Differentiation of Insect Flours by Elemental Analysis and Chemometrics: A Study Using Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) Authors: Mattia Montanaro, Alessandra Biancolillo, Angelo Antonio D’Archivio, Martina Foschi, Mihkel Koel Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractBackground: This study aimed to validate a method for characterizing and quantifying the multi-elemental profiles of different insect flours to enable their distinction, identification, and quality assessment. The focus was on three insect species: cricket (Acheta domesticus), buffalo worm (Alphitobius diaperinus), and mealworm (Tenebrio molitor). Methods: Mealworms were powdered in the laboratory through mechanical processing. Sample analysis involved acid digestion using a microwave digester, followed by profiling with Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS). This technique enabled rapid, multi-elemental analysis at trace levels. Chemometric methods, including Principal Component Analysis (PCA) for exploratory analysis, Covariance Selection-Linear Discriminant Analysis (CovSel-LDA), alongside forward stepwise LDA classification methods, were applied and compared. Results: ICP-MS accurately detected elements at micro trace levels. Both classification models, based on different variable selection methods and externally validated on a test set comprising 45% of the available samples, proved effective in classifying samples based on slightly different pools of trace elements. CovSel-LDA selected Mg and Se, whereas the stepwise-LDA focused on Mg, K, and Mn. Conclusions: the validated methods demonstrated high accuracy and generalizability, supporting their potential use in food industry applications. This model could assist in quality control, facilitating the introduction of insect-based flour into European and international markets as novel foods.Keywords: insect flour, cricket flour, ICP-MS, explorative analysis, PCA, discriminant classification, LDA, variable selection, covariance selection 1. Introduction In the context of alternative food sources, edible insect flours are playing an increasingly central role in addressing the challenges associated with sustainable nutrition. Entomophagy has become quite widespread, as evidenced by information from the FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations): according to their data, over 2 billion people consume more than 2000 species of insects [1]. Although this practice is still relatively uncommon in Europe, this practice is traditional in parts of Asia, South America, and Africa [2]. The consumption of edible insects, and especially of their derivatives such as flour, can address various environmental and economic issues. According to the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) data, the world population increase is leading to a depletion of available resources; in this context, the vast availability of edible insects in nature could be a compelling reason to promote their production and consumption on a large scale [3]. Fiebelkorn and collaborators have shown that in vitro insect farming enables a reduction in CO2 emissions, lower water demand, and decreased land use; due to their sustainability, many companies have already recognized the economic potential of edible insects [4]. However, most studies on edible insects focus on their nutritional profile, which is also highly diverse [5]. Many edible insects can meet the amino acid requirements of the human diet; in addition to proteins, they are also rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids, contain high levels of essential minerals (copper, iron, magnesium, manganese, phosphorus, selenium, and zinc), and include fibers, such as chitin, not found in traditional meats [6]. Insects exhibit a highly variable protein content, ranging from 13% to 77%, depending on the development stage and order [6]. Edible insects are rich in oleic, linoleic, and linolenic acids, though their fatty acid profile depends heavily on their diet. Mineral content in insects is also extremely variable; not all edible insects can meet daily mineral requirements [7]. However, it has been shown that in some cases, certain mineral contents in insects can exceed those found in traditional meats; for example, beef has an average zinc content of approximately 12.5 mg per 100 g of dry weight, while R. phoenicis larvae contain 26.5 mg per 100 g [6]. While most studies focus on the protein and fatty acid profiles in insect flours, there are not numerous examples in the literature where flours can be characterized by assessing their multi-element profile, which, as noted above, is nutritionally significant. Indeed, some insect flours have been analyzed by infrared spectroscopy (IR). Benes and collaborators [8] have shown that it is possible to accurately differentiate and identify flour from seven insect species mixed with wheat flour; this study employed near-infrared spectrophotometry (NIR) coupled with chemometric classification methods. Another study [9], conducted by Foschi et al., aimed to use an IR spectrometer to establish a procedure for detecting potential adulterations in cricket flour through spectral comparison. Using Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) in studies on insect flours represents an innovative and effective alternative for their classification. The originality of this approach is evidenced by the fact that it is commonly applied to plant-based flours, such as rice flour [10], while studies on insect flours remain relatively limited. Its effectiveness, on the other hand, stems from its significant advantages in terms of precision and sensitivity. In light of this, the present study aims at validating a method for characterizing and quantifying the multi-elemental profiles of different insect flours to enable their distinction, identification, and quality assessment. The focus was on three insect species: cricket (Acheta domesticus), buffalo worm (Alphitobius diaperinus), and mealworm (Tenebrio molitor). This exploits the sensitivity of ICP-MS, coupled with advanced chemometric methods, to provide a robust framework for the classification and quality assessment of insect flours. By identifying trace elements critical for discrimination, this research represents a novel application of ICP-MS to a burgeoning area of sustainable food science. 2. Results and Discussion 2.1. ICP-MS Analysis and Validation The ICP-MS analysis has been run as described in Section 3.2. Table 1 presents the isotopes of the elements analyzed, the lower and upper concentrations, expressed in µg/L, of the respective calibration curves, and the coefficients of determination (R2). Table 1The isotopes of the analyzed elements, the minimum (LLOQ) and maximum (HLOQ) concentrations in µg/L, defining the extremes of the calibration lines, and the coefficients of determination (R2) are reported.IsotopeLLOQ (µg/L)HLOQ (µg/L)R210B0.54000.997023Na15030000.998024Mg7530000.993027Al0.21600.998031P30080000.998039K30080000.999944Ca5010000.996052Cr0.1800.998055Mn0.2400.998057Fe24000.999059Co0.05400.999060Ni0.1800.999064Zn0.54000.999965Cu0.1800.999980Se0.54000.999088Sr0.25200.981098Mo0.25200.9999111Cd0.05400.9999138Ba0.21600.9999 The isotopes of the analyzed elements, the minimum (LLOQ) and maximum (HLOQ) concentrations in µg/L, defining the extremes of the calibration lines, and the coefficients of determination (R2) are reported. The calibration curves and independent measurements of blank samples were employed to determine the limit of detection (LOD) and the limit of quantification (LOQ). Table 2 presents the validation parameters assessed according to Eurachem guidelines [11]. Specifically, it includes the relative standard deviation (RSD) of the method, estimated from five replicates of unfortified samples, the recovery rates for two matrices (crickets and buffalo worms), also calculated from five replicates for each class, as well as the LOD and LOQ expressed in µg/g of dried samples. Table 2Validation parameters of the method for each analyzed isotope and mean concentrations of the element in the different classes of flours (crickets (C) and buffalo worms (B) and 28 samples for mealworms (W)).Parameters10B23Na24Mg27Al31PRSD (%)X0.4161RecoveryB (%)X9996103105RecoveryG (%)X999610493mean B class (ppm)