Single-cell transcriptomics of vomeronasal neuroepithelium reveals a differential endoplasmic reticulum environment amongst neuronal subtypes Authors: GVS Devakinandan, Mark Terasaki, Adish Dani, Stephen D Liberles, GVS Devakinandan, Mark Terasaki, Adish Dani Published: 2024 ABSTRACT Specialized chemosensory signals elicit innate social behaviors in individuals of several vertebrate species, a process that is mediated via the accessory olfactory system (AOS). The AOS comprising the peripheral sensory vomeronasal organ has evolved elaborate molecular and cellular mechanisms to detect chemo signals. To gain insight into the cell types, developmental gene expression patterns, and functional differences amongst neurons, we performed single-cell transcriptomics of the mouse vomeronasal sensory epithelium. Our analysis reveals diverse cell types with gene expression patterns specific to each, which we made available as a searchable web resource accessed from https://www.scvnoexplorer.com. Pseudo-time developmental analysis indicates that neurons originating from common progenitors diverge in their gene expression during maturation with transient and persistent transcription factor expression at critical branch points. Comparative analysis across two of the major neuronal subtypes that express divergent GPCR families and the G-protein subunits Gnai2 or Gnao1, reveals significantly higher expression of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) associated genes within Gnao1 neurons. In addition, differences in ER content and prevalence of cubic membrane ER ultrastructure revealed by electron microscopy, indicate fundamental differences in ER function. Introduction The Vomeronasal organ (VNO), part of the vertebrate accessory olfactory system, is a major pheromone-sensing organ, that is thought to be specialized to evoke innate social behaviors in mammals. The rodent VNO neuroepithelium consists of two major neuronal subtypes, that are defined primarily based on the expression of two distinct families of G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) and their associated G protein alpha subunit: vomeronasal type-I GPCRs (V1R) with G⍺i2 subunit (Gnai2) neurons or vomeronasal type-2 GPCRs (V2R) with G⍺o subunit (Gnao1) neurons. V1R and V2R expressing neurons are spatially segregated within the neuroepithelium, and project to distinct locations in the accessory olfactory bulb along the anterior-posterior axis. Functional evidence suggests that V1R and V2R neurons may recognize ligands that mediate different behaviors (Chamero et al., 2011; Oboti et al., 2014; Trouillet et al., 2019; Pallé et al., 2020). However, we currently lack a comprehensive mapping of receptor-ligand interactions and how these lead to distinct behaviors. Cognate ligand binding in both Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons, is thought to signal via the phospholipase-c pathway which results in the activation of the VNO-specific cation channel, Trpc2 (Liman et al., 1999; Stowers et al., 2002; Zufall, 2005). In the main olfactory epithelium (MOE), neurons regenerate throughout life, continuously differentiating from a stem cell population into neurons and supporting cell types (Fletcher et al., 2017). Neuronal differentiation is also associated with the expression of a single GPCR to the exclusion of many others (Hanchate et al., 2015; Tan et al., 2015), leading to the hallmark feature termed as ‘one neuron one receptor (ONOR)’ rule (Malnic et al., 1999; Serizawa et al., 2000; Serizawa et al., 2003). VNO sensory neurons (VSNs) also continuously regenerate (Barber and Raisman, 1978; Wilson and Raisman, 1980) from a stem cell population, and differentiating cells take on the identity of supporting cells and mature neurons of either the Gnao1 or Gnai2 sub-types (Katreddi et al., 2022). While Gnai2 neurons seem to largely follow the ONOR rule in expressing one V1R gene per neuron (Serizawa et al., 2004), Gnao1 neurons seemingly deviate from this rule by co-expressing a combination of GPCRs. Thus, each Gnao1 neuron expresses a single V2R gene from the ABD family as well as a member of the C family V2R genes (Martini et al., 2001; Silvotti et al., 2007; Ishii and Mombaerts, 2011). In addition, further molecular diversification of Gnao1 neurons occurs due to combinatorial co-expression of a family of non-classical Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) genes, H2-Mv, that are co-expressed along with V2Rs (Ishii et al., 2003; Loconto et al., 2003, Ishii and Mombaerts, 2008). A few combinations of V2R and H2-Mv expression have been identified, indicating that these co-expression patterns are non-random and could be functionally important (Martini et al., 2001; Ishii et al., 2003; Loconto et al., 2003; Silvotti et al., 2007; Ishii and Mombaerts, 2008; Ishii and Mombaerts, 2011). However, identifying the precise combinatorial expressions of V2R-ABD, V2R-C and H2-Mv has been elusive, partly due to the challenges in generating RNA or antibody reagents to identify closely homologous genes, combined with the challenges with multiplexing more than three targets. Starting with a common progenitor population, how do cells of the VNO sensory epithelium diversify in their gene expression patterns that define the sensory neuron types? Recent studies using single-cell transcriptomic analysis have implicated Notch signaling along with downstream transcription factors, Tfap2e, Bcl11b to play a role in specifying the fates of developing VSNs (Enomoto et al., 2011; Katreddi et al., 2022; Lin et al., 2022). As the progenitor cells differentiate to mature neurons, transcriptional reprogramming downstream to Notch signaling leads to distinct neuronal populations: Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons. While these studies identified transcription factors, it is not clear whether the two major differentiated VSN subtypes expressing Gnao1-V2Rs or Gnai2-V1Rs fundamentally differ in their cellular properties. Here, we applied a multilevel transcriptomics approach which bundles single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA seq) validated by low-level spatial transcriptomics to characterize gene expression of the mouse VNO sensory epithelium. Our results identified genes specifically expressed in sensory, and non-sensory cell types and the divergence of gene expression between Gnao1 - Gnai2 neurons at different maturation stages. Analysis of mature neurons provided a comprehensive picture of specific co-expression patterns of VR and H2-Mv genes. Surprisingly, mature Gnao1 neurons revealed a significant enrichment of endoplasmic reticulum-related gene transcripts and proteins, which is indicative of a fundamental divergence in cellular function between these cell types. Electron microscopy further revealed a hypertrophic ER ultrastructure consisting of gyroid cubic membrane morphology, more prevalent in Gnao1 neurons. Results Single-cell transcriptome of mouse vomeronasal neuroepithelium We standardized VNO neuroepithelium dissociation to obtain a single-cell suspension along with optimizing cell viability. We performed single-cell droplet-based capture coupled with scRNA seq, using the 10 X genomics platform on four biological replicates consisting of male and female animals. Initial quality control steps were performed (see methods) to remove cells with high or low total RNA content and red blood cell contamination, resulting in the retention of 9185 cells from all samples for further analysis. Since our comparison of gene expression obtained from male versus female mice, did not reveal appreciable differences other than known sexually dimorphic genes that include Eif2s3y, Ddx3y, Uty, and Kdm5d (Figure 1—figure supplement 1), we pooled cells from both sexes for further analysis. To group cells based on their gene expression profiles, we performed dimensionality reduction and unsupervised clustering, which resulted in 18 distinct clusters (Figure 1A), with gene expression markers specific to each cluster (Figure 1B). Major markers for each cluster were identified by differential expression analysis and the cell type identity was assigned to each cluster based on known markers for each cell type. Amongst 9185 cells, we observed that 63.7 percent (5852 cells) were neuronal cell types at different developmental stages which includes progenitor cells (Cluster 5; defined by expression of Ascl1, Neurod1, Neurog1), immature neurons (Cluster12; expression of Gap43), Gnao1 neurons (Cluster 14; based on expression of Gnao1, V2Rs), and Gnai2 neurons (Cluster 7, 16; characterized by Gnai2, V1Rs expression) (Figure 1C). The remaining 36.3 percent of cells were classified to be of non-neuronal types which include sustentacular cells (Cluster 15; defined by Cyp2a5, Ppic), cells from non-sensory epithelium (Cluster 11; defined by Ly6d, Krt5), cells from glandular tissue (Cluster 13; characterized by Obp2a, Lcn3), immune cells which include macrophages (Cluster 8, 6, 10; defined by C1qa, C1qb, H2-Aa), T cells (Cluster 9; defined by Cd3d, Cd3g), neutrophils (Cluster 2; defined by s100a8, s100a9), olfactory ensheathing cells (Cluster 3; defined by Gfap, Plp1, Sox10), endothelial cells (cluster 1 and 17; defined by Gng11, Egfl7, Eng), fibroblasts (Cluster 4; defined by Igfbp4, Dcn, Lum) and solitary chemosensory cells (Cluster 18; defined by Trpm5, Gnat3). A complete list of the top 20 differentially expressed genes associated with each cluster and proportion of cells are provided in Supplementary file 1 and Supplementary file 2. Single-cell RNA sequencing of the mouse vomeronasal neuroepithelium. (A) Uniform Manifold Approximation and Projection (UMAP) of 9185 cells from vomeronasal neuroepithelium with 18 identified clusters. Each point represents a cell that is color-coded according to the cell type. Clusters were assigned a cell type identity based on previously known markers. Percentage of total cells corresponding to each cluster is in Supplementary file 2. (B) Dot plot showing the expression of the top 10 gene markers for each cluster identified by differential expression analysis. Gene expression markers shared across multiple clusters are listed only once. The dot radius and dot color indicate the percentage of cells expressing the gene and scaled expression value in that cluster, respectively. Top 20 gene markers for each cluster with log2 fold change are listed in Supplementary file 1. (C) Feature plot showing the expression level of major known gene markers of neuronal and sustentacular cell types. Figure 1—figure supplement 1 shows UMAP clusters and gene expression comparison between males and females. Figure 1—figure supplement 1.Comparison of cell type composition and gene expression from the male and female vomeronasal neuroepithelium.(A) Uniform Manifold Approximation Projection (UMAP) of cells from male and female vomeronasal neuroepithelium, with the cluster numbers corresponding to Figure 1A and B. Solitary chemosensory neurons (Cluster 18) were seen only in female data. (B) Scatter plots comparing the average expression of genes across each cluster from male and female with Pearson correlation coefficient at the top of the plot. Each point in the plot represents a gene. Known sexually dimorphic genes: Eif2s3y, Ddx3y, Uty, and Kdm5d are marked in red. Scatter plot of cluster 17 between male and female is not shown due to low cell count. Differential gene expression between each cluster of males and females organized in a cluster-wise manner is shown in Figure 1—figure supplement 1—source data 1. Figure 1—figure supplement 1—source data 1.Average log2 fold change gene expression between male and female along with the fraction of cells expressing the gene in male or female cluster.The comparison of each cluster is separated in sheets. Comparison of cell type composition and gene expression from the male and female vomeronasal neuroepithelium. (A) Uniform Manifold Approximation Projection (UMAP) of cells from male and female vomeronasal neuroepithelium, with the cluster numbers corresponding to Figure 1A and B. Solitary chemosensory neurons (Cluster 18) were seen only in female data. (B) Scatter plots comparing the average expression of genes across each cluster from male and female with Pearson correlation coefficient at the top of the plot. Each point in the plot represents a gene. Known sexually dimorphic genes: Eif2s3y, Ddx3y, Uty, and Kdm5d are marked in red. Scatter plot of cluster 17 between male and female is not shown due to low cell count. Differential gene expression between each cluster of males and females organized in a cluster-wise manner is shown in Figure 1—figure supplement 1—source data 1. Figure 1—figure supplement 1—source data 1.Average log2 fold change gene expression between male and female along with the fraction of cells expressing the gene in male or female cluster.The comparison of each cluster is separated in sheets. Average log2 fold change gene expression between male and female along with the fraction of cells expressing the gene in male or female cluster. The comparison of each cluster is separated in sheets. We performed RNA in situ hybridization (RNA-ISH) on VNO sections to confirm the spatial classification of various non-sensory cell type clusters based on some of the genes identified in our study (Figure 2A). Thus, we confirmed Ppic to be expressed in sustentacular cells and Ly6d in cells of non-sensory epithelium bordering the VNO lumen. Since, Cbr2 - a known marker of sustentacular cells is also expressed in the non-sensory epithelium (Figure 1C), Ppic and Ly6d are better markers to distinguish them. Obp2a was confirmed to be expressed in cells from glandular tissue on the non-sensory side. Plp1 and Mgp, markers of olfactory ensheathing glial cells and endothelial cells/fibroblasts, respectively, were observed to be expressed in cells located at the periphery of the neuro-epithelium. Macrophage cell markers C1qb and H2-Aa were observed to be specifically expressed in scattered cells throughout the neuroepithelium, with H2-Aa co-expression also seen in sustentacular cells (Figure 2A), confirming the presence of these cell types within the neuroepithelium. Gene markers of non-sensory cells in the vomeronasal organ identified from single-cell RNA sequencing. (A) Uniform Manifold Approximation and Projection (UMAP) feature plot (top) of a single representative gene marker for non-sensory cell clusters and their spatial gene expression pattern by RNA in situ hybridization on Vomeronasal organ (VNO) coronal sections (bottom, scale bar: 100 µm). (B, C) Three clusters of macrophage-like cell types represented by UMAP projection (B) and a dot plot (C) showing differentially expressed genes between these clusters. The dot radius indicates the percentage of cells expressing a gene, whose scaled expression level is represented by the intensity of color as per the scale. Additional markers of each non-sensory cell type are in Supplementary file 1 and differential expression between macrophage clusters is in Supplementary file 3. Since our study identified multiple immune cell clusters, we examined these in some detail. Three clusters (Figure 1A, clusters 6, 8, 10 termed as Mac1, Mac2, Mac3, respectively) comprised of macrophage-like cells based on the expression of C1qa, C1qb, C1qc, and MHC class II gene - H2-Aa (Figure 2B and C). Further analysis indicates that cluster 10 (Mac3) expresses classical microglial markers such as Tmem119, Aif1 (Iba1), P2ry12, Cx3cr1, Trem2, along with chemokine genes - Ccl3, Ccl4, and Ccl7 and Interleukins – Il1a, Il1b (Figure 2C), indicating an activated macrophage subset. Cluster 8 (Mac2) is similar to Mac3 in regard to expression of classical tissue-resident macrophage marker - Adgre1 (F4/80), C1qa, C1qb, C1qc but lacks expression of chemokine and interleukin genes mentioned earlier. In comparison to Mac3 and Mac2, the Mac 1 cluster is distinguished by the lack of C1qa, C1qb, Cd68, Adgre1(F4/80), and microglial markers but possesses high levels of Napsa, Lsp1, H2-Aa (Figure 2C, Supplementary file 1 and Supplementary file 3). In summary, the identification of discrete macrophage cell types from our data, along with experimental validation of their presence using some of the expression markers, points to the possibility of tissue-resident or tissue-infiltrating macrophages within the VNO neuroepithelium. These VNO macrophage types could have functional implications toward influencing processes such as neuronal differentiation or responses to tissue repair and injury. On the other hand, we did not observe evidence via RNA-ISH for T-cell markers (Cd3d, Cd3g), raising the possibility that these immune cell types may have co-purified from blood. Lastly, we were able to identify via RNA-ISH, the expression of Trpm5 (Figure 2A) and Gnat3 genes from our dataset, that mark solitary chemosensory cells expressing taste receptors and related markers (Ogura et al., 2010; Supplementary file 1), indicating that rare cell-populations were captured, and their markers identified in our study. Neuronal cell types and transient gene expression in developing neurons Our next step was to perform in-depth analysis of vomeronasal sensory neurons. In order to obtain a better resolution on neuronal sub-types, We pooled cells from clusters representing neuronal types identified in Figure 1 (clusters 5, 7, 12, 14, 16), created a new Seurat object, and performed re-clustering. This resulted in 13 clusters (labeled n1-n13), which potentially represent distinct neuronal sub-populations within the broadly defined Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons (Figure 3—figure supplement 1A). Since neurogenesis is a continuous process in VNO neurons (Barber and Raisman, 1978; Wilson and Raisman, 1980), these clusters also represent a snapshot of cells at different developmental states, identified by known markers: Globose basal cells (Cluster n5; Ascl1), progenitor cells (Cluster n5; defined by expression of Neurod1, Neurog1), immature neurons (Cluster n6, n7; defined by Gap43) expressing Gnao1 or Gnai2 (Figure 3—figure supplement 1B). Among Gap43 negative mature neurons, Gnao1 neurons are clusters n1-n4, (Figure 3—figure supplement 1A, B, corresponding to cluster 14 in Figure 1A), where sub-cluster identity is clearly defined by their co-expression of H2-Mv and Vmn2r GPCRs (discussed in detail in the co-expression section below). In contrast, six clusters (n8-n13) correspond to mature Gnai2 neurons (clusters 7, 16 from Figure 1A), of which n8-n11 do not have any definite gene markers and differ based on differences in the expression level of a few genes (Figure 3—figure supplement 1C, Supplementary file 4). Neurons of sub-cluster n12 (cluster 7 from Figure 1A) exclusively express genes Tmbim1, Lgi2, Cleg2g, and n13 are distinguished by the expression of previously identified activity-dependent genes - Rasgrp4, Pcdh10, and S100a5 (Fischl et al., 2014; Figure 3—figure supplement 1C, Supplementary file 4). To our knowledge, unlike mature Gnao1 neurons, mature Gnai2 subclusters n8-n11 and n13, do not have an obvious principal parameter for their subclassification. Expression of cognate V1R or V2R GPCRs is one of the hallmarks of VSN differentiation. We asked the question, to what extent do VRs influence neuronal sub clustering. Exclusion of VRs from clustering parameters did not affect the divergence of mature neurons into Gnai2 /Gnao1 and only selectively affected some of the subclusters (Figure 3—figure supplement 2), thus indicating that neuronal subtype identity was governed by gene expression differences beyond vomeronasal GPCRs. Since immature neurons are separated into two clusters expressing Gnao1 or Gnai2, these imply a possible branch point in the developmental trajectory towards mature neurons. To confirm this, we performed pseudo-time analysis on neurons using Slingshot, and progenitor neurons (cluster n5) as a start/anchor point. For the purpose of developmental analysis, we merged subclusters within mature Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons. The trajectory of development confirms a split of immature Gap43 +neurons into Gnao1 or Gnai2 cell clusters (Figure 3A). We performed differential expression analysis between immature neurons (cluster n6: Gap43+, Gnao1 + vs cluster n7: Gap43+, Gnai2+) (Figure 3B). To identify potential transcription factors in this developmental branch point, we manually curated genes that have molecular features associated with DNA binding domains or transcription regulation based on literature (Figure 3C). To our surprise, we found multiple genes that are known transcription regulators but are not previously reported to be enriched in Gnao1 neurons. These include Creb5, Prrxl1, Shisa8, Lmo4, and Foxo1. Creb5, Prrxl1 are transcription factors expressed only in immature Gnao1 neurons whereas Shisa8, Lmo4, and Foxo1 expression is enriched in immature Gnao1 neurons compared to mature ones (Figure 3C). Prrxl1 was reported to auto-repress its expression which explains how its expression is limited to immature Gnao1 neurons (Monteiro et al., 2014). These data indicate that the developmental transition of VNO neurons to Gnao1 lineage may involve the transient expression of transcription factors within immature neurons after dichotomy is established. Gene expression dynamics during development of sensory neurons. (A) Uniform Manifold Approximation and Projection (UMAP) of neuronal cells with clusters (n1-n13 from Figure 3—figure supplement 1) represented in different colors. Sub-clusters within mature Gnai2, and Gnao1 neurons are merged. The line on the UMAP plot shows the pseudotime developmental trajectory of neurons. (B) Volcano pot of differential gene expression between immature Gnai2 (cluster n6; Gap43+, Gnai2+) vs immature Gnao1 (cluster n7; Gap43+, Gnao1+) neurons. Genes that satisfy |log2 fold change normalized expression|>1 (green) and -log10 p-value >6 (blue) are considered significant and colored in red. Non-significant (NS) genes are colored in gray. Arrows point to transcription regulators enriched in Gnao1 + immature neurons. Complete list of differentially expressed genes is in Figure 3—source data 1. (C) Feature plots showing the normalized expression levels of previously known markers for immature neurons (Gap43), Gnao1 neurons (Tfap2e), Gnai2 neurons (Meis2), and transcription factor or related genes: Creb5, Prrxl1, Shisa8, Lmo4, Foxo1. Arrows highlight the limited expression of Creb5 and Prrxl1 to immature neurons, but are absent from mature indicating transient expression during the development of Gnao1 neurons. Subclusters within Gnao1, Gnai2 neurons and the effect of VRs on sub-clustering are in Figure 3—figure supplements 1 and 2 respectively. Figure 3—source data 1.Differentially expressed genes between immature Gnao1 and immature Gnai2 neurons.Genes that satisfy the criteria |log2 foldchange|>1 and adjusted p-value <10–6 are saved in a separate sheet. Differentially expressed genes between immature Gnao1 and immature Gnai2 neurons. Genes that satisfy the criteria |log2 foldchange|>1 and adjusted p-value <10–6 are saved in a separate sheet. Figure 3—figure supplement 1.Neuronal cell types of vomeronasal sensory epithelium.(A) Uniform Manifold Approximation and Projection (UMAP) projection of neurons with 13 clusters (n1–n13). (B) Feature plot showing expression of neuronal markers associated with various stages of differentiation: Globose basal cells (n5; Ascl1), progenitor cells (n5; Neurod1, Neurog1), immature neurons (n6, n7; Gap43+), mature Gnao1 neurons (n1-n4; Gap43-, Omp+, Gnao1+) and mature Gnai2 neurons (n8-n13; Gap43-, Gnai2+, Omp+). Arrows highlight the expression of Gnao1 and Gnai2 in Gap43+immature neurons (n6, n7). (C) Dot plot showing enriched genes in each cluster compared to all other clusters obtained by differential expression analysis. Size of the dot represents the percentage of cells expressing the gene in that cluster and the color indicates the scaled expression value. Top five gene markers based on log2fold change from each cluster were chosen by filtering the genes whose adjusted p-value is less than 0.005, expression in at atleast 50% of cells, and less than 50% of cells of all other clusters. No markers were found for cluster n9 with this filtering criteria. Complete list of the top 30 markers for neuronal clusters is in Supplementary file 4. Neuronal cell types of vomeronasal sensory epithelium. (A) Uniform Manifold Approximation and Projection (UMAP) projection of neurons with 13 clusters (n1–n13). (B) Feature plot showing expression of neuronal markers associated with various stages of differentiation: Globose basal cells (n5; Ascl1), progenitor cells (n5; Neurod1, Neurog1), immature neurons (n6, n7; Gap43+), mature Gnao1 neurons (n1-n4; Gap43-, Omp+, Gnao1+) and mature Gnai2 neurons (n8-n13; Gap43-, Gnai2+, Omp+). Arrows highlight the expression of Gnao1 and Gnai2 in Gap43+immature neurons (n6, n7). (C) Dot plot showing enriched genes in each cluster compared to all other clusters obtained by differential expression analysis. Size of the dot represents the percentage of cells expressing the gene in that cluster and the color indicates the scaled expression value. Top five gene markers based on log2fold change from each cluster were chosen by filtering the genes whose adjusted p-value is less than 0.005, expression in at atleast 50% of cells, and less than 50% of cells of all other clusters. No markers were found for cluster n9 with this filtering criteria. Complete list of the top 30 markers for neuronal clusters is in Supplementary file 4. Figure 3—figure supplement 2.Effect of VR genes on neuronal clustering.(A) Clustering of neurons based on the top 2000 variable geneset in the dataset leading to 13 clusters (same as Figure 3—figure supplement 1A). (B) Reclustering performed after excluding genes coding vomeronasal receptors from the variable geneset without changing any other parameters. The bifurcation of Gnao1, Gnai2 neurons at mature and immature stages remains unchanged. The only changes are the merger of mature Gnao1 sub-clusters n1/n3 and the change in mature Gnai2 n8 composition. Effect of VR genes on neuronal clustering. (A) Clustering of neurons based on the top 2000 variable geneset in the dataset leading to 13 clusters (same as Figure 3—figure supplement 1A). (B) Reclustering performed after excluding genes coding vomeronasal receptors from the variable geneset without changing any other parameters. The bifurcation of Gnao1, Gnai2 neurons at mature and immature stages remains unchanged. The only changes are the merger of mature Gnao1 sub-clusters n1/n3 and the change in mature Gnai2 n8 composition. Co-expression of vomeronasal receptors One of the features that differentiate vomeronasal sensory neurons from main olfactory sensory neurons is their systematic deviation from the ‘one neuron one receptor rule,’ especially in mature Gnao1 neurons. V2R receptors have been classified into families-A, B, D, E, and a distinct family-C that is phylogenetically closer to calcium-sensing receptors (Young and Trask, 2007). Several studies have established a broad pattern of co-expression amongst these V2R family members, such as members of family ABDE co-express with family-C GPCRs and components of family-C (Vmn2r1 -also termed -C1, Vmn2r2-Vmn2r7 -termed C2) in turn co-express with each other in specific combinations (Martini et al., 2001; Silvotti et al., 2007). Furthermore, H2-Mv genes within Gnao1 neurons also exhibit non-random co-expression patterns with the V2R GPCRs. (Ishii et al., 2003; Loconto et al., 2003; Silvotti et al., 2007; Silvotti et al., 2011; Ishii and Mombaerts, 2008; Ishii and Mombaerts, 2011). To further investigate these co-expression patterns and subpopulations within Gnao1 neurons, we took a closer look at clusters n1-n4 comprised of mature Gnao1 neurons (Figure 3—figure supplement 1A). These four clusters (Figure 4A) are found to be organized majorly based on the expression of family-C V2Rs and H2-Mv genes, especially Vmn2r1 or Vmn2r2 (Figure 4B–E). Of the four clusters, cluster n1 and cluster n4 express Vmn2r1 (Figure 4B and E) whereas cluster n3 neurons are distinguished by the co-expression of Vmn2r2 along with other family-C members (Vmn2r3, Vmn2r4, Vmn2r5, Vmn2r6, Vmn2r7) (Figure 4C and E). Cluster n2 is a mixture of either Vmn2r1 or Vmn2r2 expressing neurons (Figure 4E), with Vmn2r2 being similarly co-expressed along with other family-C members in those cells. We observed that among family-ABDE members, A1-A6 V2Rs are highly expressed in cluster n2, n3 which co-express Vmn2r2 whereas A8-A10, B, D, and E family V2Rs are mainly expressed along with Vmn2r1 in cluster n1 neurons (Figure 4E). These observations of family biased expression of ABDE with Vmn2r1 or Vmn2r2 agrees with earlier studies (Silvotti et al., 2007; Silvotti et al., 2011) that have used antibody or RNA probe based approaches. Subpopulation of Gnao1 neurons defined by vomeronasal type-2 GPCR (V2R) and H2-Mv expression. (A) Uniform Manifold Approximation and Projection (UMAP) representation of Gnao1 neurons from Figure 3. Each dot represents a cell and four Gnao1 neuron clusters (n1–n4) are marked in different colors. (B–D) Feature plot showing exclusive expression of Vmn2r1 (B), Vmn2r2 (C), and the most abundant H2-Mv gene, H2-M10.3 (D) in Gnao1 neurons. (E) Heat map showing the expression of V2R and H2-Mv genes in Gnao1 neurons. Cluster numbers are marked on the top with color coding as in (A) and gene families are labeled on the left. Each column represents a cell and the scaled gene expression in each row is color coded as per the scale with red and blue indicating high and low expression, respectively. Vmn2r1 is expressed in almost all cells of cluster-1 and cluster-4; Vmn2r2 is expressed in all cells of Cluster 3; Cluster2 has mutually exclusive expression of Vmn2r1 and Vmn2r2. (F–H) Bar plot showing a number of cells expressing: 0–7 family-C vomeronasal type-2 GPCRs (V2Rs) per cell (F), 0–5 family-ABD V2Rs per cell (G), 0–6 H2-Mv genes per cell (H) with composition of cells associated with family C1 (orange) or C2 (blue) V2R color coded on the bar. (I) Box plots comparing the sum of normalized expression levels of family-C V2Rs and Gnao1 (Green) in a cell that expresses 1–5 family-C V2Rs. (J) Box plot comparing the level of total ABD-V2R expression from cells with 1 and 2 ABD-VRs along with Gnao1 expression level (green). (K) Box plot comparing the level of total H2-Mv expression in cells that express 1–5 H2-Mv genes along with Gnao1 expression level (Green). Multiple combinations of family-C, family ABD V2Rs, and H2-Mvs identified to be co-expressed in a single-cell and their cell frequency are listed in Supplementary file 5. Figure 4—figure supplement 1.Frequency and distribution of vomeronasal type-2 GPCR (V2R) and H2-Mv genes.Bar plot showing the number of cells expressing top 20 vomeronasal type-I GPCRs (V1Rs) (A), vomeronasal type-2 GPCRs (V2Rs) (B), and H2-Mvs (C). Normalized gene expression values were extracted for all V1Rs (D) from Gnai2 neurons, V2Rs (E), and H2-Mvs (F) from Gnao1 neurons and density was plotted to identify the distribution of gene expression. The red dashed line represents a normalized gene expression value that was used as the threshold to call the expression of respective genes. Frequency and distribution of vomeronasal type-2 GPCR (V2R) and H2-Mv genes. Bar plot showing the number of cells expressing top 20 vomeronasal type-I GPCRs (V1Rs) (A), vomeronasal type-2 GPCRs (V2Rs) (B), and H2-Mvs (C). Normalized gene expression values were extracted for all V1Rs (D) from Gnai2 neurons, V2Rs (E), and H2-Mvs (F) from Gnao1 neurons and density was plotted to identify the distribution of gene expression. The red dashed line represents a normalized gene expression value that was used as the threshold to call the expression of respective genes. Figure 4—figure supplement 2.Characteristics of H2-Mv expression.(A, B) Feature plot showing the expression H2-M10 family genes (A) and limited expression of phylogenetically divergent H2-Mv members H2-M1, H2-M9, and H2-M11 (B) in Gnao1 neurons. (C) Feature plot showing the expression of Vmn2r81 and Vmn2r82 in a few cells of clusters 2 and 4 of Gnao1 neurons that express H2-M1, M9, and M11. (D) Scatter plot showing the normalized expression level per cell of rarely expressed H2-Mv genes (H2– M1, M9, and M11) on the x-axis and Vmn2r1 or Vmn2r2 on the y-axis indicating that H2-M1, M9 and M11 co-express with Vmn2r1, unlike other H2-Mv genes. (E) Two-color RNA in situ hybridization of H2-M1, H2-M9, and H2-M11 with Vmn2r81/82 confirming the co-expression. The in situ hybridization (ISH) probe was common for Vmn2r81 and 82; H2-M1/M9/M11 indicates pooling of individual probes. Scale bar: 100 μm. Characteristics of H2-Mv expression. (A, B) Feature plot showing the expression H2-M10 family genes (A) and limited expression of phylogenetically divergent H2-Mv members H2-M1, H2-M9, and H2-M11 (B) in Gnao1 neurons. (C) Feature plot showing the expression of Vmn2r81 and Vmn2r82 in a few cells of clusters 2 and 4 of Gnao1 neurons that express H2-M1, M9, and M11. (D) Scatter plot showing the normalized expression level per cell of rarely expressed H2-Mv genes (H2– M1, M9, and M11) on the x-axis and Vmn2r1 or Vmn2r2 on the y-axis indicating that H2-M1, M9 and M11 co-express with Vmn2r1, unlike other H2-Mv genes. (E) Two-color RNA in situ hybridization of H2-M1, H2-M9, and H2-M11 with Vmn2r81/82 confirming the co-expression. The in situ hybridization (ISH) probe was common for Vmn2r81 and 82; H2-M1/M9/M11 indicates pooling of individual probes. Scale bar: 100 μm. Figure 4—figure supplement 3.Co-expression characteristics of vomeronasal type-2 GPCR (V2R) and H2-Mv genes using data from Hills et al., 2024.(A–C) Bar plot showing the number of cells expressing: 0–7 family-C V2Rs per cell (A), 0–5 family-ABD V2Rs per cell (B), 0–6 H2-Mv genes per cell (C) with composition of cells associated with family C1 (orange) or C2 (blue) V2R color coded on the bar. The trend of co-expression is similar to Figure 7F, G and H indicating that co-expression counts are similar across datasets. Co-expression characteristics of vomeronasal type-2 GPCR (V2R) and H2-Mv genes using data from Hills et al., 2024. (A–C) Bar plot showing the number of cells expressing: 0–7 family-C V2Rs per cell (A), 0–5 family-ABD V2Rs per cell (B), 0–6 H2-Mv genes per cell (C) with composition of cells associated with family C1 (orange) or C2 (blue) V2R color coded on the bar. The trend of co-expression is similar to Figure 7F, G and H indicating that co-expression counts are similar across datasets. Figure 4—figure supplement 4.Co-expression of vomeronasal type-I GPCRs (V1Rs) in Gnai2 neurons.(A) Heatmap showing the expression of selected V1Rs in Gnai2 neurons. Each column represents a cell, and the scaled expression value of each VR is colorcoded in each row with red and blue indicating high and low expression, respectively. A continuous red line in two rows of a single column indicates the expression of two receptors in a single-cell. (B) Bar plot showing the number of cells expressing 0–3 V1Rs per cell indicating the vomeronasal type-I GPCR (V1R) co-expression is limited to a small subset of cells. (C) Box plot comparing total V1R and Gnai2 (green) expression from cells shown in (B). Combinations of V1Rs co-expressed in a single-cell and their cell frequency are listed in Supplementary file 6. Co-expression of vomeronasal type-I GPCRs (V1Rs) in Gnai2 neurons. (A) Heatmap showing the expression of selected V1Rs in Gnai2 neurons. Each column represents a cell, and the scaled expression value of each VR is colorcoded in each row with red and blue indicating high and low expression, respectively. A continuous red line in two rows of a single column indicates the expression of two receptors in a single-cell. (B) Bar plot showing the number of cells expressing 0–3 V1Rs per cell indicating the vomeronasal type-I GPCR (V1R) co-expression is limited to a small subset of cells. (C) Box plot comparing total V1R and Gnai2 (green) expression from cells shown in (B). Combinations of V1Rs co-expressed in a single-cell and their cell frequency are listed in Supplementary file 6. Furthermore, we observed that expression of H2-Mv genes (H2-M10.1, H2-M10.2, H2-M10.3, H2-M10.4, H2-M10.5, H2-M10.6) is largely confined to clusters n2 and n3, where they are co-expressed selectively in Vmn2r2 positive neurons and mostly absent from Vmn2r1 expressing cluster n1, n2 neurons (Figure 4D and E, Figure 4—figure supplement 2A). These observations align with prior reports from antibody or RNA probe-based experiments, that demonstrated a sub-division amongst Gnao1 neurons based on their expression of family-C Vmn2rs and co-expression of H2-Mv genes with the Vmn2r2 subset (Silvotti et al., 2007). We then asked whether, at the single neuron level, we could identify trends in co-expression patterns between ABD-family V2Rs and H2-Mv genes, or between members of the ABD family themselves. We performed co-expression analysis to identify specific VR and H2-Mv combinations by setting an expression threshold from normalized counts. The distribution of normalized expression for VRs and H2-Mvs across cells was bimodal, with the first peak near zero and a second peak likely corresponding to true expression (Figure 4—figure supplement 1D–F). We set the starting of the second peak as a threshold to call the expression of VRs or H2-Mvs in a single-cell. Thus, a VR or H2-Mv was considered as co-expressed in a cell only if its normalized expression value surpasses the set threshold based on the distribution (Figure 4—figure supplement 1E and F). The threshold was 1.25 for V2Rs (Figure 4—figure supplement 1E) and H2-Mv genes (Figure 4—figure supplement 1F). This analysis resulted in the identification of multiple co-expressing V2Rs and H2-Mv genes per cell. The chance that a combinatorial pattern identified can be due to a doublet is dependent on the frequency of expression of that gene. Therefore, for abundantly expressed family C V2Rs, it is possible some combinatorial patterns may be from doublets. But in the case of family ABD V2Rs, the probability of a particular combination falsely identified due to a doublet more than once is very low. Hence, we assigned a threshold for combinatorial co-expression patterns that are identified in two or more cells to be more reliable. These combinatorial expression patterns along with their observed frequency are listed in Supplementary file 5. Within the expression patterns represented by a frequency of more than two cells, we observed that family C1 V2R (Vmn2r1) is mostly expressed alone without any other family-C members (Figure 4F and E) as shown earlier (Silvotti et al., 2007). Surprisingly a few cells (31 neurons out of 1025 Gnao1 neurons) were observed to co-express Vmn2r1 along with Vmn2r7 (Supplementary file 5), contrary to earlier reports that Vmn2r1 does not co-express with family-C2 receptors. Most of Gnao1 neurons with family C2 V2Rs (Vmn2r2-Vmn2r7) co-express multiple members amongst them, ranging from 2 to 6 V2Rs per cell (Figure 4F and E). In the case of family-ABD V2R expression, we observed that most Gnao1 neurons follow the ‘one ABD-V2R, one neuron’ rule, except for a few that express two ABD-V2Rs (Figure 4G). Amongst cells that express more than two ABD-V2Rs, the combination of Vmn2r20 and Vmn2r22 stood out as the highest (44 cells), followed by Vmn2r39, Vmn2r43, and Vmn2r50 (10 cells, Supplementary file 5). It is worth noting that these ABD co-expressions in each cell are observed irrespective of whether that cell expresses family-C1 or C2 V2R (Figure 4G). Among Gnao1 neurons (n1-n4), 229 cells did not express family-C V2Rs (Figure 4F) and 46 cells did not express ABD-V2Rs (Figure 4G) as per our threshold. In the case of H2-Mv genes, each cell expresses 1–4 members mostly with famlily-C2 V2Rs (Figure 4H, C and D). Interestingly, in deviation from this, we observed a pattern whereby H2-M1, H2-M9, and H2-M11 genes that show sequence divergence from rest of the H2-Mv cluster (Ishii et al., 2003), are specifically expressed in cluster n4 and restricted cells amongst cluster n3, where they co-express with Vmn2r1 GPCR, rather than family-C2 V2Rs (Figure 4—figure supplement 2B and D). Overall, 56.9% of Gnao1 cells that express either C1-V2R or C2-V2R, did not express any H2-Mv genes (Figure 4H) as per our threshold, reinforcing earlier observations (Ishii and Mombaerts, 2008) that their functional role maybe restricted to a subset of V2R expressing neurons. Furthermore, these H2-M1, H2-M9, or H2-M11 expressing cells along with Vmn2r1, also co-express either Vmn2r81 or Vmn2r82 (V2rf) (Figure 4—figure supplement 2B and C) as identified before (Ishii et al., 2003). Two color RNA in situ hybridization with a common probe targeting Vmn2r81 and Vmn2r82 and separate probes for H2-M1, H2-M9, and H2-M11 shows that Vmn2r81/82 cells always colocalized with the selected H2-Mv probes (Figure 4—figure supplement 2E). We performed a similar co-expression analysis on scRNAseq data of p56 VNO from Hills et al., 2024 and observed that the overall co-expression pattern of V2Rs and H2-Mv genes in Gnao1 neurons matches with ours (Figure 4—figure supplement 3). This rules out the possibility of dataset-specific artifacts leading to spurious co-expression patterns. Altogether, these data validate the co-expression analysis methodology and identify novel combinatorial co-expression patterns of V2Rs and H2Mv genes. We next asked, whether the total GPCR or H2-Mv expression level is regulated or capped in a single-cell? To answer this question, we calculated the total family-C-V2R, ABD-V2R, and H2-Mv expression in a single-cell that either expresses one member or multiple members of each family (Figure 4I–K). The results showed that when cells express more than one V2R, total V2R expression of either family-C or family-ABD (Figure 4I and J) scales up proportional to a total number of expressed V2Rs of that family. This is also true in the case of multiple H2-Mv expression where total H2-Mv expression is proportional to the number of H2-Mv genes expressed in a cell (Figure 4K). As a control, and to eliminate the possibility of doublets, we see that the levels of Gnao1 do not change with a number of V2Rs or H2-Mv genes expressed in a cell (Figure 4I–K). Lastly, we performed a similar co-expression analysis for V1Rs with a threshold value of 2.5 (Figure 4—figure supplement 1D). In similarity to the pattern observed for ABD-V2Rs, most Gnai2 neurons expressed a single V1R per cell with some cells co-expressing two V1Rs (Figure 4—figure supplement 4B and A, Supplementary file 6). Some of these V1R combinations have been reported recently (Lee et al., 2019). Even in the case of Gnai2 neurons, total V1R expression in the cells that co-express two receptors is higher compared to cells that express one GPCR with Gnai2 levels being same (Figure 4—figure supplement 4C), indicating that these measurements are from singlet cells. Due to the stringent expression threshold, it is possible that VRs expressed at very low levels were not considered and thereby leading to neurons where zero VRs are detected (Figure 4—figure supplement 4B). However, these neurons express other genes like neuronal marker Gnai2 at same level as other neurons (Figure 4—figure supplement 4C) ruling out the possibility of them being debris. Collectively, these data reveal the patterns of GPCR, and H2-Mv co-expression in VNO neurons, which is likely to be instrumental in deciphering how these neurons respond to a single or combination of stimuli, as well as the cellular mechanisms that orchestrate these expression patterns. Divergent gene expression profile of mature Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons Since the exclusion of VR genes did not fundamentally alter the clustering and divergence into mature Gnai2 /Gnao1 neurons, we decided to investigate the gene expression differences between these neurons by performing differential gene expression analysis of mature Gnao1 (cluster 14 from Figure 1) and Gnai2 neurons (cluster 7, 16 from Figure 1) and identified 924 differentially expressed genes with at least log2 fold change of 1 and adjusted p-value <10e-6. Of these, 456 genes are enriched in Gnao1 neurons and 468 genes in Gnai2 neurons (Figure 5A). In agreement with previous studies, we see enrichment of V2Rs, H2-Mvs, and B2m (Ishii et al., 2003; Loconto et al., 2003), Robo2 (Prince et al., 2009), Tfap2e (Lin et al., 2018), Calr4 (Dey and Matsunami, 2011) in Gnao1 neurons and V1Rs, Meis2 (Chang and Parrilla, 2016) in Gnai2 neurons (Figure 5A). Along with such known genes, our analysis revealed new differentially expressed genes in the two neuronal subtypes. Divergent gene expression: Gnao1 vs Gnai2 neurons. (A) Volcano plot showing differentially expressed genes between mature Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons. Genes that satisfy |log2 fold change normalized expression|>2 (green) and -log10 p-value >6 (blue) are considered significant and colored in red. Non-significant (NS) genes are colored in gray. Complete list of differentially expressed genes is in Figure 5—source data 1. (C–D) Two color RNA in situ hybridization (ISH) of selected enriched genes marked in bold on the volcano plot. Gnao1, Gnai2, respective markers of basal and apical neurons are shown in (B). Genes enriched in Gnai2 neurons (C) or Gnao1 neurons (D) are co-localized with the respective markers. RNA-ISH for additional enriched genes is shown in Figure 5—figure supplement 1. Scale bar:100 µm. Figure 5—source data 1.Differentially expressed genes between mature Gnao1 and mature Gnai2 neurons.Genes that satisfy the criteria |log2 foldchange|>1 and adjusted p-value <10–6 are saved in a separate sheet. Differentially expressed genes between mature Gnao1 and mature Gnai2 neurons. Genes that satisfy the criteria |log2 foldchange|>1 and adjusted p-value <10–6 are saved in a separate sheet. Figure 5—figure supplement 1.Expression pattern of enriched genes in Gnai2 or Gnao1 neurons.Chromogenic RNA-in situ hybridization (ISH) showing expression of Gnai2 enriched genes: Nsg1, Rtp1, Dner, Qpct, Pcdh7, Prph (A) and Gnao1 enriched genes: Apmap, Selenof, Hspa5 (Bip), Itm2b, Agpat5, Sncg (B). Sncg and Prph are expressed in a scattered pattern amongst a few neurons. Scale bar: 100 μm. Expression pattern of enriched genes in Gnai2 or Gnao1 neurons. Chromogenic RNA-in situ hybridization (ISH) showing expression of Gnai2 enriched genes: Nsg1, Rtp1, Dner, Qpct, Pcdh7, Prph (A) and Gnao1 enriched genes: Apmap, Selenof, Hspa5 (Bip), Itm2b, Agpat5, Sncg (B). Sncg and Prph are expressed in a scattered pattern amongst a few neurons. Scale bar: 100 μm. To confirm differential gene expression amongst mature neurons, we performed two-color fluorescence RNA-ISH of the top candidates from Figure 5A, using Gnao1 or Gnai2 as co-labeling markers (Figure 5B, C and D). Among these genes, Nrp2 and Socs2 expression is restricted to Gnai2 neurons (Figure 5C); Tppp3 and Gm36028 expression is restricted to Gnao1 neurons (Figure 5D). Some of the enriched genes such as Ckb in Gnai2 and Krt18 in Gnao1 neurons, were also observed to be expressed in sustentacular cells (Figure 5C and D). Furthermore, from chromogenic RNA-ISH experiments, we observed genes such as Nsg1, Rtp1, Dner, Qpct, Pcdh7 to be either restricted to or highly expressed in Gnai2 neurons (Figure 5—figure supplement 1A) and others such as Apmap, Selenof, Hspa5, Itm2b, Agpat5 were observed to have a gradient of high to low-level expression from Gnao1 to Gnai2 zones (Figure 5—figure supplement 1B). Two genes: Sncg and Prph specifically expressed in scattered subsets of Gnao1 or Gnai2 neurons, respectively, (Figure 5—figure supplement 1A and B) indicating selective expression in a particular neuronal subpopulation. Gene ontology terms associated with the genes validated with RNA-ISH are in Supplementary file 7. These experiments validated that several of the candidate genes identified as differentially expressed from scRNA seq data, are highly specific and spatially localized to one of the neuronal sub-populations. Taken together our data indicate that VNO neurons that start from a common progenitor, go on to transiently express genes during immature stages that could decide their cell fate and these cells exhibit markedly different gene expression profiles in the mature stage. Differential ER environment in Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons Given that Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons express divergent GPCR families, we asked the question of whether the differentially expressed genes indicate fundamental differences in cellular or molecular processes between these two cell types. We performed gene ontology (GO) enrichment analysis on the two sets of genes. Interestingly, we observed that amongst the Gnao1 neuron genes, most of the enriched terms with p-value <0.05, are related to endoplasmic reticulum (ER) processes, which include ‘protein folding,’ ‘response to ER stress,’ and ‘ERAD pathway’ (Figure 6A). Conversely, a gene ontology analysis of Gnai2 neuron genes did not reveal any particular enrichment of GO terms in this neuronal subset. As more than 20% of the genes associated with protein folding (Figure 6A) are enriched in Gnao1 neurons, we sought to probe the spatial transcription pattern of some of the candidates. Fluorescence RNA in-situ hybridization confirmed the selective expression of ER genes such as Creld2, Dnajc3, Pdia6, and Sdf2l1 amongst Gnao1 neurons (Figure 6B). Enrichment of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) genes in Gnao1 neurons. (A) ER gene expression in Gnao1 neurons. Annotation of gene ontology (GO) biological processes of genes that are significantly enriched in Gnao1 neurons from Figure 5A. GO terms related to ER processes are marked in red. p-value <0.05 was used as a cut-off. (B) Vomeronasal organ (VNO) coronal section two-color fluorescent RNA-in situ hybridization (ISH) of selected Gnao1 enriched ER chaperone genes (Creld2, Pdia6, Dnajc3, Sdf2l1: green), co-labeled with Gnao1 probe (red) shows Gnao1 zone restricted expression of these genes. Scale bar 100 µm. To test whether these findings extend to the protein level, we performed immuno-fluorescence microscopy of VNO sections using antibodies specific to a collection of ER proteins. We first tried an antibody against SEKDEL, a common ER retention signal, which intensely labeled Gnao1 neurons (Figure 7A). This selective labeling was confirmed by co-labeling with anti-Gnao1 (Figure 7B and D), where an anti-SEKDEL ER signal is seen in Gnao1 neurons. We quantified enrichment of SEKDEL across multiple (26) VNO sections from three mice, labeled with anti-SEKDEL, anti-Gnao1, and anti-Omp as a control. Normalized fluorescence intensity quantified along the apical-basal axis (Figure 7D and E), shows that SEKDEL signal intensity increases along with Gnao1. Surprisingly, several other antibodies that detect ER chaperone proteins: Hspa5 (BiP), PDI, Grp94, Calnexin (Figure 7F, Figure 7—figure supplement 1A); as well as antibodies against ER membrane/structural proteins: Sec61β, Atlastin1, NogoB, Climp63, Reep5 (Goyal and Blackstone, 2013) show a similar enrichment in Gnao1 neurons, as seen from the immune-fluorescence images and their quantification with Gnao1 or SEKDEL antibodies (Figure 7G and H, Figure 7—figure supplement 1B). Some ER protein localizations (SEKDEL, Hspa5, PDI, Atlastin1, NogoB) were detected selectively amongst basal zone Gnao1 neurons, while others (Sec61β, Calnexin, Grp94, Reep5, Climp63) detected a pattern of Gnao1 neuron enrichment, with lower levels in Gnai2 neurons. To test whether higher levels of these ER proteins resulted from their increased transcription, we compared their RNA levels in Gnai2 /Gnao1 neurons from our scRNA dataset (Figure 7—figure supplement 2). In the case of Hspa5 (Bip), Hsp90b1 (Grp94), and Sec61b mRNA levels are higher in Gnao1 neurons (also see Hspa5 in Figure 5A, and RNA-ISH in Figure 5—figure supplement 1). On the other hand, RNA levels of Atlastin1, and PDI were comparable (Figure 7—figure supplement 2), indicating that Gnao1 neuron enrichment of some ER proteins could also arise due to post-transcriptional regulatory mechanisms. Differential localization of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) proteins in Vomeronasal organ (VNO) neurons. Pseudocolored immunofluorescence images of VNO coronal sections labeled with antibodies against KDEL (anti-SEKDEL), a common ER retention signal (A). The section is co-labeled with anti-Gnao1 to mark basal zone neurons (B) and anti-OMP to mark all mature neurons (C). Signal intensity of KDEL, Gnao1, and OMP channels are quantified from ROIs along the apical-basal axis as shown in example (D). Signal intensity measured from multiple sections (n>20 for each antibody) from three biological replicates was normalized and the trendline was fitted to show the Gnao1 neuron-enriched localization of anti-KDEL (E). Points on the plot show normalized intensity values color-coded for each antibody on which the trendline was fitted. Similar immuno-labeling and quantification of ER chaperone Hspa5 (BiP) (F), ER membrane translocon subunit Sec61β (G), and ER membrane protein Atlastin1 (H) indicate their enrichment in Gnao1 neurons compared to Gnai2 neurons. Distribution of additional ER chaperone and membrane proteins is shown in Figure 7—figure supplement 1 along with combined source data in Figure 7—source data 1. Scale bar: 50 µm. Figure 7—source data 1.Fluorescence intensity values of ROIs along an apical-basal axis from immunolabeled images of Vomeronasal organ (VNO) neuroepithelium. Fluorescence intensity values of ROIs along an apical-basal axis from immunolabeled images of Vomeronasal organ (VNO) neuroepithelium. Figure 7—figure supplement 1.Pseudocolored immunofluorescence images of Vomeronasal organ (VNO) coronal sections labeled with antibodies against endoplasmic reticulum (ER) proteins.(A) Chaperone proteins: PDI/Grp94/Calnexin, (B) ER structural proteins: NogoB/Climp64/Reep5. Higher intensity in Gnao1 neurons compared to Gnai2 neurons is seen from the images and quantified along the apical-basal axis by co-labeling sections with anti-OMP to mark all neurons and anti-Gnao1 (or anti-SEKDEL -see Figure 7A–E depending on antibody species), to mark Gnao1 neurons. Fluorescence intensity along the apical-basal axis is quantified from at least 20 sections from three biological replicates. The normalized fluorescence intensity of ER proteins increases along the apical-basal axis, similar to Gnao1 or SEKDEL, while the level of OMP either remains the same or slightly decreases. Scale bar: 50 µm. Pseudocolored immunofluorescence images of Vomeronasal organ (VNO) coronal sections labeled with antibodies against endoplasmic reticulum (ER) proteins. (A) Chaperone proteins: PDI/Grp94/Calnexin, (B) ER structural proteins: NogoB/Climp64/Reep5. Higher intensity in Gnao1 neurons compared to Gnai2 neurons is seen from the images and quantified along the apical-basal axis by co-labeling sections with anti-OMP to mark all neurons and anti-Gnao1 (or anti-SEKDEL -see Figure 7A–E depending on antibody species), to mark Gnao1 neurons. Fluorescence intensity along the apical-basal axis is quantified from at least 20 sections from three biological replicates. The normalized fluorescence intensity of ER proteins increases along the apical-basal axis, similar to Gnao1 or SEKDEL, while the level of OMP either remains the same or slightly decreases. Scale bar: 50 µm. Figure 7—figure supplement 2.Comparison of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) gene expression between Gnai2, Gnao1 neurons.Violin plots showing the gene expression levels in mature Gnao1 or Gnai2 neurons whose protein levels are shown via immunofluorescence in Figure 7 and Figure 7—figure supplement 1. Log2 fold change value for Gnao1 vs Gnai2 calculated from pseudobulk differential gene expression analysis is mentioned on top of the line and the Bonferroni-adjusted p-value is mentioned below the line (ns - not significant). RNA levels of Hspa5, Calnexin, Hsp90b1, Sec61b, and Reep5 are significantly upregulated in Gnao1 neurons while PDI and Atlastin1 do not differ significantly between Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons. Comparison of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) gene expression between Gnai2, Gnao1 neurons. Violin plots showing the gene expression levels in mature Gnao1 or Gnai2 neurons whose protein levels are shown via immunofluorescence in Figure 7 and Figure 7—figure supplement 1. Log2 fold change value for Gnao1 vs Gnai2 calculated from pseudobulk differential gene expression analysis is mentioned on top of the line and the Bonferroni-adjusted p-value is mentioned below the line (ns - not significant). RNA levels of Hspa5, Calnexin, Hsp90b1, Sec61b, and Reep5 are significantly upregulated in Gnao1 neurons while PDI and Atlastin1 do not differ significantly between Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons. Many of the Gnao1 enriched ER genes and their protein products are chaperones, while others are ER structural proteins. The upregulation of both types of ER proteins prompted us to examine the cells by electron microscopy. Serial sections (70 nm thick) of ~1 mm square regions of the VNO were collected on tape and were imaged by scanning electron microscopy (Baena et al., 2019). Since the sections contained the entire VNO, we were able to distinguish Gnai2 from Gnao1 cells by their location as they are spatially segregated into apical or basal zones, respectively, within the neuroepithelium (Figure 8A). In Gnao1 cells, more than half of the cytoplasm contained dense smooth ER with cubic membrane morphology (Almsherqi et al., 2006; Almsherqi et al., 2009), also known as organized smooth ER (OSER) (Snapp et al., 2003; Figure 8A and B, Figure 8—figure supplement 1). In the remainder of the cytoplasm, there were closely apposed parallel sheets of ER membrane that were contiguous with lamellar ER surrounding the nucleus (Figure 8—figure supplement 1). The apical/Gnai2 neuronal cell bodies are smaller than those of Gnao1 cell bodies. They also appeared to have cubic ER membranes, but these seemed denser and occupied a smaller fraction of cytoplasmic volume (Figure 8A and C). Basal/Gnao1 neurons are densely packed with cubic membrane endoplasmic reticulum (ER). (A) Scanning electron micrographs of the vomeronasal sensory epithelium at low magnification showing cell bodies of VNO sensory neurons (VSNs), sustentacular cells, and basal lamina. Boxed regions in red or green mark cell bodies of basal/Gnao1 or apical/Gnai2 neurons, respectively, that are displayed at higher magnification below. Nucleus (N) appears light and ER is dark. Cell bodies of basal/Gnao1 neurons are larger and occupied by a substantial amount of ER, in comparison to apical/Gnai2 neurons. (B, B’) Magnified micrographs show the cell body of a basal/Gnao1 neuron, packed with cubic ER membranes. White arrows point to dense membrane stacks that are better resolved in Figure 8—figure supplement 1. Red arrow points to the lamellar ER membrane that is contiguous with the cubic membrane. (C, C’) Cell bodies of apical/Gnai2 neurons also seem to show dense cubic membrane ER, that is smaller in comparison to basal/Gnao1 neurons. Figure 8—figure supplement 1.Cubic membrane endoplasmic reticulum (ER) in Gnao1 neurons.Scanning electron micrographs showing cell bodies of basal/Gnao1 neurons with sinusoidal ER membranes interspersed with stacked membranes (arrows). Cubic membrane endoplasmic reticulum (ER) in Gnao1 neurons. Scanning electron micrographs showing cell bodies of basal/Gnao1 neurons with sinusoidal ER membranes interspersed with stacked membranes (arrows). Taken together, our data indicates that mature Gnao1 neurons differ substantially from Gnai2 neurons in selectively upregulating the transcription of several ER genes. Furthermore, this neuronal subset also exhibits higher levels of ER proteins, via transcriptional and post-transcriptional mechanisms, as well as a hypertrophic smooth ER that is arranged in the form of an organized cubic membrane ultrastructure. Collectively, these observations indicate a specialized ER environment that could play a significant functional role in the Gnao1 subset of VNO neurons. Discussion The vomeronasal organ has been a model of considerable interest for molecular sensory biology, to study the diversification of sensory neurons, uniquely evolved gene families, and their patterns of expression, all of which are essential to understand how specific social chemo-signals elicit innate behaviors. In this study, using single-cell and low-level spatial transcriptomics, we developed a comprehensive resource identifying cell types of the VNO neuroepithelium and studied the developmental and receptor co-expression patterns within sensory neurons. We organized our dataset as an interactive web portal resource, accessible from https://www.scvnexplorer.com, where a gene can be queried for its expression pattern and levels amongst cell clusters. The identification of distinct cell clusters and validation of marker expression through RNA in situ hybridization, revealed a heterogeneous cellular composition of the vomeronasal neuroepithelium. In particular, we identified specific new gene markers, such as Ppic in sustentacular cells and Ly6d in non-sensory epithelium, which would be helpful in the future to genetically tag or target these cell types and to study their developmental origins. Our study also identified specific types of macrophage cells within the neuroepithelium. Given the increasing appreciation of the role of tissue-resident or infiltrating macrophages in a variety of physiological processes (Nobs and Kopf, 2021; Mass et al., 2023) it is tempting to speculate that macrophages could also play an important role in VNO neuronal differentiation or the regulation of inflammatory/immune responses to external insults. Future experiments, performing targeted purification, deep sequencing, and functional manipulation of VNO macrophage types could provide deeper insights into their role in VNO function and whether they share cellular identity with MOE macrophages. Development of VSNs VNO sensory neurons expressing Gnao1 and Gnai2 develop continuously throughout life from a single progenitor cell population located within the VNO marginal zones and differentiate into immature and mature neurons. Recent developmental studies have demonstrated that the dichotomy is established by Notch signaling followed by transcription factor, Bcl11b expression that marks the progenitor cells to take Gnao1 fate (Enomoto et al., 2011; Katreddi et al., 2022). Most Importantly, a critical period of Notch signaling determines whether progenitors give rise to apical, basal, or sustentacular cell types. After Gnao1/Gnai2 identity is established, transcription factor Tfap2e, continuously expressed from immature to mature Gnao1 neurons, is required to maintain the Gnao1 fate (Lin et al., 2018; Lin et al., 2022; Katreddi et al., 2022). Pseudo-time analysis of our data confirmed a developmental trajectory that starts with progenitor cells, leading to immature neurons that take on either Gnai2 or Gnao1 fate. From our scRNA seq data, a comparison of immature neurons revealed that apart from Tfap2e, transcription factors: Creb5, Prrxl1, Lmo4, and Foxo1 also express in immature Gnao1 neurons. But unlike Tfap2e, Creb5, and Prrxl1 expression is restricted to only the immature stage of Gnao1 neurons. Although, Foxo1, and Lmo4 continue to express in mature Gnao1 neurons, their RNA levels are high in immature Gnao1 neurons and reduce upon maturation. Among the transcription factors identified, Prrxl1 has been shown to be involved in the development of dorsal root ganglion neurons where it has been shown to autoregulate its expression (Monteiro et al., 2014). Our observations on the tight temporal regulation of these transcription factor-related genes in the developmental trajectory of Gnao1 neurons indicate that additional molecular players might be important in further specification or maintenance of this neuronal lineage. Further experiments are needed to tease out the mechanism and precise choreography by which these transcription factors collectively specify and maintain the Gnao1 cell identity as well as gene expression patterns unique to these neurons. Receptor co-expression in Gnao1 neurons One of the key features distinguishing basal zone Gnao1 VNO neurons from apical Gnai2 or MOE neurons, is the combinatorial co-expression of two or more V2R family GPCRs along with H2-Mv class-1b MHC molecules in each cell. Our analysis of receptor expression in mature VNO neurons, revealed that members of V1R and V2R-ABD gene families largely follow the one-neuron-one receptor rule, but with multiple exceptions. Some V1Rs were found to consistently co-express in Gnai2 neurons and the major combinations observed from our analysis (such as Vmn1r85/86, Figure 4—figure supplement 4), match those identified recently from a functional single-cell study (Lee et al., 2019), leading confidence to the methodology used in our co-expression analysis. Receptors of the ABD-V2R subfamilies are also mostly expressed at one receptor per neuron, with notable exceptions being the observed combinations of Vmn2r20/22 and Vmn2r39/43/50 being co-expressed per cell. In our study, the analysis of family-C, family ABD-V2Rs and H2-Mv genes expressed per cell, confirmed the earlier reported sub-division of basal/Gnao1 neurons into those that express either Vmn2r1 (family-C1) or Vmn2r2-Vmn2r7 (family-C2), resulting in a broad four-part division of mature VNO neurons: those expressing (a) Gnai2/V1Rs, (b) Gnao1/Vmn2r1, (c) Gnao1/Vmn2r2-2r7; H2-Mv+, (d) Gnao1/Vmn2r2-2r7; H2-Mv-. The co-expression of ABD-V2R sub-families A1-A5 and most of the H2-Mv genes with Vmn2r2/family-C2 neurons (Figure 4C–E, cluster n3, n2, Supplementary file 5) as well as preferential co-expression of A6-A9, B, D, E sub-families with Vmn2r1 along with exclusion of H2Mv genes from these neurons (Figure 4E), points to the overall non-random logic of V2R/H2Mv co-expression. It would be interesting to see how receptor deorphanization and future functional experiments will map onto these elaborate co-expression patterns. At the same time, there were notable deviations observed from these rules, namely the restricted and sparse expression of H2-M1/M9/M11 with Vmn2r1 neurons in cluster n4 (Figure 4E, Figure 4—figure supplement 2B and E), where the receptors Vmn2r81/82 are also expressed selectively in these neurons. Of note, the combined expression of VR/H2-Mv in a cell is not capped and is proportional to a number of VRs and H2-Mv genes expressed in that cell (Figure 4I–K). It would be interesting to see whether the levels of co-expressing transcripts also translate to protein levels in cells and their impact on functional interactions, if any, between co-expressed proteins. ER environment in VNO neurons When comparing gene expression amongst Gnai2/Gnao1 mature neurons, what stood out was the unexpected enrichment of gene ontology terms associated with ER functions within Gnao1 neurons (Figure 6A and E). Most of these ER-Gnao1 enriched genes from our dataset, match the ones identified from a similar comparison by Lin et al., 2022, supporting our findings. We validated several of these ER genes via RNA-ISH to be exclusively expressed or enriched in Gnao1 neurons. Even more puzzling was our observation that this enrichment pattern extended at the protein level to many ER proteins probed by immune labeling (Figure 7). In some cases, both RNA and proteins were Gnao1 enriched, whereas in others, RNA levels were comparable but protein levels were biased towards Gnao1 cells. The enrichment of ER genes/proteins via transcriptional and/or post-transcriptional mechanisms presents a new feature of these cell types that could be associated with their differentiation and function. High levels of several chaperones such as Creld2, Dnajc3, Pdia6, PDI, Hspa5/Bip, Grp94, and Calnexin in Gnao1 neurons (Figure 6B, Figure 7F, Figure 7—figure supplement 1A) compared to Gnai2 neurons indicates a chaperone rich ER environment in these neurons. The chaperone Calr4 has been shown to be enriched in Gnao1 neurons (Dey and Matsunami, 2011). Our observations indicate that the enrichment of chaperones is a generalized feature of Gnao1 neurons that extends to several other genes/proteins of related function and localization. Since it has been proposed that the V2R family is an evolutionarily recent acquisition in rodents and marsupials (Takigami et al., 2004) and sub-family members, such as sub-family-C2, A1-A6 V2Rs, as well as H2-Mv genes have evolved in Muridae (Young and Trask, 2007; Silvotti et al., 2011), it is possible that mouse Gnao1 neurons may have required to co-evolve ER protein folding mechanisms to handle multiple GPCR/H2-Mv co-expression and their putative protein interactions. In addition to our observations on the generalized upregulation of ER genes in Gnao1 neurons, it may be possible that some specific ER genes are also necessary for proper folding of vomeronasal type-2 GCPRs. These data and observations assume significance given the well-recognized fact that functional reconstitution of these GPCRs and H2-Mv molecules in heterologous cells remains a persistent challenge, with some success being reported using the chaperone Calr4 (Dey and Matsunami, 2011). On the other hand, olfactory receptors have been shown to co-opt the ER unfolded protein response (UPR) pathway via the ER proteins PERK/CHOP and transcription factor ATF5 as a mechanism for their functional expression, setting the stage for ONOR expression pattern (Dalton et al., 2013). ATF5 is observed in the VNO, however, it is reported to be broadly expressed across Gnai2 and Gnao1 neurons (Nakano et al., 2016; Dalton, 2018b; Dalton, 2018a),. Further experiments are required to evaluate whether V2Rs and Gnao1 neurons adopt similar mechanisms and how the chaperone-rich ER environment observed here might impact the expression, folding of GPCRs, and neuronal function. It is worth noting that in addition to the expression of ER chaperones in Gnao1 neurons, we also observed distinctly higher levels of ER structural and membrane proteins. Levels of membrane curvature stabilizing proteins - Reep5, NogoB/Reticulon4B, the three-way junction formation protein - Atlastin1 (Goyal and Blackstone, 2013), ER sheet lumen spacer protein - Climp-63/Ckap4 as well as Sec61β - a commonly used ER membrane marker were all observed to be high in Gnao1 neurons (Figure 7G and H, Figure 7—figure supplement 1B). Thus, it is possible that an added layer of complexity could involve modulation of total ER content or ER structure in Gnao1 neuronal subtypes. Our electron microcopy results (Figure 8, Figure 8—figure supplement 1) revealed a strikingly higher smooth ER membrane content in Gnao1 neurons compared to Gnai2 neurons. Interestingly, this ER adopts a cubic membrane architecture, packing the Gnao1 neuron cell body with a gyroid/sinusoidal membrane. Early electron microscopy studies in rodents, identified that smooth ER content is higher in VSNs than in olfactory sensory neurons (Ciges et al., 1977; Breipohl et al., 1981; Taniguchi and Mochizuki, 1982), however, these studies preceded the discovery of Gnao1-Gnai2 dichotomy. To our knowledge, Breipohl and colleagues (Breipohl et al., 1981) reported the presence of smooth ER whorls in VSNs, later termed as cubic membranes. Future studies using serial section EM would be instrumental in reconstructing the 3D architecture of VSN ER. Cubic membranes, representing highly curved periodic structures, have been observed in a variety of biological contexts, however, their functional significance has been harder to pin down (Almsherqi et al., 2006; Almsherqi et al., 2009). In the context of VNO, and in particular Gnao1 neurons, we speculate that the high ER content and dense packing in the form of cubic membranes, could indicate a perpetual stress-like state in these neurons, necessary to address unique folding requirements of V2R or H2-Mv proteins. For instance, the maturation of these proteins and their proper folding or multimerization may require a slower transit through the ER, necessitating the sinusoidal arrangement of ER membranes. Likewise, the V2R biosynthetic processes in Gnao1 neurons may require enhanced levels of ER chaperones, which could in turn induce ER membranes into a homeostatic response. Can V2Rs themselves trigger the upregulation of ER chaperones and the hypertrophic ER, or are these cellular characteristics established before the onset of V2R expression? From our single-cell transcriptomics data, we tried to identify at what stage ER chaperones express during the developmental trajectory of VSNs. We observed that the onset of Vmn2r1 expression coincides with the upregulation of ER chaperones in cluster n6 immature Gnao1 neurons (Figure 9A and B). However, some Gnao1 cells show upregulated ER gene expression without Vmn2r1/Vmn2r2 expression (Figure 9B), hence further experiments are needed to dissect the mechanism and precise relationship between neuronal differentiation, GPCR expression, and ER chaperones as well as ER ultrastructure. Onset of vomeronasal type-2 GPCR (V2R) expression coincides with the expression of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) chaperone genes. (A) Feature Plot showing the expression of Gnao1, Vmn2r1, Sdf1l1, and Manf. Sdf2l1 and Manf are known ER chaperones and their upregulation in Gnao1 neurons coincides with Vmn2r1 expression, which is preceded by Gnao1 expression. (B) Heatmap showing the expression of Gnao1, Vmn2r1, Vmn2r2, and several ER chaperone genes (red) in the clusters arranged as per their developmental trajectory. (C) Cartoon summarizing major transcription factor expression during development leading to Gnao1 neurons with chaperone-rich hypertrophic ER compared to Gnai2 neurons. Overall, our data opens a new aspect to look at Gnao1 neurons, when understanding their function: a highly specialized ER environment that is divergent from Gnai2 neurons. The ER genes and their Gnao1 biased expression we identified, could be downstream targets of specific transcription factors and as a result of neuronal differentiation, while functionally these could be required for the proper folding and co-expression of V2R GPCRs. The developmental trajectory of VSNs into Gnai2/Gnao1 neurons via transcription factors and their differential ER environment is summarized as a model in Figure 9C. In conclusion, the comprehensive scRNA seq analysis presented in this study contributes valuable insights into the complexity of the vomeronasal neuroepithelium, offering a roadmap for further investigations into the molecular mechanisms underlying sensory perception and neural development in this specialized sensory organ. Vomeronasal neurons may also serve as a model system to study specialized ER structure-function relationships and their role in the maturation of GPCR-expressing neurons. Materials and methods Key resources tableReagent type (species) or resourceDesignationSource or referenceIdentifiersAdditional informationOtherPapainWorthington Biochemical corporationLK003178Enzyme used for single-cell dissociationOtherRNAse-free Deoxyribonuclease IRoche4716728001Enzyme used for single-cell dissociationChemical compound, drugEDTAHimediaML014-500MLOtherOvomucoid inhibitor and albumin mixWorthington Biochemical corporationLK003182Used in single-cell dissociationChemical compound, drugGlycerolSigmaG6279-1LOther2 mL Protein Lo-Bind tubesEppendorf022431102Used for single-cell dissociationOtherPasteur pipettesFisher13-678-8BUsed in single-cell dissociationOtherHBSSHycloneSH30268.02Used in single-cell dissociationOtherEBSSHycloneSH30029.02Used in single-cell dissociationOther40 um cell strainerPluriselect43-10040-60Used in single-cell dissociationOther70 um cell strainerPluriselect43-10070-60Used in single-cell dissociationCommercial assay or kitChromium Next GEM Single-Cell 3' Kit v3.1, 4rxns10 X Genomics1000269Commercial assay or kitChromium Next GEM Chip G Single-Cell Kit10 X Genomics1000120Commercial assay or kitGoTaq DNA polymerasePromegaM3005Commercial assay or kitNucleoSpin Gel and PCR Clean-up, Mini kitMacherey-Nagel740609.250AntibodyAnti-Digoxigenin-AP (purified Fab fragments from Sheep)RocheCat#11093274910RRID: AB_514497Dilution - 1:7500AntibodyAnti-Digoxigenin-POD (purified Fab fragments from Sheep)RocheCat#11207733910RRID: AB_514500Dilution - 1:500AntibodyAnti-Fluorescein-AP (purified Fab fragments from Sheep)RocheCat#11426338910RRID: AB_2734723Dilution - 1:7500AntibodyAnti-Fluorescein-POD (purified Fab fragments from Sheep)RocheCat#11426346910RRID: AB_840257Dilution - 1:500Commercial assay or kit10 X Flu RNA labeling mixRoche11685619910Commercial assay or kit10 X Dig RNA labeling mixRoche11277073910Peptide, recombinant proteinT7 RNA polymerasePromegaP2075Peptide, recombinant proteinSP6 RNA polymerasePromegaP1085Chemical compound, drug5 X Transcription optimized bufferPromegaP1181Peptide, recombinant proteinRNasin PlusPromegaN2611Chemical compound, drug100 mM DTTPromegaP1171Chemical compound, drugDiethyl pyrocarbonateSigma40718–25 MLChemical compound, drugAkoya Blocking powderAkoyaFP1020Chemical compound, drugTSA plus Cy3AkoyaNEL744001KTChemical compound, drugTSA Plus FluoresceinAkoyaNEL741001KTCommercial assay or kitBCIP/NBT kitPromegaS3771OtherBovine Serum AlbuminJackson ImmunoResearch IncCat#001-000-173RRID:AB_2336947Blocking reagent in IHCOtherOCT freezing mediumLeicaCat#14020108926Used for freezing tissueChemical compound, drugParaformaldehydeElectron Microscopy Sciences157–8Antibodyanti-Omp (Goat polyclonal)WakoCat#019–22291RRID:AB_3094987Dilution –1:2000Antibodyanti-Gnao1/GαO (Rabbit polyclonal)MBL life scienceCat#551RRID:AB_591430Dilution –1:2000Antibodyanti-SEKDEL ER marker (Mouse monoclonal)Santa CruzCat #sc-58774RRID:AB_784161Dilution –1:1000Antibodyanti-Grp94 (Rat monoclonal)InvitrogenCat#MA3-016RRID:AB_2248666Dilution –1:1000Antibodyanti-Hspa5/BiP (Mouse monoclonal)BDCat#610978RRID:AB_398291Dilution –1:1000Antibodyanti-Atlastin1 (Rabbit polyclonal)InvitrogenCat#PA5-85682RRID:AB_2792821Dilution –1:500Antibodyanti-PDI (Mouse monoclonal)EnzoCat#ADI-SPA-891RRID:AB_10615355Dilution –1:500Antibodyanti-Sec61β (Rabbit polyclonal)InvitrogenCat#PA3-015RRID:AB_2239072Dilution –1:400Antibodyanti-Calnexin (Rabbit polyclonal)AbcamCat#ab10286RRID:AB_2069009Dilution –1:500Antibodyanti-Reep5 (Rabbit polyclonal)ProteinTechCat#14643–1-APRRID:AB_2178440Dilution –1:500Antibodyanti-NogoB (Rabbit recombinant monoclonal)InvitrogenCat#MA5-32763RRID:AB_2810040Dilution –1:500Antibodyanti-Ckap4 (Rabbit polyclonal)ProteinTechCat#16686–1-APRRID:AB_2276275Dilution –1:500Antibodyanti-Mouse IgG- Alexa Fluor 647 (Donkey polyclonal)Jackson ImmunoResearch IncCat#715-605-150RRID:AB_2340862Dilution –1:1600AntibodyAnti-Rat IgG-Cy3 (Donkey polyclonal)Jackson ImmunoResearch IncCat#712-165-153RRID:AB_2340667Dilution –1:1600AntibodyAnti-Rabbit IgG-Cy3 (Donkey polyclonal)Jackson ImmunoResearch IncCat#711-165-152RRID:AB_2307443Dilution –1:1600AntibodyAnti-Goat IgG-Alexa Fluor 488 (Bovine polyclonal)Jackson ImmunoResearch IncCat#805-545-180RRID:AB_2340883Dilution –1:1600Software, algorithmCell Ranger v5.0.110 x genomics; Zheng et al., 2017RRID:SCR_023221Software, algorithmSeurat v4.3.0Satija Lab; Hao et al., 2021RRID:SCR_016341Software, algorithmSoupX v1.6.2 Young and Behjati, 2020 RRID:SCR_019193 https://github.com/constantAmateur/SoupX Software, algorithmTrimGalore v0.6.6TrimGaloreRRID:SCR_011847 https://github.com/FelixKrueger/TrimGalore/releases/tag/0.6.6 Software, algorithmClusterprofiler v4.2.2 Wu et al., 2021 RRID:SCR_016884 https://bioconductor.org/packages/release/bioc/html/clusterProfiler.html Software, algorithmSlingshot v2.2.1 Street et al., 2018 RRID:SCR_017012 https://bioconductor.org/packages/release/bioc/html/slingshot.html Software, algorithmEnchancedVolcano v1.12.0EnhancedVolcanoRRID:SCR_018931 https://github.com/kevinblighe/EnhancedVolcano Software, algorithmggplot2 v3.5.0ggplot2RRID:SCR_014601 https://ggplot2.tidyverse.org Software, algorithmAdobe illustrator CCAdobe https://www.adobe.com/products/illustrator Software, algorithmShinyCell Ouyang, 2021 RRID:SCR_022756 https://github.com/SGDDNB/ShinyCell Animals C57BL/6 J mice were purchased from JAX (RRID:IMSR_JAX:000664) and were used for all experiments. Mice were housed in a specific pathogen-free barrier facility, with a 12 hr light-dark cycle and ad-libitum provision of feed and water. For single-cell RNA sequencing experiments, male and female mice were weaned at postnatal 3 wk age, followed by housing in separate individually ventilated cage racks to avoid exposure to opposite-sex stimuli, and used at 7–8 wk age. All experiments were carried out with approval from the Institutional Animal Ethics Committee of TIFR Hyderabad (Protocol number TCIS/2019/05). VNO dissociation Papain dissociation buffer (PDB) was made by reconstituting a single use papain vial from Worthington Biochemical Corporation with 5 mL Earle’s balanced salt solution (EBSS) (pH 7.2) and warmed to 37 °C until the solution appeared clear by maintaining 95% CO2, 5% O2 environment. VNOs were dissected from male and female animals (six male, 10 female) and processed separately. The sensory epithelium was separated using forceps and immediately placed in EBSS equilibrated with 95% CO2, and 5% O2. 60 U of DNase was added to the prewarmed PDB made earlier and 3 mL of it was transferred to a single well of 12-well dish. Neuroepithelial tissue from multiple animals was transferred to this well containing the final dissociation buffer and was cut into small pieces, and the suspension was transferred to a 14 mL tube and was incubated with gentle shaking at 37 °C for 30 min on a thermomixer (Eppendorf) by passing 95% CO2,5% O2 on top of the liquid headspace. During this incubation, the solution was triturated with a fire-polished Pasteur pipette every 10 min and at the end of the incubation. After incubation, the suspension was passed sequentially through 70 µm, and 35 µm filters to remove tissue debris. The filtered suspension was further layered over a mix of ovomucoid inhibitor (2.5 mg/mL) and albumin (2.5 mg/mL) in EBSS and centrifuged at 400 × g for 5 min at room temperature to remove subcellular debris or membrane fragments. The supernatant was discarded, and the cell pellet was used for the next steps after Hank’s balanced Salt solution (HBSS) wash. Single-cell library preparation and sequencing Dissociated neurons resuspended in HBSS were used for library preparation. Using a hemocytometer and trypan blue staining, cell density was estimated at 1200 cells/μl and 1100 cells/μl for male and female samples, respectively with greater than 80% cell viability. Single-cell capture, and library preparation were done using a Chromium Next GEM Single-Cell 3’ GEM, Library and Gel Bead Kit v3.1 on a 10 X Chromium controller (10 X Genomics). The volume of suspension to be loaded was decided as per the manufacturer’s recommendation to ensure the target capture of 6000 cells per well. Single-cell suspension from male and female samples was loaded onto two separate wells of different chips giving a total of four libraries (two male and two female samples). Each library was barcoded and sequenced separately on a single lane of HiSeq X to obtain a mean depth of at least 100,000 reads per cell in a 2 × 150 bp configuration. Single-cell RNA sequencing data analysis Trimming the reads To obtain an informative portion of raw reads, they were hard trimmed to make sure read-1 and read-2 are 28 and 91 bps long as per requirements specified by 10 X genomics using trim_galore. Alignment, UMI counting, and cell calling Mouse reference genome mm10 (Mus_musculus.GRCm38.dna.primary_assembly.fa) and GTF file were downloaded from Ensembl (Genome build GRCm38.p6). The GTF file was filtered to retain only protein-coding transcripts by removing readthrough and any non-coding transcripts using cell ranger mkgtf using attribute = gene_biotype:protein_coding and readthrough_transcript. A custom reference was built with cell ranger mkref using filtered GTF and mm10 genome. Alignment to custom reference, UMI counting, and cell calling, removal of empty droplets, and count matrix generation were done in a single step using cell ranger count individually for each sample using default parameters. Integrating samples and read depth normalization After alignment, integration of two male and two female samples was done at raw data level ensuring an average number of confidently mapped reads for each sample is equal using cell ranger aggr pipeline. This pipeline subsampled reads in higher-depth samples to ensure the sequencing depth is normalized across samples. During this step, a sample suffix (1–4) was added to each cell barcode to distinguish its source and to avoid barcode clashes in the integrated count matrix. Ambient RNA correction, quality check, and filtering Before downstream analysis stringent filtering was implemented to retain high-quality cells. Ambient RNA contamination was removed using the soupX package with default parameters in auto mode. The adjusted count matrix from soupX consisting of 10,615 cells was used as an input to the Seurat package using the CreateSeuratObject function. To remove potential doublets and low gene count cells, an additional filter was applied to select cells that express 200–7000 genes resulting in dropping 683 cells. Normalization, scaling, dimensionality reduction, clustering, marker identification, and additional filtration The data was normalized using the NormalizeData function using the LogNormalize method that log-transforms the expression counts after multiplying with scaling factor 10000. After normalization, the top 2000 variable genes in the dataset were identified using the FindVariableFeatures function using mean.function=ExpMean, dispersion.function=LogVMR, x.low.cutoff=0.0125, x.high.cutoff=3, y.cutoff=0.5 as parameters. This variable gene set was used for all downstream analysis including dimensionality reduction and clustering. All vomeronasal receptors were amongst the variable features gene set. Data was scaled and centered using ScaleData using the default model by regressing out a percentage of mitochondrial genes and the total number of RNA molecules per cell to remove their contribution in downstream analysis. The basis of scaling for each gene is by subtracting the mean from the value and dividing the difference by the standard deviation. To cluster the cells, we initially performed principal component analysis (PCA) with 50 components using RunPCA. We used elbow plot and Jack Straw plot and determined the optimum number of dimensions required for the next steps of clustering as 37. Graph-based clustering was performed using Seurat’s FindNeighbours function to identify the neighboring cells that share similar expression patterns in a network constructed in PCA space with 37 dimensions. Later the clusters were identified by using the FindClusters function by varying the resolution parameter from 0.2 to 0.8. The resolution parameter 0.3 was chosen, as it shows minimum overlapping markers upon plotting the heatmap of gene markers for each cluster identified by the FindAllMarkers function. To clean up the dataset further, cells (408) expressing the Hbb-bs gene were considered as RBC contamination, and a cluster (215 cells) enriched with mitochondrial genes indicative of dying cells was removed from the data. This resulted in a total of 9180 cells. Dimensionality reduction for 2D representation and cell type assignment UMAP was generated using the RunUMAP function. Cluster identity was assigned based on known markers of each cell type. Two clusters expressing Gnai2 as a major marker were merged as they had very similar expression profiles. Solitary chemosensory cells and endothelial cells were manually assigned a cluster identity based on the expression of Trpm5/Rgs21 and Aqp1/Egfl7 and by selecting the cells using the CellSelector function of Seurat. Comparison of male and female data Based on suffix assigned to barcodes during the integration of male and female samples, a metadata column was added to the Seurat object marking the sex of source tissue as male or female. Furthermore, cells in each cluster were divided by appending the sex to the cluster identities. Differential expression analysis was performed between cells from male and female VNO for each cluster using the FindMarkers function of Seurat. Clustering and downstream analysis of neurons For neuron-specific analysis, neuronal cell types representing Gnao1 neurons, Gnai2 neurons, immature neurons, and progenitor cells were separated from the main Seurat object using subset function to create a new ‘neurons’ object. The data was scaled again, PCA was performed, the number of principal components was determined, and clustering was performed as described above with resolution = 0.4 to define neuronal subtypes. To compare the results of clustering with and without VRs, a new Seurat object– ‘neurons_no_VR’ was created by removing all vomeronasal receptors from the variable gene set. Dimensionality reduction, and clustering were performed again using the same method mentioned above. Seurat’s query to reference mapping module was used to project the neurons_no_VR object in the same UMAP space as the neurons object so that UMAPs are comparable. The anchors were identified by using the FindTransferAnchors function with neurons object as reference and neurons_no_VR as query. The reference UMAP model was computed using the MapQuery function using the anchors. Pseudotime analysis Developmental trajectory of VSNs was inferred using the SlingShot package. ‘neurons’ objects with five major clusters: progenitor cells, Gnao1+ immature neurons, Gnai2+ immature neurons, mature Gnao1 neurons, and mature Gnai2 neurons. Progenitor cells/cluster n5 was chosen as the starting cluster. Differential gene expression of Gnao1, Gnai2 neurons Differentially expressed genes between Gnao1 and Gnai2 neurons (mature or immature) were identified using the FindMarkers function of Seurat on the ‘neurons’ object with default parameters. The results are plotted as volcano plots using the EnhancedVolcano package. Non-parametric Wilcoxon rank sum test was used for calculating p-values and the Bonferroni method to calculate adjusted p-values for multiple testing. GO analysis Gene ontology analysis of Gnao1 enriched genes was done with cluster Profiler package using enricher function on mouse gene sets related to mouse biological processes (GO:BP) ontology downloaded from Mouse Molecular Signatures Database. The enrichment analysis was restricted to the differentially expressed genes with log2 fold change greater than 1. Co-expression analysis Non-zero expression level for a particular gene may not indicate that the VR is expressed. Therefore, we identified the cut-off for V1R, V2R, and H2-Mvs based on the distribution of expression levels across all cells. Normalized gene expression values of V1R, V2R, and H2-Mv genes were extracted from each cell of Gnai2 and Gnao1 clusters and the distribution is plotted across all cells. This resulted in a Bi-modal distribution and starting of the second peak was considered as a cut-off for V2R/V1R/H2-Mv genes (Figure 4—figure supplement 1D and F). The genes were considered co-expressed in a single-cell if their normalized expression value was greater than the identified threshold value of 1.25 for V2R, H2-Mv gene, and 2.5 for V1R genes. Furthermore, the number of cells crossing the threshold was calculated for each combination. Raw single-cell RNA seq data of VNO from p56 animals generated by Hills et al., 2024 was downloaded from NCBI GEO with ID: GSE252365. The data was analyzed in the same method as described above and Gnao1 neurons from mature neuronal clusters identified based on the expression of Gnao1, Omp were used for co-expression analysis. The graphical user interface for scvnoexplorer.com was made using the ShinyCell tool Ouyang, 2021. Reference details of software used for data analysis are mentioned in a tabular form below. RNA in situ hybridization (ISH) Probe design and synthesis Primers (Supplementary file 8) targeting unique regions of each gene were designed by adding a T7/SP6 promoter sequence. PCR (GoTaq DNA polymerase) was performed using gene specific primers with VNO cDNA as template and the product was run on an agarose gel to confirm the specific amplification of each gene. When multiple bands were seen, the band with desired molecular weight was cut from the gel, and PCR product clean-up or gel purification was performed using NucleoSpin Gel and PCR Cleanup kit. Purified PCR product was verified by Sanger sequencing and was used as the template for in vitro transcription to obtain digoxigenin (Dig) and fluorescein (Flu) labeled riboprobes using the following reaction composition: 1 ug Template DNA, 1 x Dig/Flu RNA labeling mix, 1 U/uL RNAsin plus, 5 mM DTT, 1 x Transcription buffer in nuclease-free water. The reaction was purified using a Qiagen/MN RNA cleanup kit and stored at –80℃ by adding formamide to 50% of the volume. H2-Mv genes and Gnai2 were cloned to a plasmid vector with T7 or SP6 promoters. Gnao1 plasmid was purchased from Invitrogen (6309166). The plasmid was linearized, and in vitro transcription was performed as described earlier. Chromogenic ISH Fresh VNO was embedded in OCT and 14 µm thick sections were collected on a cryostat. Tissue sections were fixed with 4% PFA in Diethyl Pyrocarbonate (DEPC) treated phosphate buffer saline (PBS) and acetylation was performed using Propionic Anhydride, Triethanolamine, and NaCl. Permeabilization was done using 0.1 M HCl and sections were pre-hybridized using hybridization buffer (50% Formamide, 5 X SSC, 5 X Denhardt’s solution, 0.1 mg/mL Salmon sperm DNA, 0.25 mg/mL yeast t-RNA) for 2 hr. Probes were diluted (1:100) in the hybridization buffer and added to the slides. Hybridization was performed for 12–16 hr at 67 °C. To remove the unbound probe, sections were washed thrice with 0.2 X SSC for 30 min each. Slides were equilibrated in a buffer consisting of 0.1 M Tris-HCl. pH 7.5, 150 mM NaCl for 5 min and blocked with 10% FBS in the same buffer. Hybridized Digoxigenin (DIG) or Fluorescein (Flu) containing RNA probes were detected by alkaline phosphatase-conjugated Anti-DIG or Anti-Flu Fab2 fragments (1:7500 dilution). Unbound antibody was washed, and the development of alkaline phosphatase was done using BCIP/NBT substrate diluted as per manufacturer’s protocol in 0.1 M Tris-HCl pH-9, 0.1 M NaCl, 50 mM MgCl2. The signal was developed for 12–72 hr based on the intensity. After development, slides were washed with PBS and mounted using 10% glycerol in 0.1 M Tris-HCl (pH 7.5). ISH for each gene was done twice with biological replicates. Two-color fluorescence ISH As described above, the same protocol for chromogenic ISH was followed until 0.2 X SSC washes, after which the hybridized probes were detected using peroxidase-conjugated anti-FLU or anti-DIG Fab(2) fragments and the Tyramide signal amplification (TSA) system from Akoya Biosciences. Slides were incubated in 3% H2O2 in PBS for 1 hr and washed thrice for 10 min each and blocked with 0.5% blocking buffer for 30 min. Dig and Flu were sequentially developed using TSA-FITC or TSA-Cy3. Immunohistochemistry VNOs were dissected from animals of age 8–12 wk, fixed with 4% Paraformaldehyde (PFA) in PBS, and cryopreserved with 30% sucrose. Tissue was embedded in an OCT-freezing medium and cryosections of 14 µm thickness were collected on glass slides. Sections were post-fixed again with 4% PFA in PBS, blocked, and permeabilized by incubating for 2 hr with a blocking buffer (3% Bovine Serum Albumin, 0.1% TritonX-100 in PBS with 0.02% Sodium Azide). After blocking, the sections were incubated with primary antibodies diluted in the blocking buffer for 2 hr followed by washing off excess antibody and secondary antibody incubation for 2 more hours. All washes were done using 0.1% TritonX-100 in PBS. Light microscopy image acquisition Chromogenic images were acquired on an Olympus BX43 upright microscope using bright field Koehler illumination and 10 X objective (PlaN, 0.24 NA) equipped with an Olympus DP25 color CCD camera. Two- or three-color fluorescent RNA-ISH images and fluorescent Immunohistochemistry images were acquired sequentially using Leica Stellaris upright confocal microscope using 10 X (HC PL APO 0.40 NA) or 63 X (HC PL APO 1.40–0.60 NA Oil) objective keeping 1 Airy unit as pinhole size. Acquisition parameters were adjusted and calibrated using single-channel controls to ensure that there was no spectral cross-talk between channels in multi-color imaging experiments. Immunohistochemistry images of ER antibodies were pseudo-colored using the ImageJ Fire LUT with 0–255 linear scaling. Quantification of ER antibody signal intensities VNO sections were labeled with a single ER antibody, along with goat anti-OMP and rabbit anti-Gnao1 or mouse anti-KDEL as markers of neurons and Gnao1 zone, respectively. At least 20 sections from three biological replicates were imaged via confocal microscopy and used for each ER antibody quantification. 50-pixel wide rectangular regions of interest (ROI) were drawn along the apical to basal axis and the signal intensity along the ROI for each channel was extracted from the images using Fiji software. To make the signal intensities along the apical-basal axis across different images and antibodies comparable, the signal intensity and length of ROI were normalized by min-max normalization,x`=x-min⁡(x)max⁡x-min⁡(x) where, x is the measured or actual value, min⁡x and max⁡x are minimum and maximum values of x, respectively. The trendline of normalized signal intensity along the ab axis was generated by fitting a smoothened curve using the geom_smooth function of the ggplots package based on the generalized additive model for each antibody. Electron microscopy VNOs were dissected from animals that were trans-cardially perfused with PBS followed by 4% PFA in PBS buffer. Dissected VNO was embedded in 2% agarose and coronal sections of 400 um were obtained on a vibratome in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate buffer (pH 7.4). Sections were fixed with Karnovsky’s fixative (3% PFA + 2% glutaraldehyde in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate) for up to 1 wkk. Subsequent processing steps were similar to those described before (Terasaki et al., 2020). Briefly, vibratome sections were rinsed with 0.1 M sodium cacodylate and then immersed in 1% osmium, and 0.8% potassium ferricyanide in the cacodylate buffer for 1 hr. This was followed by incubation in 1% aqueous uranyl acetate for 1 hr, then 30 min in lead aspartate (Walton, 1979), dehydration in graded ethanol, infiltration with epon resin then embedding and polymerization at 60 °C for 2 d. Serial 70 nm thick sections were collected using a Powertome automated tape collector (RMC Boeckeler, Tucson, AZ). The tape was mounted on a silicon wafer, carbon coated, and imaged with a field emission electron microscope (Thermo Fisher/FEI Verios, Hillsboro, OR). Backscatter electrons were imaged from a 5 keV/0.8 nanoAmp beam of electrons. This is a valuable manuscript analyzing single-cell RNA-sequencing data from the mouse vomeronasal organ. Convincing evidence in this manuscript allows the authors to identify and verify the differential expression of genes that distinguish apical and basal vomeronasal neurons. The authors also show that Gnao1 neurons exhibit enriched expression of ER-related genes, which they verify with in situ hybridizations and immunostaining and also explore via electron microscopy. Devakinandan et al. present a revised version of their manuscript. Their scRNA-seq data is a valuable resource to the community, and they further validate their findings via in situ hybridizations and electron microscopy. Overall, they have addressed my major concerns. I only have two minor comments. (1) The authors note in Figure 4I, and K that because the number of C2 V2Rs or H2-Mv receptors increased while the normalized expression of Gnao1 remained constant (and likewise for V1Rs and Gnai2 in Figure 4-S4C) that their results are unlikely to be capturing doublets. I'm not sure that this is the case. If the authors added together two V2R cells the total count of every gene might double, but the normalized expression of Gnao1 would remain the same. To address this concern, the authors should also show the raw counts for Gnao1 as well as the total number of UMIs for these cells. (2) As requested, the authors have now added a colorbar to the pseudocolored images in Figures 7. However, this colorbar still doesn't have any units. Can the authors add some units, or clarify in the methods how the raw data relates to the colors (e.g. is it mapped linearly, at a logscale, with gamma or other adjustments, etc.)? Moreover, it's also unclear what the dots in the backgrounds of plots like Figure 7E mean. Are they pixels? Showing the individual lines, the average for each animal, or omitting them entirely, might make more sense. Summary: The study focuses on the vomeronasal organ, the peripheral chemosensory organ of the accessory olfactory system, by employing single-cell transcriptomics. The author analyzed the mouse vomeronasal organ, identifying diverse cell types through their unique gene expression patterns. Developmental gene expression analysis revealed that two classes of sensory neurons diverge in their maturation from common progenitors, marked by specific transient and persistent transcription factors. A comparative study between major neuronal subtypes, which differ in their G-protein sensory receptor families and G-protein subunits (Gnai2 and Gnao1, respectively), highlighted a higher expression of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) associated genes in Gnao1 neurons. Moreover, distinct differences in ER content and ultrastructure suggest some intriguing roles of ER in Gnao1-positive vomeronasal neurons. This work is likely to provide useful data for the community and is conceptually novel with the unique role of ER in a subset of vomeronasal neurons. Strengths: (1) The study identified diverse cell types based on unique gene expression patterns, using single-cell transcriptomic. (2) The analysis suggest that two classes of sensory neurons diverge during maturation from common progenitors, characterized by specific transient and persistent transcription factors. (3) A comparative study highlighted differences in Gnai2- and Gnao1-positive sensory neurons. (4) Higher expression of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) associated genes in Gnao1 neurons. (5) Distinct differences in ER content and ultrastructure suggest unique roles of ER in Gnao1-positive vomeronasal neurons. (6) The research provides conceptually novel on the unique role of ER in a subset of vomeronasal neurons, offering valuable insights to the community. Comments on latest version: In the revised manuscript, the authors have thoroughly addressed all of this reviewer's concerns. Summary: In this manuscript, Devakinandan and colleagues have undertaken a thorough characterization of the cell types of the mouse vomeronasal organ, focusing on the vomeronasal sensory neurons (VSNs). VSNs are known to arise from a common pool of progenitors that differentiate into two distinct populations characterized by the expression of either the G protein subunit Gnao1 or Gnai2. Using single-cell RNA sequencing followed by unsupervised clustering of the transcriptome data, the authors identified three Gnai2+ VSN subtypes and a single Gnao1+ VSN type. To study VSN developmental trajectories, Devakinandan and colleagues took advantage of the constant renewal of the neuronal VSN pool, which allowed them to harvest all maturation states. All neurons were re-clustered and a pseudotime analysis was performed. The analysis revealed the emergence of two pools of Gap43+ clusters from a common lineage, which differentiate into many subclusters of mature Gnao1+ and Gnai2+ VSNs. By comparing the transcriptomes of these two pools of immature VSNs, the authors identified a number of differentially expressed transcription factors in addition to known markers. Next, by comparing the transcriptomes of mature Gnao1+ and Gnai2+ VSNs, the authors report an enrichment of ER-related genes in Gnao1+ VSNs. Using electron microscopy, they found that this enrichment was associated with specific ER morphology in Gnao1+ neurons. Finally, the authors characterized chemosensory receptor expression and co-expression (as well as H2-Mv proteins) in mature VSNs, which recapitulated known patterns. Strengths: The data presented here provide new and interesting perspectives on the distinguishing features between Gnao1+ and Gnai2+ VSNs. These features include newly identified markers, such as transcription factors, as well as an unsuspected ER-related peculiarity in Gnao1+ neurons, consisting in a hypertrophic ER and an enrichment in ER-related genes. In addition, the authors provide a comprehensive picture of specific co-expression patterns of V2R chemoreceptors and H2-Mv genes. Importantly, the authors provide a browser (scVNOexplorer) for anyone to explore the data, including gene expression and co-expression, number and proportion of cells, with a variety of graphical tools (violin plots, feature plots, dot plots, ...). The following is the authors’ response to the current reviews. Reviewer #1 (Public review): Devakinandan et al. present a revised version of their manuscript. Their scRNA-seq data is a valuable resource to the community, and they further validate their findings via in situ hybridizations and electron microscopy. Overall, they have addressed my major concerns. I only have two minor comments. (1) The authors note in Figure 4I, and K that because the number of C2 V2Rs or H2-Mv receptors increased while the normalized expression of Gnao1 remained constant (and likewise for V1Rs and Gnai2 in Figure 4-S4C) that their results are unlikely to be capturing doublets. I'm not sure that this is the case. If the authors added together two V2R cells the total count of every gene might double, but the normalized expression of Gnao1 would remain the same. To address this concern, the authors should also show the raw counts for Gnao1 as well as the total number of UMIs for these cells. In Figure 4I, 4K and Figure 4-Figure supplement 4C, on Y-axis, we plotted the sum of normalized counts of all V1R/V2R/H2-Mv genes expressed in each cell along with the normalized expression value of Gnao1/Gnai2. Both VR/H2-Mv and Gnao1/Gnai2 are normalized values, with normalization based on LogNormalize (mentioned in methods). We show here plots of total expression calculated from raw counts corresponding to the same Figure. Raw counts of VRs/H2-Mv, Gnao1/Gnai2 are plotted separately due to difference in scale. The overall trend matches normalized counts, with minor fluctuations in Gnao1/Gnai2. As mentioned in our response to version-1 reviews and in our manuscript, doublets generally are a random combination of two cells and the probability that a combinatorial pattern is due to doublet is proportional to the abundance of cells expressing those genes. It is possible that some of the family-C V2R combinations represented by 2 cells are doublets because of their widespread expression. The frequency of combinatorial expression patterns, greater than a set threshold of 2 cells, that we observed for family ABD V2Rs or V1Rs (supplementary tables 7, 8) is an indication of co-expression and unlikely from random doublets. For instance, 134 cells express two V1Rs, of which 44 cells express Vmn1r85+Vmn1r86, 21 cells express Vmn1r184+Vmn1r185, 13 express Vmn1r56+Vmn1r57, 6 express Vmn1r168+Vmn1r177. Some of the co-expression combinations we reported were also identified and verified experimentally in Lee et al., 2019 and Hills et. al., 2024. The co-expression of multiple family-C2 V2Rs (Vmn2r2-Vmn2r7) along with ABD V2Rs per cell as shown in our data, has been shown experimentally in earlier studies. (2) As requested, the authors have now added a colorbar to the pseudocolored images in Figures 7. However, this colorbar still doesn't have any units. Can the authors add some units, or clarify in the methods how the raw data relates to the colors (e.g. is it mapped linearly, at a logscale, with gamma or other adjustments, etc.)? Moreover, it's also unclear what the dots in the backgrounds of plots like Figure 7E mean. Are they pixels? Showing the individual lines, the average for each animal, or omitting them entirely, might make more sense. We used the Fire LUT with linear scale within Fiji / Image-J software to assign scale to the pseudo-colored images in Figure 7. We will include this description in our methods and thank the reviewer for pointing it out. The dots in the background are mentioned in Figure 7 legend as fluorescence intensity values normalized to a 0-1 scale and color coded for each antibody. The trendline was fitted on these values. Reviewer #2 (Public review): Summary: The study focuses on the vomeronasal organ, the peripheral chemosensory organ of the accessory olfactory system, by employing single-cell transcriptomics. The author analyzed the mouse vomeronasal organ, identifying diverse cell types through their unique gene expression patterns. Developmental gene expression analysis revealed that two classes of sensory neurons diverge in their maturation from common progenitors, marked by specific transient and persistent transcription factors. A comparative study between major neuronal subtypes, which differ in their G-protein sensory receptor families and G-protein subunits (Gnai2 and Gnao1, respectively), highlighted a higher expression of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) associated genes in Gnao1 neurons. Moreover, distinct differences in ER content and ultrastructure suggest some intriguing roles of ER in Gnao1-positive vomeronasal neurons. This work is likely to provide useful data for the community and is conceptually novel with the unique role of ER in a subset of vomeronasal neurons. Strengths: (1) The study identified diverse cell types based on unique gene expression patterns, using single-cell transcriptomic. (2) The analysis suggest that two classes of sensory neurons diverge during maturation from common progenitors, characterized by specific transient and persistent transcription factors. (3) A comparative study highlighted differences in Gnai2- and Gnao1-positive sensory neurons. (4) Higher expression of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) associated genes in Gnao1 neurons. (5) Distinct differences in ER content and ultrastructure suggest unique roles of ER in Gnao1-positive vomeronasal neurons. (6) The research provides conceptually novel on the unique role of ER in a subset of vomeronasal neurons, offering valuable insights to the community. Reviewer #3 (Public review): Summary: In this manuscript, Devakinandan and colleagues have undertaken a thorough characterization of the cell types of the mouse vomeronasal organ, focusing on the vomeronasal sensory neurons (VSNs). VSNs are known to arise from a common pool of progenitors that differentiate into two distinct populations characterized by the expression of either the G protein subunit Gnao1 or Gnai2. Using single-cell RNA sequencing followed by unsupervised clustering of the transcriptome data, the authors identified three Gnai2+ VSN subtypes and a single Gnao1+ VSN type. To study VSN developmental trajectories, Devakinandan and colleagues took advantage of the constant renewal of the neuronal VSN pool, which allowed them to harvest all maturation states. All neurons were re-clustered and a pseudotime analysis was performed. The analysis revealed the emergence of two pools of Gap43+ clusters from a common lineage, which differentiate into many subclusters of mature Gnao1+ and Gnai2+ VSNs. By comparing the transcriptomes of these two pools of immature VSNs, the authors identified a number of differentially expressed transcription factors in addition to known markers. Next, by comparing the transcriptomes of mature Gnao1+ and Gnai2+ VSNs, the authors report an enrichment of ER-related genes in Gnao1+ VSNs. Using electron microscopy, they found that this enrichment was associated with specific ER morphology in Gnao1+ neurons. Finally, the authors characterized chemosensory receptor expression and co-expression (as well as H2-Mv proteins) in mature VSNs, which recapitulated known patterns. Strengths: The data presented here provide new and interesting perspectives on the distinguishing features between Gnao1+ and Gnai2+ VSNs. These features include newly identified markers, such as transcription factors, as well as an unsuspected ER-related peculiarity in Gnao1+ neurons, consisting in a hypertrophic ER and an enrichment in ER-related genes. In addition, the authors provide a comprehensive picture of specific co-expression patterns of V2R chemoreceptors and H2-Mv genes. Importantly, the authors provide a browser (scVNOexplorer) for anyone to explore the data, including gene expression and co-expression, number and proportion of cells, with a variety of graphical tools (violin plots, feature plots, dot plots, ...). The following is the authors’ response to the original reviews. Public Reviews: Reviewer #1 (Public Review): Devakinandan and colleagues present a manuscript analyzing single-cell RNAsequencing data from the mouse vomeronasal organ. The main advances in this manuscript are to identify and verify the differential expression of genes that distinguish apical and basal vomeronasal neurons. The authors also identify the enriched expression of ER-related genes in Gnao1 neurons, which they verify with in situ hybridizations and immunostaining, and also explore via electron microscopy. Finally, the results of this manuscript are presented in an online R shiny app. Overall, these data are a useful resource to the community. I have a few concerns about the manuscript, which I've listed below. General Concerns: (1) The authors mention that they were unable to identify the cells in cluster 13. This cluster looks similar to the "secretory VSN" subtype described in a recent preprint from C. Ron Yu's lab (10.1101/2024.02.22.581574). The authors could try comparing or integrating their data with this dataset (or that in Katreddi et al. 2022) to see if this is a common cell type across datasets (or arises from a specific type of cell doublets). In situ hybridizations for some of the marker genes for this cluster could also highlight where in the VNO these cells reside. Cluster13 (Obp2a+) cells identified in our study have similar gene expression markers to “putative secretory” cells mentioned in Hills et al.. At the time this manuscript was available publicly, our publication was already communicated. We have now performed RNA-ISH to Obp2a, the topmost marker identified with this cluster, and found it to be expressed in cells from glandular tissue on the non-sensory side. Some of the other markers associated with this cluster such as Obp2b, Lcn3, belong to the lipocalin family of proteins. Hence in our estimate these markers collectively represent non-sensory glandular tissue. We have added Obp2a RNA-ISH to Figure 2-figure supplement-1A and results section in our revised manuscript. Cluster-13 also has cells expressing Vmn1r37, which typically is expressed in neuronal cells. However, we do not see Obp2a mRNA in the sensory epithelium. It is possible that cluster-13 comprises a heterogenous mixture of cells, some of which are clearly non-sensory cells from glandular tissue, co-clustered with other cell types as well as a possibility that Obp2a is expressed below the detection level of our assay in neurons, which will require further experiments. We do not have any possible reason to confidently assign this cluster as a neuronal cell type, hence, we excluded it in downstream analysis of neurons. We used the data from Hills et al., to compare co-expression characteristic of V2Rs, which is added as Figure 3-figure supplement 3. (2) I found the UMAPs for the neurons somewhat difficult to interpret. Unlike Katreddi et al. 2022 or Hills et al. 2024, it's tricky to follow the developmental trajectories of the cells in the UMAP space. Perhaps the authors could try re-embedding the data using gene sets that don't include the receptors? It would also be interesting to see if the neuron clusters still cluster by receptor-type even when the receptors are excluded from the gene sets used for clustering. Plots relating the original clusters to the neuronal clusters, or dot plots showing marker gene expression for the neuronal clusters might both be useful. For example, right now it's difficult to interpret clusters like n8-13. a) We have revised the UMAP in Figure 3A, and labeled mature, immature, progenitor neurons so that it is easier to follow the developmental trajectory. b) In our revised text we have explicitly drawn equivalence between neuronal clusters from Figure 1 to re-clustered neurons in subsequent figures (Figure 3 and 4 in revised submission). For developmental analysis, we merged mature Gnao1, Gnai2 neuronal subclusters to two major clusters that are equivalent to original neuronal clusters in Figure 1. As UMAP is an arbitrary representation of cells, we also show expression of markers for major neuronal cell types in Figure 1C and Figure 3-figure supplement 1B, helpful in making the connection. c) The purpose of re-clustering with higher resolution was to identify sub-populations within Gnao1 and Gnai1 neurons. It was useful to make sense of mature Gnao1 neurons, where family-C Vmn2r and H2-Mv expression maps onto distinct subclusters. Along with neuronal subclusters in revised Figure 3-figure supplement-1 we include a dot plot of gene expression markers. d) In Figure 3-figure supplement-2, we show a comparison of neuronal clusters with and without VRs. Exclusion of VRs did not substantially alter mature neuron dichotomy into Gnao1/Gnai2. Only Gnao1 subclusters n1/n3 whose organization is dependent on family-C Vmn2r expression were affected, as well as redistribution of subcluster n8 from Gnai2 neurons. VR expression does not seem to be the primary determinant of VSN cluster identity. Reviewer #2 (Public Review): Summary: The study focuses on the vomeronasal organ, the peripheral chemosensory organ of the accessory olfactory system, by employing single-cell transcriptomics. The author analyzed the mouse vomeronasal organ, identifying diverse cell types through their unique gene expression patterns. Developmental gene expression analysis revealed that two classes of sensory neurons diverge in their maturation from common progenitors, marked by specific transient and persistent transcription factors. A comparative study between major neuronal subtypes, which differ in their G-protein sensory receptor families and G-protein subunits (Gnai2 and Gnao1, respectively), highlighted a higher expression of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) associated genes in Gnao1 neurons. Moreover, distinct differences in ER content and ultrastructure suggest some intriguing roles of ER in Gnao1-positive vomeronasal neurons. This work is likely to provide useful data for the community and is conceptually novel with the unique role of ER in a subset of vomeronasal neurons. This reviewer has some minor concerns and some suggestions to improve the manuscript. Strengths: (1) The study identified diverse cell types based on unique gene expression patterns, using single-cell transcriptomic. (2) The analysis suggests that two classes of sensory neurons diverge during maturation from common progenitors, characterized by specific transient and persistent transcription factors. (3) A comparative study highlighted differences in Gnai2- and Gnao1-positive sensory neurons. (4) Higher expression of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) associated genes in Gnao1 neurons. (5) Distinct differences in ER content and ultrastructure suggest unique roles of ER in Gnao1-positive vomeronasal neurons. (6) The research provides conceptually novel on the unique role of ER in a subset of vomeronasal neurons, offering valuable insights to the community. Weaknesses: (1) The connection between observations from sc RNA-seq and EM is unclear. (2) The lack of quantification for the ER phenotype is a concern. We have extensively quantified the ER phenotype as shown in Figure 7, Figure 7-figure supplement-1 in our revised version. We would like to point out that the connection between scRNA-seq and EM was made due to our observations in the same figures, that levels of a number of ER luminal and ER membrane proteins were higher in Gnao1 compared to Gnai2 neurons. This led us to hypothesize a differential ER content or ultrastructure, which was verified by EM. Reviewer #3 (Public Review): Summary: In this manuscript, Devakinandan and colleagues have undertaken a thorough characterization of the cell types of the mouse vomeronasal organ, focusing on the vomeronasal sensory neurons (VSNs). VSNs are known to arise from a common pool of progenitors that differentiate into two distinct populations characterized by the expression of either the G protein subunit Gnao1 or Gnai2. Using single-cell RNA sequencing followed by unsupervised clustering of the transcriptome data, the authors identified three Gnai2+ VSN subtypes and a single Gnao1+ VSN type. To study VSN developmental trajectories, Devakinandan and colleagues took advantage of the constant renewal of the neuronal VSN pool, which allowed them to harvest all maturation states. All neurons were re-clustered and a pseudotime analysis was performed. The analysis revealed the emergence of two pools of Gap43+ clusters from a common lineage, which differentiate into many subclusters of mature Gnao1+ and Gnai2+ VSNs. By comparing the transcriptomes of these two pools of immature VSNs, the authors identified a number of differentially expressed transcription factors in addition to known markers. Next, by comparing the transcriptomes of mature Gnao1+ and Gnai2+ VSNs, the authors report the enrichment of ER-related genes in Gnao1+ VSNs. Using electron microscopy, they found that this enrichment was associated with specific ER morphology in Gnao1+ neurons. Finally, the authors characterized chemosensory receptor expression and coexpression (as well as H2-Mv proteins) in mature VSNs, which recapitulated known patterns. Strengths: The data presented here provide new and interesting perspectives on the distinguishing features between Gnao1+ and Gnai2+ VSNs. These features include newly identified markers, such as transcription factors, as well as an unsuspected ER-related peculiarity in Gnao1+ neurons, consisting of a hypertrophic ER and an enrichment in ER-related genes. In addition, the authors provide a comprehensive picture of specific co-expression patterns of V2R chemoreceptors and H2-Mv genes. Importantly, the authors provide a browser (scVNOexplorer) for anyone to explore the data, including gene expression and co-expression, number and proportion of cells, with a variety of graphical tools (violin plots, feature plots, dot plots, ...). Weaknesses: The study still requires refined analyses of the data and rigorous quantification to support the main claims. The method description for filtering and clustering single-cell RNA-sequencing data is incomplete. The Seurat package has many available pipelines for single-cell RNA-seq analysis, with a significant impact on the output data. How did the authors pre-process and normalize the data? Was the pipeline used with default settings? What batch correction method was applied to the data to mitigate possible sampling or technical effects? Moreover, the authors do not describe how cell and gene filtering was performed. The data in Figure 7-Supplement 3 show that one-sixth of the V1Rs do not express any chemoreceptor, while over a hundred cells express more than one chemoreceptor. Do these cells have unusually high or low numbers of genes or counts? To exclude the possibility of a technical artifact in these observations, the authors should describe how they dealt with putative doublet cells or debris. Surprisingly, some clusters are characterized by the expression of specific chemoreceptors (VRs). Have these been used for clustering? If so, clustering should be repeated after excluding these receptors. The identification of the VSN types should be consistent across the different analyses and validated. The data presented in Figure 1 lists four mature VSN types, whereas the re-clustering of neurons presented in Figure 3 leads to a different subdivision. At present, it remains unclear whether these clusters reflect the biology of the system or are due to over-clustering of the data, and therefore correspond to either noise or arbitrary splitting of continua. Clusters should be merged if they do not correspond to discrete categories of cells, and correspondence should be established between the different clustering analyses. To validate the detected clusters as cell types, markers characteristic of each of these populations can be evaluated by ISH or IHC. There is a lack of quantification of imaging data, which provides little support for the ERrelated main claim. Quantification of co-expression and statistics on labeling intensity or coverage would greatly strengthen the conclusions and the title of the paper. a) scRNA-seq data analysis methods: Our revised submission has expanded on the methods section with details of parameters, filtering criterion and software used. b) Inclusion/exclusion of VRs: Figure 3-Figure supplement-2 of our revised submission shows a comparison of neuronal sub-clusters with and without VRs. Overall sub-cluster identities were not affected by VR exclusion, except for Gnao1 sub-clusters n1/n3 -governed by family C Vmn2r1/Vmn2r2 and redistribution of Gnai2 cluster n8. The minimal effect of VRs on Gnai2 sub-clustering can also be confirmed by lack of V1R in the dot plot showing markers of neuronal clusters. c) Neuronal clusters and potential over-clustering: we pooled neuronal cells from Figure-1 and re-clustered to identify sub-populations within Gnao1 and Gnai1 neurons. Several neuronal sub-clusters identified by us including progenitors, immature neurons and mature neurons are validated by previous studies with wellknown markers. Amongst the mature neurons, the biological basis of four Gnao1 neuron sub-clusters (n1-n4) is discussed in our co-expression section (Figure 4AE) and these are also validated by previous experimental studies. These Gnao1 clusters are organized according to the expression of family-C V2Rs (Vmn2r1 or Vmn2r2) as well as H2M_v_ genes. Within Gnai2 sub-clusters, n12 and n13 exclusively express markers that distinguish them from n8-n11 which we have described in our revised version. However, n8-n11 do not have definitive markers and whether these sub-clusters are part of a continuum or over-clustered, will require further extensive experiments and analysis. We prefer to show all subclusters, including Gnai2 sub-clusters, in Figure 3-Figure supplement-1, along with a dot plot of sub-cluster gene expression, so that this data is available for future experiments and analysis. We share the concern that some Gnai2 sub-clusters may not have an obvious biological basis at this time. Hence in our revised submission, we have merged mature Gnao1 and mature Gnai2 sub-clusters for the developmental analysis shown in Figure 3A. d) Quantification of the ER phenotype: In our revised submission, we provide extensive quantification of the ER phenotype in Figure 7, Figure7-figure supplement-1. e) We think that the cells expressing zero as well as two V1Rs are real and cannot be attributed to debris or doublets for the following reasons: i) Cells expressing no V1Rs are not necessarily debris because they express other neuronal markers at the same level as cells that express one or two V1Rs. For instance, Gnai2 expression level across cells expressing 0, 1, 2 V1Rs is the same, which we have included in Figure 4-figure supplement 4-C of our revised submission. Higher expression threshold value used in our analysis may have somewhat increased the proportion of cells with zero V1Rs. Similarly, Gnao1 levels across cells expressing multiple V2Rs and H2-M_v_ per cell stay the same, indicating that these are unlikely to be doublets (Figure 4 I-K). The frequency of each co-expression combination (Supplementary Table 7 and 8) itself is an indication of whether it is represented by a single cell or an artifact. ii) Cells co-expressing V1R genes: We listed the frequency of cells co-expressing V1R gene combinations in Supplementary table - 8. Among 134 cells that express two V1Rs, 44 cells express Vmn1r85+Vmn1r86, 21 express Vmn1r184+Vmn1r185, 13 express Vmn1r56+Vmn1r57, 6 express Vmn1r168+Vmn1r177, and so on. Doublets generally are a random combination of two cells. Here, each specific co-expression combination represents multiple cells and is highly unlikely by random chance. Some of the co-expression combinations we reported were also identified and verified experimentally in Lee et al., 2019 and Hills et. al., 2024. Recommendations for the authors: Reviewing Editor (Recommendations for the Authors): The editor had a query about the analysis of FPRs, which are a third family of sensory receptors in the rodent VNO. FPRs were found in our study as expressed in subsets of Gnai2 and Gnao1 neurons as well as non-neuronal cells. These can be easily searched in www.scvnoexplorer.com. For instance, Fpr1 and Fpr2 are expressed in immune cell clusters - 2,6,8,10; whereas Fpr-3 is expressed in Gnao1 subcluster n1. Consistent with earlier reports (10.1073/pnas.0904464106, 10.1038/nature08029) expression of Fpr-rs3, Fpr-rs4, Fprrs6, Fpr-rs7 is restricted to Gnai2 neurons, of which Fpr-rs3 and Fpr-rs4 are limited to Tmbim1+ Gnai2 neurons. Reviewer #1 (Recommendations For The Authors): (1) The reference to "genders" on page 3 should be changed to "sexes". We have modified the text. (2) Did the authors identify any Ascl1+ GBCs in their data? Ascl1+ GBCs were identified and are now marked in our revised version Figure3-figure supplement 1B. (3) The plots in Figures 1B and 2B say they're depicting gene "Expression", but it looks like the gene expression was z-scored. If so, the authors should describe how the expression was scaled. We have modified the legend title to ‘scaled expression’ and described the basis of scaling in the methods section of our revised version. (4) The main text mentions Figure 2C, but maybe this refers to the right part of Figure 2B? Panel 2C was mistakenly not marked in the figure. We have now marked it in revised Figure 2. (5) The authors should attempt to describe the other branch points in the trajectory shown in Figure 3A. If they don't seem biologically plausible, then the authors might want to reconsider using Slingshot for their analyses. We do not seek to claim additional branch points within mature Gnao1 or Gnai2 neurons from our analysis. Whether there exist additional branch points leading to subcategories within mature neurons, requires extensive experimental investigation. Hence, in our revised submission, we have merged mature Gnai2 / Gnao1 subclusters for pseudotime developmental analysis and to keep our analysis focused on the single branch point at immature neurons. (6) The most significantly enriched gene in Figure 3B in immature Gnao1+ neurons is Cnpy1, which is also an ER protein. It could also be interesting to look at its expression or speculate on its function in immature neurons. Multiple ER genes were found to be enriched in Gnao1 neurons. We would not be comfortable speculating on the function of individual genes, without a proper study, which is beyond the scope of this manuscript. (7) For figures with pseudo-colored expressions, it would be useful to have color bars. I'm also not sure the pseudocolors are necessary; presenting the data in grayscale or a single color like green might also be sufficient. We used pseudocolor in the IHC images of ER proteins, because there is a wide variation in the fluorescence signal intensity across apical to basal axis for various proteins. In some cases, gray scale images could lead to the false impression that there is no signal in apical Gnai2 neurons, whereas pseudocolor shows low fluorescence level in these neurons. We have added intensity scale bar to the figures in our revision version. (8) For in situ images with two colors it would be more colorblind-friendly to use green and magenta rather than green and red. Since no single color palette can help readers with different types of colorblindness, we decided to rely on user’s operating systems that offer rendering of the images to a color palette based on their type of colorblindness. We believe this would be a better option as described here: https://markusmeister.com/2021/07/26/figure-design-for-colorblindreaders-is-outdated/ (9) The heatmap in Figure 7E would likely look more accurate without interpolation/aliasing/smoothing. We have not performed smoothening on any of the heatmaps. We have noticed that sometimes heatmaps take time to load in software (such as Adobe Acrobat) leading to the impression of smoothing. Changing the zoom level or reopening the file may fix this. (10) Rather than just citing the literature on the unfolded protein response in the MOE, it could be useful to cite work on the ATF5 expression and the UPR in the VNO e.g. 10.1101/239830v1 or 10.12688/f1000research.13659.1. We have cited and commented on the ATF5 VNO expression in our discussion. (11) I might try to condense the discussion. Additionally, in the discussion, the section on receptor co-expression comes before that on the VNO ER, so I might consider reorganizing the figures and results to present all of the scRNA-seq analyses (including the receptor co-expression figure) first before the figures on the ER. We welcome this suggestion and have reorganized figures and results such that the scRNA-seq analysis flow is maintained before ER results. Reviewer #2 (Recommendations For The Authors): (1) Upregulation of ER-related mRNAs and expanded ER lumen in Gnao1-positive neurons is interesting, but the connection between these observations is unclear. The authors can strengthen the link by adding immunohistochemistry of representative ER proteins to test if the upregulation of mRNAs related to ER results in increased levels of these proteins in the ER of these neurons. Connection between scRNA-seq and EM was made due to our observations that levels of a number of ER luminal and membrane proteins were higher in Gnao1 compared to Gnai2 neurons (Figure 7, Figure 7-figure supplement-1 in our revised submission). This led us to hypothesize a differential ER content or ultrastructure, which was verified by EM. We have also addressed the question of whether upregulation of mRNAs related to ER proteins results in their increased levels (Figure 7-figure supplement-2). In some cases, for example Hspa5 (Bip), mRNA as well as protein levels are upregulated in Gnao1 neurons (see Figure 3A volcano plot, Figure 5-figure supplement-1 RNA-ISH, Figure 7-figure supplement-1 comparison of mRNA levels, Figure 7F immunofluorescence). However, there are other genes in the same figures, for which mRNA levels are not upregulated, yet protein levels are higher in Gnao1 neurons. As mentioned in our text and discussion, upregulated mRNA levels as well as post-transcriptional mechanisms are both likely to play a role in upregulating ER protein levels in Gnao1 neurons. (2) In Figure 3, the authors seemed to exclude cluster 13 from Figure1 in the pseudotime analysis without justification. Cluster13 has markers such as Obp2a, Obp2b, Lcn3. We confirmed via RNA-ISH (Figure 2-figure supplement-1A in our revised submission) that Obp2a maps to cells from glandular tissue on the non-sensory side. Cluster-13 also has cells expressing Vmn1r37, which typically is expressed in neuronal cells. However, we do not see Obp2a mRNA in the sensory epithelium. It is possible that cluster-13 comprises a heterogenous mixture of cells, some of which are non-sensory glandular cells, co-clustered with other cell types as well as the possibility that Obp2a is expressed in neurons, below the detection level of our assay. Further experiments will be required to distinguish between these possibilities. We do not have any possible reason to confidently assign this cluster as a neuronal cell type, hence, it was excluded in the downstream analysis of neurons. (3) In Figure 3, the line appears to suggest that Gnao1-positive cells can be progenitors of Gnai2-positive cells. Please clarify. We thank the reviewer for pointing this out. We did not seek to give the impression that Gnao1 cells can be progenitors of Gnai2 cells. This may be due to the placement of dots in the trajectory leading to misinterpretation and the UMAP itself. We have modified the pseudotime trajectory in our revised version to make it more intuitive. (4) Figure 3: Please label pseudotime lineage cluster identities. Cluster identities are now labeled in Figure 3A pseudotime lineage as well as in Figure 3-figure supplement-1 dot plot. (5) Figure 4: Please label the genes used for in situ hybridization in the volcano plot. Genes used for RNA-ISH are labeled (bold font) in the volcano plot in Figure 5A. (6) Figure 4: Please clarify which genes shown in the in situ hybridization figures correspond to which GO terms. We have added supplementary table-10 containing gene ontology terms associated with genes for which RNA-ISH was performed. (7) The EM shown in Figure 5 makes this work unique and intriguing. However, the lack of quantification for the ER phenotype is a concern. For example, does the ER area of a given cell correlate with the relative position of the cells along the apical-basal axis of the vomeronasal organ? What about the ER morphology in the progenitor cells? We show here a quantification of the ER area from the low magnification EM image shown in Figure 8A. The ER area shows an increase going towards the basal side of the cross-section. However, this quantification is complicated by the following factors: (a) Processing for EM, results in some shrinkage of the tissue, (b) Gnao1 neurons follow an invaginating pattern in cross-sections. Due to these reasons, some Gnao1 neurons could come very close to, and at times lie adjacent to Gnai2 neurons in EM cross-section. Due to a lack of contrast, it is harder to identify the ER within the cell at low mag, especially in the apical zone. The plot shown here does indicate that roughly, the ER area of a cell correlates with its position along the apical-basal axis. In our revised submission, we have quantified the fluorescence intensities of various ER proteins along the apical basal axis from confocal images (Figure 7, Figure 7-figure supplement-1). ROIs (yellow) are manually drawn in the sensory epithelium, wherever possible to identify ER without ambiguity. Area and centroid of ROI are calculated and x coordinates of centroid of each ROI are used to position ER area along the apical-basal axis as shown in the plot below. Establishing ER ultrastructure in progenitor or immature cells, as well as unambiguous quantification of ER area in mature neurons, requires identification of these cells in crosssections using fluorescent molecular markers, followed by performing correlative light and electron microscopy (CLEM). This procedure being technically challenging is beyond the scope of our manuscript. Reviewer #3 (Recommendations For The Authors): (1) The main claim is about ER differences between Gnao1+ and Gnai2+ VSN. The ISH, IHC, and EM microscopy images are not quantified and, therefore, poorly support this main claim. In our revised submission, we provide extensive quantification of the ER phenotype in Figure 7, Figure7-Figure supplement-1. Quantification of ER area from EM images is challenging and described above it in our response to reviewer #2 recommendation 7. (2) The annotation of VSN subclusters should be more rigorous, consistent throughout the paper (VSN clusters are inconsistent between Figure 1 and Figure 3, and the multiplication of subclusters in Figure 3 is not discussed), and verified (using ISH or IHC) that they reflect discrete, actual cell types. The authors should provide a list of differentiating marker genes for the clusters in Figure 3. At present, it remains unclear whether these clusters are the result of over-clustering of cells (and therefore represent either noise or arbitrary splits of continua) or whether they reflect the biology of the system. Subsequent characterization of these curated VSN subtypes (as done in Figure 4) would add value to the study. We pooled neuronal cells from Figure-1 and re-clustered at higher resolution to identify subtypes. Several neuronal sub-clusters identified by us including progenitors, immature neurons and mature neurons are validated by previous studies with well-known markers. Amongst the mature neurons, the biological basis of four Gnao1 neuron sub-clusters (n1n4) is discussed in our analysis and these are also validated by previous experimental studies. These Gnao1 clusters are organized according to the expression of family-C V2Rs (Vmn2r1 or Vmn2r2) as well as H2Mv genes. Within Gnai2 sub-clusters, n12 and n13 exclusively express markers that distinguish them from n8-n11 which we have described in our revised version. However, Gnai2 n8-n11 do not have definitive markers and whether these sub-clusters are part of a continuum or over-clustered, will require further extensive experiments and analysis. We prefer to show all sub-clusters, including Gnai2 sub-clusters, in Figure 3-Figure supplement-1, along with a dot plot of sub-cluster gene expression, so that this data is available for future experiments and analysis. We share the concern that some Gnai2 sub-clusters may not have an obvious biological basis at this time. Hence in our revised submission, we have merged mature Gnao1 and mature Gnai2 sub-clusters for the developmental analysis shown in Figure 3A. (3) Some clusters are characterized by the expression of specific chemoreceptors (VRs). Have these been used for clustering? If so, clustering should be repeated after excluding these receptors. Figure 3-Figure supplement-2 of our revised submission shows a comparison of neuron clusters with and without VRs. We also describe in the results, specific clusters that are affected by exclusion of VRs. (4) Given the title and the data, the paper should be structured around its main claim (i.e. differential ER environment between VSN types). For example, Figure 7, which deals with the characterization of receptor expression and co-expression in VSNs, is sandwiched between the validation of ER substructure (Figure 6) and the timing of coexpression of ER chaperone genes (Figure 8). The data presented in Figure 7 would fit better if used as a validation of the dataset prior to the investigation presented in the current Figure 4. In addition, we suggest that expression and co-expression diagnostics should be used to filter cells for subsequent analyses. We appreciate this suggestion and have reorganized the figures in our revised version. Our subsequent analysis showing enrichment of ER related genes at RNA, protein level covers all Gnao1 neurons and is not restricted to a specific subset. This is reflected in the ISH and IHC of ER genes. (5) Figure 7-Supplement 3 suggests the presence of co-expressed V1Rs in VSNs. It is unclear from the data presented whether these co-expressing cells are artifactual cell doublets and should be removed from the analysis or whether the expression of the coexpressed receptors reflects a reality. To better address this observation, one may want to see the expression levels of the individual co-expressed V1rs in Figure 7-Supplemet 3 rather than the sum of V1r expression. I am also concerned about the unusually high frequency of "empty" neurons (i.e. without expressed VRs). Could these be debris? We think that the cells expressing zero as well as two V1Rs are real and cannot be attributed to debris or doublets for the following reasons: i) Cells expressing no V1Rs are not necessarily debris because they express other neuronal markers at the same level as cells that express one or two V1Rs. For instance Gnai2 expression level across cells expressing 0, 1, 2 V1Rs is the same, which we have included in Figure 4-figure supplement 4-C of our revised submission. Higher expression threshold values used in our analysis may have somewhat increased the proportion of cells with zero V1Rs. Similarly, Gnao1 levels across cells expressing multiple V2Rs and H2-M_v_ per cell stay the same, indicating that these are unlikely to be doublets (Figure 4 I-K). As doublets are formed randomly, the frequency of each co-expression combination (Supplementary Table 7 and 8) itself is an indication of whether it is represented by a single cell or an artifact. ii) Cells co-expressing V1R genes: All cells used for co-expression analysis were filtered via an expression threshold (Figure 4-figure supplement 1D), which eliminates cells with low counts of V1R expression. We listed the frequency of cells co-expressing V1R gene combinations in Supplementary table - 8. Among 134 cells that express two V1Rs, 44 cells express Vmn1r85+Vmn1r86, 21 express Vmn1r184+Vmn1r185, 13 express Vmn1r56+Vmn1r57, 6 express Vmn1r168+Vmn1r177, and so on. Doublets generally are a random combination of two cells. Here, each specific co-expression combination represents multiple cells and is highly unlikely by random chance. iii) Some of the co-expression combinations we reported were identified earlier and verified experimentally in Lee et al., 2019 using FACS based single collection in 96-well plates following the cellseq-2 protocol with very low chance of doublets, and Hills et. al., 2024. (6) The authors use either dot plots or scatter plots to show gene expression in cell clusters. It looks nice, but it is very difficult to deduce population levels of expression from these plots. Could we see the distribution of gene expression across clusters using more quantitative visualizations such as violin or box plots? Dot plots are majorly used in our manuscript to show markers of cell clusters in Figure 1, Figure 2 and Figure 3-figure supplement 1. We would like to show at least 5 gene markers for each cluster that are important to identify the cell type. Using violin plot or bar plot for this will make the panel extremely big and overwhelming, especially with 16 clusters in Figure 1 and 13 clusters in Figure 3-figure supplement 1 or make the bars/violin too small to interpret. Hence, for the sake of simplicity, we used dot plots to give our reader a birds-eye of gene expression differences across clusters. Scatter plots were used when we want to compare the expression levels of genes between male and female samples and show the expression of two genes (VRs) simultaneously in a single cell. This cannot be achieved by Violin/box plot. However, we have made our dataset available at scvnoexplorer.com to explore the expression patterns across cell clusters with different visualization options, including violin or box plots. (7) To investigate whether sex might bias clustering, the authors calculated the Pearson coefficient of gene expression between sexes for each cluster. Given the high coefficient observed across all clusters (although no threshold is used), the authors conclude that there was no bias. While the overall effect may show a strong similarity in gene expression in each cluster between the sexes, this overlooks all the genes that are significantly differentially expressed. It would be worth investigating and discussing these differences. Relatedly, what batch correction method was applied to the data (to mitigate any possible sampling or technical effect)? We chose the Pearson coefficient as a representative parameter to show that there is no bias. In addition, we have performed differential expression analysis for each cluster and the results are in supplementary table-1. Except known sexually dimorphic genes, other genes are not differentially expressed significantly with adjusted p-values greater than 0.05. This was also shown by earlier studies using bulk RNAseq (doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1004593, doi.org/10.1186/s12864-017-4364-4). We used depth normalization to integrate samples and described this in the methods section of our revised version. (8) We found the method description to be incomplete for the single-cell RNA sequencing analyses. The method section should include a detailed explanation of the code used by the authors to analyze the data. The Seurat package has many available pipelines for single-cell RNA-seq analysis, which have a major impact on the output data. It is therefore imperative to describe which of these pipelines were used and whether the pipeline was run with default settings. Our revised submission has expanded on the methods section with details of parameters, filtering criterion and software used.