Airborne-Particle Abrasion vs. Hydrofluoric Acid Etching of Dental Ceramics: Impact on the Tensile Bond Strength Authors: Valerie Lankes, Andrea Coldea, John Meinen, Falk Schwendicke, Bogna Stawarczyk Published: 2024 ABSTRACT This study evaluated whether airborne-particle abrasion could be an alternative to hydrofluoric acid etching as a pretreatment for the adhesive bonding of silicate ceramic restorations. Feldspar (FEL; n = 100), lithium silicate (LiSi; n = 100), and zirconia (ZrO2; (n = 80) substrates were CAD/CAM-fabricated and airborne-particle-abraded with Al2O3 (25 µm or 50 µm of mean particle size) at pressures of 0.05 or 0.1 MPa. The controls included FEL (60 s) and LiSi (20 s) etched with hydrofluoric acid. The surface free energy (SFE) and roughness (Ra) were measured. For the tensile bond strength (TBS), surfaces were conditioned using a primer (Monobond Plus) and luted to a resin composite (Variolink Esthetic). TBS was assessed initially (24 h, 37 °C water storage) and after thermocycling (5/55 °C, 10,000×). Statistical analysis (SPSS, V29) was performed using a one-way ANOVA, post hoc Scheffé, and a two-group t-test (p = 0.05). Abrasion with 50 µm and 0.1 MPa induced the highest Ra values across the materials (62.5 ± 3.88 µm). ZrO2 exhibited a higher TBS (35.4–49.5 MPa) than FEL and LiSi. For aged LiSi, the specimens treated at 0.1 MPa showed a higher TBS (18.7 ± 9.0 MPa) than those treated at 0.05 MPa, regardless of the particle size. The etched and aged FEL showed a higher SFE but a lower TBS compared to abrasion. Al2O3 particle abrasion (25 or 50 µm at 0.1 MPa) may replace etching for silicate-based ceramics, while 50 µm is recommended for ZrO2 at either pressure. 1. Introduction Hydrofluoric acid (HF) is widely used in dentistry for etching silicate-based ceramics to enhance the bonding of restorations, such as crowns, bridges, and veneers [1]. However, the improper handling of HF can result in severe chemical burns to skin and eyes, posing significant risks to dental professionals and patients [2]. Additionally, HF can damage porcelain sinks and work surfaces, necessitating extreme caution when using this corrosive substance. HF etches silicate-based ceramics by selectively dissolving the glassy (SiO2) matrix, creating a roughened surface that enhances micromechanical retention for bonding [3]. The etching pattern, optimal etching time (from 20 s to 240 s), and HF concentration (1–10%) depend on the ceramics’ composition [4,5,6]. Feldspar ceramics, such as leucite-reinforced or feldspathic ceramics, consist predominantly of a glassy matrix with dispersed crystalline phases like leucite. Lithium disilicate ceramics have a higher crystalline content, composed mainly of lithium disilicate crystals within a glassy matrix [7]. These compositional differences affect their mechanical, optical, and chemical properties, influencing the etching behavior and bonding protocols [8]. Despite the efficacy of HF etching, concerns about its toxicity and handling risks have led to the exploration of alternative surface treatments. Given that airborne-particle abrasion with alumina (Al2O3) particles is successfully used for surface cleaning and the roughening of most other dental materials [9], its application to silicate-based materials represents a logical alternative to explore. Zirconia ceramics, due to their high crystallinity and lack of a glassy phase, are not susceptible to HF etching. Instead, airborne-particle abrasion with Al2O3 particles is employed to create micromechanical retention for bonding [10,11]. The effectiveness of airborne-particle abrasion depends on variables such as abrasive particle size, pressure, distance, angle of application, and duration. For delicate ceramic restorations, finer particles (e.g., 25–50 µm) are used to achieve adequate surface roughness without compromising the integrity of the restoration [12]. However, excessive airborne-particle abrasion pressure or inappropriate particle size may lead to surface damage or the alteration of the restoration’s fit [13]. Therefore, selecting appropriate airborne-particle abrasion factors is crucial for the effective and safe surface conditioning of zirconia restorations. Besides micromechanical retention, chemical bonding is crucial for durable adhesion and for the stability and integrity of the restoration itself. Universal primers containing functional monomers like 10-methacryloyloxydecyl dihydrogen phosphate (MDP) facilitate chemical bonding to metal oxides and zirconia surfaces [14]. For silicate-based ceramics, silane coupling agents are used to enhance adhesion by forming covalent bonds between the silica in the ceramic and the resin matrix [15,16]. The combination of appropriate surface treatments and primers is essential to achieve optimal bond strength. Earlier studies have reported acceptable bond strengths ranging from 7 to 15 MPa when silicate-based ceramics were airborne-abraded using alumina particles sized between 25 and 50 µm. However, these studies employed very high pressures (0.25–0.4 MPa), which could potentially damage the ceramic and compromise its mechanical properties [17,18,19,20]. Moreover, these studies often lacked artificial aging processes to simulate clinical conditions [21,22,23]. Simulating intraoral conditions is essential for evaluating the long-term durability of the ceramic–resin bond. Thermocycling is commonly used to mimic thermal stresses and water exposure in the oral environment by subjecting specimens to repeated temperature changes between 5 °C and 55 °C [24,25]. The aim of this study was to investigate whether silicate-based ceramics can be effectively bonded without the need for acid pretreatment, utilizing airborne-particle abrasion in conjunction with a ceramic primer. Additionally, the study aimed to evaluate the airborne-particle abrasion parameters for ZrO2 restorations. These tests were conducted in close proximity to clinical conditions, incorporating an artificial aging process. The null hypothesis posited that neither the alumina particle size nor the pressure would influence surface properties (surface free energy and surface roughness), and that neither the material composition, pretreatment variables (alumina particle size and pressure), nor aging would impact the tensile bond strength. Within silicate-based ceramics, it was assumed that there would be no difference in bond strength between etched and airborne-abraded surfaces. Comparing different airborne-particle abrasion parameters, such as the particle size and pressure, is clinically significant as these factors directly impact the mechanical properties. Moreover, selecting appropriate parameters for each type of restorative ceramic is essential to achieve sufficient bond strength while minimizing adverse effects on mechanical properties. 2. Materials and Methods 2.1. Specimen Preparation In this in vitro study, three different CAD/CAM ceramics, (i) feldspar [FEL] (VITABLOCS Mark II, VITA Zahnfabrik, Bad Säckingen, Germany, Lot.Nr.: 93910), (ii) lithium silicate [LiSi] (IPS e.max CAD, Ivoclar, Schaan, Liechtenstein, Lot.Nr.: R49412), and (iii) 3 mol% yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystal (3Y-TZP) [ZrO2] (Lava Plus, Solventum, Seefeld, Germany Lot.Nr.: 468470), were investigated (Figure 1). Using an automatic precision cutting machine (Secotom-50, Struers, Ballerup, Denmark), the ceramic blocks were sectioned under water cooling into 280 equal-sized substrates (7.5 × 7.5 × 2 mm3; FEL: n = 100, LiSi: n = 100, ZrO2: n = 80). LiSi substrates, cut in their pre-crystallized state, were crystalli