the result of these meniscus repairs.Osteotomy might be considered more in the presence of meniscus lesions or deficiency, especially in severe injury patterns and chronic casesChronicityChronic ACL insufficiency might lead to changes in laxity of the whole joint capsule and periphery with subsequent higher grades of instability [34, 35].Osteotomy might be considered more in chronic than in acute casesType of injuryNon-contact injuries have been shown to be more frequently associated with a high PTS than contact injuries [36].Osteotomy should be considered more in non-contact injuriesTrauma mechanismAn inadequate trauma mechanism or graft failure without trauma may be a sign of chronic overload, spontaneous failure without other obvious causes, or what is sometimes referred to as biological failure [37].Osteotomy should be considered more in inadequate trauma mechanismsNumber of previous ACL reconstructionsRepeated graft failures are highly correlated with a high PTS [12, 15].Osteotomy might be considered more the more previous ACL reconstructions have been performedQuality of previous ACL reconstructionsAn ACL reconstruction might fail because of inadequate reconstruction, non-anatomic tunnel placement or technical errors within the previous surgery [25]. In these cases, the PTS might not be the decisive factor.In particular, when patients report that an ACL reconstruction was never successful after surgery, it is not unlikely that technical errors were present.Osteotomy might be considered more if previous ACL reconstructions have been performed technically correctPrevious LET or anterolateral reconstructionAn additional LET or anterolateral reconstruction appears to relatively reduce the risk of further ACL injury in all slope conditions, although high failure rates have been reported in elevated slope conditions, especially in combination with distinct static anterior translation [20, 38]In cases without previous LET or anterolateral reconstruction an ACL revision with adding these might be sufficient without considering osteotomy based on individual factors.Osteotomy might be considered more in cases with previously performed LET or anterolateral reconstructionsTime since previous ACL reconstruction(s) and functional level sinceA significant correlation has been reported between PTS and time to graft insufficiency [12, 15]. Generally, a longer time period and a high functional level since the preceding ACL reconstruction indicate that an ACL reconstruction worked well as intended, despite a high PTS may have been present.Osteotomy might be considered less if previous ACL reconstructions had good function over longer time periodsAgeAge is generally seen as a risk factor for ACL injury as well as subsequent re-injuries [23, 24, 39–41]. This reflects the fact that the many individual risk factors and the resulting individual risk constellation can lead to ACL injury already early in life.Osteotomy should be considered more in patients of younger ageSexNo difference has been reported between males and females with regard to the radiologically measured PTS [42].Repeated graft insufficiencies are seen more often in males [12, 15, 40].Osteotomy should be considered independent of genderACL injury of the contralateral sideContralateral ACL rupture is a strong independent risk factor for further ACL injuries [39]. Patients with bilateral ACL reconstructions have been reported to have a higher PTS compared to patients with unilateral ACL injury [43].Osteotomy might be considered more in cases with bilateral ACL injuriesFamily historyA family history of ACL ruptures is an independent risk factor for ACL injuries, and might be seen as an expression of the fact that several hereditary factors lead to an overall increased risk [25].Osteotomy might be considered more when a family history of ACL injuries and especially re-injuries is presentSports levelHigh rates of return-to-preinjury-level and overall high Tegener activity scale have been reported in cases of primary ACL reconstruction with PTS correction [10]. Comparable return-to-sports-rates have been reported for 3rd ACL reconstruction with osteotomy compared to revision ACL reconstructions without osteotomy [11, 44]. Return-to-sports rate and especially the achievable sport level seems to be mainly determined by the general condition and the previous history of the knee, and less by the osteotomy itself.No data is available on professional athletes.High sports level does not seem to be a contraindication for osteotomyOsteotomy in professional athletes should be indicated very cautious, reserved and highly individualHyperextension and general laxityGeneral laxity is often related to hyperextension. Pre-existing hyperextension is likely to further increase after slope-decreasing osteotomy. The resulting increase of hyperextension after osteotomy is usually not equivalent to the amount of slope correction, and even postoperative hyperextension has been reported to be usually asymptomatic [11]. However, distinct hyperextension and recurvatum with impaired function can be a serious problem. Additional procedures to prevent overall hyperextension by creating an intraarticular extension deficit to counteract the bony correction should be seen extremely critical.Hyperextension is not a strict contraindication for osteotomy, but cases with pre-existing hyperextension and larger corrections should be carefully evaluated. A controlled correction to a different target value may be discussedACL anterior cruciate ligament, LET lateral extraarticular tenodesis, PTS posterior tibial slope, ATT anterior tibial translation Factors and conditions influencing individual ACL insufficiency and their implication in the decision whether slope-decreasing osteotomy might be indicated High degrees of instability, especially with excessive ATT and greater static anterior subluxation of the tibia have been shown to be associated with a high PTS [26, 27]. High-grade instabilities have been shown to have a higher failure rate in ACL reconstruction [2, 20, 25]. An increased risk of failure for revision ACL reconstructions has been shown in cases with pre-existing high-grade instabilities [28] The presence of additional anteromedial and/or anterolateral instabilities might additionally increase this effect. An ACL reconstruction might fail because of inadequate reconstruction, non-anatomic tunnel placement or technical errors within the previous surgery [25]. In these cases, the PTS might not be the decisive factor. In particular, when patients report that an ACL reconstruction was never successful after surgery, it is not unlikely that technical errors were present. An additional LET or anterolateral reconstruction appears to relatively reduce the risk of further ACL injury in all slope conditions, although high failure rates have been reported in elevated slope conditions, especially in combination with distinct static anterior translation [20, 38] In cases without previous LET or anterolateral reconstruction an ACL revision with adding these might be sufficient without considering osteotomy based on individual factors. No difference has been reported between males and females with regard to the radiologically measured PTS [42]. Repeated graft insufficiencies are seen more often in males [12, 15, 40]. High rates of return-to-preinjury-level and overall high Tegener activity scale have been reported in cases of primary ACL reconstruction with PTS correction [10]. Comparable return-to-sports-rates have been reported for 3rd ACL reconstruction with osteotomy compared to revision ACL reconstructions without osteotomy [11, 44]. Return-to-sports rate and especially the achievable sport level seems to be mainly determined by the general condition and the previous history of the knee, and less by the osteotomy itself. No data is available on professional athletes. High sports level does not seem to be a contraindication for osteotomy Osteotomy in professional athletes should be indicated very cautious, reserved and highly individual ACL anterior cruciate ligament, LET lateral extraarticular tenodesis, PTS posterior tibial slope, ATT anterior tibial translation With regard to the PTS itself it is essential to be aware of the prevalence of different slope values: a PTS of ≥ 12° (according to the proximal anatomical axis as proposed by Dejour and Bonnin) is a generally not uncommon condition which is present in more than 32% of ACL injuries, 35% of ACL revisions, 45% of multiple ACL revision cases, and even 20% of healthy controls—with significant differences between ethnic groups [12, 42, 45, 46]. If all of these would be treated as pathological and subsequently be corrected an enormous and inadequate number of osteotomies would result against the background of the overall satisfying results in the majority of revision ACL reconstructions [44, 47, 48]. This again demonstrates the necessity of taking other factors into account. Understanding risk interpretation and treatment goals: why a scoring system is not an option In scenarios where various factors have to be considered, the idea might arise to simplify risk stratification using a score and then base the clinical decision in either yes or no on the resulting final score. However, the use of a defined score massively underestimates the overall complexity even if the PTS is additionally considered. This might consequently be seriously misleading for various reasons: Oversimplification: Complex factors (e.g. meniscus status) would be reduced to either yes or no, not taking into account their severity, significance or pathogenesis ('linearization of complex factors'). Further, qualitative factors (e.g. quality of previous reconstructions) cannot be reasonably quantified. Interrelations between individual factors are lost: some factors mutually reinforce each other when they coincide and cannot be adequately represented with a sum of points.Ultimately, extremely subtle differences can lead to a completely different treatment decision, as a half a degree higher PTS or one point of a factor with minor relevance might completely change the treatment decision. Oversimplification: Complex factors (e.g. meniscus status) would be reduced to either yes or no, not taking into account their severity, significance or pathogenesis ('linearization of complex factors'). Further, qualitative factors (e.g. quality of previous reconstructions) cannot be reasonably quantified. Interrelations between individual factors are lost: some factors mutually reinforce each other when they coincide and cannot be adequately represented with a sum of points. Ultimately, extremely subtle differences can lead to a completely different treatment decision, as a half a degree higher PTS or one point of a factor with minor relevance might completely change the treatment decision. Illusion of precision: Score items appear objective, but are simply arbitrary. Neither the respective significance of the individual factors nor, in particular, their interaction between each other has been clearly and coherently investigated. The individual weighting of factors would be highly subjective. Illusion of precision: Score items appear objective, but are simply arbitrary. Neither the respective significance of the individual factors nor, in particular, their interaction between each other has been clearly and coherently investigated. The individual weighting of factors would be highly subjective. Lack of evidence: A system that ultimately produces a definitive yes-or-no result needs to be based on a broad range of existing evidence. In this field, the available data is nowhere near sufficient to justify a clear decision. Lack of evidence: A system that ultimately produces a definitive yes-or-no result needs to be based on a broad range of existing evidence. In this field, the available data is nowhere near sufficient to justify a clear decision. Treatment goals, surgeon’s and patient’s perspectives: Discussion on slope corrections usually involves the likelihood of suffering a re-rupture as key parameter. Neither can a slope correction prevent this in 100% of the cases, nor does ligamentous reconstruction alone without osteotomy fail in the majority of cases. For the patient, the ultimate consideration is whether a potential reduction in risk from X to Y% justifies the additional surgery and associated risks. From the surgeon’s point of view, this is essentially the ‘number needed to treat’ – to possibly prevent one re-rupture. For the patient it is the decision whether the achievable risk reduction and benefits are worth to take the potential risks, larger surgical procedure and potential adverse effects. Ultimately, it is therefore a highly individual decision, and a score value in a sense disempowers the patient, as it predetermines the outcome of this decision. Treatment goals, surgeon’s and patient’s perspectives: Discussion on slope corrections usually involves the likelihood of suffering a re-rupture as key parameter. Neither can a slope correction prevent this in 100% of the cases, nor does ligamentous reconstruction alone without osteotomy fail in the majority of cases. For the patient, the ultimate consideration is whether a potential reduction in risk from X to Y% justifies the additional surgery and associated risks. From the surgeon’s point of view, this is essentially the ‘number needed to treat’ – to possibly prevent one re-rupture. For the patient it is the decision whether the achievable risk reduction and benefits are worth to take the potential risks, larger surgical procedure and potential adverse effects. Ultimately, it is therefore a highly individual decision, and a score value in a sense disempowers the patient, as it predetermines the outcome of this decision. Understanding risk stratification in avalanches Avalanches represent a significant, often life-threatening danger in all areas of alpine sports, especially skiing, ski touring and freeriding and on point assessment is crucial to prevent severe incidents [49]. Modern assessment concepts are based on the work of Swiss mountain guide Werner Munter in the 1980s [50]. Ultimately, the risk of an avalanche occurring is based on a combination of various factors, some of which are predetermined, some of which can vary and change, and some of which represent individual factors related to the skier: The overall situation is usually reported in an avalanche bulletin issued by the competent authorities using a risk scale (Fig. 1) taking particularly into account weather conditions such as the amount and type of snowfall and fresh snow, wind strength, temperatures and solar radiation. In addition, further assessment of local parameters must be considered for the specific situation, such as actual exposure, terrain conditions, altitude and terrain shape. It is absolutely essential to know or measure the steepness of the terrain, as the slope gradient is crucial for the probability of an avalanche occurring: in low slope gradients, the probability of triggering an avalanche is minor. Last but not least, the skier himself must also be taken into account, with his individual abilities and experience. To aid the decision-making process, researchers and avalanche experts have developed different decision-making frameworks (DMFs). One of them is the so-called SnowCard developed by Engler et al., distributed by the German Alpine Association (Deutscher Alpenverein, DAV) [51]. In Fig. 2 the SnowCard is displayed and its practical application is explained. The European Avalanche Danger Scale (permission: European Avalanche Warning services, avalanches.org) The SnowCard of the German alpine association: In practical application, the warning levels (= Gefahrenstufe) from the avalanche bulletin are plotted on the x-axis, and the presence of additional risk factors lead to a position further to the right or left within the warning level. The slope gradient in the individual situation is plotted on the y-axis. The underlying colour of the intersection of the two defines the risk of triggering an avalanche. The final decision on whether to put oneself in danger and ski down the slope in question is made by the skier themselves. (Translation: Hangneigung = Slope, Gefahrenstufe = Danger Level, Level 1–4 refer to low, moderate, considerable, high. The title (Ungünstige Expositionen) refers to the use of this card in terrain with unfavourable expositions). The scale from 25° to 45° is an additional tool for measurement of the slope when in the terrain. (permission: Jan Mersch) The Avalanche Concept The Avalanche Concept for individualized indication of slope changing osteotomies transfers the established risk stratification principles and the decision-making frameworks in avalanches to knee surgery: It combines the individual risk assessment of specific factors (in their presence, quantity and quality) with the standardized measured PTS (which corresponds to the steepness of the terrain) to display the individual risk on a heat map, and thus define the degree of recommendation for a slope changing osteotomy. It serves as a decision-guidance tool, but ultimately leaves the individual decision to the patient and the surgeon in the respective case. Thereby it overcomes the oversimplified approach using a strict threshold of the PTS or simply counting the number of previous ACL reconstructions. It must be acknowledged at this point that some additional factors for defining the indication of slope changing osteotomy have already been discussed [9, 10, 52, 53]. However, no approach has yet included the extensive range of risk factors, correlated them with the PTS and combined them into a comprehensive dynamic concept. Figure 3 demonstrates the practical application: The presence and severity of individual conditions and risk factors listed in Table 1 should be analyzed and ultimately mapped to an increasing degree via the x-axis. This axis is intentionally not specified more precisely, as the individual significance of the respective factors cannot be reasonably stated and a scoring system based on available evidence is insufficient. However, many risk factors and increasing severity of those ultimately lead to a point far on the right on the x-axis. The tibial slope (ideally measured according to the mechanical axis) is plotted on the y-axis. The point defined this way in this coordinate system then defines the strength of the recommendation for an additional bony correction by the background color of the underlying heat map: from green (no recommendation for osteotomy) to dark red (strong recommendation for osteotomy). The authors recommend considering a slope-decreasing osteotomy in revision cases from a PTS ≥ 10° according to the mechanical axis and necessarily taking all factors of Table 1 into account. Heat maps for the indication of a slope-decreasing osteotomy for the different settings of revision (a, b) and primary cases (c). Patient-specific factors are plotted on the x-axis, and the radiologically measured PTS on the y-axis. The point defined this way in this coordinate system defines the strength of the recommendation for slope decreasing osteotomy by its underlying color: Dark red indicates a strong recommendation for slope decreasing osteotomy whereas green means no recommendation for osteotomy (a). The white circles represent different exemplary possible patient conditions (b, c): Patient A has a high tibial slope of around 15° (MA) but has no further risk factors. The heat map shows “green”. This patient might preferably be treated with ligament reconstruction only. Patient B has a moderately increased PTS of around 12.5° but has a number of severe concomitant factors, resulting in “red”, and thus resulting in a strong recommendation for concomitant osteotomy. Patient C has a primary ACL injury (c). With a number of severe concomitant risk factors and a high PTS of 18.5° the heat map shows “dark orange”, and ACL reconstruction combined with a slope changing osteotomy might be considered in this case Different heat maps for revisions and for the primary situation are proposed as slope changing osteotomy might also play a role in selected primary cases with high or excessive slope and severe additional risk [10]. It is important to the authors to clarify that this model and the used background colors should generally be understood as a path for complex decision-making rather than a model to clearly producing a yes or no answer. The result provides guidance and can then be used as a basis for what is ultimately a highly individual decision. Limitations The Avalanche Concept is a conceptual model that serves as a decision-making guide, but with current evidence it cannot and should not be used to provide an absolute decision. Future findings and results of clinical studies and future developments need to be integrated. However, the model can constantly be adapted by adjusting the color gradient of the heat map. Further, the major focus of the concept is the ACL and the risk for further injury. However, in many cases of existing ACL insufficiency the dominant clinical problem is actually a different one, for instance secondary osteoarthritis or medial/lateral instability with varus or valgus deviation. In these even more complex cases, the PTS is also of exceptional importance, however, even more individualized treatment strategies are necessary then, which cannot be depicted in this model. Finally, it is essential to take into account the fundamental aspects of ACL reconstruction (anatomical reconstruction, meniscus therapy, additional stabilization, etc.) before considering the indication for a slope osteotomy. Conclusion The Avalanche Concept provides an individualized decision guidance for indicating slope decreasing osteotomies predominantly in revision ACL reconstructions by combining numerous individual and patient-specific factors with the measured PTS in a dynamic heat map model. Thus, it provides the basis for an individualized treatment decision. Acknowledgements The authors have no funding to report. Author contributions Philipp Schuster had the idea for this concept and this publication. The concept was developed in its details by all authors together. The specific factors and background information in the field of avalanche science were prepared by Philipp Schuster and Philipp Mayer. The first draft of the manuscript was written by Philipp Schuster and all authors commented on previous versions of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Data availability As a concept paper, this study does not contain any specific data. Declarations Conflict of interest Philipp Schuster received speaking fees and royalties from Newclip Technics (France). The other authors have no conflicts of interest do declare. Ethics statement The concept and its publication have been approved by the institutional review board. Footnotes Publisher's Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement As a concept paper, this study does not contain any specific data.