Translation, Cultural Adaptation, and Validation of the Spanish Version of the Person-Centred Practice Inventory-Staff (PCPI-S) Authors: Ana Carvajal-Valcárcel, Edgar Benitez, Marta Lizarbe-Chocarro, María José Galán-Espinilla, Mónica Vázquez-Calatayud, Begoña Errasti-Ibarrondo, Ana Choperena, Brendan McCormack, Vaibhav Tyagi, Virginia La Rosa-Salas, Pablo Martínez-Angulo, Luís Ángel Pérula-De-Torres, Pedro E Ventura-Puertos Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractBackground: Person-centredness, a global movement in healthcare, is consistent with international developments in healthcare policy. It is important to have instruments to measure person-centred care. The Person-Centred Practice Inventory-Staff (PCPI-S) is an internationally recognized instrument that aims to measure how healthcare staff experience person-centred practice. Aim: To perform the cultural adaptation and psychometric testing of a Spanish version of the PCPI-S (PCPI-S (Sp)). Method: A two-stage research design was implemented as follows: (1) the translation and cultural adaptation of the PCPI-S from English to Spanish using the “Translation and Cultural Adaptation of Patient Reported Outcomes Measures-Principles of Good Practice”; (2) a quantitative cross-sectional survey for the psychometric evaluation of the PCPI-S. Test–retest reliability was evaluated using the Kendall tau concordance coefficient, internal reliability was assessed through the ordinal theta (OT) coefficient, and confirmatory factor analysis was performed to examine the theoretical measurement model. Results: A Spanish version of the PCPI-S was obtained. There were no significant difficulties in the translation process or the consulting sessions. A sample of 287 healthcare professionals participated in the study at least once. All the items showed at least a fair level of test–retest reliability. The OT scores were adequate (>0.69). The model showed good to adequate levels of fit: CFI = 0.89, SRMR = 0.068; RMSEA = 0.060 with CI90% (0.056–0.063). Conclusions: The Spanish translation of the PCPI-S was psychometrically valid when tested with Spanish healthcare professionals. This instrument will help identify professionals’ perceptions of person-centred practice, track the evolution of this practice over time, and assess interventions aimed at improving person-centred practice.Keywords: cross-cultural adaptation, healthcare provider, measures, PCPI-S, person-centred care, person-centred practice, psychometric properties 1. Introduction Person-centredness has become a global movement in healthcare [1,2] and is consistent with international developments in healthcare policy [3]. In Crossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System Report, the Institute of Medicine (IOM) emphasized the centrality and importance of person-centredness as one of the six major aims for improvement [4]. More recently, the World Health Organization (WHO) in the Sixty-Ninth World Health Assembly [5] stated that developing more integrated people-centred care systems has the potential to generate significant benefits in healthcare, including “improved access to care, improved health and clinical outcomes, better health literacy and self-care, increased satisfaction with care, improved job satisfaction for health workers, improved efficiency of services, and reduced overall costs” [5] (p. 2). Furthermore, the juxtaposition of person-centred integrated care models with a health promotion/public health approach has recently been identified as a possible means to improve health and wellbeing outcomes for individuals, communities, and populations [6,7]. It is widely acknowledged that person (and family)-centred care focuses on the whole person as a unique individual and not just on his or her illness or disease. In viewing the individual through this lens, healthcare providers come to know and understand the person’s life story, his or her experience of health, the role of the family in the person’s life, and the role they may play in supporting the person to achieve health outcomes [8]. Likewise, person-centred health systems enable individuals to make informed decisions about and to successfully manage their own health and care [9]. In addition, evidence shows that meeting the needs of the patient within a person-centred care (PCC) approach is imperative for an efficient and effective healthcare system [10,11]. This requires healthcare services to work in partnership to deliver care responsive to people’s individual abilities, preferences, lifestyles, and goals [9]. As person-centredness is central to healthcare, it has often been conceptualized as a singular concept in different frameworks and models. These include relationship-centred care [12], compassionate care [13], and dignified care [14]. However, none of these models adopt a holistic perspective of person-centredness or integrate the main attributes that help to understand the person as a whole. In this regard, the person-centred practice framework (PCPF) developed by McCormack and McCance [3] is an internationally recognized theoretical framework that assists healthcare professionals in fully understanding all the dimensions that integrate person-centredness and how these dimensions can be operationalized in practice [15]. This framework has been applied for more than a decade, and although it was designed in the field of nursing practice, it is currently situated within healthcare systems more broadly [16]. The PCPF includes four main domains: prerequisites, the care environment, person-centred processes, and person-centred outcomes (Figure 1 [3]). The four domains are nested within a fifth domain, the macro context of the person-centred health setting [16]. As shown in Table 1, the domains include their corresponding defining constructs. From this point of view, staff, who are an essential element of the prerequisites domain, are considered necessary to manage the care environment to provide effective care by means of person-centred processes. This process leads to the achievement of the outcome of a healthful culture, which is the central domain of the framework. Furthermore, this framework goes a step further by suggesting that a healthful caring culture should focus not only on the person receiving care but also on staff well-being. As such, the framework also asserts that the environment in which healthcare is experienced should ensure the individual health and well-being of all those involved in PCC [16]. Person Centred Practice Framework (PCPF) by McCormack, B., McCance, T. (2021) [3,16]. Table 1Theoretical framework that underpins the PCPI-Staff and the items of each construct.DimensionsConstructsItemsPrerequisites1. Professionally competent32. Developed interpersonal skills43. Being committed to the job54. Knowing self35. Clarity of beliefs and values3Care environment6. Skill mix37. Shared decision-making systems48. Effective staff relationships39. Power sharing410. Potential for innovation and risk taking311. The physical environment312. Supportive organizational systems5Care processes13. Working with patients’ beliefs and values414. Shared decision-making315. Engagement316. Having sympathetic presence317. Providing holistic care3Total items59 Theoretical framework that underpins the PCPI-Staff and the items of each construct. Based on the PCPF, three instruments have been developed: The Person-Centred Practice Inventory-Staff (PCPI-S) [15], the Person-Centred Practice Inventory-Student (PCPI-ST) [17], and the Person-Centred Practice Inventory-Care (PCPI-C) [18]. Specifically, the PCPI-S was developed for healthcare staff with the aim of measuring how they experience person-centred practice. Paying attention to staff experiences is not common in other instruments that assess PCC [9,19]. As stated above, an additional strength of the PCPI-S is that unlike other instruments, it maps onto a theoretical framework [15,20]. Similarly, in contrast to other Spanish-translated instruments that are primarily used in elderly care services [19,21,22], the PCPI-S is designed to assess person-centred practice in a broader range of healthcare settings (hospitals, primary care, nursing homes, long-term care, etc.). Finally, this instrument has been validated in Norwegian [1], German [23], Malaysian [24], and Korean [25], showing good psychometric properties. However, it has not yet been translated and validated in Spanish, which is the fourth most spoken language in the world and the official language of most Latin American countries [26]. In sum, this tool is based on the PCPF, measures the key elements of the culture and context that contribute to the development of person-centred practice from the perspective of healthcare professionals, and can be used in different healthcare settings [3]. Accordingly, this instrument is anticipated to enable practitioners to evaluate their level of person-centred practice, thereby serving as a foundation for the development and implementation of targeted interventions aimed at advancing their professional growth. Likewise, this instrument will assist managers and supervisors across diverse healthcare settings by enabling the assessment of PCC levels among healthcare professionals, while also identifying barriers and facilitators to the delivery of PCC. This comprehensive understanding will support the design, implementation, and evaluation of interventions aimed at enhancing person-centred practices at individual, environmental, and care process levels. Hence, there is significant interest in developing a translated and validated Spanish version of the PCPI-S. This would facilitate the conduct of interterritorial studies within Spain, a country characterized by the coexistence of multiple regional languages, while Spanish serves as the common official language. This interest stems from the growing focus on developing PCC policies, programs, approaches, and/or initiatives in Spain, all aimed at the humanization of care [27,28,29,30,31,32,33]. 2. Methods The aim of this study was to carry out the cultural adaptation and psychometric testing of a Spanish version of the PCPI-S (PCPI-S (Sp)). The following two-stage research design was used: (1) translation and cultural adaptation of the PCPI-S from English to Spanish and (2) a quantitative cross-sectional survey for the psychometric evaluation of the PCPI-S. Description of the Instrument Description of the Instrument The PCPI-S consists of 59 items drawn from 17 constructs of the PCPF [15]. All the items are measured on a five-point Likert scale (1-strongly disagree to 5-strongly agree). The PCPI-S has shown good psychometric properties in the following different languages: Norwegian [1] (α = 0.88–0.93), German [23] (α = 0.90–0.94), Malaysian [24] (α = 0.59–0.86), and Korean [25] (α = 0.95). The aim of the instrument is to measure healthcare professionals’ perceptions of PCC in any healthcare context. This instrument provides a numerical score, but it does not aim to quantify how healthcare professionals provide PCC. It guides how professionals perceive PCC [15]. 2.1. Phase 1: Translation and Cultural Adaptation Participants Participants The participants in this phase included the principal investigator, the author of the questionnaire, two forward translators (Spanish native speakers fluent in English from the healthcare context and with knowledge of PCC), two back translators (English native speakers fluent in Spanish), an expert in humanities to correct lexicon-semantic errors, an expert in psychometric properties, a panel of six experts, and a group of five healthcare professionals who tested the instrument. Description of the Procedure Description of the Procedure The PCPI-S was translated into Spanish following the guide of the “Translation and Cultural Adaptation of Patient Reported Outcomes Measures-Principles of Good Practice” [34]. The steps that were carried out according to this guide were as follows: Preparation: The principal investigator contacted one of the authors of the questionnaire. Preparation: The principal investigator contacted one of the authors of the questionnaire. Forward translation: The forward translators translated the questionnaire from English to Spanish (Spanish version or SV) (SV1 and SV2). Forward translation: The forward translators translated the questionnaire from English to Spanish (Spanish version or SV) (SV1 and SV2). Reconciliation: From the two forward translations (SV1 and SV2) of the questionnaire, a single forward translation in Spanish (SV3) was obtained by consensus of a committee composed of the forward translators, the principal investigator, and an expert in PCC. Reconciliation: From the two forward translations (SV1 and SV2) of the questionnaire, a single forward translation in Spanish (SV3) was obtained by consensus of a committee composed of the forward translators, the principal investigator, and an expert in PCC. Back translation: The back translators translated the new Spanish version (SV3) into English (English version or EV) (EV1 and EV2). Back translation: The back translators translated the new Spanish version (SV3) into English (English version or EV) (EV1 and EV2). Back translation review: The committee that participated in the reconciliation obtained a new English version (EV3) of the questionnaire. Back translation review: The committee that participated in the reconciliation obtained a new English version (EV3) of the questionnaire. Harmonization: The EV3 was compared with the English translation of the Norwegian versions of the PCPI-S. Harmonization: The EV3 was compared with the English translation of the Norwegian versions of the PCPI-S. Cognitive debriefing: An expert group—heterogeneous in terms of academic education, academic discipline, and person-centred practice education—assessed the clarity and relevance of the SV3 using a Likert scale from 1 (not clear or relevant) to 4 (strongly clear or relevant). Likewise, a small group of healthcare professionals tested the instrument. Both the expert group and the healthcare professionals were asked about their perception after completing the questionnaire. The time for completion of the questionnaire was also registered. Cognitive debriefing: An expert group—heterogeneous in terms of academic education, academic discipline, and person-centred practice education—assessed the clarity and relevance of the SV3 using a Likert scale from 1 (not clear or relevant) to 4 (strongly clear or relevant). Likewise, a small group of healthcare professionals tested the instrument. Both the expert group and the healthcare professionals were asked about their perception after completing the questionnaire. The time for completion of the questionnaire was also registered. Review of the cognitive debriefing results: To assess the content validity of the instrument, the content validity index (I-CVI) and the scale content validity (S-CVI/Ave) were calculated. A content analysis of the comments suggested by the experts and the healthcare professionals was carried out. The author of the questionnaire was asked to clarify discrepancies. Review of the cognitive debriefing results: To assess the content validity of the instrument, the content validity index (I-CVI) and the scale content validity (S-CVI/Ave) were calculated. A content analysis of the comments suggested by the experts and the healthcare professionals was carried out. The author of the questionnaire was asked to clarify discrepancies. Proofreading: One of the study researchers who is an expert on humanities corrected the lexicon-semantic (words), morphosyntactic (concordance among gender and verb tense), and orthographic errors from the last version achieved in consensus with the project manager. Proofreading: One of the study researchers who is an expert on humanities corrected the lexicon-semantic (words), morphosyntactic (concordance among gender and verb tense), and orthographic errors from the last version achieved in consensus with the project manager. Final report: The principal investigator wrote the final report, including the process and methodologies used. Final report: The principal investigator wrote the final report, including the process and methodologies used. Data Analysis Data Analysis Clarity and relevance were determined by the item content validity index (I-CVI), which assesses the quality and relevance of each individual item, and the scale content validity index (S-CVI/Ave), which refers to the extent to which an instrument adequately captures the domain or construct it is intended to measure. To obtain the I-CVI, the number of observers who scored the items with 3 or 4 was divided by the total number of observers. Moreover, the kappa statistic was calculated to identify the degree of agreement beyond chance. The results were interpreted according to the Cicchetti and Sparrow classification [35]. The content validity of the entire instrument (S-CVI/Ave) was calculated as the average of the I-CVIs and was interpreted as excellent if the value obtained was greater than 0.90 [36]. 2.2. Phase 2: Psychometric Properties Settings and Participants Settings and Participants The instrument was tested in a sample of health professionals from seven different settings: four hospitals (two private Clínica Universidad de Navarra and Clínica San Miguel) and two public (Hospital Universitario de Navarra and Hospital Reina Sofía)), primary care, and two public nursing homes (Amma Mutilva and Amma Oblatas). The sample comprised all healthcare professionals who were working within those settings with patients and families, who had any experience with PCC and who were willing to participate in the study. Ethical Committee Ethical Committee The study was approved by the Ethics Committee on Clinical Research (CEIC) at Universidad de Navarra (2021.125 Mod1) and the Ethics Committee on Clinical Research at Departamento de Salud, Gobierno de Navarra (PI_2021/141). One of the authors of the PCPI-S (B.M.), who is part of the project, provided authorization to validate the instrument. Description of the Procedure Description of the Procedure Once the manager of the centers provided the authorization, the questionnaire was disseminated online via the weekly newsletter of the hospitals, leaflets in the units, or the unit managers. The gatekeeper of each setting promoted participation in the study. All healthcare professionals willing to participate had access to the information sheet, questionnaire, and consent form online. The participants who agreed to participate provided the following information: Age, sex, profession, years of experience, and setting. Then, they completed the questionnaire. Those participants who wanted to complete the questionnaire for the retest provided their email address as well as their consent to contact them. Three weeks later, an email was sent to them with the questionnaire link and one week later, a reminder. Sample Size Sample Size Based on the guidelines provided by MacCallum, Browne, and Sugawara (1996) [37], the required sample size to achieve a statistical power of 80% was calculated. The analysis used the following input parameters: α = 0.05 (level of significance), RMSEA (null hypothesis) = 0.05 (close fit under the null hypothesis), RMSEA (alternative hypothesis) = 0.08 (adequate fit under the alternative hypothesis), and df = 1364 (degrees of freedom). The results indicated that a minimum sample size of 200 was necessary to meet the desired level of statistical power. This analysis confirms that the sample size used in the study is adequate for the analyses conducted. Statistical Analysis Statistical Analysis Preliminary, skewness, and kurtosis statistics were evaluated for all items (Table S1). Sixteen items were identified to have absolute values above the two units considered as the cut-off point for an approximation to a normal distribution [38]. Starting from this deviation from the normal approximation, the test–retest validity was evaluated using the Kendall tau concordance coefficient [39,40]. In the same sense, the correlation coefficients shown in Table S1 are polychoric. The internal reliability evaluation of the constructs was performed using the ordinal theta (OT) coefficient, proposed by Zumbo et al. [41]. In accordance with the two-step approach proposed by Anderson and Gerbing for performing factor analysis and evaluating causal relationships [42], confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) was performed using the simplest possible model, where all factors were correlated. The estimation of the CFA was performed using the robust two-stage maximum likelihood (RML) method [38]. For the validation and evaluation of the fit, the values proposed by Hu and Bentler (1999) [43] were used: 1) comparative fit index (CFI) > 0.95 and standardized root mean square residual (SRMR) < 0.09 or 2) root mean square error of approximation (RMSEA) < 0.05 and SRMR < 0.06. Modifications to the model and the restriction or release of parameters were performed using Wald’s test and Lagrange multipliers, respectively. Changes were accepted if the variations in χ2 values were significant at p < 0.05, and if there was a theoretical justification for said modification. Modifications to the model were made one at a time. The reliability and validity of the constructs were evaluated in the final model with the following goodness-of-fit criteria: item reliability >0.39, composite reliability >0.7, and variance extracted >0.49 units [44,45]. Convergent validity was assessed by t-tests on parameters and discriminant validity on the ±2 standard errors around the correlation between factors. Data analysis was performed using SAS version 9.4. 3. Results 3.1. Phase 1: Translation and Cultural Adaptation Preparation: Permission for the translation of the questionnaire was obtained from the author of the questionnaire (BM). Preparation: Permission for the translation of the questionnaire was obtained from the author of the questionnaire (BM). Forward translation: Two forward translations from English to Spanish were performed (Spanish version or SV) (SV1 and SV2) by two fluent speakers. The mean time for the translation was two hours each. Forward translation: Two forward translations from English to Spanish were performed (Spanish version or SV) (SV1 and SV2) by two fluent speakers. The mean time for the translation was two hours each. Reconciliation: A new Spanish version (SV3) merged from the two forward translations (SV1 and SV2) was obtained. Consensus was achieved by a committee composed of the principal investigator and the forward translators. They resolved discrepancies between the forward translation (e.g., they clarified the term “evidence”; they discussed the Spanish word “feedback” that was maintained in English because it is also used in the Spanish context; and they considered it appropriate to use the word “care” in the whole questionnaire due to the similar meaning of the term “care” for all healthcare professionals). Reconciliation: A new Spanish version (SV3) merged from the two forward translations (SV1 and SV2) was obtained. Consensus was achieved by a committee composed of the principal investigator and the forward translators. They resolved discrepancies between the forward translation (e.g., they clarified the term “evidence”; they discussed the Spanish word “feedback” that was maintained in English because it is also used in the Spanish context; and they considered it appropriate to use the word “care” in the whole questionnaire due to the similar meaning of the term “care” for all healthcare professionals). Back translation: Two back translations were performed (English version or EV) (EV1 and EV2). The translations were conceptual rather than literal to maintain the key concepts of the questionnaire. The back translators did not have problems carrying out the translation. Back translation: Two back translations were performed (English version or EV) (EV1 and EV2). The translations were conceptual rather than literal to maintain the key concepts of the questionnaire. The back translators did not have problems carrying out the translation. Back translation review: The committee obtained a new English version of the questionnaire (EV3). This version was revised by the author of the questionnaire, and it was suggested that 12 items be modified. Back translation review: The committee obtained a new English version of the questionnaire (EV3). This version was revised by the author of the questionnaire, and it was suggested that 12 items be modified. Harmonization: The author of the questionnaire did not identify significant differences among the versions. Harmonization: The author of the questionnaire did not identify significant differences among the versions. Cognitive debriefing: A group of six healthcare professionals participated in a panel of experts. They were clinical, academic–clinical, and health managers. Four of them had knowledge and experience with PCC. One of them had experience in psychometric validation. Moreover, five healthcare professionals (one physician, three nurses, and one assistant nurse) completed the questionnaire in an average time of six minutes. Cognitive debriefing: A group of six healthcare professionals participated in a panel of experts. They were clinical, academic–clinical, and health managers. Four of them had knowledge and experience with PCC. One of them had experience in psychometric validation. Moreover, five healthcare professionals (one physician, three nurses, and one assistant nurse) completed the questionnaire in an average time of six minutes. Regarding clarity, 53/59 of the items had an excellent I-CVI, and 6/59 had an acceptable I-CVI (Table 2). The S-CVI/Ave was excellent, at 0.90. Regarding relevance, the I-CVI was excellent for all the items, and the S-CVI/Ave was 0.96. Regarding clarity, 53/59 of the items had an excellent I-CVI, and 6/59 had an acceptable I-CVI (Table 2). The S-CVI/Ave was excellent, at 0.90. Regarding relevance, the I-CVI was excellent for all the items, and the S-CVI/Ave was 0.96. Review of the cognitive debriefing results: The minor changes suggested by the experts were made to items 18, 45, 47, 52, and 54 (Table 3). The healthcare professionals considered that the questionnaire was easy to understand and included all the relevant aspects of their clinical practice. Review of the cognitive debriefing results: The minor changes suggested by the experts were made to items 18, 45, 47, 52, and 54 (Table 3). The healthcare professionals considered that the questionnaire was easy to understand and included all the relevant aspects of their clinical practice. Proofreading: Lexicon-semantic, morphosyntactic, and orthographic errors were corrected in the following five items: 12, 35, 38, 44, and 46. Proofreading: Lexicon-semantic, morphosyntactic, and orthographic errors were corrected in the following five items: 12, 35, 38, 44, and 46. Final report: The final version of the questionnaire was obtained. Final report: The final version of the questionnaire was obtained. Table 2Clarity and relevance of the Spanish version of the Person-Centred Practice Inventory-Staff (PCPI-S). ClarityRelevance I-CVIK *EvaluationI-CVIK *Evaluation Professionally competent Item 1I have the necessary skills to negotiate care options11 11ExcellentItem 2When I provide care I pay attention to more than the immediate physical task11Excellent11ExcellentItem 3I actively seek opportunities to extend my professional competence0.830.81Excellent0.830.81Excellent Developed interpersonal skills Item 4I ensure I hear and acknowledge others’ perspectives0.670.57Acceptable11ExcellentItem 5In my communication I demonstrate respect for others0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 6I use different communication techniques to find mutually agreed solutions0.830.81Excellent0.830.81ExcellentItem 7I pay attention to how my non-verbal cues impact on my engagement with others11Excellent11Excellent Being committed to the job Item 8I strive to deliver high-quality care to people0.830.81Excellent0.670.57AcceptableItem 9I seek opportunities to get to know the person and their family in order to provide holistic care0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 10I go out of my way to spend time with people receiving care11Excellent11ExcellentItem 11I strive to deliver high-quality care that is informed by evidence0.830.81Excellent0.830.81ExcellentItem 12I continuously look for opportunities to improve the care experiences0.670.57Acceptable0.830.81Excellent Knowing self Item 13I take time to explore why I react as I do in certain situations11Excellent11ExcellentItem 14I use reflection to check out if my actions are consistent with my ways of being0.830.81Excellent0.830.81ExcellentItem 15I pay attention to how my life experiences influence my practice11Excellent11Excellent Clarity of beliefs and values Item 16I actively seek feedback from others about my practice0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 17I challenge colleagues when their practice is inconsistent with our team’s shared values and beliefs11Excellent11ExcellentItem 18I support colleagues to develop their practice to reflect the team’s shared values and beliefs0.830.81Excellent11Excellent Skill mix Item 19I recognize when there is a deficit in knowledge and skills in the team and its impact on care delivery11Excellent11ExcellentItem 20I am able to make the case when the skill mix falls below acceptable levels0.830.81Excellent0.830.81ExcellentItem 21I value the input from all team members and their contributions to care11Excellent11Excellent Shared decision-making systems Item 22I actively participate in team meetings to inform my decision-making0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 23I participate in organization-wide decision-making forums that impact on practice11Excellent11ExcellentItem 24I am able to access opportunities to actively participate in influencing decisions in my directorate/division11Excellent11ExcellentItem 25My opinion is sought in clinical decision-making forums (e.g, ward rounds, case conferences, discharge planning)11Excellent11Excellent Effective staff relationships Item 26I work in a team that values my contribution to person-centred care11Excellent11ExcellentItem 27I work in a team that encourages everyone’s contribution to person-centred care11Excellent11ExcellentItem 28My colleagues positively role model the development of effective relationships0.830.81Excellent0.830.81Excellent Power sharing Item 29The contribution of colleagues is recognized and acknowledged0.670.57Acceptable11ExcellentItem 30I actively contribute to the development of shared goals11Excellent11ExcellentItem 31The leader facilitates participation11Excellent11ExcellentItem 32I am encouraged and supported to lead developments in practice11Excellent11Excellent Potential for innovation and risk taking Item 33I am supported to do things differently to improve my practice11Excellent0.830.81ExcellentItem 34I am able to balance the use of evidence with taking risks0.670.57Acceptable0.830.81ExcellentItem 35I am committed to enhancing care by challenging practice0.830.81Excellent11Excellent The physical environment Item 36I pay attention to the impact of the physical environment on people’s dignity11Excellent11ExcellentItem 37I challenge others to consider how different elements of the physical environment impact on person-centredness (e.g., noise, light, heat, etc.)11Excellent11ExcellentItem 38I seek out creative ways of improving the physical environment11Excellent0.830.81Excellent Supportive organizational systems Item 39In my team we take time to celebrate our achievements11Excellent11ExcellentItem 40My organization recognizes and rewards success11Excellent11ExcellentItem 41I am recognized for the contribution that I make to people having a good experience of care11Excellent0.830.81ExcellentItem 42I am supported to express concerns about an aspect of care11Excellent0.830.81ExcellentItem 43I have the opportunity to discuss my practice and professional development on a regular basis11Excellent11Excellent Working with patients’ beliefs and values Item 44I integrate my knowledge of the person into care delivery0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 45I work with the person within the context of their family and carers11Excellent11ExcellentItem 46I seek feedback on how people make sense of their care experience0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 47I encourage people to discuss what is important to them0.830.81Excellent11Excellent Shared decision-making Item 48I include the family in care decisions where appropriate and/or in line with the person’s wishes0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 49I work with the person to set health goals for their future11Excellent11ExcellentItem 50I enable people receiving care to seek information about their care from other healthcare professionals11Excellent11Excellent Engagement Item 51I try to understand the person’s perspective0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 52I seek to resolve issues when my goals for the person differ from their perspectives0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 53I engage people in care processes where appropriate0.670.57Acceptable11Excellent Having sympathetic presence Item 54I actively listen to people receiving care to identify unmet needs0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 55I gather additional information to help me support people receiving care0.830.81Excellent11ExcellentItem 56I ensure my full attention is focused on the person when I am with them11Excellent11Excellent Providing holistic care Item 57I strive to gain a sense of the whole person0.670.57Acceptable11ExcellentItem 58I assess the needs of the person, taking account of all aspects of their lives11Excellent11ExcellentItem 59I deliver care that takes account of the whole person11Excellent11Excellent S-CVI/ave = 0.90S-CVI/ave = 0.96K * = Modified kappa adjusted for chance. K * = (I-CVI − pc)/(1 − pc). I-CVI = observed index adjusted for the content validity index. Pc = probability that the event occurs by chance Clarity and relevance of the Spanish version of the Person-Centred Practice Inventory-Staff (PCPI-S). K * = Modified kappa adjusted for chance. K * = (I-CVI − pc)/(1 − pc). I-CVI = observed index adjusted for the content validity index. Pc = probability that the event occurs by chance Table 3Items of the questionnaire that needed changes.ItemsOriginal Terms (English)Original Terms (Spanish)Final ChangesItem 18SupportFavorezcoApoyoItem 45Of their family and carersDe su familia y sus cuidadoresDe su familia y el de sus cuidadoresItem 47I encourage people to discuss what is important to themAnimo a las personas a que compartan lo que es importante para ellasAnimo a que las personas compartan lo que es importante para ellasItem 52PersonPersonaPersona cuidadaItem 54People receiving careA las personas que reciben cuidadosA las personas que cuido Items of the questionnaire that needed changes. 3.2. Phase 2: Psychometric Properties Characteristics of the Participants Characteristics of the Participants Data were gathered between September and November 2021. A total of 287 health professionals completed the PCPI-S at least once. One participant’s responses were withdrawn because the descriptive data were not completed. Table 4 shows the characteristics of the sample. The questionnaire was completed three weeks later by 114 participants (39.7% retention rate). Table 4Descriptive statistics of the sample.Characteristics of the SampleN = 287% Mean age 44.5 Sex Male3411.97Female25287.68No response10.35 Professional group Nurse15253.52Physician7526.41Nursing assistant5016.90Manager31.06Technician31.06Social worker30.70Neuropsychologist10.35 Experience ≤10 years7526.06>10 years21273.94 Descriptive statistics of the sample. Psychometric Aspects Psychometric Aspects In the evaluation of skewness and kurtosis, items with values that fell outside the criteria defined for normality indicated high kurtosis and negative skewness, especially in Domain 1 (Prerequisites) (see Table S1), showing a high coincidence of responses towards high values of the scale. Regarding the polychoric correlations, the correlations of the items in general showed independent patterns (low correlations) between Domain 1 and Domain 2 (the practice environment) and to a lesser extent with Domain 3 (person-centred processes). In the same sense, Domain 3 presented a pattern of correlation less with Domain 2 than with Domain 1. Within each domain, the correlation coefficients within Domain 3 (person-centred processes) were, in general, high compared to those in Domains 1 and 2. In the test–retest reliability analysis, all the items showed fair levels of congruence (0.2–0.4), with half of the items reaching moderate levels (0.4–0.6) and 5% of items reaching substantially high levels (0.6–0.8) (see Table S1). In the internal reliability analysis, the constructs showed adequate OT values (>0.69); however, construct C17 showed multicollinearity (OT >0.9) (Table 5). The skewness and kurtosis values of the constructs remained within the predetermined limits (<|2|). Table 5Descriptive statistics of the construct variables (sum of items for each construct) of the instrument: skewness, kurtosis, ordinal theta, and polychoric correlation coefficient (n = 284).ConstructThetaSkewnessKurtosisMeanStd.12345678910111213141516C1.Professionally competent0.75−0.690.4213.321.48 C2. Developed interpersonal skills0.83−0.45−0.6918.081.630.55 C3. Being committed to the job0.89−0.45−0.7122.262.170.560.67 C4. Knowing self0.88−0.21−0.7813.031.560.480.580.66 C5. Clarity of beliefs and values0.74−0.04−0.1611.301.850.360.490.570.60 C6. Skill mix0.760−0.2112.151.610.410.500.570.500.65 C7. Shared decision-making systems0.82−0.380.1914.643.030.300.340.420.380.550.46 C8. Effective staff relationships0.86−0.540.1511.702.210.210.350.430.390.470.440.66 C9. Power sharing0.88−0.580.0215.512.990.230.390.420.410.470.430.700.79 C10. Potential for innovation and risk taking0.730−0.4311.761.820.310.470.570.520.520.510.650.640.70 C11. The physical environment0.86−0.330.1312.261.820.400.480.630.600.600.620.300.360.360.52 C12. Supportive organizational systems0.88−0.24−0.2416.014.070.140.290.380.390.450.400.610.670.730.600.36 C13. Working with patients’ beliefs and values0.880−0.3916.702.100.480.610.750.650.610.610.430.430.370.530.710.40 C14. Shared decision-making0.83−0.370.4712.291.730.320.470.620.460.450.450.380.390.370.500.540.350.72 C15. Engagement0.870.1−0.6412.821.450.400.550.620.470.430.490.380.360.350.500.490.290.690.74 C16. Having sympathetic presence0.87−0.05−0.2512.751.520.460.580.670.520.500.540.350.420.370.490.590.360.750.620.65 C17. Providing holistic care0.94−0.490.1613.181.590.440.570.680.530.480.510.310.320.310.480.630.300.720.610.680.76Green color: Highest level of reliability. Yellow and orange color: Middle level of reliability. Red color: Lowest level of reliability. Descriptive statistics of the construct variables (sum of items for each construct) of the instrument: skewness, kurtosis, ordinal theta, and polychoric correlation coefficient (n = 284). Green color: Highest level of reliability. Yellow and orange color: Middle level of reliability. Red color: Lowest level of reliability. The CFA for the original PCPI-S [15] yielded fit values below the established cut-off points (Table 6). Therefore, it was decided to evaluate the modification indices with the aim of allowing adjustment of the instrument. The descriptive results were also considered (Table 5); the constructs with the lowest level of reliability were construct C5 “Clarity of beliefs and values” and construct C10 “Potential for innovation and risk taking”. In addition, the Wald test did not identify any parameter to release, contrary to the Lagrange multiplier test, which identified several dependencies of construct C10 “Potential for innovation and risk taking” that were not identified in the original factorial model, PCPI-S [15]. Within these relationships, the most relevant, according to the Lagrange multiplier test, were related to the influence of constructs C6 “Skill-Mix”, C11 “The physical environment”, and C13 “Working with patients’ beliefs and values”; of items 32 and 36; or of the items of construct C10 (items 33 and 35). Since these relationships were not supported by the PCPF and since C10 had the minimum number of items (three), for identifiability processes [44], the complete construct was removed from the original model [15]. After this construct was removed, the defined criteria for the RMSEA and SRMR values were achieved (Table 6). Table 6Goodness-of-fit indices for various models.Modelχ2d.f.Δχ2Δd.f.Prob. > χ2CFISRMRRMSEA(RMSEA CL90)Base model10,873.501711 Original PCPI-S (Slater 2017)2716.6015168156.9195<0.0010.870.0680.053(0.050–0.056)Spanish PCPI-S (without C10)2329.181364387.42152<0.0010.890.0580.050(0.047–0.053) Goodness-of-fit indices for various models. The instrument that was obtained, which had 56 items and 16 factors, was evaluated for its measurement properties (Table 7). Low variance extraction values were observed for constructs C1 “Professionally competent”, C2 “Developed interpersonal skills”, C3 “Being committed to the job”, C5 “Clarity of beliefs and values”, C6 “Skill mix”, and C7 “Shared decision-making systems”. For constructs C1 “Professionally competent”, C5 “Clarity of beliefs and values”, and C6 “Skill-mix”, the composite reliability values were also below the criteria (<0.7). The item reliabilities were also low for some of the items in these constructs. Regarding the analysis of convergent validity, it was only found that the correlation between C5 “Clarity of beliefs and values” and C6 “Skill-Mix” presented a value statistically equal to one, r = 0.94 with 95% CI (0.84–1.03). Table 7Properties of the revised model of the PCPI-S.Construct/ItemVariance Extracted EstimateReliabilityStandardized Loadingt Value1 Professionally competent 0.31a 0.56 I have the necessary skills to negotiate care options 0.200.458.03 When I provide care, I pay attention to more than the immediate physical task 0.200.458.17 I actively seek opportunities to extend my professional competence 0.530.7315.842 Developed interpersonal skills 0.41a 0.73 I ensure I hear and acknowledge others’ perspectives 0.610.7823.70 In my communication I demonstrate respect for others 0.280.5310.84 I use different communication techniques to find mutually agreed solutions 0.430.6516.01 I pay attention to how my non-verbal cues impact on my engagement with others 0.310.5611.763 Being committed to the job 0.45a 0.80 I strive to deliver high-quality care to people 0.390.6215.42 I seek opportunities to get to know the person and their family in order to provide holistic care 0.440.6717.99 I go out of my way to spend time with people receiving care 0.520.7221.97 I strive to deliver high-quality care that is informed by evidence 0.470.6919.45 I continuously look for opportunities to improve the care experiences 0.430.6517.184 Knowing self 0.59a 0.81 I take time to explore why I react as I do in certain situations 0.640.8027.75 I use reflection to check out if my actions are consistent with my ways of being 0.720.8532.99 I pay attention to how my life experiences influence my practice 0.400.6315.555 Clarity of beliefs and values 0.41a 0.68 I actively seek feedback from others about my practice 0.340.5812.92 I challenge colleagues when their practice is inconsistent with our team’s shared values and beliefs 0.410.6415.42 I support colleagues to develop their practice to reflect the team’s shared values and beliefs 0.500.7018.806 Skill mix 0.39a 0.66 I recognize when there is a deficit in knowledge and skills in the team and its impact on care delivery 0.430.6515.84 I am able to make the case when the skill mix falls below acceptable levels 0.410.6415.39 I value the input from all team members and their contributions to care 0.330.5812.637 Shared decision-making systems 0.47a 0.78 I actively participate in team meetings to inform my decision-making 0.480.6919.48 I participate in organization-wide decision-making forums that impact on practice 0.390.6215.24 I am able to access opportunities to actively participate in influencing decisions in my directorate/division 0.600.7726.10 My opinion is sought in clinical decision-making forums (e.g., ward rounds, case conferences, discharge planning) 0.430.6617.318 Effective staff relationships 0.61a 0.82 I work in a team that values my contribution to person-centred care 0.730.8539.02 I work in a team that encourages everyone’s contribution to person-centred care 0.700.8436.52 My colleagues positively role model the development of effective relationships 0.390.6215.539 Power sharing 0.57a 0.84 The contribution of colleagues is recognized and acknowledged 0.490.7020.95 I actively contribute to the development of shared goals 0.480.6920.53 The leader facilitates participation 0.580.7627.44 I am encouraged and supported to lead developments in practice 0.720.8540.8811 The physical environment 0.55a 0.79 I pay attention to the impact of the physical environment on people’s dignity 0.530.7321.78 I challenge others to consider how different elements of the physical environment impact on person-centredness(e.g., noise, light, heat, etc.) 0.600.7825.93 I seek out creative ways of improving the physical environment 0.520.7221.1012 Supportive organizational systems 0.54a 0.85 In my team we take time to celebrate our achievements 0.480.6919.90 My organization recognizes and rewards success 0.550.7424.19 I am recognized for the contribution that I make to people having a good experience of care 0.460.6818.82 I am supported to express concerns about an aspect of care 0.670.8233.83 I have the opportunity to discuss my practice and professional development on a regular basis 0.550.7423.9613 Working with patients’ beliefs and values 0.53a 0.82 I integrate my knowledge of the person into care delivery 0.520.7223.49 I work with the person within the context of their family and carers 0.590.7728.21 I seek feedback on how people make sense of their care experience 0.460.6719.59 I encourage people to discuss what is important to them 0.560.7526.5414 Shared decision-making 0.53a 0.77 I include the family in care decisions where appropriate and/or in line with the person’s wishes 0.550.7422.96 I work with the person to set health goals for their future 0.550.7423.00 I enable people receiving care to seek information about their care from other healthcare professionals 0.470.6918.9115 Engagement 0.55a 0.79 I try to understand the person’s perspective 0.560.7524.05 I seek to resolve issues when my goals for the person differ from their perspectives 0.510.7121.07 I engage people in care processes where appropriate 0.600.7726.3616 Having sympathetic presence 0.58a 0.80 I actively listen to people receiving care to identify unmet needs 0.680.8334.05 I gather additional information to help me support people receiving care 0.490.7020.46 I ensure my full attention is focused on the person when I am with them 0.560.7524.5417 Providing holistic care 0.69a 0.87 I strive to gain a sense of the whole person 0.620.7930.09 I assess the needs of the person, taking account of all aspects of their lives 0.670.8235.45 I deliver care that takes account of the whole person 0.780.8848.93a Composite reliability. Properties of the revised model of the PCPI-S. a Composite reliability. 4. Discussion The first version of the PCPI-S culturally adapted and validated in Spanish (PCPI-S-Sp) was obtained. The PCPI-S has been widely used and validated in different countries [1,19,20,21]. Having the Spanish version of the instrument will reinforce and facilitate its dissemination in other contexts. Furthermore, this instrument will allow us to explore person-centred practice at the individual, unit, and organizational levels [15] in the Spanish context. It is important to note that the validation of the PCPI-S in Spain serves as the starting point for its applicability in the other 20 countries where Spanish is the official language. However, linguistic and cultural differences may impact its applicability, requiring further adaptations and validations in each of these contexts. Conducting multi-country validation studies or cross-cultural research in diverse healthcare settings would be essential to confirm the tool’s psychometric robustness and cultural adaptability across various contexts, thereby establishing its generalizability [46]. Unlike other instruments measuring PCC that are focused on singular aspects of person-centredness [12,13,14] or that are not underpinned by a framework [15,20], the PCPI-S is based on the PCPF [3]. It is important to highlight that this framework defines the main aspects of person-centredness and that it has recently been culturally adapted into Spanish [47]. Moreover, the PCPI-S was developed to be used by different healthcare professionals (physicians, nurses, assistant nurses, etc.) [15]. On the one hand, this helps identify the perceptions of different professionals regarding person-centred practice, and on the other hand, it helps generate evidence that providing a PCC needs an interdisciplinary perspective [48]. The Spanish version of the PCPI-S was the result of a complex process of translation and adaptation following the “Translation and cultural adaptation process for Patient-Reported Outcomes Measures-Principles of Good Practice” [34]. This guide is widely used and internationally recognized. It was also used to translate and adapt the PCPI-S into Norwegian [1] and German [23]. Following the same guide for the cultural adaptation of three different versions of the PCPI-S provides consistency among the different versions [49]. Moreover, it allows the comparison of the results of the different versions measuring the same phenomenon. One strength of the study is that the author of the PCPI-S, who is also the author of the PCPF, took part in the process of translation and cultural adaptation. This allowed us to clarify questions about the instrument at any time in the process to maintain the conceptual meaning of the items rather than the literal meaning. The literature shows that this is one of the most important requisites to reach quality during the process of translation and cultural adaptation [34]. The term “care”, which is key in PCC, appears throughout the entire questionnaire. This term is mainly associated with the field of nursing. In fact, in the translation of the PCPI-S for the Norwegian context [1], it was found that this term is not applicable to other professions such as medicine or psychology. In the present study, the healthcare professionals from the panel of experts concluded that in the Spanish cultural context, this term is generalizable to all healthcare professionals. For this reason, as in the original version of the PCPI-S, the term “care” (cuidado in Spanish) was maintained in the Spanish version. In the present study, no difficulties in the translation, cultural adaptation, and validation of the PCPI-S were encountered, consistent with other studies that have translated the instrument into other languages, such as Norwegian [1], German [23], Malaysian [24], and Korean [25]. The validation of the same instrument in different languages will allow us to compare international findings about how person-centred practice is provided in different countries. However, there are some issues that deserve consideration, as shown below. From the psychometric evaluations, some items exhibited low retest reliability, ranging between 0.2 and 0.35. For example, in the ‘Prerequisites’ dimension, items 2, 8, and 11 demonstrated this issue, as did items 29 and 36 in the ‘Care environment’ dimension. Similarly, in the ‘Care Processes’ dimension, items 50 and 55 showed low reliability. This may be attributed to the nature of the aspects being assessed, which are related to the relationships with patients, colleagues, and other professionals. These factors are expected to evolve over time. Therefore, it is natural for the reliability of these elements to vary in repeated tests, as they are neither constant nor static [50]. On the other hand, construct C10 “Potential for innovation and risk taking” already showed problems by presenting low reliability indices and low correlations. This was reflected in their inability to evaluate this construct, and in this way, other constructs began to show influences on this construct, such as “skill mix” and “power sharing” (e.g., Skill Mix influencing answers related to whether support is given to do different things that improve the practice). This correlation is supported conceptually since it is apparent that when a skill mix is present, the potential for innovation and risk taking is higher [44]. The literature shows that one important element in healthcare is how a good ratio of skill mix has a positive influence on complex and innovative decisions according to the patient’s needs. When power sharing is elicited more effectively, the team involves patients and incorporates important information for and from patients in deliberations, and therefore, more balanced and appropriate decisions are made. As a consequence, interprofessional shared decision-making is associated with improved processes and outcomes and decreased risks. Some examples of this are the studies made by different authors [51,52,53]. In future works, different ways of evaluating this construct should be explored to identify possible correlations with the different constructs that have not been identified. Previous research has shown that quality of care improves when the employees within a healthcare team differ in terms of education, expertise, and competencies. As shown in Aiken and colleagues’ review [54], a rich nurse skill mix (a higher percentage of professional nurses among all nursing personnel) was associated with better quality of care, higher safety, and higher hospital ratings from patients. Additionally, in the psychometric testing, a strong correlation between Construct 5, “Clarity of Beliefs and Values”, and Construct 6, “Skill Mix”, was found, presenting a value statistically equal to one, r = 0.94. This correlation is expected within the theoretical framework underpinning this study, the PCPF by McCormack et al. (2021) [16]. According to this framework, clarity of beliefs and values, particularly the shared commitment to placing the patient at the center of care, is intrinsically linked to the composition and expertise of the care team (skill mix) [55]. This synergy ensures that the team functions cohesively to meet the patient’s needs effectively. However, the magnitude of the correlation (r = 0.94) raises potential concerns about conceptual overlap. While the constructs are theoretically distinct, the high correlation suggests they may not be entirely independent. To address this, future iterations of the tool could refine the items to emphasize the structural aspects of “Skill Mix” and the relational dynamics within “Clarity of Beliefs and Values”. Such adjustments would preserve the constructs’ theoretical foundations while enhancing the tool’s ability to distinguish between them. Despite this, the findings underscore the importance of integrating these two constructs in the delivery of PCC. As highlighted by the Dutch Health Care Inspectorate, ensuring that the quantity and expertise of staff are aligned with the healthcare needs of patients is critical for providing high-quality care [56,57]. The optimal fit between professionals and the skill mix—while focused on patient needs—is essential for delivering safe and effective care. Another finding in this study was the low reliability values of the constructs C1 “Professionally competent” and C6 “Skill Mix”. International research shows that when professionals perceive themselves to be professionally competent, interprofessional collaboration is essential to obtain an adequate skill mix [58]. However, one barrier that could emerge is that professionals may lack understanding of the specific professional roles and responsibilities of the different professionals [58]. Therefore, they lack knowledge about the contribution of other professionals in the patient’s care and hence the impact of the whole team on the patient’s health [59]. Finally, although the recruitment was not probabilistic, participants from various work environments and with a wide age range were still included. This improved the external validity of the findings reported in this study. However, some caution must be taken when using this instrument. Because the instrument was developed for different healthcare professionals, it would be advisable to test the instrument with larger heterogeneous samples. In general, the measurement instrument shows adequate adjustment values. It is to be expected that, being such a complex instrument, the adjustment indices show nonconformities; however, there were few steps followed to achieve the aforementioned adjustment, and the required level was easily reached. 5. Conclusions In this research, the first Spanish version of the PCPI-S (Sp), which assesses the perception of healthcare professionals about a person-centred practice, was developed. Having this tool in Spanish will increase the interest in developing PCC policies, programs, interventions, approaches, and/or initiatives in Spain. The PCPI-S has adequate psychometric properties for the measurement of person-centred practice in the Spanish context. This will facilitate the identification of different professionals’ perceptions of person-centred practice, tracking the evolution of this practice over time and assessing interventions that seek to improve person-centred practice. This version of the PCPI-S will allow the development of international comparative studies in different countries. Furthermore, the existence of two additional instruments based on the same framework as the PCPI-S, namely, the PCPI-ST (students’ perceptions) and the PCPI-C (patients’ perceptions), will allow us to measure the same phenomenon from the perspective of all those involved in PCC, providing a global overview of the phenomenon. These instruments are currently being culturally adapted and validated in Spanish. Supplementary Materials The following supporting information can be downloaded at: https://www.mdpi.com/article/10.3390/healthcare12232485/s1, Table S1. Descriptive statistics of the explicit variables of the instrument: skewness, kurtosis, Kendall Tau concordance coefficient and polychoric correlation coefficients. Author Contributions Conceptualization: A.C.-V., B.E.-I., B.M. and V.L.R.-S.; Methodology: A.C.-V., E.B., M.L.-C., M.J.G.-E., M.V.-C., B.E.-I. and A.C.; Formal analysis: A.C.-V., E.B., M.L.-C., B.E.-I., A.C. and V.L.R.-S.; Resources: M.J.G.-E. and M.V.-C.; Data curation: A.C.-V. and B.E.-I.; Writing—original draft: A.C.-V., E.B., M.L.-C., B.E.-I. and V.L.R.-S.; Writing—review & editing: M.J.G.-E., M.V.-C., A.C., B.M. and V.T.; Supervision: B.M. and V.T.; Project administration: A.C.-V.; Funding A.C.-V. Quisition: A.C.-V., B.E.-I., A.C. and V.L.R.-S. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript. Institutional Review Board Statement The study was approved by the Ethics Committee on Clinical Research (CEIC) at Universidad de Navarra (project 2021.125 Mod1 on 3 March 2022) and the Ethics Committee on Clinical Research at Departamento de Salud, Gobierno de Navarra (PI_2021/141 on December 2021). Informed Consent Statement Written informed consent for publication has been waived due to not relating to identified data. Authorization to utilize the PCPI-S was received from the author of the questionnaire. Data Availability Statement The data presented in this study are available on request from the corresponding author. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare no conflicts of interest. Funding Statement This study was funded by the State Plan for I+D+I 2017–2020 and co-financed by the ISCIII-General Subdirectorate for Research Evaluation and Promotion and the European Regional Development Fund (FEDER) (PI20/01644). The funding organization had no role in the design of this study or its execution, analysis, interpretation of the data, or writing of the manuscript. Footnotes Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. References Associated Data Supplementary Materials Data Availability Statement The data presented in this study are available on request from the corresponding author.