RBA4SDS – Risk–benefit assessment for sustainable dietary shifts Authors: European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), Martina Pavlić, Géraldine Boué Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractDiets are evolving to cope with the ecological transition and reduce the environmental impact of agri‐food systems. The alternatives currently available will influence the nutritional content of diets and will also change consumers' exposure to microbiological and chemical hazards. Health impacts need to be considered to suggest safe, nutritious and sustainable alternatives. Quantifying this overall health impact is now possible using methods of food risk–benefit assessment (RBA), a recognised and well‐established approach that integrates scientific knowledge on nutrition, toxicology, microbiology and human epidemiology. The Risk–Benefit Assessment for Sustainable Dietary Shift (RBA4SDS) project aimed to train a fellow to analyse the overall health impacts of dietary transitions towards more climate‐friendly diets. This included performing RBA and applying the necessary quantitative tools to evaluate nutritional, microbiological and toxicological risks and benefits. The present project focused on a practical case considering the substitution of meat by insects and plant‐based alternatives including lentil and red kidney bean for Croatia, France and Greece. As part of the programme, the fellow was involved in the following activities: (i) understanding key steps of food health RBA, with a focus on nutrition, microbiology and toxicology; (ii) defining and characterising various sustainable diet alternatives, including meat, insect‐based and plant‐based options; (iii) identifying available and missing data inputs needed for RBA of selected alternative scenarios; (iv) applying RBA methods to assess a chosen alternative scenarios; (v) identifying strategies for further development of RBA methodologies. Within the research group, multi‐criteria decision analysis (MCDA) tool was used to rank sustainable options for alternative scenarios. The project enabled the fellow to define different sustainable food alternatives and to identify both available and missing inputs required to perform RBA and to suggest strategies to develop further RBA methodology.Keywords: alternative proteins, beef meat, food safety, lentil, public health impact, red kidney bean SUMMARY RBA aims to assess beneficial and adverse health impacts associated with the consumption of foods, food ingredients or diets. It is now a recognised and well‐established approach that integrates scientific knowledge on nutrition, toxicology, microbiology and human epidemiology. RBA is used to inform food safety policies or to provide dietary advice based on the available scientific knowledge and to prevent food‐associated diseases. Significant progress has been made with more than 200 RBAs already performed, demonstrating its feasibility and added value. EFSA has established the basis of the risk–benefit assessment (RBA) method with a guidance published in 2006 and 2010 that was recently revised (2024). EU‐FORA Programme has been hosted by the mixed unit INRAE‐ONIRIS, named Secalim, located in Nantes, France under the supervision of Prof. Géraldine Boué, awarded by EFSA to the Croatian Agency for Agriculture and Food in Croatia as sending institution. The present work programme aimed to train a fellow to analyse the overall health impact related to dietary transition towards more climate‐friendly diets by performing RBA of sustainable dietary shifts and the associated tools needed to assess the risks and the benefits in a quantitative way, related to nutrition, microbiology and toxicology. Main objectives of this programme were: (i) understanding key steps in food health RBA, with a focus on nutrition, microbiology and toxicology; (ii) defining and characterising potential sustainable diet alternatives, including meat, insect‐based and plant‐based options; (iii) identifying available and missing data inputs needed for RBA of selected alternative scenarios; (iv) applying RBA methods to assess a chosen alternative scenarios; (v) proposing strategies for further development of RBA methodologies. The RBA case study in this work extended the model developed through the EFSA‐supported NovRBA project (Novel foods as red meat replacers – an insight using RBA methods)that was developed to estimate health impacts of substituting beef meat by insects powder in burgers, linked to seven nutrients, six microorganisms and one chemical. This new version includes two plant‐based alternatives, lentil and red kidney bean, for Croatia, France and Greece. Methodologies employed in this research included extensive data search and management, development of ranking tool for sustainable plant‐based alternatives, definition of the input variables and considering sources of variability and uncertainty. The fellow became autonomous in using databases to perform RBA on dietary transition towards more climate‐friendly diets. This programme helped to better understand the challenges involved in expanding and adapting the existing model for application across additional countries, exposure scenarios and components within the RBA framework. INTRODUCTION Concerns over carbon footprint and animal welfare have heightened awareness of the environmental impact of red meat production, intensifying debates in Western countries about reducing red meat consumption. Research has also highlighted public health risks associated with red meat consumption, particularly its processed forms, linked to an increased prevalence of chronic diseases such as type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular diseases and colorectal cancer. Consequently, reducing red meat intake, particularly processed varieties, is considered a key step in public health strategies to lower the incidence of these diseases. However, it remains essential to evaluate health implications of alternative protein sources in order to avoid merely shifting the problem elsewhere. Background and Terms of Reference as provided by the requestor Secalim is recognised in the field of RBA at the international level and participated in 3 projects founded by EFSA over the past years: RISKBENEFIT4EU (Alvito et al., 2019), NovRBA (Naska et al., 2022) and ALTERNATIVA (Assunção et al., 2024). RBA and multicriteria analysis are highly connected to risk assessment but integrate other scientific domains. In this topic 2 PhD theses were supervised, one devoted to the risk–benefit evaluation associated with the consumption of infant milk in the first 6 months of children's life, and the second one, on the risk–benefit evaluation associated with consumption of red meat. The nominated supervisor has 9 years of experience in food public health RBA and has contributed to all three RBA‐related projects at Secalim. Under the NovRBA project (Novel foods as red meat replacers – an insight using RBA methods) in 2019–2022, partnering grant funded by EFSA a RBA model was created associated with the substitution of red beef by Acheta domesticus insect‐based powder in ground beef. Methodological framework for the harmonised identification, ranking and selection of nutritional, microbiological and toxicological components in RBA was developed. Calculations in NovRBA project were performed for adult population scenarios in Greece, France and Denmark. DATA AND METHODOLOGIES Data Consumption data for minced beef patties were taken from national dietary surveys. The existing model already included French (ANSES, Agence nationale de sécurité sanitaire de l’alimentation, de l’environnement et du travail (France), 2017) and Greek surveys (Magriplis et al., 2019), while the Croatian data (Sokolić et al., 2024) were newly incorporated into the model. Environmental impact scores were obtained from the French Agribalyse LCI database (eng. Life Cycle Inventory) (Colomb et al., 2015) and Nutri‐Score (Scientific Committee of the Nutri‐Score, 2022) was calculated for food items listed in the Ciqual database (ANSES, 2024). For plant‐based alternatives, toxicological data came from chemical monitoring, while no additional microbiological hazards were included due to absence of data. Data for Acheta domesticus were based on a systematic review (Ververis et al., 2022). Estimates of foodborne illness were sourced from the World Health Organization's Global Burden of Disease (GBD) data for Toxoplasma gondii and Salmonella spp., and from French national data for Clostridium perfringens. Dose–response data for nutrition, toxicology, microbiology were obtained from the NovRBA project (Naska et al., 2022; Ververis et al., 2024). Incidences and Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALY) per rate for diseases, as well as population numbers were retrieved from GBD Study for year 2021 (Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, 2021) using country‐specific data when available. Methodologies Food alternative scenarios to support sustainable dietary shifts were defined by ranking potential plant‐based alternatives based on both nutritional quality (Nutri‐Score) and environmental impact (Single Score EF 3.1) using Ciqual and Agribalyse databases. Multi‐criteria decision analysis tool (MCDA) was used to calculate a composite Nutri‐Eco ranking index. The methodology for component selection, including nutrients, microbial and toxicological hazards, is described in (Boué et al., 2022). Dose–response models for nutritional components and inorganic arsenic (iAs) were included in NovRBA model, while cadmium (Cd) was assessed as additional toxicological component. For nutrient composition, Ciqual food composition database (ANSES, 2024) was used. For microbiological hazards in patties made from cricket powder a bottom‐up approach was applied, using exposure assessment and microbial risk modelling with a threshold model for Bacillus cereus and an exponential dose–response for C. perfringens, described in (Ververis et al., 2024). The RBA methodology followed key steps illustrated in Figure 1 (EFSA Scientific Committee, 2010, 2024). The RBA model employed a probabilistic approach using @Risk® add‐in software version 8.1 (Palisade Corporation, Ithaca, NY, USA) with Monte Carlo simulations considering variability and uncertainty. Health impacts of each alternative scenario were quantified using DALYs, a standard metric in food RBA representing years of healthy life lost. Risk–benefit assessment framework (EFSA Scientific Committee, 2024). The model chosen for training and further development was on the one created by the NovRBA project, which addressed net health impact of partially or totally substituting the beef in burger patties with cricket powder in the adults of Denmark, France and Greece. Computational activities Different data processing strategies were applied throughout the implementation of the work programme. The first approach involved the use of Excel and @Risk, as developed in the NovRBA project, for conducting exposure assessments and DALY calculations. In parallel, a second approach was undertaken using R software, which included an additional toxicological component and code custom‐written by Technical University of Denmark (Thomsen et al., 2022). This phase involved gaining familiarity with various computational models related to Cd exposure. Strategies were selected and applied based on the specific objectives and requirements of the research. Secondary scientific outcomes Conferences: Alternative Proteins for Food and Feed International Conference, 03–05 December 2024, Berlin, BfR – online participation Alternative Proteins for Food and Feed International Conference, 03–05 December 2024, Berlin, BfR – online participation 1st International Congress on Sustainable Food, Green Chemistry and Human Nutrition, 6–9 April 2025, Dubrovnik – lecture Evaluating the public health impact of plant based alternatives: a risk – benefit assessment to guide the protein transition 1st International Congress on Sustainable Food, Green Chemistry and Human Nutrition, 6–9 April 2025, Dubrovnik – lecture Evaluating the public health impact of plant based alternatives: a risk – benefit assessment to guide the protein transition 14th International Food Data Conference (IFDC), 1–3 September 2025, FAO Headquarters, Rome, Italy – lecture Integrating food composition and environmental impact data: identifying and ranking sustainable food choices for risk–benefit assessment 14th International Food Data Conference (IFDC), 1–3 September 2025, FAO Headquarters, Rome, Italy – lecture Integrating food composition and environmental impact data: identifying and ranking sustainable food choices for risk–benefit assessment Knowledge acquisition and exchange: The fellow was involved in multiple activities at the hosting organisation, enrolling in modules of the Master 2 One Health Ermerge at Oniris and including attending presentations of PhD students and working group meetings. The fellow also held a presentation regarding EU‐Fora project activities at Secalim Info Science meeting. At 17th Food Consumption Data Network Meeting fellow held a presentation with title Risk–Benefit Assessment for sustainable dietary shift: Evaluating the public health impact of plant‐based alternatives. Publications: The fellow plans to submit two publications to international scientific journals to communicate results and methodologies developed. ASSESSMENT Definition of the RBA scenario and formulation of the question Ranking of food items from Ciqual database showed promising substitutes for beef burger patty with priority given to red kidney bean‐based or green lentil‐based burger patty. To explore alternatives to red meat, four scenarios were proposed: a reference scenario (current beef consumption), an insect‐based patty (from NovRBA) and two plant‐based alternatives (Table 1). Final RBA question was defined as ‘What would be the net health impact of totally substituting the beef in burger patties with cricket powder or red kidney bean or green lentil in the adult populations of France, Greece and Croatia?’ TABLE 1Patty ingredients for each scenario.IngredientsAmount (%)Reference a A b B c C d Minced beef 90 Other ingredients 10101010 Insect powder 18 Lentil, green, boiled/cooked in water 90 Red kidney beans, boiled/cooked in water 90 Water 72 a Beef. b Lentil, green cooked. c Red kidney beans, cooked. d Acheta Domesticus insect powder. Patty ingredients for each scenario. Beef. Lentil, green cooked. Red kidney beans, cooked. Acheta Domesticus insect powder. Selection of model components and related health outcomes Methodological framework for the harmonised identification, ranking and selection of nutritional, microbiological and toxicological components in RBA developed in NovRBA was used to select model components for new scenarios (Boué et al., 2022). Each food component was ranked and selected based on its prevalence, the severity of related health outcomes, and the availability and reliability of supporting data. Final list of components included in current study is presented in Table 2. TABLE 2Final list of components included in RBA model.DomainComponentsMinced beefLentil, green, cooked in waterRed kidney beans, cooked in waterInsect powder Nutrition Calcium XXX Fibre XXX Iron XXX Magnesium XXX Selenium XXX Sodium XXX Vitamin B12 XX Zinc XXX Microbiology Toxoplasma gondii X Salmonella spp.X Bacillus cereus X Clostridium perfringens X Toxicology iAs XXXX Final list of components included in RBA model. Exposure assessment Exposure assessment was done with Monte Carlo simulations to account for variability in concentration of components as well as patty intake by different countries. Cumulative distribution of current intake of beef patties is depicted in Appendix A (Figure A1). Risks and benefits characterisation Health risks and benefits of food substitution were assessed by combining exposure data with dose–response models across nutrition, toxicology and microbiology. Disease cases were estimated using relative risks, potential impact fractions and national consumption data. A top‐down approach used existing disease data and attribution estimates (nutrition and toxicology domain), while a bottom‐up approach relied on exposure levels and dose–response models (microbiology domain). The impact of Cd as toxicological component could not be observed, as the threshold for an adverse outcome estimation was set at 1.0 μg/g creatinine, while substitution a single food source results in urinary cadmium levels below this threshold. Scenario comparison in DALYs The net public health impact of replacing beef burger patty with low‐environmental impact foods such as lentil, red kidney bean or insect powder patties was estimated in DALYs. Shifting from the reference scenario to any alternative one results in notable changes in the intake of the components present in the analysed scenarios. For instance, alternative scenarios led to increased fibre intake, which is associated with a reduced risk of various cancers and cardiovascular diseases (ΔDALY < 0). In contrast, a reduction of iron intake is expected across all alternative scenarios leading to increased risk of oesophageal cancer (ΔDALY > 0). The analysis showed that the most impactful domain in terms of shaping the overall health impact is the one of nutrition (Figure 2). Change in disability adjusted life years (DALYs) across seven nutritional components when switching from the reference to alternative scenarios in three countries. CONCLUSION Replacing beef burger patties with plant‐based alternatives reflects a broader shift towards more sustainable diets. RBA supports this transition by evaluating nutritional and food safety trade‐offs, providing evidence‐based insights for consumers and policymakers. According to this research, if beef in burger patties was fully substituted with insect powder or plant‐based alternatives (red kidney bean or lentil) DALYs will be saved in all countries under consideration. This research involved structured data management, the development of a ranking tool for assessing plant‐based alternatives and the definition of key input variables, incorporating sources of variability and uncertainty. The fellow gained practical skills in using databases to conduct RBAs related to dietary shift. The project also explored methodological challenges in adapting and scaling the existing RBA model to different countries, exposure scenarios and food components. As part of the EU‐FORA programme, the fellow received comprehensive training. Training consisted of an EFSA‐led induction course, four modules and practical work in RBA at the host institution, including modelling incorporating Monte Carlo simulations and DALY calculations. This food substitution case study contributed to a broader RBA framework and supported continued collaboration among participating institutions, fellows and the EU‐FORA network. ABBREVIATIONS cadmium disability adjusted life years Global Burden of Disease Study inorganic arsenic French Agribalyse database Life Cycle Inventory multi‐criteria decision analysis risk–benefit assessment Risk–Benefit Assessment for Sustainable Dietary Shift COPYRIGHT FOR NON‐EFSA CONTENT EFSA may include images or other content for which it does not hold copyright. In such cases, EFSA indicates the copyright holder and users should seek permission to reproduce the content from the original source. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This report is funded by EFSA as part of the EU‐FORA programme. The authors wish to thank the following members of the NovRBA project: Androniki Naska, Ermolaos Ververis, Aikaterini Niforou, Sara Monteiro Pires and Lea S. Jakobsen. We thank all colleagues from the hosting site, especially Xin Yan for the support during the stay. Cumulative distribution of current intake of minced beef patties. EFSA (European Food Safety Authority), Pavlić, M. , & Boué, G. (2025). RBA4SDS – Risk–benefit assessment for sustainable dietary shifts. EFSA Journal, 23(S1), e231109. 10.2903/j.efsa.2025.e231109 Approved: 29 September 2025 The declarations of interest of all scientific experts active in EFSA's work are available at https://open.efsa.europa.eu/experts. REFERENCES