The impact of using simulation-based learning to further develop communication skills of pharmacy students and pharmacists: a systematic review Authors: Laura Foucault-Fruchard, Vanessa Michelet-Barbotin, Alison Leichnam, Martine Tching-Sin, Pierre Nizet, Sophie Tollec, Fabien Nativel, Elise Vene, Clémentine Fronteau, Jean-François Huon Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundEffective communication in healthcare, among professionals and between professionals and patients is crucial for delivering high-quality care. While simulation effectively translates technical skills to clinical practice, its impact on communication, particularly in pharmacies, is less well documented.AimThis systematic review examined the impact of simulation-based education on communication skills among pharmacy students and pharmacists. It aims to identify the types of simulations used, the outcomes obtained, and the effectiveness of these simulations in enhancing communication skills, perception and confidence.MethodWe conducted searches in MEDLINE, LISSA, EMBASE, and PsycINFO for articles on communication training through simulation for pharmacy students and pharmacists. The search covered the period from inception to August 31, 2022. To be included, studies had to meet the following criteria: (i) target pharmacy student or graduate pharmacists; (ii) use simulation in the field of clinical pharmacy; (iii) provide a complete description of the outcome measure. Studies for which it was impossible to extract data specific to pharmacy students or simulation were excluded. Three investigators independently evaluated each title and abstract. If each investigator considered the citation eligible, six authors progressed to full-text review. The outcomes related to communication were categorized into three groups: perception of the importance of communication in delivering high-quality patient care, confidence in communication skills, and assessed communication proficiency. The quality of studies included in this review was assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT).ResultsThe total number of participants was 3337. Among the 20 articles reviewed, which were primarily published in the United States over the last decade, only one focused on community pharmacists. Quasi experimental designs were predominant, and studies often relied on learners' self-assessments with non-validated questionnaires. Simulation-based learning aimed to enhance communication skills and attitudes across interprofessional contexts (involving nursing and medical students), patients, and families, frequently utilizing simulated patients. Studies evaluating outcomes have emphasized communication skills with patients and families, while those involving healthcare professionals often focused on perception of the importance of communication in delivering high-quality patient care.ConclusionDespite study heterogeneity, this systematic review concluded that simulation-based training significantly enhances perception, confidence, and communication skills. The development of clear guidelines and standardized assessment tools to evaluate communication would significantly improve the validity and reliability of future research efforts (PROSPERO registration: n°CRD42022371915).Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12909-024-06338-6.Keywords: Simulation, Communication, Clinical pharmacy, Students, Learning Introduction Communication skills are essential for healthcare professionals because they play a crucial role in patient care and safety [1]. Effective communication skills allow healthcare workers to understand their patients' needs, concerns, and expectations and to tailor care to each patient's unique circumstances [2, 3]. Among all professionals involved in patient care, pharmacists primarily serve as active communicators with patients, other health professionals, and the public [4]. Clinical pharmacy is a patient-centered healthcare discipline whose practice aims to optimize therapy at each stage of the care process [5]. It ensures the safe, appropriate, and efficient use of health products through collaboration with other healthcare professionals, patients, and caregivers [6]. Effective communication with healthcare teams is crucial for coordinating care, exchanging information, and making informed treatment decisions [4]. In contrast, poor communication can lead to medical errors, treatment delays, and reduced patient satisfaction [7]. Communication failures among healthcare professionals are reported to be the primary contributing factor to more than 50% of 'Never Events' involving patients [8, 9]. A 'Never Events' is defined by the health system as a serious, largely preventable, patient safety incident that should never be allowed to happen [10]. Simulation-based training, which has emerged as an effective method for improving healthcare professionals’ skills, and learning in clinical settings is crucial for developing and maintaining learners’ skills [11]. In healthcare education, simulation can be used to reproduce situations or environments of care, to teach diagnostic and therapeutic procedures and to allow repeat processes or decision-making by healthcare professionals [12]. Simulations facilitate healthcare workers’ learning to practice their skills in a safe and controlled environment where they can receive feedback and without patient consequences. Among all simulation activities, communication skills training provides healthcare workers the opportunity to practice communication techniques relevant to their specific field. Different types of simulation exist, whether involving the use of simulated or standardized human patients, virtual patients, manikins, or serious (educational) games [13]. A simulated patient is a person specially trained to interpret the story of a real patient or to systematically reproduce the clinical signs, personality, body language and emotional reactions defined in a scenario. They can be amateur or professional actors or expert patients whose role is to exchange verbal or non-verbal information with learners (i.e., healthcare professionals or students) to symptoms or receive care-related information [14]. In simulation, the patient may also be 'standardized'. In this case, their role is predefined, and they must adhere strictly to it to facilitate summative assessment of the learners [14]. In short, standardized patients must behave in a consistent and predictable manner, whereas simulated patients should act flexibly and authentically to meet the needs of learners [15]. Finally, virtual patient software is used to simulate realistic clinical scenarios. Students and healthcare professionals interact with the virtual patient to gather medical history, conduct examinations, diagnose, and make therapeutic decisions [16]. Despite the growing use of simulation-based training in pharmacy curricula and in the continuing medical education of pharmacists, little is known about the impact of simulation on the communication skills of pharmacists and pharmacy students in the area of clinical pharmacy. Previous research has focused mainly on physicians, nurses, and other healthcare professionals. Indeed, Granheim et al. demonstrated in their review that communication skills training in nursing schools aimed to increase collaboration, teamwork, learning in practice, understanding of roles, and communication, particularly between nurses and doctors, by combining interprofessional learning and simulation [17]. Another scoping review in medical schools primarily discussed high-fidelity approaches with standardized patients for interprofessional communication, focusing on attitude and perception changes rather than comprehensive assessment [18]. Blackmore et al., in their systematic review, emphasized that communication skills learned through simulation could have benefits beyond the simulation center, although they critiqued the study designs of many reviewed studies, often using before-and-after designs instead of study and control groups [19]. Methodological biases have also been reported in other studies conducted on communication training through simulation [20]. Therefore, it is essential to investigate the effectiveness of simulation-based training to identify successful practice models for enhancing communication skills in clinical pharmacies. Aim This systematic review examined the impact of simulation-based education on communication skills among pharmacy students and graduate pharmacists in performing clinical pharmacy activities. In particular, it aims to identify the types of simulations used, the outcomes measured in these studies, and the effectiveness of these simulations in enhancing communication skills. Method This review was undertaken by pharmacists of the hospital pharmacy network (HUGOPharm) of university hospitals in Western France (Angers, Brest, Nantes, Orléans, Rennes, and Tours). Protocol This systematic review was registered into the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO n°CRD42022371915) and was conducted in adherence with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines [21]. Search strategy The literature search was carried out in PubMed (Medline), Embase, Lissa and PsycInfo from inception to August 31, 2022. The search strategy was developed by the authors in consultation with two academic librarians. The following search strategy was used in PubMed (Medline): ((simulation training[MeSH Terms]) OR (active learning[Title/Abstract])) AND (pharmac*[Title/Abstract]). This search strategy was adapted to the syntax of the Embase, Lissa and PsycInfo databases. The search strategy is described in the supplementary material. Eligibility criteria and study selection Only original research was considered. To be eligible for inclusion, the studies had to meet the following criteria: (i) they targeted pharmacy students or graduate pharmacists; (ii) they employed simulation (human simulation, virtual simulation, and manikin) in the field of clinical pharmacy, defined as “any action taken by the pharmacist directly with the patient, their caregivers, or their medication”; and (iii) they provided a full description of outcome measures. Reviews were excluded. Studies involving multiple professions where it was not possible to extract data specific to pharmacy students or graduate pharmacists and studies using multiple pedagogical methods where the impact of simulation in clinical pharmacy was not specifically identified were also excluded. Three investigators (JFH, LFF, FN) independently evaluated each title and abstract. If all three studies were deemed eligible for inclusion, a full-text review was performed. Disputes were resolved through discussion. Second, six authors conducted a full-text screening of the previously selected articles to retain only those reporting communication outcomes and written in French or English. Rayyan and Zotero referencing software were used for sorting articles, managing duplicates, and screening. Data extraction The full texts of the included articles were analyzed by six authors (VMB, AL, MTS, EV, CF, and JFH). A standardized electronic data-charting form was created in Microsoft Excel® software to collect data from the included studies. The following data were collected: first author, publication year, country, setting, population targeted by the intervention (i.e., patient and/or family, healthcare professionals), study design and number of study participants, academic level, simulation type (i.e., simulated or standardized patient, virtual patient, manikin), intervention, study objectives, communication assessment method, and key results. Reviewing the bibliographies of the included articles led to the inclusion of additional articles that were not identified by the search strategy. Synthesis The outcomes related to communication were categorized into three distinct groups: perception of the importance of communication in delivering high-quality patient care, confidence in communication skills, and assessed communication skills. Quality assessment The quality and risk of bias of each included study were assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) [22]. Five authors evaluated all the articles (CF, FN, VM, LFF, PN). If there was any doubt about the evaluation of an article, two authors discussed the quality of the articles and a final decision was made by consensus (VM, LFF). Results Overall, 1727 articles were retrieved from the databases. After removing duplicates and excluding records that did not meet the selection criteria, 137 studies were assessed for full text, of which 18 were included. After screening the references, 20 articles were ultimately included for extraction (Fig. 1). PRISMA flow diagram Study characteristics A total of 20 studies, which are listed in Table 1 [23–42], were included in this systematic review. Among the included studies, 15 were conducted in the United States. Notably, more than two-thirds of the studies (70%) were published since 2015. The sample sizes varied across studies, ranging from 15 to 195 participants per study. The total number of participants was 3337. These participants were mainly pharmacy students at different stages of their curriculum, with the third year being the most represented (n = 6). One study was conducted among community pharmacists [30]. Table 1Characteristics of included studiesAuthorYearCountrySettingNumber of participantsaStudy designAcademic levelTargetbBarker et al. [23]2018AustraliaPharmacy school92/92Pre/post non-controlledFirst yearP/IBartlett et al. [24]2020USAMixed63/63Pre/post non-controlledFirst yearIBaumgartner et al. [25]2021USAPharmacy school101 (1-year simulation) and 195 (2 years simulation)/98Quasi experimentalFirst and second yearPBodein et al. [26]2022FrancePharmacy school185/18595Pre/post non-controlledObservationalSixth yearIBorja-Hart et al. [27]2019USAPharmacy school203/163Pre/post non-controlledFirst yearPBrennan et al. [28]2021USAMixed17/17Pre/post non-controlledFourth yearICowart et al. [29]2020USAPharmacy school83/54Pre/post non-controlledFirst yearP/IDolovich et al. [30]2007CanadaCommunity pharmacies33/31Randomized controlledN/APFernandez et al. [31]2007USAPharmacy school73ObservationalSecond yearP/IFusco et al. [32]2018USAMixed133/104Pre/post non-controlledThird yearIGillette et al. [33]2017USAPharmacy school76/144Quasi experimentalSecond yearPJin et al. [34]2019KoreaPharmacy school64/0Pre/post non-controlledFifth yearP/ILuiz et al. [35]2015USAPharmacy schooln = 63 + comparison between 2 classes: n = 92 (2015) vs n = 88 (2014)Pre/post non-controlled + comparison of evaluators' scores between class of 2015 and 2014Second yearN/AMonaghan et al. [36]1997USAPharmacy school40ObservationalThird yearP/IMotycka et al. [37]2018USAPublic university in a medical center15/15Pre/post non-controlledSecond and third yearIOrr et al. [38]2007USAPharmacy school81/81Pre/post non-controlledThird yearPOttis et al. [39]2016USAPharmacy school58/58Pre/post non-controlledFourth and fifth yearIShrader et al. [40]2011USPharmacy school72/64Pre/post non-controlledThird yearIStehlik et al. [41]2017AustraliaMixed60/61Pre/post non-controlledFinal yearIVyas et al. [42]2012USPharmacy school110/110Pre/post non-controlledThird yearP/IaIf Pre/post: number of students pre/number of students’ post; if Observational: number of students; if Quasi experimental or Randomized controlled: number of students in intervention arm/number of students in control armbP patient and/or family, I interprofessional Characteristics of included studies 185/185 95 Pre/post non-controlled Observational aIf Pre/post: number of students pre/number of students’ post; if Observational: number of students; if Quasi experimental or Randomized controlled: number of students in intervention arm/number of students in control arm bP patient and/or family, I interprofessional In terms of study design, 80% of the studies (16 out of 20) were quasi experimental studies. Two studies were observational, one study was both observational and quasi experimental, and one study employed a randomized controlled design. In the studies selected, simulation-based learning aimed to enhance communication skills and attitudes, either within an interprofessional context involving nursing and medical students (n = 8) or with patients and their families (n = 5). Seven studies focused on these two populations. Intervention characteristics and outcomes The simulation types, intervention characteristics, study objectives, and evaluated outcomes, such perception of the importance of communication in delivering high-quality patient care, confidence in communication skills, and communication skills, are presented in Table 2. The most common simulation method involved simulating patients alone (n = 5), while others combined simulated patients with standardized patients (n = 4), virtual patients (n = 2), or manikins (n = 1). Some studies used virtual patients either with standardized patients (n = 1) or alone (n = 3), while others focused exclusively on either manikins (n = 1) or standardized patients (n = 3). The majority of studies evaluated communication skills outcomes with patients and families (4 out of 5 studies that focused on these groups), while the perception of communication was most common examined in studies involving healthcare professionals (6 out of 8 studies targeting this population type). Confidence in communication skills was a predominant outcome in studies encompassing both populations (6 out of 7 studies concerned). Table 2Intervention characteristics and outcome categoriesOUTCOMESAuthorSimulation type *InterventionStudy ObjectivesPerception of communicationConfidence in communication skillsCommunication skillsTarget population: patient and/or family Baumgartner et al. [25]VPSeveral different simulation scenarios- study case- case presenting- debriefTo compare student performance on acute care advanced pharmacy practice experiences (APPEs) pre- and post-incorporation of mock acute care patient simulations (MACAS) into the curriculumX Borja-Hart et al. [27]VPOne simulation scenarioTo assess students' confidence and impressions in using their communication skills with a virtual patient and to evaluate their skills using this technologyX Dolovich et al. [30]SiPSimulation group: workshop with role playing with SiP + practice (two telephone calls)Control group: practice only (two telephone calls)To determine if an educational program designed for community pharmacists to help patients self-manage their asthma could improve pharmacists abilities to facilitate asthma treatment plansX Gillette et al. [33]StPSiPSimulation group: five different simulation scenarios with StP patientControl group: case studies, discussion, and role playingTo examine whether standardized patient encounters led to an improvement in a student pharmacist-patient communication assessment compared to traditional active-learning activities within a classroom settingX Orr et al. [38]VPStPEmail corresponding to a virtual patient (10 questions/semester)To develop, implement, and evaluate the use of virtual patients as a teaching tool for third-professional year PharmD students within an advanced elective self-care courseXTarget population: healthcare professionals (interprofessional communication) Bartlett et al. [24]VPOne simulation scenario (interaction with phone)To assess improvement in the knowledge, skills, and attitudes of students with respect to the medication use processX Bodein et al. [26]SiPFour different simulation scenarios (3 h)To assess the impact of a simulation session on the ability of pharmacy and medicine students in general practice to communicate in the resolution of patient-facing situationsX Brennan et al. [28]StPOne scenario simulation (10') + Debriefing with standardized team checklist (10')To teach interprofessional communication and teamwork skills to health professions students through a standardized patient simulation on acute patient stabilization and measure the impact on learners’ perceptions of interprofessional collaborationX Fusco et al. [32]MTwo different scenarios (50’)To evaluate the effects of interprofessional high-fidelity simulation-based learning (SBL) on third-year pharmacy and senior nursing students’ perceptions of interprofessional careXX Motycka et al. [37]VP/SiPTeamSTEPPS® training + Four simulations scenariosTo utilize simulated medication management scenarios in an interprofessional training environment, and to evaluate the impact of the training on team based skills and attitudesX Ottis et al. [39]StPSiPOne simulation scenarioTo emphasize patient safety in acute pain management, gauge change in attitudes about interprofessional learning, and have students understand more about the roles of different professionsX Shrader et al. [40]SiPTwo different simulation scenarios (75’)To implement a simulated interprofessional rounding experience using human patient simulators as a required activity for third-year pharmacy students in a clinical assessment courseXX Stehlik et al. [41]VP/SiPTwo different simulation scenariosTo evaluate change in student attitudes toward IPC, students’ perception of other health professionals and their role in patient care, and student’s perceived educational value of the tutorialsXTarget population: healthcare professionals and patient/family Barker et al. [23]StPSiPTwo different simulation scenarios per group—The ExcelL ProgramTo examine whether post-graduate students (MPharm) rated self-improvements in their generic communication competencies after participation in simulated learning modules (SLMs) and after placement and to explore the reflections of students and facilitators about their experience of SLMsX Cowart et al. [29]StPTraditional training + One scenario simulation + Pre-casedTo assess first-year Pharm.D. students' confidence in performing manual blood pressure techniques, drug information, and communication skills through a remote SBLX Fernandez et al. [31]M/SiPOne simulation scenario:- traditional training- practice using the manikinTo determine the effectiveness and acceptance of using a human patient simulation training module focused on interdisciplinary teamwork skillsX Jin et al. [34]SiPTraditional training + One scenario simulationTo evaluate the effects of communication skills training in pharmacy educationXX Luiz et al. [35]SiPSeveral role playing simulationTo evaluate the impact on pharmacy students of a communication course, which used role-playing to develop active-learning skillsX Monaghan et al. [36]StPThree different simulation scenario:1: role play observation2 and 3: role playTo assess student attitudes toward the use of simulation in the laboratoryX Vyas et al. [42]StPSiPFive different simulation scenariosTo assess the effectiveness of human patient simulation to teach patient safety, team-building skills, and the value of interprofessional collaboration to pharmacy studentsXM manikin, SiP simulated patient, StP standardized patient, VP virtual patient Intervention characteristics and outcome categories Several different simulation scenarios - study case - case presenting - debrief Simulation group: workshop with role playing with SiP + practice (two telephone calls) Control group: practice only (two telephone calls) StP SiP Simulation group: five different simulation scenarios with StP patient Control group: case studies, discussion, and role playing VP StP One scenario simulation (10') + Debriefing with standardized team checklist (10') TeamSTEPPS® training + Four simulations scenarios StP SiP StP SiP One simulation scenario: - traditional training - practice using the manikin Three different simulation scenario: 1: role play observation 2 and 3: role play StP SiP M manikin, SiP simulated patient, StP standardized patient, VP virtual patient Impact of simulation-based training on communication skills Assessed communication skills The methods used to assess communication skills and the main results are presented in Table 3 [25, 30, 33, 35, 38]. Communication skills were often assessed by self-assessment using questionnaires developed by the authors, either in their entirety (n = 10) or on the basis of existing questionnaires (n = 4). Six studies conducted their evaluation using published questionnaires that had not been modified by the investigating team. The questionnaires used were the Students' Perceptions of Interprofessional Clinical Education Revised (SPICE-R), TeamSTEPPS Teamwork Attitudes Questionnaire (T-TAQ), Interdisciplinary Education Perception Scale (IEPS) and Student Satisfaction and Self-Confidence in Learning (SSSCL). The Global Rating Scale (GRS) assessed by simulated patients and the National League for Nursing (NLN) Student Satisfaction and Confidence Scale were also mentioned. In addition, one study used a validated assessment tool created by the research team and published previously [25]. Finally, although outcomes were mainly assessed through self-assessments, some studies used assessments by instructors or assessors (n = 5) or by simulated patients (n = 1). Table 3Impact of simulation on communication training: methods and key resultsRESULTS(related to communication)AuthorCommunication assessment methodSignificant resultsNon-significant resultsTarget population: patient and/or family Baumgartner et al. [25]Standardized preceptor evaluations by validated assessment tool (created by the authors and previously published)Improved communication skills (p = 0.04) (communication skills components not detailed)Similar coefficients were observed for students who had benefited from one or two years of teaching with virtual patientsN/A Borja-Hart et al. [27]Self-assessment (Questionnaire designed by the authors)Improved confidence in communication skills (p < 0.001) including:Patient care process- ability to elicit relevant subjective health information- ability to document subjective and objective data using professional terminology- history takingSpecific communication behaviors and skills- ability to ask relevant follow-up questions to assess the cause and the severity of the patient's reason for visit- conduct an organized patient interviewN/A Dolovich et al. [30]Four-part structured outcome evaluation and Global Rating Scale (GRS) assessed by the simulated patientImproved communication skills for case 1 (p = 0.043) and case 3 (p = 0.01) including specific communication behaviors and skills:- empathy- coherence- verbal expression- non-verbal expressionOverall communication skills for case 2 (p = 0.16) including:- empathy- coherence- verbal expression- non-verbal expression Gillette et al. [33]Assessment form by instructor (Questionnaire based on the Indian Health Services method of medication counseling and assessing patient self-efficacy for correct medication use based upon social cognitive theory)Improved communication skills (p < 0.01)including:Patient care process- collect information on the medicines taken by patients- advising patients on medicationSpecific communication behaviors and skills- verified patient’s understanding- expresses interest in and concern for the patient- uses appropriate communication level for the patient- pace, tone, volume appropriate enough to communicate clearly- language and gestures were appropriate and polite- wears appropriate attire- shows positive attitude toward patientStudents who worked with a simulated patient achieved significantly higher results, on average, than students who received traditional classroom based active learning in the flipped classroom and role-playingA significantly higher percentage of students who were taught using simulated patient passed the first attempt compared to the othersN/A Orr et al. [38]Assessment form by the instructor and self-assessmentImproved communication skills (p < 0.001) including:Patient care process- skill to gather necessary information- skills to read and interpret medical literature- skills to educate patient on proper way to administer medications- skill to find answer about OTC: herbal drugsSpecific communication behaviors and skills- questioning, listening, non-verbal communication skills-skills to assist language and cultural barriersN/ATarget population: healthcare professionals (interprofessional communication) Bartlett et al. [24]Self-assessmentNLN Student Satisfaction and Self-Confidence in Learning + 5 questions from a tool developed and reviewed by College of Pharmacy expertsConfidence in communication skills (observational results)- Rate your confidence in your ability to meet the requirements of your role in this simulation: 12/15- Rate your confidence in your ability to accurately perform this activity in the clinical practice setting:17/20Rate your overall communication skills: 12/12 change in post survey from no confidence to confidenceRate your confidence in communications skills: 10/10 change in post survey from no confidence to confidenceRate your confidence with receiving a professional voicemail: 16/19 change in post survey from no confidence to confidence Bodein et al. [26]Self-assessment(Questionnaire designed by the authors from previous qualitative study)Improved perception of communication (p ≤ 0.03) including:- increase in the proportion of students rating doctor/pharmacist communication as effective, necessary, collaborative, trusting and improvable and decrease when described as difficult, brief and stressfulN/A Brennan et al. [28]Self-assessmentStudent Perceptions of Interprofessional Clinical Education-Revised Instrument (SPICE-R2)Improved perception of communication in teamwork between pre-post1 (p = 0.02) and pre-post 2 (p = 0.005) including:- working with students from different disciplines enhances my education- participating in educational experiences with students from different disciplines enhances my ability to work on an interprofessional team- health professional students from different disciplines should be educated to establish collaborative relationships with one another- during their education, health professional students should be involved in teamwork with students from different disciplines in order to understand their respective rolesPerception of communication in teamwork between post1—post2 (p = 0.35) Fusco et al. [32]Self-assessmentSPICE-R (Student Perceptions of Interprofessional Clinical Education-Revised)SSSCL (Student Satisfaction and Self-Confidence in Learning)Improved perception of communication about team structure (p < 0.05) including:- perception of communication in teamwork- working with students from different disciplines enhances my education- participating in educational experiences with students from different disciplines enhances my ability to work on an interprofessional team- health professional students from different disciplines should be educated to establish collaborative relationships with one another- during their education, health professional students should be involved in teamwork with students from different disciplines in order to understand their respective rolesN/A Motycka et al. [37]Online Teamwork Attitudes Questionnaire (TTAQ)Improved perception of communication (p = 0.003) including:- teams that do not communicate effectively significantly increase their risk of committing errors- poor communication is the most common cause of reported errors- adverse events may be reduced by maintaining an information exchange with patients and their families- I prefer to work with team members who ask questions about information I provide- it is important to have a standardized method for sharing information when handing off patients- it is nearly impossible to train individuals how to be better communicatorsAbout team structure (interprofesionnal and patient) including:- it is important to ask patients and their families for feedback regarding patient care- patients are a critical component of the care team- this facility's administration influences the success of direct care teams- a team's mission is of greater value than the goals of individual team members- effective team members can anticipate the needs of other team members- high performing teams in health care share common characteristics with high performing teams in other industries Ottis et al. [39]Self-assessmentQuestionnaire adapted from the Readiness for Interprofessional Learning Survey and the Evaluation of Teamwork Knowledge, Attitudes and Skills for Health Sciences StudentsImproved confidence in communication skills (p < 0.05) including: - I can easily communicate therapeutic recommendations with other members of the healthcare team- I feel I am very good at integrating information into a planN/A Shrader et al. [40]Self-assessmentSurvey instrument (Questionnaire designed by the authors)Improved perception of communication (p ≤ 0.001) including: - shared learning will help me communicate better with other healthcare professionals after graduationImproved confidence in communication skills (p ≤ 0.001) including: - I am confident in recognizing and managing medicationN/A Stehlik et al. [41]Self-assessmentInterdisciplinary Education Perception Scale (IEPS)Improved perception of communication (p < 0.001) including: - individuals in my profession need to cooperate with other professions- individuals in my profession are willing to share information and resources with other professionals- individuals in my profession have good relations with people in other professions- individuals in my profession work well with each other- no difference regardless of gender and profession (p = 0.082 and p = 0.923, respectively)Target populations: healthcare professionals and patient/family Barker et al. [23]Self-assessmentEXCELL Competency Scale (ECS)(Questionnaire designed by the authors)Improved confidence in communication skills between T1 (before simulation) and T3 (after 1 simulation formation) (p = 0.14) and between T1 and T4 (after 2 simulation formation) (p < 0.001), including: seeking help, making social contact, participating in a group, expressing disagreement, refusing a request, giving feedback, receiving feedback- no change of perceived communication competencies between T3 and T4 (p = 0.12) Cowart et al. [29]Self-assessment(Questionnaire designed by the authors)Improved confidence in communication skills including:- ability to communicate a recommendation using the “SBAR” format (p < 0.01)N/A Fernandez et al. [31]Self-assessment(Questionnaire designed by the authors)Not concerned (observational study) Jin et al. [34]Self-assessmentSurvey instrument based on Calgary-Cambridge Observation Guide modified by the Centre for Pharmacy Postgraduate Education (CPPE) of the National Health System (NHS)Improved perception of communication (p < 0.001) including:- developing my communication skills is just as important as developing my knowledge of pharmacy- in order to be a good pharmacist, I must have good communication skills- learning communication skills has helped or will help me respect patients- learning communication skills has improved my ability to communicate with patients- developing my communication skills is just as important as developing my knowledge of pharmacy- I can’t see the point of learning communication skills- learning communication skills has helped or will help me respect my colleagues- I don’t need good communication skills to be a pharmacist Luiz et al. [35]Assessment by evaluator(using a rubric designed by the authors and inspired by Bruce Berger’s Communication Skills for Pharmacists)Improved communication skills (p unspecified) including:Specific communication behaviors and skills- professionalism and empathy- provide accurate and complete information to patients about their medication- be comfortable while speaking with patients- interact with patientsSpecific communication behaviors and skills- demonstrate the ability to evaluate and modify interpersonal behaviors for effective social interactions- define empathetic responding- define compassion (in a health care context)- define effective listening skillsN/ASelf-assessment via SurveyMonkey(Questionnaire designed by the authors)Improved communication skills (p unspecified) including:Patient care process- patient counseling skills- demonstrate speaking and writing communication skills appropriate to the practice of pharmacy in various audiences and settings- implement a pharmaceutical plan careSpecific communication behaviors and skills- demonstrate the ability to evaluate and modify interpersonal behaviors for effective social interactions- define empathetic responding- define compassion (in a health care context)- define effective listening skillsN/A Monaghan et al. [36]Self-assessment(Questionnaire designed by the authors)Not concerned (observational study)N/A Vyas et al. [42]Knowledge, skills, and attitudes survey administered by faculty members and self-assessment by a team building and interprofessional communications survey toolImproved confidence in communication skills (p ≤ 0,07) including:- I feel confident working with a team, mapping out the flow of care processes- I feel confident supporting and advising a peer who must decide how to respond to an error- I feel confident disclosing an error to the patient’s physician- I feel confident disclosing an error to an instructor- I feel confident reporting patient safety concerns into a reporting system Impact of simulation on communication training: methods and key results Improved communication skills (p = 0.04) (communication skills components not detailed) Similar coefficients were observed for students who had benefited from one or two years of teaching with virtual patients Improved confidence in communication skills (p < 0.001) including: Patient care process - ability to elicit relevant subjective health information - ability to document subjective and objective data using professional terminology - history taking Specific communication behaviors and skills - ability to ask relevant follow-up questions to assess the cause and the severity of the patient's reason for visit - conduct an organized patient interview Improved communication skills for case 1 (p = 0.043) and case 3 (p = 0.01) including specific communication behaviors and skills: - empathy - coherence - verbal expression - non-verbal expression Overall communication skills for case 2 (p = 0.16) including: - empathy - coherence - verbal expression - non-verbal expression Improved communication skills (p < 0.01)including: Patient care process - collect information on the medicines taken by patients - advising patients on medication Specific communication behaviors and skills - verified patient’s understanding - expresses interest in and concern for the patient - uses appropriate communication level for the patient - pace, tone, volume appropriate enough to communicate clearly - language and gestures were appropriate and polite - wears appropriate attire - shows positive attitude toward patient Students who worked with a simulated patient achieved significantly higher results, on average, than students who received traditional classroom based active learning in the flipped classroom and role-playing A significantly higher percentage of students who were taught using simulated patient passed the first attempt compared to the others Improved communication skills (p < 0.001) including: Patient care process - skill to gather necessary information - skills to read and interpret medical literature - skills to educate patient on proper way to administer medications - skill to find answer about OTC: herbal drugs Specific communication behaviors and skills - questioning, listening, non-verbal communication skills -skills to assist language and cultural barriers Self-assessment NLN Student Satisfaction and Self-Confidence in Learning + 5 questions from a tool developed and reviewed by College of Pharmacy experts Confidence in communication skills (observational results) - Rate your confidence in your ability to meet the requirements of your role in this simulation: 12/15 - Rate your confidence in your ability to accurately perform this activity in the clinical practice setting:17/20 Rate your overall communication skills: 12/12 change in post survey from no confidence to confidence Rate your confidence in communications skills: 10/10 change in post survey from no confidence to confidence Rate your confidence with receiving a professional voicemail: 16/19 change in post survey from no confidence to confidence Self-assessment (Questionnaire designed by the authors from previous qualitative study) Improved perception of communication (p ≤ 0.03) including: - increase in the proportion of students rating doctor/pharmacist communication as effective, necessary, collaborative, trusting and improvable and decrease when described as difficult, brief and stressful Self-assessment Student Perceptions of Interprofessional Clinical Education-Revised Instrument (SPICE-R2) Improved perception of communication in teamwork between pre-post1 (p = 0.02) and pre-post 2 (p = 0.005) including: - working with students from different disciplines enhances my education - participating in educational experiences with students from different disciplines enhances my ability to work on an interprofessional team - health professional students from different disciplines should be educated to establish collaborative relationships with one another - during their education, health professional students should be involved in teamwork with students from different disciplines in order to understand their respective roles Self-assessment SPICE-R (Student Perceptions of Interprofessional Clinical Education-Revised) SSSCL (Student Satisfaction and Self-Confidence in Learning) Improved perception of communication about team structure (p < 0.05) including: - perception of communication in teamwork - working with students from different disciplines enhances my education - participating in educational experiences with students from different disciplines enhances my ability to work on an interprofessional team - health professional students from different disciplines should be educated to establish collaborative relationships with one another - during their education, health professional students should be involved in teamwork with students from different disciplines in order to understand their respective roles Improved perception of communication (p = 0.003) including: - teams that do not communicate effectively significantly increase their risk of committing errors - poor communication is the most common cause of reported errors - adverse events may be reduced by maintaining an information exchange with patients and their families - I prefer to work with team members who ask questions about information I provide - it is important to have a standardized method for sharing information when handing off patients - it is nearly impossible to train individuals how to be better communicators About team structure (interprofesionnal and patient) including: - it is important to ask patients and their families for feedback regarding patient care - patients are a critical component of the care team - this facility's administration influences the success of direct care teams - a team's mission is of greater value than the goals of individual team members - effective team members can anticipate the needs of other team members - high performing teams in health care share common characteristics with high performing teams in other industries Self-assessment Questionnaire adapted from the Readiness for Interprofessional Learning Survey and the Evaluation of Teamwork Knowledge, Attitudes and Skills for Health Sciences Students Improved confidence in communication skills (p < 0.05) including: - I can easily communicate therapeutic recommendations with other members of the healthcare team - I feel I am very good at integrating information into a plan Self-assessment Survey instrument (Questionnaire designed by the authors) Improved perception of communication (p ≤ 0.001) including: - shared learning will help me communicate better with other healthcare professionals after graduation Improved confidence in communication skills (p ≤ 0.001) including: - I am confident in recognizing and managing medication Self-assessment Interdisciplinary Education Perception Scale (IEPS) Improved perception of communication (p < 0.001) including: - individuals in my profession need to cooperate with other professions - individuals in my profession are willing to share information and resources with other professionals - individuals in my profession have good relations with people in other professions - individuals in my profession work well with each other Self-assessment EXCELL Competency Scale (ECS) (Questionnaire designed by the authors) Self-assessment (Questionnaire designed by the authors) Improved confidence in communication skills including: - ability to communicate a recommendation using the “SBAR” format (p < 0.01) Self-assessment (Questionnaire designed by the authors) Self-assessment Survey instrument based on Calgary-Cambridge Observation Guide modified by the Centre for Pharmacy Postgraduate Education (CPPE) of the National Health System (NHS) Improved perception of communication (p < 0.001) including: - developing my communication skills is just as important as developing my knowledge of pharmacy - in order to be a good pharmacist, I must have good communication skills - learning communication skills has helped or will help me respect patients - learning communication skills has improved my ability to communicate with patients - developing my communication skills is just as important as developing my knowledge of pharmacy - I can’t see the point of learning communication skills - learning communication skills has helped or will help me respect my colleagues - I don’t need good communication skills to be a pharmacist Assessment by evaluator (using a rubric designed by the authors and inspired by Bruce Berger’s Communication Skills for Pharmacists) Improved communication skills (p unspecified) including: Specific communication behaviors and skills - professionalism and empathy - provide accurate and complete information to patients about their medication - be comfortable while speaking with patients - interact with patients Specific communication behaviors and skills - demonstrate the ability to evaluate and modify interpersonal behaviors for effective social interactions - define empathetic responding - define compassion (in a health care context) - define effective listening skills N/A Self-assessment via SurveyMonkey (Questionnaire designed by the authors) Improved communication skills (p unspecified) including: Patient care process - patient counseling skills - demonstrate speaking and writing communication skills appropriate to the practice of pharmacy in various audiences and settings - implement a pharmaceutical plan care Specific communication behaviors and skills - demonstrate the ability to evaluate and modify interpersonal behaviors for effective social interactions - define empathetic responding - define compassion (in a health care context) - define effective listening skills Self-assessment (Questionnaire designed by the authors) Improved confidence in communication skills (p ≤ 0,07) including: - I feel confident working with a team, mapping out the flow of care processes - I feel confident supporting and advising a peer who must decide how to respond to an error - I feel confident disclosing an error to the patient’s physician - I feel confident disclosing an error to an instructor All articles provided results on changes in communication skills. The various aspects evaluated have been classified in Table 3 into two categories: ‘Patient care processes’ and ‘Specific communication behaviors and skills’. These two categories were combined in the evaluation of the effect of the intervention reported by the authors. Three studies used only one type of simulation [25, 30, 35]. The combination of standardized patients and simulated patients or standardized and virtual patients was used in the two other studies [33, 38]. These studies showed significant improvements in communication skills and referred to verbal communication skills. Two articles also referred to non-verbal communication skills [30, 38]. Different types of non-verbal communication, including body language and gestures, were studied. Assessed perception of the importance of communication Seven articles provided results on changes in the perception of the importance of communication in delivering high-quality patient care [26, 28, 32, 34, 37, 40, 41] (Table 3). These seven articles used self-assessment questionnaires, and four used validated scores (NLN, T-TAQ, SPICE-R, SPICE-R2, IEPS). The results, based on a comparison of questionnaire responses before and after the intervention, indicated an increase in interest in interprofessional and patient communication after simulation-based training with simulated patients, standardized patients, virtual patients, or manikins. Non-significant results were obtained for questions that indicated an interest in communication before the intervention, such as 'It is important to ask patients and their families for feedback regarding patient care’. The SPICE-R and SPICE-R2 questionnaires included items on organizing sessions with students from different disciplines. The results confirmed the positive impact of these interprofessional sessions on identifying roles and facilitating subsequent communication. The study by Brennan et al. showed a significant improvement in the perception of the importance of communication in students who had received simulation training compared with those who had not [28]. However, there was no additional benefit to carrying out a second training session compared to carrying out only one training session. Assessed of confidence in communication skills Seven studies assessed confidence in communication skills [23, 24, 27, 29, 39, 40, 42] (Table 3). One study used validated scores (NLN score) [30]. A single virtual patient was used for the simulation method. Three studies used a combination of standardized patients and simulated patients. Two studies used only the standardized patient technique. All seven studies demonstrated a significant increase in confidence in communication skills. Students were more confident in their ability to communicate with patients and other healthcare professionals, allowing them to easily exchange information, formulate treatment recommendations, and disclose errors. Among the included articles, three were observational studies that examined the satisfaction levels of pharmacy students who had participated in simulation-based training [26, 31, 36]. A study by Bodein et al. reported favorable feedback regarding simulation in the context of acquiring communication skills particularly in the context of interprofessional interactions [26]. They highlighted the difficulties of engaging with other healthcare professionals, but felt that simulation was beneficial. Fernandez et al.’s s demonstrated that students felt more comfortable interacting with patients after simulation sessions [31]. In contrast, the study by Monaghan et al. revealed that students were reluctant to use simulation to develop their communication skills, as it did not boost their self-confidence and left them feeling ill-prepared to counsel patients [36]. Finally, on the basis of qualitative responses to questions included in questionnaires from the studies reviewed [29, 39], students expressed a strong appreciation for the role-play aspects of these simulations, emphasizing that these encounters enriched their understanding of effective communication and interactions with patients. They particularly appreciated the feedback provided by the actors, believing that it enabled them to hone their communication skills. Importantly, qualitative data revealed that students felt that they had acquired a critical skill through simulation-based training: the ability to actively listen to and empathize with the concerns of others. Study quality The results of the MMAT quality assessment are detailed in the supplementary file. The overall score obtained was 40% for non-randomized quantitative studies and 52% for descriptive quantitative studies. The randomized study included in the review obtained an overall score of 40. Discussion Summary of evidence This review synthesizes the results of 20 studies using a variety of study designs, such as observational studies, pre/post (non)controlled studies, and randomized controlled trials. Only one study focused on graduate pharmacists, while the student participants varied across different academic levels and workshop sizes. It should be noted that in some studies, the number of participants after the intervention was lower than that before the intervention. This could introduce bias due to missing data. No specific type of simulation predominated among the studies dealing with communication with patients, families, and/or interprofessional teams. The outcomes focused on learners' perceptions of communication, their confidence in communicating effectively, and their actual communication skills. Overall, the analysis consistently demonstrated a significant improvement in communication through simulation-based training across multiple stages of the patient care process, including patient assessment and history-taking, care plan development, monitoring and follow-up with patients and healthcare professionals, and documentation. Additionally, specific communication behaviors and skills, such as demonstrating empathy, active listening, non-verbal communication, verifying understanding, or even delivering clear instructions, adapting communication style to patient needs, and providing constructive feedback, showed marked enhancement. Interpretation The results of this systematic review suggest that simulation-based training has a positive impact on pharmacy students’ and pharmacists’ communication skills. However, evaluation methods often rely on self-developed questionnaires rather than validated questionnaires, raising questions about the accuracy and objectivity of the confidence ratings obtained. This methodological variability highlights the lack of standardized guidelines for simulation-based training and the assessment of communication skills in pharmacy education. A study by Huon et al. on the influence of simulation on the confidence of clinical pharmacy students also highlighted these methodological limitations [43]. Communication plays an essential role in the pharmacist profession, which interfaces with many other medical professions in patient care [44]. As demonstrated in this review, simulation workshops can be organized at each stage of the patient care process [45, 46], particularly to improve the acquisition of communication skills. First, there is information gathering. Simulation-based learning teaches students how to effectively gather information from patients, their families, and/or health professionals. Second, simulation reinforces students' knowledge and improves their ability to recognize errors. It also increases learners' confidence in sharing information about identified errors with nurses and doctors [24, 39]. Next, a care plan should be developed in collaboration with other healthcare professionals and the patient or caregiver. Learning to work as part of a team through simulation helps students understand each other's roles, gain confidence to interact effectively, and discuss treatment recommendations [28, 41]. Finally, simulation improves students' ability to implement and monitor care plans [30]. It has also improved their ability to inform patients or caregivers about medication details (efficacy, dosage, adverse effects, etc.) during pharmaceutical interviews [27, 33, 38]. Simulation training provides a controlled environment conducive to exchanges between professionals. This environment enables students to feel confident while they are exposed to potentially stressful practical situations, as explored in the systematic review of Ung et al. on simulation in mental health [47]. This enables them to develop communication strategies to deal with them in their real-life practice, through both verbal and non-verbal communication. This is an opportunity, as it can be adapted to a multitude of scenarios, such as managing frustrated patients, communicating difficult information or transmitting complex medical information. There is a lack of clear guidelines for simulation courses in the pharmacy curriculum. Qualitative data revealed mixed results, with some students reporting limited improvement or even negative impacts on clinical abilities post-simulation, influenced by previous interprofessional team experiences and initial confidence in teamwork skills [39]. Advanced pharmacy students may find it difficult to change their attitudes and perceptions because of the ingrained habits they have developed as part of their more or less regular pharmacy practice. Consequently, improving their communication skills can be particularly challenging. They may need other methods (besides simulation-based learning) to enhance their communication skills. The early integration of simulations could effectively improve pharmacy students' communication skills. Strengths and weaknesses This review followed best practices, including protocol registration, rigorous research methodology, and meticulous data sorting, extraction, and analysis. However, several limitations affect the interpretability of the results. The variability of simulation techniques between studies introduces significant heterogeneity, limiting comparability and generalizability. Reviews on simulation-based training for medical students show predominantly positive impacts on patient communication and interprofessional skills, but they also highlight the difficulties in comparing studies due to the diversity of methodologies and the non-standardisation of data collection [18, 48]. In addition, some studies reporting improved communication skills assessed both stages of the patient care process and specific communication behaviors and skills. The patient care process is seen as an essential framework of clinical pharmacy practice, and its success is underpinned by effective communication skills (based on communication behaviours). Hence, these two elements should therefore have been considered and evaluated separately. Finally, new studies, including a standardized assessment design with the aim of measuring students' knowledge and communication skills rather than their perceptions [23], would make it possible to supplement the research data and propose simulation workshops adapted to contexts or levels of study. Future research To improve simulation-based pharmaceutical training, the development of clear guidelines and standardized assessment tools to evaluate communication would significantly improve the validity and reliability of future research efforts. Furthermore, they should aim to investigate the long-term impact of simulation-based training beyond the simulation center. Finally, a cost-effectiveness analysis of the use of simulation versus traditional classroom activities in pharmacy education could complement the research data. Conclusion In conclusion, the use of robust methodologies with standardized guidelines and validated assessment tools would allow the impact of simulation on communication skills to be better measured. Despite study variations, this systematic review consistently demonstrated that simulation-based training significantly improves pharmacy students and pharmacists’ perceptions, confidence, and enhances their communication skills. Educators are encouraged to integrate simulation into curricula to enhance students’ learning experiences. Supplementary Information Supplementary Material 1. Supplementary Material 2. Supplementary Material 3. Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank two librarians, Julie Brugneaux and Aurore Guillon, from the Orléans Hospital for their valuable assistance. Authors’ contributions J.F.H, L.F.F, and F.N conceived the article. P.N., S.T., J.F.H,L.F.F, and F.N. performed the literature search and data analysis. V.M.B, A.L., M.T.S., E.V., C.F. and J.F.H drafted the article. P.N., S.T., L.F.F., and F.N. critically revised the work. Funding The authors declare that no funds, grants, or other support was received during the preparation of this manuscript. Data availability The datasets analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate Not applicable. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Laura Foucault-Fruchard and Vanessa Michelet-Barbotin contributed equally to this work. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Supplementary Material 1. Supplementary Material 2. Supplementary Material 3. Data Availability Statement The datasets analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.