Patient satisfaction with infection prevention and control interventions in acute hospitals: a systematic review and meta-analysis Authors: Mairead Skally, Aoife Kearney, Judith Strawbridge, John Heritage, Cheryl Cox, Kathleen E Bennett, Hilary Humpreys, Fidelma Fitzpatrick Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractIntroductionInfection prevention and control (IPC) interventions are multifactorial and are used to prevent healthcare-associated infections in healthcare facilities. However, patient views and enabling patient and public involvement (PPI) in their development has been minimal.ObjectivesThis systematic review aims to identify peer-reviewed publications reporting patient satisfaction outcomes in the context of IPC interventions, to document the methods used to assess patient satisfaction and to conduct a meta-analysis on reported satisfaction outcomes.DesignSystematic review and meta-analysis following the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) methodology and the PRISMA statement, with oversight from a steering group including PPI partners. Studies in peer-reviewed journals were included based on eligibility criteria.Data sourcesMEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, CINAHL and PsycINFO were searched in June 2024.Eligibility criteriaIncluded studies investigated satisfaction among hospitalised patients in acute care settings following IPC measures, including isolation, cohorting, screening, hand hygiene, antimicrobial stewardship, patient flagging, education, personal protective equipment use, visiting restrictions and treatment delaysData extraction and synthesisTitles and abstracts were screened independently by two reviewers; disagreements were resolved by a third. Study quality was assessed using the JBI manual for evidence synthesis. A meta-analysis was conducted where four or more studies used comparable designs and methods within the same areas of IPC, with heterogeneity evaluated using Cochran’s Q statistic and I2 and pooled estimates calculated with 95% CIs using the Wilson (score) method.ResultsTwenty-nine studies were identified. Among IPC measures, isolation precautions were the most commonly reported intervention (11 studies, 38%). The Likert scale was the predominant assessment method (13 studies, 45%). Patient satisfaction with IPC interventions ranged from 58.3% to 97.2%. Meta-analysis of four studies using the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems survey showed substantial heterogeneity (I2, 55%, p=0.08) and a pooled patient satisfaction level of 69% (95% CI 63.6% to 74.4%) for isolation precautions.ConclusionSixty-nine percent of isolated patients reported satisfaction with their care. Patient satisfaction with IPC interventions varies widely, highlighting limitations in current measurement approaches. Strengthening PPI in the design and evaluation of satisfaction measures is essential to capture meaningful data and improvements in IPC programmes.PROSPERO registration numberIS 2024 CRD42024558385. STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS OF THIS STUDY This systematic review aims to evaluate and elucidate patient satisfaction in relation to infection prevention and control (IPC) interventions, considering it as a distinct indicator of healthcare quality; specifically, to assess the degree to which patient expectations are met and the methods used to measure and quantify satisfaction across studies. This systematic review aims to evaluate and elucidate patient satisfaction in relation to infection prevention and control (IPC) interventions, considering it as a distinct indicator of healthcare quality; specifically, to assess the degree to which patient expectations are met and the methods used to measure and quantify satisfaction across studies. The results demonstrate marked heterogeneity in both the types of IPC interventions reported and the methods used to measure patient satisfaction, while inadequate reporting of comparator groups limited the meta-analysis to pooled proportions within IPC cohorts. The results demonstrate marked heterogeneity in both the types of IPC interventions reported and the methods used to measure patient satisfaction, while inadequate reporting of comparator groups limited the meta-analysis to pooled proportions within IPC cohorts. The studies focused on meticillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and COVID-19, with no studies involving patients exposed to other common infections, such as Clostridioides difficile infection or norovirus. The studies focused on meticillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and COVID-19, with no studies involving patients exposed to other common infections, such as Clostridioides difficile infection or norovirus. This systematic review demonstrates the feasibility of using questionnaire-based surveys to assess whether patients’ expectations of their care were met and to highlight areas requiring improvement; however, a consensus on a standardised approach to measuring patient satisfaction in the context of IPC is needed. This systematic review demonstrates the feasibility of using questionnaire-based surveys to assess whether patients’ expectations of their care were met and to highlight areas requiring improvement; however, a consensus on a standardised approach to measuring patient satisfaction in the context of IPC is needed. Introduction Infection prevention and control (IPC) interventions in healthcare facilities aim to prevent healthcare-associated infections (HAIs) among patients and staff.13 IPC measures are multifactorial and include horizontal interventions like hand hygiene and respiratory etiquette and vertical measures like isolation precautions and patient cohorting. These interventions are widely recommended by national and international bodies,2 4 based mainly on scientific knowledge, with minimal patient and public involvement (PPI) in their development. PPI can support quality improvement of IPC services.5 PPI enables service-users to apply their priorities to healthcare evaluation, development, organisation and delivery.6 While the importance of PPI for IPC-related policy and guideline development is central to implementing local and global measures (eg, restricted movement during the COVID-19 pandemic),7 8 there remains no single strategy to indicate how best to engage and embed PPI. Systematic reviews in the area show low frequency of PPI reporting in patient safety research.9 10 Assessing whether patient expectations are met is key to capturing the patient voice. Two commonly used measures are ‘patient experience’ and ‘patient satisfaction’. Although often used interchangeably, they represent distinct concepts. Patient experience reflects patients’ views of care relative to their expectations, while patient satisfaction measures whether or not those expectations were met. Qualitative studies of patient experience may provide deeper insights into perceptions of care, whereas quantitative satisfaction measures provide ratings that allow for systematic synthesis where methods and measures are comparable. Patient satisfaction is crucial for health service quality.1114 As different services are offered within healthcare facilities, overall patient satisfaction and transaction-specific satisfaction (ie, with IPC services) should be differentiated.15 So, how satisfied are patients with IPC services? Previous systematic reviews have focused either on ‘patient satisfaction’ or on only one IPC measure. To date, no systematic review has addressed patient satisfaction with IPC interventions, whether assessed directly or as part of broader factors such as general hygiene.121618 As such, it is not known whether patients’ expectations of IPC measures are being met. This systematic review aimed to identify peer-reviewed publications reporting patient satisfaction outcomes in the context of implemented IPC interventions, whether satisfaction was the primary focus or one of several factors examined, to document the methods used to quantify patient satisfaction and to conduct a meta-analysis of reported satisfaction levels associated with specific IPC interventions where feasible. Methods The concept and design of this systematic review was overseen by a steering group that included PPI partners. This systematic review (PROSPERO protocol registration number: IS 2024 CRD42024558385) was conducted in accordance with the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) methodology for systematic reviews of aetiology and risk.19 The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis statement was followed.20 The full study protocol has been published previously.21 The only variation from the published protocol is the use of the appropriate JBI checklist for quality assessment due to diversity of included studies. Patient and public involvement Two PPI partners (JH and CC) were members of the project’s steering group. The study concept and design were developed under the guidance of this group. The steering group noted that while hospitals routinely collect patient-experience data, feedback specific to IPC interventions is rarely documented; this observation informed the review question. The PPI partners contributed throughout the study, including protocol development, methodological review and interpretation of findings. Eligibility criteria Studies in peer-reviewed journals meeting the search criteria were assessed for inclusion. A population, exposure, outcomes (PEO) framework was applied to guide study selection. The population of this review comprised hospitalised patients in acute care hospitals. Exposures included a range of IPC interventions, either as a broad category or specific strategies, such as isolation precautions, patient cohorting, screening for multidrug-resistant organisms (MDROs), hand hygiene, antimicrobial stewardship, MDRO patient flagging, IPC-related education and communication, the use of personal protective equipment (PPE) by staff, visitors or patients, restricted visitor policies and delays in transfer, discharge or procedures. The outcome of interest was patient satisfaction following exposure to IPC interventions, measured using self-administered surveys or interviews. Where available, comparator data (ie, either usual care without the specified IPC intervention(s) or alternative IPC strategies) were noted but were not a requirement for inclusion. No language or time restrictions were applied. Studies of non-admitted patients, patients aged <18 years or without a quantifiable measure of patient satisfaction were excluded. Case reports, case series, letters, editorials, meta-analyses, commentaries, review articles and conference abstracts were also excluded. Reference lists of systematic reviews identified during the literature search were searched for eligible studies. Search terms Search strategy information is provided in online supplemental material 1. Search strings focused on combining terms for ‘infection prevention and control’ and ‘patient satisfaction’ to ensure all results were captured. To account for the wide range of recommended IPC measures,2 4 search terms were intentionally kept broad and generic, for example, “isolation precautions”, “hand hygiene”, so as to exhaustively search the literature. Information sources Searches were conducted across a broad range of databases. MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature and PsycINFO databases were searched electronically in June 2024. Selection process Studies were imported to Rayyan Systematic Review software, and duplicates were removed.22 Titles and abstracts were screened and assessed for eligibility, as outlined above, independently by two reviewers, MS and AK. Studies reporting on patient satisfaction and general hygiene were assessed for eligibility as the cleanliness of the hospital environment is recognised as a key component of IPC in healthcare settings.2 4 Studies were eligible if they reported patient satisfaction in the context of implemented IPC interventions, or in relation to IPC-related outcomes (eg, surgical site infection (SSI)), given the direct association between these outcomes and IPC effectiveness. Conflicts were resolved by HH and final numbers of included studies displayed as per the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) format (table 1).20 Table 1Determining patient satisfaction among included studies based on how this was measured and reportedMeasurement scale/methodCriteria used in this review to determine patient satisfaction5-point Likert scaleScoring either 4 or 5 on 5-point scaleHospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems‘Top box’ scores, that is, responding ‘always’ or ‘yes’ when asked if they were satisfied with their careORScoring either 9 or 10 on 10-point Likert scaleOtherIf overall scores with a measure were presented, the number of patients was calculated by working backwards from the satisfaction calculation formula, where possible. These calculated fields are marked as such on the data extraction tables2 3. Determining patient satisfaction among included studies based on how this was measured and reported Table 2Summary of papers identified reporting patient satisfaction with infection prevention and control (IPC) measuresYear publishedNumber of studies (n=29)Number of studies by scale usedLikert scaleHCAHPSNot reportedOther pre-201041111 2010–201510451 2016–2020105221 2021–June 2024532Country/regionEuropean based France33 UK211 Germany11 Italy11 Spain11 USA1028 Pakistan211 China211 Iran22 Canada11 Ethiopia11 Hong Kong11 Singapore and Philippines11 Turkey11 IPC measures studied Isolation precautions113512 General hygiene85111 Surgical site infection321 COVID-19211 Intravascular devices22 Other321 Study design Case control3111 Case series211 Cohort5131 Cross sectional107111 Quasi experimental6231 RCT321 Mode of data capture Interview3111 Questionnaire171142 Survey927HCAHPS, Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems; RCT, randomised control trial. Summary of papers identified reporting patient satisfaction with infection prevention and control (IPC) measures HCAHPS, Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems; RCT, randomised control trial. Table 3Studies where infection prevention and control (IPC) measures and patient satisfaction were reported by IPC type, data collection method, scale and non-IPC cohortAuthorCountry/regionPeriodScale usedPoints on scaleDescription of points on scalePrimary outcome reported no. of satisfied patients/no. surveyed (%)Study designOverall quality of study Isolation precautions studies Chittick et al31USA01 January 2014–31 December 2014Likert51=disagree strongly, 5=agree stronglyOverall satisfaction: 206/249 (82%)Quasi-experimentalModerateGasink et al26USA07 August and 25 August 2006HCAHPSScale of 0–1011Overall satisfaction: median rating of 9 (IQR, 8–10)Cross-sectionalHighGaube et al34GermanyJune 2021–February 2022PPE15Dichotomous (0=no issue, 1=issue).15-item picker patient experienceOverall dissatisfaction: mean score 6.20, SD 4.08Case-controlHighGuilley-Lerondeau et al32FranceMarch–July 2012Likert4Very dissatisfied, dissatisfied, satisfied, very satisfiedOverall satisfaction: 25/30 (83.3%)CohortHighLau et al35Canada10 October 2013–2 November 2014Not reportedNot reportedNot reportedMean score for overall satisfaction: 8.39, SD 1.68CohortHighLivorsi et al27USA1 January 2012–31 May 2012 and 1 June 2012–31 March 2013HCAHPS0–10, where 0 is worst and 10 is best11Overall satisfaction: 44/68 (64.7%)Case-controlHighLupión-Mendoza et al33Spain2011–2012LikertNot reportedNot reportedOverall satisfaction with care received from professionals: 67/72 (93.1%)Case-controlHighMehrotra et al28USA11 January 2010–17 November 2010HCAHPSNot reportedNot reportedOverall satisfaction: 22/37 (58.3%)CohortHighRees et al36UKNot reportedNot reported11Not reportedMean score for overall satisfaction: 7.62, SD 2.06Case seriesHighSiddiqui et al29USAJuly 2011 and July 2016HCAHPSNot reportedNot reportedOverall satisfaction: 1302/1784 (73%)Quasi-experimentalHighVinski et al30USA1 January 2010 and 30 September 2010.HCAHPSScale of 1–1010Overall satisfaction:133/195 (68%)Quasi-experimentalHigh General hygiene studies Erden and Emirzeoglu37TurkeyJuly 2018–December 2019Likert51=never, 2=very poor, 3=poor, 4=often, 5=alwaysMean score for overall satisfaction: 3.25, SD 1.05Cross-sectionalHighFormal and Riddell44USA2011–2012HCAHPSNot reportedNot reportedOverall satisfaction 91%Quasi-experimentalHighHussain et al38PakistanDecember 2010–February 2012Likert51=disagree strongly, 5=agree stronglySatisfaction with general hygiene of ward: 453/710 (63.8%)Cross-sectionalHighLucadamo et al39ItalyFirst semester 2018Likert71=minimum level of satisfaction, 7=full satisfaction.Not reportedCross-sectionalHighTasneem et al43PakistanJune 2010Not reported3Satisfied, dissatisfied, undecidedSatisfaction with general cleanliness: 173/190 (91.1%)Cross-sectionalHighWoldeyohanes et al40Ethiopia08 May–02 June 2011Likert51 very satisfied to 5=very dissatisfiedOverall satisfaction: 117/189 (61.9%)Cross-sectionalHighWong et al42Hong KongJune–October 2010HKIEQ5Excellent/very good, good, fair, poor, very poorOverall satisfaction: 4029/5030 (80.1%)Cross-sectionalHighZiapour et al41IranJanuary–March 2014Likert51 for very bad responses, 5 for very goodThe patients’ total satisfaction with medical services was 3.49 out of 5.Cross-sectionalHigh Surgical site infection-related studies Boulet et al45FranceOctober 2018–January 2019Likert4Very satisfied/rather satisfied/rather dissatisfied/very dissatisfiedSatisfaction with preoperative shower process: 363/430 (84.4%)Cross-sectionalHighDay et al47USA2010–2011HCAHPSScale of 1–10Normalised to 100-point scaleOverall satisfaction score: 94.8, n=155†CohortHighMerle et al46FranceOctober/November 2005 and April–August 2006Likert4Very satisfied, rather satisfied, rather not satisfied and not at all satisfied useSatisfaction with information provided regarding SSI: 58/87 (67%)RCTHigh COVID-19 studies Farajzadeh et al48Iran2020Likert50=completely dissatisfied, to 4 completely satisfiedOverall satisfaction: 63/73 (86%)‡Cross-sectionalHighZeh et al49USA2 February–16 April 2020HCAHPSNot reportedNot reportedOverall satisfaction: 35/59 (66.0%)CohortHigh Intravascular device studies Prasad et al51Singapore & PhilippinesNovember 2018–February 2019Likert51 very dissatisfied, 5 very satisfiedOverall satisfaction with catheterisation: 471/544 (86.6%)§Quasi-experimentalModerateSun et al50ChinaJune 2017–May 2019Not reported3-point scale, study specificExcellent: >90%, good: 70%–89%, poor: <70%Overall satisfaction: 103/106 (97.2%)RCTHigh Other studies Bellamy52UK18-month period year not specifiedLikert5Not reportedSatisfaction with IPC measures used when caring for patients with MRSA: 36/46 (78.2%)¶Case seriesModerateSchulte et al53USANot reportedLikert51 representing ‘not satisfied at all’ and 5 representing ‘extremely satisfied’Satisfaction with intervention for smoking cessation: 13/17 (76.5%)¶RCTModerateLiu and Sun54ChinaApril 2016–2017Not reportedNot reportedNot reportedHand hygiene with the introduction of group: 57/60 (95.6%)Quasi-experimentalHigh*Calculated by averaging results across sites.†Scores were normalised to a 100-point scale.‡Translated version of paper used.§Domains surveyed: infection management, professionalism of staff, effectiveness of communication, physical comfort, pain management.¶Calculated using an average satisfaction score for ‘Satisfied’ and ‘Very satisfied’ categories and calculation the overall score by summing individual question scores.HCAHPS, Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and System; HKIEQ, Hong Kong Inpatient Experience Questionnaire; MRSA, Meticillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus; PPE15, Picker Patient Experience Questionnaire; RCT, randomised control trial; SSI, Surgical site infections. Studies where infection prevention and control (IPC) measures and patient satisfaction were reported by IPC type, data collection method, scale and non-IPC cohort Calculated by averaging results across sites. Scores were normalised to a 100-point scale. Translated version of paper used. Domains surveyed: infection management, professionalism of staff, effectiveness of communication, physical comfort, pain management. Calculated using an average satisfaction score for ‘Satisfied’ and ‘Very satisfied’ categories and calculation the overall score by summing individual question scores. HCAHPS, Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and System; HKIEQ, Hong Kong Inpatient Experience Questionnaire; MRSA, Meticillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus; PPE15, Picker Patient Experience Questionnaire; RCT, randomised control trial; SSI, Surgical site infections. Data extraction MS completed full-text review and data extraction of studies meeting inclusion criteria. AK completed this process in duplicate for 20% of included studies. Discrepancies were resolved through discussion, with arbitration by a third reviewer (HH) if needed. No a priori discrepancy threshold was set as this process served as a quality check to ensure consistency prior to single data extraction. Data were extracted into a Microsoft Excel file and included title, authors, year, journal, study design, intervention, data capture method and reported satisfaction scores. Numbers of satisfied patients in both IPC and non-IPC cohorts were extracted, where possible. Risk of bias in individual studies The study design of each study was determined and a critical appraisal of the paper performed by MS using the appropriate JBI checklist according to their manual for evidence synthesis.23 AK completed this process in duplicate for the 20% of included studies. All included studies, regardless of methodological quality assessment, underwent data extraction. Data synthesis Study characteristics were summarised by author, year, country, number of facilities included and study period. Outcome variables extracted included: patient groups observed, design of method and scale used to measure satisfaction, satisfaction criteria, primary outcome reported, number of IPC patients included and the proportion meeting satisfaction criteria. For each study, the number of satisfied patients was extracted according to authors’ specified definitions and thresholds with no additional reclassification applied. The number of patients in non-IPC comparator groups, if reported, as well as the number of those who were satisfied, the study design and the overall quality of study were also extracted. Due to inconsistent reporting of comparator data across studies, a quantitative synthesis of absolute or relative differences between IPC and non-IPC cohorts was not feasible. For studies where comparator data were available, the results have been presented within the main dataset. Statistical analysis A random effects meta-analysis of pooled proportions was conducted where four or more studies used comparable designs and measurement methods within the same areas of IPC. Proportions were pooled using Stata’s meta routine, using untransformed proportions,24 and a random effects model applied using Restricted Maximum Likelihood. Cochran’s Q statistic and I2 were used for heterogeneity. A p value <0.10 for the Cochran’s Q test or I 2>50% indicate heterogeneity between studies.25 All analyses were performed using Stata V.18.5. Results The literature search conducted in June 2024 identified 18 361 publications (figure 1). Following duplicate removal (n=5233), abstract/title screening (n=13 128), assessment of full-text eligibility (n=41) and a search of citations, 29 studies were included. Defining ‘satisfied’ was dependent on the data collection method used by the authors and is shown in table 1. Study designs included case-control (n=3), case series (n=2), cohort (n=5), cross-sectional (n=10), quasi-experimental (n=6) and randomised control trials (n=3). Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis flow diagram of included studies. Records identified, screened and excluded are shown at each stage. Isolation precautions were the most common IPC measure reported (n=11/29, 38%) followed by general hygiene (n=8/29; 28%) and SSI prevention (n=3/29, 10%). The Likert scale was the most reported assessment method (n=13/29) (table 2). Most studies from the USA reported findings from the country’s national Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and System (HCAHPS) survey (n=8/29). Table 3 provides an overview of each study. Full details are provided in online supplemental material 2. Risk of bias and overall quality of evidence Study design was determined and the appropriate JBI checklist completed for each study. Individual study checklists are provided in online supplemental material 3. Most of the included studies were considered high quality (n=25, 86%) (table 2). Those of moderate quality (n=4, 14%) reported information relevant to the subject area and were included to ensure representation of a comprehensive overview of the literature landscape. Isolation precautions Eleven studies (published 2000–2023) reported satisfaction with isolation precautions, 10 high quality and one moderate. Most (n=8/11) reported overall hospital satisfaction among isolated patients, while three examined specific populations or satisfaction domains. Five studies (sample sizes ranging 37–1748) used the HACHPS survey method.2630 Gasink et al performed a cross-sectional study in a 1070-bedded tertiary care centre, reporting a median of nine (IQR: 8–10) for isolated versus eight (IQR 7–10) among non-isolated patients.26 The other four studies using the HCAHPS method reported ‘top box’ responses among isolated patients (range 58.3–73%).2730 The lowest ‘top box’ proportion (58.3%; vs 70% among non-isolated patients) was reported by Mehrotra et al28 and the highest 68% among versus 74% for 7806 non-isolated patients by Vinski et al. A random-effects meta-analysis of pooled proportions of these four studies showed some heterogeneity (l2=55.7%, p=0.08).2730 The pooled level of patient satisfaction of patients under isolation precautions was 0.69 (95% CI 0.64 to 0.74), indicating 31% of individuals under isolation precautions were not satisfied with their care (figure 2). Forest plot of proportions of satisfied patients undergoing isolation precautions. Each row represents one study in the meta-analysis, with proportion of satisfied patients under isolation precautions (box) plotted with 95% CI (horizontal line). The diamond represents the pooled proportion of satisfied patients under isolation and estimated 95% CI. Three studies conducted in the USA, France and Spain reported on the satisfaction of isolated patients using the Likert scale.3133 Chittick et al (moderate quality) reported 82% overall hospital satisfaction using the Likert scale noting HCAHPS was unsuitable as it is ‘retrospective’ with limited scope.31 Guilley-Lerondeau et al (high quality) found 83.3% satisfaction in isolated patients versus 100% in non-isolated patients using a four-point scale.32 Lupión-Mendoza et al (high quality) reported 93.1% satisfaction with ‘care received from professionals’ in Spain, though overall satisfaction of the hospital and scale details were not provided.33 Gaube et al (high quality) evaluated patient dissatisfaction associated with isolation precautions using the Picker Patient Experience Questionnaire.34 This employs a dichotomous scoring method to generate a ‘problem score’, where responses are coded as either 0 or 1 and subsequently summed. The higher the score, the greater the patient dissatisfaction. Among isolated patients (n=118) the mean problem score was 6.20 (SD 4.08), compared with a mean score of 4.85 (SD 3.11) reported by non-isolated patients. Two studies did not specify data collection methods.35 36 Rees et al (high quality) reported a mean satisfaction score of 7.62 (SD 2.06) on a 0–10 scale among isolated patients, with no control group. Lau et al (high quality) reported mean discharge satisfaction scores of 8.39 (SD 1.68) for isolated patients and 8.50 (SD 1.87) for non-isolated patients. No details on scales used were given.35 General hygiene Eight high-quality studies (published 2010–2020) reported patient satisfaction with general hospital hygiene as part of overall experience. Five studies from Ethiopia, Pakistan, Iran, Turkey and Italy used Likert scales.3741 Four studies used five point scales. Woldeyohanes et al reported 76.8% satisfaction with ward hygiene,40 Hussain et al reported general hygiene at 63.8% with general hygiene.38 Ziapour et al reported mean satisfaction with general hygiene 3.26/5 (SD not reported)41 and Erden and Emirzeoglu reported mean satisfaction for room cleanliness of 3.58 (SD 0.78).37 Lucadamo et al used a seven-point scale to construct a statistical model for evaluating patient satisfaction,39 but no comparable data were extractable. Wong et al found 98.6% of patients reported the hospital as ‘very clean’ or ‘fairly clean’ using the Hong Kong Inpatient Experience Questionnaire, a five-point scale’42 . Tasneem et al found 91.3% of patients satisfied overall with the general cleanliness of the hospital.43 Hussain et al, using a Likert scale, found 63.8% were satisfied with ward hygiene.38 Fornwalt and Riddell used HCAHPS data to assess changes in patient satisfaction with general hygiene after introducing ultraviolet environmental cleaning.44 Satisfaction increased from 79.6% to 91%; however, no denominator data were provided. Surgical site infection prevention Three studies, of high quality, reported patient satisfaction with SSI, two on prevention45 46 and one with postoperative infection care.47 Both studies investigating SSI prevention used a four-point scale. Merle et al found satisfaction with information received about SSI prevention with leaflets was 66.7% compared with 43% without leaflets.46 Boulet et al found patient satisfaction with preoperative showers45 to be 84.4%. Neither study reported results from a comparator group. Day et al, using HCAHPS data and scores that were normalised to a 100-point scale, reported a satisfaction score of 94.8 among patients with an SSI, compared with 94.0 of patients without an SSI.47 COVID-19 Two high-quality studies conducted in 2020 reported patient satisfaction with the hospitals’ overall COVID-19 measures.48 49 Farajzadeh et al used a five-point Likert scale to report satisfaction of 86% among COVID-19 patients post discharge.48 Zeh et al compared the satisfaction of surgical patients with and without visitor restrictions, during the initial period of the COVID-19 pandemic.49 Fewer patients reported ‘complete satisfaction’ (66%) in the restricted visiting group, compared with 80.7% without restrictions. Intravascular device infection prevention Two studies investigated the satisfaction of patients with intravascular devices (IVDs). Sun et al (high quality) evaluated the impact of care bundles for preventing central venous catheter-associated infections on patient satisfaction.50 No data collection method was described. Satisfaction of patients with the bundles was 97.2% compared with 85.8% of patients without the bundle. Omkar Prasad et al (moderate quality) used a five-point Likert scale to examine vascular access management and patient satisfaction with infection management, professionalism of healthcare workers, communication, physical comfort and pain management,51 with 86.6% of patients ‘satisfied’ with the different domains. Other studies There were three additional studies identified covering elements of IPC not already discussed.5254 Each reported on patient satisfaction with a specific area of IPC, and none of the three reported on overall hospital satisfaction. The study by Bellamy et al (moderate quality) investigated patients with methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) satisfaction with service and treatment of 78.2% using a five-point Likert scale.52 Satisfaction for patients receiving usual care was not reported. Schulte et al (moderate quality) studied patient satisfaction using a five-point Likert scale with a smoking cessation initiative, noting that smoking increases HAI risk.53 Satisfaction with the intervention was 76.5%. Liu and Sun (high quality) introduced group nursing as an intervention to improve hand hygiene.54 How satisfaction was measured was not reported. Of patients with group nursing, satisfaction was 95.6% compared to 83.8% without. Discussion This systematic review identified 29 studies reporting patient satisfaction outcomes in the context of IPC interventions. The findings revealed considerable heterogeneity, both in the types of IPC interventions studied and in the methodologies used to assess satisfaction, including survey instruments and rating scales used. Meta-analysis was possible for only four studies that used the HCAHPS survey to assess patients’ views during isolation. These studies reported a satisfaction level of 69% among isolated patients. Key performance indicators (KPIs) are metrics accepted as an international standard for performance monitoring and benchmarking of healthcare facilities by national agencies. KPIs are important for effective management and the prevention of HAI and for identification of areas for improvement.55 While such measures are crude, they are consistent and routinely interrogated.56 There are several studies reporting on the patient experience and their views on HAI.5759 As this is a subjective measure, these studies are limited in terms of scale and scope. Patient satisfaction offers a more systematic, metric type approach to capturing patient feedback. However, the findings of this review show disparity even when the same measurement methods have been used, that is, Likert scale (ranging 4–7 points) and HCAHPS (reported differently). While most studies used HCAHPS, limitations were noted including the retrospective nature of such surveys as well as subject material being nonspecific to IPC. Our findings highlight that many studies relied on generic patient satisfaction tools that may not adequately capture perceptions of IPC-specific practices. There is a need to develop tailored tools that include domains such as hand hygiene, isolation procedures and communication regarding infection risk. Ideally, these tools should be co-designed with patients and members of the public to ensure greater relevance and responsiveness to their concerns. Greater standardisation of IPC-specific satisfaction measures would also facilitate comparability across studies and healthcare settings. Additionally, the review highlights the importance of PPI in the development of tailored tools to measure patient satisfaction with IPC interventions. Future surveys should be designed with meaningful input from patients to ensure that the data captured reflects their experiences and priorities, thereby enabling actionable conclusions. Future studies should focus on issues that concern patients, and not only on those perceived important by IPC teams. Some studies may need to address general IPC concerns, for example, hospital hygiene, hand hygiene and PPE use. However, others should target specific issues, infections or settings, such as SSI, CDI and care in oncology/haematology units. The quality of the included studies was mostly high (86%). While the presence of moderate/low-quality studies introduces potential risk of bias in results and findings, this did not affect the findings of the meta-analysis, as these studies were excluded from the pooled analyses. As most studies reported only crude satisfaction estimates of patients’ satisfaction, direct comparisons between isolated and non-isolated patient groups were not conducted. Any such comparative analysis would need adjustment for potential confounders such as illness severity, length of hospital stay and other relevant clinical factors. Isolation precautions, the focus of most of the studies included, are widely recommended for the prevention of HAI and used in conjunction with standard precautions.60 Though widely used, it has been reported that isolation has negative consequences for segregated patients, including increased anxiety and psychological suffering.61 It is therefore unsurprising that isolation precautions are the most studied element of IPC and patient satisfaction. Meta-analysis of four studies with suitable findings showed that while 69% of patients being isolated were satisfied with their hospital stay, 31% of patients’ expectations with IPC interventions were not met. Patient satisfaction with hospital inpatient care is typically assessed using standardised national surveys, with satisfaction targets for positive overall ratings often set at or above 80%. For example, Ireland’s 2024 national inpatient survey reported that 85% of respondents rated their experience as ‘good’ or ‘very good,’ consistent with international benchmarks.62 Likewise, top-performing hospitals in the USA consistently achieve patient satisfaction rates in the 80–85% range as measured by the HCAHPS survey.63 General hygiene was the second-most identified area of IPC and patient satisfaction. Though general hygiene is a core principle of good IPC, most of the included studies did not evaluate it in an IPC context. Instead, these studies were generic patient satisfaction type studies, where general hygiene was reported as a subtheme of overall care. Such an approach may bias patients’ views. Patient responses are influenced by context and question framing. The same individual may respond differently to a ‘hospital hygiene’ item in a general experience survey compared with an IPC-specific survey administered during isolation, potentially altering satisfaction estimates independent of actual experience. The healthcare environment is dynamic and complex, especially for patients on their healthcare journey, with numerous interactions across many disciplines. A systems approach in healthcare research involves understanding and improving the complex interactions within healthcare systems to enhance patient outcomes, efficiency, and overall health. It takes a more holistic perspective of the complexity of social processes in the healthcare environment, enabling the study of different system components and their relationships within a wider environment.64 Given the breadth and diversity of IPC measures, a systems approach may be useful when developing methods for measuring patient satisfaction and IPC intervention. Several included studies assessed patient satisfaction in the context of SSI prevention. While SSI represents an outcome rather than a direct IPC intervention, it is a core endpoint of IPC programmes and hence provides indirect insight into patient perceptions of IPC effectiveness, though the findings should be interpreted within this context. The review also found limited reporting on specific topics such as SSI, hand hygiene and IVD care. Despite the recent COVID-19 pandemic, only two studies reported patient satisfaction in that context. The pathogens specifically studied were limited to MRSA and COVID-19. No studies investigated patient experiences of other common causes of acute illness, such as Clostridioides difficile or norovirus. Strengths of this study include the use of a rigorous methodology, adherence to the JBI and PRISMA guidelines and a thorough critical appraisal of included studies. To minimise the risk of missing relevant publications, broad search terms were applied across multiple databases without language restrictions. However, as data extraction and risk of bias assessment were not conducted in full duplicate for all studies, a small potential for error or bias should be considered when interpreting the findings. Additionally, the scope of meta-analysis was limited by the heterogeneity in both IPC interventions reported and patient satisfaction measurement methods. Most studies did not report satisfaction outcomes for non-IPC comparator groups in a manner that allowed for the calculation of absolute or relative differences. As a result, the analysis focused on pooled satisfaction proportions within IPC cohorts rather than comparative effect estimates. The overall quality of 14% of studies was rated as moderate; however, these results were excluded from pooled analysis. Further research should be extended to include the perspectives of children and carers to provide a more comprehensive understanding and overview of patients experience across diverse populations and healthcare settings. Surveys are the most feasible, practical method of assessing patient satisfaction. While questionnaire surveys lack detail compared with qualitatively assessing patient experience, they provide a consistent method of data capture from large numbers of patients and allow for systematic synthesis of findings where methods and measures are comparable. This empowers patients to provide an assessment of the care they received and highlight areas requiring improvement. This systematic review is the first to comprehensively examine patient satisfaction with IPC interventions in hospital settings, providing valuable insights for clinicians, healthcare management and policymakers, particularly when 31% of IPC patients were not satisfied with their hospital stay. Greater involvement of patients and the public is increasingly recognised as essential in the prevention and control of HAIs.65 Enhancing patient engagement will help inform and improve IPC programmes. Studies on patient satisfaction can provide important insights into the patient experience and whether IPC interventions align with their expectations. Our findings suggest that greater PPI could improve patient experience with IPC. Potential approaches include co-developing IPC-specific satisfaction instruments with patients and the public; involving patients in the design of IPC-related educational materials and communication strategies related to IPC measures and including patient representatives in IPC committees or quality improvement initiatives. Such interventions could ensure that patient perspectives are embedded into IPC practices, and those institutional priorities are more closely aligned with patient concerns. Conclusion This review shows that measuring patient satisfaction with IPC intervention is possible and increasingly relevant. Despite the associated complexities of IPC, often involving multicomponent approaches and diverse HAI-specific pathways, several studies attempted to assess patient experience in this context. Our findings show that suitable data collection methods are available. The meta-analysis showed that 31% of patients receiving IPC interventions were dissatisfied with their hospital experience, indicating room for improvement in service provision. These findings highlight the need for greater engagement with PPI groups and the development of patient-centred research and guidelines to inform future IPC practice. Establishing consensus on appropriate measurement tools and priority areas is essential to capture meaningful data and improve the quality and acceptability of IPC interventions. Supplementary material