The role of maize sap beetles (Coleoptera: Nitidulidae) and maize weevils (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) in the spread of Aspergillus flavus in pre-harvest maize in Kenya Authors: Ginson Riungu, James W Muthomi, Wolfgang Buechs, John M Wagacha, Esther Sheila Philip, Torsten Meiners Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractThe spread of toxigenic Aspergillus into maize by insects and the subsequent aflatoxin contamination poses a risk to humans and animals and has been investigated in North and South America. To evaluate this effect in an African context, Greenhouse studies were conducted in 2022 to determine the role of sap beetles, Carpophilus dimidiatus Fabricius, 1792 (Coleoptera: Nitidulidae) and maize weevils, Sitophilus zeamais Motschulsky, 1855 (Coleoptera: Curculionidae) on infection of maize kernels by Aspergillus flavus Link and the resultant aflatoxin accumulation. To test the beetles’ efficacy, treatments were applied on partially opened primary ears at 3 different stages of kernel development (BBCH 75, 83, and 87). The treatments were: (i) distilled water, (ii) water with A. flavus spores, (iii) maize grits, (iv) maize grits with A. flavus spores, (v) C. dimidiatus, (vi) C. dimidiatus with A. flavus spores, (vii) S. zeamais, and (viii) S. zeamais with A. flavus spores. Data on kernel infection, maize rotting, yield, and aflatoxin content in kernels were collected. The highest kernel spoilage and yield loss were recorded for the co-inoculation of S. zeamais and A. flavus spores, followed by S. zeamais without A. flavus spores, and then C. dimidiatus with the fungal spores. Inoculation of maize at the BBCH 83 growth stage resulted in the highest kernel damage and aflatoxin contamination. S. zeamais and, to a lesser extent, C. dimidiatus effectively spread the A. flavus inoculum into non-wounded ears, resulting in fungal and aflatoxin contamination. The yield loss from S. zeamais-Aspergillus co-inoculation occurred due to the grain rotting and actual feeding of the maize weevils. Thus, insect management is important in reducing pre-harvest contamination of maize with mycotoxigenic fungi and their resultant toxins. Introduction Maize (Zea mays L.) is a staple food for many households in East Africa, a key ingredient in animal feed, and is used to manufacture various industrial products. However, the mycotoxin contamination of maize used for food and feed in Kenya and most sub-Saharan African countries remains a challenge (Probst et al. 2014, Mwihia et al. 2020). The contamination is mainly attributed to infection by Aspergillus flavus, which produces aflatoxins (Udoh et al. 2000, Muthomi et al. 2012), or Fusarium verticillioides (Sacc.) Nirenberg, which produces fumonisins (Giorni et al. 2019). High levels of aflatoxin in maize have been recorded in the Eastern region of Kenya, an occurrence that is attributed to the prevailing climatic conditions (Probst et al. 2014, Mutunga et al. 2017) and the presence of a highly virulent and toxigenic strain of A. flavus, the S-morphotype (Probst et al. 2014). Ingestion of high levels of aflatoxins may lead to acute aflatoxicosis and death (Lewis et al. 2005), whereas chronic exposure to low doses predisposes humans to liver cancer and may affect protein metabolism and immunity, and thus may worsen disease infections and malnutrition (Williams et al. 2004). Chronic exposure to aflatoxins is associated with impaired growth in children (Kang’ethe et al. 2017, Mahfuz et al. 2018) and with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), particularly in individuals chronically infected with the hepatitis B virus (Mitchell et al. 2017). In addition to the health concerns for consumers, aflatoxin contamination lowers the market value and uses for the contaminated crop. Animals fed with contaminated maize or its byproducts may exhibit stunted growth and reduced yields of milk and eggs (Schmale and Munkvold 2009, Suleiman et al. 2015). Pre-harvest entry of fungal pathogens into maize occurs through the silks and later infection into glumes, kernels, ear tips, and down to the ear base (Koehler 1942, Marsh and Payne 1984, Thompson and Raizada 2018). The fungal spores are carried into the entry points mainly by lepidopterans and coleopterans (Drepper and Renfro 1990, Nesci and Etcheverry 2002, Chulze 2010). Among the caterpillars associated with the enhancement of mycotoxins in maize are the corn earworm (Helicoverpa zea Boddie), European corn borer (Ostrinia nubilalis Hübner), and the fall armyworm (Spodoptera frugiperda, J. E. Smith), whereas among the beetles, maize weevils (Sitophilus zeamais Motschulsky) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), and sap beetles (Carpophilus spp. Stephens) (Coleoptera: Nitidulidae), are important (Dowd, 1998). Other insects, including moths, worms, bees, grasshoppers, and flies, are often colonized by Aspergillus and other mycotoxigenic fungi and can, therefore, vector them to maize and other crops (Guthrie et al. 1982, Bosque-Pérez and Mareck 1991, St Leger et al. 2000, Gupta and Gopal 2002). In previous studies, wounding and non-wounding techniques were applied when inoculating maize with Aspergillus. Commonly used non-wounding techniques include spraying and atomization of spores onto maize silks (Payne et al. 1988) and the use of granular material infected with A. flavus to inoculate ears (Olanya et al. 1997, Bock and Cotty 1999). Spray inoculation has been used to study A. flavus interaction with southwestern corn borer (Diatraea grandiosella, Dyar), and the interaction significantly increased aflatoxin contamination (Windham et al. 1999). Wounding inoculation techniques used in maize trials include the pinbar, knife, pinboard, side needle, toothpick, and punch drill (Windham et al. 2003). In a recent study, C. dimidiatus and S. zeamais collected from maize in 3 regions in Kenya were colonized with aflatoxigenic strains of A. flavus and A. minisclerotigenes Vaamonde (Riungu et al., personal observation). Sap beetles, including Carpophilus lugubris Murray and C. freemani Dobson, have been identified as vectors of Aspergillus flavus to maize and can contaminate maize with aflatoxins (Lussenhop and Wicklow 1990). Though listed as secondary pests, sap beetles have, in some instances, caused substantial damage to maize by feeding on damaged or exposed kernels where they feed on fungi growing on the wounds or directly on the kernels, thus enhancing mycotoxins contamination (Bruck et al. 2006). In contrast, S. zeamais is a major pest of maize, particularly in storage, and damages maize, leading to quality and quantity losses (Khakata et al. 2018), including mycotoxin contamination (Beti et al. 1995). However, little is known about the effect of insect infestation on the spread of the fungal inoculum in maize before harvest, particularly in Kenya and Africa, where maize is a staple food. Most studies have been conducted on stored maize, and when done on maize ears, the wounding method has been used (Windham et al. 2003, 2018). Trials mimicking the vectoring aspect without wounding the ears and the stage of kernel development when the co-occurrence would be most detrimental in maize are scarce. Therefore, the present study investigated (1) the impact of S. zeamais and C. dimidiatus in the spread of Aspergillus spores in maize, (2) the resulting fungal infection and aflatoxin contamination, and (3) the stage of kernel development that is the most suitable for fungal inoculation. Materials and Methods Experimental Site and Crop Establishment Experiments were conducted in 2 greenhouse cycles set up in April and October 2022 to correspond with Kenya’s long and short rain cropping seasons, respectively. Maize was sown in an insect-proof greenhouse at the Kibos Sugar Research Institute in Kisumu County, Kenya (GPS coordinates: N 00° 02ʹ 11″, E 34° 49ʹ 17″, 1,250 m above sea level). It has an annual average temperature of 19.7 °C, an average relative humidity of 66%, and an average annual precipitation of 1,362 mm (Nyberg et al. 2020). The area experiences a bimodal rainfall pattern from March to July and September to January for long and short rains, respectively. The maize hybrid WH 505 (FAO 500, Western Seed Company, Kenya), which matures in 120–130 days, has a level 3 husk coverage on a 1 to 5 scale, where 1 = very loose, 2 = loose, 3 = moderate tightness, 4 = tight, and 5 = very tight, and is commonly grown in Western Kenya was used. It was grown in 15 cm diameter plastic buckets filled with forest soil obtained from the Kakamega forest and sterilized by autoclaving at 121 °C to ensure no Aspergillus spores were present. To each pot, 5 g of di-ammonium phosphate fertilizer (18:46:0) was added. Insect Rearing, Inoculum Preparation, and Inoculation Sap beetle (C. dimidiatus) and maize weevils (S. zeamais) were collected from maize fields in Makueni County, Kenya, and identified using morphological characteristics (Tumuramye 2010, Reales et al. 2018) with the help of Mr. Morris Mutua, an entomology expert at the National Museum of Kenya. Voucher specimens were deposited at the Kenya Agricultural and Livestock Research Organization (KALRO). Cultures of C. dimidiatus were maintained in sterile fresh maize ears placed in 3-L glass jars with the bottom layered with 2 cm moist sterile soil. The ears were obtained from the KALRO biotechnology laboratory and were replaced weekly to ensure constant nutrition. The jars were incubated at 30 ± 2°C, 72% ± 10% RH, and a photoperiod of 12:12 h (L:D). Pre-adult stages and young adult C. dimidiatus were fed on a sterilized maize meal prepared using a coffee grinder (AR1100, Moulinex, UK) and placed on 9 cm diameter Petri dishes (Odeyemi et al. 2004). The Petri dishes were kept in conditions similar to the jars for maintaining the adults above. The maize for preparing the meal had been grown in a greenhouse at the research center. The maize meal had been autoclaved and samples were plated on agar plates to confirm it had no Aspergillus contamination. Maize weevils (S. zeamais) were reared by placing 20 pairs of 1-week-old beetles in 2 kg of sterile maize placed in 5 kg capacity Kilner jars covered with mesh lids (Ojo and Amoloye 2016). The jars were then incubated for 7 days at 26 ± 0.5 °C, 55% ± 5% RH, and 12:12 h (L:D) photoperiod (Power and Pritam 1974) until inoculation. An aflatoxigenic strain of A. flavus (MKU-6) isolated from C. dimidiatus obtained from naturally infected maize ears from Makueni County, Kenya, was used in the trials. The identity of the fungus was confirmed based on cultural and morphological features (Klich 2002), spore characteristics observed under a Motic BA410 microscope (Meyer Instruments, Inc, Houston, USA), and by earlier DNA sequencing (Riungu et al., not published). Spores were multiplied on sterile maize grits (40 mesh, Ramtons Grinder RM541, autoclaved at 121 °C for 15 min). Two cork borer discs of a 5-day A. flavus colony were placed into the maize grits (100 mL distilled water, 50 g of maize grits into a 500-mL flask) and incubated at 28 ± 2 °C (Windham et al. 1999). After 7 days, a gram of the maize grits was placed in 25-mL plastic sterile centrifuge tubes, and in each tube, 5 adults of either the C. dimidiatus or the S. zeamais were introduced. Beetles were placed in centrifuge tubes containing sterile maize grits for the uninoculated control. The tubes were plugged using a sterile cotton plug, shaken, and left for 1 h for the spores to come into contact with the beetles’ cuticles (Bhusal and Khanal 2019). The inoculated vs. uninoculated beetles were placed on partially opened primary ears to expose the silks. The ears were then covered with muslin cloths to contain the insects, and the whole crops in different batches were randomly placed in mesh fabric cages (BugDorm 6M630, MegaView Science Co., Ltd., Taiwan) in the greenhouse to reduce the risk of cross-contamination. The treatments entailed either spraying maize ears with (i) distilled water, (ii) distilled water with A. flavus spores, or placing (iii) maize grits, (iv) maize grits with A. flavus spores, (v) C. dimidiatus without A. flavus spores, (vi) C. dimidiatus with A. flavus spores, (vii) S. zeamais without A. flavus spores, and (viii) S. zeamais with A. flavus spores. The treatments were applied on partially opened primary ears to expose the silks at 3 different times of kernel development: the milky stage, BBCH 75; early dough stage, BBCH 83; and at physiological maturity, BBCH 87. A 1-L garden flower sprayer was used to spray the distilled water treatments. Harvesting, Sample Handling, and Grain Data Collection Harvesting was done at BBCH 97, and from each batch, 5 ears were harvested and de-husked for ear rot rating assessment on a scale of 1 to 5, based on a visual appraisal of grain color and development, where 1 = sound and 5 = kernels damaged and covered with the fungus or discolored (Cardwell et al. 2000). The other batch was shelled by hand, and kernels sundried to a moisture content of below 13.5% (Twist Grain Pro, Draminski, Poland) and finely milled using a coffee and spice grinder (AR1100, Moulinex, UK) for aflatoxin analysis and fungal enumeration. The blender was disassembled, brushed, and rinsed between samples using 70% ethanol. The 400 seeds’ weight was determined using a weighing balance (Nimbus 1602E, Adam Equipment, UK), and the grains were sorted into clean vs unusable/spoilt grains. A kernel was described as spoilt if rated at 4 or 5 on the rotting scale described above. The damaged and undamaged grains were counted and weighed separately in 4 runs of 100 seeds, and the yield loss was determined using the function: Fungal contamination was determined by diluting 1 g of flour into 9 mL of distilled water successively and plating the10-−3 dilutions in 3 replicates on Potato Dextrose Agar modified with an antibiotic (39 g PDA, oxoid, 25 mg chloramphenicol, in a liter of water. The plates were incubated for 7 days at 28 °C, and yellow–green-colored colonies characteristic of A. flavus were enumerated, and the mean from the 3 plates was expressed as colony-forming units per gram (CFU/g) of flour. The identity of the Aspergillus was confirmed using the morphological features described by Klich (2002). Total aflatoxin was analyzed on 10 g of flour in duplicates using the manufacturer’s instructions (Helica, Biosystems Inc.). The assay is based on a solid-phase competitive inhibition enzyme immunoassay with an aflatoxin-specific antibody optimized to cross-react with all 4 subtypes of aflatoxin (B1, B2, G1, and G2) in grain with a detection limit of 20 ppb (Hygiena 2023). Data Analysis Data were subjected to SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC 2001) for analysis of variance (ANOVA) at P ≤ 0.05. A combined analysis of variance was carried out on all the collected data to determine the effects of the cycles, treatment, development stages, and their interactions. Data for the weight of rotten grains, percent infection rate, yield loss, CFU/g, and aflatoxins (ppb) were not normally distributed, and therefore they were log-transformed (log10). Since the factor cycle did not influence the data in the ANOVA, we performed a combined analysis. The mean separation test was performed using Tukey’s honestly significant difference (Tukey HSD) procedure at P ≤ 0.05 level of significance for each trait determined whenever the main effects were significant. Results Effect of Aspergillus and Insect Treatments on Cob and Kernel Damage and Yield Parameters The co-inoculation of maize with Aspergillus-S. zeamais or Aspergillus-C. dimidiatus resulted in visible rotting and seed damage. The rots and damage were more pronounced in ears co-inoculated with Aspergillus and S. zeamais, which showed the weevil entry and exit holes on the seeds (Fig. 1A). In contrast, the C. dimidiatus-Aspergillus treated ears had some rotting but no exit holes (Fig. 1B and C). Within a range from 1 to 5, the combined mean of ear rot severity from the 2 experimental cycles ranged from 1.1 in the control to 2.2 in the weevil-Aspergillus co-inoculation treatments (Fig. 2). Analysis of variance showed that treatment, time, and their interactions significantly (P ≤ 0.05) affected many of the parameters (Table 1). Table 1.ANOVA results on the influence of cycle, treatment (water, maize grits, S. zeamais, and C. dimidiatus with or without A. flavus [ASP]), and plant development stage/time (T) on the number and weight of clean seeds, kernel infection rate, weight of rotten grain, weight of 400 kernels, yield loss, fungal contamination, and aflatoxin contaminationEffectsdfNo. clean seeds/400Weight clean seed (g)Infection rate %Weight rotten seed (g)F-value P-valueF-value P-valueF-value P-valueF-value P-valueCycle (S)12.950.08780.370.54654.330.03921.50.2228Treatment (TRT)726.21<0.00015.23<0.000126.41<0.000119.9<0.00001Time (T)213.56<0.00010.170.83979.440.000114.42<0.0001Replicates30.380.76551.010.38920.70.55070.660.581S × TRT70.650.71210.230.9770.620.74050.820.5723S × T20.370.68861.820.1660.020.98190.260.7696TRT × T147.09<0.00012.910.00072.780.00115.58<0.0001S × TRT × T140.630.83440.340.98660.650.82140.680.7905Residual Mean square141219.68439.880.150.03 R 2 0.70.390.650.65C.V (%)3.8417.2813.137.1EffectsdfWeight 400 seeds (g)Yield loss %CFU/gAflatoxin level (ppb) F-value P-value F-value P-value F-value P-value F-value P-valueCycle (S)10.140.7041.760.18634.950.02770.610.4344Treatment (TRT)73.710.00122.82<0.000119.19<0.0001467.5<0.0001Time (T)20.870.422312.25<0.00017.280.0011.680.1892Replicates30.850.46730.870.45750.850.46961.30.2763S × TRT70.190.98810.80.58840.510.82750.690.6845S × T22.020.13610.160.85410.210.81470.310.7364TRT × T143.10.00034.87<0.00011.540.10531.810.0418S × TRT × T140.350.98480.660.81230.630.83240.810.6532Residual Mean square141458.750.020.710 R 2 0.370.660.580.96C.V (%)17.326.1719.812.51df, degrees of freedom; R2, coefficient of determination; CV (%), coefficient of variation. The weight of rotten seed, infection rate %, yield loss %, colony-forming units/g (CFU/g), and aflatoxin level (ppb) were log-transformed. ANOVA results on the influence of cycle, treatment (water, maize grits, S. zeamais, and C. dimidiatus with or without A. flavus [ASP]), and plant development stage/time (T) on the number and weight of clean seeds, kernel infection rate, weight of rotten grain, weight of 400 kernels, yield loss, fungal contamination, and aflatoxin contamination df, degrees of freedom; R2, coefficient of determination; CV (%), coefficient of variation. The weight of rotten seed, infection rate %, yield loss %, colony-forming units/g (CFU/g), and aflatoxin level (ppb) were log-transformed. Damage after co-inoculation of Aspergillus and insects. A) Damage after co-inoculation with S. zeamais; B) and C) damage after co-inoculation with C. dimidiatus.The figure was created with BioRender.com. Mean ear rot severity (scales 1–5) after inoculating maize ears with water, maize grits, S. zeamais, and C. dimidiatus with or without A. flavus (ASP). Values on the y-axis are means, and error bars represent the standard error of the mean; the x-axis is inoculation treatments; bar graphs accompanied by the same letters are not significantly different (Tukey’s honestly significant difference tests, P ≤ 0.05). The treatment significantly affected the number of clean seeds (F = 26.21; df = 7, 14; P < 0.001). The highest number of clean seeds was recorded in ears treated with distilled water (397.4 ± 0.1), and the lowest (349.6 ± 4.6) was in seeds with interaction between S. zeamais and Aspergillus (Table 2). Similarly, the weight of the clean seed was significantly influenced by the treatments (F = 5.23; df = 7, 14; P < 0.0001), with the heaviest clean seed (137.0 ± 1.8 g) reported from maize grit treated seeds while the lowest weight (110.0 ± 2.5 g) was reported from the S. zeamais-Aspergillus interaction. The weight of rotten seed was significantly influenced only by the interaction of S. zeamais and the pathogen (F = 19.9; df = 7, 14; P < 0.001) to record the highest weight of (9.2 ± 1.1 g). The infection rate varied across the treatments (F = 26.41; df = 7, 14; P < 0.001), with the S. zeamais-Aspergillus treated seeds recording the highest infection rate of (45.6% ± 3.8 %). The S. zeamais-Aspergillus interaction was the only treatment that resulted in significant yield loss (F = 22.82; df = 7, 14; P < 0.001), of (7.5% ± 0.8%) and aflatoxin levels (F = 467.5; df = 7, 14; P < 0.001) of 12.1 ppb total aflatoxin content. Table 2.Effect of treatment (water, maize grits, S. zeamais, and C. dimidiatus with or without A. flavus [ASP]) on the number and weight of clean seeds, kernel infection rate, weight of rotten grain, weight of 400 kernels, yield loss, fungal, and aflatoxin contaminationTreatmentsNo. clean seeds/400Weight clean seed (g)Infectionrate %Weight rotten seed (g)Weight.400 seeds (g)Yield loss %CFU/gAflatoxin level(ppb)Maize grits394.6 ± 0.5a137.0 ± 1.8a5.4 ± 0.5c0.7 ± 0.1b137.7 ± 1.9a0.5 ± 0.1b44.6 ± 4.7c