Australians’ Well-Being and Resilience During COVID-19: The Role of Trust, Misinformation, Intolerance of Uncertainty, and Locus of Control Authors: Nida Denson, Kevin M Dunn, Alanna Kamp, Jehonathan Ben, Daniel Pitman, Rachel Sharples, Grace Lim, Yin Paradies, Craig McGarty, Michele Roccella, Gennaro Ruggiero, Valeria Carola, Giampaolo Nicolais Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractBackground/Objectives: In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, Australian state and federal governments enacted boarder closures, social distancing measures, and lockdowns. By the end of October 2020, the 112-day lockdown in the Australian state of Victoria was the longest continuous lockdown period internationally. Previous studies have examined how the COVID-19 pandemic and government restrictions have affected Australians’ mental health and well-being; however, less is known about the relationship between psychological variables and well-being. Methods: We administered a national survey of Australians aged 16 years and over (N = 1380) in November 2020 to examine the psychological factors that promoted and hindered Australians’ well-being and resilience during the first year of the pandemic. Results: Our study found that Australians reported normal to moderate levels of anxiety, moderate stress, mild depression, and moderate to high loneliness. Interpersonal trust was consistently a protective factor for well-being and resilience and was associated with less depression, anxiety, stress, and loneliness, and greater resilience. Participants with greater inhibitory anxiety (intolerance of uncertainty) and an external locus of control were more likely to be depressed, anxious, stressed, and lonely, and less resilient, compared with those with less inhibitory anxiety and those who believed that these outcomes were determined by their own actions. COVID-19 beliefs were associated with more depression, anxiety, stress, and resilience. Conclusions: This study seeks to inform the development of mental-health, well-being, and resilience strategies by government agencies, non-government organisations, and healthcare providers in times of crisis and in “ordinary” times.Keywords: COVID-19 pandemic, psychological factors, mental health, loneliness, resilience, Australia 1. Introduction The COVID-19 pandemic created a global physical and mental health crisis, with far-reaching economic, social, political, and ethical consequences that remain felt today, more than four years after its outbreak [1,2]. Populations across the globe have faced unprecedented levels of socioeconomic uncertainty while needing to respond to the virus by adopting and adapting to preventative health measures, restrictions on daily proximities and activities, and fragmented societal structures [3]. Taking place across diverse contexts (e.g., geopolitically, socio-culturally), the pandemic affected countries differently, and some of its effects have been acutely uneven [2,4,5]. National, state, and local responses to the pandemic have varied, including the use of preventative measures [6], reigniting long-standing concerns about readiness and systemic inequality in health responses, both within and between countries [7,8]. By November 2020, Australia had 27,893 confirmed cases of COVID-19 and 907 deaths [9]. Compared with other countries, Australia’s relatively low cases were attributed to fairly successful compliance with border closures and social distancing measures to prevent the virus’s spread [10]. Key amongst such measures were several “lockdowns” (i.e., stay-at-home orders) to minimise outbreaks. Such measures had immediate impacts on the employment and financial security of individuals. When the current study was conducted, the unemployment rate in Australia was 6.8% [11], an increase of 1.7% from before the pandemic in 2019 [12], and 22% of businesses reported revenue decreases [13]. International research has demonstrated that the COVID-19 government restrictions contributed to adverse mental health and well-being outcomes, such as increased loneliness, depression, anxiety, and financial worry and reduced social support [14,15,16]. Similar effects were found in the United States and United Kingdom, revealing that the pandemic increased loneliness and poor mental health amongst adults [17,18]. A US study found that stay-at-home orders were associated with increased anxiety and financial worry as well as increased loneliness [19]. Research on previous pandemics has also found negative impacts on mental health outcomes, for example, increased levels of anxiety during the 2009 H1N1 pandemic [20] and the 2003 SARS outbreak [21]. However, the fuller, long-term extent of the COVID-19 pandemic’s (and its associated transformations’) negative mental health implications is still unclear, and researchers continue to grapple with issues that range from “long-COVID” to persisting racial disparities in pandemic health outcomes [4]. Numerous Australian studies have examined the well-being and resilience of Australians during the COVID-19 pandemic. Most notable is the ANU Social Research Centre’s COVID-19 Impact Monitoring Series [22]. They administered 11 surveys over the first 2 years of the pandemic. They found that life satisfaction decreased substantially at the beginning (during the first few months of the pandemic) and then fluctuated after that. In terms of psychological distress, there was a large increase in in the beginning, and again, it fluctuated after that. Social interaction has seen a dramatic decrease, which in 2022 had not yet returned to pre-pandemic levels, and has contributed to increased social isolation and loneliness. They also found that social cohesion (trust, fairness, helpfulness) increased significantly in the first six months of the pandemic and has slightly decreased since, but remains above pre-COVID levels [22]. Notably, at the beginning of the pandemic, they found that Australians had a high level of trust and confidence in the government and systems [22]. Another study on Australian adolescents found that 53% experienced worsening physical health, and 75% experienced worsening mental health as a result of the pandemic [23]. Unfortunately, these negative impacts on physical and mental health were exacerbated for adolescents with a history of depression or anxiety. There were also negative impacts of the pandemic on Australian adolescents’ interpersonal relationships, with 66% reporting feeling less connected to their friends, and 68% reported that the pandemic had a negative impact on family stress. These studies have focused on various factors that have impacted the well-being and resilience of Australians during the initial impacts of COVID-19, such as social isolation and economic uncertainty. However, one aspect that has been relatively understudied is the relationship of psychological variables on mental health and well-being. We were particularly interested in the potential influence of trust (trust in government and interpersonal trust), belief in COVID-19 misinformation, intolerance of uncertainty, and locus of control. These variables have been shown to be important factors in pandemics, shaping how societies mitigate the impact of COVID-19. Trust in government (or political trust) is the extent to which people “trust in political actors and institutions”, and interpersonal trust (or social trust) refers to “trust in other people” [24], with a recent meta-analysis showing that the object of trust (e.g., government, president) moderates the relationship between trust and various pandemic behaviours such as vaccine uptake and compliance with public health measures [24]. As has been shown in other times of uncertainty, another influencing factor that emerged during the pandemic was an increase in beliefs in conspiracy theories (i.e., explanations for the causes of events or circumstances secretly plotted by multiple powerful actors) [25] and misinformation (inaccurate or false information) [26,27]. At the time this study was conducted (November 2020), there were various beliefs, including beliefs in conspiracy theories, circulating on social media, such as that COVID-19 was a bio-engineered virus created by the Chinese, COVID-19 is worsened through installing 5G towers, and hot temperatures kill the virus [28]. Belief in conspiracy theories, especially as they relate to COVID-19, has been shown to be associated with a decrease in institutional trust (trust towards the police, state authorities, politicians, experts, and hospitals/doctors), less support of governmental regulations to curb the virus (e.g., closing schools), and lower likelihood of adopting physical distancing measures (e.g., limiting physical contact) [29]. Belief in conspiracy theories has also been shown to be associated with perceptions of lower risk to one’s own health and the health of others, but higher perceptions of risk to the economy and human liberties, which in turn were both associated with lower compliance with governmental COVID-19 guidelines [30]. Understanding beliefs in conspiracy theories will help elucidate both the public health challenges they pose as well as broader patterns of how societies respond to large-scale threats, making them an important focus of any comprehensive analysis of pandemic response and behaviour. Personality characteristics, such as intolerance of uncertainty (the inability to tolerate uncertainty and ambiguous situations) and having an external locus of control (beliefs that whatever happens to them is beyond their control) have also been shown to affect how people responded to the COVID-19 pandemic, with both being associated with increased mental health outcomes such as depression, anxiety, and stress [31,32]. The current study sought to provide this evidence by gauging the extent to which Australians’ mental health and well-being have been affected by the COVID-19 pandemic and the psychological variables that promoted and hindered their well-being and resilience in the context of the pandemic. This study was part of a larger project on enhancing resilience and social belonging during the pandemic, and a subset of the findings has been presented in the project’s final report [33]. The current study included the investigation of the following research questions: (1)During the first year of the pandemic, how did Australians fare in terms of their well-being and resilience? During the first year of the pandemic, how did Australians fare in terms of their well-being and resilience? (2)What were the psychological factors that promoted or hindered Australians’ well-being and resilience in the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic? What were the psychological factors that promoted or hindered Australians’ well-being and resilience in the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic? Our second research question has the following associated hypotheses: Participants who have higher trust in government will report better mental health, less loneliness, and higher resilience. Participants who have higher interpersonal trust will report better mental health, less loneliness, and higher resilience. Participants who hold various COVID-19 beliefs (including conspiracy theories and misinformation) will report poorer mental health, more loneliness, and less resilience. Participants who are more intolerant of uncertainty will report poorer mental health, more loneliness, and less resilience. Participants who have an external locus of control will report poorer mental health, more loneliness, and less resilience. 2. Materials and Methods 2.1. Participants and Procedure This study received ethics approval from the Western Sydney University Human Research Ethics Committee (H14042 on 27 October 2020). We administered a national online survey to Australians between 12 and 26 November 2020. Inclusion criteria consisted of Australian residents 16+ years of age. We included 16- and 17-year-olds, as they have the “maturity and capacity” to make an “informed decision” [34]. Even the Australian Psychological Society’s (APS) ethical guidelines deem that minors 14–15 years of age have sufficient maturity to give voluntary informed consent to participate in research [34]. One empirical study examined the capacity of 4th, 7th, and 10th graders and university students to understand their research rights. While understanding generally increased with age, this study found that 10th graders’ (ranging from 14.9–17.6 years of age) understanding of the purpose and nature of the research, research risks and benefits, confidentiality, and voluntary nature of participation, and the right to withdraw, did not differ from adults’ understanding [35]. In particular, 4th and 7th graders did not fully understand the right to withdraw. Given the low-risk nature of the survey, it was appropriate to include 16–17-year-olds in this study [35]. We utilised Dynata, an online panel provider, which has a pool of over 300,000 Australian panellists (including 16–17-year-olds). Dynata (https://www.dynata.com/about/ (accessed on 13 September 2024)) is one of the world’s largest first-party data platforms and survey service companies. With a global reach, Dynata has a strong Australian presence with a diverse panel, and it can also accommodate multiple data collection methods (e.g., online surveys, mobile surveys, telephone interviews). Our inclusion criteria consisted of Australian residents 16 years of age and older. Our exclusion criteria are non-Australian residents as well as Australian residents aged 15 years and younger. We targeted a national sample that was representative by state/territory, with a 1:2 ratio of those from culturally and linguistically diverse (CALD) backgrounds to those from Anglo backgrounds in order to obtain a culturally diverse sample. Dynata contacts the panellists, providing information about the research and asking them if they would like to participate in the study. They are also informed that their participation is entirely voluntary and that their responses will be anonymous. Only interested participants proceeded to completing the survey. The final sample consisted of 1380 respondents who were currently residing in Australia and were 16 years of age and older. Our sample was representative by state/territory [36] and income [37]. In terms of geographic distribution, 31.0% were in New South Wales, 25.0% in Victoria, 21.6% in Queensland, 11.0% in Western Australia, 7.3% in South Australia, 1.9% in Tasmania, 1.5% in the Australian Capital Territory, and 0.7% in the Northern Territory. Almost half (48.9%) of the participants earned