Assessing national climate-neutrality plans through a modelling nexus lens: the case of Greece Authors: Phoebe Koundouri, Angelos Alamanos, Ioannis Arampatzidis, Stathis Devves, Kostas Dellis, Christopher Deranian Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractAchieving climate-neutrality is a global imperative, requiring interdisciplinarity and science-supported policies across multiple sectors. For the first time, we simulated a scenario representing Greece’s climate-neutrality goals drawing upon its key energy, agricultural and water policies. Using a linked-nexus framework encompassing the FABLE Calculator, the Low Emissions Analysis Platform, the WaterReqGCH, LandReqCalcGCH, and BiofuelGCH tools, we find that Greece’s climate-neutrality policies can deliver large emission reductions by 2050, only under optimistic implementation assumptions. The energy-related emissions can be reduced almost fivefold by 2050, and total energy demand by ~20%. Further improvements can be achieved if domestic biofuel production potential is realized. Sectoral interdependencies and infrastructure constraints are overlooked in existing policies, such as land requirements to meet renewables’ expansion targets, and trade-offs among land-energy-water policies. Our findings indicate that progress towards climate-neutrality depends strongly on full, coordinated policy implementation, and we provide recommendations for a timely, unified and holistic sustainable transition.Subject terms: Climate sciences, Energy and society, Environmental sciences, Environmental social sciences, Environmental studies, Scientific community, Social sciences Introduction Becoming climate-neutral through strategies aimed at reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 55% by 2030 (compared to 1990 levels) and ultimately achieving net-zero emissions by 2050 has been established as a top priority by the European Union (EU)1. These EU goals, as a unified Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) under the Paris Agreement, highlight the urgency of action against climate change. Each Member-State’s National Energy and Climate Plan (NECP), as outlined in Regulation 2018/1999/EU on energy and climate action governance, sets out how each state can achieve these shared European climate targets. Climate-neutrality and clean energy affect directly and indirectly multiple sectors, including agriculture, food production, land uses, water resources, as well as the social and economic prosperity2,3. Although climate-neutrality is primarily defined as achieving net-zero GHG emissions, in practice, realizing this decarbonization transition requires that interconnected systems such as the economy, land use, food production, and water use become also more sustainable4,5. International and European policy acknowledge that, making it particularly evident in the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) framework, where principles such as indivisibility, integration and universality are highlighted6. However, in reality, the scientific community exposes crucial weaknesses of policies in addressing more holistic and sustainable progress. Merfort et al.7 explore the negative effects of fragmented land-energy policies. Fujimori et al.8 argue on the poor coordination and incompatible nature of national climate policies, revealing that there are individual challenges in energy system transformations and investment needs. Roelfsema et al.9 explain that even the implementation of current national policies fall short to close the GHG emissions gap needed to achieve the Paris Agreement’s goals, while other studies even highlight national regulatory conflicts10. A key element in assessing different future climate-neutrality scenarios, evaluate and guide relevant policies, is the use of sound scientific tools, so that multiple relevant systems are assessed11. There are several examples in the literature using modeling approaches for such purposes. Common cases are the integrated assessment models simulating effects across different sectors12, the deep decarbonization models, which are bottom-up, engineering-economic models that minimize the costs of achieving net-zero emissions13, or custom combinations based on case-specific needs and concepts14. Several studies couple different models, representing mainly the water-energy-food-land systems, as the core ones to climate-neutrality15. For instance, Doelman et al.16 explored water-land-food-climate trade-offs by combining the MAgPIE and IMAGE models. Yue et al.17 designed an optimization-based decision support tool for water-food-energy-climate change-land nexus pathways. However, the use of such models to assess different existing climate-neutrality national policies is rarer. Kattelmann et al.18 combined the energy system model TIMES with the computational general equilibrium model NEWAGE to suggest efficient climate-neutrality strategies. Awais et al.19 have used a MESSAGEix-GLOBIOM nexus module to integrate water sector and climate impacts, considering interactions among population, growth, energy and land systems. There have been approaches that are focusing on the energy system, as for example, Capros et al.20 who used the PRIMES energy model to explore pathways towards climate-neutrality in the EU energy-system by 2050 and 2070. Other approaches have primarily examined the land system, such as Duffy et al.21, who developed and applied the GOBLIN model, focusing on land use, to identify national agriculture and land use pathways to climate-neutrality. Furthermore, other nexus-oriented tools have been also developed to capture multiple systems interactions (IIASA22). At the regional level, TIMES-based implementations (including EU-TIMES and JRC/EU-TIMES variants) have been used to analyze multi-country energy systems and policy pathways (Luxembourg et al.23; Cassetti et al.24). However, to the best of our knowledge, there is no study following such a holistic approach in the national context of Greece, after its recent policies that aim to climate-neutrality. Our contribution is therefore to add a timely, policy-relevant case study for Greece, by linking a suite of sectoral models (food-land, water, and cross-sectoral energy systems including residential, industrial, agriculture, transportation, and services sectors) into a single, nationally tailored nexus framework and explicitly test the implications of its policy packages. We developed a scenario assuming the joint implementation of these policies, exploring potential trade-offs and aiming to provide useful insights on whether these plans can achieve the climate-neutrality goals, and what is missing to use them as opportunities for a broader sustainability transition. Greece’s efforts towards climate-neutrality face several significant challenges, primarily its continued reliance on fossil fuels, which account for a substantial portion of energy supply25. Despite notable progress in renewable energy adoption, fossil fuels still dominate. The government has set ambitious commitments to phase out lignite by 2028, and reduce overall GHG emissions to net-zero by 2050. However, the transition is complicated by the need for substantial investments in renewable infrastructure and energy-efficient technologies26. The NECP is the main policy instrument dealing with these challenges (NECP27), proposing a pathway to climate-neutrality through the decarbonization of all sectors of the economy. The main idea is to use cleaner fuels and improve energy use efficiency, for all uses. While limited research so far explores specific sectors’ decarbonization pathways, such as transportation28, or macroeconomic impacts29, there is no study exploring multiple sectors as a whole, in a single model, like the present paper. Agriculture in Greece remains significant in terms of employment and output, contributing ~4% to the national GDP and employing around 11% of the workforce. Nonetheless, the sector faces key challenges, most importantly low productivity and tech adoption, aging farmers, and fragmented land holdings. Moreover, agriculture is challenged by resources limitations (e.g., water and soil conditions, energy), as well as natural hazards (droughts and floods). Scientists have been advocating for nexus approaches considering all those factors together, long ago, to avoid food security problems30. While there are no substantial land use changes in Greece, the land degradation is a pressing issue for agriculture and food production31. In line with the decarbonization commitments, the transition to more sustainable diets with reduced carbon footprints is among the country’s goals, with limited progress so far32,33. The NECP does not have specific recommendations for agriculture though. The Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) is an overarching plan covering such concerns, aiming at a resilient and more sustainable food system. However, subpar performance in crop and livestock productivity is attributed to the marginal spread of cutting-edge technologies, stemming from the inherent attributes of the Greek agricultural sector as well as the poor functioning of national and subnational innovation systems. Water management in Greece is also grappling with critical issues, in several fronts. These include water scarcity, particularly exacerbated by climate change and increasing demand (e.g., tourism)34; competing water uses over the over-reliance on groundwater resources, which in turn has resulted in over-extraction and salinization, further compromising water quality and availability35,36. Water governance is often fragmented across various authorities, leading to inefficiencies and poor coordination, which is evident in several sectors, but mainly in the residential and the agricultural ones37,38. The Water Framework Directive WFD 2000/60/EC is the EU policy dealing with these challenges, and each Member-State develops River Basin Management Plans (RBMPs) with sets of measures for the restoration and protection of water bodies, and a more responsible and efficient demand management. The importance of tracking water consumption by sector is increasingly recognized as the core target of water use efficiency improvements39. It is also relevant for climate-neutrality goals, as it allows for a more complete assessment of resource use efficiency in general, and helps identify potential conflicts or synergies between water use and decarbonization efforts40. Most studies explore the effects on specific sectors or regions of Greece41, with limited research on a cross-sectoral basis, like in this paper. For the aforementioned sectors we considered one main policy that reflects the National Climate Neutrality Commitments (NCNC), and we compare it with a Business As Usual (BAU) scenario. Our rationale is that we aim to focus on the main policies that are currently implemented in each sector. Other policies that are not considered in this study concern mostly economic measures. Such policies include, among others, the EU Taxonomy, the Climate Delegated Act, the EU Circular Economy Act, Industrial Policy, and ETS for energy and agriculture. In this research, we do not look at economic policies, since the focus is on the “water-energy-food-emissions modeling nexus”, showcasing the combination of such models. Nonetheless, it is in our future plans to augment our methodology with a Computable General Equilibrium (CGE) model that will allow us to explicitly consider and evaluate the main economic policies for each sector as well. Each sector of the economy also faces unique challenges. The residential sector, which is the largest energy consumer and second-largest water user, faces significant resource pressures and aging infrastructure. Agriculture must address competing water and energy needs, environmental pressures, and productivity gaps, along with its transition to cleaner fuels and modernization of current practices. Industrial decarbonization is also challenged by resource limitations, outdated technologies, and high reliance on fossil fuels42. Moreover, the Greek industry being not as big as in other EU Member-States, is an overlooked issue with limited research. The transportation sector, as a whole, struggles with reliance on conventional fuels, inefficiencies, and policy gaps, hindering its decarbonization efforts43. The transition of the transportation sector to cleaner fuels is still at a preliminary stage, and the sector often appears to be “isolated” from the broader future energy planning44. While sector-specific challenges are critical, comprehensive nexus approaches assessing all these sectors as a whole, and each one at a fine resolution, are still lacking. The interdisciplinary and complex science-to-policy nature of such cross-sectoral climate-neutrality efforts make their simulation particularly challenging. This applies particularly to countries that are not traditionally used to such holistic governance45,46. Greece is such an example, and this research aims to fill a critical gap in terms of cross-sectoral fine-resolution modeling approaches, and in terms of its national climate-related policy assessment. Results Food-land system The BAU scenario leads to increased production-based agricultural emissions by 2050, as expected. In contrast, the NCNC scenario shifts productivity levers for crop and livestock, dropping GHG emissions by 2050 by 50% (3 MtCO2e) compared to the BAU scenario (Fig. 1a, b). This represents a 29% reduction from 2020 levels and a dramatic 73.4% decline from Greece’s agricultural emissions in 2050. This reduction is primarily achieved through livestock-related emissions dropping to 2.47 MtCO2e in 2050, and land use changes leading to increased emission withdrawals of 3.28 MtCO2e in 2050. This improvement in land-use efficiency stems from the assumed shift to more sustainable diets managing the demand-side, and the higher and more efficient agricultural productivity, which enables greater yields without requiring additional inputs or extensive land expansion, as evidenced by declining pastureland areas (Fig. 1e, f). Additionally, emissions from crop production show notable improvements in the NCNC scenario, with a marked divergence from the BAU projections becoming apparent after 2035. Enhanced agricultural productivity is beneficial both in terms of climate change mitigation (GHG emissions), and of domestic agriculture’s competitiveness. This is particularly relevant following the 2023 extreme weather events and 2023–27 CAP implementation, with Devot et al.47 highlighting how climate change-intensified weather events impact EU agricultural production and costs. Food-land system’s main results. The NCNC scenario dramatically cuts emissions (−58%) and production costs (−46%) compared to the BAU by 2050, largely due to healthier diets (less meat), higher productivity, and reduced reliance on inputs. Land allocation shifts strongly: pasture declines, while “other land” expands, reflecting land sparing and improved efficiency. Cropland remains roughly constant in both scenarios, while forests are protected in both. Under the NCNC scenario, total costs are projected to decrease from 828 million € in 2025 to less than 630 million € by 2050. This reduction is largely attributed to declining pesticide expenses, which constitute the majority of total costs. Most notably, producers’ pesticide expenditures decrease by 27.5% between 2025–2050 in the high productivity scenario, amounting to just 40% of the costs projected in the BAU. While fertilizer costs show a more modest decline of 14.8% over the same 25-year period, the contrast with the BAU’s upward trend still results in significant cost savings of nearly 40%. This demonstrates how improved productivity can strengthen competitiveness while adapting to climate challenges. The two main messages of the national land-use policy frameworks (Table 1) are to discourage urban sprawl in agricultural and natural areas, and increase forest area, ensuring that agricultural expansion does not come at the expense of woodland health. Under the BAU scenario, none of those two goals is being achieved (Fig. 1e). While urban land grows only modestly, much of the land-use change is driven by cropland and harvested area, which means agricultural expansion is the dominant driver of sprawl into rural and natural areas (directly at odds with discouraging land-take outside existing settlements). Also, there is no meaningful increase in forest area, but a slightly downward trend. Under the NCNC scenario, only one of these two land-use objectives is met (Fig. 1f): Urban land remains essentially flat through 2050, showing that new housing and infrastructure are indeed being held within existing settlements. However, the pronounced increase in agricultural productivity and the shift to healthier diets, associated with reduced red meat consumption, leads to the marked drop in pastureland (by 29% in the 2020–2030 period, and 78% in 2050, compared to the 2020 levels; The respective decreases for the BAU scenario are 17.3% and 31.2%, respectively). Given the lack of national commitment for a quantitative afforestation target and the marginal reduction in cropland, this leads to a significant surge in the area described as “Other” Land in the FABLE Calculator. “Other land” increase reflects areas under restoration, set-aside, or low-intensity uses, but these gains do not translate into designated, fully protected forests. So, the aspiration to increase forest area and strengthen woodland health remains unmet under the NCNC scenario. Table 1The description of the NCNC scenario, according to each sectoral policy, compared to the BAUSectorsPlanned pathway according to sector-specific policiesResidential, Industry, Transportation, ServicesThe Greek National Energy and Climate Plan (NECP), as defined by the Greek Ministry of Energy and Environment (2024), assumes certain interventions per sector. These refer to improvements of energy use efficiencies and cleaner energy mixes. So, for all sectors, the NCNC’s expected energy consumption led to the respective energy intensities assumed in this simulation. Also, for each sector, the NECP’s expected fuel mixes (phasing out of fossil fuels and replacing them by cleaner ones) were simulated.Food-land system,Agricultural production-based and energy-based systemsThe Greek CAP, aligned with the broader EU CAP framework, clearly acknowledges the need to boost agricultural productivity, promote sustainable diets (reducing meat) within the constraints of limited land, and enhance energy efficiency in agriculture. However, while these objectives are articulated as strategic goals, the policy largely outlines broad priorities and financial support mechanisms rather than prescribing specific, technical interventions or detailed action plans43,70. The NECP focuses primarily on generic agroecological practices and cyclical economic considerations to decarbonize the agricultural sector. To model such a trajectory, considering land-use, GHG emissions and costs, we developed a high crop and livestock productivity scenario within FABLE Calculator, corresponding to the NECP (and CAP) requirements by 2050. High productivity growth shifts historical (2000–2010) growth rates by reversing negative values, multiplying by a factor of 2 if they were below 1%, and by 0.7 if they exceeded 1%67. In the case of Greece, the average productivity growth during the first decade of the century had negative values.Land use changesAlthough this is not directly related to decarbonization commitments, it is recognized that the requirements on natural resources should be also considered in sustainability assessments. Greece’s land use policy is defined by the Presidential Decree 59/2018, which categorizes all national territory into defined zones (residential, urban, agricultural, industrial, recreational, and strict nature protection) thereby channeling urbanization into existing settlements and discouraging sprawl in agricultural and natural areas71. Complementing this, the CAP Strategic Plan 2023–27 seeks to modernize Greek agriculture by promoting innovation, securing farmer incomes, and crucially reducing the sector’s environmental footprint through eco-schemes and conditionality that support crop diversification, cover crops, and maintenance of permanent grasslands56. It also aims to increase forest area, ensuring that agricultural expansion does not come at the expense of woodland health.Water consumptionAgain, this is not directly linked to decarbonization commitments, but as an important natural resource, it is necessary to consider. The European Union’s Water Framework Directive (WFD) 2000/60/EC establishes a comprehensive framework for water policy, aiming to protect and enhance the quality of water resources across Member States. While the WFD sets overarching objectives for achieving ‘good status’ of all water bodies, it does not prescribe specific water consumption reduction targets for individual sectors72. In all Member States, the implementation of the WFD is carried out through River Basin Management Plans (RBMPs), assessing the status of water bodies and outline Programmes of Measures (PoMs) to address identified issues. While the RBMPs focus on protecting and managing water resources, they do not set explicit sector-specific water consumption reduction targets or measures. Instead, they emphasize the need to improve water efficiency and sustainable use across various sectors40,73. In this scenario, we assumed a central measure to improve water use efficiency by reducing urban water losses (LC) by half. The description of the NCNC scenario, according to each sectoral policy, compared to the BAU Food-land system, Agricultural production-based and energy-based systems Cross-sectoral energy-emissions analysis The energy-emission simulation of all sectors was performed for the BAU scenario, continuing current accounts’ trends and assumptions, and the NCNC scenario, which is in essence the Greek NECP. The parameters that are changing according to the specific NECP recommendations include the fuel mix shares serving the demand (increasing the share of cleaner fuels), and improvements in energy efficiencies per sector and use. The results project a significant reduction in energy consumption and emissions under the NCNC scenario, in contrast to the BAU (Fig. 2a, b). An overall reduction in energy demand of ~20% is observed, with the most drastic reductions achieved in industry (~48%), passengers and freight transportation (~52%), including international aviation and maritime (~49% overall). Improvements in energy efficiency are mainly driving these trends. The decreasing trend of residential energy consumption over time is primarily driven by the country’s shrinking population (AL). The services sector, including public buildings, hotels, hospitals, exhibits a ~18% increase in energy consumption, following increased future needs for services. Agriculture’s energy consumption increases by ~12%, following the increased productivity requirements simulated in the FABLE Calculator. Overall, the level of energy consumption is estimated to remain significantly high in 2050, under both scenarios. Total energy consumption and GHG emissions (100-Year GWP) per sector. There is an overall energy demand reduction by ~20% under NCNC versus BAU, driven primarily by industry and transportation, while GHG emissions follow analogous and substantial downward trends, under the NCNC scenario. With respect to the supply side (energy generation), Fig. 3a, b illustrate the total energy generated per feedstock fuel type, which is then used to cover the consumption. As expected, there is a substantial decline in oil refining products under NCNC, almost by 3 times in 2050. Conversely, electricity production is expected to rise significantly, by 3.7 Mtoe in 2050. New contributions to energy production include hydrogen and synthetic fuels, reaching in total 1.1 Mtoe and 0.571 Mtoe, respectively. The shift in energy production types, highlighted by the reduced reliance on conventional petroleum products and fossil-based electricity, contributes to further GHG emission reductions. Emissions are projected to decrease from 26 MtCO₂e in 2022 to 5.2 MtCO₂e by 2050. These changes are attributed to the evolving energy mix and technologies introduced under the NCNC scenario. Energy generation and feedstock fuels’ GHG emissions (100-Year GWP). Under NCNC the supply mix shifts by 2050, with oil refining falling by ~68%, electricity generation increasing by ~3.6 Mtoe, and new shifts (hydrogen + synthetic fuels) contributing about 1.7 Mtoe in total. These shifts drive a reduction in emissions from energy generation of ~20 MtCO₂e. Note that both energy consumption and fuels supply results were also validated, cross-checking with data from NCNC’s assumptions, EUROSTAT48, and the IEA49. The NECP-projected energy sources, particularly for electricity, indicate a complete phase-out of lignite for electricity production, a 77% reduction in natural gas use, and substantial increases in clean energies (renewables, hydrogen and synthetic fuels). These have been also simulated in detail. Indicatively for the significant changes that are projected, we mentioned that wind and solar power deployment are about to increase by 540% by 2050, while the hydroelectric power output is projected to rise by 120%. The implementation of the NECP would lead to a dramatic reduction of GHG emissions by 2050 compared to the BAU scenario, decreasing by 91.7% (Fig. 2c, d, Fig. 3c, d). These emissions are calculated using the 100-year Global Warming Potential (GWP) of direct GHG emissions and are predominantly composed of Carbon Dioxide (CO₂), with smaller contributions from Methane (CH₄), Nitrous Oxide (N₂O), and Carbon Monoxide (CO). By 2050, the NCNC scenario achieves near-complete decarbonization, whereas the BAU emission reductions are more minor. At this stage, it is worth commenting again on the key difference between the FABLE Calculator’s production-based agricultural GHG emissions and LEAP’s energy-based agricultural GHG emissions. FABLE Calculator estimates agricultural GHG emissions by simulating food and livestock production processes, including land use changes, agronomic practices, and non-energy-related processes (such as enteric fermentation, manure management, and fertilizer application), capturing thus a broader range of emissions associated with agricultural production. Hence the term “production-based emissions” for FABLE Calculator. Complementarily, the LEAP model calculates the emissions based solely on the energy use in production processes (per unit of final products). Hence the term “energy-based emissions” for LEAP. In general, regarding the total GHG emissions, the primary driver of the reductions in the total emissions (both from energy consumption and energy generation) is the significant decrease in fossil fuel use across the residential, industrial, and transportation sectors, one of the core recommendations of the NECP. Additionally, the adoption of renewable energy sources in electricity production—coupled with the introduction of hydrogen and synthetic fuels, particularly in the transportation sector—further contributes to these reductions. Figure 4a, b show the flows of feedstock fuels into energy transformation processes to produce fuels that cover different energy demand uses, indicatively for 2050. The transition to cleaner fuels is obvious, as mentioned. Both Sankey diagrams indicate that the energy production-transformation-consumption balance is “confirmed” throughout the simulation period. Sankey diagrams for energy generation and consumption flows. Under NCNC most emissions cuts come from a sharp drop in fossil fuel use, with renewables and minor contributions from cleaner fuels replacing a large share of fossil fuels and oil products. Biofuel production potential As mentioned, the agricultural output results of the FABLE Calculator are analyzed through the BiofuelGCH Calculator, to account for the residues available for biofuel production (without affecting food production), and estimate this potential. This refers to the amount of bioethanol (produced from corn, sugarbeets, and wheat residuals), and the amount of biodiesel (produced from sunflower and olive residuals). So, it does not take into account the wooden and pellet potential production, which is however the major use of biomass for residential heating and cooking. The results indicate that there is a significant potential to produce biofuels domestically, ranging from 208–435 ktoe in 2022 to 268–519 ktoe in 2050. This production can fully cover the biofuel demand from uses such as agriculture, transportation, energy production and transformation processes (Fig. 5a), and the excess amount can be used for exports (Fig. 5b). Biofuel demand, production and exports potential. By 2050 the production potential (min-max) ranges from 268–519 ktoe, and it is able to cover the domestic demand (excluding wood and pellet products), providing thus the option for exports up to 253–503 ktoe under the NCNC demand case. Land requirements The implementation of the NCNC, as simulated in LEAP, requires in total 35051 MW of solar energy, and 24780 MW of wind power in 2050. This corresponds to an additional capacity of 28051 MW and 16280 MW, respectively, compared to the current (2025) solar and wind power. Moreover, the NCNC projects that 52.46% of the wind power will be onshore, while the rest should be offshore. So, this results in 8541 MW. The LandReqGCH model, based on these figures, uses typical values from the literature to convert these additional required capacities in solar and wind power into land requirements (km2) for the installation of additional solar panels and wind farms (onshore). These values from the literature are used as land conversion coefficients (km2/MW), taking into account the types of land uses and the types of projects, and considering a range of options, according to Denholm et al.50 and Ong et al.51. So, for solar panels that would range from 670 km2 (min) to 846 km2 (average) and to 1022 km2 (max). The onshore wind farms would require from 19 km2 (min) to 25 km2 (average) and to 35 km2 (max). These magnitudes, even at their high end, are under 1100 km2 or about 0.8% of Greece’s total land area, but it is non-negligible when overlaid on a landscape already under competing demands. Specifically, in Fig. 1e, f we observe rapid growth in “Other land” (mosaic, low-intensity uses) and continued pressure on cropland and pasture, under both the BAU and NCNC scenarios. Installing solar parks and wind farms will most likely encroach on these less-intensive zones or marginal agricultural lands, rather than pristine forests. If this required renewables infrastructure ends up replacing set-aside fields or semi-natural grasslands, it may conflict with the objective to preserve permanent grasslands and pastures, which will challenge traditional grazing economies and even biodiversity. The LandReqGCH model also provides estimates of the expected costs for the installation of these projects, considering their typical costs52,53. Regarding the solar panels, the cost would range (min-average-max) from 669.8 million € to 845.7 million € and to 1021.6 million €. The respective costs for wind farms would range from 28.2 million € to 38 million € and to 52.5 million €. Water Requirements The WaterReqGCH model was applied for all sectors and years of the studied period, providing also estimates for monthly distributions, accounting thus for seasonality in water requirements. The water sector faces the highest uncertainties, as the consumption is affected by various socio-economic, infrastructure, and hydro-climatological factors that are inherently uncertain. Moreover, there are no specific demand management measures per sector, according to the Greek RBMPs. Urban water use, encompassing residential and service sectors, represents the 7–8% of total consumption. This comparatively modest share is indicative of more efficient urban water management, for a lower population-driven demand relative to agricultural needs. Urban water consumption decreases from an average of 725.19 hm³ in 2020 to 630.31 hm³ in 2050, driven by Greece’s declining population. The NCNC scenario assumed a reduction in water network losses, so they reach 20% in total. This measure would further reduce the urban water requirements to 578 hm³ in 2050, which is within the estimated range area plotted in Fig. 6. Sectoral and seasonal distribution of water requirements. Urban (residential and services) (a), agricultural (irrigation and livestock) (b), and industrial water requirements (c). The monthly water requirements plot (d) shows the monthly allocation of the total consumption. Agriculture remains dominant (~88–89% of water use to 2050) with strong seasonality, while other uses stay minor, with residential and industry being the most significant ones. Agriculture is the dominant consumer of water resources, consistently accounting for 88–89% of the total consumption over the period 2020–2050. This is indicative of the sector’s reliance on irrigation and water-intensive practices, which reflect Greece’s Mediterranean climate and the importance of agriculture in its economy. Agricultural water consumption follows a slight increase after 2025 and reaches an average consumption of 8041.12 hm³ by 2050, with only minor fluctuations. The NCNC scenario for agriculture, as defined within the FABLE Calculator, assumes that the number of livestock population and the amount of irrigated areas will remain stable, aiming to higher productivity outputs while using the same input resources. Based on this assumption, the livestock and irrigation water requirements will not vary outside of the plotted uncertainty range for agriculture, as shown in Fig. 6. Another key factor here is the assumption that demand remains stable, driving this relatively stable behavior, which is largely uncertain though. Industrial use remains the smallest contributor at 3–4%, aligning with Greece’s economic structure, where industrial activity is less dominant compared to agriculture and services. Its water consumption remains relatively stable, with slight increases from 328 hm³ in 2020 to 331.61 hm³ in 2050. The ranges of minimum-maximum values are larger for agriculture and reflect various data and computational uncertainties. The NCNC does not assume any specific measures per industry types’ water use. The monthly distribution of the total water requirements is shown indicatively for 2020, and follows the same pattern until 2050. It reveals a sharp increase during the prolonged Greek summer period (May–October), reflecting peak irrigation needs and heightened urban water use during the tourist season, and due to increased temperatures. For instance, the average monthly water requirement in July (1866.6 hm³) is more than eight times higher than in December (134.55 hm³). This pronounced seasonality underscores the pressure on water resources during the dry season and the importance of adequate storage and distribution infrastructure34. Discussion So far, Greece’s progress towards achieving climate neutrality has been notably limited, with slow decarbonization across major sectors despite EU mandates and global commitments, and despite its overly ambitious targets54. As mentioned, the country continues to rely heavily on fossil fuels, and investments in renewable energy and energy efficiency remain insufficient compared to the NECP’s goals. The overall slow progress so far makes the achievement of the NECP targets quite challenging, as documented by the European Environment Agency (EEA) and echoed in recent analyses (e.g., IEA reports and the NECP review by the European Commission)54,55. The agricultural sector in Greece is also underperforming in terms of sustainability and resource efficiency. The Greek CAP plan emphasizes to improved competitiveness by promoting innovation and new technologies, fostering young entrepreneurship, as the sector consists mainly of aging and declining population56. In parallel, it sets ambitious targets on reducing the environmental footprint of agriculture and apply innovative technologies. However, the sector suffers from outdated farming practices and limited modernization opportunities, weak managerial control and accountability mechanisms43,57,58. This results in low productivity and inefficient energy use, as highlighted in studies such as Shan et al.41 and Kourgialas38, as well as in a recent living lab in Greece’s major agricultural region59. Under the WFD, Member States must update and report their RBMPs with the respective programs of measures every 6 years. Greece delayed two and a half years to review, adopt or report its RBMPs, along with other Member States. The European Commission referred Greece to the Court of Justice of the European Union60. This inaction is reflected also in the actual progress, with the latest cycles of the RBMPs revealing a slight degradation of water bodies, along with a big body of research warning about ecological and water management issues, with agriculture being the main pressure38,41,61. Demand management is at a very primitive stage, where the general perception still sees large-scale engineering works increasing the (limited supply) as synonymous to the country’s development, and is skeptical to more integrated, efficiency-oriented strategies59,62. A scenario achieving the National Commitments (in line with the NCNC) is conditional to the joint implementation of different policies examined (NECP, CAP, Land-use, RBMPs). This joint implementation is a challenging task as the individual policies have different planning horizons, target years, and implementation responsibilities. Specifically, the current NECP sets targets for 2030 and 2050, while CAP operates on a 7-year cycle (with the current one running from 2023 to 2027), and the RBMPs are updated every 6 years to manage water resources at the river basin level, and their third and final cycle ends in 2027. This misalignment in timelines and objectives can result in uncoordinated strategies, where policies may not effectively complement each other. Building on these challenges, the integrated modeling results highlight that policy fragmentation and temporal misalignment lead to scattered and sometimes counterproductive outcomes across sectors. Next, we elaborate on such unintended consequences and potential pathways to improve policy coherence. The multi-model simulated NCNC scenario, as mentioned, assumes the joint implementation of different sectoral policies. This approach allows the exploration of trade-offs between such policies that are hidden when they are examined in isolation. Below we discuss the trade-offs and potentially unintended consequences from the individual/isolated consideration of such policies. First, it is worth considering the overlooked resource requirements: The achievement of the NECP’s objectives requires an increase of wind and solar power deployment by 540% by 2050. This translates to an additional land requirement (on average) of 871 km2 for solar panels and onshore wind farms, costing on average 845.7 million €. Capacity and economic feasibility concerns can naturally occur though. For instance, it is worth mentioning as a measure of comparison, that in Fig. 1f, the forest land is around 36 km2. The currently overlooked potential conflicts with competitive land uses (e.g., agriculture, forestry, biodiversity, smallholders and farmers’ ownerships and interests) should be addressed in such plans of green energy expansion. Therefore, we recommend the inclusion of land use co-siting strategies and prioritization planning jointly by the NECP and CAP (e.g., prioritizing brownfield and rooftop photovoltaics, agrivoltaics, and expansion primarily into low-value and degraded lands, reducing new land take). Second, the realization of NECP’s potential to curb emissions from agriculture, residential, industrial, transportation, services, and energy production sectors would require its full implementation through a number of measures. These would require certain behavioral changes (e.g., adoption of technologies to improve energy efficiency for all sectors, and cleaner fuel mixes). How each sector will implement the NECP-projected measures (as simulated in the NCNCN scenario), and how the respective behavioral changes will happen is currently omitted from the plan, and remains an (optimistic) assumption. Therefore, we recommend strengthening the NECP with social and financial aspects and analyses to provide trackable plans and pathways towards its adoption and implementation. Even if the NECP is fully implemented, our findings indicate that it does not achieve complete decarbonization in 2050, there are still emissions, but significantly lower. So, it is necessary to focus on the swift implementation including timely behavioral adjustments, to then build on with additional measures for a complete decarbonization. Third, for the case of agriculture, the NECP does not explicitly indicate technological and fuel mix changes to be considered. Our modeled NCNC scenario in the FABLE Calculator is actually more ambitious than the NECP itself, because we took into account broader goals and national commitments. For instance, the European food policy aims for higher productivity and resilience, along with the decarbonization goals, while in the Greek CAP these are represented more vaguely. Our model presented a scenario showing that a combination of these goals – since they are inherently interconnected (higher productivity, same land, lower emissions) is actually possible, and at a lower cost. However, it also led to a slight (15%) increase in energy use, while it cannot directly account for the potential increases in water use63,64. The dominance of agriculture in water consumption emphasizes the need for targeted interventions in this sector, which are side-mentioned by the RBMPs40. Therefore, we recommend considering these trade-offs through a complementary (or revised) plan explicitly outlining the NECP’s energy efficiency strategies for agriculture, bridging them with the CAP and the RBMPs to account for potentially new water supply projects and water demand management within the agricultural sector. Fourth, another area where the NECP and the CAP could further be bridged refers to the biofuel production. Our findings indicate that Greece has the capacity to potentially fully cover the biofuel demand from certain uses and even become net exporter (while currently Greece imports biofuels). Also, with respect to biofuels, currently no policy considers their role as an alternative clean fuel for shipping decarbonization, despite the IMO’s FuelEU Maritime regulation’s suggestions. In fact, there is still no plan for the decarbonization of the shipping sector, nor within the Greek NECP, nor as part of any national transportation policy. These four overarching points are currently not captured by policies, their trade-offs are overlooked, and they remain vague governance assumptions, hence the characterization “scattered” policies. Moreover, the implementation of the decarbonization measures falls under the jurisdiction of different ministries and regional authorities, such as the Ministry of Environment and Energy overseeing the NECP, the Ministry of Rural Development and Food managing the CAP, and all 13 Greek Regional Authorities being responsible for the implementation of their respective RBMPs, while the Ministries of Transportation and Economics are not yet involved. These fragmented governance structures can create siloed communication channels, hindering effective collaboration and integrated policy execution. Recognizing these challenges, the European Commission has provided support to enhance collaboration among Greek governing bodies and public entities through an inter-ministerial coordination manual65. Overall, this research presented an integrated modeling approach to assess the Greek NCNC, as closely as possible to the current real-world policy landscape, referring to the main systems (food, land, energy, emissions, and water). The simulated NCNC scenario is a theoretical case, assuming that policies like CAP, the NECP, and the RBMPs will be fully implemented. Unavoidably, this work does not come without limitations. First, the assumption of the NCNC scenario as a hypothetical case, which however, served as a useful cross-sectoral analysis to inform about trade-offs, gaps, and areas for improvement. Second, we simulated Greece as a whole, without providing a more refined spatial representation, considering the different regions of the country. This was due to data limitations and inconsistencies across all studied systems in different regions, as well as the increased computational demand when combining different models that consider inputs that are mostly subject to different scales, units and time-steps. However, we believe that for the purpose of this national plans’ assessment, the results provide a satisfactory picture of the studied nexus and policy in Greece. Third, the focus on food, land, energy, emissions, and water system does not mean that these are the only relevant ones. They are simply the main ones relevant to the existing NCNCs, and highly interconnected in modeling terms. Nonetheless, augmenting our current nexus-systems approach with social, economic, biodiversity, and waste systems is included in our future research plans. To this direction, we plan to develop a CGE model that will be interconnected with all individual models presented in this paper. This will allow us to evaluate, besides the main policies considered for each sector so far, additional policies that concern, among others, economic externalities (e.g., health effects, co-benefits from waste management), the economic and social distribution of costs and benefits, and explicit impacts on employment. This approach will yield further insights on the direct and indirect (economic) costs and (environmental) benefits of alternative decarbonization pathways. Besides the limitations, the presented combination of tools for the assessment of different planned efforts towards climate-neutrality provide critical insights into nexus systems and potential trade-offs, which is crucial for addressing complex sustainability challenges. Such assessments allow also the exploration of the impact of real policies. Although specific sectoral plans have the potential to achieve multiple co-benefits, the absence of a unified framework can lead to insufficiencies and missed opportunities for synergies and unintended conflicts among objectives. A key point in transitioning to unified and more integrated approaches is the realization that climate adaptation cannot be seen merely as an emissions reduction effort. It requires a broader sustainability context, wider than just decarbonization, involving the improvement of all interconnected sectors. This position is in line with a recent Comment in Nature66 arguing that the European policy itself has to evolve first, to accommodate global changes that happened since the design of ambitious targets. This research further highlights that national policies can also play a pivotal role in triggering such policy evolutions, considering multiple sectors under more unified and coordinated frameworks. Greece could benefit from the European Commission’s guidance and establish an inter-ministerial coordination mechanism, creating a dedicated body to align the implementation of NECP, CAP, and RBMPs, their planning horizons, developing thus more coherent long-term strategies that would consider multiple trade-offs. Finally, integrated modeling approaches can serve as central tools in these efforts. Therefore, the development of robust national integrated modeling systems of fine resolution is also recommended. The creation of a unified platform for simulating complex systems, monitoring policy interactions, and tracking progress across all related policies can facilitate better decision-making, resource allocation, and long-term sustainability planning. Methods A systems-nexus modeling approach was followed to simulate all sectors described in the previous section. This approach consists of: the FABLE Calculator67 for the potential evolution of food and land-use systems; the Low Emissions Analysis Platform (LEAP)68 for the simulation of the energy consumption and the associated GHG emissions of multiple pollutants; the WaterReqGCH accounting tool69 for the estimation of the water requirements of the studied sectors; and the LandReqCalcGCH tool to estimate the land requirements for any potentially additional renewable energy production units. These models were linked through specific outputs becoming inputs elsewhere, and tools (e.g., the BiofuelGCH Calculator), as illustrated in Fig. 7. The modeling framework, with the tools, their inputs and outputs, and their connections. All models run under the same time horizon, socio-economic, climate and demographic data, and assumptions. More details follow in Table 2, providing purpose, key inputs and outputs, core assumptions, and notes on uncertainties. Full technical detail and equations are provided in the Supplementary Material. Table 2A summary of our framework’s modelsFABLE Calculator67Short DescriptionPrimary purposeLand use allocation; crop & livestock production projections; Costs and emissions; agronomic practices; LULUCF fluxes.Key inputsCORINE national land cover baseline; FAOSTAT crop yields (historical & trend), livestock numbers, food demand projections, annual time-step; Built-in scenario menu, multiple pathways options; Land availability and regulatory restrictions, used as thresholds to the estimated outputs.Main outputsGHG emissions from agriculture and non-energy (livestock) production processes; production costs; dietary choices; land use by category, annually.Core assumptionsNational population and GDP projections depending on SSPs; Dietary choices imply a basic uptake in ingredients/products which are defined by SSPs, EAT Lancet Diet, or other custom scenarios; Different default rates of crop, livestock productivity (low, middle, high), and also for afforestation, climate change, and land expansion (for more details, see Table S1).Uncertainties and sensitivitiesThese inputs and assumptions are used for the estimation of targeted land, crop and livestock production, estimating the respective available resources, costs and emissions through coefficients. The FABLE Calculator offers a portfolio of more than 1.5 billion pathways (a combination of in-build scenarios through changing different assumption variables on climate conditions, economic and agricultural policy, regulation and demographics, which can be the main sources of uncertainty67). We have explored the main sensitivities under the key driving factors of the demand (since the tool is demand-based), i.e.,: population and GDP, dietary choices, crop and livestock productivity (see Table S1 and Fig. S1).LEAP68Short DescriptionPrimary purposeLong-term integrated energy, climate mitigation, and air pollution planning and analysis, scenario-based tool. Simulation of the energy demand (consumption) across various sectors, the fuel supply and their production, as well as the associated GHG emissions for each process.Key inputsDemand-side: Sectors (residential and services, industry, agriculture, transportation including terrestrial, domestic and international maritime and aviation); The respective activity levels (e.g., population, tons of produced products, sectoral value added per product, transport km). For the case of agriculture, the inputs are obtained from FABLE Calculator’s outputs; Their respective energy use coefficients, and fuel shares per use (see Table S2).Supply-side: Primary and secondary fuels, resources and transformation processes (see Table S2).Main outputsEnergy demand per sector, emissions per sector, fuels used per sector, through their transformation process, emissions per fuel combustion, total emissions, annual energy balances.Core assumptionsThe energy demand is estimated as the product of an activity level and the energy use per unit of activity (see Equation 1 in supplementary material). The resources are fed into the transformation processes (simulating how energy is converted, transmitted, and distributed through technologies like power plants, refineries, and grids). The supply system ensures alignment with the per sector demand-side inputs and can simulate constraints, imports, exports, and system losses, offering detailed insights into energy flows. The GHG emissions are estimated based on the emission coefficients of the IPCC’s Fifth Assessment Report74 per sector, per use and per fuel type for the demand side, and per process for the supply side in Global Warming Potential (GWP) values, and in units of tonnes of CO2 equivalent per tonne of pollutant (T CO2e/T) (see Table S2).Uncertainties and sensitivitiesThe model is validated against the explicit BAU and NCNC projections of the Greek NECP by 2050 (NECP27). Potential uncertainty sources include the policy implementation timelines, technology and electrification adoption rates, and economic/price pathways, exogenous to model. The sensitivities tested include the population and GDP projections (common for all models) and cross-sectoral renewables uptake rates (as a result of potential cost reductions or shifts already underway). For more details see Table S3 and Fig. S2.BiofuelGCHShort DescriptionPrimary purposeModel feedstock conversion to biofuels, to provide insights about the agriculture’s residuals potential for biofuels production and coverage of domestic demand.Key inputsCrop and livestock products (FABLE Calculator’s outputs) and residues from corn, sugarbeet, sunflower, olive, and wheat (common crops that can be used for biofuels production were selected, according to FABLE Consortium data for Greece75), to meet energy demands (LEAP’s output).Main outputsThe biofuel production potential, per biofuel type (in liters), calculated as the product of the available residuals per crop (in tons of residues) and the respective biofuel production coefficients per biofuel and per crop [liters of biofuel/ton of residues]. See also Equation 2 in supplementary material.Core assumptionsResidues generated during agricultural production from crop are based on typical values from previous studies by Elbehri et al. and Yang et al.76,77. The biofuels considered are biodiesel and bioethanol (e.g., biomass such as pellet for heating is excluded). The biofuels production coefficients are obtained by FAO, Talebnia et al., and IEA78–80. The projected demand for biofuels is obtained by the NECP (NECP27).Uncertainties and sensitivitiesConversion efficiency; Mandated blending uptake per NCNC; Feedstock availability. The sensitivities tested include crops’ residuals availability, biofuel production coefficients, and technology adoption rates (see Table S4 and Fig. S3).LandReqCalcGCHShort DescriptionPrimary purposeTranslate NECP-projected needs for additional renewable energy infrastructure into land-area footprints (km²), namely, the land requirements for additional solar panels and onshore wind farms installation.Key inputsInputs from LEAP regarding the future energy mix, to get the required capacity of renewable solar and wind power, excluding the existing production capacity. See also Equation 3 in supplementary material.Main outputsLand area required for new solar panels and onshore wind farms (km²), with the respective installation costs (€).Core assumptionsArea conversion coefficients (in km2/MW) are used per renewable source (solar, onshore wind), and land use type, for typical projects, as reported in Ong et al.51 and Denholm et al.50.Uncertainties and sensitivitiesUncertainties include the area conversion coefficients and typical installation costs, and the model is tested for the sensitivity to these parameters (see Fig. S4).WaterReqGCH69Short DescriptionPrimary purposeEstimate sectoral water demand (residential, industrial, agricultural), to provide resource requirements insights, for the same sectors used in LEAP and FABLE Calculator.Key inputsPopulation, quantity of industrial products, crops and animal populations per species for livestock; average consumption rates per person/product/crop/animal; losses coefficients (pumping, transmission, distribution).Main outputsAnnual and monthly water requirements (hm³) per sector (residential, industrial, irrigation, livestock).Core assumptionsThe water requirements per sector were estimated following the same approach with the energy demand, assuming the activity levels and typical water consumption values, accounting for any losses81–84 (see Equation 4 in supplementary material).Uncertainties and sensitivitiesUncertainties include the population, industry and agricultural sectors’ growths, technology upgrades potentially reducing losses or altering the water use efficiency per use, along with other external socio-economic parameters affecting water requirements69,85. These were reflected in different SSP scenarios capturing most of those trajectories, thus, the sensitivities tested referred to the Population, GDP and Technology scenarios used for the other models as well (see Table S5 and Fig. S5). A summary of our framework’s models Demand-side: Sectors (residential and services, industry, agriculture, transportation including terrestrial, domestic and international maritime and aviation); The respective activity levels (e.g., population, tons of produced products, sectoral value added per product, transport km). For the case of agriculture, the inputs are obtained from FABLE Calculator’s outputs; Their respective energy use coefficients, and fuel shares per use (see Table S2). Supply-side: Primary and secondary fuels, resources and transformation processes (see Table S2). All models described run under a common simulation period, from 2020 to 2050, at an annual time-step. All models use a shared set of harmonized baseline inputs to ensure internal consistency (e.g., population, GDP and/or respective technological shifts according to SSP scenarios, harmonized units and annual time-steps), while each model is calibrated/validated against historical observations (e.g., land‑cover change 2000–2020 for FABLE Calculator, national energy demand, supply sources and sectoral allocation, as well as balances, 2022 for LEAP, along with the NECP-projected changes and GHG emissions targets in 2050). As mentioned, all models described below were set up under a BAU (baseline) and a National Commitments (NCNC) scenario: The ‘current accounts’ (Business-As-Usual—BAU) scenario assumes certain projections per sector. In particular, the population, climate conditions and GDP projections are following the SSP2 (middle of the road scenario), there are no dietary shifts, and no changes in the crop and livestock productivity, while the land use changes are following the baseline (historic 2000–2020) trends. The BAU scenario also reflects a baseline projection on the (moderate) adoption of renewables and cleaner fuels mixes such as electrification (in all sectors, as a result of potential baseline cost reductions or shifts already underway) (see Table S3). These trends are obtained mainly from the Greek CAP and the NECP, which include such projections for both expected baseline and National Commitments cases (CAP56 and NECP27). The NCNC assumes that the different policies per sector, which are relevant to climate-neutrality, are applied and implemented together (Table 1). Thus, it simulates the pathway for Greece’s climate-neutrality across all sectors, as it is currently planned/described in its respective sectoral policies. Supplementary information Supplementary Information Acknowledgements P.K., I.A., S.D., and K.D. acknowledge funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the ERC Synergy Grant Water-Futures grant agreement ID 951424 and the CARMINE, HORIZON Research and Innovation Actions, 101137851. C.D. acknowledges funding from the Fulbright Foundation in Greece. Author contributions Conceptualization: P.K., A.A.; Methodology: A.A., I.A., S.D., K.D., C.D.; Software: A.A., I.A., S.D., K.D., C.D.; Formal Analysis: A.A., I.A., S.D., K.D.; Writing—Original Draft: A.A., I.A., C.D.; Writing—Review and Editing: All authors. Data availability Available from the authors upon request. Code availability N/A. No custom code was used. Competing interests The authors declare no conflict of interest. P.K. is a member of the editorial board of the npj Climate Action, but she had no interaction with the editors handling this manuscript. Footnotes Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Supplementary information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1038/s44168-025-00318-2. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Information Data Availability Statement Available from the authors upon request. N/A. No custom code was used.