Research of digital management on sport: An analysis of bibliometrics using CiteSpace Software Authors: Gang Xu, Qian Yang, Qiang Li, Hongli Yu Published: 2024 ABSTRACT Digital management on sport (DMS) has become a hot topic around sports management. However, a more comprehensive and in-depth investigation into the structure and progression of this field is necessary. We used CiteSpace software to conduct a bibliometric analysis, revealing dynamic patterns in the evolution of co-citation, collaboration, and keyword co-occurrence within this field. Data gathers from the Web of Science Core Collection, which includes Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI), Arts & Humanities Citation Index (A&HCI), Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI) and Science Citation Index Expanded (SCI-EXPANDED), and SCOPUS. Published works in this field have shown a consistent upward trend since 2013. England institutions are leading the way in cooperation, while the US is the most collaborative region with different priorities for collaboration in various topics. The most influential author is the one who receives the most citations, but unfortunately, the most frequently co-cited author shows “ANONYMOUS.” Highly cited journals typically exert a substantial influence. Additionally, further study is expected to concentrate on efficacy and validation. Since 2018, the growth in publications on DMS reflects increasing academic interest. Australia’s institutions lead in collaboration, though international cooperation is limited. High co-citation authors hold significant influence and research focuses on management, social media, and physical activity. 1. Introduction The Fourth Industrial Revolution, commonly referred to as Industry 4.0, is characterized by the extensive implementation of digitalization and information technology. Although its original objective was to enhance the industrial process in manufacturing, engineering, material utilization, life cycle and supply chain management, digital management has penetrated into various fields and has become an important means of modern management.[1] Sports as a social and cultural phenomenon, The COVID-19 epidemic in 2020 has expedited the integration of technology into society, the economy, and state administrations. The sports industry is familiar with this process of digitization and must undergo its own digital transformation.[2] In the field of sports, the utilization of digital management not only determines the correlation between sports and digital information technology, but also improves management efficiency and scientific decision-making level.[3] There are a lot of related researches of digital management on sport (DMS), the application of sports digital management to games explores whether it can help future sports managers and sports management students enter this complex field of work, furthermore, it verifies that there is indeed a substantial level of concurrence between competency models in sports administration and the manner in which digital games are engaged in.[4] Digital management has also been applied to the media, significantly improving sport, mainly through the broadcast of sports and media events, as well as through training preparation and implementation. Digital media is also used to monitor the security of sports venues like video surveillance.[5] Also promoting the adoption of targeted curricula that prioritize digital literacy and capability development is crucial. Developing and implementing curricula that specifically address digital literacy can effectively meet industry requirements and equip the next generation of sport management students with essential skills.[6] The digital platform’s capabilities in managing the entire educational process cycle are described.[7] The longevity of a digital platform relies on the owner’s capacity to enable streamlined and productive collaboration among the many participants within the platform, at both the service ecosystem and service system levels, with the aim of generating value.[8] The argument posits that the impact of the digital revolution on decision-making and managerial accounting remains uncertain.[9] An extensive analysis was conducted on the publications pertaining to the field of digitalization in management accounting. Subsequently, they were categorized according to particular criteria, aiming to offer valuable understanding of the influence of digitalization on the highly recognized field of management accounting.[10] Study which focuses on enhancing our understanding of models and ways that assist firms in effectively managing the process of digital transformation, so making a valuable contribution to the progress of knowledge in this field. Managers can utilize the identification of change management activities and ideas on how to effectively handle them to successfully guide their firms through the transition to Industry 4.0.[11] The research adds to the existing literature of research on knowledge management systems (KMS) which plays a critical role in capturing, organizing, and disseminating information within organizations, making them essential tools in modern digital infrastructure, by examining it through the lens of digital innovation processes. It highlights the importance of implementing new methods for knowledge generation and sharing, which are essential for promoting inclusive and global growth.[12] Additionally, aiming to provide a more comprehensive basis for redefining research on innovation management in the context of a digital world. The content discusses the stages and methods of incorporating digital transformation into management and quality control tools. The goal is to fully integrate these tools into a modern management system that aligns with the latest editions of international standards in occupational safety, quality, health, and ecology.[13] A debate is currently taking place over the distinctions between digital communication, static unidirectional digital presence, and interactive social media relationships. Additionally, provide methods for creating and nurturing a digital profile, evaluate the advantages and drawbacks of participating in social media for professional purposes, and explain how digital and social media technologies can be beneficial for both practice management and reimbursement.[14] These studies greatly facilitate the expansion of DMS research. The investigations, however, possess both advantages and disadvantages. Currently, studies tend to concentrate on specific independent factors, which has led to the neglect of other important factors, such as the overall development and trends in this field. This oversight has hindered the comprehensive understanding and growth of knowledge in DMS. In addition, contemporary research uses various methodologies and techniques, including bibliometric analysis using CiteSpace, to assess the advancement of the field. While these studies examine specific aspects of DMS, they often overlook the broader, overarching concept of “DMS” as a whole. Hence, it is imperative to provide a concise overview of the research advancements, present development status, prominent areas of research, and exploring possible future trends is crucial for acquiring a thorough grasp of “DMS,” including its current status and features, and developing a comprehensive knowledge framework in this field. It is beneficial for researchers in selecting appropriate study directions and ensuring the sustained development of the area. This research employs the CiteSpace visualization program to perform a bibliometric analysis of DMS from various viewpoints. We conducted a comprehensive analysis of global collaborative networks in this field, focusing on collaborations among authors, institutions, and regions, and describe the overarching characteristics of these networks. Additionally, we identified influential journals, authors, and key literature to highlight valuable study directions and classifications for researchers. To observe the evolution of knowledge in this area, we analyze current high-activity research areas and forecast future trends by examining keyword occurrences and bursts. Finally, based on this analysis, we constructed a theoretical knowledge framework. This framework presents a thorough summary of DMS research and explores the potential areas for future research. This study has following innovations. From a knowledge perspective, we analyzed the research advancements in DMS through co-citation, collaboration, and co-occurrence, providing comprehensive, multifaceted insights to help readers understand the dynamics of this field. Theoretically, we established a novel framework that offers a clearer and more accessible view of the systematic structure of DMS research. Practically, we examined existing challenges and areas for further study, guiding researchers toward selecting relevant topics and conducting their studies more effectively and efficiently. This paper’s second part outlines the process of software selection and operation. Section 3 provides a concise overview of the analytic findings, focusing on publishing statistic summary, co-citation networks, collaboration, and keyword co-occurrence. Section 4 conducts a discussion. The conclusion in Section 5 offers a comprehensive understanding of the research for researchers. 2. Materials and methods 2.1. Databases and the process of selection This research retrieved data from SCOPUS the Web of Science Core Collection, incorporating indexing from Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI), Arts & Humanities Citation Index (A&HCI), Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI) and Science Citation Index Expanded (SCI-EXPANDED). The reasons for choosing SCOPUS, SSCI, A&HCI, ESCI, and SCIE as the primary databases are outlined as follows: WoS and SCOPUS databases offer comprehensive and extensive datasets spanning a long period, making it an excellent resource for scientific research. Its sophisticated search functionalities enable precise retrieval of necessary data. Furthermore, the global recognition and widespread use of WoS and SCOPUS as a reputable indexing service lend credibility and representativeness to research findings, ensuring that outcomes are both authoritative and persuasive.[15–18] To ensure the accuracy of our search and the reliability of the analysis results, we follow strict guidelines throughout the process. Specifically, we input carefully selected criteria into the Web of Science search interface, ensuring a systematic and thorough approach to data retrieval. The all fields inputs “digital management”and“sport” The all fields inputs “digital management”and“sport” The retrieval strategy was set as TS= (“digital management” and “sport”). The retrieval strategy was set as TS= (“digital management” and “sport”). The document type selects “Article or Review Article.” The document type selects “Article or Review Article.” Select the language “English, Spanish and Chinese.” Select the language “English, Spanish and Chinese.” The publication spans from January 2013 to December 2023. The publication spans from January 2013 to December 2023. The dataset has 896 articles (Text S1–3, Supplemental Digital Content, http://links.lww.com/MD/O137), which adhere to the following premises: The data comprehensively illustrate the notion of DMS by elucidating the relationship between digital management and sport, and the data enhance the research on DMS. 2.2. Research methodology A wide range of software applications are accessible for doing bibliometric statistics, each with its own set of pros and shortcomings.[19] For example, VOSviewer provides user-friendly functionalities that enable fast analysis and visualization, allowing for a swift review of correlations in literature. Nevertheless, its ability to do intricate clustering and temporal analysis is restricted, and it encounters difficulties when dealing with extensive literature datasets. HistCite demonstrates exceptional proficiency in doing frequency analysis, but, it lacks the capability to thoroughly investigate co-occurrence or co-citation connections. SATI is proficient in analyzing co-occurrence and co-citation data, but it does not have the capability to visually represent the chronological development of study topics. RefViz is user-friendly for keyword analysis and grouping, however it has constraints when it comes to integrated and complete analysis.[15] Instead, CiteSpace, a Java-based bibliometric analysis software, represents a cutting-edge tool in information visualization technology, adept at handling multi-dimensional, time-based, and dynamic complex network analysis. Widely adopted in scientometrics, CiteSpace facilitates the depiction of a domain’s scientific knowledge through various network types. For instance, in a timeline network, clusters summarize similar nodes, with node size indicating keyword frequency and line color representing the time of initial keyword and co-occurrence.[20] Through the assessment of cluster size and the mean publication year, researchers could identify and trace the evolution of field hotspots.[21] Additionally, It was highlighted that burst detection in CiteSpace could reveal study hotspots by analyzing literature with unusually high citation rates over a period, breakout words with unusually high occurrence frequencies, and milestone literature marked by prominent citation rates. Strategic diagrams further describe research hotspots through a clustering and co-word matrix, defined by degrees of novelty and attention.[22] More precisely, bibliometric visual analysis of the literature on DMS is conducted using the CiteSpace software. This software has gained global recognition from numerous researchers due to its robust visualization of data and quantitative analytical skills, which effectively illustrate the dynamic development of study area. CiteSpace has been effectively employed in prior bibliometric research across many fields, including metaverse, resilient shipping network, and diet in Alzheimer’s disease.[23–25] The objective of this study is to analyze the key features and notable aspects of DMS research, including its current publishing status, collaborative relationships, research development, and emerging areas of interest. This analysis will help researchers gain a more comprehensive understanding of the field. The operation homepage and selection criteria are presented in Figure 1. Operational running homepage. By using CiteSpace, we obtained results and visually represented the networks through the following procedures (Fig. 2). Obtain the dataset comprising 896 items extracted from SCOPUS and WoS, removing redundant data to achieve the final dataset spanning 2013 to 2023. Set the time range from January 2013 to December 2023 and configure the data processing parameters to include the keywords, author keywords, abstract and title plus as sources for text analysis. Identify the node types for authors, institutions, and countries, and generate visual collaboration networks that illustrate the connections between these nodes, allowing for the identification of key stakeholders in DMS research over the past decade. Define node types for cited authors, references, and journals to assess the co-citation landscape within this study area. Specify node types for keywords and generate networks of keyword co-occurrences, providing insight into the evolution of research, current areas of focus, and noteworthy developments. This analysis of each component offers a cohesive understanding and comprehensive view of DMS research, helping to build a knowledge framework according to study findings and forecast further study directions and areas of interest.[26,27] Study procedures. 3. Results 3.1. Publication statistics Publication statistics offer a comprehensive summary of the current publication status and trends in a specific subject. They help scholars determine the popularity and emergence of the field, as well as identify the preferred topics and journals among scholars in that field.[28] Figure 3 depicts the yearly publishing of articles on DMS from January 2013 to November 2023. Overall, there is a growing body of study on DMS. Specifically, it went through 3 stages of development: Annual publication analysis. The period from 2013 to 2018 can be described as the childhood stage. During this period, the annual publication count was minimal, with less than 10 publications per year. This indicates that research on DMS was not a primary focus during this stage. However, these publications played a crucial role in establishing the groundwork for future expansion. The second phase, known as the puberty stage, occurred between 2018 and 2020. During this period, there was a marginal rise in the number, which eventually settled at approximately 30 per year. This trend suggests the development and expansion of DMS research. The third phase, which occurred between 2020 and 2023, witnessed a consistent and gradual rise in the number of articles, starting at approximately 50. Despite minor fluctuations in certain years, the overall growth potential of the subject remains evident. The year characterized by the greatest quantity of publications (2023, 221 publications) is about twice as high as the year with the lowest number of publications (2020, 105 publications) over this period. That suggests that DMS research has garnered heightened interest from scholars. Additionally, it is important to mention that our analysis did not include literature produced after 2023. Consequently, the data for 2023 had a comparatively higher value compared to previous years. In conclusion, the field of DMS has garnered significant interest over the last 10 years, and it is imperative for current scholars to further allocate resources towards research in this domain. 3.2. Relations of collaboration The objective of collaboration analysis is to graphically illustrate cooperation networks, therefore offering a lucid portrayal of the interconnections among researchers. This facilitates a rapid comprehension of the topology and significant subjects of the network. Moreover, it facilitates the identification of the primary contributors (including regions, institutions, and authors) inside the collaborative networks, so offering valuable understanding of the current state and development of the collaboration. This information is valuable for identifying prospective influential collaborators and motivating less engaged academics to further their involvement in the area.[19,29] The next analysis will include extensive study features and specifics, allowing readers to have a very comprehensive comprehension of the general features and important specialized insights in this area. 3.2.1. Analysis of Institutional collaboration Figure 4 shows the Network of Institutional collaboration in DMS. If the institution label is getting smaller, then the lower the level of cooperation. Table 1 provides data on the top 15 collaborative institutions in the field of DMS. The table includes their rankings, publication counts, centrality, and the year of their initial joint scientific publication. Centrality refers to the level of relevance of a journal, institution or author in the area, with higher centrality indicating greater significance.[15] The majority of the leading collaborative universities, specifically 5 out of 15, are located in the United Kingdom, while 4 out of 15 are in Australia. This suggests that academic institutions in the UK and Australia possess considerable competence and experience in collaborating in the field of research. Table 1Top 15 Most collaborative institutionsRankingCountCentralityYearInstitution1400.012016La Trobe University23102018University of London3280.032014Loughborough University4280.012013University System of Ohio5270.092016Deakin University62602019Technical University of Munich72202021University of Melbourne8190.042016Harvard University9190.052020Egyptian Knowledge Bank (EKB)101802021Pennsylvania Commonwealth System of Higher Education (PCSHE)111702021University of Oradea121702020King’s College London13170.072013University of Sydney141602021Imperial College London151502020University College London Top 15 Most collaborative institutions Network of Institutional collaboration. There are specific and comprehensive findings. Deakin University in AUSTRALIA is a leading institution in the field of DMS, with the highest centrality, the 5th highest count of collaborations, and the initial joint scientific publication in 2016. It has published 27 collaboration publications, with a centrality score of 0.09. These statistics highlight the university’s important role and substantial contributions to collaboration in this area since its inception. The most recent research examines the development and implementation of a consultation tool on digitalization. This tool is considered the initial and essential step in conducting comprehensive, reliable, and replicable research. Its purpose is to gather information on the digitalization requirements of sports organizations, enabling the design of an effective digital transformation roadmap and the efficient distribution of resources for digital transformation.[2] Similarly, La Trobe University, with 40 collaboration articles and a centrality of 0.01, is significantly involved in institutional cooperation. Digital management and sports education play essential roles in fostering sustainable urban systems and environmental resilience. Empirical studies have identified income, urbanization, digital management, sports employment, tourism, and green energy as key factors impacting sustainability across selected European countries between 2010 and 2021. By determining that income growth, urbanization, and activities in sports and tourism contribute most to environmental degradation, whereas advancements in digital management and the adoption of green energy are vital for sustainable development. Furthermore, digital management serves as a crucial intermediary, supporting the stability and efficiency of urban energy systems.[30] University College London, ranked 15th globally, has a low number of publications (15 cooperation papers with a centrality score of 0.00). Nevertheless, this indicates that its collaborative contribution to this field is nevertheless significant. The influential literature explores how the elderly view digital coaching as a potential tool to motivate them towards physical activity by offering informative guidance and motivational feedback. Furthermore, it was shown that it had a beneficial impact on their workout self-efficacy. Nevertheless, it was evident that digital coaching gadgets should be customized for this specific demographic and provide a user-friendly interface to generate interest among them.[31] To summarize, those interested in conducting collaborative research in this field should prioritize established institutions and actively explore prospective chances to engage with them on specific subjects related to DMS study. 3.2.2. Regional collaboration analysis Figure 5 illustrates the cooperative areas inside the DMS. The size of the region label increases in proportion to the extent of collaboration. Table 2 lists the 15 regions that are actively participating in joint research on DMS. The primary collaborative regions are typically found in the United States, comprising around 5 times the amount of the 15th ranked country. This investigation yields numerous captivating and intricate discoveries. The United States of America remains in the top position with the greatest publications counts, with 198 publications with a centrality of 0.02, thanks to its extensively developed DMS that stimulates research endeavors in this area. The United States is ready to continue its cooperative efforts in DMS research, with the goal of improving its DMS system while providing vital research resources. A significant collaboration by DMS highlights the need of utilizing indicators for evaluating DMS. However, the implementation of indicators may face technical and conceptual obstacles, such as definitional ambiguity and limited data availability. It is crucial to make efforts to solve these hurdles[32]; The study emphasizes the USA’s tendency to engage in cooperation over pragmatic matters in DMS. Ranked among the top 5 regions based on both publication volume and centrality are ENGLAND (147 articles with a centrality of 0.05), AUSTRALIA (117 articles with a centrality of 0.01), GERMANY (113 articles with a centrality of 0.02), and PEOPLES R CHINA (95 articles with a centrality of 0.00). This implies that these places demonstrate exceptional performance in both the quantity and quality of joint endeavors. In addition, Although Romania has only 38 articles, its high centrality of 0.04 indicates successful collaboration in the field of DMS. Surprisingly, although AUSTRALIA is in third place, GERMANY is in fourth place, and PEOPLES R CHINA is in fifth place in terms of cooperative publication numbers, their centrality is less than 0.04. These figures are lower than Romania’s. Table 2Top 15 collaborative regionsRankingCountCentralityYearRegion11980.022013USA21470.052013ENGLAND31170.012013AUSTRALIA41130.022014GERMANY59502013PEOPLES R CHINA6880.052013SPAIN7800.012013CANADA8650.022014ITALY9630.012014NETHERLANDS104702014NORWAY11470.012016FRANCE124302016SLOVAKIA13390.012014SWITZERLAND143802014SWEDEN15380.042016ROMANIA Top 15 collaborative regions Regional collaboration network. It can be inferred that the distribution of major research resources is uneven, with a concentration in developed countries such as the United States, the United Kingdom, and Australia, while regions such as Latin America, Africa, and parts of Asia face relative resource scarcity. This imbalance may result in research themes being more aligned with the needs or interests of developed economies, potentially overlooking the unique perspectives of other regions. For example, while Western countries focus on the impact of high technology on professional sports, developing countries are more concerned with digital management in infrastructure and education.[33] Regional bias may limit the global applicability of research findings. To address this issue, it is recommended to establish multinational collaboration platforms, promote regional research alliances, and encourage the sharing of data and technologies across regions to reduce resource disparities. Additionally, advocating for open-access resources, increasing the citation of non-English literature, and encouraging international journals to accept multilingual submissions will foster broader global participation. This will ensure greater diversity and universality of research outcomes, ultimately mitigating regional bias. 3.2.3. Analysis of author collaboration Figure 6 displays the writers who have collaborated in the DMS system. The size of the author label increases as the level of cooperation rises. Table 3 shows an exhaustive compilation of the top 15 authors who have exhibited exceptional levels of collaboration in the field of DMS research. Overall, author collaborations are relatively infrequent and lack significance. Only 4 authors have contributed to 8 or more joint publications, with most leading collaborators having centrality scores of 0.00. Ilies, Dorina Camelia has the highest number of joint publications, with a total of 14. Caciora, Tudor and Hodor, Nicolaie follow closely with 13 and 10 collaborative works, respectively. Table 3Top 15 collaborative authorsRankingCountCentralityYearAuthor11402021Ilies, Dorina Camelia21302021Caciora, Tudor31002021Hodor, Nicolaie4802016Chawansky, Megan5702020Driss, Tarak6702022Tinsley, Grant M7702020Chamari, Karim8702020Chtourou, Hamdi970.032020Aloui, Asma10702021Hayhurst, Lyndsay M C11702022Ilies, Alexandru12702022Safarov, Bahodirhon13702020Boukhris, Omar14702021Thorpe, Holly1570.022020Ammar, Achraf Top 15 collaborative authors Author collaboration network. This implies a strong and effective collaboration between these 3 authors and their colleagues. More precisely, digital approaches, as a whole, are used to include them into traditional mobile heritage objects, such as garments[34]; Nevertheless, It is important to mention that the majority of authors have a centrality score of 0.00, which indicates a generally low level of collaboration among them. We advocate enhancing collaboration across authors to facilitate sharing of resources and coordinated initiatives in improving DMS research. 3.3. Status of co-citation Co-citation analysis is a technique aimed at uncovering the relationships between journals, scholarly works, and authors. When pieces of literature, authors, or 2 journals are co-cited in other articles indicates a possible correlation, implying their relevance to a specific study area. The frequency with which 2 entities are co-cited strengthens the perceived relationship, reflecting a common focus within the academic community and a comparable level of influence. This method offers critical insights into the current research landscape and highlights the key contributors who hold a foundational and influential position in the field. Co-cited references, which may or may not be included in our database, are those cited together in the articles we analyze. These references help reveal the relative significance of research contributions, identifying those with greater foundational importance and impact.[15] 3.3.1. Analysis of author co-citation Figure 7 and Table 4 display the 15 authors most frequently co-cited. Author co-citation refers to the occurrence of 2 authors being cited together in other academic publications. Author co-citations are determined by CiteSpace software by analyzing the co-citation of the primary author., while ensuring that numerous citations of the same author within the same literature are only counted once. Figure 7 illustrates how author co-citation networks can be used to identify the relationships throughout the academic community in a specific study field.[35,36] Table 4Top 15 most co-cited authorsRankingCountCentralityYearAuthor14390.492013[ANONYMOUS]2450.012019WORLD HEALTHORGANIZATION3440.112019MICHIE S4410.012019BRAUN V5310.042016HUTCHINS B6300.022020WANG Y7270.032020HAIR JF8250.012020WHO9230.072019FUNK DC10210.012021VENKATESH V11210.082019WANN DL12190.032020COHEN J13190.192017BANDURA A14190.012016FILO K15180.042021RATTEN V Top 15 most co-cited authors Network of author co-citation. Here are specific and comprehensive findings. Authors who are most frequently referenced are the most influential. Sadly, ANONYMOUS (Some references, such as editorial articles, marginalia, corrections, newsletters, conference references, etc., can also be cited as quotations, and since there is no author’s name, these quotations are centrally indexed as anonymous quotations) is the author who has received the most co-citations, totaling 439, is followed by WORLD HEALTHORGANIZATION with 45 co-citations, and MICHIE S with 44 co-citations. At the same time, [ANONYMOUS] has the highest centrality (0.49), suggesting that there are a lot of authors significantly impact this field without their names. Specifically, one of the author of ANONYMOUS cluster indicated the rise and widespread use of new media technologies have significantly transformed the media industry, resulting in a complex cross-media environment that combines popularity and personalization, as well as structure and agency. The dynamic nature of the environment brings about changes in the professional sport sector, and embracing these changes will result in the growth and prosperity of the industry in the era of digital media.[37] The co-cited Organizations and exert impact in this area. For example, the WORLD HEALTHORGANIZATION (WHO) is ranked among the top 10 non-individual authors with a total of 45 co-citations. This indicates that certain international organizations have a positive impact on DMS research by offering necessary structures and sources for the scholarly communities. Authors with co-citation exhibit a significant level of centrality, with the top co-cited authors having centrality values more than or equal to 0.01. This indicates that these authors have a considerable influence, despite having a large number of co-cited articles. Ultimately, it is advisable for these highly cited authors to maintain their current research directions and interests while also striving to amplify their influence. Additionally, other researchers can benefit from studying these influential authors to promote the effectiveness of their own status endeavors in the future. 3.3.2. Analysis of journal co-citation Figure 8 and Table 5 display the 15 journals that are most commonly co-cited in research on DMS. Journal co-citation is the occurrence of 2 journals being referenced together in the same body of literature, indicating a relationship or connection between different journals. The top 15 journals with the highest citation rates generally have exceptional impact factors, indicating their crucial role in advancing the scientific area. The following are specific findings: Journals that receive frequent citations from other scholars tend to exert a substantial impact. The journal that is most commonly co-cited alongside others is PLOS ONE, with a total of 192 co-citations. J MED INTERNET RES has 140 co-citations, while BMJ-BRIT MED J has 110 co-citations. PLOS ONE stands out for its high co-cited numbers and centrality, indicating that its total influence in the field surpasses that of other journals. The most recent study published in PLOS ONE examines the financial implications of sports data governance and sharing, as well as the level of compliance with sports data regulations. Furthermore, it underscores the importance of the government incentive structure and regulatory mechanism in exerting influence on the decision-making process of each stakeholder involved.[38] The top 7 co-cited journals exhibit superior performance compared to other publications. More precisely, the 7 highest-ranked journals exhibit a greater frequency of co-citation compared to those ranked 8 to 15, which have been co-cited less than 100 times. This indicates that these 7 journals hold significant value in the area, leading researchers to cite them more frequently. Researchers can enhance their citation count by giving priority to submitting their work to high-ranking journals (ranked 1–7) or other open-access journals. Certainly, researchers have the option to submit their submissions to other publications that have comparable objectives and areas of focus. Table 5Top 15 most co-cited journalsRankingCountCentralityYearJournal11920.152014PLOS ONE21400.032016J MED INTERNET RES31100.072013BMJ-BRIT MED J41070.072016INT J ENV RES PUB HE51050.052016SPORT MANAG REV61020.022021SUSTAINABILITY-BASEL71010.022019LANCET8990.062019J BUS RES9980.042018COMPUT HUM BEHAV10930.042016J SPORT MANAGE11840.022015BRIT J SPORT MED12810.072013BMC PUBLIC HEALTH13780.012016EUR SPORT MANAG Q14780.022019BMJ OPEN15780.072014JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC Top 15 most co-cited journals Journal co-citation network. 3.3.3. Reference co-citation analysis Figure 9 and Table 6 present the 15 most frequently co-cited references. Co-citation occurs when 2 references are cited together in the same publication. This analytical method helps uncover the knowledge structure of a research topic, highlighting key publications and identifying emerging research areas.[39] Table 6Top 15 co-cited referencesRankingCountCentralityYearReference11602018Pizzo AD, 2018, SPORT MARKET Q, V27, P1082140.012018Funk DC, 2018, SPORT MANAG REV, V21, P7, DOI 10.1016/j.smr.2017.07.008390.012022Doyle JP, 2022, EUR SPORT MANAG Q, V22, P506, DOI 10.1080/16184742.2020.18068974902015Filo K, 2015, SPORT MANAG REV, V18, P166, DOI 10.1016/j.smr.2014.11.0015902021Page MJ, 2021, BMJ-BRIT MED J, V372, P0, DOI 10.1186/s13643-021-01626-4670.012018Hallmann K, 2018, SPORT MANAG REV, V21, P14, DOI 10.1016/j.smr.2017.07.0117702018Cunningham GB, 2018, SPORT MANAG REV, V21, P1, DOI 10.1016/j.smr.2017.11.0028702014Stavros C, 2014, SPORT MANAG REV, V17, P455, DOI 10.1016/j.smr.2013.11.004970.012019Abeza G, 2019, COMMUN SPORT, V7, P80, DOI 10.1177/216747951774034310702018Tricco AC, 2018, ANN INTERN MED, V169, P467, DOI 10.7326/M18-085011602021Cranmer EE, 2021, COMPUT HUM BEHAV, V117, P0, DOI 10.1016/j.chb.2020.10667112602021Marcu F, 2021, INT J ENV RES PUB HE, V18, P0, DOI 10.3390/ijerph181899081360.012020Qian TY, 2020, EUR SPORT MANAG Q, V20, P458, DOI 10.1080/16184742.2019.163046414602021Lopez C, 2021, J BUS RES, V133, P208, DOI 10.1016/j.jbusres.2021.04.06815602019Pizzo AD, 2019, INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SPORT MANAGEMENT, V20, P171 Top 15 co-cited references Co-citation reference network. The majority of widely co-cited papers are journal publications that specifically address sport management, such as SPORT MANAG REV, EUR SPORT MANAG Q, and INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SPORT MANAGEMENT. That indicates that the literature with a large number of co-citations is focused on sport management. In addition, there are several in-depth talks. Out of the 15 most frequently cited papers, 3 were authored by Pizzo AD, who has the highest number of co-citations (16 co-citations in total). One of the publications published in this magazine highlighted that the majority of researches on digital revolution in sport marketing primarily centers on studies pertaining to social media platforms.[40] Most of the literatures co-cited with the second and third rank covered distinct subjects. Funk DC’s literature, which was published in 2018 and ranked second with 14 co-citations, and Doyle JP’s literature, published in 2022 and ranked third with 9 co-citations, primarily address the current research status and challenges in DMS research. These works also propose potential avenues for future study. On the other hand, Doyle JP’s literary works achieved a third place ranking and were published in 2022, with a total of 9 co-citations. Additionally, additional literary works have made substantial contributions to the study of DMS. These results provide valuable insights that the highly co-cited publications in this area encompass diverse subject matters. They will be crucial in guiding future study, enabling scholars to thoroughly examine and reference papers from many fields. 3.4. Co-occurrence evolvement Analysis of Co-occurrence is a method that examines the correlations between common terms and keywords in the literature. The objective is to exhibit the core ideas in the literature, establish connections between studies, comprehend previous areas of research focus, and speculate on prospective further avenues for study.[18] 3.4.1. Analysis of keyword co-occurrence Figure 10 and Table 7 display the 15 terms that most commonly appear together in DMS research, together with their centrality, counts, and year of initial appearance. The 5 most commonly appearing keywords in the DMS field are management, social media, physical activity, impact, and technology, with frequencies of 97, 69, 63, 62, and 45, respectively. These keywords are intimately associated with the DMS sector. In addition, it is noteworthy that digital health (27 co-occurrences), dependability (20 co-occurrences), and danger (19 co-occurrences) are very uncommon in the Table; nevertheless, they suggest a strong connection to DMS. The presence of these keywords together indicates that management, social media, and physical exercise are the current focal points of research in the field of DMS. Furthermore, the term “management” has the great centrality value of 0.25, meaning that the analysis of DMS places significant emphasis on innovation. Table 7Top 15 co-occurring keywordsRankingCountCentralityYearReference1970.252013management2690.192013social media3630.152013physical activity4620.082018impact5450.022019technology6420.12013health7340.142015performance8320.022016sport9280.152014behavior10280.072017model11270.042019digital health12200.062018reliability13190.052014care14190.012021risk15190.072013exercise Top 15 co-occurring keywords Network of keyword co-occurrence. In the DMS field, social media is evolving from a platform for information dissemination to an interactive, data-driven ecosystem. It supports sports promotion, brand development, and audience engagement, offering new avenues for data analysis. This trend facilitates real-time feedback, enriching decision-making in sports management. Future research should explore optimizing the use of social media data to enhance fan engagement and improve organizational strategies.[41] Digitalization is reshaping how physical activities are participated in and monitored. Tools like smart devices, activity trackers, and virtual reality are integrating into sports, providing detailed data analysis and personalized experiences.[42] Technologies like AI, big data, and cloud computing are increasingly used in sports management, offering new dimensions for resource allocation, performance analysis, and forecasting.[43] Future studies could investigate how these technologies enable more adaptive sports management models and address challenges in balancing efficiency with data privacy, particularly in international collaborations. Standardization and flexibility in technology application will be key topics in future DMS research. 3.4.2. Keyword burst analysis Figure 11 displays the 15 most prominent areas of research, together with the year they were initially identified, the magnitude of their rapid growth, and the chronology of their duration. These keywords were present prior to 2013, but gained significant attention and were focal points after that year. This indicates that 2013 was a crucial period when DMS research underwent noticeable transformations. There are certain specifics. The first significant term to get attention is “traumatic brain injury” in 2013. This keyword pertains to the domain-specific search of medical websites. The terms exhibiting the longest duration of heightened interest were “risk factors,” “disorders,” “Mental health,” “disease,” “moderating role,” “efficacy,” and “depression.” These topics have remained popular among researchers for a continuous period of 2 to 3 years since 2020. Notably, the term “reliability” has the highest magnitude (3.19), followed by “adolescents” (2.99) and “knowledge” (2.52). This illustrates that the use of DMS in the medical field has been a subject of significant interest for a considerable period of time. The most recent trending keywords are “validation” and “covid-19 pandemic,” which originated in 2021. Their main objective is to assess the efficacy of DMS during the epidemic. The occurrence of the keyword bursts was only observed after 2013, indicating that research conducted in 2013 and before did not include notably popular or transformative keywords or locations. In addition, when we assess these sudden surges in keyword popularity, a significant number of them are connected to the medical field in the domain of DMS. Therefore, researchers may want to concentrate their efforts on those specific fields for further investigations. Top 15 keywords with strong bursts. 3.5. Knowledge framework The analysis of DMS demonstrates that the evolution phenomenon of the area is complex, with diverse study orientations and focal points that change over time. These new research directions can either broaden or delve deeper into existing topics, resulting in dynamic shifts in research hotspots and directions. Prior research has conducted a comprehensive analysis, integration, and theoretical framework about DMS.[44,45] Nevertheless, they are unsuccessful in creating a structured system of knowledge, which hinders readers from easily and instinctively acquiring essential information. Hence, it is imperative to develop a novel, encompassing, and user-friendly theoretical framework for DMS research that offers a holistic understanding of this domain and directs forthcoming studies. Figure 12 illustrates a comprehensive theoretical framework for DMS research, which succinctly and clearly depicts the overall research connections, key stakeholders, and potential future paths. This framework serves as a great reference for future study. Theoretical knowledge framework. (1) Publication analysis provides insights about the popularity of a research topic, with the goal of persuading readers about the significance of continuing study and activity in that field. An analysis of fundamental publication statistics demonstrates a growing and fluctuating pattern in total publications, suggesting a promising future for the area. (2) Collaboration analysis examines the active partnerships between regions, institutions, and authors. We identified the key participants in these collaborations to assist researchers in finding potential partners and identifying suitable areas for collaborative research. Notably, the main cooperation institutional members include of La Trobe University, University of London, and Loughborough University. England, Australia, and the USA are the most dynamic regions for collaboration. Ilies Dorina Camelia, Caciora Tudor, and Hodor Nicolaie are identified as the most prolific collaborative authors. (3) Co-citation refers to the quantification of the frequency with which journals, authors, and references are co-cited. It identifies the individuals and sources that are most frequently referenced and considered significant in the field. The objective of co-citation is to help researchers enhance comprehension of the current state of DMS research and provide valuable insights for future studies. The authors that are frequently cited together include ANONYMOUS, WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION, and MICHIE S. The journals that are frequently cited together include PLOS ONE, J MED INTERNET RES, and BMJ-BRIT MED J. The key co-cited publications were written by Pizzo AD in 2018, Funk DC in 2018, and Doyle JP in 2022. The co-cited authors and sources in question cover a wide range of subjects, including eco-labels, sports digitalization, and information deficiency. Keyword co-occurrence analysis uncovers the prominent topics and trends within a research field. It identifies the central themes during specific time periods and potential shifts, with the goal of predicting the future evolution of the field, identifying potential research directions, and highlighting future hot topics. The main subjects covered in this field are management, social media, and physical activity. Some recent important topics that have been discussed are “efficacy,” “validation,” and the “covid-19 pandemic in the DMS process.” These topics offer vital insights for future researchers. 4. Discussion 4.1. Current challenges Based on the analysis provided, it can be concluded that DMS is an interdisciplinary field that encompasses a wide range of issues. This diversity of themes adds complexity to the definition of DMS and gives rise to new interdisciplinary challenges. The aforementioned analysis and framework indicate that current research faces the subsequent issues, which warrant the attention of researchers and practitioners. (1) The precise function of DMS goals remains ambiguous. Sport is commonly regarded as a means of maintaining and enhancing physical well-being. Some scholars argue that there is a connection between sport and digital management, although the latter is often seen as complex. Can digital management offer advantages to the field of sports? What are the ways in which it offers advantages? What are the specific responsibilities and ethical obligations of various stakeholders involved in the DMS process? These difficulties continue to provide challenges for the ongoing development of the DSM. (2) The method to attain DMS is yet unclear. Various intricate aspects significantly impact the effectiveness and efficiency of accomplishing DMS; these factors have varying effects on DMS. Furthermore, our understanding of the specific methods we can employ to accomplish DMS remains limited, except from the ones we have previously addressed (such as validation and efficacy programs). Moreover, the existing policies and remedies may not effectively enhance DMS, which is also a difficult task. (3) DMS exhibits unique traits in many situations, posing challenges to both research and practice. Are DMS activities implemented in impoverished areas, for example? Will citizens and villagers have a comparable perception of the benefits of DMS? Can universal theories be applied in all scenarios? Do smaller institutions get the same level of success in implementing Document Management Systems (DMS)? Various scenarios present challenges for future study in DMS. 4.2. Comparison discussions We conducted a comparative analysis of our study with previous literature reviews on DMS and identified several disparities. This comparative discussion enhances understanding of the field, highlighting the originality and contribution of this research.[46] (1) This research uses extensive visual clusters to convey data and demonstrate the interconnections across many literary works, offering researchers a lucid and intuitive comprehension of the essential knowledge foundation in the field. These clusters are generated through quantitative analysis. Additionally, we present detailed information regarding the clusters and the dynamics of keywords, allowing researchers to closely investigate specific developments in the DMS research area over different time periods and to identify emerging trends within this domain. In contrast to prior studies that often rely on subjective textual summaries or comparisons – which can cause personal bias and excessive detail – some literature reviews in this area tend to list key works and compare the results manually.[47,48] While these reviews offer valuable insights, they can be challenging to comprehend due to their reliance on textual descriptions and may overlook crucial aspects of this field. (2) This research constructs a comprehensive framework by performing an in-depth analysis that encompasses co-citation, collaboration, co-occurrence analysis, and publication data. This approach guarantees a coherent logical structure across key facets of DMS research, facilitating a better understanding of critical insights in the field. In contrast, some studies convey their findings through tables or textual explanations,[48,49] which may not be as effective in capturing the core elements of the research. Furthermore, several works propose frameworks derived from their analytical outcomes,[50,51] supporting the validity of the framework applied in this research. While these frameworks differ in their specific focuses, ours stands out for its broader scope. This methodology is set to be a significant reference for future research. (3) This study examines present obstacles and prospective research avenues, offering significant insights for academics to comprehend modern issues and feasible remedies through cluster analysis and the existing knowledge framework. Its objective is to encourage further exploration in this field. However, prior research has identified challenges and future research opportunities, though these studies tend to focus on niche aspects and do not offer a complete overview of the future of “DMS.” Furthermore, as these studies were published nearly 5 years ago, their relevance for guiding current research may be limited. 5. Conclusion and limitations Using CiteSpace software, we performed a bibliometric analysis of literature from the SCOPUS and WoS database. Our analysis includes publication trends over the past decade, co-citation networks, collaboration patterns, and keyword co-occurrence. During this period, we observed significant growth in DMS, largely driven by advancements in digital technologies. The following key findings were identified: (1) The analysis of yearly publications reveals a consistent and compound growth in the quantity of publications in DMS since 2018. This indicates that the academic communities in various disciplines are showing a growing interest in this topic. (2) The analysis of the collaboration network reveals that institutions in AUSTRALIA engage in cooperation more often in this sector. Additionally, various regions may commence cooperation in different areas of study. Nevertheless, there is currently limited international collaboration among writers, indicating the need to promote greater participation and cooperation in study endeavors. (3) Analysis of the co-citation network indicates that the author with the greatest number of co-citations has the greatest influence. Additionally, journals that receive a high number of citations typically have a large number of publications. Moreover, the most often cited sources cover a broad spectrum of topics. Consequently, we recommend that scholars consult these highly cited references to enhance their knowledge base and invigorate their study endeavors. (4) This study of the co-occurrence network of keywords reveals that the primary areas of research are management, social media, physical activity, and the creation of influence. It is expected that future research will mostly concentrate on examining the effectiveness and validation of these areas. In order to make important contributions in the discipline, researchers must possess a thorough understanding of the implications associated with these keywords. This study is innovative in the following manner. From a knowledge standpoint, we thoroughly examine and assess the research advancements of DMS using the views of cooperation, co-occurrence and co-citation. These perspectives offer a comprehensive, integrated and multidimensional approach to provide readers with ample information to comprehend the dynamics of the subject. In theory, we establish a novel knowledge framework for this topic, which helps to enhance the comprehension of the logical structure and progress of DMS study in a more vivid, clear, and efficient manner. In practical terms, we determine the characteristics of future research, which helps academics discover study interests that are more suitable and allows them to continue their research more successfully and efficiently. There are certain limitations to this study. Given the evolving nature of scientific study, the findings are time-sensitive and may pave the way for future discoveries. However, we relied on SCOPUS and WoS database for our data. It is important to recognize that authors in certain regions may favor publishing in other indexes and archives, potentially leading to regional bias. Furthermore, we focused exclusively on English, Spanish, and Chinese language papers, as they are widely used in academic circles. Nonetheless, research published in other different languages is also valuable, and excluding English, Spanish and Chinese language papers may result in an incomplete analysis of some aspects. We plan to conduct a further bibliometric analysis of recent publications, incorporating new discoveries. This study will include articles published after November 2023. Additionally, we aim to expand our analysis by incorporating more databases, such as EBSCO and CNKI, to enhance the representativeness of our findings. We will also include research published in languages other than English, Spanish, and Chinese, such as Portuguese and German, to broaden our understanding of DMS research. Furthermore, we may study differences in research development across studies published in different languages. Acknowledgments We are grateful to the Web of Science Core Collection, which includes Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI), Arts & Humanities Citation Index (A&HCI), Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI) and Science Citation Index Expanded (SCI-EXPANDED), and SCOPUS database, and all participants in our study. Author contributions Conceptualization: Gang Xu, Hongli Yu. Data curation: Gang Xu, Qian Yang. Formal analysis: Gang Xu, Qian Yang, Hongli Yu . Funding acquisition: Gang Xu. Investigation: Qiang Li. Methodology: Gang Xu, Qiang Li. Software: Gang Xu, Hongli Yu. Supplementary Material