Comparative Efficacy of Different Interventional Methods on Salivary pH Authors: K. Lakshmikumari, Kavitha Rajesh, Merlin Jayaraj, Vishnu Prasad, Nagappan Nagappan, V. Nyklesh Published: 2024 ABSTRACT ABSTRACTAim:To evaluate and compare the efficacy of four interventional methods (water rinsing, brushing with water, brushing with non-fluoridated dentifrice, and brushing with fluoridated dentifrice) in maintaining the salivary pH after an acidic surge.Background:Salivary pH plays an important role in caries formation and progression; even though there are many interventional methods available for oral hygiene measures, not many studies reveal the potency of the various interventional methods after an acidic surge.Materials and Methodology:Forty-three children of age group 4-5 years were selected for this study. The unstimulated saliva was collected using Dawe’s method in sterile containers and pH was measured using color coded pH strips. The mean value was calculated, tabulated, and statistically analyzed using analysis of variance (ANOVA) and paired t-test.Results:A significant increase was seen in the salivary pH, when brushing was performed using fluoridated and non-fluoridated tooth paste (P = 0.00) compared to that of brushing without dentifrice and water rinsing groups.Conclusion:The study concluded that water can be used as an intermediate intervention to revert the salivary pH until a definitive intervention like toothbrush and dentifrice is available. Tooth brushing with dentifrice is the better home care interventional method to succumb the salivary fall. INTRODUCTION Dental caries is a significant public dental health problem affecting 60–90% of school children in developed countries[1] (WHO, 2003). The changing dietary habits with modernization have lead to an increase in consumption of sugared items in diet which is directly responsible for the increased prevalence of dental caries. As the demineralization progresses so will the carious lesion leading to the loss of tooth structure.[2] The study by Andersen P et al. proved that the decreased concentration of calcium and phosphate ions in primary teeth enamel predisposes them for faster demineralization and also at a higher salivary pH.[3] The salivary pH being an important biomarker for dental caries, the ideal intervention should be targeted towards the maintenance of salivary pH. Preventive strategies are considered as top priority in dental health program for the high-risk individuals.[4] Although not based on any reliable data, most clinicians encourage patients to swish and swift with water whenever tooth brushing is not possible. Hence, the present study was undertaken to compare the efficacy of water rinsing, brushing without dentifrice, brushing with non-fluoridated dentifrice and brushing with fluoridated dentifrice in maintaining the salivary pH following an acidic surge. MATERIALS AND METHODS Forty three school going children aged 4–6 years of both the sexes who were willing to participate with informed written consent signed by their parent/guardian/teacher participated in the present study to test the efficacy of four different interventional methods that is, water rinsing, brushing without dentifrice, brushing with non-fluoridated dentifrice and brushing with fluoridated dentifrice on salivary pH during the experimental period. Children with overall good general/oral health with minimal or no caries (dmft = 0-3), No antibiotic coverage for past one month, with no acute intra-oral or extra-oral lesions were included in the study. For the collection of unstimulated saliva, the children were asked to sit comfortably; the baseline saliva collection was done within a period of 30–60 seconds by Dawe’smethod.[5] On the first day, after taking unstimulated baseline saliva samples, then the subjects were asked to drink 50 ml of freshly prepared apple juice in one minute and to swish and drink carefully in order to maintain a uniform method in drinking. A minute later, a saliva sample was obtained from each participant. Immediately, they rinsed their mouth with tap water for 1 min. A third saliva sample was taken after another 1 min. On the second day, the subjects repeated the first two steps (i.e., saliva collection before and after juice consumption). Then they were asked to brush their teeth instead of rinsing their mouth with tap water. The third sample was collected 1 min after brushing. On the third day of experiment the children were asked to follow the same steps except for the intervention method which was brushing with non-fluoridated toothpaste. On the final day of experiment, the participants brushed with fluoridated toothpaste as the intervention method after the initial steps of saliva collection before and after fruit juice consumption. Based on the calorimetric change of the strip; the pH of the saliva was recorded. The changes in the pH measurements were tabulated and analyzed with SPSS software (version 17.0 for Windows) by analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Paired T-test. RESULTS The mean pH on day 1 at baseline was 7.384 ± 0.37 and after sugar exposure it fell significantly to 4.895 ± 0.72. The salivary pH increased significantly to 6.337 ± 0.69 after water rinsing (P = 0.00)* [Table 1]. The fall in the salivary pH increased significantly after rinsing with water but did not reach the baseline salivary pH. The mean pH on day 2 was 7.430 ± 0.39 at baseline and after sugar exposure decreased significantly to 4.779 ± 0.74. After brushing without dentifrice the salivary pH increased to 6.733 ± 0.45 (P = 0.00)* [Table 1]. The fall in the salivary pH increased significantly after brushing but failed to reach the baseline salivary pH. The mean pH on day 3 was 7.302 ± 0.60 at baseline and decreased significantly to 4.372 ± 0.57 after the sugar challenge. After brushing with non-fluoridated tooth paste there was significant increase in salivary pH to 8.291 ± 0.47 (P = 0.00)*. The mean pH on day 4 at baseline was 7.465 ± 0.33 and decreased to 4.395 ± 0.62 after the sugar intake. After brushing with fluoridated tooth paste the salivary pH increased to 8.407 ± 0.29 and the increase was highly significant with P = 0.00* [Table 1]. But a significant increase was seen in the salivary pH, when brushing was performed using fluoridated and non-fluoridated tooth paste (P = 0.00)* compared to that of brushing without dentifrice and water rinsing groups. There was no significant difference among brushing with fluoridated and non-fluoridated toothpaste groups in increasing the salivary pH after sugar exposure (P = 1.00) [Table 1]. Table 1Mean values of the pH changes in saliva after sugar exposure and after various interventional methodsDay of experimentSalivary pH at Baseline±std.deviationBaseline salivary pH Std.errorSalivary pH after sugar exposure±std.deviationSalivary pH after sugar exposure Std.errorSalivary pH after intervention±Std.deviationAfter intervention Std.error P Day 17.384±0.37.07034.895±0.72.10986.337±0.69.10620.000Day 27.430±0.39.05664.779±0.74.11326.733±0.45.06930.000Day 37.302±0.60.06034.372±0.57.08828.291±0.47.07300.000Day 47.465±0.33.05104.395±0.62.09498.407±0.29.04480.000 P 0.2510.3680.000 Mean values of the pH changes in saliva after sugar exposure and after various interventional methods DISCUSSION In our study whole saliva was collected using Dawe’s method; whole saliva was collected for a 5-min time span. The subject was seated at a low table and asked to swallow residual saliva present in the mouth before the beginning of collection and then, with the head down and mouth slightly open, saliva was allowed to drip from the lower lip into a small sterile container.[56] In the present study results, water was found to cause a significant rise in pH although it did not reach the baseline value. Water has a positive effect in dislodging the loosely stuck food debris from the teeth, also the pH of water being neutral will help in increasing the pH of saliva and plaque, thereby increasing the calcium and phosphate ions in them[7] (Tenuta et al.). However it was found to have the least effect in altering the salivary pH when compared with other groups (P < 0.001) after a sugar exposure owing to the fact that it dilutes the oral fluids which seems to explain why tap water did not enhance oral pH when compared to that of other groups in this trial; which was similar to the studies conducted by Mirjalili et al.[8] and Tolentino et al.[9] Brushing is potent in removing the plaque and debris. There was a significant difference in the salivary pH between the brushing without dentifrice group and brushing with dentifrice groups (P = 0.000), which is contradictory to a study conducted by Ligtenberg[10] in which brushing without dentifrice did not make much of a difference in increasing the salivary pH compared to that of brushing with dentifrice, which was attributed to the fact that even though brushing had a mechanical effect increasing the salivary pH, the gustatory stimulus provided by the dentifrices had an increased effect along with brushing in increasing the salivary pH. CONCLUSION The study concludes that water can be used as an intermediate intervention to revert the salivary pH until a definitive intervention like toothbrush and dentifrice is available. Tooth brushing with dentifrice is the better home care interventional method to succumb the salivary fall. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.