Challenges in the food supply chain following the great earthquake disaster in Turkey: A study of the regions of Malatya, Adıyaman and Kahramanmaraş Authors: Hacer Alataş, Nurgül Arslan Published: 2024 ABSTRACT BACKGROUND:The consequences of natural disasters, such as damage to food systems, destruction of transport infrastructure, and organizational issues, can threaten the food security of people. Hence, food security measures are among the most important responses in the management of natural disasters. This study was conducted to identify the challenges in food security response following a great earthquake in Turkey.MATERIALS AND METHODS:This study used a qualitative approach. Within the scope of this study, 37 food cooking and preparation points were examined in the Malatya, Adıyaman, and Kahramanmaraş-Pazarcık regions. Forty-five authorized individuals working at KIZILAY, who were responsible for all aspects of nutrition, were interviewed. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews, with 27 inquiries selected using purposive sampling. Qualitative content analysis was performed to analyze the data. The data analysis process utilized inductive qualitative content analysis to produce themes and categories.RESULTS:Most participants (%80.00) stated that there was no food variety. Menus generally consists of foods with a low nutritional value such as refined grains, legumes, sweets, spices, seasonings, oils, and sugary drinks (particularly soft drinks). The majority of the participants stated that they could not give milk group (%91.11), vegetables (%93.33), fruits (%97.78), and eggs (%100.00). The participants stated that organizational problems (%77.77), transportation problems (%64.44), cold weather conditions (%84.44), and a lack of stock (%64.44) prevent food safety.CONCLUSION:According to the findings of this study, underlying challenges such as geographical and weather conditions, organizational problems, and vulnerability of part of the population threatened food security. The lack of nutritional diversity can cause health problems such as obesity, malnutrition, and anemia, especially in vulnerable people. Introduction Due to the devastation of natural disasters on people’s livelihoods, sources of food, food reserves, and food systems, food insecurity is a real possibility in their wake[1] Earthquakes, floods, and droughts are a few examples of natural disasters that can have long-lasting effects. A major risk to food security is posed by the condition of roads, livestock, and agricultural inputs, which threaten people’s ability to earn a living.[2] When it comes to what it means to guaranteeing that everyone has access to healthy and nutritious food, there is broad agreement.[2] According to the provided definition, a wide variety of responses can be made to ensure food security in the face of natural disasters. These steps consist of planning for adequate relief food supplies, selecting suitable food items, thinking about health and nutrition, providing a variety of food aid options, and employing appropriate strategies that are in line with compensation and livelihood provisions.[12] Nutritional difficulties that arise after disasters have been the primary focus of previous research in this area. Inoue et al.[3] provided a comprehensive account of gastro-intestinal disturbances seen after the Great East Japan Earthquake in their research. According to Nakazawa and Beppu,[4] the disruption of storage and distribution systems was the biggest issue in the aforementioned incident. According to the research conducted by Chodur et al.,[5] an inefficient distribution system poses a serious threat to the continuation of food security in the wake of a natural disaster. Clay et al.[6] provide evidence to support the claim that addressing food insecurity in vulnerable populations is crucial. Previous research has highlighted the challenges faced by executives and managers in a variety of settings. Nekouie Moghadam et al.[7] stressed the need for humanitarian actors to coordinate their logistics. In addition, Scarpin and Silva[8] argued that Brazil’s bureaucratic disaster management framework was the primary factor endangering its food supply. Two major earthquakes hit southeastern Turkey on February 6, 2023 at 4:17 a.m and 13:24 p.m local time. Kahramanmaraş-Pazarck was the epicenter of the first quake, whereas Kahramanmaraş-Elbistan was the epicenter of the second. Both earthquakes were recorded as 7.7 (Mw) and 7.6 (Mw) magnitudes, respectively.[9] As a result, a major earthquake struck this area. The earthquakes, also known as the “catastrophe of the century,” caused widespread damage and loss of life across a wide area as well as significant economic repercussions [see Figure 1]. Nearly half of the world’s population has been uprooted from their homes, making up 1.5 million people who are currently homeless. Some families still sleep outside at night, despite not having lost their homes, due to either significant structural damage or fear of potential aftershocks. The area affected by the Kahramanmaraş-centered earthquake dated 2023 February 6. The provided map depicts the geographical region in which the catastrophic earthquake event occurred on February 6, 2023. The epicenter of the earthquake with a magnitude of 7.8 was identified to be located west of Gaziantep, while the epicenter of the earthquake with a magnitude of 7.5 was determined to be situated northeast of Kahramanmaraş. Both seismic events originated within the East Anatolian region In Turkey, the Ministry of the Interior’s Disaster and Emergency Management Presidency (AFAD) is responsible for directing and coordinating integrated management across various stages of disaster management, including policy formulation, planning, coordination, and solidarity.[10] The purpose of this study was to analyze the measures taken to safeguard food security in the wake of earthquakes in 11 provinces across Turkey. Using the insights of experts in the field, this research aimed to determine what was standing in the way of more effective responses to concerns about food safety. The provided map depicts the geographical region in which the catastrophic earthquake event occurred on February 6, 2023. The epicenter of the earthquake with a magnitude of 7.8 was identified to be located west of Gaziantep, while the epicenter of the earthquake with a magnitude of 7.5 was determined to be situated northeast of Kahramanmaraş. Both seismic events originated within the East Anatolian region. Materials and Methods Study design and setting This study was conducted between February 27 and March 10, 2023. Within the scope of the research, 37 food cooking and preparation points were examined in the Malatya, Adıyaman, and Kahramanmaraş-Pazarcık regions. At these points, authorized individuals who provided food supplies were interviewed. The participants had considerable experience in food security responses to natural disasters as they included managers and experts working in related organizations. The selection of participants for interviews was based on purposive sampling. No other exclusion criteria were used: Participants were at least 18 years old and worked for organizations that were based in or served Kızılay. The inclusion criteria were as follows: expertise and experience in food assistance and nutrition responses to natural disasters, willingness to participate in the study and conduct the interviews, and accessibility. During the process of obtaining consent, participants were provided with information regarding the voluntary nature of their participation and the assurance of confidentiality. The study results would maintain the confidentiality of the participants’ identities. Oral informed consent was obtained from all the participants. Two informant categories were used to stratify semi-structured in-depth interviews with stakeholders in the “Kızılay food system” (n = 45). These categories were organizations that focused on promoting food access, such as non-profits and governmental agencies (henceforth, food assistance providers), and companies and organizations involved in supplying and distributing food in Kızılay, such as producers, wholesalers, and retailers (henceforth, suppliers/distributors). During the process of obtaining consent, participants were provided with information regarding the voluntary nature of their participation and the assurance of confidentiality. The study results would maintain the confidentiality of the participants’ identities. Oral informed consent was obtained from all participants. Data collection tool and technique In the framework of the study, 27 inquiries were posed to participants in a semi-structured format. We have omitted unresolved inquiries from this study. On average, the duration of each interview was 60 minutes. Ethical consideration Necessary permissions for this project have been obtained by TÜBİTAK 1002-C Natural Disasters Focused Field Study Emergency Support Program and AFAD. Statistical analyzes Data were analyzed using SPSS @22 and for @Windows Excel 2019 programs. The mean and percentage values of the data were calculated. Descriptive statistics were presented as percentages (%) and numbers (n); continuous variables were expressed as mean. Inductive qualitative content analysis was employed to generate themes and categories during the data analysis process. This analysis method examines both the nutritional status reported by the participants and the underlying meaning behind their verbal expressions, as interpreted by the researcher.[11] The data analysis process involved the following steps: The transcript recorded during the first interview was transcribed, and this interview transcript was read carefully multiple times.The interview text content was analyzed in two specific areas: “nutritional diversity” and “nutritional adequacy” in accordance with the interview questions.The process of “open coding” involved identifying expressions that had similar meanings, while “coding” involved naming the determined expressions in each of these areas.The designated codes were categorized and sub-categorized based on their similarities and differences. The transcript recorded during the first interview was transcribed, and this interview transcript was read carefully multiple times. The transcript recorded during the first interview was transcribed, and this interview transcript was read carefully multiple times. The interview text content was analyzed in two specific areas: “nutritional diversity” and “nutritional adequacy” in accordance with the interview questions. The interview text content was analyzed in two specific areas: “nutritional diversity” and “nutritional adequacy” in accordance with the interview questions. The process of “open coding” involved identifying expressions that had similar meanings, while “coding” involved naming the determined expressions in each of these areas. The process of “open coding” involved identifying expressions that had similar meanings, while “coding” involved naming the determined expressions in each of these areas. The designated codes were categorized and sub-categorized based on their similarities and differences. The designated codes were categorized and sub-categorized based on their similarities and differences. The creation of themes involved establishing connections between the meanings of the categories. Results All individuals included in the study worked with Kızılay under the umbrella of AFAD. Volunteers work voluntarily under the roof of the Kızılay. Within the scope of this study, 45 authorized individuals responsible for all stages of nutrition were interviewed. The provinces and job descriptions of the individuals are presented in Table 1. Table 1City and occupation distribution of the participation interviewed within the scope of the researchPerson interviewed (n=45)Mean conversation timeAdministratorSpecialistCookVolunteerMalatya (n=21)4 (19.05)6 (28.57)4 (19.05)7 (33.33)62 minuteAdıyaman (n=13)3 (23.08)3 (23.08)4 (30.77)3 (23.08)83 minuteKahramanmaraş (n=11)2 (18.18)4 (36.36)3 (27.27)2 (18.18)74 minute City and occupation distribution of the participation interviewed within the scope of the research Findings regarding participation in food safety problems are presented in Table 2. The existence of the organizational problem was observed in all three cities within the scope of this research. It has been stated by administrators in all three provinces that there is a problem in ensuring nutrition, food safety, and resource management. It was stated that geographical conditions and bad weather conditions disrupted nutrition and food services. The absence of cold storage was mostly determined in Malatya and Kahramanmaraş. The conditions of transportation, preparation, cooking, food distribution and lack of food hygiene were determined as 16 (76.19%), 12 (92.31%), and 10 (90.91%) in all three provinces, respectively. It was observed that the presence of sensitive people (infants, the elderly and bedridden individuals) in all three provinces caused disruptions in the nutrition organization. It was determined that food aid was distributed improperly and that the distribution could not be organized. Table 2Participation status of individuals in food safety problemsMalatya (n=21)Adıyaman (n=13)Kahramanmaraş (n=11)Organization problem Yes17 (80.95)9 (69.23)9 (81.82) No4 (19.05)4 (30.77)2 (18.18)Challenges of process and resource management Yes11 (52.38)7 (53.85)9 (81.82) No10 (47.62)6 (46.15)2 (18.18)Geographical and weather conditions (existence of regions with heavy snowfall) Yes21 (100.00)11 (84.62)6 (54.55) No02 (15.38)5 (45.45)Transportation problem (roads are closed due to the destruction caused by the disaster) Yes19 (90.48)6 (46.15)4 (36.36) No2 (9.52)7 (53.85)7 (63.64)Lack of cold storage Yes16 (76.19)3 (23.08)7 (63.64) No5 (23.81)10 (76.92)4 (36.36)Lack of stock Yes16 (76.19)7 (53.85)6 (54.55) No5 (23.81)6 (46.15)5 (45.45)Lack of diversity Yes21 (100.00)4 (30.77)11 (100.00) No09 (69.23)0Food hygiene Yes16 (76.19)12 (92.31)10 (90.91) No5 (23.81)1 (7.69)1 (9.09)Presence of vulnerable people (infant, elderly, bedridden individuals) Yes14 (66.67)7 (53.85)9 (81.82) No7 (33.33)6 (46.15)2 (18.18)Inappropriate distribution of food aid Yes20 (95.24)6 (46.15)8 (72.73) No1 (4.76)7 (53.85)3 (27.27) Participation status of individuals in food safety problems Within the scope of this research, food diversity was questioned according to food group [Table 3]. In this study, 53.33% of the participants consumed meat group foods 2–3 days per week, whereas 91.11% did not consume any dairy group foods. Additionally, 86.67% of the participants consumed cereal group foods 6–7 days per week and 80% consumed legume group foods 6 days per week. According to his statement, a total of 7 days were observed, during which 93.33% of the individuals did not consume any food from the vegetable group, and 97.78% did not consume any food from the fruit group. Nevertheless, it has been ascertained that eggs, classified as members of the meat group, are never ingested. Table 3Participation status of individuals in food diversity questionsFoods GroupParticipation (n=45)6-7 days per week n (%)4-5 days per week n (%)2-3 days per week n (%)One day per week n (%)Never n (%)Meat group foods4 (8.89)3 (6.67)24 (53.33)10 (22.22)4 (8.89)Dairy group foods1 (2.22)1 (2.22)1 (2.22)1 (2.22)41 (91.119)Cereal group foods39 (86.67)1 (2.22)1 (2.22)4 (8.89)0Legumes group foods36 (80)8 (17.77)1 (2.22)00Vegetable group0003 (6.67)42 (93.33)Fruit group0001 (2.22)44 (97.78)Egg000045 (100.00) Participation status of individuals in food diversity questions Discussion The objective of this study was to enhance comprehension of the challenges encountered by food security interventions in Turkey following catastrophic earthquakes. The research revealed that the factors influencing the measures taken to guarantee food security have become increasingly intricate owing to various underlying challenges such as geographical and climatic conditions, organizational issues, and the susceptibility of a segment of the population. The southeastern region of Turkey exhibits a distinctive topography characterized by the rough terrain and a vast expanse of mountainous landscapes. The region experienced notable accumulation of snowfall in February, coinciding with the timing of the earthquake event. Consequently, a significant number of participants attributed challenging topographical conditions (84.44%), transportation disruptions (64.44%), and substantial snowfall to the principal factors contributing to food scarcity. The earthquake presented a significant challenge to food security in the most severely affected areas of Nepal. The significant contribution to this situation can be attributed to the unfortunate demise of livestock and the consequential inability of affected households to successfully perform crop harvesting and grain and seed storage. Furthermore, the exacerbation of challenges in food distribution is compounded by the destruction of infrastructure, such as roads and markets.[12] There is a correlation between the frequency of earthquakes in Tokyo and the sufficiency of food assistance provided to individuals in the aftermath of significant seismic events.[13] A seismic event that disrupts an established social structure leads to a notable decline in an individual’s quality of life. Individuals who endured the aftermath of a catastrophic seismic event, witnessing the destruction of their dwellings, may encounter difficulties in accessing sustenance within nations that lack sufficient preparedness for earthquakes. This scenario has the potential to result in inadequate food sanitation practices that may subsequently lead to health issues. According to the study, the findings indicate that a significant majority of respondents, specifically 84%, reported a lack of access to sufficient food hygiene facilities. Since the 2010 earthquake, Haiti, a nation already burdened by poverty, has experienced a multitude of health issues including cholera, malnutrition, poisoning, anxiety, and depression.[14] The city water networks incurred damage subsequent to the 2015 Nepal earthquake, which registered a magnitude of 7.8 on the Richter scale. The prevalence of malnutrition is increasing owing to inadequate access to potable water, substandard hygiene practices, and unhygienic residential environments.[15] Research conducted in a region near the equator has established a correlation between inadequate hygiene practices and the prevalence of numerous chronic diseases, particularly among children below the age of five. Furthermore, the incidence of such diseases tends to increase after natural disasters.[16] Given the anticipated challenges in food preservation following an earthquake, it is imperative to prioritize the safeguarding of perishable food items such as dairy products and other highly susceptible foodstuffs. One crucial determinant in the prevention of malnutrition is the consumption of ready-to-eat food items that possess a high energy density.[17] According to the findings of the study, the majority of individuals (66%) expressed the opinion that individuals who are considered vulnerable have not taken sufficient measures to guarantee food security. Dolatabadi et al.[18] discovered that natural disasters have a disproportionate influence on the most vulnerable segments of Iran’s population. Individuals who can be classified within these groups encompass those who have disabilities, advanced age, female individuals who are the primary earners in their households, individuals who have lost their parents, those who are unemployed, individuals who are experiencing poverty, and those who are socially excluded. The user’s text did not contain any information to rewrite in an academic manner. A separate study conducted subsequent to the occurrence of Hurricane Katrina in the states of Louisiana and Mississippi revealed the presence of various risk factors that were linked with heightened vulnerability to negative consequences. These risk factors include low levels of social support, compromised physical or mental health, and female sex. There is a contention that endeavors aimed at enhancing the availability of food resources among susceptible populations are of utmost importance in mitigating the adverse health consequences of disasters.[6] The user has provided a scholarly source to substantiate their assertion. Dorosh et al.[19] conducted a study subsequent to the 2010 flood in Pakistan, wherein the researchers’ findings underscored the importance of implementing food security and household livelihood programs. The design of the distribution methods employed by these programs should prioritize the most socio-economically disadvantaged families. A user’s text is suitable for an academic audience. The findings of the present study indicate that the establishment of coordination among diverse actors and the organization of multiple governmental and non-governmental stakeholders poses an additional obstacle to effectively addressing food security. The findings indicated that a significant proportion of individuals (77.77%) experienced work-related difficulties because of internal factors. In addition, the majority of the participants, specifically 60%, identified issues pertaining to process and resource management. An important finding is the assertion made by the participants regarding the inefficient distribution of food aid. The misallocation of funds could be a consequence of ineffective management. One factor contributing to this phenomenon is the prioritization of political interests over the equitable distribution of food aid. Managers may allocate excessive financial resources to conceal their deficiencies and maintain favorable public perceptions. The results of our study on flood recovery in Blumenau, Brazil, were successfully replicated by Scarpin and Silva in a subsequent qualitative investigation. The findings of this study indicate that the presence of governmental authority and bureaucratic processes hinders effective coordination among humanitarian actors. It is crucial to consider the multitude of minor factors that can accumulate into significant issues in the future, potentially leading to disruptions in logistics and supply chain coordination, if not adequately addressed. The user failed to provide any source material for editing.[8] According to Moghadam et al.,[20] the primary obstacles to the implementation of nutritional interventions following the Bam earthquake were identified as managerial, infrastructure, and executive issues. The inequitable allocation of food assistance has been found to exacerbate food insecurity within populations with limited mobility. Concurrently, independent investigation which revealed that the quality of food storage equipment, food supplies, and food distribution during the aforementioned time period was below satisfactory standards. The user’s text is already suitable for an academic audience. This study examines the impact of the California drought from 2013 to 2017 and Winter Storm Jonas in 2016 in the city of Baltimore. Chodur et al.[5] employed a fault tree model to demonstrate the vulnerability of individuals dependent on food donations to hunger, attributing this to the inefficiencies present within distribution networks. Based on these findings, it is evident that a significant issue arises from the absence of early stage health monitoring during the response. Another concern pertains to the indiscriminate distribution of identical food baskets to diverse demographic groups across various regions without considering the distinct nutritional needs and considerations of different age groups and patients. In this study, participants assessed the level of dietary diversity they maintained by recollecting the assortment of food items they consumed during a representative day. While the respondents in Adyaman did not report any issues regarding food variety, all respondents in Malatya (100%) and Kahramanmaraş (100%) expressed concerns in this regard. The study revealed that soft drinks, sugary beverages, refined grains, and desserts occupied a disproportionate share of the menu allocation. However, the consumption of vegetables, grains, and legumes is lower than that of fruits, meat, eggs, and dairy products. In contrast to the prevalent misclassification of legumes as meat types, it is important to note that eggs were not categorized within any of the established food groups. A significant proportion of the study participants (57.77%) lacked access to cold storage facilities, thereby impeding their ability to preserve protein-rich food items, such as eggs and meat. Therefore, preserving the nutritional value of proteins is of utmost significance. Accessibility of a wide range of food options is constrained by various factors. The dietary patterns observed within each group exhibited a high degree of homogeneity, which may pose challenges in promoting optimal health outcomes. Despite the plethora of available cooking techniques, the menus provided a limited array of culinary choices, resulting in monotonous dining encounters. The nutritional composition of the diet decreased owing to the omission of certain food groups during the preparation of routine meals. Consequently, individuals may experience nutritional deficiencies after prolonged adherence to this dietary regimen. Our findings confirm that the nutritional challenges persisted for several weeks following the Bam earthquake owing to the absence of a distribution program and a limited range of food choices, and the user did not provide any raw materials.[19] Nozue et al.[21] conducted an investigation to document inadequate availability of food resources in the aftermath of the Great East Japan Earthquake. The authors emphasized the importance of generating accurate predictions and maintaining sufficient food reserves in preparation for potential emergencies during the pre-emergency stage. According to a parallel study conducted by Inoue et al.,[3] the primary component of the participants’ diets consisted of carbohydrates. Researchers observed a decline in food consumption and subsequent weight loss as well as the emergence of gastrointestinal symptoms, approximately 1 month after the traumatic incident. Conclusion Attempts to improve food security face formidable obstacles during crises. Our research showed that there are substantial difficulties associated with choosing food items, such as type, quality, and preservation and storage methods, in the context of response efforts. Significant threats to food security in regions affected by natural disasters stem from a lack of effective coordination and organization among actors and stakeholders, interventions that are primarily focused on individual organizations, the influx of unsolicited donations, and the presence of nutrition and health challenges. Even in the provision of humanitarian aid after a disaster, efforts must be made to increase the consumption of nutritious food items, particularly fruits and vegetables, and to guarantee the inclusion of a wide range of nutrients. The results of this research highlight the need for additional work to strengthen the nation’s food security and develop effective disaster-management frameworks. Informed Consent Before beginning the survey, all respondents read the written permission form and voluntarily consented to participate. Ethical Permission Necessary permissions for this project have been obtained by TÜBİTAK 1002-C Natural Disasters Focused Field Study Emergency Support Program and AFAD. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.