Associations between the built environment and jogging behaviour based on voluntarily contributed tracking data: a systematic review and meta-analysis Authors: Dengkai Huang, Wenjun Xu, Marco Helbich, Xiaochun Yang Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundRunning is a widely promoted form of physical activity with significant public health benefits, yet the built environment influences its engagement. Existing evidence on the associations between the built environment and running behaviour remains heterogeneous, with prior reviews not quantifying the overall effect sizes. Additionally, gaps persist in understanding how emerging geospatial data, such as volunteered geographic information (VGI), can enhance insights into runnability.AimTo provide (1) a comprehensive synthesis of the literature and meta-analysis of the evidence for the effects of the built environment on jogging behaviour, and (2) to identify methodological limitations and future research priorities for promoting running-inclusive cities.MethodsThree databases (the Web of Science Core Collection (WoS), Scopus, and PubMed) were systematically searched for English-language studies published up to December 31, 2024. Meta-analysis was conducted to obtain pooled elasticity values for the environmental factors.ResultsOf the 1,884 studies identified, 39 studies fulfilled the inclusion criteria, and 14 studies were suitable for meta-analysis leveraging VGI-derived physical activity data. Meta-analysis revealed that floor area ratio had the largest effect size, followed by land use mix and blue space density. Distance to parks and public transport density showed minor effects. Natural environment features (e.g., blue space density and green view index) consistently correlated positively with running activity, while terrain slope exhibited context-dependent relationships. Critical methodological limitations included insufficient spatiotemporal analysis, overreliance on single-platform VGI data, and inconsistent geographic units.ConclusionsTo advance runnability research, future studies should adopt dynamic spatiotemporal modelling, integrate multi-platform VGI with participatory GIS, and employ equity-focused metrics and demographic-stratified analyses. These strategies will inform evidence-based urban planning to create running-inclusive environments, ultimately supporting population health through targeted built environment interventions.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12942-025-00428-4.Keywords: Runnability, Active living, Crowdsource data, Meta-analysis, Healthy city Introduction Running, health, and the environment Promoting physical activity is crucial for preventing non-communicable chronic diseases, reducing all-cause mortality, and contributing to the economic and environmental sustainability of cities [1–3]. Running, as a non-organised and cost-effective form of physical activity, has been associated with a range of physical and mental health benefits, including reduced resting heart rate, improved lung function, increased longevity, and a lower risk of depression and anxiety [4, 5]. Beyond these well-documented health benefits, running has also emerged as a zero-carbon and sustainable commuting mode [6, 7]. Given its health and environmental benefits, running has attracted increasing research attention, with studies examining its spatial and temporal patterns and identifying environmental factors that promote this activity [8–11]. While the built environment’s relationship with walking [12] and cycling [13] is well-established, running warrants a distinct assessment [14–19]. As a vigorous-intensity activity, running offers unique, efficient health benefits for combating non-communicable diseases [4]. Furthermore, its spatial patterns and environmental demands differ significantly [20]; runners typically traverse longer distances than walking and may prioritize extended, uninterrupted routes over the fine-grained connectivity important for walking [12] or the dedicated infrastructure essential for cycling [13]. A synthesis specific to running is therefore critical to inform targeted urban design strategies that support this distinct form of physical activity. Understanding these relationships is essential for informing urban planning and health policy aimed at creating activity-supportive environments. Defining runnability with user-generated geospatial information Previous research on the association between the built environment (e.g., street connectivity, proximity to green spaces, land use mix, and urban density) and running has primarily relied on surveys rather than tracking data techniques [20]. While surveys can effectively capture general patterns, such as running frequency, perceived attractiveness of the running environment, and restorativeness [16, 17], they lack the spatial precision needed to correlate running activities with specific built environment characteristics. With the advancement of digital participatory mapping approaches, Public Participation Geographic Information Systems (PPGIS) have gained traction to collect non-expert spatial data on running routes retrospectively reported by participants [21]. For example, D Huang, B Jiang and L Yuan [20] found that nature exposure was associated with perceived satisfaction with running routes in the Helsinki metropolitan area, and that the built environment-running associations likely vary spatially [22]. Although PPGIS provides an in-depth understanding of running geographies, its data collection faces challenges such as representativeness issues, time-intensive processes, and the routes being accurately recalled [23]. To address some of these limitations, location-acquisition technologies, including global positioning system (GPS)-enabled devices (e.g., wearables and smartphones), have become widely adopted, contributing to the growth of volunteered geographic information (VGI) [24]. VGI refers to citizens’ voluntary contribution of geographic data [24, 25]. Key strengths of VGI data are cost-effectiveness, richness, and the capacity to provide frequent updates. However, concerns about data reliability, uneven spatial completeness, and privacy issues remain notable limitations [26]. User-generated sport-tracking platforms (e.g., Strava, Keep) offer large-scale, real-time data with high spatial and temporal resolution on running routes. Numerous studies have examined the relationship between the built environment and running activity using crowdsourced GPS data from Strava [8, 27], Keep [28, 29], Edooon [9], and Endomondo [30], yielding partially contradictory results with various effect sizes. Therefore, identifying the environmental correlates most consistently associated with increased running activity is essential for guiding and prioritising urban planning. Related work A few reviews have summarised the associations between the built environment and physical activity (e.g., walking, cycling, and running). For example, PRW McCrorie, C Fenton and A Ellaway [31] used a combination of GPS, GIS, and accelerometry to highlight the relationship between the environment and physical activity in children and adolescents. However, the reviewed studies primarily focus on total physical activity, rather than isolating specific forms of physical activity such as running. Y Yang, X Wu, P Zhou, Z Gou and Y Lu [13] reviewed survey-based studies published between 2007 and 2017 that examined associations between cycling behaviour (e.g., frequency and duration) and the built environment at participants’ residential locations. However, this review does not account for cycling activity beyond the residential neighbourhood, creating a critical gap in our understanding of how specific environmental characteristics influence physical activity patterns at the precise locations where they occur. Our review addresses this limitation by focusing on VGI-based studies that provide geospatial data on runners’ environmental preferences, revealing how specific urban features (e.g., park trail density, street connectivity) influence route selection behaviour at fine spatial scales. A scoping review of 102 studies examined environmental influences on runnability, categorising relevant factors into six domains: nature exposure, perceived safety, traffic conditions, pollution, terrain, and connectivity [32]. While this comprehensive review analysed both individual running behaviours (e.g., frequency, motivation, perceived restorativeness) and spatial activity patterns at specific locations (e.g., street segments or parks), it did not conduct a meta-analysis to pool the effect sizes of different built environment factors across studies. While previous reviews have offered qualitative summaries of the built environment’s relationship with jogging [32], a quantitative synthesis capable of guiding evidence-based policy has been lacking. This study presents, to our knowledge, the first systematic review and meta-analysis to fill this gap. Our primary contribution is the calculation of pooled effect sizes (elasticities), which transcend mere statistical significance to serve as actionable tools for urban planning and public health. These elasticities enable policymakers to move beyond generic recommendations by identifying which specific environmental features—such as greenspace exposure, street connectivity, or population density—provide the strongest leverage on jogging behaviour, thereby facilitating cost-effective investment in health-promoting environments. However, the evidence base relies heavily on VGI platforms like Strava, which have a well-documented demographic bias toward younger, male, and more athletic populations [33], creating a critical equity blind spot. Therefore, the aims of this review are (1) to synthesise the existing evidence narratively and quantitatively through a meta-analysis and (2) to evaluate limitations, including demographic representativeness, to identify priorities for future research. Methods Search strategy The review followed the PRISMA guideline [34]. Our literature review used three major databases: the Web of Science Core Collection (WoS), Scopus, and PubMed. We extracted studies from the databases on January 26, 2025. We systematically searched for articles using the following combination of search terms applied to the title, abstract, and keywords: (“run” OR “running” OR “runnability” OR “jogging”) AND (“environment” OR “greenspace” OR “green space” OR “nature”) AND (“association” OR “relationship” OR “correlation” OR “associated” OR “related” OR “correlated”) AND (“GIS” OR “VGI” OR “spatial” OR “geographical”). The search was restricted to peer-reviewed original research articles published in English between 2010 and 2024 (Table 4). This date restriction was applied because VGI-based physical activity studies only became feasible following the advent of GPS-enabled fitness apps like Strava (founded in 2009) and Keep (2014), which enabled crowd-sourced activity data collection. Table 4Search strings and their setup in WOS, scopus and pubmed used in this reviewBasic search stringNumber of studiesIn string duplicate removedExact string WOSExact string scopusExact string PubMedWOSScopusPubMed(run OR running OR runnability OR jogging) AND (environment OR greenspace OR green space OR nature) AND (association OR relationship OR correlation OR associated OR related OR correlated) AND (GIS OR VGI OR spatial OR geographical)872873139716((((((((TS = (run OR running OR runnability OR jogging) AND TS = (environment OR greenspace OR green space OR nature) AND TS = (association OR relationship OR correlation OR related OR associated OR correlated) AND TS = (GIS OR VGI OR geographical OR spatial))))))) AND LA=(English)) AND DT=(Article)) AND PY=(2010–2024)TITLE-ABS-KEY(“RUN” OR “RUNNING” OR “RUNNABILITY” OR “JOGGING”) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY(“ENVIRONMENT” OR “GREENSPACE” OR “NATURE” OR “GREEN SPACE”) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY(“ASSOCIATION” OR “RELATIONSHIP” OR “CORRELATION” OR “related” OR “associated” OR “correlated”) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY(“GIS” OR “VGI” OR “geographical” OR “spatial”) AND PUBYEAR > 2010 AND (LIMIT-TO (DOCTYPE,“ar”)) AND (LIMIT-TO (LANGUAGE,“English”))((((((RUN[Title/Abstract] OR RUNNING[Title/Abstract] OR RUNNABILITY[Title/Abstract] OR JOGGING[Title/Abstract]) AND (ENVIRONMENT[Title/Abstract] OR GREENSPACE[Title/Abstract] OR NATURE[Title/Abstract] OR (“GREEN“[Title/Abstract] AND “SPACE“[Title/Abstract])) AND (ASSOCIATION[Title/Abstract] OR RELATIONSHIP[Title/Abstract] OR CORRELATION[Title/Abstract] OR ASSOCIATED[Title/Abstract] OR RELATED[Title/Abstract] OR CORRELATED[Title/Abstract])))) AND (GIS[Title/Abstract] OR VGI[Title/Abstract] OR GEOGRAPHICAL[Title/Abstract] OR SPATIAL[Title/Abstract])) AND (“2010/01/01“[PDAT] : “2024/12/31“[PDAT])) AND (Journal Article[ptyp]) Search strings and their setup in WOS, scopus and pubmed used in this review After removing 716 duplicates, 1,168 unique articles were identified. The article selection process involved two stages of screening (Fig. 1). First, we screened the abstracts to exclude articles that met any of the following criteria: (1) the study focused on irrelevant topics, or (2) the study did not examine the associations between running activity and any built environmental characteristic. Built environmental characteristics were categorized according to established frameworks [35] focusing on natural environment (e.g., green space density, NDVI, green view index); urban design and transportation (e.g., intersection density, street density, public transport accessibility); and land use (e.g., land use mix, population density, point-of-interest density). Variables related to perception (e.g., safety, maintenance) were analysed separately due to methodological differences in their measurement. Other environmental variables, such as weather conditions, were excluded as they fall outside the scope of this review, which focuses specifically on the built environment. This resulted in excluding 1,137 articles, leaving 31 articles for full-text review. Second, we performed a backwards and forward citation search (i.e., snowballing) based on the reference lists of the eligible articles. This resulted in an additional 22 relevant articles. Fifty-three articles were subjected to full-text evaluation, during which articles were excluded if they: (1) did not specifically measure running as a distinct form of physical activity but instead aggregated it with other activities such as walking or cycling (n = 10), (2) did not use crowdsourced GPS data (e.g., from fitness trackers, smartphones, or navigation apps) to quantify running activity (n = 4). After applying these exclusion criteria, 39 articles were deemed eligible for further analysis. The lead author performed the initial title and abstract screening, with verification by the second and fourth authors. For full-text evaluation, the lead and second author independently assessed eligible studies, extracted relevant data, and synthesized findings under the oversight of the fourth author. Any disagreement was resolved through discussion until a consensus was reached. The selection process for the literature review, detailing the number of studies included and excluded at each stage Data extraction and synthesis Following previous reviews on walking [12] and cycling [13], we extracted key information from each study, including author details, year of publication, location of the study area, sample size, analysed geographic unit, buffer size, types of environmental attributes, statistical models, running activity-related outcome variables, the reported associations, number of crowdsourced data records, the source GPS data, and the journal. The extracted data were tabulated in Table 5 (for detailed associations, see Supplementary Table S1 due to space constraints) and analysed using frequency analyses and cross-tabulation in Excel and SPSS (version 26). Table 5Characterization of studies by country, sample size, crowdsourced data records, built environmental factors, analysed geographic unit, outcomes, and major resultsAuthorCountrySample sizeCrowdsourced data recordsVGI data sourceBuilt environment factorsAnalysed geographic unitsOutcomesResults1Y Chen, B Wang, J Huang, H Gao and X Shu [18]ChinaNA5767 tripsFoooooot1. Density of services2. Diversity3. Accessibility4. Terrain5. LandscapeHexagonal gridRunning distanceLand use diversity and varied topography are appealing for both leisure trips and trip length2L Dong, H Jiang, W Li, B Qiu, H Wang and W Qiu [14]United States of America26,201HeatmapStrava Macro-scale built environment (BE) Density: building density, 311 calls density, reported safety concerns densityDiversity: POI density, land useDesign: tree density, open space area, street segment length, street light density, street slope, traffic signal densityDestination accessibilityDistance to transit Eye-level street environment (SE) Objective featuresBuilding, sky, tree, road, sidewalk, person, car, fence, signboard, street light, traffic light, wall, grass, plant, railing, earth, awning, ashcan, ceiling, water, column, flower, mountain, van, bridge, door, boat, windowpane, chair, minibike, bicycle, fountain, field, lake, sculpture, lamp, pier, skyscraper, hovel, bulletin board, animal, booth, sofa, glass, deskSample pointsRunning intensityThe street environment is significantly correlated with running. Accounting for the spatial effects, the collective strength of street attributes was almost the same as the counterpart of the built environmentStreet factors can complement built environment factors, indicating the necessity of using both macro-scale and eye-level environmental features to interpret runningIn addition to higher accessibility and more public transportation, the safer, wider and relatively open streets with more natural views, street lights, amenities and furniture, could promote running, while the enclosed environment, dense and overwhelming buildings, excessive interruptions on streets might hinder running3C Fang, R Homma and T Qiu [43]Japan69,91846,628 pointsStravaPopulation densityResidential densityLand-use mixRiver areaTree canopy areaElevationRoad slopeRoad densityDistance to the city centerDistance to the local hubDistance to the living hubDistance to school playgroundsDistance to natural parksLocated in large-scale parkLocated in small-scale parkDistance to riverDistance to railway stationsDistance to bus stopsRoad segmentsRunning intensityLarge parks were the primary places for recreational runningPopulation density and small-scale parks significantly affected leisure running on weekdaysRoad density and distance to rivers significantly affected weekend leisure running4T Fang, L Zhou, Z Cai, Z Tan, C Chen, J Zheng and C Fang [11]China8722,001 data recordsKeepTotal areaNDVIBlue landscapeLSIRoad lengthRoad densityRoad widthSynthetic surface trackNumber of public toiletsDensity of intersectionsRoad densityResidential land ratioPopulation densityDistance to the city centerAverage night lightDensity of bus stopsBuilding land ratioCommercial land ratioParks1. Running intensity2. Running distance3. Running duration4. Running speedTotal area and road length positively correlated with the running flow, while distance to the city center and NDVI negatively correlated with the running flowRunning distance shows positive correlations with the number of public toilets and road length, while it is negatively correlated with density of bus stops nearby and road density nearbyRunning time is positively correlated with number of public toilets and road length, and negatively correlated with density of intersections nearby and density of bus stops nearby5F Gao, X Chen, S Liao, W Chen, L Feng, J Wu, Q Zhou, Y Zheng, G Li and S Li [77]ChinaNA56,471 jogging tracksKeepRoad accessibilityPublic transportJogging trackFacility densityFacility diversitySports facility densityParkStreet lightingGreen View IndexSky view factorSafety scoreWealth scoreTemperatureSlopeAir qualityRoad segmentsRunning intensityRoad accessibility, and public transport density were found to be significantly and positively correlated with jogging frequencySports facilities were found to be positively correlated with joggingOutdoor street night lighting was positively correlated with joggingGVI and perceived safety were found to be positively correlated with jogging6X Gu, Z Lai, L Zhu and X Liu [28]China12,096NAKeepGreen View IndexNormalized Difference Vegetation IndexCooling EffectPopulation DensityAging DegreeBuilding DensityBuilding SpacingRoad DensityRoad FacilitiesLand-use MixSky View IndexVisual Motorization IndexTerrain SlopeAir HumidityGridsRunning intensityAreas with higher cooling effects and street-scale greenery correlate with increased jogging vitality7H Guo, S Zhang, Y Liu, R Lin and J Liu [47]China882545 routes with a total of 9.73 million running timesKeep Macroscale built environment Population densityAverage building heightLand use HHIRoad connectivityDensity of road intersectionsDistance to nearest metroDensity of bus stopsDistance to nearest parkDistance to nearest river Microscale streetscapes Green view indexCrowd concentration indexSky view factorBuilding-to-street ratioPublic-facility convenience indexNon-motorized vehicles interferenceStreet complexityVisual crowdednessTransparencyRoad segmentsRunning intensity1) Sky and green view indexes were positively associated with running intensity, whereas visual crowdedness had a negative effect;2) There were negative interactions of land use Herfindahl–Hirschman index with sky and green view indexes, while a positive interaction was observed for visual crowdedness8W Guo, J He and W Yang [64]ChinaNA287,663 trajectory tripswith 96,939,911 GPS pointsEdooonPM2.5 exposureSpatial factors (six administrative districts)Meteorological factors (Temperature, Precipitation, Wind Speed)Grids1. Activity space size2. Running distance3. Running duration4. Running rotation5. Running eccentricity6. Running speed(1) There exist significant spatiotemporal disparities in jogging exposure to PM2.5. Joggings in the city center, in the morning, on weekdays and in autumn and winter seasons were exposed to higher pollution concentrations(2) Jogging behavior characteristics, especially distance, activity space size, duration and rotation, were systematically associated with PM2.5 exposure across space and time(3) The role of gender directly shaped joggers’ dose inhalation of PM2.5 pollution and indirectly via duration, timing choice and distance(4) The effects of weather conditions on joggers’ exposure to PM2.5 are mainly via direct effects, whereas the direct impacts of precipitation and wind speed are mitigated by indirect effects stemming from jogging behavior patterns9SR Harden, N Schuurman, P Keller and SA Lear [55]Canada242,265NAStravaGreen and/or Blue SpaceSESUrbanicityRoad segmentsRunning intensityHigh neighborhood SES, the presence of green and/or blue space, and high population density are associated with increased running activities in all age and gender groups10D Huang, F He and W Liu [8]China9,392NAStravaConnectivityTerrain slopeBlue space densityDistance to the city centreLevels of PM2.5 concentrationsNormalized difference vegetation indexTrail densityLandscape shape indexGreen view indexPopulation densityBuilding densityStreet densityPublic transportation node densityHousing pricePark trailsRunning intensityTrail network connectivity was the only environmental attribute indicating consistent and positive associations with running intensityBlue space density was positively correlated with running intensity in urban parks but indicated no significant association in forest parks before the pandemicIn the pre-pandemic era, population density was positively related to running intensity in urban and forest parks. However, after the pandemic, the associations between running behaviours and population density remained positive in forest parks but turned insignificant in urban parks. The outbreak of the pandemic also altered the influence of other park features (e.g. park shape and trail density) on running intensity11D Huang, M Tian and L Yuan [35]Finland13,322NAStravaGreen View IndexNDVIBlue space densityTerrain slopeFloor area ratioHeight-to-width ratioLand use mixTraffic noiseAir quality indexStreet densityTraffic volumeTraffic accident densityStreet network connectivityPopulation densityMedian annual household disposable incomeRoad segmentsRunning intensityStreet greenery assessed by GVI represented the greenness exposure to runners better than top-down greenness assessed by NDVI, and thus can be considered as a more reliable predictor for running behavioursBlue space density was the predominant factor and associated with running intensity positivelyRunning intensity negatively correlated with urban density, connectivity and traffic accidents, and positively correlated with traffic noise and air pollutionPopulation density and income level were positively associated with running intensity12H Jiang, L Dong and B Qiu [41]United Kingdom40,290NAStrava Macro-scale built environments 5Ds Population densityJob densityBuilding densityStreet typePOI entropyOpen space areaCanopy densityNumber of intersectionsNumber of traffic lightsNumber of parking lotsMaximum speedStreet lengthNumber of crimesNumber of traffic accidentsNumber of firesAnnual mean NO2Annual mean PM2.5Street noise pollution levelStreet slopeNight-light intensityAnnual mean temperatureDestination accessibilityDistance to transit Micro-scale built environments Wall, building, tree, road, grass, sidewalk, earth, plant, car, fence, signboard, awning, streetlight, van, ashcan, railing, person, minibike, chair, sculpture, bicycle, column, bridge, water, fountain, windowpane, mountain, ceiling, booth, sofa, lamp, skyscraper, lake, bulletin board, desk, pierSky view factor (SVF)Sample pointsRunning intensity(1) Running occurs more frequently on trunk, primary, secondary, and tertiary roads, cycleways, and footways, but runners choose tracks, paths, pedestrian streets, and service streets relatively less;(2) Safety, larger open space areas, and longer street lengths promote running;(3) Streets with higher accessibility might attract runners;(4) Higher job density, POI entropy, canopy density, and high levels of PM 2.5 might impede running(5) Wider roads, more streetlights, trees, higher sky openness, and proximity to mountains and water facilitate running;(6) More architectural interfaces, fences, and plants with low branchingpoints might hinder running13Y Lai, J Li, J Zhang, L Yan and Y Liu [71]China8,979660,891 trajectoriesKeepPopulation densityInbound distanceOutbound distanceLocal residentsPOI densityPOI diversityPOI completenessEducation facilityCultural facilityHealth facilitySports facilityGrocery facilityStreet qualityGreen spaceGridsRunning intensityThe results reveal thestrong impact of urban form on local vibrancy but not physical activenessAlthough physical activity is related to the local population, residential percentage, business, and public facilities, it does not show a strong spatial gradient that matches the monocentric urban form as vibrancy14B Li, Q Liu, T Wang, H He, Y Peng and T Feng [46]China735NASmartwatch providers(Duorui wearable and application)Land-use mixResidential land densityBuilding densityArterial road densitySecondary road densityBranch road densityBus stop densityUniversity campuses densityComprehensive parks densityCommunity parks densitySquare densityMarket densityLiving service points densityNDVISample pointsRunning intensityBuilt environment impacts on outdoor physical activities in Changsha are not always consistent with similar studies’ results in other cities.The most effective measures to promote outdoor physical activities are the provision of good arterial and secondary road networks, and community parks15Y Liu and Y Lai [67]ChinaNA11,080 trajectoriesKeepStreetsTracksUniversity campusSpatial-temporal patternsBased on classification and pattern identification, the results reveal three major running activity types on streets, tracks, and mixed spatial conditions16Y Liu, J Hu, W Yang and C Luo [39]China14733,738 trajectoriesEdooonPark sizeNDVILSIPresence of walking loopsPresence of waterscapePark trail densityDistance to CBDNumber of road intersectionsNumber of bus stopsNumber of populationNumber of SFPOIsParksRunning intensityWalking loops and waterscapes have positive effects on jogging flowThe landscape shape index of urban parks and the distance to the city center negatively affect the jogging flow17Y Liu, Y Li, W Yang and J Hu [56]China2,90396,850 trajectoriesEdooonNDVIGVIOpennessNumber of parksNumber of tracksDistance to the nearestparkDistance to the nearesttrackDistance to the nearest water bodyNumber of road intersectionsNumber of bus stopsDistance to the nearest bus stopPopulation densityBuilding densityBlocksRunning intensity(1) BE factors exert diverse nonlinear effects on jogging at trip and OD levels(2) Quantity and accessibility of facilities contribute largely to model predictive power(3) Nonlinear effects are symmetrical for O/D of jogging, unlike long-distance travel. Distance to park, distance to track, and population density show U-shaped effects on OD volume(4) Effective ranges and thresholds in nonlinear effects vary across trip/OD levels18Y Liu, G Zhang and W Yang [78]ChinaNA7,269 trajectoriesEdooonTemperatureWind speedRelative humidityDirect solar radiationSolar scatteredradiationTotal radiationBuilding footprints and heightsElevationLand useRoad networkTraffic analysis zones (TAZs)Spatial-temporal patternsJogging patterns influence the heat exposure. Regarding motion patterns, looping jogging has lower sum heat exposure than non-looping. From temporal dimensions, weekend joggers face higher heat exposure than weekdays. For spatial patterns, joggers along east-west experience higher heat exposure than along a south-north direction;Roadside jogging exhibits the lowest sum heat exposure and park jogging demonstrates the highest one because of the duration of joggingHeat emission, building shade, and physical activity collectively affect heat exposure19C Luo, H Yu, Y Liu and W Yang [45]China2,42083,332 trajectoriesEdooonUGS areaPer capita UGS areaNDVIUGS trail densityWater area ratioAverage slopeIntersection densityNumber of bus stopsBlocks1. Running intensity2. Running durationThe findings revealed distinct spatial imbalances in the supply and demand of PA services in the case of ChongqingPA services exhibited spatial heterogeneity, with undersupply in the urban center and oversupply inthe suburbs20P Luo, B Yu, P Li and P Liang [79]ChinaNANAStravaFARLand-use mixRiver line lengthRoad densityGreen space areaNumber of bus stationsNumber of enterprisesGreen view indexSky view indexRoad view indexGridsRunning intensityGVI has a wide-ranging and positive impact on running activities while hampers them in the PA-unfriendly old townThe road view index widely promotes running activities but hinders them in some areas of the old town dominated by automobiles and under construction21P Norman and CM Pickering [73]Australia4096,720 running routesStrava, MapMyFitness and WikilocPark sizeAverage slopeHighest elevationElevation rangeTrail lengthRecreational trail lengthMountain biking trail lengthWalking and running trail lengthRainforest areaTotal rainforest areaDirect distance to large urban area boundaryDirect distance to large urban area centreRoad distance from park facilities to urban areasParksRunning intensityDistance (road and directdistance) from large urban areas best predicted visitation using routes from MapMyFitness and Strava with three parks within 2 km of urban areas experiencing over 70,000 visits (Strava)For urban parks, recreational trail length best predicted usage, while for more remote parks, the direct distance to urban areas remained the most important factor. In contrast, people using the adventure platform Wikiloc preferred more remote parks with rugged terrainThe results highlight factors affecting park popularity including distance22P Norman, CM Pickering and G Castley [10]Australia226226 running routesMapMyFitness/on-ground trail countersTheir relative proximity to urbanareasEase of accessThe types of activities permittedThe availability of facilitiesPark trailsRunning intensityMountain biking was more popular than walking or running across the three reservesBikers went further, used a greater range of trail combinations and used more reserves per trip than the other two activities23T Shi and F Gao [80]China3,73856,471 trajectoriesKeepPopulation densityRoad densityPublic transportFacility densityFacility diversitySports facility densityResidential densityDistance to parkNighttime lightingBuilding densityGreen view indexSky view indexWallPerceived safetyPerceived livelinessTemperatureAir qualitySlopeDistance to body of waterGridsRunning intensity(1) Factors related to the built environment and street perception significantly influence jogging frequency distribution(2) Public sports facilities, the level of greenery, and safety perception were identified as key factors influencing jogging activities, representing the three aspects of service facilities, objective perception, and subjective perception, respectively(3) Specifically, the influence of each factor on jogging activities displayed significant spatial variation. For instance, sports facilities and greenery level were positively correlated with jogging frequency in the city center24L Tan, J Jiang, M Guo and Y Zhong [29]China1,063NAKeepEnvironmental perception factorsSafetyVibrancyCleanlinessSlopeWidthAccessibilityConnectivityAir qualityScenic beautyGreeneryLightingSoundscapeTemperatureEnvironmental elements factorsVehiclesPedestriansTraffic infrastructureLandscapeGreen spaceWaterfront spaceService facilitiesLighting facilitiesPavementcultureBuildingsVertical elementsLand use typeRunning intensityStreets, residential areas, campuses, parks, and greenways possess significant potential to support jogging, particularly streetsThese types of land use exhibit varying spatial potentials and attractions in environmental preferences25N Wang, W Wei, Y Qian, H Gao and H Qiu [63]China35,662220,188 pieces of dataStravaPark view elementsWall, building, sky, floor-road-earth, tree, grass-plant, sidewalk-path, person, car, water, fence-railing, signboard, bench, streetlight-pole, ashcan, altitude and slope gradientSample points1. Running HR2. Running speed(1) The influence of the same park view elements on the exercise physiological indicators of different genders is small;(2) Park view elements combination based on sky, grass-plant and tree can better stabilize the walking HR of the older adult;(3) Semi-enclosed trail dominated by tree can improve the walking HR and speed of people with larger body weight;(4) Natural routes dominated by sidewalk-path and supplemented by tree and sky elements are more suitable for walking, while the trails with larger sky area, no trees and wider trails are more suitable for running26M Xie, Z Feng, W Long, S Wang, X Liu, G Ji and X Guo [52]China10,6643,271 trajectoriesKeepNDVITerrain slopeBlue space distanceGVISOIRoad intersection densityTraffic signal densityPublic transportation station densityStreet densityPOI densityBuilding densityBuilding heightHousing pricePopulation densityRoad segmentsRunning intensityStreets with higher running intensity are closer to water bodies and green spaces, while lower-intensity areas are often associated with busy traffic, noisy commercial activities, and sparsely populated regions27L Yang, B Yu, P Liang, X Tang and J Li [81]China2,788NAStravaResidential building densityFARLand-use mixWater areaRiver line lengthGreen space areaLight indexRoad densityNumber of bus and metro stationsNumber of enterprisesNumber of schoolsNumber of stadiumsHousing priceGridsRunning intensityLand-use mix has insignificant effects on the physical activity of residentsRoad density, water area, green space area, number of stadiums, and numberof enterprises significantly facilitate runningRiver line length and the light index have positive associations with runningHousing price is positively correlated with running28W Yang, H Chen, J Li, W Guo, J Fei, Y Li and J He [48]China1,085454,575 tripsEdooonGreening view indexVisual opennessVisual enclosureVisual walkabilityVisual humanization indexVisual entropy indexPopulation densityBuilding densityRoad densityIntersection densityLand-use mixNDVIDistance to bus stopDistance to metro stopDistance to trackDistance to parkDistance to waterwayNumber of tracksNumber of parksNumber of waterwaysTraffic analysis zones (TAZs)Running intensityVisual greenery, openness, and walkability play an important role in determining jogging behaviorsEffects of some VE variables display distinct scale effects and spatial non-stationarityNotably, the dual effects or synergistic effects of specific VE factors, such as visual greenery, walkability, between inside and outside the TAZ were identifiedEffects of visual greenness and openness, on jogging behavior vary across peak-hours, weekdays and weekends, and seasons, respectively29W Yang, J Fei, Y Li, H Chen and Y Liu [9]China1,851648,010 tripsEdooonMacroscale BE variablesPopulation densityBuilding densityLand-use mixIntersection densityroad densityThe distance to the nearest track, park, and waterwayThe number of tracks, parks, and waterwaysdistance to the nearest bus stop and metro stopNDVIGreening view indexSky view indexVisual motorization index visual humanization indexShannon’s diversity indexTraffic analysis zones (TAZs)Running intensity(1) Macroscale BE including sports amenities and accessibility play an important role in affecting jogging(2) All BE factors have nonlinear association with jogging, and the effective range and threshold effects vary by variables. Notably, several variables associated with jogging are in inverted U or V shapes(3) The complex interaction effects including synergistic, weakened, among BE factors were scrutinized. BE factors regarding accessibility and sports amenity interact more easily30W Yang, J Hu, Y Liu and W Guo [49]China5,94280,507 trajectoriesEdooonGVISVFNumber of sport and leisure POIsNumber of retail POIsNumber of bus stopsNumber of road intersectionsWalking time to the nearest parkProximity of road to waterscapesLocation at intervals of ring roadsPopulation heat indexFARRoad segmentsRunning intensity(1) BE factors, including sky view factor, bus stop density, presence of waterscapes, and geographic location significantly, impact jogging activity(2) The significance and effect of BE factors vary across time. Jogging activities are more sensitive to BE on weekends than on weekdays(3) Jogging trips are more closely related to BE factors in urban areas than in the suburbs. Jogging activities are mainly affected by the artificial environment in urban areas and the natural environment in suburban areas. Moreover, the effects of multiple BE factors become obvious as trip distance increases31W Yang, Y Li, Y Liu, P Fan and W Yue [50]China1,851575,070 tripsEdooonPopulation densityBuilding densityLand-use mixIntersection densityRoad densityThe distance to the nearest track, park, and waterwayThe number of tracks, parks, and waterwaysdistance to the nearest bus stop and metro stopGreening view indexSky view indexVisual motorization index visual humanization indexSimpson’s diversity indexHousing priceRent priceTraffic analysis zones (TAZs)Running intensity(1) Built Environment (BE) factors play a more important role than visual landscape factors in determining jogging behavior, with sports facilities such as tracks and parks having higher contributions(2) All environmental variables, including the BE, visual landscape, and social economics, exhibit nonlinear and threshold effects on jogging behavior(3) Certain factors such as population density, number of parks, Greening View Index, and Sky View Index exhibit differential effects across different periods, regions, and mobility patterns of jogging32C Zhang, D Shi and Z Xiao [53]China3,5681,371 trajectories2buluElevationSlopeNDVIGreen space areaWater body areaPopulation densityFARRetail & Service Facilities DensityLand Use MixIntegration IndexChoice IndexIntersection DensityLiving Road DensityTraffic Road DensityGridsRunning intensityNatural environmental factors are most contributing to outdoor jogging, while density-related built environment factors contribute the least. Additionally, environmental effects vary in scale, direction, and intensity, with seven variables exerting global impacts and five showing localized effects33H Zhang, S Nijhuis, C Newton and Y Tao [68]Netherlands24,05035,685,390 recordsStravaTypes of blue spaceWater View IndexGVIOpennessBuilding densityLand use mixVisual complexityRoad trafficIntegrationChoiceUrbanicityNon-westernLow-incomeRoad segmentsRunning intensityRecreational exercise levels on street segments vary based on the blue space type and design. Compared to inland canals and rivers, small-scale recreational waterbodies are more conducive to running but not cyclingInterestingly, the Water View Index shows a general negative association with both activities after adjusting for the blue space type. Higher GVI, lower building density, more diverse land use, greater connected street network and fewer traffic elements, are associated with more running and cycling exercises34S Zhang, Z Wang, M Helbich and D Ettema [30]NetherlandsUrban: 25,720 tracks, Rural: 8,140 tracks66,497 tracksEndomondoThe level of greennessResidential building densityLand use mixStreet connectivityUrbanisation indexThe proportion of water bodiesResidential (1,000 m) and GPS-based buffer (25 m)1. Spatial-temporal patterns2. Running duration3. Distance4. FrequencyBoth urban and rural runners preferred environments with more blue spaces and fewer streets, and a lower density of residential buildingsMore green and blue spaces, streets, less addresses and land use with higher heterogeneity were in the surroundings of > 30 min tracks35S Zhang, N Liu, B Ma and S Yan [42]China9590.973 million check-insKeepResident numberPoint-of-interestGreen-land and riverRoad networkResident densityFunction densityFunction mixGreen-land distanceBlue space distanceWaterfront trail sectionTSV skyTSV buildingTSV treeOld façadeRoad section lengthRoad section widthJunction densityIntergrationWall continuityBuilding densityRoad segmentsRunning intensityBlue space and trail continuity are the most important factors in improving road running intensityThere is an optimum design value for the sky openness and the street enclosure, which need to be balanced with shade while meeting the light of the road. And it is also important to provide appropriate visual permeability. Furthermore, unlike daily activities, it was found that higher function mixture and function density did not have significant positive effects on the road running intensity36Q Zhong, B Li and Y Chen [54]China8,311NADorrayResidential land densityGreen land densityNighttime lightArterial road densitySecondary road densitySecondary road densityLand-use mixFacilities diversityMetro line densityBus stop densityPrecipitationTemperatureNDVISlopeBus distance densityMetro distancendensityPopulation densityGross Domestic ProductRoute bufferRunning intensity(1) jogging activities (JA) were mainly concentrated in the community footpath environment;(2) Built environments, social environments, and natural environments significantly affected the relative jogging distance of residents;(3) Arterial road density (ARD) and bus distance density (BDD) have opposite significant effects on the JA of communities and green land footpaths;(4) ARD has the significant opposite effect on the JA for residents of different genders on urban footpaths and community footpaths. Facilities diversity (FD), population density (PD), and bus stop density (BSD) also had significant opposite effects on the JA of residents of different genders on greenland footpaths37Q Zhong, B Li and T Dong [40]ChinaNA4,483 trajectoriesSport app (not specify)Population densityBuilding densityWater densityResidential land densityGreen space densityLand use mixUrban functions mixRoad densityRoad crossings densityRoad connectivityNighttime Lighting IndexDegree of reliefNDVIDistance to bus stationsBus line densityBus stop densityAccessibility to recreational facilities, catering facilities, commercial facilities, workplace, educational facilities, government organizations and scenic spotsGridsRunning intensityWomen participated in walking, jogging, and bicycling activities at a higher rate than men Various leisure-time physical activities have different requirements for the built environment38Y Zhong, M Guo, M Zhang and L Tan [19]China1,001NAKeepPedestriansGreen spaceWaterfront spaceLandscapeSports facilitiesCommercial areaAccessibilityRoute bufferRunning intensity(1) Discrepancies between expert opinions and public attention, with experts more likely to overlook factors such as slope, visual quality, width, and acoustic quality;(2) The public tends to notice factors like pedestrians, green spaces, waterfront spaces, landscapes, culture, sports facilities, and accessibility on routes with high jogging frequency;(3) EFPAI for traffic infrastructure, waterfront spaces, landscapes, residential areas, and campuses is associated with route shape;39W Zhou, Z Liang, Z Fan and Z Li [44]China31,356201,785 trajectoriesKeepPopulation densityBuilding densityStreet densityRoad intersectionsFunctional densityPOI entropyStreet typesBus stopsSubway stationsPark green spaceGreenwaysNDVIRoad segmentsRunning intensityUrban park green space, greenway, and the normalized difference vegetation index had the most significant effects on running activityThe effects of population, buildings, streets, road intersections, and points of interest on running activity changed during the Coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic Characterization of studies by country, sample size, crowdsourced data records, built environmental factors, analysed geographic unit, outcomes, and major results 1. Density of services 2. Diversity 3. Accessibility 4. Terrain 5. Landscape Macro-scale built environment (BE) Density: building density, 311 calls density, reported safety concerns density Diversity: POI density, land use Design: tree density, open space area, street segment length, street light density, street slope, traffic signal density Destination accessibility Distance to transit Eye-level street environment (SE) Objective features Building, sky, tree, road, sidewalk, person, car, fence, signboard, street light, traffic light, wall, grass, plant, railing, earth, awning, ashcan, ceiling, water, column, flower, mountain, van, bridge, door, boat, windowpane, chair, minibike, bicycle, fountain, field, lake, sculpture, lamp, pier, skyscraper, hovel, bulletin board, animal, booth, sofa, glass, desk The street environment is significantly correlated with running. Accounting for the spatial effects, the collective strength of street attributes was almost the same as the counterpart of the built environment Street factors can complement built environment factors, indicating the necessity of using both macro-scale and eye-level environmental features to interpret running In addition to higher accessibility and more public transportation, the safer, wider and relatively open streets with more natural views, street lights, amenities and furniture, could promote running, while the enclosed environment, dense and overwhelming buildings, excessive interruptions on streets might hinder running Population density Residential density Land-use mix River area Tree canopy area Elevation Road slope Road density Distance to the city center Distance to the local hub Distance to the living hub Distance to school playgrounds Distance to natural parks Located in large-scale park Located in small-scale park Distance to river Distance to railway stations Distance to bus stops Large parks were the primary places for recreational running Population density and small-scale parks significantly affected leisure running on weekdays Road density and distance to rivers significantly affected weekend leisure running Total area NDVI Blue landscape LSI Road length Road density Road width Synthetic surface track Number of public toilets Density of intersections Road density Residential land ratio Population density Distance to the city center Average night light Density of bus stops Building land ratio Commercial land ratio 1. Running intensity 2. Running distance 3. Running duration 4. Running speed Total area and road length positively correlated with the running flow, while distance to the city center and NDVI negatively correlated with the running flow Running distance shows positive correlations with the number of public toilets and road length, while it is negatively correlated with density of bus stops nearby and road density nearby Running time is positively correlated with number of public toilets and road length, and negatively correlated with density of intersections nearby and density of bus stops nearby Road accessibility Public transport Jogging track Facility density Facility diversity Sports facility density Park Street lighting Green View Index Sky view factor Safety score Wealth score Temperature Slope Air quality Road accessibility, and public transport density were found to be significantly and positively correlated with jogging frequency Sports facilities were found to be positively correlated with jogging Outdoor street night lighting was positively correlated with jogging GVI and perceived safety were found to be positively correlated with jogging Green View Index Normalized Difference Vegetation Index Cooling Effect Population Density Aging Degree Building Density Building Spacing Road Density Road Facilities Land-use Mix Sky View Index Visual Motorization Index Terrain Slope Air Humidity Macroscale built environment Population density Average building height Land use HHI Road connectivity Density of road intersections Distance to nearest metro Density of bus stops Distance to nearest park Distance to nearest river Microscale streetscapes Green view index Crowd concentration index Sky view factor Building-to-street ratio Public-facility convenience index Non-motorized vehicles interference Street complexity Visual crowdedness Transparency 1) Sky and green view indexes were positively associated with running intensity, whereas visual crowdedness had a negative effect; 2) There were negative interactions of land use Herfindahl–Hirschman index with sky and green view indexes, while a positive interaction was observed for visual crowdedness 287,663 trajectory trips with 96,939,911 GPS points PM2.5 exposure Spatial factors (six administrative districts) Meteorological factors (Temperature, Precipitation, Wind Speed) 1. Activity space size 2. Running distance 3. Running duration 4. Running rotation 5. Running eccentricity 6. Running speed (1) There exist significant spatiotemporal disparities in jogging exposure to PM2.5. Joggings in the city center, in the morning, on weekdays and in autumn and winter seasons were exposed to higher pollution concentrations (2) Jogging behavior characteristics, especially distance, activity space size, duration and rotation, were systematically associated with PM2.5 exposure across space and time (3) The role of gender directly shaped joggers’ dose inhalation of PM2.5 pollution and indirectly via duration, timing choice and distance (4) The effects of weather conditions on joggers’ exposure to PM2.5 are mainly via direct effects, whereas the direct impacts of precipitation and wind speed are mitigated by indirect effects stemming from jogging behavior patterns Green and/or Blue Space SES Urbanicity Connectivity Terrain slope Blue space density Distance to the city centre Levels of PM2.5 concentrations Normalized difference vegetation index Trail density Landscape shape index Green view index Population density Building density Street density Public transportation node density Housing price Trail network connectivity was the only environmental attribute indicating consistent and positive associations with running intensity Blue space density was positively correlated with running intensity in urban parks but indicated no significant association in forest parks before the pandemic In the pre-pandemic era, population density was positively related to running intensity in urban and forest parks. However, after the pandemic, the associations between running behaviours and population density remained positive in forest parks but turned insignificant in urban parks. The outbreak of the pandemic also altered the influence of other park features (e.g. park shape and trail density) on running intensity Green View Index NDVI Blue space density Terrain slope Floor area ratio Height-to-width ratio Land use mix Traffic noise Air quality index Street density Traffic volume Traffic accident density Street network connectivity Population density Median annual household disposable income Street greenery assessed by GVI represented the greenness exposure to runners better than top-down greenness assessed by NDVI, and thus can be considered as a more reliable predictor for running behaviours Blue space density was the predominant factor and associated with running intensity positively Running intensity negatively correlated with urban density, connectivity and traffic accidents, and positively correlated with traffic noise and air pollution Population density and income level were positively associated with running intensity Macro-scale built environments 5Ds Population density Job density Building density Street type POI entropy Open space area Canopy density Number of intersections Number of traffic lights Number of parking lots Maximum speed Street length Number of crimes Number of traffic accidents Number of fires Annual mean NO2 Annual mean PM2.5 Street noise pollution level Street slope Night-light intensity Annual mean temperature Destination accessibility Distance to transit Micro-scale built environments Wall, building, tree, road, grass, sidewalk, earth, plant, car, fence, signboard, awning, streetlight, van, ashcan, railing, person, minibike, chair, sculpture, bicycle, column, bridge, water, fountain, windowpane, mountain, ceiling, booth, sofa, lamp, skyscraper, lake, bulletin board, desk, pier Sky view factor (SVF) (1) Running occurs more frequently on trunk, primary, secondary, and tertiary roads, cycleways, and footways, but runners choose tracks, paths, pedestrian streets, and service streets relatively less; (2) Safety, larger open space areas, and longer street lengths promote running; (3) Streets with higher accessibility might attract runners; (4) Higher job density, POI entropy, canopy density, and high levels of PM 2.5 might impede running (5) Wider roads, more streetlights, trees, higher sky openness, and proximity to mountains and water facilitate running; (6) More architectural interfaces, fences, and plants with low branchingpoints might hinder running Population density Inbound distance Outbound distance Local residents POI density POI diversity POI completeness Education facility Cultural facility Health facility Sports facility Grocery facility Street quality Green space The results reveal thestrong impact of urban form on local vibrancy but not physical activeness Although physical activity is related to the local population, residential percentage, business, and public facilities, it does not show a strong spatial gradient that matches the monocentric urban form as vibrancy Smartwatch providers (Duorui wearable and application) Land-use mix Residential land density Building density Arterial road density Secondary road density Branch road density Bus stop density University campuses density Comprehensive parks density Community parks density Square density Market density Living service points density NDVI Streets Tracks Park size NDVI LSI Presence of walking loops Presence of waterscape Park trail density Distance to CBD Number of road intersections Number of bus stops Number of population Number of SFPOIs Walking loops and waterscapes have positive effects on jogging flow The landscape shape index of urban parks and the distance to the city center negatively affect the jogging flow NDVI GVI Openness Number of parks Number of tracks Distance to the nearestpark Distance to the nearesttrack Distance to the nearest water body Number of road intersections Number of bus stops Distance to the nearest bus stop Population density Building density (1) BE factors exert diverse nonlinear effects on jogging at trip and OD levels (2) Quantity and accessibility of facilities contribute largely to model predictive power (3) Nonlinear effects are symmetrical for O/D of jogging, unlike long-distance travel. Distance to park, distance to track, and population density show U-shaped effects on OD volume (4) Effective ranges and thresholds in nonlinear effects vary across trip/OD levels Temperature Wind speed Relative humidity Direct solar radiation Solar scatteredradiation Total radiation Building footprints and heights Elevation Land use Road network Jogging patterns influence the heat exposure. Regarding motion patterns, looping jogging has lower sum heat exposure than non-looping. From temporal dimensions, weekend joggers face higher heat exposure than weekdays. For spatial patterns, joggers along east-west experience higher heat exposure than along a south-north direction; Roadside jogging exhibits the lowest sum heat exposure and park jogging demonstrates the highest one because of the duration of jogging Heat emission, building shade, and physical activity collectively affect heat exposure UGS area Per capita UGS area NDVI UGS trail density Water area ratio Average slope Intersection density Number of bus stops 1. Running intensity 2. Running duration The findings revealed distinct spatial imbalances in the supply and demand of PA services in the case of Chongqing PA services exhibited spatial heterogeneity, with undersupply in the urban center and oversupply inthe suburbs FAR Land-use mix River line length Road density Green space area Number of bus stations Number of enterprises Green view index Sky view index Road view index GVI has a wide-ranging and positive impact on running activities while hampers them in the PA-unfriendly old town The road view index widely promotes running activities but hinders them in some areas of the old town dominated by automobiles and under construction Park size Average slope Highest elevation Elevation range Trail length Recreational trail length Mountain biking trail length Walking and running trail length Rainforest area Total rainforest area Direct distance to large urban area boundary Direct distance to large urban area centre Road distance from park facilities to urban areas Distance (road and directdistance) from large urban areas best predicted visitation using routes from MapMyFitness and Strava with three parks within 2 km of urban areas experiencing over 70,000 visits (Strava) For urban parks, recreational trail length best predicted usage, while for more remote parks, the direct distance to urban areas remained the most important factor. In contrast, people using the adventure platform Wikiloc preferred more remote parks with rugged terrain The results highlight factors affecting park popularity including distance Their relative proximity to urbanareas Ease of access The types of activities permitted The availability of facilities Mountain biking was more popular than walking or running across the three reserves Bikers went further, used a greater range of trail combinations and used more reserves per trip than the other two activities Population density Road density Public transport Facility density Facility diversity Sports facility density Residential density Distance to park Nighttime lighting Building density Green view index Sky view index Wall Perceived safety Perceived liveliness Temperature Air quality Slope Distance to body of water (1) Factors related to the built environment and street perception significantly influence jogging frequency distribution (2) Public sports facilities, the level of greenery, and safety perception were identified as key factors influencing jogging activities, representing the three aspects of service facilities, objective perception, and subjective perception, respectively (3) Specifically, the influence of each factor on jogging activities displayed significant spatial variation. For instance, sports facilities and greenery level were positively correlated with jogging frequency in the city center Environmental perception factors Safety Vibrancy Cleanliness Slope Width Accessibility Connectivity Air quality Scenic beauty Greenery Lighting Soundscape Temperature Environmental elements factors Vehicles Pedestrians Traffic infrastructure Landscape Green space Waterfront space Service facilities Lighting facilities Pavementculture Buildings Vertical elements Streets, residential areas, campuses, parks, and greenways possess significant potential to support jogging, particularly streets These types of land use exhibit varying spatial potentials and attractions in environmental preferences Park view elements Wall, building, sky, floor-road-earth, tree, grass-plant, sidewalk-path, person, car, water, fence-railing, signboard, bench, streetlight-pole, ashcan, altitude and slope gradient 1. Running HR 2. Running speed (1) The influence of the same park view elements on the exercise physiological indicators of different genders is small; (2) Park view elements combination based on sky, grass-plant and tree can better stabilize the walking HR of the older adult; (3) Semi-enclosed trail dominated by tree can improve the walking HR and speed of people with larger body weight; (4) Natural routes dominated by sidewalk-path and supplemented by tree and sky elements are more suitable for walking, while the trails with larger sky area, no trees and wider trails are more suitable for running NDVI Terrain slope Blue space distance GVI SOI Road intersection density Traffic signal density Public transportation station density Street density POI density Building density Building height Housing price Population density Residential building density FAR Land-use mix Water area River line length Green space area Light index Road density Number of bus and metro stations Number of enterprises Number of schools Number of stadiums Housing price Land-use mix has insignificant effects on the physical activity of residents Road density, water area, green space area, number of stadiums, and numberof enterprises significantly facilitate running River line length and the light index have positive associations with running Housing price is positively correlated with running Greening view index Visual openness Visual enclosure Visual walkability Visual humanization index Visual entropy index Population density Building density Road density Intersection density Land-use mix NDVI Distance to bus stop Distance to metro stop Distance to track Distance to park Distance to waterway Number of tracks Number of parks Number of waterways Visual greenery, openness, and walkability play an important role in determining jogging behaviors Effects of some VE variables display distinct scale effects and spatial non-stationarity Notably, the dual effects or synergistic effects of specific VE factors, such as visual greenery, walkability, between inside and outside the TAZ were identified Effects of visual greenness and openness, on jogging behavior vary across peak-hours, weekdays and weekends, and seasons, respectively Macroscale BE variables Population density Building density Land-use mix Intersection densityroad density The distance to the nearest track, park, and waterway The number of tracks, parks, and waterways distance to the nearest bus stop and metro stop NDVI Greening view index Sky view index Visual motorization index visual humanization index Shannon’s diversity index (1) Macroscale BE including sports amenities and accessibility play an important role in affecting jogging (2) All BE factors have nonlinear association with jogging, and the effective range and threshold effects vary by variables. Notably, several variables associated with jogging are in inverted U or V shapes (3) The complex interaction effects including synergistic, weakened, among BE factors were scrutinized. BE factors regarding accessibility and sports amenity interact more easily GVI SVF Number of sport and leisure POIs Number of retail POIs Number of bus stops Number of road intersections Walking time to the nearest park Proximity of road to waterscapes Location at intervals of ring roads Population heat index FAR (1) BE factors, including sky view factor, bus stop density, presence of waterscapes, and geographic location significantly, impact jogging activity (2) The significance and effect of BE factors vary across time. Jogging activities are more sensitive to BE on weekends than on weekdays (3) Jogging trips are more closely related to BE factors in urban areas than in the suburbs. Jogging activities are mainly affected by the artificial environment in urban areas and the natural environment in suburban areas. Moreover, the effects of multiple BE factors become obvious as trip distance increases Population density Building density Land-use mix Intersection density Road density The distance to the nearest track, park, and waterway The number of tracks, parks, and waterways distance to the nearest bus stop and metro stop Greening view index Sky view index Visual motorization index visual humanization index Simpson’s diversity index Housing price Rent price (1) Built Environment (BE) factors play a more important role than visual landscape factors in determining jogging behavior, with sports facilities such as tracks and parks having higher contributions (2) All environmental variables, including the BE, visual landscape, and social economics, exhibit nonlinear and threshold effects on jogging behavior (3) Certain factors such as population density, number of parks, Greening View Index, and Sky View Index exhibit differential effects across different periods, regions, and mobility patterns of jogging Elevation Slope NDVI Green space area Water body area Population density FAR Retail & Service Facilities Density Land Use Mix Integration Index Choice Index Intersection Density Living Road Density Traffic Road Density Types of blue space Water View Index GVI Openness Building density Land use mix Visual complexity Road traffic Integration Choice Urbanicity Non-western Low-income Recreational exercise levels on street segments vary based on the blue space type and design. Compared to inland canals and rivers, small-scale recreational waterbodies are more conducive to running but not cycling Interestingly, the Water View Index shows a general negative association with both activities after adjusting for the blue space type. Higher GVI, lower building density, more diverse land use, greater connected street network and fewer traffic elements, are associated with more running and cycling exercises The level of greenness Residential building density Land use mix Street connectivity Urbanisation index The proportion of water bodies 1. Spatial-temporal patterns 2. Running duration 3. Distance 4. Frequency Both urban and rural runners preferred environments with more blue spaces and fewer streets, and a lower density of residential buildings More green and blue spaces, streets, less addresses and land use with higher heterogeneity were in the surroundings of > 30 min tracks Resident number Point-of-interest Green-land and river Road network Resident density Function density Function mix Green-land distance Blue space distance Waterfront trail section TSV sky TSV building TSV tree Old façade Road section length Road section width Junction density Intergration Wall continuity Building density Blue space and trail continuity are the most important factors in improving road running intensity There is an optimum design value for the sky openness and the street enclosure, which need to be balanced with shade while meeting the light of the road. And it is also important to provide appropriate visual permeability. Furthermore, unlike daily activities, it was found that higher function mixture and function density did not have significant positive effects on the road running intensity Residential land density Green land density Nighttime light Arterial road density Secondary road density Secondary road density Land-use mix Facilities diversity Metro line density Bus stop density Precipitation Temperature NDVI Slope Bus distance density Metro distancendensity Population density Gross Domestic Product (1) jogging activities (JA) were mainly concentrated in the community footpath environment; (2) Built environments, social environments, and natural environments significantly affected the relative jogging distance of residents; (3) Arterial road density (ARD) and bus distance density (BDD) have opposite significant effects on the JA of communities and green land footpaths; (4) ARD has the significant opposite effect on the JA for residents of different genders on urban footpaths and community footpaths. Facilities diversity (FD), population density (PD), and bus stop density (BSD) also had significant opposite effects on the JA of residents of different genders on greenland footpaths Population density Building density Water density Residential land density Green space density Land use mix Urban functions mix Road density Road crossings density Road connectivity Nighttime Lighting Index Degree of relief NDVI Distance to bus stations Bus line density Bus stop density Accessibility to recreational facilities, catering facilities, commercial facilities, workplace, educational facilities, government organizations and scenic spots Pedestrians Green space Waterfront space Landscape Sports facilities Commercial area Accessibility (1) Discrepancies between expert opinions and public attention, with experts more likely to overlook factors such as slope, visual quality, width, and acoustic quality; (2) The public tends to notice factors like pedestrians, green spaces, waterfront spaces, landscapes, culture, sports facilities, and accessibility on routes with high jogging frequency; (3) EFPAI for traffic infrastructure, waterfront spaces, landscapes, residential areas, and campuses is associated with route shape; Population density Building density Street density Road intersections Functional density POI entropy Street types Bus stops Subway stations Park green space Greenways NDVI Urban park green space, greenway, and the normalized difference vegetation index had the most significant effects on running activity The effects of population, buildings, streets, road intersections, and points of interest on running activity changed during the Coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic Meta-analysis using weighted average elasticity values of built environmental characteristics We computed elasticity values for the environmental factors in each study to assess how sensitive the dependent variable is to changes in the relevant independent variables [13, 36, 37]. For example, if the elasticity of street connectivity is 0.4, it indicates that a 1% increase in street connectivity is associated with a 0.4% increase in running activity. As done by R Ewing and R Cervero [38], elasticity values were derived using one of two approaches: (1) directly extracting reported elasticity values from the reviewed studies, or (2) calculating elasticity using regression coefficients along with the mean values of the dependent and independent variables. The formulas for these calculations are provided in Table 1, depending on the type of regression model applied to estimate the coefficients. We calculated weighted average elasticity values for each environmental characteristic using sample size as the weighting factor, but only when the following three conditions were met: (1) at least three studies reported relevant data; (2) descriptive statistics were available for both the dependent and independent variables; and (3) a statistically significant association was found between running activity and the environmental characteristic. Strong evidence was defined as cases where the number of statistically significant expected results was more than twice the combined total of unexpected and null findings. Evidence was considered emerging when expected results outnumbered the combined count of unexpected and null findings but did not meet the threshold for strong evidence [13]. Table 1Approaches to determine elasticity valuesRegression modelElasticity formulasLinearβ ×Log-logβLogisticβ × X × (1 -)β is the given study’s regression coefficient for a built environmental characteristic. Ȳ is the mean value of running behaviour in that study, while X̄ is the mean value of the built environment characteristic.refers to the mean estimated probability of occurrence Approaches to determine elasticity values β is the given study’s regression coefficient for a built environmental characteristic. Ȳ is the mean value of running behaviour in that study, while X̄ is the mean value of the built environment characteristic.refers to the mean estimated probability of occurrence Results Study characteristics We identified 39 studies that examined the environmental effects on running activities using VGI data. These studies were published between 2019 and 2024, covering 20 study areas across eight countries on four continents (Fig. 2). Most studies (79.5%, n = 31) focused on Asia, with an intense concentration in China. In contrast, only 10% examined Europe. North America and Oceania were represented in just 5% of studies each (n = 2), while Africa and South America were not. At the city level, Chinese cities dominated, with Beijing (n = 8), Shanghai (n = 6), Chengdu (n = 5), and Guangzhou (n = 4) comprising most studies. By comparison, cities outside China, such as Vancouver, London, Boston, Rotterdam, Helsinki, and Kumamoto (each n = 1), were infrequently studied, revealing a geographic imbalance in the literature. International publication volume over time (A) and by geography (B). Panel B shows individual study locations Sample sizes varied considerably across the studies, with 33 reporting the number of records in their datasets. These ranged widely, from 40 to 242,265 records, with an average of around 18,000 samples per study. Among the 23 studies that reported volumes of VGI running data, the number of trajectories ranged from 226 to 660,891, with an average of approximately 150,000 per study. This illustrates the substantial scale of available volunteered running data. Most studies were published in urban studies, environmental science, and public health journals. The three most frequently featured journals were Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, Landscape and Urban Planning, and Frontiers in Public Health. In contrast, fewer studies appeared in journals focused on geography and computer science. Within these fields, only a few journals (e.g., Health & Place, Applied Geography, Computational Urban Science, and Sustainable Cities and Society) featured at least two publications each in this research area. Definition of runnability outcome variables The analysis of outcome variables revealed distinct patterns in data sources and methodological approaches. Keep and Strava were the most commonly used sports-tracking platforms (n = 12 and 11, respectively), accounting for 59% of the studies. Edooon followed with nine studies (23.1%), while MapMyFitness (n = 2) and Foooooot (n = 1) were used less frequently (Fig. 3a). In terms of analytical focus, studies were nearly evenly divided: 53.7% focused solely on spatial patterns, while 46.3% analysed both spatial and temporal aspects of running behavior. a) Characteristics in the reviewed studies. Number of sports-tracking apps used and their cross-tabulation with spatiotemporal analysis patterns; b) Number of statistical models used, categorised by type of analysed geographic unit; c) The eight most frequently assessed environmental attributes and the number of studies evaluating each; d) Frequency of different data source types used for specific environmental characteristics The extracted running activity data demonstrated considerable variability in format, including raw jogging trajectories that offer detailed movement paths [39, 40], aggregated heatmaps that show spatial densities [14, 41], and check-in points that record specific locations [42, 43]. The runnability index was typically measured within predefined buffer zones around runners’ activity locations. Spatial analysis revealed distinct methodological patterns (Fig. 3b). Most studies used street segments as analysed geographic units to assess environmental attributes and runnability (n = 33), while others applied buffers around specific areas such as parks or university campuses (n = 21). Additionally, grid-based units were used in some studies (n = 19). Buffer sizes varied considerably, ranging from 15 m to 1 km. Notably, only one study using street segments incorporated a multi-scale buffer approach, accounting for road hierarchy and varying street widths [44]. For statistical modelling, conventional regression analysis was the most common (n = 31), with spatial regression and machine learning (ML) techniques equally represented (n = 17 each). The total exceeds the article count, as some studies employed multiple analytical approaches. Our review classified running metrics into seven dimensions: running intensity, frequency, duration, distance, speed, heart rate, and spatial-temporal patterns. Running intensity, also referred to in the literature as “running amount” or “jogging flow”, was the most frequently examined metric (n = 34). It was typically quantified as the total length of jogging trajectories within a given area, normalised by the area’s size. While some studies considered route counts overlapping specific locations as “running frequency” [44–46], we classified these as intensity metrics, as they fundamentally reflect spatial utilisation rates. Running frequency (n = 1) was defined as the number of running activities performed by an individual within a specified time interval, such as weekly or monthly counts [30]. Other trajectory-level performance metrics were less commonly examined, including distance (n = 4), duration (n = 4), speed (n = 3), and heart rate (n = 1). Spatiotemporal analyses revealed distinct geographic patterns in running routes across various time scales, reflecting collective runner preferences and their dynamic associations with the built environment. To ensure a robust and consistent meta-analysis, we focused solely on running intensity as the dependent variable. This was because it was the most frequently examined variable, providing sufficient data for synthesis, while other metrics (e.g., speed, heart rate) were reported in too few studies (n < 3 each) to reliably calculate pooled effect sizes. Environmental contexts Natural environment-related variables were the most frequently examined, with blue space provision (59%), Normalized Differnce Vegetation Index (NDVI) (46%), and Green View Index (GVI) (38%) being the most investigated (Fig. 3c). Among building-related and land use factors, land use mix (59%) and points of interest (POI) (51%) were the most studied, followed by building density (44%). Public transport and street density were analysed in 49% of studies for traffic-related factors. In terms of data sources, built environment measures were primarily assessed using remote sensing and satellite imagery, government and public datasets, and map data (Fig. 3d). More recent studies have adopted advanced approaches to improve measurement accuracy, including the integration of high-resolution map data with street view imagery [47, 48] or utilising VGI (e.g., OpenStreetMap) [35]. Associations between running activity and built environment Built environmental factors were classified based on the consistency of reported findings following Yang et al. [13]. As shown in Table 2, the analysis revealed strong evidence linking features of the natural environment to runnability, particularly for blue space density (38 expected vs. 15 unexpected results), green view index (31 vs. 5), distance to park (19 vs. 7), and park area (27 vs. 1). In contrast, evidence for an association with NDVI was weak. Among built environment characteristics, strong evidence was found for building density (30 vs. 5), floor area ratio (12 vs. 2), and intersection density (27 vs. 8). However, road density (26 vs. 23), POI density (20 vs. 11), and population density (35 vs. 32) showed only preliminary or inconclusive associations. Table 2Strength of associations between environmental attributes and runnability, categorised by expected, unexpected, and null findingsEnvironmental attributesDirection of associationNumber of studies with expected resultsNumber of studies with null resultsNumber of studies with unexpected resultsPark area+2701Green view index+3105Building density-3005Floor area ratio-1202Intersection density+2726Blue space density+38213Distance to park-1934POI density+20011Land use mix-21416Road density+26419Public transport density+29016Population density-35329Road connectivity+603Slope-1628NDVI+17024Dark orange shading indicates strong empirical evidence, while light orange represents emerging evidence. A minus sign (−) denotes that a negative association with running was considered an expected outcome Strength of associations between environmental attributes and runnability, categorised by expected, unexpected, and null findings Dark orange shading indicates strong empirical evidence, while light orange represents emerging evidence. A minus sign (−) denotes that a negative association with running was considered an expected outcome Elasticity values of built environmental factors Table 3 presents the number of studies underlying the weighted average elasticity calculations. The analysis identified floor area ratio as the most influential built environment factor, with an elasticity of −0.99. This indicates that a 1% increase in floor area ratio is associated with a 0.99% decrease in runnability. Similarly strong negative associations were found for land use mix (−0.81) and green view index (−0.67), while blue space density showed a substantial positive relationship (0.81). Other environmental attributes had more modest effects, with elasticity magnitudes below 0.3. For instance, park accessibility (−0.01) and public transport density (0.01) had minimal influence, suggesting they may play a limited role in runners’ route selection behaviours. Table 3Results of the weighted average elasticity estimates of environmental characteristics in relation to runnability, and the corresponding number of studies contributing to each estimateEnvironmental attributesNumber of available studiesElasticity valueFloor area ratio4−0.99Land use mix4−0.81Blue space density60.81Green view index6−0.67Slope40.28Road density70.13Park area30.13NDVI5−0.12Road connectivity3−0.11Intersection density50.04Building density6−0.08Population density6−0.08POI density50.08Distance to park3−0.01Public transport density50.01 Results of the weighted average elasticity estimates of environmental characteristics in relation to runnability, and the corresponding number of studies contributing to each estimate Discussion Principal findings This study systematically reviewed the associations between running behaviors and the built environment, synthesizing evidence from 39 studies. Our meta-analysis revealed strong negative associations between running activity and building density, floor area ratio, and distance to parks. In contrast, strong positive associations were observed with park area, green view index, blue space density, and intersection density. Emerging but less consistent evidence was found for the relationships between running activity and road density, POI density, public transport density, and road connectivity. However, definitive conclusions regarding the association between running and green space (i.e., NDVI) remain challenging due to limited supporting evidence. Our analysis of elasticity values showed that the floor area ratio had the largest effect size, followed by land use mix and blue space density, with distance to parks and public transport density demonstrating the smallest effects. We found a substantial regional bias, with disproportionate representation from Asia, particularly Chinese cities. Methodologically, Strava and Keep emerged as the dominant tracking platforms, followed by Edooon. Analytical approaches were evenly split between studies focusing exclusively on spatial patterns (approximately half) and those examining both spatial and temporal dimensions of running behavior. Non-spatial regression models predominated in the statistical analyses, though we noted a growing adoption of spatial regression techniques and machine learning (ML) algorithms in recent studies. Our review shows that research using VGI to examine how the built environment influences jogging has grown rapidly, especially since 2019. This growth reflects advances in geospatial analytics and increasing recognition of fitness-tracking data as a valuable resource for understanding active living behaviours. The literature highlights the potential of sports-tracking platforms to explore spatiotemporal activity patterns, built environment-runnability associations, and population-level health trends. Crucially, these data-driven approaches provide urban planners and policymakers with actionable insights for creating running-friendly environments that support sustainable mobility and public well-being, positioning VGI analytics as a key tool in promoting active lifestyles. Comparison with previous reviews Our findings align with a previous review [32] suggesting that runners prefer routes with greater green space exposure than built environments. Green spaces enhance runnability through multiple pathways, including improved connectivity of road network, greater access to blue spaces, and reduced exposure to noise and pollution. Our synthesis of studies provides strong evidence linking runnability to four key environmental factors: blue space density, GVI, floor area ratio, and intersection density. These findings corroborate earlier work by D Huang, B Jiang and L Yuan [20], W Yang, J Hu, Y Liu and W Guo [49], and Y Liu, J Hu, W Yang and C Luo [39]. Notably, our meta-analysis’s first three factors exhibited relatively high elasticity values, indicating a more substantial influence on running behaviour. The observed negative pooled elasticity for the GVI appears counterintuitive, considering the established preference of runners for green environments such as parks [32]. This finding may be attributable to the scale of analysis employed in the primary studies. In metropolitan-wide analyses, running activity is typically concentrated in denser urban cores characterized by lower green space exposure, whereas extensive peripheral green spaces (e.g., forests, agricultural land) may attract less recreational running. This spatial mismatch can induce a spurious negative correlation at the macro-scale, potentially obscuring positive associations. Furthermore, the relationship is likely non-linear [9, 50]. While moderate green space exposure may encourage running, the effect could plateau or even reverse in areas with very high exposure that lack running-specific infrastructure or are perceived as less accessible or safe [51]. Terrain slope is one of the most debated environmental factors affecting runnability [8, 14]. While traditionally seen as a desirable challenge by distance runners aiming to increase training intensity, our synthesis of crowdsourced data identifies slope as an emerging but negatively correlated factor in runnability assessments. Contrary to conventional assumptions, the analysis suggests that although elite runners may intentionally seek out inclined routes, the broader running population tends to avoid steeper gradients. This pattern is consistently reflected in VGI-derived movement data across multiple urban settings [52–54]. Towards a robust methodological framework Building on our systematic review, we propose a methodological framework (Fig. 4) that synthesizes the analytical approaches used in VGI-based studies exploring the relationship between the built environment and running activity. Recreational activity-related VGI data has gained increasing attention in studies examining running behavior and built environment associations. Its advantages include high spatial-temporal resolution, cost-effectiveness, large-scale coverage, real-time updates, and a user-generated nature. However, these data also present several limitations, such as inconsistent accuracy, uneven spatial coverage, privacy concerns, and platform bias [26, 33]. Methodological framework summarizing the analytical workflow of studies examining environment-running activity relationships using VGI data Our review identified Strava, Keep, and Edooon as the most popular platforms. The collected VGI data typically falls into three categories: spatial data (e.g., trajectories, or activity-specific check-in points), temporal data (e.g., precise timestamps enabling analysis across multiple time scales from diurnal patterns to annual trends, including pre- and post-event comparisons such as the COVID-19 pandemic), and supplementary data (e.g., runner perceptions, activity details, and text or photo data, which were rarely utilized in the reviewed studies). Built environment data were categorized into four types: natural environment (e.g., green space density, green view index, NDVI), traffic-related features (e.g., street density, public transport density, intersection density), land use characteristics (e.g., land use mix, POI service density), and other factors (e.g., environmental safety, maintenance). Primary data sources included remote sensing, satellite imagery, street view images, government and public datasets, and additional VGI data. These datasets were typically processed using geographic information systems (e.g., ArcGIS) and analyzed through ML techniques (implemented via Python or R). Our synthesis revealed significant heterogeneity in methodological approaches, particularly in the choice of geographic units, buffer sizes, and statistical models. While this diversity reflects an evolving field, it challenges the comparability of findings and the accumulation of a coherent knowledge base. Below, we critically assess these variations and distil evidence-based recommendations for future research. The geographic unit used to quantify running activity and environmental exposure is a fundamental methodological choice. While grid cells offer simplicity, they poorly match the street network-based nature of running, potentially introducing measurement bias by incorporating non-navigable spaces. Street segments and network buffers are conceptually superior as they align with actual movement paths. Therefore, researchers should prioritize these street network-based assessments over grid cells. The choice between segments and buffers depends on the research question. For example, street segments are ideal for analysing route choice, whereas buffers are more appropriate for assessing exposure to area-based features like land use mix. Buffer selection critically influences environmental assessments due to the modifiable areal unit problem (MAUP). Although some studies employed multiple buffers to address this issue [41], buffer sizes in the literature varied arbitrarily from 15 m to 1 km. This variation is a primary source of heterogeneity in meta-analyses, as the effect of an environmental variable is inherently scale-dependent. For instance, a 100 m buffer captures immediate streetscape greenery, while a 1 km buffer captures access to a park. To enhance methodological rigor, buffer sizes must be justified theoretically rather than chosen arbitrarily. We recommend a multi-scale approach where feasible. For destination-based features (e.g., parks, transit stations), buffers should reflect reasonable access distances (e.g., 400–800 m network distance). For pervasive features (e.g., general greenness), smaller buffers may be suitable. Researchers should explicitly state the justification for their chosen scale. The statistical approaches employed also showed a clear evolution. Although conventional regression models were predominant [18, 55], spatial regression and ML methods showed increasing adoption [35, 50, 56]. The field’s reliance on conventional regression prioritizes model interpretability, providing the clear, parametric coefficients essential for informing policy. However, this may mean the evidence base captures only linear effects, potentially missing nuanced threshold effects or complex interactions that ML models can reveal. The choice of model should be driven by the research objective. For policy guidance, conventional or spatial regression remains the standard, as it provides transparent, interpretable effect sizes. For predictive accuracy and exploring complex interactions, ML models are highly recommended, supplemented by interpretation techniques (e.g., SHAP values) to overcome their “black box” nature. Additionally, spatial regression should be routinely considered to validate results, as spatial autocorrelation is prevalent in geographic data. Future research directions While objectively measured running intensity dominates current research, subjective runner perceptions warrant greater scholarly attention. Running intensity has emerged as a predominant metric in running-environment studies [9, 14, 55, 57], serving as a key indicator of runners’ route preferences, as evidenced by our review. While this measure effectively captures environmental preferences and route selection behaviours, it offers limited insight into runners’ perceptual experiences during activity, a critical factor influencing participation frequency and long-term engagement [17]. Specifically, subjective dimensions such as running satisfaction [20] and running pleasantness [22], which reflect affective responses to the running environment, remain underrepresented in current scholarship. Recent studies employing GIS methodologies—particularly those utilizing Public Participation GIS (PPGIS) approaches—have begun to address this gap by systematically evaluating these perceptual metrics [58, 59]. These investigations highlight the need to incorporate subjective experiential data beyond purely behavioural measures (e.g., intensity). Social media platforms (e.g., Twitter, Strava Community, or fitness-focused forums) offer rich, untapped sources of self-reported perceptions, sentiment, and qualitative feedback that could effectively complement trajectory analysis [60–62]. By merging these diverse datasets, researchers could develop a more comprehensive framework for assessing built environment-runnability associations, bridging the gap between quantitative metrics and qualitative perspectives. Current research lacks sufficient focus on individual-level running metrics, with only a limited number of studies examining characteristics such as frequency, duration, distance, speed, and physiological markers (e.g., heart rate) [17, 30, 63, 64]. This narrow analytical scope overlooks critical dimensions of runner–environment associations, particularly how personal running profiles, physiological responses, and psychological restoration needs shape spatial usage [65, 66]. Future research should integrate these individualised metrics with spatial data to develop more comprehensive runnability models that account for both environmental features and runner-specific factors. Integrating temporal dimensions helps clarify runner–environment dynamics across different timescales. Our review found a notable increase in studies applying spatiotemporal analyses to examine the effects of the built environment on running behaviour [8, 44, 45, 50]. Runnability assessments have started incorporating temporal dimensions with varying analytical depth. While some studies document annual variations [44], others distinguish between weekday-weekend patterns or diurnal fluctuations [45, 50]. Particularly noteworthy are investigations of behavioural shifts during disruptive events like the COVID-19 pandemic [8, 57, 67], which reveal the dynamic nature of these associations. The field exhibits a methodological progression from descriptive temporal analyses (e.g., characterization of running patterns) [45, 49, 67] to explanatory approaches that examine how built environment effects vary across temporal contexts [44, 50]. This evolution highlights the need for dynamic assessment frameworks that systematically integrate short-term variations (e.g., diurnal patterns, weather-related fluctuations), medium-term patterns (e.g., seasonal changes, weekly changes), with long-term shifts (e.g., event-driven, life-course changes). Such temporal integration would advance runnability research beyond static models, enabling more responsive urban planning and policy interventions that account for the dynamic nature of running behaviours. Our review found that studies primarily operationalized greenspace using simplistic, aggregate metrics such as NDVI or area-based measures [14, 52, 68]. While these approaches capture the presence and visibility of vegetation, they overlook critical morphological qualities like configuration, distribution, and connectivity that fundamentally influence usability. This limitation may explain inconsistent findings in our synthesis, such as the negative elasticity for the GVI. The neglect of greenspace morphology is particularly problematic, as emerging evidence suggests that the shape, arrangement, and internal structure of green features (e.g., tree canopy connectivity, trail network design) are crucial determinants of runners’ route choices [8, 39]. For instance, uninterrupted linear green corridors may facilitate running continuity [17, 20], while clustered vegetation can offer perceptual variety and microclimate benefits [69]. Without accounting for these morphological factors, existing runnability assessments risk oversimplifying environmental quality, potentially leading to urban designs that prioritize green quantity over functional and experiential suitability for runners. Therefore, future research must move beyond aggregate measures to investigate how the greenspace morphology, including shape, connectivity, and internal features, affects its appeal for running. This will require integrating advanced geospatial techniques (e.g., LiDAR-derived 3D metrics, space syntax analysis) with participatory methods to develop metrics that more holistically reflect runners’ needs. The methodological evolution of this field, as revealed by our synthesis, shows a progression from foundational conventional regressions [16, 17] to GIS-enabled spatial analyses [20, 59]. However, the evidence base remains dominated by linear models, which are likely capturing only main effects and struggling to account for the complex, non-linear relationships emerging in the literature [9, 44, 56]. To better reflect the multifaceted nature of human-environment interactions, a paradigm shift towards advanced analytical techniques is necessary. Machine learning methods, such as random forest, XGBoost, and neural networks, are well-suited to capturing these intricate nonlinearities and interactions that traditional models overlook [56]. A primary obstacle to their adoption has been the “black-box” nature of these algorithms. This challenge can now be addressed through interpretable ML frameworks like SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) [50]. SHAP bridges the gap between predictive power and explanatory insight by providing both global feature importance and local, context-specific explanations, thereby disentangling complex associations [9]. Therefore, we recommend that future runnability studies prioritize the adoption of interpretable machine learning to move beyond static, linear modelling towards dynamic techniques that can more accurately capture the complexity of running behaviours. Stratified analyses reveal variations in running preferences across different population subgroups, highlighting the need for more tailored approaches to understanding built environment-runnability associations. Our review found that none of the examined studies incorporated stratified analyses based on demographic characteristics (e.g., age or gender). This limitation has obscured essential variations in how different population groups use urban spaces for running. For instance, older adults may prioritise features like smooth surfaces and proximity to green spaces, while gender-related safety concerns often influence route selection among female runners. Incorporating demographic stratification could provide deeper insights into diverse runner needs and support more inclusive urban design [70]. Implementing demographic-stratified analyses offers two key benefits: first, it uncovers subgroup-specific relationships between running behaviours and built environment features; second, it informs the design of more targeted and effective urban planning interventions. Future studies are encouraged to integrate demographic factors to enhance the inclusivity and relevance of runnability research. Expanding the geographical scope of studies helps reduce regional bias and enhances the generalizability of findings. Our review reveals a pronounced geographical bias in runnability research, with most empirical studies concentrated in China [8, 39, 42, 50]. While this reflects growing interest in this research domain, significant gaps remain in regions facing high environmental health risks, particularly across South and Southeast Asia, the Middle East, Africa, and South America. A more nuanced understanding of how built environments shape running behaviours across diverse global contexts is critical to inform equitable landscape and urban planning strategies, especially in rapidly urbanising areas experiencing dynamic land-use changes. Future research should prioritise broader geographical representation to strengthen the generalizability of findings and adopt open datasets and standardised methodologies to facilitate robust cross-context comparisons. Cross-platform analysis can improve the generalizability of findings and help mitigate platform-specific biases in runnability assessments. Relying solely on crowdsourced data from a single sports-tracking platform may limit the generalizability of runnability assessments, as such platforms often exhibit inherent demographic and behavioural biases [71]. For example, fitness application users tend to skew toward male, younger, and highly active athletes [33], potentially underrepresenting casual runners, female participants, or older age groups. Furthermore, platform-specific user bases may exhibit distinct recreational activity behaviours [72]. For example, a study conducted in Queensland, Australia, revealed that users of the adventure platform Wikiloc predominantly preferred remote parks with rugged terrain, better representing off-trail users’ behaviours than other platforms [73]. This preference leads to divergent spatial patterns in recorded running intensity across different platforms. Consequently, data from a single source may not accurately reflect the broader population’s usage of street segments, raising concerns about the reliability and representativeness of the findings [74, 75]. To address these limitations, cross-platform analysis is essential. Integrating multiple VGI sources can mitigate platform-specific biases, improve demographic coverage, and yield more robust insights into runnability across diverse user groups. Additionally, VGI datasets should be rigorously evaluated for spatial and demographic population-based representativeness [76], with explicit comparisons to population-level distributions. Advancing equity metrics in activity space analysis can be achieved by applying population-weighted methodologies, ensuring more representative and inclusive assessments of spatial accessibility and runnability. A key methodological limitation identified in the reviewed VGI-based studies is their failure to incorporate population-weighted approaches when assessing runnability [77]. Current analytical frameworks that disregard population density distributions risk generating biased estimates, as they cannot distinguish whether observed activity concentrations stem from genuinely running-supportive environments or merely reflect spatial artefacts of high residential density [28]. This methodological limitation undermines our capacity to accurately evaluate neighbourhood runnability, particularly in areas where population distribution and built environment quality are misaligned. Integrating population density into runnability indices would significantly improve the equity dimensions of activity space analysis, enabling more precise identification of areas requiring infrastructure improvements to promote physical activity. Strengths and limitations This review advances the literature in several ways. First, to our knowledge, this represents the first systematic review incorporating a meta-analysis to examine associations between running activity and built environment characteristics. Second, our work provides novel insights into applying physical activity-related VGI data, highlighting both opportunities and challenges in this emerging methodology. Third, we developed a comprehensive methodological framework that synthesizes and evaluates analytical approaches across VGI-based studies. This framework provides concrete recommendations for future research, including quantification methods for environmental attributes and running metrics, selection criteria for appropriate geographic units and buffer sizes, and guidance for determining suitable statistical modelling approaches. Several limitations should be acknowledged. First, this review is limited by its focus on crowdsourced GPS data, which excludes insights from surveys or participatory GIS that capture subjective experiences. More critically, the reliance on data from platforms like Strava and Keep introduces significant demographic bias, as they disproportionately represent younger, male, and more athletic users [33]. This underrepresentation of key groups (e.g., older adults, women, lower-income individuals), combined with a lack of stratified analyses in the primary studies, means our aggregated findings may mask important heterogeneity in how different subpopulations respond to built environmental features. Future research must therefore prioritize equitable sampling, conduct stratified analyses by demographics, and develop methods to correct for platform bias to generate universally applicable and equitable insights. Second, the methodological scope of this meta-analysis was constrained by the primary studies, which predominantly employed linear regression models. Consequently, our synthesis captures linear associations but may not reflect potential non-linear relationships between built environment features and jogging behaviour that could be identified using machine learning techniques. Third, our inclusion of GIS and spatial-related terms, which is less common in health literature, may have excluded relevant studies not using such terminology, potentially biasing results toward spatially focused research and underrepresenting broader health-related findings on running and the built environment. Another limitation is the heterogeneity in the measurement of built environment variables across studies (e.g., differing spatial units and buffer sizes). While our findings provide a valuable summary of effects across methodological approaches, future research would benefit from greater methodological standardization to enhance the comparability of results and strengthen evidence synthesis. Fourth, our focus on peer-reviewed journal articles may have omitted findings from grey literature. Finally, the English-language restriction may have introduced geographic bias by excluding potentially relevant studies published in other languages. Conclusions This systematic review highlights the transformative potential of VGI and geospatial analytics in understanding how built environments influence jogging behaviours. Our literature synthesis reveals that the field has grown substantially since 2019, driven by the availability of fitness trackers and analytical approaches. Key findings of our meta-analysis demonstrate that factors such as green and blue space density, floor area ratio, intersection density, and terrain slope play critical, yet sometimes contested, roles in shaping runners’ route preferences. Notably, while certain features (e.g., parks, water bodies) consistently promote runnability, others (e.g., slope, high-density urban areas) exhibit more nuanced relationships, reflecting diverse runner needs and preferences. The integration of VGI data offers opportunities for evidence-based urban planning and the creation of running-friendly cities. However, key challenges remain, including data biases, the lack of standardized metrics, and limited consideration of temporal dynamics. Future research should prioritize multi-city comparisons, longitudinal designs, and participatory approaches to support more inclusive and equitable urban environments. Appendix Supplementary Information Supplementary Material 1. Acknowledgements We thank the reviewers for the constructive comments that have enhanced the quality of the manuscript. Author contributions Dengkai Huang contributed to the conceptualization, methodology, data curation, and writing of the original draft. Wenjun Xu performed the formal analysis, visualization, and contributed to the writing of the original draft. Marco Helbich contributed to manuscript review, editing, and supervision. Xiaochun Yang contributed to manuscript review, editing, project administration, and supervision. Funding This study was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 52308069), the State Key Laboratory of Subtropical Building and Urban Science (No. 2024ZB16) and Shenzhen University 2035 Program for Excellent Research (NO: 2022B005). Data availability No datasets were generated or analysed during the current study. Declarations Clinical trial number Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1. Data Availability Statement No datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.