Acceptance of Parents toward Hand-over-mouth Exercise and Other Behavior Management Techniques for Pediatric Dental Care in the 21st Century: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Observational Studies Authors: Ashwin Jawdekar, Farheen Tafti, Sayali Deolikar, Laresh Mistry Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundHand-over-mouth exercise (HOME) is an aversive technique for child behavior management in a dental office. HOME has been omitted from various guidelines and certain teaching curricula due to legal and ethical issues. This systematic review meta-analysis (SRMA) was undertaken to understand the acceptance of parents toward HOME in comparison with that of other behavior management techniques (BMTs).ObjectivesThis SRMA compared parental acceptance for HOME and other BMTs from observational studies reported in the literature from 1st January 2000, to date.MethodologyTwo authors independently searched data from the Cochrane Library, PubMed, Google Scholar, Semantic Scholar, and others. Twenty-one studies remained in the systematic review, of which eleven could be included in the meta-analysis. Based on the summary findings of 1,034 participants from 10 studies, we compared parents’ acceptance for HOME vs other BMTs [voice control (VC), tell-show-do (TSD), physical restraint-active (PR-A), physical restraint-passive (PR-P), parental separation (PS), conscious sedation (CS), general anesthesia (GA), oral premedication (OP), and positive reinforcement (PR)]. Data analyses were carried out using RevMan 5.3. The Joanna Briggs Risk of Bias (JB-ROB) tool for cross-sectional analytical studies was used for bias assessment. A funnel plot was used to detect publication bias.ResultsOf 20 studies, nine studies reported higher acceptance for GA than HOME; seven reported higher acceptance for HOME than GA, and the remaining four appeared inconclusive. The meta-analysis results (eleven studies) based on forest plots with fixed effects models in terms of OR (CI) indicated no statistically significant difference in the acceptance for HOME vs GA [1.03 (0.84, 1.25)], CS [0.77 (0.60, 1.00)], and PR-P [1.21 (0.92, 1.59)]. In comparison with the acceptance for HOME, CS (NO) [0.65 (0.51, 0.84)], VC [0.48 (0.39, 0.59)], TSD [0.04 (0.03, 0.05)], PR-A [0.65 (0.50, 0.84)], PS [0.28 (0.22, 0.36)], OP [0.55 (0.39, 0.78)], distraction [0.11 (0.09, 0.15)], and PR [0.06 (0.04, 0.08)] were preferred; these being statistically significant. Heterogeneity values (I2) for all comparisons were high (above 80%), with the exception of one (comparison of HOME vs OP) having 50%. ROB across studies was judged to be moderate. The publication bias using the funnel plot analysis for all studies on the basis of SE [Log (OR)] showed marked and fairly equal dispersion on either side of the central line.ConclusionNo statistically significant difference was seen in the acceptance for HOME vs GA, CS, and PR-P. BMTs such as TSD, VC, PR-A, PS, CS (NO), OP, distraction, and PR were preferred to HOME; the difference in acceptance being statistically significant. The differences in acceptance between HOME vs CS (NO) and PR-A did not remain statistically significant when random effects models were used. The heterogeneity was high, the ROB was moderate, and the publication bias was minimal.How to cite this articleJawdekar A, Tafti F, Deolikar S, et al. Acceptance of Parents toward Hand-over-mouth Exercise and Other Behavior Management Techniques for Pediatric Dental Care in the 21st Century: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Observational Studies. Int J Clin Pediatr Dent 2024;17(11):1302–1319.Keywords: Behavior management, Child Behavior in dental office, Hand-over-mouth exercise, Hand-over-mouth, Meta-analysis, Parental acceptance, Systematic review Background Hand-over-mouth exercise (HOME) (placing a hand on a crying child's mouth firmly so as to gain control of the uncooperative child) is an aversive technique for child behavior management in a dental office that has been practiced for over 100 years since it was first advocated by Evangelin Jordan in 1920.1,2 In a survey of program directors offering advanced training in pediatric dentistry, reported by Davis and Rombom in 1979, 89% of the programs included training and practice of HOME, including 31% accepting the use of airway restraint along with HOME, that is, hand-over-mouth airway restriction (HOMAR).3 Acs and Burke (1990) reported a marked reduction in the acceptance of HOMAR during the decade after the Davis and Rombom survey; however, no decrease was reported in the acceptance of HOME.3,4 In an article published in 2001, “A 20-Year Perspective on the Changing Use of Hand Over Mouth and Restraint in Post-Doctoral Pediatric Dental Education,” it was reported that between 1989 and 1999, 50% of previous HOME users discontinued its use.5 HOME has been omitted from various guidelines and certain teaching practices due to legal and ethical issues (Acs et al., 2001; AAPD, 2020).5,6 Parental approval and preferences for HOME and various other behavior management techniques (BMT) have been investigated by various authors. Desai et al. (2019) reported the least acceptance of HOME compared to tell-show-do, positive reinforcement, and modeling techniques of behavior management.7 In another study (Eaton et al., 2005) comparing all BMTs, the mean parental acceptance rating was in the acceptable range for all other techniques such as tell-show-do, nitrous oxide sedation, passive restraint, voice control, oral premedication (sedation), active restraint, and general anesthesia, with the exception of HOME.8 In another study by Muhammad et al. (2011), comparing the acceptance of various BMTs by parents, positive reinforcement, effective communication, tell-show-do, distraction, modeling, and nonverbal communication were the most acceptable; hypnosis and parental separation were moderately acceptable, and voice control, nitrous oxide sedation, protective stabilization (physical restraint), general anesthesia, HOME, and conscious sedation were the least acceptable techniques.9 Similar to these studies, several studies have reported varying degrees of acceptance of HOME and other BMTs by parents.10,14 This research has been undertaken to understand the acceptance of parents toward HOME in comparison with other BMTs based on the findings from the recent literature. The research question was framed as follows: How is the acceptance of parents for HOME and other BMTs reported in the literature from the year 2001 onwards? Aim and Objectives The study was aimed at assessing the acceptance of parents toward HOME in comparison with other BMTs, such as: General anesthesia (GA). General anesthesia (GA). Tell-show-do (TSD). Tell-show-do (TSD). Voice control (VC). Voice control (VC). Physical restraint-active (PR-A). Physical restraint-active (PR-A). Physical restraint-passive (PR-P). Physical restraint-passive (PR-P). Parental separation (PS). Parental separation (PS). Conscious sedation (CS). Conscious sedation (CS). Oral premedication (OP). Oral premedication (OP). Distraction. Distraction. Positive reinforcement (PR). Positive reinforcement (PR). The abovementioned techniques are standard nonpharmacological and pharmacological behavior management methods used in dentistry. Methods Criteria for Considering Studies for this Review Observational questionnaire-based studies reporting the acceptance of parents to nonpharmacological and pharmacological behavior management methods used in dentistry were included. The inclusion of HOME was a requirement for a study to be considered. The focus of this research was to assess the acceptance of parents in the recent past; articles published in the current century (from January 1, 2000) were considered for inclusion. Types of participants: The following were the eligibility criteria for the studies included in this review. Inclusion Criteria Observational studies written in English or with the full text available in English. Observational studies written in English or with the full text available in English. Studies reporting comparisons of parental acceptance of HOME vs any other BMTs. Studies reporting comparisons of parental acceptance of HOME vs any other BMTs. Children belonging to the age group from 0 to 16 years (to ensure inclusion of studies not reporting the age in the title and abstract). Children belonging to the age group from 0 to 16 years (to ensure inclusion of studies not reporting the age in the title and abstract). Articles that were published or available prior to publication. Articles that were published or available prior to publication. Exclusion Criteria Studies reporting acceptance from children, dentists, training program directors, or anyone other than parents. Studies reporting acceptance from children, dentists, training program directors, or anyone other than parents. Studies with incomplete information available about the participants and variables. Studies with incomplete information available about the participants and variables. This being a systematic review on observational studies, following population, exposure, comparison, outcome, study (PECOS) were considered. Participants/population: Children under 16 years of age. Participants/population: Children under 16 years of age. Exposure: HOME. Exposure: HOME. Comparator(s)/control: Pharmacological and nonpharmacological BMTs other than HOME. Comparator(s)/control: Pharmacological and nonpharmacological BMTs other than HOME. Outcome: Parental acceptance. Outcome: Parental acceptance. Study type: Observational. Study type: Observational. Search Methods for Identification of Studies/Electronic Searches The two authors of this review (FT and SD) conducted systematic searches in the following databases for observational studies published from 1st January 2000, to date, meeting the eligibility criteria: Cochrane Library. Cochrane Library. PubMed. PubMed. Google Scholar. Google Scholar. The search was extended to another search engine, Semantic Scholar, and included cross-references from the selected articles. The period of the search was from June to August 2021. See Figure 1 for the flowchart of included articles. Flowchart—selection and inclusion of studies Data Collection and Analysis: Selection of Studies Following the electronic search, the two authors (FT and SD) independently reviewed the articles with respect to the title, abstract, and full texts. Articles were included after the two authors reached an agreement. In case of any disagreement between the two authors, it was resolved by an independent third author (AJ). Data Extraction and Management Data extraction was carried out independently by the two authors (FT and SD) first, and then by all authors (including AJ and LM). The data extraction sheet was finalized to include the following details. See Tables 1 and 2 for the data extraction of studies for SR and MA, respectively. Table 1:Data extraction for systematic review Sr. no. Author, year, settings Sample characteristics BMTs included Variable measurements Results Conclusion Remarks 1Paryab et al. (2014), Iran14Parents (22–42 years) of 3–6-year-old children, n = 90PR-A, PR-P, HOME, OP, GA5-point Likert scale (acceptance, consent, concern)Group I: Information with printed documentGroup II: Information by pediatric dentist with 5 years of experienceGroup III: Informati on by demonstration videoPercentage acceptance for PR-A, PR-B, HOME, OP, GA was 82.2, 37.8, 53.3, 54.4, 38.9 percent, respectivelyNo statistically significant differences in the 3 groups based on acceptance, consent and concernsGood acceptance for HOME (53.3%); superior to GA and comparable to OPConsidered for MA2Noor et al. (2019), India11Age unspecifiedn = 100TSD, distraction, invasive techniques, GA, HOME, PS12-point questionnaireAcceptance for TSD, audiovisual distraction, invasive techniques, GA, HOME, leave child and move out of dental setup was 92, 58, 36.7, 58.3, 49, 53.1 percent, respectivelyMost of the parents do not prefer any kind of invasiveBMTs such as VC, PR-P, and HOME apart from these many parents readily accepted for TSD technique as this technique is parent and patient-friendlyGood acceptance for HOME (49%) but inferior to GA (58.3)Considered for MA3de León et al. (2010), Spain12Parents of 3–13-year-old children, n = 50TSD, CS (NO), PR-P, VC, HOME, OP, PR-A, GAQuestionnaire, video demonstration, BMT on scale of 10Statistically different: socioecono mic level: PR-P, PR-A, OP, GAMost accepted: TSD. Least accepted: HOMEThe socioecono mic level of parents affects their acceptance of PR-P, PR-A, OP, GAPoor acceptance for HOME (7%); much inferior to GA (18%); calculated from the graphConsidered for MA4Muhammad et al. (2011), Kuwait9Parents (24–51 years, 54 M, 64 F) of 6–13-year-old children, n = 118PR, effective communication, TSD, distraction, modelling, NVC, hypnosis, PS, VC, NO, PR-P, GA, HOME, CSPercentage acceptancePR 100%, effective communication 100%, TSD 99.2%, distraction, 99.2%, modelling 95.8%, NVC81.4%, hypnosis 66. 1%, PS, 51.7%, VC, 30.5% NO, 20.3%, PR-P, 19.5%, GA, 5.9%, HOME, 5. 1%, CS 4.2%Parents prefer nonpharmacological over pharmacological techniquesPoor acceptance for HOME (5. 1%); comparable to GA (5.9%)Considered for MA5Venkataraghavan et al. (2016), India13Parents (20–40 years) of 2–4-year-old children, n = 51VC, TSD, PR, PS, HOME, PR-A, NO, GADental fear, anxiety level of study populationTSD followed by PR most preferred, GA followed by PR-A/P and HOME least preferredParents preferred more positive approaches and management techniques even in emergency dental conditions. A generalized low parental tolerance level for firm management techniquesNo acceptance for HOME (0%) and for GA (0%) in the most preferred categoriesConsidered for MA7Boka et al. (2014), Greece16Parents of 3–12 years,n = 123 Overall, university and private practiceTSD, CS (NO), PR-P, VC, HOME, OP, PR-A, GA and PSVideo presentation 10 seconds each 10-point scaleTSD>PS>C S(NO)>VC>PR-A>HOME>OP>PR-P>GAPS was highly accepted technique by Greek parentsParents with negative dental experience would prefer GA over PR-A, PR-P, HOME and VCHOME was superior to GA. Not considered for MA because the acceptance was not recorded in percentage but in mean (SD)8Desai et al. (2019), India7Parents of 2–13 years, n = 300TSD, PR, modelling, VC, HOME, PR-P PR-A, OP, CS(NO), and GA100 each ofGroup A: 2–5 years,Group B: 6–9 years,Group C: 10–13 yearsVideo of 40–60 seconds for each BMT was shown to parentsThe name of the technique was displayed before each video for 6 secondsTSD, PR, and M were the most accepted techniques. The least accepted technique among all groups was HOMEParents accepted techniques involving a communicative management, such as TSD, PR and modelling. HOME technique was the least accepted technique a pharmacological BMT such as CS (NO) and OP techniques were preferred over the aggressive management techniquesThe least accepted technique among all groups was HOME. Not considered for MA because the acceptance was not recorded using VAS9Rahman et al. (2021), Malaysia17Parents of Chinese, Indian and Malay children [age in mean (SD) per group given], n = 72TSD, VC, modelling, PR-A, distraction, PS, HOME, CS (NO), OP and GAVideo was 10 minutes in duration, after which the parents were asked to express their level of agreement to each method using a 100-point visual analog scaleTSD>distraction>PS>modelling>VC>CS (NO)>OP>PR-A>HOME>GATSD, distraction and modelling PS and reinforcements have been shown to produce similarly acceptable results among Asian parents with statistically insignificant differences in the amount of approval given for the techniques PR-A, OP and GA were the least approved in the current studyHOME was superior to GA. Not considered for MA because the acceptance was not recorded using VAS10Eaton et al. (2005), USA8Age unspecified, n = 45TSD, NO, PR-P, VC, HOME, OP, PR-A, GAVideotape followed by questionnaire using VAS (100 mm)TSD was rated as the most acceptable technique, followed (in order of decreasing acceptance) by nitrous oxide sedation, general anesthesia, active restraint, oral premedicati on, voice control, passive restraint, and hand-over-mouthAggressive physical management techniques (PR-P, HOME) appear to be less favorably accepted. Advanced pharmacologic techniques (sedation and GA) are increasing in acceptance over timeThe least accepted technique among all groups was HOME. Not considered for MA because the acceptance was not recorded using VAS11Razavi and Purtaji (2007), Iran18Age unspecified, n = 50 mothersGA, PS, HOME, VCFilm showed, questionnaire usedMothers' acceptance of PS was 100%, VC 92%, HOME 50%, and GA 30%There was a statistically significant relationship between the acceptance of VC and child's order, child's age, and the number of children Also, a significant relationship between the acceptance of GA and the child's order and mother's education was foundPS and GA are the most and the least accepted technique, respectivelyAcceptance for HOME superior to GAConsidered for MA12Elango et al. (2012), India19Parents of 3–15-year-old children, n = 102TSD, PR, modelling, contingent escape, mouth prop, VC, PR-A, HOME, OP, and GA10 minutes videotape: each technique 35–60 seconds, VAS%Acceptance of TSD = 90.70%, PR = 89.43%, modelling = 88.52%, contingent escape = 91.81%, mouth prop = 89.32%, VC = 77.57%, PR-A = 85.23%, HOME = 72. 14%, OP = 84.68% and GA = 80.40%HOME should be used with great caution and clinicians should approach the issue of informed consent on an individual basisAcceptance was good for both GA and HOME; that for GA was superior to HOMEConsidered for MA13Thirunavakarasu et al. (2021), India20Parents (30–40 years) of 6–12-year-old children, n = 100TSD, VC, PR, HOME, PR-A, PR-P, OP, GAPhotographs of technique followed by questionnaire for acceptanc e of techniquesTSD = 91.5%, VC = 76.8%, PR = 89.2%, HOME = 60.8%, PR-A = 27.4%, PR-P = 14.7%, OP = 45.8%, GA = 16.3%Parents prefer a management technique which required the dentist to communicate and interact with their child. By doing so this will create a bond between the dentist and the child. The child will not be afraid and will be more open toward accepting a treatmentAcceptance for HOME superior to GAConsidered for MA14Alammouri et al. (2006), Jordan21Parents (66 M, 70 F) age unspecified, n = 138TSD, PR, NVC, VC, PS, distraction, HOME, PR-A, hypnosis, CS (NO), CS, GAVideotape followed by questionnaireAcceptance of TSD = 92.8%, PR = 91.3%, NVC = 55.8%, VC = 56.5%. PS = 55. 1%, distraction =76.8%, HOME = 9.4%, PR= 23.9%, hypnosis = 19.6%, CS (NO) = 30.45%, CS = 27.5%, GA = 32.6%Parents accepted techniques involving a communicative management, such as TSD, PR and live modeling. HOME technique was the least accepted technique. Pharmacological BMT such as nitrous oxide sedation and oral sedation techniques were preferred over the aggressive management techniquesAcceptance was poor for HOME; that for GA was superior to HOMEConsidered for MA15Acharya (2017), India22Parents (20–40 years) of 3–6-year-old children, n = 50VC, TSD, PR, mouth prop, modelling, HOME, PR-A, OP, CS (NO), GAPower-Point presentation, followed by VAS%TSD = 86%, PR = 76%, modelling = 76%, GA = 56%, CS (NO)= 44%, mouth props = 42%, OP = 40%, VC = 28%, physical restraints = 26%, HOME =24%TSD technique was the most accepted behavior technique and HOME the least accepted behavior technique. Parents seem to be more acceptable to pharmacologic methods than in previous studiesAcceptance for GA was superior to HOMEConsidered for MA16Fuccio et al. (2003) Brazil23Parents of 3–12-year-old children, n = 49TSD, VC, PR, M, HOME, PR-A PR-P, CS, GACustom made scale using cardboard and VelcroNonrestricti ve techniques (TSD, PR, VC, modelling): Always accept: 81%, sometimes accept: 15%, never accept: 4%. Restrictive techniques (HOME, PR-A, PR-P): Always accept: 29%, sometimes accept: 33%, never accept: 38%. Pharmacologic techniques (CS, GA): Always accept: 18%, sometimes accept: 40%, never accept: 42%Nonrestrictive techniques were most accepted (TSD, VC are PR) accepted. Restrictive (HOME, PR-A and PR-P) and sedation/GA techniques were most unacceptedArticle in Portuguese. No comparison with GA was madeNot considered for MA17Simoes et al. (2016) Brazil24Parents (21–59 years, 7 M, 31 F) of 0–12-year-old childrenTSD, VC, PR, PS, modelling, HOME, PR-P, PR-A, CSPre- and postexplanati on acceptance for behavior management technique s was comparedTSD (before explanation: 86.8%, after explanation; 100%), PR (before explanation: 84.2%, after explanation; 76.3%)Rejection of HOME: 38.8%, PR-P: 51%, PR-A: 24.5%Acceptance of nonrestrictive techniques such a TSD and PR much higher than restrictive techniquesArticle in Portuguese. No comparison with GA was madeNot considered for MA18Abushal and Adenubi (2003), Saudi Arabia25n = 133VC, TSD, PR, PR-A, HOME, GA, PS, CS, distraction, NVCVAS scores (0–100) of acceptances were compared in four categoriesMost threatening dental procedureTSD and PR was the most accepted and VC and HOME were least acceptedAcceptance for GA superior to HOMENot considered for MA19Jafarzadeh et al. (2015), Iran26Parents (18 M, 36 F) of children, n = 54VC, TSD, PR, PR-P, HOME, GA, OPPercentages of VAS scores 0–100 of acceptances were comparedPR-P and HOM scores were 35 and 30%, respectivelyTSD was the most accepted and PR-P and HOME were least acceptedAcceptance for GA superior to HOMENot considered for MA20Jahanimoghadam et al. (2018), Iran27Parents (20 M, 40 F) of 2–15-year-old children, n = 60VC, TSD, PS, PR, HOME, GAMeans and SDs of VAS scores of acceptances were compared before and after explanation to parentsTSD (81.98 + 20.2 1)PS (55.01 + 32.9 3)PR-A (29.68 + 29.9 5)VC (29.40 + 30.9 0)GA (29.06 + 29.1 7)HOME (20.21 + 27.4 9)In the order of acceptance, TSD was the most accepted followed by PS, followed by PR, followed by VC, followed by GA followed by HOMEAcceptance for HOME superior to GANot considered for MA21Gupta and Khajuria (2018)*, India28100 C= 2–6 years64 males36 femalesParents' age—20–40VC, TSD, PR, mouth prop, M, HOME, PR-A, OP NO, GAVAS based acceptance in percentages were compared and rankedTSD = 86%, PR = 76%, modelling = 76%, GA = 56%, NO = 44%, mouth props = 42%, OP = 40%, VC = 28%, physical restraints = 26%, HOME = 24%TSD was the most accepted and HOME was the last preferred BMTAcceptance for GA superior to HOMEConsidered for MA*This study was omitted in the MA as it was found to be a duplication of Acharya (2017) Data extraction for systematic review *This study was omitted in the MA as it was found to be a duplication of Acharya (2017) Table 2:Data extraction for meta-analysis Author and year Subject (n) Age Gender HOM E VC TSD PR-A PR-P GA PS CS D OP PR Kamolmatayakul and Nukawl, 2002Songkla (Thailand)10185C = 2–15 yearsP = mean 36.6 (±6.8)C = 54% girls 43% boysP = 65% mother 15% father 15% guardian42%44%100%63%38%56%45%83%94%Noor et al., 2019Tamil Nadu (India)1110049%34%92%58. 3%53.1%58%de León et al., 2010Barcelona (Spain)1250C = 3–13 yearsC = 56% girls 44% boysP = 34% women 16% men7%33%57%20%10%18%20%10%Venkataraghavan et al., 2016Ahmedabad, Gujarat (India)1351C = 2–4 years 58.8% (2–3 years) 41.2% (3–4 years)P = 20–40 years 64.7% (20–30 years) 35.3% (30–40 years)0%0.3%41.1%1.1%0%2.5%0%6.%Paryab et al., 2014Tehrain (Iran)1490C = 3–6 yearsP = 22–42 (mean 30 years)P = 100% female53.3%82.2%37.8%38. 9%54. 4%Muhammad et al. 2011 (Kuwait)9118C = 8.8 ± 2. 1 (6–13 years)P = 37.6 ± 6.2 (24–51 years)P = 54 males64 females5. 1%30.5%99.2%19.5%5.9%51.7%4.2% 20.3% (NO)99.2%20. 3%100%Razavi and Purtaji, 2007Iran1850Females = 5050%92%30%100%Elango et al., 2012Bengaluru (India)19102C = 3–15 years72.1 4%77.5 7%90.7 0%85.2 3%80. 40%84. 68%89.43%Thirunavakarasu et al., 2021Chennai (India)20100C = 6–12 yearsP = 30–40 years60.8%76.8%91.5%27.4%14.7%16. 3%45.8%89.2%Alammouri et al., 2006Jordan21138Females = 51.5%Males = 48.5%9.4%56.5%92.8%23.9%32. 6%55.1%27.5%30.45% (NO)76.8%91.3%Acharya (2017)India2250C = 3–6 yearsP = 20–40 years64% males36% females24%28%86%26%56%44%40%76%Gupta and Khajuria, (2018)*Jammu, India28100C = 2–6 yearsP = 20–40 years64% males36% females24%28%86%26%56%44%40%76%*This study was omitted as it was found to be a duplication of Acharya (2017) Data extraction for meta-analysis *This study was omitted as it was found to be a duplication of Acharya (2017) Author, year, and settings (country). Author, year, and settings (country). Subjects (n). Subjects (n). Age. Age. Gender. Gender. Details pertaining to parental acceptance of each technique: HOME, VC, TSD, PR-A, PR-P, GA, PS, CS. Details pertaining to parental acceptance of each technique: HOME, VC, TSD, PR-A, PR-P, GA, PS, CS. Details pertaining to risk of bias assessment. Details pertaining to risk of bias assessment. Assessment of Risk of Bias in Included Studies We assessed the risk of bias using the “Joanna Briggs ROB tool for cross-sectional analytical studies.”15 The results are reported in Table 3. Table 3:Joanna Briggs Risk of Bias tool for cross-sectional analytical studies Questions Study Paryab et al. 2014 Noor et al. 2019 de Leon et al. 2010 Muhammad et al. 2011 Venkataraghavan et al. 2016 Kamolmatayakul and Nukaw 2002 Boka et al. 2014 Desai et al. 2019 Rahman et al. 2021 Eaton et al. 2005 Razavi and Purtaji 2007 Elango et al. 2012 Thirunavakarasu et al. 2021 Alammouri et al. 2006 Fuccio et al. 2003 Simoes et al. 2016 Abushal and Adenubi 2003 Jafarzadeh et al. 2015 Jahanimoghadam et al. 2018 Acharya 2017 Gupta and Khajuria 2018 1. Were the criteria for inclusion in the sample clearly defined?YNYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY2. Were the study subjects and the setting described in detail?YNYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYNN3. Was the exposure measured in a valid and reliable way?NNNNNNNNNYNNNNNNNNNNN4. Were objective, standard criteria used for measurement of the condition?NNNNNNNNNYN?NNNNNNNNN5. Were confounding factors identified?YYYYYYYYYY?YNYYYYYYYY6. Were strategies to deal with confounding factors stated?NNNNNNNNY/NN?NNNNNNNNNN7. Were the outcomes measured in a valid and reliable way?YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY8. Was appropriate statistical analysis used?YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY = low risk; N = high risk; ? = unclear Joanna Briggs Risk of Bias tool for cross-sectional analytical studies Y = low risk; N = high risk; ? = unclear Variables of Interest Percentage acceptance for each technique was the main variable of interest for comparison. The acceptance of parents for HOME was compared with other techniques individually. Meta-analyses were attempted for all possible comparisons of HOME with other techniques. Analysis Issues Analyses were based on dichotomous data comparison using OR and CI. Because of heterogeneity across studies, we used both fixed-effects and random-effects models for all comparisons. Dealing with Missing Data Since studies reported parental acceptance of HOME with different techniques, all available variables and data reported in the individual studies (with HOME being a mandatory inclusion) were recorded. Studies and data were grouped for pairwise comparisons (such as acceptance for HOME vs GA, HOME vs TSD, etc.). No attempt was made to add values to any missing or empty cells in the data tables. Assessment of Heterogeneity Heterogeneity in the results of the trials was assessed by inspecting a graphical display of the results and by the formal tests of heterogeneity, I2. Assessment of Reporting Biases A funnel plot was used to assess the publication bias across all studies (11 in total). The results are reported in Figure 2. HOME vs GA; (A) FEM; (B) REM Data Synthesis and Analysis Data analyses were carried out using RevMan 5.3 software. For the meta-analysis, odds ratios and confidence intervals (OR and CI) were used for the analyses. A total of 10 different comparisons were made, with HOME being the constant outcome in comparison with other BMTs (Plots 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7I, 7II, 8, 9, 10). Only one additional analysis was carried out for CS (NO) because two studies reported CS and NO as distinct variables. Results Description of Studies Dates of publication for the search ranged from 2000 to 2021. Using different combinations of keywords, a total of 5,712 records were identified in the preliminary search from search engines: PubMed, Cochrane Library, and Google Scholar; from which 5,633 studies were excluded as being irrelevant. After assessing titles and abstracts, 79 studies were found to report parental acceptance of HOME and other BMTs, from which articles reporting acceptance of children and studies other than observational (comparison of child and parent acceptance) were excluded. This left us with 37 articles. In addition, an extra 10 studies could be retrieved after searching through another search engine (Semantic Scholar) and checking cross-references. After excluding studies that did not record parental acceptance in percentages, only 21 studies remained in the final selection for the systematic review, of which 12 could be included in the meta-analysis. One study (Gupta and Khajuria) was found to be a duplicate of a previously reported paper (Acharya et al.) and was therefore removed from the meta-analysis. Thus, the number for the meta-analysis was 11 studies. The stepwise selection and exclusion of studies (with reasons) are summarized in a flowchart (Fig. 1). Data extraction was begun by FT and SD (postgraduate students) and completed by AJ and LM (the two senior investigators). After the data extraction, studies were segregated based on the parameters of comparison of acceptance for HOME and other techniques of behavior management. The two variables for comparison were percentage acceptance for HOME and other techniques of behavior management, and visual analog scale (VAS) scores pertaining to the acceptance of HOME and other techniques of behavior management. Studies related to the VAS scores could not be included unless percentage acceptance could be calculated. Table 1 includes the description of studies that were considered for comparison. From the data available in Table 1, it is evident that out of twenty studies, nine studies reported higher acceptance of parents for GA than for HOME; seven reported higher acceptance of parents for HOME than for GA, and the remaining four appeared inconclusive. Table 2 includes the studies that were considered for the meta-analysis based on the common variable (i.e., reported acceptance in percentages for each technique). All studies reported comparisons in terms of percentages of acceptance for HOME vs GA; nine studies reported comparisons in terms of percentages of acceptance for HOME vs VC and HOME vs TSD; eight studies reported comparisons in terms of percentages of acceptance for HOME vs PR-A. Seven studies reported comparisons in terms of percentage acceptance for HOME vs PR. Six studies reported comparisons in terms of percentages of acceptance for HOME vs PS, HOME vs CS, and HOME vs CS (NO). Five studies reported comparisons in terms of percentages of acceptance for HOME vs OP. Only four studies reported comparisons in terms of percentages of acceptance for HOME vs distraction and HOME vs PR-P. Characteristics of the Participants A total of 20 studies were included in the systematic review (SR). The participants/respondents were predominantly mothers of children (age range 20–50 years) belonging to the age-group of 2–15 years. In the SR, eight studies were reported from Southeast Asia (six from India, one from Malaysia, and one from Thailand), seven were from the Middle Eastern region (four from Iran, one from Kuwait, one from Saudi Arabia, and one from Jordan), two studies were from Europe (one from Spain and one from Greece), two studies were from South America (both from Brazil), and only one study was from North America (United States). Eleven studies (1,034 participants) remained in the meta-analysis (MA). Six studies were reported from Southeast Asia (five from India and one from Thailand), four were from the Middle Eastern region (two from Iran, one from Kuwait, and one from Jordan), and one study was from Spain. Characteristics of Outcome Measures The main outcome measure was acceptance of HOME by parents. The acceptance of HOME was compared with that of each of the other techniques of behavior management, all recorded in percentages (ratio variable). The mean percentages and standard deviations (SDs) for the variables were as follows: HOME, VC, TSD, PR-A, PR-P, GA, PS, CS, D, OP, and PR. The quantitative assessment with the meta-analysis (MA) was based on the calculation of risk ratios (RR) and confidence intervals (CI) from the available data. Forest Plots The MA was carried out for the comparison of acceptance for HOME vs each BMT. Reported are the plots of pairwise comparisons favoring either HOME or other BMTs. Ten studies compared parental acceptance for HOME vs GA. When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 1.03 (0.84, 1.25), indicative of a statistically non-significant difference in the acceptance of parents for HOME or GA (p = 0.80). Due to high heterogeneity (I2 = 89), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.92 (0.48, 1.77), indicative of a statistically nonsignificant difference in the acceptance of parents for HOME or GA (p = 0.80) (Fig. 2). Nine studies compared HOME vs VC. When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.48 (0.39, 0.59), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of VC (p < 0.00001). Due to high heterogeneity (I2 = 90), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.37 (0.17, 0.78), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of VC (p = 0.009) (Fig. 3). HOME vs VC; (A) FEM; (B) REM Nine studies compared HOME vs TSD. When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.04 (0.03, 0.05), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of TSD (p < 0.00001). Due to high heterogeneity (I2 = 88), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.03 (0.01, 0.09), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of TSD (p < 0.00001) (Fig. 4). HOME vs TSD; (A) FEM; (B) REM Eight studies compared parental acceptance for HOME vs PR-A. When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.65 (0.50, 0.84), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of PR-A (p = 0.0001). Due to high heterogeneity (I2 = 88), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.52 (0.22, 1.25), indicative of a statistically nonsignificant difference in the acceptance of parents for HOME or PR-A (p = 0.14) (Fig. 5). HOME vs PR-A; (A) FEM; (B) REM Four studies compared parental acceptance for HOME vs PR-P. When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 1.21 (0.92, 1.59), indicative of a statistically nonsignificant difference in the acceptance of parents for HOME or PR-P (p = 0.17). Due to high heterogeneity (I2 = 95), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 1.56 (0.36, 6.72), indicative of a statistically nonsignificant difference in the acceptance of parents for HOME or PR-P (p = 0.55) (Fig. 6). HOME vs PR-P; (A) FEM; (B) REM Six studies compared parental acceptance for HOME vs PS. When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.28 (0.22, 0.36), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of PS (p < 0.00001). Due to high heterogeneity (I2 = 92), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.17 (0.05, 0.54), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of PS (p = 0.003) (Fig. 7). HOME vs PS; (A) FEM; (B) REM Six studies compared parental acceptance for HOME vs CS. When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.77 (0.60, 1.00), indicative of a statistically non-significant difference in the acceptance of parents for HOME or CS (p = 0.05). Due to high heterogeneity (I2 = 78), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.67 (0.36, 1.27), indicative of a statistically nonsignificant difference in the acceptance of parents for HOME or CS (p = 0.22) (Fig. 8—I). I: HOME vs CS; (IA) FEM; (IB) REM; II: HOME vs CS (NO); (IIA) FEM; (IIB) REM Six studies compared parental acceptance for HOME vs CS (NO). When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.65 (0.51, 0.84), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of CS (NO) (p = 0.0009). Due to high heterogeneity (I2 = 84), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.50 (0.25, 1.04), indicative of a statistically nonsignificant difference in the acceptance of parents for HOME or CS (NO) (p = 0.06) (Fig. 8—II). Four studies compared HOME vs distraction. When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.11 (0.09, 0.15), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of distraction (p < 0.00001). Due to high heterogeneity (I2 = 96), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.05 (0.01, 0.29), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of distraction (p = 0.001) (Fig. 9). Five studies compared HOME vs OP. When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.55 (0.39, 0.78), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of OP (p = 0.0007). Due to moderate heterogeneity (I2 = 50), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.53 (0.31, 0.89), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of OP (p = 0.02) (Fig. 10). HOME vs distraction; (A) FEM; (B) REM HOME vs OP; (A) FEM; (B) REM Seven studies compared HOME vs PR. When FEM was applied, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.06 (0.04, 0.08), indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of PR (p < 0.00001). Due to high heterogeneity (I2 = 91), REM was applied; however, the OR (CI) was found to be 0.05 (0.01, 0.16), also indicative of a statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents in favor of PR (p < 0.00001) (Fig. 11). HOME vs PR; (A) FEM; (B) REM Risk of Bias Assessment Two tools were used for the risk of bias (ROB) assessment. The Survey Assessment Framework (Gauthier, 2003)29 was employed for the primary screening of the studies included in the meta-analysis. The Joanna Briggs ROB Tool for Cross-sectional Analytical Studies was utilized for the studies included in the systematic review. The results of the Joanna Briggs ROB Tool are shown in Table 3. The publication bias was assessed using funnel plot analysis for all 11 studies based on the standard error (SE) of the log odds ratio [Log(OR)]. The results indicated marked and fairly equal dispersion on either side of the central line, suggesting minimal publication bias (Fig. 12). Funnel plot-publication bias Discussion “Systematic reviews aim to appraise and synthesize the available evidence addressing a specific research question; a meta-analysis is a statistical summary of the results from relevant studies.”30 The preferences for certain BMTs employed by dentists can be assessed only with questionnaire-based observational studies; hence, we chose to attempt a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies on the pertaining topic. Meta-analysis of observational studies can be useful because observational studies not only provide additional information to RCTs but also, for many research questions, are the most reliable and the only source of available evidence.31 Furthermore, meta-analyses of observational studies are being used for the synthesis of evidence to fulfill the compelling need for timely and informed decisions in public health and clinical practice.32 In a scoping review of recommendations for the meta-analysis of observational studies based on 93 articles, Mueller et al. (2018) reported a lack of consensus and conflicting recommendations on various aspects of the process, such as the choice of study designs, quality scales to assess the risk of bias, and the choice of model (fixed or random effects, etc.).33 Therefore, we attempted to make use of the appropriate checklists and methods for the assessment of risk of bias, such as the JB ROB Tool for Cross-sectional Analytical Studies, which was used for the studies included in the SR, and the Survey Assessment Framework, which was used for the studies included in the MA.15,29 The JB ROB Tool is used in the MA of BMTs by Massignan et al. (2020).34 A common observation across most of the studies was that there was a lack of standardized, prevalidated, or piloted study tools. This can introduce bias in the measurements of the parameters of interest. A prerequisite for the meta-analysis is the identification of a common variable of interest across the studies. In the present SRMA, acceptance of various BMTs was the main variable of interest. Several studies reported this in percentage acceptance, whereas a few studies reported acceptance based on VAS scores. The studies reporting only VAS scores could not be included unless the percentage acceptance was obtainable for a few reasons. VAS is often used as a categorical scale. At times, VAS scores are also reported as mean and SD; however, the scale range varies from 0 to 10 or 0 to 100. Though we compared the acceptance of HOME to several BMTs that are commonly employed, we feel that the most noteworthy comparison is HOME vs GA. GA for child behavior management is often considered the last resort, and there may be significant resistance from parents to accepting the same due to the fear associated with the risks involved. We found another MA of observational studies on BMTs by Massignan et al. (2020); however, the MA differs in three ways: firstly, there were no comparisons made; secondly, it was not time-specific; and thirdly, it did not focus on the acceptance of a certain technique such as HOME in view of changing trends over the past few decades. Questionnaire-based studies on the selection of BMTs have a limitation in that the questions may not adequately portray a real-life situation, that is, how the child is behaving while undergoing treatment and how the dental team is making an effort to manage the same. Al Zoubi et al. (2021) compared acceptance for techniques during the normal course and emergencies and found higher acceptance of pharmacological methods, PR-P, and PR-A (did not, however, include HOME) in emergency situations.35 A few studies also reported acceptance of modeling and hypnosis, such as that reported by Peretz and Zadik (2013); however, these techniques were not consistently represented in other studies.36 Ramos et al. (2005) (Brazil) on 400 children aged 4–10 years was omitted because of the inclusion of children with clefts.37 We could not assess the impact of parents’ age, gender, children's age, socio-economic status, and other factors such as the number of children, order of the child, and marital factors on the preferences in the selection of BMTs due to the unavailability of such information from all or most of the studies. Results of our meta-analysis indicate low acceptance of HOME, comparable only to GA, passive restraints, and CS. All other BMTs were preferred to HOME by parents. According to the recent reference manual of AAPD, Behavior Guidance Techniques (BGTs) are classified as basic and advanced.6 The manual omits HOME from the BGTs. Our study, however, finds parental acceptance of HOME comparable to GA, passive restraints, and CS. Thus, judicious use of HOME with parental consent can still be a choice, at least in the settings where the law permits the same. This is in agreement with the views mentioned by Jawdekar (2010).37 Findings based on the selected studies in this SRMA have limited generalizability due to several reasons. Firstly, most studies were conducted in academic institutes and not in private settings. Secondly, there were no studies from North America, most of Europe, Australia-New Zealand, China, and Africa. The majority of the studies came from Middle Eastern and Southeast Asian countries, possibly because the Western world and many countries have already parted with the HOME technique and accepted pharmacological management as the standard of care for child behavior management. The selected studies in the SRMA exhibit diverse methodological variations. Regarding the explanation of the BMTs to parents, a few studies included explanations through videos, while others showed photographs. In a few studies, BMTs were explained by the pediatric dentists or dentists, while in others, the same was done by staff other than the dentists. Quality of the Evidence Using the two tools, the risk of bias was judged to be moderate. The publication bias was found to be minimal, too. The evidence can be considered low quality owing to high heterogeneity and also because the MA is based on observational studies. Conclusion Based on the quantitative analyses (meta-analyses with forest plots using fixed effect models), we conclude that, No statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents was seen for HOME vs. GA, CS, and PR-P. No statistically significant difference in the acceptance of parents was seen for HOME vs. GA, CS, and PR-P. VC, TSD, PS, PR-A, CS (NO), OP, distraction, and PR were preferred to HOME; the difference in acceptance being statistically significant. VC, TSD, PS, PR-A, CS (NO), OP, distraction, and PR were preferred to HOME; the difference in acceptance being statistically significant. However, the above interpretations should be accepted with caution due to high heterogeneity among the studies. The differences in acceptance between HOME vs. CS (NO) and PR-A did not remain statistically significant when random effects models were used. The risk of bias across the studies was moderate, with inconsistencies in the measurements of parameters in a standardized manner and the use of prevalidated or piloted tools. The publication bias was found to be minimal. Implications for Practice This review is the first of its kind to uncover the acceptance of parents to HOME and compare that with other BMTs. In the absence of other evidence, this can help develop guidance for dentists on BMTs, including HOME, based on parental approval. Our findings, however, have limited generalizability due to the limited number of studies included (not adequately representative) and cultural, social, and legal differences in the recommendations, training, and practice of BMTs across the globe. Implications for Research Preferences of parents (and thereby of children and dentists) toward various BMTs may vary over time. Periodic assessment of acceptance of various BMTs by all stakeholders (dentists, parent/child dyads, professional bodies, and policymakers) is therefore essential. More primary research is needed in different settings (public/private setups, general dental/specialty practices, etc.) and different social and cultural contexts in view of the same. Acknowledgments We sincerely acknowledge the assistance in statistics from Dr Dheeraj Kalra (Reader, Public Health Dentistry, SMBT Dental College and Hospital, Ghoti). We also acknowledge Dr Tejashri Gupte for her help in procuring a few articles from the library of Nair Hospital Dental College. Footnotes Source of support: Nil Conflict of interest: None References