Eggshell Derived Nanohydroxyapatite as a Bone Graft for Intrabony Defects was Evaluated Using (CBCT) - A Randomized Controlled Trial Authors: Vishnuvarthan Ganapathy, Anitha Balaji, T S Sampath Kumar, Mohanasatheesh Shanmugam Published: 2024 ABSTRACT ABSTRACTAim:The study aims to assess the effectiveness of eggshell-derived nanohydroxyapatite (EnHA) as a bone graft material for treating intrabony defects, using cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) for evaluation.Materials and Methods:Ten patients were divided into two groups: Group 1: individuals with 2-wall defects, Group 2: those with 3-wall defects. Follow-up appointments at 1-, 3-, and 6-month intervals included assessments of clinical attachment level (CAL), probing depth (PD), and gingival recession (GR). CBCT scans were conducted pre-operative, immediately post-surgery, and at 1-month, 3-month, and 5-month follow-ups.Results:In both groups, clinical parameters such as CAL, PD, and CBCT measurements reveal significant decreases in CAL and PD values alongside positive trends in CBCT measurements. Additionally, Group 2 exhibited enhancements in periodontal health, suggesting the potential effectiveness of EnHA.Conclusion:EnHA demonstrates potential as a substitute for bone grafting in intrabony defects, showing favourable trends in both clinical and CBCT evaluations during a 6-month observation period. INTRODUCTION Periodontal diseases are prevalent globally, resulting in the degradation of essential periodontal structures.[1] Clinical studies supported by histological evidence suggest that bone grafting is a highly effective treatment for regenerating these structures and establishing a functional periodontal ligament.[2] Intrabony defects, as outlined by the Academy of Periodontology, are periodontal defects found within the bone and enclosed by one, two, or three bony walls based on the number of osseous walls involved. However, it’s crucial to consider their biological aspects, including the role of the periodontal ligament. The primary objective of periodontal therapy is to regenerate the periodontium by stimulating new cementum formation and facilitating the integration of periodontal ligament fibers, along with bone filling. Bone grafting surgery offers a potential remedy for replacing deficient or damaged bone tissues, drawing from various sources.[3456] Although autografts are often considered, the gold standard because of their compatibility. They have post-operative complications and donor site morbidity. Similarly, allografts, and Xenografts also have potential drawbacks.[789] Additionally, artificial bone graft materials such as bioactive glass, glass ionomer, aluminium oxide, calcium sulphate, and calcium phosphate have been developed specifically to ensure their suitability for use in patients’ bone graft surgeries.[1011] Eggshell-derived nanohydroxyapatites (EnHA) are emerging as effective and biocompatible alternatives to traditional bone graft materials. However, there is a lack of histological studies examining grafting outcomes in human subjects.[12131415] The main aim of this study is to improve our understanding of EnHA as a bone graft material, specifically in addressing intrabony defects in human patients. This will be achieved by utilizing advanced imaging methods such as cone beam computed tomography (CBCT).[161718] MATERIALS AND METHODS Sample selection A total of ten subjects (6 males and 4 females) were divided into two groups: Group 1, comprising individuals with 2-wall defects (3 males and 2 females), and Group 2, consisting of individuals with 3-wall defects (3 males and 2 females). The evaluation spanned 6 months. Inclusion criteria The inclusion criteria for participants were as follows: Age range between 21 and 45 years oldDiagnosis of periodontitisPresence of 2 or 3-wall interproximal intrabony defectsProbing depths exceeding 5 mmClinical attachment loss less than 3 mm from the cementoenamel junctionConfirmation of angular bone loss through radiographic evidence. Age range between 21 and 45 years old Age range between 21 and 45 years old Diagnosis of periodontitis Diagnosis of periodontitis Presence of 2 or 3-wall interproximal intrabony defects Presence of 2 or 3-wall interproximal intrabony defects Probing depths exceeding 5 mm Probing depths exceeding 5 mm Clinical attachment loss less than 3 mm from the cementoenamel junction Clinical attachment loss less than 3 mm from the cementoenamel junction Confirmation of angular bone loss through radiographic evidence. Confirmation of angular bone loss through radiographic evidence. The exclusion criteria for participants were as follows: ASA physical status classification categories other than ASA 1SmokersIndividuals with material sensitivitiesPregnant or lactating womenPostmenopausal femalesPatients with parafunctional habits such as bruxismPresence of third molarsPatients with 1-wall defects ASA physical status classification categories other than ASA 1 ASA physical status classification categories other than ASA 1 Smokers Smokers Individuals with material sensitivities Individuals with material sensitivities Pregnant or lactating women Pregnant or lactating women Postmenopausal females Postmenopausal females Patients with parafunctional habits such as bruxism Patients with parafunctional habits such as bruxism Presence of third molars Presence of third molars Patients with 1-wall defects Patients with 1-wall defects Preparation of hen’s eggshell as a bone graft material The process involves washing eggshells, heating them to 900°C to decompose organic matter and convert calcium carbonate to calcium oxide, grinding the resulting calcium hydroxide, and suspending it in water. This suspension is then reacted with diammonium hydrogen phosphate, and microwave irradiation, washing, and drying to remove unwanted ions. Further heating enhances crystallinity, and particle size is adjusted before mixing with saline to form a paste for bone grafting.[1920] Surgical procedure Patients underwent scaling and root planning before surgery. With local anesthesia, Intrasulcular incisions were made, comprehensive debridement, and granulation tissue was removed. Root surfaces were conditioned with topical tetracycline hydrochloride. Osseous defects were filled with EDnHA paste before suturing, and non-eugenol periodontal dressings were applied for one week [Figure 1a-f]. Follow-up appointments at 1-, 3-, and 6-month intervals included assessments of clinical attachment level (CAL), probing depth (PD), and gingival recession (GR). CBCT scans were conducted pre-op, immediate post-surgery, 1-month, 3-month, and 5-month follow-ups [Figure 2a-f]. Bone density measurements were performed using SIDEXIS XG-Sirona software, comparing density values between the defect sites, and surrounding normal bone. The information was tabulated in Microsoft Excel 2010, and statistical analysis was performed using the R statistical package. Group 1 (a) Preoperative; (b) 2 wall defects; (c) CBCT preoperative, (d) EDHA graft placed in 13 region; (e) 4 silk sutures placed 13 region; (f) postoperative CBCT after 6 months Group 2 (a) preoperative; (b) 3 wall defects; (c) preoperative radiograph; (d) EDHA graft; (e) 4.0 silk suture is placed; (f) post operative radiograph RESULTS Mean bone density values ranged from 200 HU to 900 HU, with an average of 330 ± 49 HU, indicating bone regeneration, particularly noticeable after 6 months postoperatively. Tabulated data illustrated the progression of CAL, PD, and CBCT values before treatment, at 3 months, and 6 months for both groups [Tables 1 and 2]. Table 1Data presented in tabular format demonstrated Clinical parameters of group 1 and 2 at varied duration (immediate, 3 months and 6 months)CALCALCALPDPDPDCBCTCBCTBefore3 Months6 MonthsBefore3 months6 monthsBefore6 monthsGroup 13.22.22.29.664.810.24.8Group 253.63.611.26.2511.24.6 Data presented in tabular format demonstrated Clinical parameters of group 1 and 2 at varied duration (immediate, 3 months and 6 months) Table 2Statistical outcomes for Group 1 and Group 2 were analysed at baseline, 3 months, and 6 monthsBEFORE TREATMENTAFTER 3 MONTHSAFTER 6 MONTHS CALPDCBCTCALPDCALPDCBCTGroup 1Mean3.29.610.22.262.24.84.8SD0.8366600271.5165750891.0954451150.4472135950.7071067810.4472135951.3038404811.25499004Min28925233.5Max4121237366Group 2Mean511.211.23.66.23.654.6SD1.8708286931.3038404811.3038404811.6733200530.8366600271.67332005310.547722558Min3101025244Max8131367665t-test P (Intergroup)0.0505799050.0561384210.1133076990.0680059470.3470452410.0680059470.396419980.378050596 P Repeated Measures ANOVA Repeated Measures ANOVA Paired t test Intragroup comparison Intergroup comparison Group 10.0066640.0000460.0002316170.034110.0341110.0060550.00021280.07048Group 20.00014160.000021150.000624480.0046360.00463610.0007990.0014940.07048 Statistical outcomes for Group 1 and Group 2 were analysed at baseline, 3 months, and 6 months Overall, both groups displayed positive trends in periodontal health over the 6-month, suggesting the potential effectiveness of grafting nanomaterials in improving periodontal outcomes. DISCUSSION Synthetic and naturally derived alternatives, such as EnHA, are being explored. Uraz et al. demonstrated the biocompatibility of EnHA with traditional hydroxyapatite across various parameters.[212223] Recent advancements aim to create grafts from naturally occurring sources with constituents similar to bone, such as hydroxyapatites and tricalcium phosphates. One example of this trend is the development of EnHA bone grafts.[2425] Jayasree et al.[26] observed a significant decrease in PD and CAL following 6 months of treatment with cement-based cement. A radiographic study during the 6-month follow-up demonstrated good bone healing. Our study observed that there were no significant modifications in PD and CAL, but there was no three-dimensional view, and only a two-dimensional view was given.[2728] Tammina Mohana Sri Vani et al.[29] used CBCT to assess bone density and fill in intrabony defects. Their findings revealed that both treatment groups exhibited significantly higher bone density and fill values, indicating the efficacy of periosteal pedicle and EnHA in promoting bone regeneration. In summary, EnHA emerges as an effective alternative for bone grafting, providing both biocompatibility and cost-effectiveness. Nonetheless, our study encountered limitations, notably a small sample size and the absence of long-term follow-up data. CONCLUSION The Results showed positive trends in clinical attachment level, probing depth, and CBCT measurements over a 6-month. Group 1 showed superior results, emphasizing individual patient responses. The study supports the potential of EnHA in promoting healing and improving periodontal health. Further research is needed to validate treatment protocols and establish their clinical significance. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.