Knowledge, attitudes and practice questionnaires in dengue, Zika, chikungunya and yellow fever settings: a scoping review protocol Authors: Claudia Ximena Robayo Gonzalez, Bouchra Nasri, Daniel Szaroz, Kate Zinszer Published: 2024 ABSTRACT Abstract AbstractIntroductionArboviruses are a broad classification of viral pathogens that require vectors such as mosquitoes for infection transmission. The burden of arboviral diseases worldwide is substantial, affecting millions of people annually, with the Aedes aegypti mosquito responsible for spreading several common arboviruses, including dengue, chikungunya, Zika and yellow fever. One public health strategy to control and prevent these viruses is to influence community members’ behaviours related to reducing the breeding sites of Aedes mosquitoes, and knowledge, attitudes and practice (KAP) questionnaires are often used as part of these education campaigns.ObjectivesTo explore the content of KAP questionnaires and methodologies used to evaluate arboviral infections, focusing on dengue, Zika, chikungunya and yellow fever.Methods and analysisTo identify and describe KAP questionnaires for the selected arboviral infections, a scoping review will be performed and reported according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Scoping Review Extension guidelines. Scientific databases such as MEDLINE, Cochrane, EMBASE, Web of Science, Scielo and LILACS will be searched systematically. Two independent reviewers will screen the title and abstract, followed by a full-text review of the selected articles using the COVIDENCE platform. The extracted information will include citation details, the type of arbovirus, the type of questions in each domain, the scoring system, the theoretical framework and the statistical analysis. The results will be presented comprehensively in tables and figures.Ethics and disseminationEthics approval is not required. Knowledge transfer will be conducted through conference presentations and publications.Keywords: Surveys and Questionnaires, Knowledge, Public health, Epidemiology, Attitude, Behaviour STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS OF THIS STUDY This review will examine the content, statistical analysis and theoretical frameworks used in knowledge, attitudes and practice (KAP) arbovirus studies. This review will examine the content, statistical analysis and theoretical frameworks used in knowledge, attitudes and practice (KAP) arbovirus studies. The inclusion of three languages and seven databases will provide a diverse selection of articles. The inclusion of three languages and seven databases will provide a diverse selection of articles. This scoping review explores studies using KAP in arboviral endemic locations worldwide. This scoping review explores studies using KAP in arboviral endemic locations worldwide. The review’s main limitation is the exclusion of grey literature, such as public health programmes that have used KAP questionnaires. The review’s main limitation is the exclusion of grey literature, such as public health programmes that have used KAP questionnaires. Introduction Arboviruses are arthropodborne viruses that transmit infections, including dengue, yellow fever, Zika and chikungunya.1 These viruses are a major public health concern due to the increasing magnitude of arbovirus infections worldwide and the health consequences of infection.1,4 Their transmission is influenced by many factors, including migration, climate change and unplanned urbanisation1 2 that provide breeding sites for the vectors in high-risk areas.1 3 Dengue, Zika, chikungunya and yellow fever share the same vector and, therefore, the same control vector strategies for Aedes mosquitoes.4 The symptoms of infection can be similar among the four viruses, sharing symptoms such as fever, headache, joint pain, nausea, vomiting, rash and swollen glands.5 However, dengue can vary from asymptomatic to severe illness, and the severe form of dengue can be haemorrhagic, causing plasma leakage and organ failure with a fatality rate of 5%.5,7 With chikungunya infections, the primary symptom is joint pain, with chronic symptoms compromising neurological, cardiovascular and renal systems.8 For the Zika infection, the risk of congenital complications during pregnancy is estimated between 5% and 15%9 and can result in Guillian-Barré syndrome among those infected.10 Yellow fever also has a severe form that can be haemorrhagic and can lead to kidney and liver failure, which has a high fatality rate ranging between 30% and 60%.11 One public health strategy to control and prevent arbovirus infections is to influence community members’ behaviours related to reducing the breeding sites of Aedes mosquitoes.12 13 This can be achieved through involving community efforts to remove stagnant water, removing objects that collect stagnant water (eg, trash, discarded tires) and promoting environmental sanitation.14 To effectively engage and motivate community members, it is necessary to understand their attitudes towards these kinds of initiatives, their perception of social pressure related to practising or not practising certain behaviours (subjective norm), and their ability to carry out these actions (perceived behavioural control).15,17 This concept is known as the ‘Theory of Planned Behaviour framework’ and proposes how positive or negative experiences, social pressure and perceived control influence behaviour engagement.15 It considers the individual’s previous knowledge of the topic, the subjective norms’ influence over attitudes, and the individual’s perceived ability or confidence to engage in the practices.15,17 The use of knowledge, attitudes and practice (KAP) questionnaires is a way in which different elements of the theory of planned behaviour can be captured regarding a particular community intervention.17,19 KAP questionnaires are among the most common ways to evaluate behaviour change. The KAP model was developed in the 1950s to address difficulties in implementing family planning programmes in Africa.1820,22 KAP questionnaires have been used worldwide to study vectorborne diseases regarding knowledge about the disease, attitudes towards control and preventive practices.23,28 A typical objective of a KAP questionnaire is to evaluate what is known (knowledge), what the opinions (attitude) are, and what is done (practice) regarding a specific health problem in a community.22 29 Historically, studies often focused on evaluating a community’s knowledge of public health concepts related to public health programmes.20 Today, knowledge is used to examine information about a disease (and modes of transmission if it is an infectious disease) and related symptoms; attitudes refer to a person’s general feelings towards the disease and the different efforts or interventions that can be used to prevent and control the disease,29 30 and practice questions are considered preventive behaviours, if the individual or household is currently practising certain prevention efforts.16 Together, this information can be used to inform public health education campaigns,28 31 32 which requires an analysis of the KAP questionnaire data. Importantly, there is wide variation in how the ‘KAP’ outcome is created, including the scoring system of the different questions within each domain and between domains as well as the approaches used to create a KAP index.24,2632 33 Often, recommendations are not followed.20 29 30 34 In implementing and using KAP questionnaires, the analysis of the results does not always consider the recommendations regarding the scoring approach, how to consider relations between domains29 30 and the use of a behavioural theory to guide the approach.17,1935 36 In terms of arboviruses and KAP studies, two systematic reviews have evaluated different KAP questionnaire-based studies in the context of dengue in the Philippines and Malaysia, respectively.37 38 Additionally, there are four registered protocols for systematic reviews on KAP related to arboviruses. One protocol includes 15 arboviruses classified as mosquitoborne emerging infectious diseases that are global in scope.39 It will examine whether a health behaviour theory was used, whether it was used in specific parts of the questionnaire (development, analysis or discussion), and whether findings were contextualised to the setting.39 The second protocol considers dengue and KAP questionnaires based on studies conducted in Southeast Asia.40 The third protocol focuses on dengue in Latin American KAP questionnaire-based cross-sectional studies. It aims to describe the results of each domain and their relations to key determinant factors in the Latin American context.41 The last protocol, which focused on West Nile Virus, aims to conduct a comprehensive descriptive analysis of the general population’s knowledge level, attitudes towards the disease and prevention measures and protective behaviours.42 In addition to the differences noted above, none of the systematic reviews focuses or will focus on describing the scoring methods used in the individual KAP studies, with only one review considering the use of health behaviour theory in the included studies. Furthermore, all the reviews are based on articles written only in English and are restricted to certain regions of the world, with the exception of one review. Given the broad use of KAP questionnaires and the variability of arboviral infections over time and between contexts,29 43 44 a comprehensive approach is essential to gain insights into the content and use of these questionnaires in different temporal and contextual settings. By consolidating and analysing the information in the literature, this scoping review aims to describe the current state of KAP-based studies, evolving trends and emerging needs in KAP assessment methodologies. Objectives This scoping review aims to explore the content of KAP questionnaires and methodologies used to evaluate arboviral studies focusing on dengue, Zika, chikungunya and yellow fever. The specific objectives are as follows: Provide a comprehensive description of the content in KAP questionnaires used in health research. Provide a comprehensive description of the content in KAP questionnaires used in health research. Analyse the various methodologies employed in assessing KAP, including indices, separate indicators for each domain and other relevant methods. Analyse the various methodologies employed in assessing KAP, including indices, separate indicators for each domain and other relevant methods. Identify the analysis used to evaluate the relationship between the domains. Identify the analysis used to evaluate the relationship between the domains. Examine and describe the construction of KAP scores and how these scores were used in analysing the results. Examine and describe the construction of KAP scores and how these scores were used in analysing the results. Evaluate the incorporation and use of theoretical frameworks to guide the design and/or analysis of the KAP questionnaire. Evaluate the incorporation and use of theoretical frameworks to guide the design and/or analysis of the KAP questionnaire. Methods and analysis The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) Scoping Review Extension guidelines checklist will be followed.45 The search equations will be adapted to librarian recommendations. The protocol is registered in the Open Science Framework (osf.io) and accessed at https://osf.io/cvw4q. The scoping review follows the methodology developed by Arksey and O’Malley,46 which comprises five stages: (1) defining the research questions, (2) identifying relevant studies, (3) selecting eligible studies, (4) organising the data and (5) summarising, combining and reporting the results. Procedures such as the literature search, data extraction and synthesis of the findings are planned between November 2024 and 2025. Stage 1: identifying the research questions Given the nature of the KAP questionnaires and the different domains that must be considered in the questionnaire and the analysis, a main question and four additional questions will help guide the data extraction. These are as follows: How are the domains in KAP questionnaires on the selected arboviruses developed and organised? What methods were used to analyse the data captured by the KAP questionnaires? What methods were used to analyse the data captured by the KAP questionnaires? How were the relations between the domains studied? How were the relations between the domains studied? What scoring approach to KAP was used, if any? What scoring approach to KAP was used, if any? Was there any use of a theoretical framework for behavioural change in constructing the questionnaire and/or guiding the analysis? Was there any use of a theoretical framework for behavioural change in constructing the questionnaire and/or guiding the analysis? Stage 2: identifying relevant studies From 1980 until today, the number of scientific publications regarding these four arboviruses has increased steadily. In 1990, only 75 publications involving the Caribbean region were related to dengue; in 2020, that number increased to 1053.47 As for chikungunya and Zika-related publications, an increase was reported after 2014 and 2016, respectively.47 Thus, the search will include studies from 2000 to the present, accounting for the increase in publications on the four arboviruses along the time frame (2000–2024) and the increase in KAP studies published after this year. The terms and strategies that will be used are presented in table 1. The search strategy will be applied to databases such as Cochrane, Medline, Web of Science, EMBASE and SCOPUS using key terms selected from MEDLINE Medical Subject Headings (MeSH). For Scielo and LILACS, the Descriptores en Ciencias de la Salud or DeCS will be used. Both will be combined with Boolean and proximity operators (online supplemental material 1). Table 1Concepts and MeSH/DeCS termsEnglishSpanishKnowledge, attitudes and practiceKnowledge, attitudes and practiceKnowledge, attitudes, practice and behaviourKAP surveysKAPKAPB surveysKAP questionnaireHealth knowledge attitudes practiceKnowledge*Attitude to healthPublic health practice*health behaviour*Conocimientos, actitudes y practicas.Conocimientos, Actitudes y Práctica en SaludCAPConocimientos, Actitudes y Práctica SanitariasConocimientos, Actitudes y Prácticas en SaludEncuestas CAPEncuestas de conocimientos, actitudes y prácticasConocimientos en saludPrácticas en saludActitud hacia la prevenciónArbovirusArbovirusDengue infectionDENV serotypeDengueSevere dengueZika virus infectionZika infectionYellow feverYellow fever infectionChikungunya infectionChikungunya feverarthropodborne virusbreak bone feverClassical dengueClassical dengue feverClassical dengue feversClassical denguesArbovirusInfecciones por ArbovirusArbovirusDengueDengue GraveVirus del dengueVirus ZikaInfección por el zika virusFiebre amarillaVirus de la fiebre amarillaVirus ChikunguñaFiebre ChikunguñaVirus Transmitido por ArtrópodosVirus Transmitidos por Artrópodos*Not MeSH terms added to the search equation.CAPconocimientos, actitudes y practicasKAPknowledge, attitudes and practiceKAPBknowledge, attitudes, practice and behaviour Concepts and MeSH/DeCS terms Knowledge, attitudes and practice Knowledge, attitudes and practice Knowledge, attitudes, practice and behaviour Knowledge, attitudes, practice and behaviour KAP surveys KAP surveys KAP KAP KAPB surveys KAPB surveys KAP questionnaire KAP questionnaire Health knowledge attitudes practice Health knowledge attitudes practice Knowledge* Knowledge* Attitude to health Attitude to health Public health practice* Public health practice* health behaviour* health behaviour* Conocimientos, Actitudes y Práctica en Salud Conocimientos, Actitudes y Práctica en Salud CAP CAP Conocimientos, Actitudes y Práctica Sanitarias Conocimientos, Actitudes y Práctica Sanitarias Conocimientos, Actitudes y Prácticas en Salud Conocimientos, Actitudes y Prácticas en Salud Encuestas CAP Encuestas CAP Encuestas de conocimientos, actitudes y prácticas Encuestas de conocimientos, actitudes y prácticas Conocimientos en salud Conocimientos en salud Prácticas en salud Prácticas en salud Actitud hacia la prevención Actitud hacia la prevención Arbovirus Arbovirus Dengue infection Dengue infection DENV serotype DENV serotype Dengue Dengue Severe dengue Severe dengue Zika virus infection Zika virus infection Zika infection Zika infection Yellow fever Yellow fever Yellow fever infection Yellow fever infection Chikungunya infection Chikungunya infection Chikungunya fever Chikungunya fever arthropodborne virus arthropodborne virus break bone fever break bone fever Classical dengue Classical dengue Classical dengue fever Classical dengue fever Classical dengue fevers Classical dengue fevers Classical dengues Classical dengues Infecciones por Arbovirus Infecciones por Arbovirus Arbovirus Arbovirus Dengue Dengue Dengue Grave Dengue Grave Virus del dengue Virus del dengue Virus Zika Virus Zika Infección por el zika virus Infección por el zika virus Fiebre amarilla Fiebre amarilla Virus de la fiebre amarilla Virus de la fiebre amarilla Virus Chikunguña Virus Chikunguña Fiebre Chikunguña Fiebre Chikunguña Virus Transmitido por Artrópodos Virus Transmitido por Artrópodos Virus Transmitidos por Artrópodos Virus Transmitidos por Artrópodos Not MeSH terms added to the search equation. CAPconocimientos, actitudes y practicasKAPknowledge, attitudes and practiceKAPBknowledge, attitudes, practice and behaviour The inclusion criteria are studies that used KAP questionnaires to collect data on selected arboviruses such as dengue, Zika, chikungunya and yellow fever. The studies must be written in English, French or Spanish, from endemic locations according to WHO and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).9 48 49 We will exclude commentaries, editorials, media reviews, opinion pieces, as well as questionnaires implemented solely on healthcare workers, students and other professionals. Additionally, articles focusing solely on developing and validating questionnaires, those lacking the complete questionnaire, or not evaluating all three domains will be excluded. Furthermore, we will not consider systematic reviews, meta-analyses or grey literature. Refer to table 2 for more details on the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Table 2Inclusion and exclusion criteria.Inclusion criteriaExclusion criteriaPopulationThe general population or communities in locations that are endemic to the selected arbovirusesNon-endemic locations for the selected arbovirus infectionsHealthcare workers, higher academic institutions, military personnel, construction workers, agricultural workers, prisons and nursing homesConceptResults and analysis of the implementation of KAP or KAPB questionnairesArticles providing the complete questionnaireArticles presenting the KAP/KAPB questionnaire development or validation process and not the results of administering the questionnaire on a selected populationArticles evaluating and analysing one or two of the three domains and not all three domainsArticles where the questionnaire is not availableContextArboviruses that are transmitted by Aedes mosquitoes. (dengue, Zika, chikungunya, yellow fever)Arboviruses including West Nile Fever, Japanese Encephalitis, Powassan virus, California encephalitis, Eastern Equine Encephalomyelitis, St. Louis Encephalitis and Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis VirusSourcesJournal articles, peer-reviewed, original researchFull-text articlesBooks, book chapters, editorials, erratum, opinion pieces, conference abstracts, dissertations, systematic reviews, meta-syntheses and analyses, and commentariesFocusRandomised trials, observational studies (cross-sectional, case-control, cohort)Grey literaturePublic health programmes that used KAP/KAPBLanguageEnglish, French, SpanishOther languagesYear2000–2024Before 2000KAPknowledge, attitudes and practiceKAPBknowledge, attitudes, practice and behaviour Inclusion and exclusion criteria. KAPknowledge, attitudes and practiceKAPBknowledge, attitudes, practice and behaviour Stage 3: selecting eligible studies The results from the different databases will be uploaded to COVIDENCE.50 After removing duplicates, two independent reviewers, PhD students (CXRG and DS), will evaluate the articles. In the first stage of the review, article titles and abstracts will be assessed based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria. In the second stage, the included papers will be evaluated by two reviewers. The inclusion of articles for the extraction phase will be based on consensus. Their inter-rater reliability will be qualitatively evaluated at this phase. Disagreements will be resolved through discussion, and a third senior reviewer (KZ) will be involved in case of persistence. The reasons for exclusion in this phase will be recorded for each study. A PRISMA flow chart will be presented to summarise the inclusion and exclusion of articles (figure 1). Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews flow diagram for study selection.55 Stage 4: charting the data Data will be extracted using a pilot-tested form. These data include the author of the study, the year of publication, the study objectives, the targeted study population, the geographical location, the specific type of arbovirus being analysed, the various KAP questions categorised by domain, the type of questions used for each domain (such as multiple options, Likert scale, true or false), a thorough description of the scoring system employed, whether or not a theoretical framework was used for the analysis, the results obtained, the statistical analysis conducted and the conclusions drawn from the study regarding the associations/correlations between among the domains (table 3). The Cochrane RoB 251 will be used for randomised controlled trials, and the Newcastle-Ottawa scale will be used to evaluate the quality of observational studies.52 Two reviewers will extract data independently. Table 3Preliminary data extraction formElementDescriptionTitleThe title of the articlesAuthorList the author(s)YearYear of publicationAims/purposeObjective of the studyResearch designRCT, cohort, cross-sectional, etcRegionAccording to the WHO regions, Americas, Asia and AfricaCountryCountry in which the study was conductedPopulationCommunity members, mothers, fathers, caretakers, adolescentsType of arbovirusDengue, Zika, chikunguya and yellow feverNumber of questions in the questionnaireThe number of questions in the questionnaire, including sociodemographicsNumber of questions in KnowledgeThe number of questionsNumber of questions in attitudesThe number of questionsNumber of questions in practice/behaviourThe number of questionsType of questions in knowledgeMultiple options, Likert scale, true or falseType of questions in attitudesMultiple options, Likert scale, true or falseType of questions in practice/behaviourMultiple options, Likert scale, true or falseScoring systemYes or noScoring system by domain or totalBy domain, total or bothDescription of the scoring systemDescription of the use or construction of a scoring systemUse of theoretical framework in the development of the questionnaireYes or noUse of theoretical framework in the analysisYes or noTheoretical framework usedName of the frameworkEvaluation of the relation between domainsYes or noType of analysis used to evaluate the relation between domainsName of the analysisKAP statistical analysis conductedName of the analysisPrincipal results from the statistical analysisPresent the measure and the analysis made by the authorsRCTrandomised controlled trial Preliminary data extraction form RCTrandomised controlled trial Stage 5: collating, summarising and reporting the results The collected data will undergo a rigorous analysis process consistent with established guidelines for the development and analysis of KAP questionnaires.20 53 54 This analysis will comprehensively examine the data, including categorising key findings of the relations between the domains and assessing methodological approaches employed across studies. Descriptive statistical analysis will be employed to summarise the characteristics of the identified literature. The results will be presented clearly and concisely using tables, figures and narrative descriptions to illustrate the breadth and depth of the literature. Additionally, a discussion will provide contextual explanations and elucidate the implications of the findings within the broader field of arbovirus infections and public health. Throughout this process, similarities and differences in the content of the different KAP questionnaires and less explored areas in the questionnaires will be identified. Moreover, identifying the methodologies employed for developing the scoring systems and the overall assessment of the KAP will show how to create these scores, the complexity they have, and the strengths and weaknesses to be improved in future studies. Regarding the relationship between the domains, the results will present evidence on how these relationships have been evaluated, highlighting the novel analytical methods employed. Finally, identifying a theoretical behavioural framework in the analyses will provide insight into one of the most widely used, the impact on the final analysis, and how these theoretical frameworks contribute to understanding KAP dynamics. The scoping review seeks to thoroughly examine and summarise the existing research on KAP questionnaires in the context of arbovirus infections. The review aims to provide in-depth insights into this area of study and to offer valuable recommendations for the future use, development and analysis of KAP questionnaires. Patient and public involvement There was no involvement of patients or the public in the protocol’s design. Ethics and dissemination This review does not require ethical approval as it involves the secondary analysis of existing data from publicly available sources. The findings will be disseminated through publication in appropriate peer-reviewed journals and presentations at relevant conferences. Limitations Conducting a scoping review is challenging, particularly when assessing KAP questionnaires. One of the major challenges is the variability in the questionnaires and the different approaches used in the analyses, including the scoring system. Another limitation is the inclusion of only studies with available questionnaires for scoping review, leaving out some articles that could have other inclusion criteria. Additionally, language restrictions may limit the availability of articles from regions where certain diseases or health conditions are endemic, making it difficult to obtain a comprehensive overview. supplementary material Acknowledgements The authors thank Simon-Pierre Crevier for assisting with the search strategy. Footnotes Funding: This research was conducted as part of the Sustainable Healthy Cities: a cluster randomised trial for Aedes control, funded by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research through the Project Grant program (grant #400444). KZ is supported as a Research Scholar Junior 2 from the Fonds de Recherche du Québec. BN is supported as a Research Scholar Junior 1 in Artificial intelligence in health and digital health from the Fonds de Recherche du Québec. Prepublication history and additional supplemental material for this paper are available online. To view these files, please visit the journal online (https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2024-090251). Provenance and peer review: Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed. Patient consent for publication: Not applicable. Patient and public involvement: Patients and/or the public were not involved in the design, or conduct, or reporting, or dissemination plans of this research. Contributor Information Claudia Ximena Robayo Gonzalez, Email: claudia.ximena.robayo.gonzalez@umontreal.ca. Bouchra Nasri, Email: bouchra.nasri@umontreal.ca. Daniel Szaroz, Email: daniel.szaroz@umontreal.ca. Kate Zinszer, Email: kate.zinszer@umontreal.ca. References Supplementary Materials