Comprehensive Analysis of Bioactive Compounds, Functional Properties, and Applications of Broccoli By-Products Authors: Iris Gudiño, Rocío Casquete, Alberto Martín, Yuanfeng Wu, María José Benito, Annalisa Tassoni Published: 2024 ABSTRACT AbstractBroccoli by-products, traditionally considered inedible, possess a comprehensive nutritional and functional profile. These by-products are abundant in glucosinolates, particularly glucoraphanin, and sulforaphane, an isothiocyanate renowned for its potent antioxidant and anticarcinogenic properties. Broccoli leaves are a significant source of phenolic compounds, including kaempferol and quercetin, as well as pigments, vitamins, and essential minerals. Additionally, they contain proteins, essential amino acids, lipids, and carbohydrates, with the leaves exhibiting the highest protein content among the by-products. Processing techniques such as ultrasound-assisted extraction and freeze-drying are crucial for maximizing the concentration and efficacy of these bioactive compounds. Advanced analytical methods, such as high-performance liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry (HPLC-MS), have enabled precise characterization of these bioactives. Broccoli by-products have diverse applications in the food industry, enhancing the nutritional quality of food products and serving as natural substitutes for synthetic additives. Their antioxidant, antimicrobial, and anti-inflammatory properties not only contribute to health promotion but also support sustainability by reducing agricultural waste and promoting a circular economy, thereby underscoring the value of these often underutilized components.Keywords: broccoli, by-products, bioactive compounds, extraction methods, beneficial effects, applications 1. Introduction Broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. italica) is a member of the cruciferous family (Brassicaceae), which also includes vegetables such as cauliflower, brussels sprouts, and kale. The Brassicaceae family encompasses up to 390 genera and approximately 3500 species, predominantly found in the Mediterranean region and Central Asia [1]. Among these, the genus Brassica is particularly significant, comprising species of substantial economic and nutritional importance. Brassica oleracea, in particular, includes a diverse array of vegetables, with broccoli being one of the most notable. The Brassica genus constitutes a significant component of the global human diet. Its consumption is particularly prominent in countries such as China, Japan, India, and various European nations, where it is considered a dietary staple [2]. Global production of Brassica species has seen a notable increase in recent years, reaching 2.2 million tonnes between 2015 and 2022. The majority of this production is concentrated in China and India, followed by the United States, Spain, Italy, and Mexico [3]. Broccoli, a member of this genus, is cultivated in a diverse range of climates due to its resilience, facilitating its global cultivation. This adaptability has also enabled the development of various broccoli cultivars. Broccoli is a vegetable abundant in bioactive compounds, including glucosinolates and their degradation products, polyphenols (such as flavonoids and hydroxycinnamic acids), vitamins (ascorbic acid), minerals (manganese, potassium, and selenium), and carbohydrates (dietary fibers) [4,5]. These bioactive compounds exhibit significant antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and anticancer activities [6,7]. Despite its numerous beneficial properties, broccoli cultivation primarily targets food consumption, with the edible portion comprising only 15% of the entire plant. This portion includes the florets, often accompanied by tender stems and sprouts. The production of broccoli generates a substantial amount of by-products, such as leaves and stems, which are typically discarded as they are considered non-usable or commercially underutilized [8,9]. However, these by-products offer considerable health benefits due to their richness in a wide array of valuable bioactive compounds, similar to the edible parts. Studies have shown that by-products like stems and leaves contain high levels of phenolic compounds, glucosinolates, vitamins, and fiber [10,11,12]. The analysis of compounds present in broccoli necessitates various extraction and analysis methods. Commonly used extraction methods include solid-phase extraction (SPE) and liquid–liquid extraction (LLE), as well as ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE) and supercritical fluid extraction (SFE), which are considered more efficient and environmentally friendly. For compound analysis, chromatographic techniques such as high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) are employed to separate and quantify the compounds, often in combination with mass spectrometry (MS) or UV–Vis detection to enhance identification [13,14,15]. The presence of these compounds, primarily phenolic compounds and isothiocyanates (ISTs) such as sulforaphane (SF), is responsible for the antioxidant and antimicrobial properties associated with this vegetable [16]. Broccoli, like many cruciferous vegetables, is renowned for its chemopreventive properties, primarily due to its rich content of compounds like SF and other ISTs. These compounds are notable for their antioxidant effects and their ability to regulate the cell cycle, induce apoptosis, and modulate enzymatic activity [17,18,19]. Consequently, the inclusion of isothiocyanates derived from broccoli reduces the susceptibility to developing chronic diseases such as cancer. Similarly, the influence of isothiocyanates, such as sulforaphane, and flavonoids like quercetin on the activity of immune cells involved in inflammation, such as macrophages and lymphocytes, has been demonstrated [19]. Dietary broccoli supplementation (sulforafane) has been found to improve glucose tolerance, attenuate liver inflammation, and alter microbial composition in mice fed high-fat diets [20]. Broccoli stalks have demonstrated positive effects on lipid parameters, insulin sensitivity, and gut microbiome diversity [20]. The use of both broccoli sprouts and leaves and stems has also been studied for their effects on other conditions such as obesity [21,22,23], as well as diabetes [24,25,26,27]. The extraction of compounds from broccoli responsible for its multiple benefits can transform broccoli cultivation by-products into new sources of bioactive compounds. This would allow the reuse of the inedible parts of the vegetable in the food industry as functional or nutraceutical products, promoting the valorization of broccoli agro-industrial waste. This review aims to compile relevant literature, mostly from the last ten years, focusing on the detailed analysis of nutrients and phytochemicals present in various parts of broccoli, as well as in different cultivars. It seeks to evaluate the importance of the choice of extraction and analysis methods in obtaining these bioactive compounds. Recent advances in their beneficial effects are also highlighted, and various applications of broccoli by-products are explored to promote their use as a rich source of compounds with high functional properties. 2. Brassica By-Products The horticultural industry generates substantial by-products at every stage of the production chain, particularly during handling and processing. Any raw material or product that fails to meet quality standards, field waste, and parts not intended for fresh consumption are classified as by-products. Broccoli production results in significant quantities of by-products, most of which remain underutilized. Since the broccoli head is the most commonly consumed part, the remainder of the plant (leaves, stems, roots, etc.) is typically treated as by-products or waste. Broccoli leaves and stems alone constitute 60 to 75% of the plant’s total biomass and are generally discarded post-harvest [1]. The rest of the plant comprises roots (17%) and florets (15%) [8]. Currently, approximately 73.65 tons per hectare of cultivated broccoli are generated as waste after crop harvesting, with the primary use being reincorporation into the soil as compost for new plantings. However, these by-products can serve as inexpensive sources of bioactive compounds. Broccoli leaves are rich in vitamins E and K, and glucosinolates, often surpassing florets in concentrations of phenolic compounds and chlorophyll, thereby exhibiting higher antioxidant activity, while stems are rich in fiber and glucosinolates [8,11,12,13,14]. The extraction of bioactive compounds from by-products facilitates their incorporation into the production of new products in the food, pharmaceutical, and cosmetic industries. This practice is already being implemented, utilizing broccoli by-products as ingredients in functional foods [28], to enhance the nutritional properties of foods [29], or as natural preservatives to extend the shelf life of foods [30], among other applications. Given the health benefits provided by broccoli beyond basic nutrition due to its wide array of phytochemicals, and the presence of these compounds in its by-products, they can be considered valuable food additives [13,14]. Utilizing these by-products not only offers economic benefits by increasing the value of materials used by other industries but also provides ecological advantages by reducing waste emissions. This approach supports a circular economy by minimizing the input of raw materials and the production of waste. Additionally, it enhances the utilization of plant foods at a time when arable land is decreasing and the global population is increasing. 3. Functional Compounds and Extraction Techniques 3.1. Phenolic Compounds Cruciferous vegetables, such as broccoli, are renowned for their high phenolic compound content. In plants, these compounds fulfill various roles, including protection against external agents, cold tolerance, and contributing to color and aroma. Humans cannot synthesize these compounds, thus relying on the consumption of plant-based foods like broccoli to incorporate them into the body. The total phenolic content (TPC) in mg gallic acid equivalent/100 g dry weight (mg GAE/100 g DW) is highest in the leaves (2435 mg GAE/100 g DW), followed by the inflorescence (1074 mg GAE/100 g DW) and stems (939 mg GAE/100 g DW) [11]. Broccoli sprouts and seeds have the lowest concentrations of phenolic compounds (385.4 and 480.4 mg GAE/100 g DW, respectively) [26]. This ranking is consistent with other studies [8,12], with the phenolic content in leaves only surpassed by discarded florets after processing [10]. The extraction method significantly influences the phenolic compound content analyzed in broccoli by-products. Borja-Marínez et al. [31] reported higher concentrations of these compounds using solvent extraction (MeOH) compared to supercritical fluid extraction (SFE) in mixed samples of leaves and stems. Le et al. [32] applied extraction on leaves and seeds using three different solvents (MeOH, EtOH, and hot water), highlighting the efficacy of alcohol. Solvent extraction, primarily using methanol, is the most commonly employed method for phenolic compound extraction [9,33,34]. However, other solvents such as acetone [35] or ethanol [15] have also been utilized. Martínez et al. [36] applied water extraction along with enzymatic extraction (EE) or ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE) in fresh broccoli leaf and stem mixtures, emphasizing the effectiveness of water extraction at 100 °C. The phenolic compound content also depends on the pre-processing of by-product samples. Md Salim et al. [37] found that osmotic dehydration (OD) of samples is more favorable for phenol content than hot air-drying (40–60 °C). However, Villaño et al. [38] achieved higher phenolic compound extraction by pre-drying broccoli stems with air at 80 °C (8.37 mg GAE/g DW) compared to freeze-drying (3.01 mg GAE/g DW). Pre-blanching the plant sample followed by freeze-drying enhances phenolic compound extraction [39]. 3.1.1. Flavonoid Broccoli by-products are a rich and accessible source of phenolic compounds, particularly flavonoids such as quercetin and kaempferol, which exhibit significant antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties. The total flavonoid content (TFC) in broccoli leaves is 9.93 mg catechin equivalent/g DW (mg CE/g DW), using ethanol (70% v/v) as the extraction solvent [32]. In another study, the TFC in broccoli sprouts and seeds was 206.9 and 216.9 mg CE/100 g, respectively, using the same solvent [26], demonstrating its effectiveness for extracting these compounds. Solvent extraction (EtOH 80%) assisted by ultrasound (UAE) has also been applied, yielding TFC values of 2.4 mg quercetin equivalent/g (mg QE/g) and 5.4 mg QE/g in stems and discarded florets, respectively [10]. Methanol is another solvent used for flavonoid extraction [9,33]. Thomas et al. [10] quantified the content of k-3-o-sophoroside and q-3-diglucoside-7-glucoside in discarded florets (39.4 and 17.2 mg/kg DW), although these flavonoids were not detected in stems. Berndtsson et al. [40] also identified significant amounts of kaempferols (k) and quercetins (q) in broccoli leaves using UAE with methanol (60%) as the solvent, including k-3-O-caffeoyl-sophoroside-7-O-diglucoside, k-3-O(feruloyl)sophoroside-7-O-diglucoside, q-3-O-(sinapoyl)-sophoroside-7-O-glucoside, and k-3-O-(sinapoyl)-sophoroside-7-O-glucoside, among others. Le et al. [32] determined the quercetin content in leaves and seeds, obtaining 0.97 and 0.56 mg/g of extract (EtOH 70%), respectively. They also measured the myricetin content, another flavonoid, with 2.77 mg/g in leaf extract and 0.31 mg/g in seed extract. This same study also highlighted the presence of another phenolic compound, esculetin, belonging to the coumarin group, with contents of 6.49 and 10.18 mg/g in broccoli leaf and seed extracts, respectively. 3.1.2. Phenolic Acids Interest in phenolic acids among phenolic compounds has surged due to their antioxidant and antimicrobial properties. Broccoli by-products are a rich source of these compounds, particularly in the leaves (3.6–5.7 mg/g DW) [40]. These compounds are categorized into two main types: benzoic acids, derived from benzoic acid, and hydroxycinnamic acids, derived from cinnamic acid. Benzoic acids such as vanillic acid and gallic acid have been extracted and identified from broccoli by-products like stems and seeds [32,41], although these compounds were not detected in the leaves [41]. However, Le et al. [32] successfully extracted gallic acid from leaves using a solvent with a higher alcohol percentage (70%) compared to the previous study (50%) [41]. The primary hydroxycinnamic acids present in broccoli include caffeic acid, ferulic acid, chlorogenic acid, neochlorogenic acid, and sinapic acid. The main extraction method for these compounds is solvent extraction, using methanol [10,40,42] or ethanol [32,41,43]. However, Martínez et al. [36] utilized water as the solvent, applying enzymatic extraction (EE) with cellulose, and ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE). The extraction of caffeoylquinic acid was higher when applying EE in a mixture of broccoli leaves and stems. Conversely, Costa-Pérez et al. [43] investigated the effect of processing broccoli stems on the content of 5-caffeoylquinic acid and di-sinapoyl-diglucoside, derivatives of hydroxycinnamic acids. They extracted a higher concentration of 5-caffeoylquinic acid after freeze-drying the stems (4.30 mg/kg DW), whereas the content of di-sinapoyl-diglucoside was higher after drying them with a descending temperature gradient (14.93 mg/kg DW). These findings suggest that the choice of vegetable processing depends on the target compound. Berndtsson et al. [40] also identified numerous hydroxycinnamic acids such as o-diglucoside and trisinapoyl-diglucoside in broccoli leaves using HPLC-DAD-ESI-MS. Caffeoyl derivatives, caffeoyl-hexose derivatives, and feruloyl-caffeoyl derivatives, among other compounds, were also identified using this analytical method [36]. 3.2. Organic Acids Broccoli by-products encompass a diverse array of organic acids, with malic acid, citric acid, and oxalic acid being particularly abundant in the sprouts [42]. The leaves are notably rich in gluconic acid, cinnamic acid, succinic acid, and fumaric acid [11,15,33]. Additionally, the inflorescence is especially rich in gluconic acid with 420.64 arbitrary units of area (UAA), exceeding the levels found in other by-products [11]. Table 1 presents the phenolic compounds and organic acids identified in various parts of broccoli, contingent on the pre-processing techniques applied to the vegetable. It also details the different extraction and analytical methods employed for their determination. Table 1Phenolic compounds and organic acids in diverse broccoli by-products.CompoundUnitsBy-Products ContentVegetable ProcessingExtraction MethodAnalysis MethodRef. Phenolic Compounds Total phenolic content (TPC) mg GAE/100 g DW2435 (l); 939 (st); 1074 (if)forced air oven (45 °C, 48 h)UAE: EtOH (80% v/v); 45 °C, 1 hUV–Vis[11]mg GAE/100 g DW385.4 (sp); 480.4 (s)dried ovenEtOH (70%, 1:20 w/v) orbital shaker, 50 °C, 1 hUV–Vis[26]mg GAE/100 g DW79.22 (st)dried (60 °C, 24 h)Acetone (50%)UV–Vis[35]mg GAE/g74.31 (l + st)dried in a climatic chamber (55 °C, 24 h)MeOH:Tris–HCl (50 mM, pH 7.5) (1:1 v/v), 4 °C, 20 minUV–Vis[31]19.51 (l + st) (P)SFE: CO2 40 °C, 443 bar, 7% eToh, 31 g/min of flow rate (68 min)UV–Vis29.21 (l + st) (N)UV–Vismg GAE/g DW28.50 (l); 16.55 (s)dried oven (40 °C)MeOH (70%)UV–Vis[32]25.77 (l); 15.096 (s)EtOH (70%)UV–Vis24.79 (l); 12.58 (s)Hot waterUV–Vismg GAE/g DW1.8 (st)osmotic dehydrationMeOH (80%), 2 hUV–Vis[37]0.6 (st) (40 °C), 0.45 (st) (60 °C)MW–hot air (40–60 °C)UV–Visμg/g DW10,605.5 (l + st)freeze-dryingMeOH (70%) 70 °C, 30 minUHPLC-DAD-ESI/MS[39]7419.7 (l + st)air-drying (40 °C)15,086.7 (l + st)blanching and freeze-drying4588.7 (l + st)blanching and air-drying (40 °C)2203.0 (l + st + if)freeze-drying2765.5 (l + st + if)MW hydrodiffusion and gravitymg GAE/100 g Extract0.70 (l); 0.17 (st); 0.79 (if)forced air oven (45 °C, 48 h)UAE: EtOH (80% v/v); 45 °C, 1 hUV–Vis[12]mg GAE/g DW4.14 (l); 1.41 (st)freeze–dryingMeOH (70%), 75 °CUV–Vis[8]mg GAE/g DW3.8 (st); 6.1 (rf)freeze–dryingUAE: EtOH (80% v/v); 37 °C, 20 minUV–Vis[10]5.4 (st + rf)mg GAE/g FW0.16–2.44 (sp) (3–7 days); 3.89–4.58 (s)blanched (55 °C, 15 min)MeOH, 30 minUV–Vis[9]mg/g»9 (l); »5 (st)freeze–dryingMeOH (80%), HCl (1%); 2 hUV–Vis[33]mg GAE/100 g DW154.7 (st) (P)freeze–dryingMeOH–Water–Formic acid (79/19/1 v/v/v)UV–Vis[34]mg/kg DW21.32 (l + st)FreshWater (1:3 w/w); 100 °C; 60 minUV–Vis[36]20.95 (l + st)EE: water (1:3 w/w), cellulose (0.01%)UV–Vis3.91 (l + st)UAE: Water (1:3 w/w); 75 °C; 60 minUV–Vismg GAE/100 g DW112.95 (l)dried (50 °C, 24 h)DM: EtOH (30%); 50 °C; 36, 92 minUV–Vis[15]mg GAE/g DW3.01 (st)freeze–dryingEtOH (70%; 25 °C; 30 min)UV–Vis[38]3.78 (st)air–drying (60 °C)UV–Vis8.37 (st)air–drying (80 °C)UV–Vis Flavonoid Total Flavonoid Content (TFC) mg CE/100 g206.9 (sp); 216.9 (s)dried ovenEtOH (70%, 1:20 w/v) orbital shaker, 50 °C, 1 hUV–Vis[26]mg CE/g DW8.71 (l); 3.74 (s)dried oven (40 °C)MeOH (70%)UV–Vis[32]9.93 (l); 3.51 (s)EtOH (70%)UV–Vis7.84 (l); 3.59 (s)Hot waterUV–Vismg QE/g DW2.4 (st); 5.4 (rf)freeze–dryingUAE: EtOH (80% v/v); 37 °C, 20 minUV–Vis[10]4.3 (st + rf)UV–Vis mg RE/g FW0.46–3.02 (sp) (day 3–7); 2.60–4.01 (s)blanched (55 °C, 15 min)MeOH, 30 minUV–Vis[9]mg/g3.4 (l); 0.9 (st)freeze–dryingMeOH (80%), HCl (1%); 2 hUV–Vis[33] K-3-o-sophoroside mg/kg DWND (st); 39.4 (rf)freeze-dryingUAE: MeOH (100% v/v); 75 °C, 15 minUPLC-MS/MS[10] Q-3-diglucoside-7-glucoside mg/kg DWND (st); 17.2 (rf)freeze-dryingUAE: MeOH (100% v/v); 75 °C, 15 minUPLC-MS/MS[10] Quercetin mg/g Extract0.97 (l); 0.56 (s)dried oven (40 °C)EtOH (70%)HPLC[32] Myricetin mg/g Extract2.77 (l); 0.31 (s)dried oven (40 °C)EtOH (70%)HPLC[32] Coumarins Esculetin mg/g Extract6.49 (l); 10.18 (s)dried oven (40 °C)EtOH (70%)HPLC[32] Phenolic acids Total Phenolic Acids mg/g DW3.6–5.7 (l) (B)air-driedEUA: MeOH (60%), 35 °C, 1 h; alkaline hydrolisisHPLC-DAD-ESI-MS[40] Benzoic acids Vanillic acid μg/mLND (l); 17.82 (st)freeze-dryingUAE: EtOH (50%)HPLC[41] Gallic acid mg/g Extract0.15 (l); 0.17 (s)dried oven (40 °C)EtOH (70%)HPLC[32]μg/mLND (l); 17.13 (st)freeze-dryingUAE: EtOH (50%)HPLC[41] Hydroxycinnamic acids Caffeic acid mg/g DW213.2 (sp)freeze-driedMeOH (70%, v/v); 70 °C, 30 minHPLC[42]mg/g ExtractND (l); 0.12 (s)dried oven (40 °C)EtOH (70%)HPLC[32]μg/mL1.96 (l); ND (st)freeze-dryingUAE: EtOH (50%)HPLC[41] Caffeoylquinic acid XX (l)air-driedEUA: MeOH (60%), 35 °C, 1 h; alkaline hydrolisisHPLC-DAD-ESI-MS[40]g/kg8.47 (l + st)freshWater (1:3 w/w); 100 °C; 60 minHPLC-DAD[36]9.07 (l + st)EE: water (1:3 w/w), cellulose (0.01%)1.64 (l + st)UAE: Water (1:3 w/w); 75 °C; 60 min 5-caffeoylquinic acid mg/kg DW4.30 (st) (P)freeze-dryingEtOH (50%); 20 min; 75 °CHPLC-PAD-ESI-MSn[43]1.89 (st) (P)oven-drying (40 °C, 72 h)0.46 (st) (P)temperature gradient (75–60 °C)mg/kg DW18.3 (st); 24.4 (rf)freeze-dryingUAE: MeOH (100% v/v); 75 °C, 15 minUPLC-MS/MS[10] Ferulic acid mg/g Extract0.24 (l); 0.58 (s)dried oven (40 °C)EtOH (70%)HPLC[32]μg/mL23.85 (l); 21.92 (st)freeze-dryingUAE: EtOH (50%)HPLC[41] Chlorogenic acid μg/mL2.15 (l); 0.87 (st)freeze-dryingUAE: EtOH (50%)HPLC[41] O-diglucoside XX (l)air-driedEUA: MeOH (60%), 35 °C, 1 h; alkaline hydrolisisHPLC-DAD-ESI-MS[40] trisinapoyl-diglucoside XX (l) Sinapic acid mg/kg DW21.3 (st); 54.3 (rf)freeze-driedUAE: MeOH (100% v/v); 75 °C, 15 minUPLC-MS/MS[10] Di-sinapoyl-diglucose mg/kg DW3.89 (st) (P)freeze-dryingEtOH (50%); 20 min; 75 °CHPLC-PAD-ESI-MSn[43]9.07 (st) (P)oven-drying (40 °C, 72 h)14.93 (st) (P)temperature gradient (75–60 °C)XX (l)air-driedEUA: MeOH (60%), 35 °C, 1 h; alkaline hydrolisisUPLC-MS/MS[40] p-coumaroylquinic acid mg/kg DW0.55 (P) (st)freeze-dryingEtOH (50%); 20 min; 75 °CHPLC-PAD-ESI-MSn[43]0.38 (P) (st)oven-drying (40 °C, 72 h)0.09 (P) (st)temperature gradient (75–60 °C) Organic acids Malic acid mg/g (DW)69.28 (sp)freeze-driedWater (100 °C; 1 h)HPLC-DAD[42]XX (l)dried (50 °C, 24 h)DM: EtOH (30%); 50 °C; 36, 92 minGC-EI-MS[15] Citric acid mg/g (DW)831.06 (sp)freeze-driedWater (100 °C; 1 h)HPLC-DAD[42] Oxalic acid mg/g (DW)139.62 (sp)freeze-driedWater (100 °C; 1 h)HPLC-DAD[42] Gluconic acid UAA141.67 (l); 84.22 (st); 420.64 (if)air oven (45 °C, 48 h)EUA: EtOH (80%), 45 °C, 1 hHPLC-ESI-MS[11] Cinnamic acid Peak area102,226 (l)freeze-dried-UHPLC-QTOF-MS[33] Succinic acid XX (l)dried (50 °C, 24 h)DM: EtOH (30%); 50 °C; 36, 92 minGC-EI-MS[15] Fumaric acid XX (l)dried (50 °C, 24 h)DM: EtOH (30%); 50 °C; 36, 92 minGC-EI-MS[15]Ref: References. By-products: (l) leaves; (st) stems/stalcks; (if) inflorescences; (sp) sprouts; (s) seeds; (rf): remains florets. P: Parthenon; N: Naxos; B: Beneforte; DW: dry weight; FW: fresh weight; ND: not detected; GAE: gallic acid equivalent; CE: catechin equivalent; QE: quercetin equivalent; RE: rutin equivalent; UAE: ultrasonic-assisted extraction; SFE: supercritical fluid extraction; MW: microwave; EE: enzymatic extraction; DM: dynamic maceration; UAA: arbitrary units of area; K: kaempferol; Q: quercetin; X: not quantified. Phenolic compounds and organic acids in diverse broccoli by-products. Ref: References. By-products: (l) leaves; (st) stems/stalcks; (if) inflorescences; (sp) sprouts; (s) seeds; (rf): remains florets. P: Parthenon; N: Naxos; B: Beneforte; DW: dry weight; FW: fresh weight; ND: not detected; GAE: gallic acid equivalent; CE: catechin equivalent; QE: quercetin equivalent; RE: rutin equivalent; UAE: ultrasonic-assisted extraction; SFE: supercritical fluid extraction; MW: microwave; EE: enzymatic extraction; DM: dynamic maceration; UAA: arbitrary units of area; K: kaempferol; Q: quercetin; X: not quantified. 3.3. Glucosinolates and Their Breackdown Products Glucosinolates (GLSs) are distinctive compounds found in Brassica family vegetables, including broccoli. The predominant method for extracting these compounds involves solvent extraction, primarily using methanol at elevated temperatures (>70 °C) to deactivate the enzyme myrosinase [8,10,39]. Myrosinase hydrolyzes GLSs, producing glucose and aglycone. The aglycone is highly unstable and rearranges to form various hydrolytic products, mainly isothiocyanates (ITCs) and nitriles, along with epithionitriles, thiocyanates, indoles, and oxazolidines [44]. 3.3.1. Glucosinolates The structural variation of GLSs allows these compounds to be categorized into three groups: aliphatic, aromatic, and indolic, based on the side chain structure. The primary aliphatic GLSs in broccoli by-products include glucoraphanin, glucoiberin, glucoerucin, and gluconapin. Glucoraphanin (GLP) is the most prominent, with higher concentrations in the inflorescence (3149.91 UAA) compared to leaves and stems (307.29 and 139.27 UAA) [11]. However, Liu et al. [8] reported higher concentrations in stems than in leaves in the “Green Magic” variety. Wang et al. [45] quantified GLP in seeds (2.5–129.9 μmol/g FW) and Villaño et al. [21] in sprouts (51.08 mg/30 g FW). Additionally, Thomas et al. [10] found higher aliphatic glucosinolate content in discarded floret residues post-processing compared to broccoli stems. Other identified aliphatic glucosinolates include napoleiferin, progoitrin, glucoalyssin, and glucoiberverin [8,10,46], as well as 6-(methylsulfonyl)hexylglucosinolate and 3-butenyl glucosinolate in broccoli leaves [47]. The primary aromatic GLS in broccoli leaves is gluconasturtiin [46], while sinalbin is found in stems [33]. Other GLSs, such as glucobrassicin, methoxyglucobrassicin, 4-methoxyglucobrassicin (4-MGBS), 4-hydroxyglucobrassicin (4-GBS), and neoglucobrassicin (NGBS), belong to the indolic glucosinolates group [8,10,45,46]. The GLS content in broccoli by-products is influenced by the cultivated variety. Ares et al. [46] examined the GLS content in broccoli stems from three varieties (Parthenon, Nubia, and Naxos). The Parthenon variety exhibited higher levels of aliphatic glucosinolates such as GLP, glucoiberin, and glucoerucin, as well as the aromatic gluconasturtiin and the indolic 4-MGBS. Conversely, the “Nubia” variety had higher levels of the indolic glucosinolate glucobrassicin (77–106 μg/g DW). The pre-processing of broccoli significantly affects glucosinolate extraction. Costa-Pérez et al. [43] analyzed glucosinolate content in broccoli stems (“Parthenon”) following three processing methods: lyophilization, over-drying (40 °C, 72 h), and temperature gradient drying (75–60 °C). Lyophilized stems had higher glucoraphanin (2633.89 mg/kg DW) and methoxyglucobrassicin (449.05 mg/kg DW) content, while oven-dried stems at 40 °C showed higher glucobrassicin (113.27 mg/kg DW) and glucoiberin (566.64 mg/kg DW) extraction. Another study compared lyophilization with hot air-drying at 60 and 80 °C for broccoli stems [38]. Extracts rich in GLP were obtained from stems dried at 80 °C (3.73 mg/g DW), but high temperatures degraded other GLSs like glucobrassicin and methoxyglucobrassicin, which were not detected. Lyophilized stems had high methoxyglucobrassicin content, while air-dried stems at 60 °C were notable for their glucobrassicin content. 3.3.2. Isothyocianates The formation of products when glucosinolates react with the enzyme myrosinase is contingent upon the glucosinolate’s structure and the biodegradation conditions, including pH, and the presence of proteins and metal ions. Under neutral pH conditions, the hydrolysis predominantly yields volatile active compounds known as isothiocyanates (ITCs) [44]. Among the ITCs identified in broccoli, sulforaphane (SF) is notable, being a degradation product of glucoraphanin (GLP). Lv et al. [9] reported SF contents ranging from 2.5 to 12.1 mg/g FW in fresh broccoli seeds, with an increase from 0 to 11.70 mg/g in sprouts between days 3 and 7 of germination. The SF content was higher when using UAE with ethyl acetate/water as a solvent (17.0 mg/g) [48] compared to high-pressure homogenization (HPH) (2199 μmol/g) [49] in fresh broccoli seeds. Additionally, lyophilization of stems prior to extraction increased the SF content to 1.09 mg/kg DW [43]. Indole-3-carbinol, another ITC, is present in broccoli by-products as a degradation product of glucobrassicin [43]. Abdelhalim et al. [50] identified benzyl isothiocyanate (BITC) in broccoli leaves, formed from the degradation of glucotropaeolin. Other ITCs, such as 4-(methylthio)butyl isothiocyanate (GER-ITC) and 4-(methylsulfinyl)butyl isothiocyanate (GRA-ITC), have also been identified in broccoli seeds [45]. 3.3.3. Other Breakdown Products Nitriles are another kind of degradation product formed from glucosinolates through the action of the enzyme myrosinase. The formation of these compounds occurs under acidic conditions (pH 2–5) [51]. Identified nitriles in broccoli seeds include 5-(methylthio)-pentanenitrile (GER-CN), 5-(methylsulfinyl)pentanenitrile (GRA-CN), 4-methylsulfinylbutanenitrile (GIB-CN), and 4-(methylthio)butanenitrile (GIV-CN) [45]. Table 2 compiles data from various studies on glucosinolates and their degradation products in broccoli by-products, highlighting the influence of different processing conditions and extraction and analysis methods. Table 2Glucosinolates and their breakdown products present in broccoli by-products.CompoundUnitsBy-Products ContentVegetable ProcessingExtraction MethodAnalysis MethodRef. Glucosinolates and Their Breakdown Products Glucosinolates Total glucosinolatesmg/g DW5.00 (l + st)freeze-dryingMeOH (70%), 70 °C, 30 minUHPLC-DAD-ESI/MS[39]5.15 (l + st)air-drying (40 °C)4.93 (l + st)blanching and freeze-driying2.50 (l + st)blanching and air-drying (40 °C)7.85 (l + st + if)freeze-drying6.06 (l + st + if)MW hydrodiffusion and gravityμmol/g DW10.08 (l) (Gm); 7.45 (st) (Gm)freeze-dryingMeOH (70%); 10 min; 95 °C (i.s. glucosinalbin)UHPLC-PAD[8]mg/kg DW1836.6 (l); 5775.6 (rf)freeze-dryingUAE: MeOH (100%), 75 °C, 15 minUPLC-MS/MS[10] Aliphatic glucosinolates Total aliphatic glucosinolatesμmol/g FW54.5–218.7 (s)freshH2O, 100 °C, 15 minHPLC[45]mg/30 g FW80.50 (sp)freeze-dryingEtOH; methyl jasmonate (250 μM)LC-MS[21]mg/100 g DW48 (st) (P)freeze-dryingMeOH–Water–Formic acid (79/19/1 v/v/v)HPLC-DAD-ESI-MS[34]GlucoraphaninUAA307.29 (l); 139.27 (st); 3149.91 (if)air oven (45 °C, 48 h)UAE: EtOH (80%), 45 °C, 1 hHPLC-ESI-MS[11]μmol/g DW2.77 (l) (Gm); 3.79 (st) (Gm)freeze-dryingMeOH (70%); 10 min; 95 °C (i.s. glucosinalbin)UHPLC-PAD[8]mg/kg DW2633.89 (st) (P)freeze-dryingEtOH (50%), 75 °C, 20 minHPLC-PAD-ESI-MS[43]2212.52 (st) (P)oven-drying (40 °C, 72 h)2157.00 (st) (P)temperature gradient (75–60 °C)μmol/g FW2.5–129.9 (s)freshH2O, 100 °C, 15 minHPLC[45]mg/kg DW1586.6 (st); 5076.3 (rf)freeze-dryingUAE: MeOH (100%), 75 °C, 15 minUPLC-MS/MS[10]μg/g DW995–1136 (l) (P)freeze-dryingPLE: EtOH (70%), 60 °C, 5 min, 1500 psiUHPLC-QTOF-MS[46]885–1012 (l) (Nb)980–1090 (l) (Nx)mg/30 g FW51.08 (sp)freeze-dryingEtOH; methyl jasmonate (250 μM)LC-MS[21]mg/100 g DW45.0 (st) (P)freeze-dryingMeOH–Water–Formic acid (79/19/1 v/v/v)HPLC-DAD-ESI-MS[34]mg/g DW3.21 (st)freeze-dryingMeOH (70%); 70°C, 30 minHPLC-DAD-ESI-MS[38]2.66 (st)air-dried (60 °C)3.73 (st)air-dried (80 °C)Glucoiberinμmol/g DW0.65 (l) (Gm); 0.97 (st) (Gm)freeze-dryingMeOH (70%); 10 min; 95 °C (i.s. glucosinalbin)UHPLC-PAD[8]mg/kg DW403.02 (st) (P)freeze-dryingEtOH (50%), 75 °C, 20 minHPLC-PAD-ESI-MS[43]566.64 (st) (P)oven-drying (40 °C, 72 h)407.99 (st) (P)temperature gradient (75–60 °C)μmol/g FW0–65.9 (s)freshH2O, 100 °C, 15 minHPLC[45]mg/kg DW86.1 (st); 242.9 (rf)freeze-dryingUAE: MeOH (100%), 75 °C, 15 minUPLC-MS/MS[10]μg/g DW130–173 (l) (P)freeze-dryingPLE: EtOH (70%), 60 °C, 5 min, 1500 psiUHPLC-QTOF-MS[46]110–130 (l) (Nb)ND-11 (l) (Nx)mg/30 g FW19.28 (sp)freeze-dryingEtOH; methyl jasmonate (250 μM)LC-MS[21]Glucoerucinμmol/g FW3.8–108.4 (s)FreshH2O, 100 °C, 15 minHPLC[45]mg/kg DW245.2 (st); 45.0 (rf)freeze-dryingUAE: MeOH (100%), 75 °C, 15 minUPLC-MS/MS[10]μg/g DWND-15/l) (P)freeze-dryingPLE: EtOH (70%), 60 °C, 5 min, 1500 psiUHPLC-QTOF-MS[46]ND-17 (l) (Nb)ND-