The Efficacy of Benson Relaxation for Managing Psychological Distress in Primipostpartum Women: A Systematic Review Authors: Munusamy Lakshmi, Raju Naganandini Published: 2024 ABSTRACT ABSTRACTBackground:The Benson Relaxation Technique, a mind-body approach, has been proposed as an effective intervention for prime-postnatal mothers to alleviate stress, anxiety, and depression.Objective:The study aims to comprehensively analyze and synthesize the existing literature on the influence of the Benson Relaxation Technique on psychological factors such as stress, anxiety, and depression among primi-postnatal mothers.Methods:A literature search spanning 2013-2024 analyzed studies on Benson Relaxation Technique’s impact on psychological parameters in primi-postnatal mothers, assessing changes in these parameters through validated scales.Results:The Benson Relaxation Technique significantly reduced stress, anxiety, and depression in primi-postnatal mothers, with some studies showing moderate to large effects.Conclusion:The Benson Relaxation Technique, a potentially effective intervention for reducing stress and anxiety in postnatal mothers, warrants further research for its long-term effects and mechanisms. INTRODUCTION Postpartum, or puerperium, is a crucial phase for mothers, involving physical, emotional, and psychological adjustments, causing stress, anxiety, and depression, impacting mother-infant bonding and family dynamics.[1] The Benson Relaxation Technique (BRT), a non-pharmacological intervention for postpartum mental health, has gained attention for its simplicity and potential efficacy.[2] Studies show relaxation techniques, specifically deep breathing (BRT), can reduce anxiety and depression in postpartum women by lowering cortisol levels and increasing parasympathetic nervous system activity, thereby promoting relaxation and recovery.[3] This systematic review aims to assess the Benson Relaxation Technique’s impact on stress, anxiety, and depression in primi-postnatal mothers, highlighting the need to understand its efficacy in this demographic, as they may have different experiences.[4] Rationale for review Postpartum mothers experience emotional and psychological changes, including stress, anxiety, and depression, impacting their well-being and mother-infant relationship, necessitating effective interventions to promote mental health.[5] Postpartum depression and anxiety management is influenced by factors like breastfeeding and personal preferences, prompting a growing interest in non-pharmacological interventions like Benson Relaxation Technique (BRT).[6] This systematic review evaluates the Benson Relaxation Technique (BRT) for primi-postnatal mothers, focusing on its impact on stress, anxiety, depression, and overall psychological well-being. The results will inform clinical practice, guiding healthcare providers in recommending appropriate interventions and promoting comprehensive maternal mental health strategies. MATERIAL AND METHOD A comprehensive search was conducted on pertinent electronic databases including PubMed, MEDLINE, Embase, and Cochrane Library. We performed an extensive literature search utilizing many electronic databases, such as PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and PsycINFO. The search included research published till [Insert Date]. The search approach used various combinations of keywords such as “Benson Relaxation Technique,” “primi-postnatal mothers,” “postpartum,” “stress,” “anxiety,” “depression,” and “psychological well-being.” In addition, manual searches were conducted on reference lists of pertinent research and review articles to discover any supplementary studies. The study includes studies on primi-postnatal mothers, Benson Relaxation Technique (BRT), quantitative psychological parameters, randomized controlled trials, quasi-experimental studies, and English-published full texts. Exclusion criteria include studies on mothers with specific medical conditions, non-Benson Relaxation Technique, quantitative psychological outcomes, published in languages other than English, and abstracts, conference proceedings, and unpublished theses or dissertations. Data extraction Two reviewers separately extracted data using a standardized data extraction form. The retrieved data included research attributes such as author, publication year, and country, as well as participant demographics, intervention specifics (including duration, frequency, and particular behaviors related to BRT), comparator groups, outcome measures, and significant results. Reviewers’ discrepancies were handled by engaging in conversation or seeking input from a third reviewer. Quality assessment The study utilized multiple resources, including search engines, to search for online references. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were documented, and selected studies underwent rigorous quality assessment. A comprehensive technique was developed to determine the appropriate sample group. A systematic review summarizes literature on a single question, identifying, appraising, and synthesizing evidence. Data collection strategies Data were collected from various databases and meta-data was transferred into EndNote. The inclusion and exclusion criteria were set using the PICO framework, which helps structure qualitative research questions and identify relevant themes. This approach ensures reliable, accurate, complete, and accessible data for conclusions. The study focuses on pre-postnatal mothers and uses the Benson Relaxation Technique (BRT) as an intervention, comparing it to usual care and alternative therapies. The search for nursing literature was limited to studies over 10 years old, English-language articles, and articles from CINAHL, Medline, and PubMed. The search was filtered using Boolean operators, ensuring relevant and informative content. This enabled to narrow overall search to 28 articles from CINAHL, 39 from Medline, and 75 from PubMed. Researchers used a PRISMA flow diagram to determine which articles were selected from a total of 142 articles. Several items were omitted due to their lack of relevance to the study issue. Subsequently, researchers eliminated any duplicate entries and proceeded to get the abstracts from each individual publication. Furthermore, we eliminated publications that did not address meta-analysis, resulting in a final selection of six studies that fulfilled the requirements for this systematic review and were therefore included. The study identified 117 potentially relevant studies but was excluded due to design issues and lack of detailed scientific analysis and implementation of standard operating protocols, with the reasons for each exclusion listed. RESULTS As shown in table 1, the study will critique and analyze six studies spanning three months to two years using a methodological framework from the Oxford Centre for Triple Value Healthcare Ltd, with a table providing an overview of each article. Table 1Studies on Benson Relaxation Therapy for Postpartum and Pregnant WomenAuthor/s YearSample/settingMethodology and methodsMain findings(Soumya Raj & Pillai, 2021)[7]60 postcesarean mothersThe study utilized a quasi-experimental design at Amrita Hospital, Kochi, with 60 post-cesarean mothers randomly selected from 30 groups.Benson’s relaxation therapy, administered by a midwife, has been proven to effectively alleviate pain and stress in postpartum mothers.(Rinhring & D Chanu, 2021)[8]30 antenatal mothersA study of 30 high-risk antenatal mothers found that 63.3% had severe anxiety symptoms before intervention, 30% had severe symptoms, and 53.3% were asymptomatic post-intervention, using a structured questionnaire and Perinatal Screening Anxiety Scale.The study reveals a significant difference in anxiety levels between pre-test and post-test scores, indicating the effectiveness of a simple, mind-body intervention for antenatal mothers with high-risk pregnancies.(Solehati & Rustina, 2015)[9]Post cesarean section women in experimental (n=30) or control group (n=30)A study at Cibabat Hospital Cimahi compared post-cesarean section women to an experimental group receiving Benson relaxation technique, and a control group receiving regular care, measuring pain severity using visual analogue scales before and after the intervention.The study revealed a significant (P=0.001) difference in pain intensity between CG and IG, with IG showing more pain reduction than CG, suggesting Benson relaxation could help reduce post-cesarean pain.(Abu Maloh et al., 2022)[10]Thirty-six participantsA clinical trial was conducted in two governmental hospitals to assess the effectiveness of Benson’s Relaxation on pain and perceived stress in hemodialysis patients, with an intervention group performing Benson’s Relaxation twice daily for 8 weeks.Benson’s Relaxation significantly alleviated pain and post-operative stress in haemodialysis patients, but not after a week of practice.(Saad Soliman et al., n.d.)[11]108 women with nausea and vomitingA quasi-experimental study was conducted at Benha University Hospital’s Obstetric and Gynaecological Out-Patient Clinic, focusing on women with nausea and vomiting. The sample consisted of both study and control groups, and data was collected using a structured interviewing questionnaire, a maternal knowledge questionnaire, a modified PUQE scale, and a Women’s Satisfaction Sheet.The study found that Benson’s relaxation technique effectively reduces nausea and vomiting during pregnancy.(Abarghoee et al., 2022)[12]105 women scheduled for cesarean section.A randomized controlled trial involving 105 women for a cesarean section found that BRT and MT groups performed exercises and listened to music for 20 minutes before the procedure, with anxiety levels measured before and after the intervention.BRT and MT effectively reduce anxiety in primiparous women before cesarean section, providing safe, cost-effective, and improved well-being, and can be used alongside pharmacologic methods to reduce medication overreliance. Studies on Benson Relaxation Therapy for Postpartum and Pregnant Women Raj and Pillai’s 2021 study found that Benson’s relaxation therapy significantly improved postpartum pain and stress scores in 60 mothers, with a significant difference in pretest and post-test scores compared to the control group.[7] Rinhring and Chanu’s 2021 study found a significant improvement in anxiety levels among antenatal mothers with high-risk pregnancies after implementing Benson’s Relaxation Therapy.[8] Solehati and Rustina’s 2015 study found that the Benson Relaxation Technique significantly reduced pain intensity in women post-cesarean section, with the experimental group (IG) showing more significant pain reduction than the control group (CG).[9] Abu Maloh et al.’s[10] 2022 study found that Benson’s Relaxation Technique significantly reduced pain and perceived stress in hemodialysis patients. Solomon et al.’s study found significant differences in nausea and vomiting in primigravida women during the first trimester of pregnancy compared to control groups.[11] Abarghoee et al.’s[12] 2022 study revealed that the Benson Relaxation Technique and Music Therapy significantly reduced anxiety in primiparous women before cesarean section. DISCUSSION The Benson Relaxation Technique (BRT) is a promising non-pharmacological intervention for managing postpartum discomforts in primi-postnatal mothers, reducing stress, anxiety, and pain in various settings. Soumya Raj and Pillai (2021)[7] and Rinhring and D Chanu (2021)[8] Studies show BRT effectively reduces stress and anxiety levels in postpartum and antenatal mothers, particularly for primi-postnatal mothers experiencing heightened anxiety and stress due to new responsibilities. Abu Maloh et al.[10] (2022) Studies show that BRT significantly reduces pain intensity in postcesarean mothers, enhancing recovery and quality of life, thereby providing sustained relief from discomfort. Saad Soliman et al.’s[11] study demonstrates BRT’s effectiveness in reducing nausea and vomiting symptoms during early pregnancy, highlighting its versatility as a supportive intervention in maternal health care. Abarghoee et al.[12] (2022) found that BRT significantly reduces preoperative anxiety in primiparous women, demonstrating its effectiveness in managing acute stress and anxiety for medical procedures. CONCLUSION The Benson Relaxation Technique (BRT) is a promising non-pharmacological intervention for managing postpartum symptoms in primi-postnatal mothers, showing consistent reductions in stress, anxiety, and pain. Further research is needed to fully understand its benefits and clinical application. The systematic review of published studies on BRT has limitations, including small sample sizes and heterogeneity, and suggests future research should focus on larger, randomized controlled trials. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.