“Shrink back is not my intention”: a qualitative exploration of Chinese security guards’ experiences with bystander CPR Authors: Mingzhu Yang, Junyang Song, Yuanyuan Jin, Youqing Peng Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractBackgroundOut-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) is a major public health burden worldwide. Promoting bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation (B-CPR) is a key element in improving the survival rate of OHCA. The security guard is a specific population in China that plays a significant role as bystanders in public settings. However, less is known about their experiences regarding B-CPR intention and performance. This study aimed to explore the experiences and perspectives of Chinese security guards regarding B-CPR and identify barriers to its performance.MethodsFifteen in-depth interviews were conducted with security guards in various public settings, including hospitals, residential living areas, office buildings, and public transportation stations. All interviews were audio recorded. Two researchers independently analyzed the transcripts through deductive and inductive content analysis. Informed by the “Intention-focused” model of B-CPR performance, deductive content analysis was initially performed to identify categories that align with the theoretical framework and thereby validate the theory. Subsequently, inductive content analysis was applied to code newly discovered content, therefore enriching the theory.ResultsAn “intention & performance-focused” model of B-CPR was developed. It was revealed that security personnel were more inclined to perform CPR without hesitation when the victim was a trusted individual. However, when faced with unfamiliar individuals, they tended to shrink back due to various barriers. Specifically, four layers of barriers to CPR performance were identified, encompassing security personnel factors, victim-related factors, organizational factors, and societal factors. Participants also shared their perspectives on the desired CPR training, including trainers, training contents, training formats, and training incentives.ConclusionSecurity guards should receive comprehensive CPR training to maximize their occupational value. In addition to strengthening CPR-related training, which includes theoretical knowledge and hands-on practice, psychological coping skills for managing overwhelming emotions and understanding relevant laws are also essential training elements that cannot be overlooked. When developing relevant intervention strategies, policies, and regulations, it’s critical to consider the country’s context and the cooperation of the organization where the security guard is employed. The model developed in this study can provide a reference for designing interventions and policy to improve the B-CPR intention and performance for other specific groups.Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12889-024-20888-w.Keywords: Cardiopulmonary resuscitation, Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest, Qualitative research, Security guards Introduction Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) is a major public health burden worldwide. It requires immediate intervention to minimize the risk of mortality and morbidity [1, 2]. It refers to the cessation of functional cardiac mechanical activity, coupled with the absence of systemic circulation, occurring outside a hospital setting [3]. OHCA is time-critical, linked to substantial morbidity and mortality, and characterized by a high incidence but a low survival rate. According to the International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation (ILCOR) report, the emergency medical service (EMS) treated OHCA rate was 47.9 and 62.2 per 100,000 person-years in Norway and the United States [4], while in China, the number is 95.7 [5]. The survival rates at hospital discharge or 30 days in Norway and the United States are 15.7% and 12%, respectively, while it is concerning that the survival rate in China is only 1.2% [4, 5]. In cases of OHCA, the application of cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) is considered a potentially life-saving intervention, which is pivotal to the survival rate. Layperson bystanders assume a crucial role in the initiation of CPR. CPR training for the lay public in China is offered by organizations like the Red Cross, EMS centers, hospitals, community health centers, medical schools, and commercial training institutions such as the American Heart Association (AHA), varying in duration. These programs follow Chinese Expert Consensus [6–8], which were adapted from international standards, primarily the AHA and ILCOR guidelines, while taking into account China’s specific context. Most people are willing to perform bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation (B-CPR) for someone experiencing cardiac arrest [9]. However, a multicenter, population-based study on OHCA in China revealed a significantly low level of B-CPR at only 20.3% [5], which is at the limit level of the worldwide range (19.1−79.0%) [4]. A better understanding of the underlying causes of low B-CPR performance rates can provide valuable insights into potential solutions that could help improve not only the B-CPR performance rate but also the survival rates and long-term outcomes for OHCA patients in China. According to the “Intention-focused” model of B-CPR performance [10], whether bystanders initiate B-CPR depends on various factors, including personal factors such as demographic characteristics, factors influencing intention, and factors affecting CPR performance, such as skills and environmental constraints, after forming the intention. The action can be ignited by enhancing intention through changing beliefs (i.e., attitude, perceived norms, and self-efficacy), enhancing skills, and attenuating environmental constraints [10]. Currently, many studies focus on enhancing the intention of CPR by improving the three factors of the Theory of Planned Behavior (i.e., attitude, perceived social norms, and perceived behavioral control/self-efficacy) [11–13]. However, few studies address the barriers that prevent the actual CPR performance, even when the intention is present. According to the novel concept of ‘Chainmail of Survival’, multiple joined links can strengthen the whole mission of resuscitative endeavors [14]. Thus, understanding the factors behind low CPR performance—one of the critical links following intention—is crucial for improving overall CPR outcomes. Additionally, increasing evidence shows a significant decrease in CPR intentions over time [13]. Therefore, it’s crucial to focus on both maintaining intention and promoting performance to enhance CPR success. Additionally, previous research mostly focused on the general public and did not distinguish the special social characteristics of the bystanders. Maximizing the role of bystanders in the chain of survival is a goal that countries around the world strive to achieve, and this is especially important in China, where “chivalrous conduct” is a traditional virtue [15]. Chivalrous conduct emphasizes righteousness, bravery, and moral integrity. It is deeply rooted in Chinese historical philosophies and folklore, and its relevance endures in contemporary society, reflecting an evolving understanding of social responsibility. While OHCA incidents occur more frequently in homes (73.4%) than in public settings (16.3%) [16], it’s notable that a higher survival rate is observed in public areas (36.5%) compared to 22.9% in homes [17]. Therefore, it is imperative not to overlook the significant role of bystanders in public settings. In China, the security guard is a special group that is prevalent and crucial in society. It plays pivotal roles in critical scenarios within various settings, including hospitals, public transportation stations, shopping malls, and residential communities. Due to their professional requirements, security guards need to be on duty around the clock in public places, becoming the main witnesses of OHCA. Furthermore, security guards played an essential role in maintaining public health and societal safety, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic, for example, fever screening and monitoring public health [18]. These emphasize the importance of studying the training and performance of B-CPR for security personnel, which is essential to improve the performance rate of B-CPR and then improve the survival rate of OHCA. This study sought to explore the perspectives of security guards regarding B-CPR. It endeavors to delve into their sentiments and experiences, particularly those who have undergone CPR training and have encountered instances of collapses. Furthermore, the study aims to comprehensively explore the barriers that influence the intention and effective performance of B-CPR. The findings of this study can serve as a theoretical basis for developing intervention strategies to train and encourage the performance of B-CPR among security guards. Additionally, they can provide valuable insights for the training of other specific groups and the formulation of related policies. Methods Data collection Individual in-depth interviews were conducted in person from June to August 2022. The researchers had no prior established relationships with the participants. Participants were encouraged to express their experiences and thoughts freely. The entire process was audio-recorded with agreement. The interview guide focused on personal perceptions of the occupation, personal beliefs bout B-CPR, and barriers to performing B-CPR, which was informed by the theoretical framework—the “Intention-focused” model of B-CPR performance [10]. Preliminary interviews with two qualified security guards were conducted to test the clarity of the questions, and issues identified during this process led to modifications in the interview guide. For example, initially, we asked the security guards if they had ever encountered someone collapsing, and some described situations where they dealt with people fainting due to low blood sugar. To more accurately gather experiences related to CPR, we revised the question to: “Have you ever encountered a situation where CPR was needed? If so, could you share your experience with us?” Details of the refined interview guide are provided in Table 1. Table 1Interview guide1. Characteristics of bystander (personal perception of the occupation as security guard)1.1. Could you provide a brief overview of your professional background and your experience working as a security guard?1.2. How do you think about the significance of your role as a security guard?2. Beliefs regarding CPR (i.e. attitudes, perceived norms, self-efficacy)2.1. What do you think about acquiring CPR skills, and how might it impact or enhance your performance in your role?2.2. Have you ever encountered a situation where CPR was needed? If so, could you share your experience with us?2.3. How confident are you in your ability to apply CPR in real-life emergency situations?3. CPR training and performance3.1. Have you received any CPR training? If so, how often are the training sessions held?3.2. In what circumstances do you believe performing CPR would be necessary? Conversely, what factors might lead you to decide against performing CPR?3.3. Is there any additional information or thoughts you would like to share with us? Interview guide Sampling A purposive sampling method was employed across various settings in Shanghai, including hospitals, residential living areas, office buildings, and public transportation stations. According to the theoretical framework and literature review, we presupposed inviting 10 participants to reach code saturation, which means that the code has been repeated in several interviews, and no new code appears or any other change is needed [19]. It was expected that three more participants would be invited to arrive at the stopping criterion that no more new information was needed, achieving the final meaning saturation [19, 20]. Inclusion criteria: ① Age range of ≥ 18 years old and ≤ 65 years old; ② Completion of CPR training; ③ Previous experience of encountering someone who collapsed, requiring the performance of CPR; and ④ Voluntary enrolment with informed consent obtained. Individuals with auditory impairments or any other impediments to oral communication were excluded. Data analysis NVivo 12.0 software was employed to organize data and facilitate the data analysis, with the following specific steps: Audio recordings were transcribed verbatim within a 48-hour timeframe post-interview. Two approaches to content analysis were used [21]. Deductive content analysis was initially performed to identify categories that align with the “intention-focused” model of B-CPR performance theoretical framework and thereby validate the theory. Subsequently, inductive content analysis was applied to code newly discovered content, therefore enriching the theory [21, 22]. The research group comprised two master’s degree holders in nursing and education (one of whom has over 30 years of clinical experience in the field of CPR) and one PhD in nursing with extensive expertise in qualitative research. During the data analysis process, the researchers engaged in deep reflection, integrating personal experiences, existing literature, and the cultural context of China to gain a more profound understanding of the collected data. To enhance rigor and trustworthiness, two researchers independently coded the data and regularly reported the results to the research group. This approach was used to mitigate the potential influence of researchers’ personal presumptions on the analysis process and to enhance the credibility of the results. The Standards for Reporting Qualitative Research (SRQR) checklist [23] was adhered to report this study (see Additional file 1). Results Characteristics of interviewees The recruitment was stopped after 15 interviews because no new information was identified. After conducting nine interviews, no new code emerged, indicating code saturation. Subsequent interviews were conducted to gain a diverse and deeper understanding of the codes’ meanings. Figure 1 shows the process of code development. In the figure, the x-axis represents the interview number, while the y-axis indicates the developed codes. This illustration emphasizes the distinction between achieving code saturation and meaning saturation [24], thereby enhancing the transparency and verifiability of our analyses. Process of code development. Note: The position of “code developed” indicates the first interview of the code appearing, while the position of “code meaning saturated” indicates that there is a complete and rich understanding of the corresponding code after this interview. Code saturation was achieved after nine interviews in this study The interview lasted approximately 40–55 min. Thirteen interviewees were males, and two were females. The ages ranged from 21 to 59 years old, and the mean age was 44 years (SD = 11.17). The average length of job experience was 7.87 years (SD = 5.54). Eight (53.33%) people had an education level of high school degree or above. Additionally, four (26.67%) people held senior or intermediate official titles in their respective positions. Most people had received only one CPR training (86.67%). As of the conclusion of the interviews, 80% of the participants had gone without CPR training for three years or more. For detailed information, see Table 2. Table 2Characteristics of participantsNo.SexAgeJob experience (years)EducationallevelOfficial titleDutiesWorkplaceCPR training frequency (times)Last training time(years ago)1male4813junior high schooljuniorsecurity officerhospitalonce32male3613polytechnic schoolseniorteam leaderhospitalthree times33male5910high schoolintermediateteam leaderhospitalonce34male385junior high schoolintermediateteam leaderoffice buildingstwice15male263polytechnic schooljuniorsecurity officeroffice buildingsonce36male466junior high schooljuniorsecurity officeroffice buildingsonce37male416community collegejuniorsecurity officeroffice buildingsonce68male523junior high schooljuniorsecurity officerresidential livingonce39male483community collegejuniorsecurity officerresidential livingonce310male551high schoolJuniorSecurity Officerresidential livingonce1011male351high schooljuniorsecurity officerresidential livingonce112male5220high schooljuniorteam leaderpublic transportation stationsonce1213male4813high schoolintermediateforemanpublic transportation stationsonce914female4812junior high schooljuniorjunior teacherpublic transportation stationsonce1115female21< 1community collegejuniorsecurity officerpublic transportation stationsonce1 Characteristics of participants Self-perception of the occupation as security guards Participants conveyed that becoming a security guard was often seen as a fallback option when no better alternatives were available. Security guard roles typically did not require a high level of education, and individuals were inclined to leave the job if presented with other employment opportunities. The high turnover rate in personnel posed challenges to CPR training. Furthermore, participants felt a lack of understanding and respect from society and feared potential repercussions such as being misunderstood, extorted for money, or accused if they performed CPR. Security guards in hospitals felt a heightened sense of responsibility but had fewer occasions to perform CPR. Conversely, security guards in public transportation systems, such as airports and subway stations, often had prescribed procedures to follow in emergencies. The “intention & performance-focused” model of B-CPR Key elements that influence the B-CPR intention and subsequent performance were identified. Two distinct scenarios were delineated, involving victims who are either familiar individuals with a trust relationship or strangers without a pre-existing trust relationship. It revealed that for security personnel when the victim was a trusted individual such as a family member, friend, or colleague, there was a tendency to perform CPR even in the absence of confidence, provided one possessed relevant CPR knowledge and skills. However, when faced with unfamiliar individuals without a trusting relationship, the intention of CPR hinged on personal characteristics (e.g., belief in kindness), past experiences, knowledge and skills, and self-efficacy. Despite harboring the intention to perform CPR, individuals would shrink back when faced with strangers due to multiple considerations. Action was only taken when all the barriers were overcome, facilitating CPR performance. Specifically, four categories of barriers to CPR performance were identified: security guard-related, victim-related, organizational, and societal factors. Security guard-related factors primarily involved uncertain operational skills in real-life situations. Factors related to the victim included scenarios where the victim is of the opposite sex or an older individual, uncertainty about the victim’s medical conditions, and an unsafe onsite environment. The onsite environmental safety entails the presence of video recording, cameras, or witnesses during CPR. Organizational barriers mainly stem from a lack of role identification for B-CPR performers, unreasonable workflow for handling OHCA, and non-standardized training. Social barriers predominantly include social norms, negative media reports, low awareness of relevant laws and regulations, and a lack of a reasonable training system. Notably, only by overcoming barriers at all the aforementioned layers (i.e., bystanders, victims, organizations, and society) can the intention to perform CPR be translated into action. The detailed quotes are shown in Table 3, and the schematic diagram of the “intention & performance-focused” model of B-CPR is illustrated in Fig. 2. Table 3Quotes and details of barriers to B-CPR intention and performanceCategoriesCodesTrust relationshipQuote examplesYesNoContextual key elementTrust relationship“If it is a family member, I would consider chest compressions immediately. Because, for family, it is a necessity – the bond of kinship dictates that even if the outcome is uncertain, chest compressions are imperative. However, when dealing with strangers, there are additional considerations. In uncertain situations, the immediate response would be to make a phone call and provide some basic measures.” (N3)“When it comes to a colleague or a relative collapsing, in such instances, I would take action because colleagues and relatives have mutual understanding and trust. However, with passers-by on the street, it’s not certain. We are not familiar, there is a lack of understanding, and there are concerns and reservations that I mentioned earlier.” (N9)B-CPR intentionPast experience✓“I’d like to help, but I would still shrink back because I faced numerous complaints around me when I tried to help in the past.” (N2)“This experience imparts a valuable lesson, doesn’t it? When you genuinely intend to perform good deeds… On one hand, your efforts may go unnoticed, and on the other hand, they may lead to a negative impression, causing the person to be hesitant to help in the future. Consequently, psychological shadows may be cast. It’s about learning from setbacks. For example, if you exert yourself but achieve nothing, or if the individual perceives the next encounter with a similar situation negatively, they might refrain from helping. Hence, lingering psychological shadows can ensue.” (N12)Personality traits✓“In such situations, there’s no room for overthinking; you just have to act quickly. Act first because the precious four minutes pass by rapidly. Taking action first is crucial; thinking too much is futile… if unsuccessful, then accept it with equanimity.” (N7)Knowledge and skills✓✓“ My understanding of CPR is limited to a theoretical level, and my learning has been somewhat sporadic and incomplete. Additionally, I have never had the opportunity to perform the procedures in practice. …” (N9)Self-efficacy✓“ If someone around me were to collapse, I must admit I wouldn’t feel very confident. In other words, I’m aware of my limitations. If my abilities are only average, I definitely wouldn’t feel comfortable stepping up.” (N15)B-CPR performanceSecurity guardsOperational skills in real situations✓“When it comes to actual performance, there is still uncertainty. Even though I received training about chest compression sites, compression depth, frequency of compressions, and artificial respiration at the Red Cross Training Center on Beijing West Road, I am still unsure. After all, it was with mannequins, which are different from real individuals. I am uncertain whether the procedures would be accurate on real individuals, and I question if I can do it correctly. Real-life practical experience on actual individuals is different from mannequins, right?” (N11)“If you have learned some and practiced it, there will still be some help… But I have not performed CPR in real people, so I’m not sure. (N14)VictimsAge and sex✓“If they are young and robust individuals, we would undoubtedly prioritize saving them. However, when it comes to older individuals, it’s a different scenario. We need to take more factors into consideration. If something were to go wrong, their children may not necessarily be understanding. In such cases, we would certainly prioritize not performing chest compressions, but we would still call emergency services. This is the current situation, isn’t it? We need to be cautious when dealing with older people.” (N4)“Moreover, being a young woman, there are some concerns about sex differences, you know.” (N15)Disease status✓“We cannot accurately judge the patient’s condition, which could involve serious heart issues such as heart failure or hypertension. If we cannot make the correct judgment, it might lead to unfavourable situations for the patient, such as secondary injuries or fractures.” (N9)On-site environmental safety✓“Because it’s the workplace, I’m not afraid. There are surveillance cameras here, recording everything. So, in a safe environment, I would choose to perform chest compressions.” (N5)“…if there are other witnesses present, and if there is video as evidence, and in the presence of family members, considering their consent, I would contemplate taking action.” (N9)OrganizationsRole requirements✓“Our company also does not recommend us directly participating in resuscitation. Therefore, our priority is to transport the patient to the emergency department. This is what security personnel can and must do, and it is the safest approach.” (N2)Workflow✓“Our current on-site handling procedure involves promptly evacuating surrounding passengers, quickly reporting, and contacting professional emergency personnel to come to the scene. That’s how the procedure goes.” (N12)Training rules✓“In general, the company wouldn’t consider retraining unless it’s for promoting you to become a team leader. In such cases, they might require you to undergo retraining. However, there is a lack of hands-on training…They rarely let us practice, with only a few selected individuals out of fifty or sixty getting the opportunity for hands-on experience.” (N10)SocietySocial norms✓“I’ve come across news stories in the past where a pharmacy owner saved a patient but ended up causing several broken ribs. Consequently, they were embroiled in legal issues for several years. Similar news reports are not uncommon. It’s not just an isolated incident involving a single individual; rather, it reflects a broader issue within the overall environment.” (N2)Social medias✓“Nowadays, there are quite a few incidents of older people falling, and many people try to help. However, there are also many cases of people facing legal issues after helping. I can’t say it doesn’t happen, and I can’t say it happens in all cases, but it does occur. I’ve seen it on TV and TikTok; it definitely has an impact.” (N11)Laws and regulations✓“Professionals and certain individuals who provide assistance are protected by the law in our country. For instance, when a patient is being resuscitated in a hospital, regardless of the outcome, there is no liability. While I would be willing to help, unfortunately, the country does not provide the same recognition for my role. As a mere security guard, if I handle the situation well, everyone applauds it as helping others. However, if not handled properly, it could lead to trouble. There’s a risk of facing legal charges, which wouldn’t be favorable.” (N9)Training systems✓“We only received training when obtaining the security certificate over ten years ago. They discussed CPR during the training, but there hasn’t been any further training since then. Additionally, it’s been a long time since the training, and I’ve forgotten much of the content. There have been no updates.” (N14) Quotes and details of barriers to B-CPR intention and performance “If it is a family member, I would consider chest compressions immediately. Because, for family, it is a necessity – the bond of kinship dictates that even if the outcome is uncertain, chest compressions are imperative. However, when dealing with strangers, there are additional considerations. In uncertain situations, the immediate response would be to make a phone call and provide some basic measures.” (N3) “When it comes to a colleague or a relative collapsing, in such instances, I would take action because colleagues and relatives have mutual understanding and trust. However, with passers-by on the street, it’s not certain. We are not familiar, there is a lack of understanding, and there are concerns and reservations that I mentioned earlier.” (N9) “I’d like to help, but I would still shrink back because I faced numerous complaints around me when I tried to help in the past.” (N2) “This experience imparts a valuable lesson, doesn’t it? When you genuinely intend to perform good deeds… On one hand, your efforts may go unnoticed, and on the other hand, they may lead to a negative impression, causing the person to be hesitant to help in the future. Consequently, psychological shadows may be cast. It’s about learning from setbacks. For example, if you exert yourself but achieve nothing, or if the individual perceives the next encounter with a similar situation negatively, they might refrain from helping. Hence, lingering psychological shadows can ensue.” (N12) “When it comes to actual performance, there is still uncertainty. Even though I received training about chest compression sites, compression depth, frequency of compressions, and artificial respiration at the Red Cross Training Center on Beijing West Road, I am still unsure. After all, it was with mannequins, which are different from real individuals. I am uncertain whether the procedures would be accurate on real individuals, and I question if I can do it correctly. Real-life practical experience on actual individuals is different from mannequins, right?” (N11) “If you have learned some and practiced it, there will still be some help… But I have not performed CPR in real people, so I’m not sure. (N14) “If they are young and robust individuals, we would undoubtedly prioritize saving them. However, when it comes to older individuals, it’s a different scenario. We need to take more factors into consideration. If something were to go wrong, their children may not necessarily be understanding. In such cases, we would certainly prioritize not performing chest compressions, but we would still call emergency services. This is the current situation, isn’t it? We need to be cautious when dealing with older people.” (N4) “Moreover, being a young woman, there are some concerns about sex differences, you know.” (N15) “Because it’s the workplace, I’m not afraid. There are surveillance cameras here, recording everything. So, in a safe environment, I would choose to perform chest compressions.” (N5) “…if there are other witnesses present, and if there is video as evidence, and in the presence of family members, considering their consent, I would contemplate taking action.” (N9) The “intention & performance-focused” model of B-CPR. Note: This “intention & performance-focused” model of B-CPR draws inspiration from the Swiss cheese model, where each slice represents a layer of barrier. The main idea behind the model is that failures in B-CPR performance often result from multiple layers of barriers, including security guards, victims, organizations, and society, rather than a single cause. By identifying and addressing the barriers across each layer, security guards can increase the likelihood of B-CPR performance Participants also shared their perspectives on the desired CPR training, including trainers, training contents, training formats, and training incentives. Regarding trainers, participants prefer to have medical professionals conduct the training. This preference stems from the professionals’ ability to share personal experiences with real cases, enhancing the training’s authenticity and effectiveness. Some participants expressed a desire to receive training every three months to reinforce memory and consolidate the related knowledge. For the training contents, there was an urgent demand for hands-on simulation exercises and psychological coping skills, in addition to the relevant theoretical knowledge. It was noteworthy that not every security guard had an equal opportunity to do hands-on practice——“In general, the company wouldn’t consider retraining unless it’s for promoting you to become a team leader…They rarely let us practice, with only a few selected individuals out of fifty or sixty getting the opportunity for hands-on experience.” Additionally, psychological coping encompassed not only strategies for overcoming nervousness and anxiety when confronting sudden cardiac arrest and rescue situations but also addressing or self-adjusting negative emotions following unsuccessful resuscitation attempts, such as potential feelings of guilt and flashbacks to the chaotic situations. Furthermore, certificates, rewards, and inclusion in the title evaluation system were all incentives to promote participation in training and enhance security guards’ self-confidence in performing CPR. Quotes related to these training components are shown in Table 4. Table 4Quotes relating to the desired CPR trainingTraining componentsQuote examplesTrainers“ Having training conducted by professional medical personnel, with explanations from experts, preferably accompanied by practical examples, would enhance the effectiveness of the training.” (N6)Training formats“I hope that CPR training can be conducted every three months because practice is crucial. Through repeated training, we can develop greater proficiency, even if some aspects of the knowledge may not be covered as extensively. However, when it comes to saving lives, I believe it’s essential to acquire and master practical skills.” (N12)Training contents Theory and knowledge“It should be taught by medical personnel, covering the frequency and depth of chest compressions, artificial respiration, and other pertinent techniques. Additionally, it should include information on correctly assessing the causes of collapse, factors contributing to collapse, and other relevant knowledge.” (N1) Hands-on practice“Theoretical knowledge is crucial, but practical hands-on experience is equally essential. This is particularly true during practical exercises, where small group settings allow individuals to try and practice with each other, fostering necessary skills development.” (N5) Psychological coping“It would be beneficial to include training sessions focusing on psychological aspects. Teaching psychological coping techniques would be valuable. When faced with such situations, I often feel extremely anxious and somewhat lost. Overcoming this anxiety, worry, and nervousness, especially in scenarios where mistakes may have been made despite genuine effort and the person wasn’t revived, is crucial. The feeling of guilt and its impact on future actions can lead to hesitancy in similar situations. Effective guidance in managing these negative psychological states is essential. Learning coping skills, engaging in mental development, and timely alleviation of negative emotions can help us let go, move forward, and release these feelings. We shouldn’t allow fear to paralyze us after one incident. If someone collapses again next time, I am committed to doing my best to perform the skills.” (N15)Training incentives“After receiving training and obtaining a certificate, the ability to perform rescues is reinforced by the qualification.” (N9)“I hope the training can be linked to the bonus or promotion evaluation.” (N13) Quotes relating to the desired CPR training “After receiving training and obtaining a certificate, the ability to perform rescues is reinforced by the qualification.” (N9) “I hope the training can be linked to the bonus or promotion evaluation.” (N13) Discussion The findings of this study showed that the performance of CPR by Chinese security guards is not without its challenges. While security guards exhibit readiness to perform CPR without hesitation on individuals with whom they have established trust relationships, they may hesitate or “shrink back” when faced with strangers. The factors influencing their decision to perform CPR are multifaceted, encompassing considerations at the individual, organizational, and societal levels. Specifically, these factors include, for example, the security guard’s skills and self-efficacy in performing CPR, the victim’s medical conditions, the workflow of the organization for which the security guard works, and the broader societal attitudes. As such, promoting the performance of CPR for security guards needs to take into account multi-level factors that affect their decision-making. As a vulnerable population with a relatively low socioeconomic status in China, security guards have concerns about potential job loss or facing legal complaints when performing CPR on strangers. Consequently, they tend to avoid performing CPR to mitigate potential complications. It is consistent with prior studies indicating that the fear of legal liability is one of the important reasons for reluctance to intervene [25, 26]. A 2017 online survey report [25] indicated that when administering CPR to strangers, 53.2% of participants expressed concerns about legal issues. The concern regarding legal liability highlights two primary social issues: the negative portrayal on social media and the insufficient dissemination of legal information, both of which have deterred security guards from performing CPR. Reports of negative incidents involving lawsuits due to failed rescue attempts make it more likely for security guards to anticipate being in a predetermined negative situation. However, the “chivalrous conduct” is always a traditional virtue in Chinese culture. Scholars argue that by bolstering positive publicity and providing scientific guidance, awareness of B-CPR can be heightened, thereby promoting public responsiveness to OHCA [15]. In the realm of legislation, while China initiated its laws relatively late compared to the enactment of the “Good Samaritan” law in the United States [27], it also introduced laws in 2021 to offer robust legal protection for bystanders who voluntarily provide reasonable emergency aid to the injured [15]. The reinforcement of relevant laws should be integrated into CPR training programs to encourage public responsiveness to OHCA. Furthermore, social media platforms should amplify the dissemination of relevant laws and positive examples to alleviate public fears and concerns. It is worth mentioning that security guards do not have equal opportunities for hands-on practice and tend to defer to senior colleagues and leaders. It unveiled disparities in accessing life-saving training resources among security guards across hierarchical position levels. This adds to the previous finding that the likelihood of receiving CPR training was negatively related to income and education level [1]. However, to further enhance CPR competencies among security guards, collaborative training and educational sessions involving everyone in the chain of survival are necessary [28]. It must be emphasized that everyone should have the opportunity to be trained in CPR [29]. Security personnel who maintain a 24-hour vigil in public spaces not only require a fundamental understanding of first aid knowledge and skills but also necessitate organizational initiatives to enhance their role identification as primary laypersons in CPR performance for people with OHCA. Furthermore, organizations lacking formal CPR training rules, coupled with a deficiency in incentivization mechanisms, may potentially undermine the proactive engagement of security guards in training activities. The whole training system is inseparable from the active support of social organizations. Specifically, the improvement of the CPR training system should be considered a crucial aspect of accelerating the development of the social emergency response system. The social emergency training system in Bao’an District, Shenzhen, known as the “Baoan Mode” [15, 30], emphasizes a government-led, expert-guided, technologically supported, and socially engaged approach to building the social emergency training system. Localities can adapt and refine the CPR training system, drawing inspiration from the “Baoan Mode”. Another challenge affecting the CPR performance by security guards is psychological coping, consistent with the “psychological support” as critical link in the “chainmail of survival” [14]. Resuscitation of OHCA is emotionally overwhelming and is different from simulation, which typically occurs in safe and controlled environments [31]. Consistent with other studies, unidentified factors, such as the cause of the collapse, the presence of infectious diseases, the availability of witnesses, and environmental safety, pose additional challenges to the performance of CPR [32, 33]. Security guards in the study also expressed concerns about the potential harm or failure caused by the unqualified practice, which is a concern shared by laypersons universally [34]. This concern can be effectively addressed through action points in CPR education. For example, discussions can include the importance of talking with someone about the experience after the mission and providing opportunities for professional debriefing following participation in real-life CPR situations [35]. Implications The study findings revealed barriers to CPR intention and performance at multiple levels, including the security guards, victims, organizations, and societal levels, by examining the experiences and perspectives of security guards. This “intention & performance-focused” model of B-CPR offers a theoretical foundation for developing a training model that involves close collaboration and active engagement from individuals, organizations, and society. The study findings revealed barriers to CPR intention and performance at multiple levels, including the security guards, victims, organizations, and societal levels, by examining the experiences and perspectives of security guards. This “intention & performance-focused” model of B-CPR offers a theoretical foundation for developing a training model that involves close collaboration and active engagement from individuals, organizations, and society. Security guards, as key bystanders in OHCA, play a crucial role in improving the overall effectiveness of the chain of survival by increasing their CPR performance rate. The voice of the security personnel can promote the construction of the CPR training system, the publicity of relative laws and regulations, and the improvement of the social norms on B-CPR. Security guards, as key bystanders in OHCA, play a crucial role in improving the overall effectiveness of the chain of survival by increasing their CPR performance rate. The voice of the security personnel can promote the construction of the CPR training system, the publicity of relative laws and regulations, and the improvement of the social norms on B-CPR. The “intention & performance-focused” model developed in this study can provide a reference for designing interventions to improve the B-CPR intention and performance for other specific groups. The “intention & performance-focused” model developed in this study can provide a reference for designing interventions to improve the B-CPR intention and performance for other specific groups. Limitations Firstly, the participants shared their thoughts based on memories, which could have memory bias. Secondly, only two female security guards participated in the study, primarily due to the social demographics of the security guard profession, where females constitute a lower proportion than males, leading to their potential underrepresentation. Finally, this study was conducted with security guards in an urban setting; further research to explore the differences in rural regions is warranted. This will promote the formulation of more effective policies and strategies that cater to the unique needs of security guards in both urban and rural settings. Conclusions Security personnel, often the first witnesses to OHCA, should be recognized as a critical link in the “Chainmail of Survival”. This study highlighted that existing CPR training programs have not sufficiently prepared security personnel to initiate CPR. It also identified key factors leading security guards to hesitate or “shrink back” in performing CPR, spanning four layers: bystanders, victims, organizations, and society. Particularly, the reinforcement of relevant laws should be integrated into CPR training programs to encourage public responsiveness to OHCA. The “intention & performance-focused” model” proposed in this study can offer valuable insights and a theoretical basis for shaping future CPR training initiatives. Supplementary Information Additional file 1. The SRQR checklist. Acknowledgements The authors thank all the security guards who participated in this study. Abbreviations American Heart Association Bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation Cardiopulmonary resuscitation Emergency medical service International Liaison committee on resuscitation Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest Standard deviation Authors’ contributions MZY contributed to the study design, data collection, data analysis, and manuscript writing. JYS and YYJ contributed to the study design, data analysis, data interpretation, visualization, and manuscript writing. YYJ and YQP contributed to the manuscript review and provided overall supervision. MZY and YQP acquired the funding. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Funding This study was supported by the Science and Technology Project of Songjiang District [No. 20SJKJGG373]; Shanghai Modern Nursing Vocational Education Group’s Special Parttime Teacher Assistance Program [No. hlzjtpgr202330]. Data availability The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. Declarations Ethics approval and consent to participate The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Shanghai First Hospital (Process No. 2021KY013). All interviewees were informed about the confidentiality of the data, and interviews were anonymized before analysis. Informed consents from all participants were obtained. Consent for publication Not applicable. Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests. Footnotes Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Mingzhu Yang and Junyang Song contributed equally to the study. Contributor Information Yuanyuan Jin, Email: yyjin1109@suda.edu.cn. Youqing Peng, Email: 2856580686@qq.com. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Additional file 1. The SRQR checklist. Data Availability Statement The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.