Radar to Radiology Authors: John Hedley-Whyte, Debra R Milamed Published: 2024 INTRODUCTION In November 1940 while waiting to board the Stranraer to Larne ferry, I1 heard two Glaswegian builders discussing radar. My mother thought they were Glaswegian builders going to build a radio station. When I got to Hut 1 at Musgrave Park I looked up “radar” in my 1939 Encyclopaedia Britannica1. There was no mention of radar in any of the nineteen 1939 volumes2. At Hut 1, Musgrave Park3,4 I was initially assigned for tuition to Benjamin Rycroft. Rycroft was already internationally known for his therapeutic replacement of human tissue5,6,7,8,9. Later to be knighted, Rycroft explained to me the principles of radar: “The critical need was for reliability and range.” Rycroft recounted how Robert A. Watson-Watt had pioneered the use of the radio echo method as a strategic military weapon, building on the earlier work of Professor Edward V. Appleton and the Radio Research Board10. I was later to learn that Appleton was knighted in 194111. Appleton won the 1947 Nobel Prize in Physics12. Watson-Watt was knighted in 194213. AIR DEFENSE RESEARCH, RADAR In 1934, Dr. Harry Egerton Wimperis, Director of Scientific Research of the U.K. Air Ministry, along with his colleague, A.P. Rowe, considered potential protection systems for Britain against German bombers. Director Wimperis proposed the creation of a Committee of Research on Air Defense under Professor, later Sir Henry Tizard, KCB10,14 (Fig. 1). The Tizard Committee recommended the intensification of their experimental program and in 1935 a dedicated laboratory was built at Oxfordness on the Suffolk coast10. In 1936 the research group was relocated to a larger facility at Bawdsey Manor near Felixstowe, where 240 foot-tall towers were built. By March 13, 1936, they were able to locate aircraft flying at an altitude of 1,500 feet from a 75-mile distance10. RAF pilots were trained to use the radar apparatus and in 1937 construction of a chain of twenty coastal stations was begun. By April 7, 1939, the chain of twenty stations “from Ventnor to the Tay started their continuous watch, which was never interrupted during the war except at one station which stopped for a short time owing to an unexploded bomb”10. The network of radar stations was known as the Chain Home (CH) stations. They were a component of the network known as the Dowding System controlling transmission of information and orders during German attacks15,16. Sir Henry Tizard, KCB, FRS (1885-1959), oil on canvas by Cuthbert J. Orde (1888-1968) . Presented to Imperial College, London, by the Civil Engineering Department, 1955. Leader of the Tizard Mission to the United States, August 1940. Every effort has been made to trace or contact all copyright holders. Dr. J.T. Randall, together with H.A.H. Boot, Physicist at Birmingham University, developed the cavity magnetron capable of producing a reliable output of hundreds of kilowatts in short pulses10. This small radio transmitter emitted ten-centimeter radiation at an intensity one thousand times greater than that produced by United States devices10,17. John D. Cockcroft, of St. John’s College (Fig. 2), working at Cambridge’s Cavendish Laboratory18,19,20 joined the coastal radar defense effort. The team adopted Butement’s 1.5 metre experimental radar equipment designed for coastal detection10. Six sets of this equipment were erected in the Shetland Islands. These devices could detect fully-surfaced submarines up to 25 miles away and aircraft up to 70 miles17. John D. Cockcroft (1897-1967), FRS 1936, Nobel Prize in Physics, 1951. Oil on canvas, 1944, by Rodrigo Moynihan (1910-1990), 50.8 cm x 40.6 cm. From the collections of the Imperial War Museum, London, IWM Art LD 5852; transferred from the War Artists’ Advisory Committee, 1947, and reproduced with their permission. On August 29, 1940, the group formally titled the British Technical and Scientific Mission, known as the Tizard Mission, sailed for North America. Tizard himself had departed for Ottawa in mid-August to privately meet with officials to discuss Canadian scientific participation in the war21. The team, which included Professor Cockcroft, brought with them a metal box containing secret information and a prototype cavity magnetron. During the following weeks the Tizard Mission traveled between Cambridge, MA, Washington D.C., New York, New Jersey and back again to Washington10,17,18,22. They met with the Microwave Committee of the U.S. National Defense Research Committee concurrently exploring deployment of radar in defense23. The Anglo-American Assemblage of Professors of Theoretical Physics was assembled in Washington D.C. Vannevar Bush (Fig. 3), investment banker-scientist Alfred L. Loomis24 and FDR were paying and authorizing for all activities10,17,22. Sir Joseph Larmor, Lucasian Professor Emeritus now returned to Ulster (Fig. 4)25,26 told Rycroft who later told me “Anglo- or U.S. they all appeared to have Princeton or Cambridge, U.S. and U.K. degrees.” Einstein27 or Rutherford-trained20 they were on the payrolls of Harvard, Princeton, Birmingham, Cambridge and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (M.I.T.). Tizard’s committee was flown to Boston to avail themselves of the all expenses paid largesse of Vannevar Bush, Alfred L. Loomis and FDR. It was agreed to invite from California Professor E.O. Lawrence, who had won the 1939 Nobel Prize in Physics24,28. Vannevar Bush (1890-1974), Charcoal and chalk drawing on paper, 51.5 cm x 38.5 cm, 1945 by Samuel Johnson Woolf (1880-1948). National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution, no. NPG.80.253 ©Estate of S.J. Woolf. Reproduced under Creative Commons License. Born in Everett, Massachusetts, Vannevar Bush joined the Department of Electrical Engineering at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (M.I.T.) in 1919. In 1922 he was a co-founder of the company that became Raytheon. In 1932 he was appointed Vice-President of M.I.T. and Dean of its School of Engineering. Following FDR’s suggestion, he was elected to the Presidency of the Carnegie Institution, Washington, D.C., in 1938. He became chairman of the National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics. As inaugural Science Advisor to FDR, Vannevar Bush chaired the National Defense Research Committee (NDRC) and the Office of Scientific Research and Development (OSRD), responsible for the advancement of radar and the Manhattan Project. Sir Joseph Larmor FRS, FRSE (1857-1942), oil-on-canvas, 1940, 101 cm x 86 cm, by Frank McKelvey (1895-1974). From the collection of the Naughton Gallery, Queen’s University Belfast, no. QUB 52, and reproduced with their permission. Born in County Antrim, his family moved to Belfast in 1860. He was educated at Queen’s Belfast where he received a BA in 1874 and MA 1875 in Mathematics and Experimental Science. As a Johnian, he was appointed Lucasian Professor of Mathematics in 1903. Larmor was elected Conservative MP for Cambridge University in 1922. From the outbreak of World War II until his death on May 19, 1942 he held a position of great responsibility as a liaison between King George VI and FDR. The first week in October 1940, when the Tizard Mission visited Washington, D.C., they met with Vannevar Bush, James B. Conant, President of Harvard University, E.O. Lawrence and K.T. Bainbridge, General Electric Scientist and Engineer10,17,24,29. At the U.S. Naval Reserve Laboratory the Tizard Mission was shown 8 meter radar in action. Aircraft were being picked up over 50 miles from Washington D.C. and followed to landing. Vannevar Bush saw reports, costs, and estimates, for bigger, long-range multimeter radar devices that aided the Allies in winning the WWII Battle of the Atlantic30. During the ‘Belfast Blitz’ in April 1941, there were six Chain Home radar stations in Northern Ireland, including one at Downhill31. By the end of 1941 additional radar stations were added including one to monitor the shipyards at Belfast31. Years later, My father-in-law, then RAF Flight Lieutenant George Stanley Waller of 502 (Ulster) Squadron, related how Whitley bombers had been rebuilt to fly at lower altitudes to evade radar designed to detect enemy aircraft32. Advances in radar increased the safety of medical transport by land and sea, and air evacuation of casualties throughout the world33,34,35,36,37,38,39. MUSGRAVE PARK, SIR JOSEPH LARMOR Soon after my arrival in Belfast before Christmas in 1940, Benjamin Rycroft himself introduced me to Sir Joseph Larmor (Fig.4)25,26. Larmor was, together with Max Rosenheim (later enobled)5, discussing roles of U.S. Army and American forces scheduled to arrive through Belfast, very soon to deploy throughout Northern Ireland40. Now residing in Northern Ireland, Sir Joseph Larmor was a facilitator for both FDR and the British Cabinet. Sir Joseph wanted to know who, if anyone, of the British would likely be anti-American. Lucasian Professor Emeritus Sir Joseph Larmor died on 19 May 1942 and was deeply mourned25,26. RADIOLOGY AND TEACHING In spring 1942, in Hut 1 at Musgrave Park, USAMC Lt. Col. Magnus I. Smedal asked me if he could discuss with me Mendeleev’s Periodic Table. I replied that I knew about the heavier elements. I asked “Why can’t we talk about cyclotrons”41? Dr. Magnus I. Smedal (Fig. 5) always said that he was an electrician who bragged about uses of electricity and the Bragg Effect41,42,43. At Musgrave Park he explained to me how Radiology was key to Abdominal Surgery, Ophthalmology, and Orthopaedics, and was even more important in time of war. Smedal’s three WWII Battle Stars were well deserved44. Smedal set up complex functioning electrical equipment within three hours of the first US troops landing on Omaha Beach. By 13 June 1944, the first mobile X-ray unit was in operation. Smedal used to tell Harvard, M.I.T. and Lahey Clinic staff, students, nurses and residents that image taking and making can change history. During his World War II service, Smedal also worked with tuberculosis expert Col. Theodore Badger, USAMC, in diagnosis and treatment of tuberculosis in Allied troops and civilian refugees45,46 Magnus Ingvald Smedal, M.D. (1905-1981), ca. 1944, photograph by Bachrach Photographers, Boston, MA, courtesy of the Smedal family and reproduced with their permission. Wisconsin-born, Magnus Smedal transferred from Medical School of the University of Wisconsin in 1927 to graduate M.D. from Harvard in 1929. After serving as Chief of Radiology at Harvard’s 5th General Hospital at Musgrave Park, his distinguished war record led to three Battle Stars for heroism in France at D-Day and at the Battle of the Bulge. Post-war he returned to Boston with the rank of Colonel. He served as Treasurer, then President of the New England Roentgen Ray Society. In the European Theater of Operations, X-ray machines were routinely used to diagnose combat and non-combat-related trauma and treat disease46,47,48. To assure the availability of radiographic images, U.S. medical officers from other specialties were trained in this modality and troops without training were taught to be competent X-ray technicians. Chest surgery was advanced, and the use of the X-ray facilitated removal of foreign bodies from the heart46. Because of strict US regulations for the transport and deployment of X-ray machines and supplies, most were required to be obtained in the UK. The U.S. Senior Consultant in Radiology, Col. Kenneth D.A. Allen, MD, and Dr. A.E. Barclay, Consultant to the British Ministry of Health, arranged for three-week training courses for selected U.S. radiologists at pre-eminent British radiologic centers. These courses were designed to facilitate liaison between the British and American radiologists, who were initially resistant to the use of British X-ray equipment. The US Senior Consultant also arranged meetings for all US Radiologists in Britain. The first such meeting was held on 22 May 1943 at the British Institute of Radiology, Welbeck Street, London. Brigadier D.B. McGrigor, RAMC, Consultant in Radiology to the British Army, educated his British and American colleagues on the importance of standardization of X-ray equipment. This talk was intended to make the American radiologists more amenable to the use of British equipment. Another such meeting was held at the same location on 7 December 1943, and attended by 56 radiologists, including then Lt. Col. Smedal46. While Chief of Radiology at the 5th General Hospital, Smedal produced a working manual for the effective operation of a hospital X-ray department46. At the end of WWII, Col. Magnus I. Smedal returned to M.I.T. and Harvard as senior consultant radiologist, later Department Head. He led the Radiology Department at the Lahey Clinic44,49 affiliated with the Harvard-M.I.T. Cyclotron41,44,49, and contributed much to particle acceleration in the treatment of cancer50,51,52,53,54,55,56,57. Smedal would order and personally interpret the images that turned out to be crucial in the patients’ management. EPILOGUE Rapid advances in radar and related technologies, and collaborative efforts between government and academia helped assure Allied victory in World War II. Dr. Smedal’s mentorship continued until his death in 1981. The Harvard University-Massachusetts Institute of Technology Program in Health Sciences and Technology, founded in 1970, was of great interest in our discussions58. The wartime challenges of incompatibility of medical and other equipment components, and operator training were remediated by the establishment post-World War II of the International Organization for Standardization in Geneva59. Dr. Smedal recognized the importance of standardization of medical equipment and congratulated his former pupil when I became active in this area60.