Qualitative Factors Impacting Patients and Clinicians Regarding Intravitreal Injections for Retinal Disorders: A Scoping Review Authors: Andrew Ly, Evan Harnick, Tanisha Jowsey, Amy Jean Bannatyne Published: 2025 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundIntravitreal injections are among the most frequently performed eye procedures worldwide. They are vital in managing vision-related retinal conditions such as neovascular age-related macular degeneration, diabetic macular edema and retinal vein occlusion. This review scopes qualitative research concerning people’s beliefs, perspectives, experiences and behaviors towards intravitreal injections.MethodsAcademic databases (PubMed, Embase, CINAHL and Web of Science) were searched for studies focused on qualitative research of intravitreal injections in adult patients, published between January 2000 and May 2024. We extracted data regarding publication and participants’ characteristics, main study objectives, and methodological approaches.ResultsOf the 795 identified citations, 28 met the inclusion criteria. Most studies reported on patients’ emotional experiences of undergoing intravitreal injections, with the fear of vision loss compounded with ongoing injections prompting significant anxiety and uncertainty for patients. Other studies also reported on the physical component as the invasiveness of the procedure caused pain and discomfort, which varied with the clinician’s delivery of the injection. One study reported on clinician experiences of performing intravitreal injections, stating that the treatment decisions are dependent on patient-related factors such as their adherence to regular injections. Overall, qualitative research in ophthalmology is increasing, with most studies employing semi-structured interviews with thematic analysis.ConclusionQualitative research offers valuable insights into both patient and clinician experiences of intravitreal injections, which can shape person-centered and sustainable models of intravitreal treatment. Understanding qualitative factors such as personal experiences and barriers to treatment can refine the delivery of intravitreal injections and ultimately improve patient adherence.Keywords: qualitative research, intravitreal injections, anti-VEGF, ophthalmology, scoping review Introduction Qualitative research (QR) offers valuable insights into people’s experiences, beliefs, perspectives, and practices.1 QR helps us identify how and why people behave in certain ways, and how they make sense of their experiences.2 A conceptual framework study by Oben3 underscores the critical role of understanding patient experiences and behaviors in facilitating consistent and sustainable quality improvements in medical care. The past fifty years have seen increasing use of QR approaches to better understand and enhance patient and provider healthcare experiences.4,5 In ophthalmology, QR can explore the beliefs and preferences of both patients and healthcare professionals, translating these into opportunities for improved healthcare delivery.6 Despite its value, QR remains under-represented in ophthalmology journals.7 In 2017, Jones and Jefferis7 highlighted this gap and called for more qualitative studies to support ophthalmologists in delivering ophthalmic services. Similarly, Okada et al8 urged the use of qualitative approaches to better understand issues such as poor patient adherence and persistence with intravitreal injections. This scoping review examined whether these calls to action by previous researchers (eg, Jones & Jefferis,7 Okada et al8) have been attended to. We focused specifically on QR related to intravitreal injections, one of the most frequently performed eye procedures worldwide.9 These injections involve administering medication into the eye’s vitreous humour using a fine needle.9 The main type of intravitreal injections is anti-VEGF agents, which include aflibercept (Eylea), ranibizumab (Lucentis) and bevacizumab (Avastin).9 These are mainly used to treat retinal conditions such as neovascular age-related macular degeneration, diabetic macular edema, and retinal vein occlusion.9 Anti-VEGF agents are usually needed for long-term, and often for life.9 Initially, the frequency of injections is high to gain adequate control and preserve vision, but it often decreases as the patient’s condition stabilises.9 To guide our approach, we replicated the process used by Gisselbaek et al10 in their systematic scoping review of published QR on perioperative anesthesiology. Replication was designed to enable cross-disciplinary comparisons in how QR is conducted and reported, and to build a cumulative evidence base to inform improvements in the standard of QR reporting. At the same time, we aimed to identify discipline-specific gaps and reporting challenges unique to ophthalmology. Ultimately, QR can empower clinicians to gain a better understanding of the patient experiences undergoing intravitreal injections, and apply this knowledge to improve patients’ care, adherence and experience with the regularity of intravitreal therapy. Specifically, this review scopes QR regarding patients’ and ophthalmologists’ beliefs, perspectives, experiences, and behaviors towards intravitreal injections. Methods Study Design A preliminary search of MEDLINE, the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews and JBI Evidence Synthesis on 5th July 2024, identified no existing or ongoing systematic or scoping reviews on the topic. Based on this preliminary search, a scoping review was deemed the most appropriate approach. This method is particularly well suited to providing a comprehensive overview of literature in emerging or under-researched areas.11 As such, a scoping review was conducted using the Joanna Briggs Institute Population, Concept, and Context (PCC) methodology12 and the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR) checklist.13 The scoping review protocol was registered with Open Science Framework (OSF) on the 9th September 2024. The data were managed and stored using Covidence,14 an electronic review platform. The main results of this review, including “study characteristics of included studies” and “categorization of the main topic of research and objective of included studies”, are summarized in table format. Eligibility Criteria Table 1 shows the eligibility criteria as per the PCC framework.12 Table 1Population, Concept and Context Eligibility CriteriaPopulationAdult patients over the age of 18 years old receiving intravitreal injection.Ophthalmologists or ophthalmic nurses involved in delivering intravitreal injections.ConceptOriginal research using qualitative methods (as a standalone or integrated into mixed methods study) to explore patients’ and clinicians’ beliefs, perspectives, experiences, and behaviours related to delivering anti-VEGF intravitreal injections for aged-related macular degeneration, diabetic macular edema, and retinal vein occlusion.ContextAny clinical setting involving the delivery of intravitreal injections. Population, Concept and Context Eligibility Criteria Adult patients over the age of 18 years old receiving intravitreal injection. Adult patients over the age of 18 years old receiving intravitreal injection. Ophthalmologists or ophthalmic nurses involved in delivering intravitreal injections. Ophthalmologists or ophthalmic nurses involved in delivering intravitreal injections. Original research using qualitative methods (as a standalone or integrated into mixed methods study) to explore patients’ and clinicians’ beliefs, perspectives, experiences, and behaviours related to delivering anti-VEGF intravitreal injections for aged-related macular degeneration, diabetic macular edema, and retinal vein occlusion. Original research using qualitative methods (as a standalone or integrated into mixed methods study) to explore patients’ and clinicians’ beliefs, perspectives, experiences, and behaviours related to delivering anti-VEGF intravitreal injections for aged-related macular degeneration, diabetic macular edema, and retinal vein occlusion. Any clinical setting involving the delivery of intravitreal injections. Any clinical setting involving the delivery of intravitreal injections. Additional eligibility criteria not captured in the PCC framework were that included studies needed to be (a) full-text, peer-reviewed studies, (b) published or translated into English, and (c) published from January 2000 to May 2024. The year range was restricted as our preliminary research highlighted an increase in relevant studies from the year 2000 to the conception month of this study. We excluded records that were not journal articles (eg, conference abstracts, theses, book chapters), not a report of empirical research (eg, protocols, editorials), not focused on intravitreal injections (eg, simulation studies, education studies conducted outside of the clinical setting), and not reported or translated in English. We also excluded studies that involved animal subjects or pediatric patients. Search Strategy We designed our search strategy with the assistance of a Faculty Librarian. The three main pre-specified concepts for our search were “adult patients” or “ophthalmic clinicians” as the population, “intravitreal injections” as the type of intervention, and “qualitative research” as a type of study design. Refer to Table 1 for PCC eligibility criteria. We conducted a preliminary initial search of relevant literature on PubMed to understand the topic better and identify possible key terms to search in titles and abstracts. Key index terms contained in titles and abstracts of relevant studies were identified and adapted appropriately in the development of our complete search strategy. We also screened the thesaurus of PubMed (MeSH), Embase (EmTree), CINAHL, and Web of Science to find additional important keywords. Subsequently, a systematic search of the following electronic databases was undertaken from January 2000 to May 2024: PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, and Web of Science. The final search strategy for the four databases, including search strings, is reflected in Electronic Supplementary Material (ESM), eAppendix 1. To ensure all QR on this topic are captured, we also performed a hand/citation search of the included studies to identify any additional studies missed in the initial search. All identified citations were imported into Covidence, where duplicates were removed. Study Selection Two reviewers (AL & EH) independently screened the titles and abstracts of all studies identified via the search strategy, followed by the full-text reviews of relevant studies, using the eligibility criteria. Disagreements were resolved by consensus or with a third reviewer (TJ or AB). Data Extraction and Analyses Two independent reviewers (AL & EH) conducted a trial, extracting data from a small number of studies. Once consensus was achieved, data were extracted by one author (AL) from the included studies into tabular form. Broadly, information extracted included: publication characteristics; study aims and objectives; participant characteristics; study design (QR or mixed); QR theoretical framework; data collection methods; data analysis methods; and research quality criteria (see ESM, eAppendix 2 for details on the subcategories). As this study aimed to replicate the approach of Gisselbaek et al,10 all of the subcategories for extraction were pre-determined. The exception to this was extraction related to “main topic of research” and “general objective”. For research quality criteria, we identified whether or not studies had reported reflexivity, provided evidence to support their analytical claims,15 and stated ethical approval details. Reflexivity is defined as the act of examining one’s own assumptions, beliefs and judgement systems, and thinking carefully and critically about how this influences the research process.16 Following Peters et al,12 we grouped included studies into inductively generated categories, with topics of interest developed from evaluating the data. Extraction and charting issues were resolved through discussion among all authors for consensus. Once data extraction was completed, we summarized qualitative results and undertook descriptive statistics of included studies. Results The results of the search and screening process are depicted in Figure 1. The search yielded 795 results. Once duplicates were removed, 450 studies were title and abstract screened, with 370 studies excluded due to irrelevance to the topic of interest. Eighty full-text studies were assessed for eligibility, with 28 studies included in the review. The reasons for exclusion for the 52 excluded studies are shown in Figure 1. The final list of studies is provided in the ESM, eAppendix 3. The key characteristics and findings of the 28 included studies are shown in Tables 2 and 3. PRISMA Flowchart of included studies. Table 2Study Characteristics of Included StudiesStudies (Reference)Country where Study Was ConductedAim of The StudyType of StudyData Analysis MethodType of participants (Number of participants)Key FindingsAbu-Yaghi 202017JordanInvestigate compliance rates and factors influencing adherence to anti-VEGF treatment for DME among Jordanian patients.Mixed-methodsContent analysisDME (117)Patients who reported a subjective improvement in vision after treatment was a crucial aspect for long-term adherence to the treatment plan.Bhagat 202018USEvaluate patient preferences among those receiving intravitreal anti-VEGF therapy for the management of nAMD or DME.QRDiscrete choice conjoint analysisnAMD, DME (300)Key treatment attributes that influence patient treatment decisions include visual outcomes, financial considerations, treatment regimes, and drug label status.Bolme 202142NorwayExplore nurses’ level of confidence and control after completing the training program in performing intravitreal injections.QRThematic analysisNot specified (12)Nurses after undergoing a structured training program, felt confident and capable in administering intravitreal injections. While task-shifting can improve the workload of ophthalmologists, patients were less satisfied with the lack of information provided by nurses about management plans.Boyle 201819AustraliaExplore the subjective experiences and perceptions of patients undergoing repeated anti-VEGF injections for nAMD in relation to burden of therapy, treatment satisfaction and tolerability, the effect of patient education, and barriers/facilitators to treatment compliance.QRThematic analysisnAMD (40)The benefits of anti-VEGF therapy are seen in improvement in visual outcomes; however, the psychological burden on patients remains a critical concern. The treatment burden is multifaceted, and the elements that pose a burden to one patient are not necessarily the same for all. Some of these factors are procedure-related anxiety and pain, financial considerations, travel considerations, and impact on lifestyle.Burton 201320UKInvestigate the subjective experiences of patients treated with anti-VEGF injections.Mixed-methodsThematic analysisnAMD (7)Four main themes emerged that all contribute to a patient’s ability to adhere to their treatment course, which include preparation for treatment, the treatment process, patient-provider communication, and results of treatment.Cavan 201721BelgiumHighlights experiences of DR screening and treatment.Mixed-methodsQualitative descriptionDR (6669)Reveals significant disparities in screening coverage and experiences across different regions, emphasising the necessity for tailored strategies to enhance service delivery.Curran 202222VietnamTo better understand patients’ and ophthalmologists’ perspectives in order to improve patient care and service provision in Vietnam.QRThematic analysisDR (42)There is a critical need for accessible and affordable treatment options to prevent vision loss, emphasising the importance of understanding both medical and patient-related factors in treatment decisions. To encourage long-term adherence, positive patient-practitioner interactions are encouraged.Emsfors 201743SwedenTo identify and describe nursing actions performed by nursing staff that create a sense of good nursing care in patients with nAMD.QRThematic analysisnAMD (16)The importance of personalised care and patient empowerment are crucial for enhancing patient experiences during treatment. A person-centred approach can be achieved with the inclusion of patients’ narratives in the development of a personal care plan for those who receive intravitreal injections.Enoch 202223UKExplore the overall acceptability of current intravitreal treatments in late-stage development for a sample of GA patients.Mixed-methodsFramework analysisGeographic Atrophy (30)There is a generally positive attitude towards these treatments, despite concerns regarding their efficacy and logistical demand associated with frequent and potentially lifelong treatment.Fajnkuchen 202024FranceExplore the impact on daily life, knowledge, fears and expectations about disease and treatment in patients with DME treated with intravitreal injections.QRThematic analysisDME (20)There is importance in understanding patient psychology to enhance treatment compliance and satisfaction; however, it is essential to consider that some patients may have differing perspectives, potentially viewing their treatment as a manageable aspect of their diabetes care rather than a source of anxiety.Giocanti-Aurégan 202225USA, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, SpainTo better understand the context of current anti-VEGF intravitreal injection standard of care, including treatment experiences, ophthalmologists’ definitions of non-adherence, drivers and barriers to adherence in nAMD and DME from patients’, caregivers’, and ophthalmologists’ perspectives in a multinational setting.QRThematic analysisnAMD, DME (235)Key drivers to adherence to intravitreal injections include doctor-patient relationship, patient education, and ease of appointment booking. Major barriers to adherence include treatment tolerability, logistical challenges, and routine disruptions. Each demographic population weighed each aspect differently depending on their personal experiences, which means developing individualised management strategies may be effective.Giocanti-Aurégan 201826FranceAssess the impact of new anti-VEGF-related societal factors on functional outcomes in nAMD patients.QRRetrospective analysisnAMD (94)Key societal factors such as family support, disease burden, transportation, follow-up, marital status, and daily reading can either aid in the healing process or contribute to disease progression.Granström 201844SwedenTo qualitatively describe patients’ thoughts and feelings about treatment, knowledge of the relationship between DME and visual impairment, and if and how visual impairment affects daily life.QRContent analysisDME (21)Patients often reported feelings of anxiety and apprehension regarding the treatment process, primarily due to a lack of understanding about what to expect. The apprehension experienced by patients before treatment could influence their willingness to proceed with anti-VEGF therapy.Iida 201625JapanHow proactive therapy is used to treat nAMD in clinical practices in Japan and how the different regimens impact patient, caregiver, and ophthalmologist experiences.QRQualitative descriptionnAMD (20)Reduced frequency of anti-VEGF injections leads to a lower emotional burden for both patients and caregivers, and hence patients preferred a Treat and Extend (T&E) strategy as opposed to Pro Re Nata (PRN) approach.McCloud 201528AustraliaTo understand the patients’ experience of nAMD, including ongoing treatment with anti-VEGF, with the intention of informing clinical practice.QRThematic analysisnAMD (25)Many patients expressed anxiety concerning anti-VEGF injections yet also conveyed gratitude for the treatment’s potential benefits. For patients who had uneventful and painless experiences, reveals that alleviating anxiety can be achieved by minimising the pain of the injection.Midena 202229ItalyTo explore the experiences of patients affected by nAMD in the healthcare pathway for the management of the disease, using a narrative medicine (NM) approach and the patient journey mapping process with a particular focus on analysing the real sequence and development of the disease management, the quality and flaws of care, and the patient’s global perception of the journey.QRNarrative analysisnAMD (205)Underscores the challenges faced by nAMD patients, including the psychological discomfort in terms of anxiety and stress and functional impacts of nAMD such as daily activities on patient management plans. Improvements in patient-practitioner communication can reduce psychological discomfort and increase compliance.Reitan 202330NorwayTo document patient-reported outcomes on how the disease and the treatment impact nAMD patients in Norway.QRContent analysisnAMD (130)Treatment burden included an emotional impact with a substantial number of patients reporting anxiety and stress related to the treatment, and a physical discomfort with over half of the patients describing treatment as uncomfortable and somewhat painful.Senra 201731UKTo investigate the patient experience of receiving anti-VEGF treatment for nAMD, with a particular focus on patient sources of anxiety related to anti-VEGF treatment.Mixed-methodsContent analysisnAMD (400)Anti-VEGF therapy is generally well-received; however, it is accompanied by psychological challenges such as anxiety and depression that warrant further attention. Most frequent sources of anxiety related to intravitreal injections were the fear of going blind as well as concerns about vision getting worse, and not necessarily the procedure itself.Sii 201832UKTo explore changes in patients’ expectations during a course of intravitreal treatment for nAMD.QRThematic analysisnAMD (50)The need for effective counselling at the treatment’s onset to align patient expectations, especially addressing pain and anxiety, with potential outcomes, improves patients’ adherence.Spooner 201833AustraliaTo quantify the burden and quality of life of patients and their caregivers in a cohort of patients with nAMD in an Australian clinical setting.QRThematic analysisnAMD (103)Managing nAMD not only affects visual health but also imposes substantial QoL challenges, especially mental well-being. Patients’ concerns about health and well-being in chronic retinal diseases represented a psychological burden which affects treatment compliance and continuance.Talks 202334France, Germany, UKTo gain insights into the emotions and experiences of patients with nAMD with regards to treatment, to understand the determinants of adherence, and to identify where meaningful interventions to support improved outcomes can be developed.QRThematic analysisnAMD (17)There is a complex interplay of emotions and feelings surrounding the treatment of nAMD and hence emphasises the importance of understanding patient perspectives to enhance care. Strengthening the patient-practitioner relationship can offer a personalised approach to care.Thetford 201335UKTo report the results of patient experiences of receiving treatment for nAMD with ranibizumab.QRThematic analysisnAMD (22)While patients initially felt apprehensive, their actual experiences were often more positive than anticipated. Many of the patients’ fears were rooted in the “unknown” experience, and the feeling of anxiety was alleviated after receiving the first injection.Thier 202236GermanyTo explore patients’ experiences with nAMD in Germany during the injection process and how they deal with it.Mixed-methodsThematic analysisnAMD (22)There is significant discomfort and anxiety associated with treatment, which can provoke some to discontinue therapy. Positive interactions with healthcare providers were crucial for improving patient experiences and treatment adherence.Thinggaard 202337DenmarkTo investigate patient-reported barriers to the recommended treatment for nAMD and their impact on quality of life.QRThematic analysisnAMD (21)Patient demonstrated a strong commitment to their intravitreal treatments, often prioritising their health despite reported barriers such as commute to treatment, hospital barriers, and health literacy. Adopting more patient-centred approaches can enhance patient satisfaction and improve treatment adherence.Vennedey 201638GermanyTo predict patients’ preferences for characteristics of treatment options for nAMD.Mixed-methodsConjoint analysisnAMD (86)Patients showed a significant preference for treatments that improve visual function, are approved, and follow a pro re nata (PRN) regimen.Wolfram 202339GermanyTo assess the care situation of patients who received anti-VEGF treatment.QRContent analysisnAMD, DME, RVO (2300)There were both logistical and psychological challenges to undergoing continuous anti-VEGF treatment. Understanding patients’ needs and fears is a prerequisite to explaining motivation and commitment to treatment.Yiallouridou 202340UKTo identify key variations in the intravitreal injection procedure that may influence pain, and to gain insights into the post-injection experience and treatment adherence from the perspective of patients and practitioners.QRThematic analysisnAMD (21)Supporting patients by developing rapport can help patients recognise the necessity of ongoing intravitreal treatment to prevent sight loss; however, inadequate pain management can lead to undesirable outcomes and ultimately patient non-adherence.Zografos 201941France, Germany, Italy, Spain, UKTo measure receipt of educational materials and to evaluate understanding of key safety information for aflibercept.QRQuantitative descriptionnAMD, DME, RVO (1201)Observed patterns of knowledge indicated the greatest knowledge of the most important risks emphasised in the educational material and lower knowledge of more complex or less salient aspects of safe use.Abbreviations: nAMD, Neovascular Age-Related Macular Degeneration; DME, Diabetic Macular Edema; DR, Diabetic Retinopathy; RVO, Retinal Vein Occlusion. Study Characteristics of Included Studies Abbreviations: nAMD, Neovascular Age-Related Macular Degeneration; DME, Diabetic Macular Edema; DR, Diabetic Retinopathy; RVO, Retinal Vein Occlusion. Table 3Categorisation of the Main Topic of Research and Objective of Included StudiesMain Topic of Research(N = number of studies)Objectives of InvestigationNumber ofStudies (n/total N)Studies IncludedBarriers to best care (N = 9)Identify non-medical barriers to treatmentIdentify barriers to treatment complianceIdentify societal barriers to treatment burdenUnderstand the acceptability of intravitreal injection as a treatment option5/92/91/91/9Bhagat,18 Boyle,19 Cavan,21 Reitan,30 Spooner33Abu-Yaghi,17 Thinggaard37Giocanti-Aurégan26Enoch23Experiences of care (N = 8)Understand the experiences of patients undergoing treatmentExplore how anxiety (psychological distress) can impact clinical careIdentify patient’s preferences for treatment attributesIdentify drivers for adherence to treatment plan4/82/81/81/8Burton,20 Fajnkuchen,24 Granström,44 McCloud28Senra,31 Wolfram39Vennedey38Giocanti-Aurégan25Patients’ experiences undergoing intravitreal injections (N = 7)Identify the emotions linked with intravitreal injectionExplore the experience of pain during treatmentDescribe how treatment experiences influence adherence4/72/71/7Curran,22 Midena,29 Sii,32 Thetford35Thier,36 Yiallouridou40Talks34Patients/healthcare professionals’ interaction (N = 2)Explore how attitudes and emotions are important factors in adherenceUnderstand how empowering individuals affects clinical care1/21/2Yiallouridou40Emsfors43Implementation of changes in clinical practice (N = 2)Understand and improve clinical care through feedbackExplore how to integrate nurses in performing intravitreal injections1/21/2Iida27Bolme42Transfer of information (N = 1)Identify relevant information in educational materials1/1Zografos41Ophthalmologists’ experiences performing intravitreal injections(N = 1)Understand the factors that influence treatment decisions1/1Curran22 Categorisation of the Main Topic of Research and Objective of Included Studies Study Characteristics Most included studies (89%, n = 25)17–41 were published in medical journals, with the remaining 11% (n = 3)42–44 published in nursing journals. Over the past two decades, there has been a consistent trend in the publication of qualitative studies related to intravitreal injections in ophthalmology (see Figure 2). Number of qualitative publications per year within the scope of the review. The X-axis is the year, and the Y-axis indicates the number of publications. Most of the studies (64%, n = 18) were conducted in European countries, with the United Kingdom contributing the largest number (n = 6).20,23,31,32,35,40 Other European countries represented were Germany (n = 3),36,38,39 France (n = 2),24,26 Sweden (n = 2),43,44 Norway (n = 2),30,42 Denmark (n = 1),37 Belgium (n = 1),21 and Italy (n = 1).29 Studies from Oceania accounted for three publications,19,28,33 all from Australia. In Asia, there were three studies conducted in Vietnam (n = 1),22 Japan (n = 1),27 and Jordan (n = 1).17 Only one study18 was conducted in North America, specifically the United States. Main Topic of Research and General Objective Out of 14 pre-determined main topics of research (as per Gisselbaek et al10), the included studies investigated seven main topics of research: barriers to best care (32%; n = 9), patient experiences of care (29%; n = 8), and patients’ experiences undergoing intravitreal injections (25%; n = 7). Less commonly explored topics included: patient-healthcare professional interactions (7%; n = 2), implementation of changes to clinical practice (7%; n = 2), transfer of information (4%; n = 1), and ophthalmologists’ experiences of performing intravitreal injections (4%; n = 1). Two studies addressed more than one of the main topics. Specific research objectives varied within each main topic. Table 3 summarizes the study topics and corresponding research objectives of included studies. ESM eAppendix 3 provides detailed information for each included publication. Research Team Characteristics Most studies (68%, n = 19) were conducted by multi-professional teams,20–23,25,27,28,30–32,34–40,42,44 while the remaining nine studies (32%, n = 9) were led by uni-professional teams comprising either nurses only, ophthalmologists only or other professionals only.17–19,24,26,29,33,41,43 Participants Characteristics Nearly all included studies (96%, n = 27) focused exclusively on patient experiences,17–21,23–44 with only one study22 examining the experiences of ophthalmologists alone. Study Design and Theoretical Framework Most included studies (75%, n = 21) employed a single-method QR approach, while seven (25%) reported using a mixed-methods design. The study design for included studies is shown in Table 2. Notably, 64% (n = 19) of the qualitative studies did not specify a theoretical framework or epistemology.17–19,21,22,24,26,27,29–33,35,38–41,44 Among those that did (n = 9), they reported grounded theory (11%, n = 3),25,34,36 phenomenology (7%, n = 2),20,28 critical incident technique (4%, n = 1),43 epistemological framework (4%, n = 1),37 inductive descriptive design (4%, n = 1),42 and framework method of analysis (4%, n = 1).23 Data Collection Method As shown in Table 4, the most commonly reported method was individual interviews, either semi-structured (57%, n = 16) or in-depth (11%, n = 3). Surveys and questionnaires with an open text component were the second most frequently used data collection method (32%, n = 9). Table 4Data Collection MethodsData Collection Methods*Medical Journals (n)Nursing Journals (n)Total (N)Semi-structured interviews1331617,20–23,25,27,29,34,36,37,40,42,43In-depth interviews30319,28,34Surveys/Questionnaires90918,24,30–33,38,39,41Note: *Some studies reported multiple collection methods. Data Collection Methods Note: *Some studies reported multiple collection methods. Data Analysis Method Half of the included studies (54%, n = 15) reported that they undertook thematic analysis. Other reported modes of analysis included content analysis (18%, n = 5), qualitative description (11%, n = 3), conjoint analysis (7%, n = 2), framework analysis (4%, n = 1), narrative analysis (4%, n = 1), and retrospective analysis (4%, n = 1). The data analysis methods for each study are shown in Table 2. Summary of Qualitative Research Findings The summary of qualitative findings are presented in Table 2. Patient Experiences Most of the studies included in this review explored patients’ emotional experiences with receiving intravitreal anti-VEGF injections for retinal conditions such as neovascular age-related macular degeneration, diabetic macular edema, and retinal vein occlusion. A key concern reported by many patients was the realization that they may need multiple injections and lifelong treatment.23 For some, treatment represented hope and an opportunity for improved or preserved vision.20 Burton et al20 highlighted that patients were often willing to endure the associated distress of an invasive procedure in order to maintain vision. Burton et al20 also accentuates that time spent with patients to alleviate their concerns is vital for their emotional well-being and may prevent patients from ceasing their treatment. Fajnkuchen et al24 noted that, as an invasive procedure, intravitreal injections frequently elicited stress and anxiety for patients. Fears of vision loss were intensified by the recurring nature of the injections, leading some patients to experience existential concerns about losing their vision and how to cope with everyday life.44 Importantly, these anxieties appeared to persist regardless of treatment stage, being reported by both newly diagnosed and longer-term patients.31 However, Thetford et al35 found that patients’ initial feelings of anxiety and apprehension about intravitreal injections often reduced following the first injection, as many of their fears were tied to the uncertainty of the procedure being an “unknown” experience. Particularly, there were aspects of procedure that caused pain and discomfort, in particular, the application of anaesthetic and use of surgical drapes along with the needle entry itself, which if addressed effectively, can help reduce anxiety levels.35 In addition to emotional responses, the physical aspects of intravitreal injections also contributed to heightened anxiety.32 Anticipation of pain was a common concern, particularly among patients undergoing their first injection.29 Thier et al36 reported variability in pain experiences based on factors such as the clinician administering the injection, the dosage and timing of anaesthetic, and procedural differences, including the location of injection and the time delay between applying the anaesthetic and the injection itself. While the pain sensation varied, all of the patients described feeling the sting of the injection, despite the anaesthetic given.36 Yiallouridou et al40 further noted that post-injection ocular pain, including soreness and irritation lasting up to 36 hours, was more prevalent than previously acknowledged, which can be addressed to improve the patient experience. However, not all patients reported pain or distress; for some, the injection was uneventful and associated with low levels of anxiety.28 Access to Healthcare Services Several studies reported on barriers to accessing and maintaining intravitreal injection treatment. Curran et al22 examined structural challenges in Vietnam, where high treatment costs and transportation costs along with distance from clinics, frequently disrupted patient access. Access to healthcare services was similarly identified by Thinggaard et al,37 who found that while Denmark’s tax-funded system reduced the financial burden, transport and commuting (particularly for patients reliant on public transport) remained significant obstacles. Similarly, in Australia, Spooner et al33 noted that despite government subsidies for anti-VEGF injections through the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme,45 patients still incurred personal expenses for mobility aids, low-vision equipment, and home modifications. The ALBATROS study by Wolfram et al39 provided a comprehensive categorization of treatment barriers, identifying four main domains that influence patients’ treatment decisions: tolerability, clinical factors, logistical issues, and human factors. Quality of Care A minority of the studies reported on the quality of care associated with intravitreal injections. Yiallouridou et al40 demonstrated that patient-practitioner interactions play a crucial role in shaping patients’ understanding of treatment expectations and individual needs, enabling more tailored advice for managing pain before and immediately after injection. Curran et al22 also underpins the importance of positive patient–practitioner interactions built from previous appointments that encouraged patients to adhere to the recommended series of treatments. Similarly, Wolfram et al39 recognize that a key role in maintaining adherence was seen in the quality of the relationship between patient and clinician, especially through actively assessing and addressing patients regularly along the course of treatment. Comparably, for ophthalmic nurses, Emsfors et al43 described how nurses being respectful, engaged and present in consultations improved the quality of care as patients responded well to treatment due to increased participation in the decision-making process. Additionally, the quality of care was impacted by changes in clinical practice. Given that intravitreal injections are among the most frequently performed eye procedures worldwide,9 the shortage of ophthalmologists has placed significant pressure on ophthalmology departments worldwide, including the National Health Service in England.46 Bolme et al42 revealed that following a training program, nurses felt confident and in control when administering intravitreal injections, suggesting that performing intravitreal injections can shift from ophthalmologists to nurses in the near future. In contrast, Iida and Ishii27 examined different treatment regimens for intravitreal therapy, each with associated advantages and disadvantages. The Treat and Extend (T&E) approach involved an increased number of injections and associated financial burden; however, it decreased emotional burden for patients by offering reassurance their condition was being actively managed.27 In comparison, the pro re nata (PRN) regimen involved fewer injections, but was associated with increased anxiety, as patients feared receiving “bad news” and the possibility of unexpected injections in response to disease exacerbations.27 Moreover, Zografos et al41 explored how information is transferred between ophthalmologists and patients regarding the safety and proper use of Aflibercept (Eylea), a common intravitreal medication. This study demonstrated that patients possessed relatively high levels of knowledge despite low reported receipt of educational materials, suggesting that patients were obtaining information from sources other than their ophthalmologists.41 Ophthalmologist Experiences Only one study reported on ophthalmologists’ experiences with intravitreal injections.22 Curran et al22 explored the factors influencing ophthalmologists’ treatment decisions and their recommendations for improving care for patients at risk of requiring, or already receiving, intravitreal injections. Three common factors that shaped treatment plans included: medical considerations (ie, severity of disease, benefits, and risks), availability (ie, treatment and resources), and patient-related factors (ie, costs and adherence).22 Ophthalmologists postulated that balancing realistic treatment goals with these factors may improve the care for patients requiring intravitreal injections.22 Comprehending patient-related factors such as personal experiences, financial situation, and transportation logistics can address poor patient adherence in long courses of intravitreal therapy.22 Research Quality Reflexivity Reflexivity was addressed in varying degrees across the included studies. Potential research subjectivity and limitations were acknowledged in 23 studies (82%).17–20,22–25,27–38,40–42 However, only three studies explicitly described steps taken to actively mitigate researcher biases (11%).17,34,40 Selection bias was identified as a concern in four studies (14%).20,24,31,42 Positionality statements, which are considered good practice in qualitative research as they offer insights into researchers’ identities and perspectives,47 were included in only four studies (14%).22,36–38 Presentation of Evidence to Support Analysis Claims Just over half of the included studies (54%, n = 15) transcribed and presented verbatim participant quotes to illustrate their analytical interpretations and support study conclusions.19–23,25,28,34–37,40,42–44 Ethical Review Twenty-seven studies (96%) reported they had sought and obtained approval from a registered human ethics research board.17–19,21–44 Discussion This systematic scoping review aimed to map and synthesize qualitative research exploring human lived experiences of intravitreal injections in ophthalmology. To our knowledge, this is the first review to focus specifically on qualitative inquiry in this context. The review included 28 studies, the majority of which employed interview-based data collection and were published in the past two decades, indicating growing interest in qualitative methodologies within ophthalmic research. While this upward trend is promising, our review also highlights variability in methodological rigor and reporting quality across studies. Methodological Patterns and Gaps Most studies utilised individual interviews, typically semi-structured, as their primary method of data collection, and thematic analysis as the most common approach to data interpretation. These methods, while accessible and widely used, often reflect pragmatic rather than theoretically grounded research. Only a small number of studies explicitly reported their epistemological stance or theoretical framework. This limited transparency makes it difficult to assess how researchers’ philosophical positions informed the design, conduct, and interpretation of their studies. Reflexivity was inconsistently reported. Although 82% of included studies acknowledged potential subjectivity and limitations, only a few articulated the steps taken to mitigate researcher bias, and just four studies included positionality statements. Verbatim quotes, an important marker of qualitative trustworthiness, were used in only half the studies. These gaps reflect similar concerns raised by Gisselbaek et al10 in their review of 107 qualitative studies in perioperative anesthesiology. While that review uncovered a rich array of patient and clinician experiences with the potential to shape clinical practice, many of the included studies were poorly reported, with essential methodological details often missing.10 Our review identified similar patterns. Nine studies reported qualitative results of the open-ended questions in their questionnaires. While we have included these, the data richness was variable. Nearly all studies documented ethical approval and discussed study limitations and sources of subjectivity. However, as with the broader dataset, only half included verbatim quotes to support their findings, limiting the reader’s ability to evaluate the credibility of interpretations. Overall, these methodological limitations underscore the need for qualitative researchers in ophthalmology to adopt established reporting standards such as the Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ) and the Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research (SRQR). Doing so would enhance methodological transparency, support critical appraisal, and strengthen the contribution of qualitative research to ophthalmic care. Encouragingly, our review revealed a steady increase in qualitative research publications over the past two decades, with approximately 90% of included studies published in medical journals. This growth reflects a rising interest in exploring patient and clinician perspectives within ophthalmology. However, as in anaesthesiology,10 the reporting of qualitative studies remains inconsistent. Few studies clearly articulated the philosophical assumptions guiding their research, and most relied on relatively straightforward qualitative methods, such as semi-structured interviews and thematic analysis. These approaches, while practical and time-efficient, may limit the depth and theoretical contribution of findings when not rigorously executed or clearly contextualized. Insights Into the Patient Experience The included studies offered valuable insights into patients’ perceptions and experiences of receiving intravitreal injections. A dominant theme across the literature was the profound significance patients placed on maintaining their vision.20 Intravitreal injections were often viewed as essential, sometimes even life-defining, interventions to preserve sight.23 This is consistent with broader sensory anthropology literature,48 where vision is frequently positioned as the most privileged sense. Regardless of whether one accepts the hierarchy of the senses, for the patients in these studies, preserving sight was clearly central to their identity, independence, and quality of life. Anxiety and fear associated with the injection procedure were also commonly reported. These emotional responses have clinical significance. Previous research has demonstrated that anxiety can negatively impact treatment adherence and health outcomes across a range of chronic conditions.49 Given that many ophthalmic conditions requiring intravitreal injections are chronic and progressive, these findings highlight the importance of integrating psychological support into routine care. Some studies also identified non-ophthalmic factors such as barriers impacting access to intravitreal treatment, including economic and transportation costs influencing treatment adherence. These factors can impact treatment decisions, such as determining an appropriate frequency of injections to improve treatment adherence. For instance, Ashrafzadeh’s retrospective analysis50 during the COVID-19 pandemic revealed that demographic and socio-contextual factors affected treatment continuity. These findings underscore the need for equity-informed, patient-centered approaches that consider the broader social determinants of health. Clinicians Perspectives Although less frequently studied, one included paper explored the experiences of ophthalmologists performing intravitreal injections and how their perspective can translate in improved clinical outcomes.22 This study highlighted how clinician awareness of patient fears, barriers to adherence, and systemic pressures could shape more realistic and empathic care plans. A systematic review by Ehlken et al51 exploring non-adherence and non-persistence in intravitreal injections, similarly, emphasized the importance of clinician insight into potential barriers in improving clinical outcomes. Expanding research into the experiences and perspectives of ophthalmologists represents a valuable direction for future inquiry. Implications for Practice The insights generated by QR into intravitreal injections have practical implications. First, the recurrent theme of anxiety highlights a need for enhanced communication strategies and psychological support interventions. Second, the importance placed on preserving sight suggests that clinical interactions should centre not only on biomedical outcomes but also on personal goals and living priorities. Finally, improved understanding of clinician perspectives could inform interventions to support both patients and providers in managing the long-term demands of chronic eye conditions. Strengths and Limitations A key strength of this review is its novel focus on qualitative literature in ophthalmology, which has received relatively little attention in previous reviews. By including both interview-based and open-ended questionnaire studies, we captured a broad range of perspectives. However, limitations include the exclusion of pediatric studies and treatments beyond intravitreal injections. Additionally, data extraction was completed by a single reviewer and checked by others, rather than being independently conducted by multiple reviewers, which may have introduced bias. Future Directions Future reviews should explore qualitative studies focusing on other ophthalmic procedures and include pediatric populations, whose experiences may differ considerably from adults. There is also a need for deeper exploration of clinician perspectives, as well as co-produced research that engages patients as partners. Across all future studies, clear articulation of philosophical underpinnings, reflexivity, and methodological transparency should be prioritized to strengthen the credibility and utility of findings. Conclusion This review affirms the central importance of sight to patients and highlights the psychological complexities surrounding intravitreal injection treatments, which, if addressed appropriately, can foster stronger patient-centered ophthalmic management. Important qualitative factors, such as patient and clinician personal experiences and barriers to treatment can be focused upon to improve the manner in which intravitreal treatment is delivered to patients. These qualitative findings provide meaningful insights into how intravitreal injections impact patients in terms of emotional burden and discomfort, which clinicians and nurses are able to address these factors and coordinate compassionate, effective, and equitable ophthalmic care. Acknowledgments The authors would like to thank Sarah Bateup, Faculty Librarian, Bond University, for her invaluable assistance in designing our search strategy. Funding Statement This study was supported by the Bond University MD Program. No external funding was received for this study. Data Sharing Statement The authors confirm that the data supporting the findings of the study are available within the article and its supplementary materials. Ethics Approval This scoping review did not involve human participants or the collection of primary data and was therefore exempt from ethics approval, in accordance with Bond University Human Research Ethics Committee (BUHREC) and the National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research (2023). Author Contributions All authors made a significant contribution to the work reported, whether that is in the conception, study design, execution, acquisition of data, analysis and interpretation, or in all these areas; took part in drafting, revising or critically reviewing the article; gave final approval of the version to be published; have agreed on the journal to which the article has been submitted; and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work. Disclosure The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work. References Associated Data Data Availability Statement The authors confirm that the data supporting the findings of the study are available within the article and its supplementary materials.