Development and Testing of the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index: Relationship With Preterm Birth and Small for Gestational Age Across Racial and Ethnic Groups Authors: Sueny P. Lima dos Santos, Eric E. Calloway, Ilana R. A. Chertok, Zelalem T. Haile Published: 2024 ABSTRACT IntroductionPreterm birth and small for gestational age (SGA) are significant public health concerns in the United States, with pronounced disparities across racial and ethnic groups. Traditional prenatal care adequacy indices have limitations in fully capturing their multifaceted nature. Our study introduces the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index (CPCI) to provide a more holistic assessment of prenatal care by integrating key elements of prenatal counseling and health promotion.MethodsThis cross‐sectional study used the Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System 2016‐2021 data. The CPCI was developed based on a comprehensive literature review, incorporating components such as timing, frequency, and content of prenatal visits. The index was validated using Item Response Theory (IRT) and compared with the Kotelchuck and Kessner Indices.ResultsThe study included 139,181 pregnant women. The CPCI demonstrated strong internal consistency (Cronbach's α, 0.75; ω total, 0.81). IRT analysis confirmed the index's ability to capture variability in the quality of prenatal care, with item difficulty parameters ranging from −2.93 to +2.10. CPCI scores were significantly associated with reduced odds of adverse birth outcomes. Adequate CPCI care was linked to a 63% reduction in the odds of preterm birth among non‐Hispanic White women, with similar reductions observed in Hispanic women (odds ratio [OR], 0.59) and Asian women (OR, 0.38). For SGA, adequate care was protective among non‐Hispanic White (OR, 0.86) and Hispanic women (OR, 0.82) but showed mixed results in other groups.DiscussionThe CPCI provides a more inclusive measure of the quality of prenatal care compared with traditional indices. The study's findings suggest a significant role of comprehensive prenatal care in reducing adverse birth outcomes and addressing racial and ethnic disparities. Future research should focus on refining the CPCI and exploring its applicability in diverse populations to inform targeted and culturally sensitive prenatal care strategies. INTRODUCTION In 2021, the global incidence of preterm birth was approximately 13.4 million, underscoring a critical need for intervention strategies. 1 Preterm birth and small for gestational age (SGA) remain critical indicators of maternal and newborn health in the United States and represent public health concerns. Preterm birth occurs before 37 weeks’ gestation, and SGA refers to newborns weighing less than the 10th percentile for their gestational age. 2 , 3 These disparities are especially pronounced among racial and ethnic groups. For instance, in 2022, African American women experienced preterm births at rates approximately 50% higher than White or Hispanic women. 1 , 4 These factors illustrate the complexity of adverse pregnancy outcomes, which are influenced by biological, behavioral, environmental, and socioeconomic factors that often interact in diverse ways. Obesity, gestational diabetes, and prepregnancy hypertension are significant contributors to the risk of early births and low birth weights. 5 , 6 , 7 Behavioral aspects like smoking and substance use are also contributing factors, 8 , 9 , 10 along with environmental exposure 11 , 12 , 13 and socioeconomic status. 8 , 12 Among these, the quality of prenatal care emerges as a critical, modifiable factor with the potential to influence pregnancy outcomes significantly. 8 , 14 Continuing education (CE) is available for this article. To obtain CE online, please visit http://www.jmwhce.org. A CE form that includes the test questions is available in the print edition of this issue. Continuing education (CE) is available for this article. To obtain CE online, please visit http://www.jmwhce.org. A CE form that includes the test questions is available in the print edition of this issue. Historically, prenatal care adequacy has been assessed using traditional metrics such as the Kotelchuck Index and the Kessner Index, which focus mainly on visit initiation and frequency. 15 , 16 , 17 However, the changing health care landscape needs a more comprehensive approach considering the frequency, content, quality, and context of prenatal care. Current prenatal care standards in the United States, guided by the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), offer a robust framework for health care providers. These guidelines align with international standards, such as those recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO), emphasizing prenatal counseling and health promotion as key components of care. 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 QUICK POINTS ✦We created the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index to provide a more holistic and inclusive measure of the quality of prenatal care, addressing the limitations of traditional indices.✦Our study developed the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index using a robust methodology, which includes extensive data sets, comprehensive care elements, and statistical validation techniques to ensure the index reflects the quality of prenatal care.✦The Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index predicted disparities in prenatal care and birth outcomes among different racial and ethnic groups, supporting the role of comprehensive care in improving newborn health outcomes.✦Findings from our study have implications for improving prenatal care strategies, tailoring interventions, and enhancing maternal and newborn health outcomes across diverse populations. QUICK POINTS ✦We created the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index to provide a more holistic and inclusive measure of the quality of prenatal care, addressing the limitations of traditional indices.✦Our study developed the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index using a robust methodology, which includes extensive data sets, comprehensive care elements, and statistical validation techniques to ensure the index reflects the quality of prenatal care.✦The Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index predicted disparities in prenatal care and birth outcomes among different racial and ethnic groups, supporting the role of comprehensive care in improving newborn health outcomes.✦Findings from our study have implications for improving prenatal care strategies, tailoring interventions, and enhancing maternal and newborn health outcomes across diverse populations. ✦We created the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index to provide a more holistic and inclusive measure of the quality of prenatal care, addressing the limitations of traditional indices. We created the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index to provide a more holistic and inclusive measure of the quality of prenatal care, addressing the limitations of traditional indices. ✦Our study developed the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index using a robust methodology, which includes extensive data sets, comprehensive care elements, and statistical validation techniques to ensure the index reflects the quality of prenatal care. Our study developed the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index using a robust methodology, which includes extensive data sets, comprehensive care elements, and statistical validation techniques to ensure the index reflects the quality of prenatal care. ✦The Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index predicted disparities in prenatal care and birth outcomes among different racial and ethnic groups, supporting the role of comprehensive care in improving newborn health outcomes. The Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index predicted disparities in prenatal care and birth outcomes among different racial and ethnic groups, supporting the role of comprehensive care in improving newborn health outcomes. ✦Findings from our study have implications for improving prenatal care strategies, tailoring interventions, and enhancing maternal and newborn health outcomes across diverse populations. Findings from our study have implications for improving prenatal care strategies, tailoring interventions, and enhancing maternal and newborn health outcomes across diverse populations. In response to the need for a more comprehensive assessment of prenatal care that goes beyond that traditional focus on visit timing and frequency, we propose the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index (CPCI), which integrates essential measures of frequency and timing, accessibility, and components of care. This index was developed using Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS) data from 2016 to 2021. The primary goals of this study were to validate the reliability and validity of the CPCI and to examine the association between CPCI and preterm birth and SGA across diverse racial and ethnic groups, demonstrating the potential of comprehensive prenatal care to reduce disparities in birth outcomes. METHODS Instrument Development The CPCI was developed through a secondary data analysis using the PRAMS data, focusing on the 14 prenatal care questions. 22 The PRAMS questionnaire contains several items related to prenatal care that could facilitate the development of the CPCI. The selection of items for the CPCI from items used in the PRAMS questionnaire was guided by alignment with key aspects of prenatal care recommended by the AAP, the ACOG, and the WHO guidelines. Items were chosen to reflect comprehensive dimensions of prenatal care: frequency and timing of visits, accessibility of care, and components of care (see Table 1). Although the questionnaire does lack some recommended guidelines, it includes 14 questions that effectively assess the quality of prenatal care. We employed several types of validity testing to construct and validate the CPCI as a comprehensive measure of the quality of prenatal care (detailed in Supporting Information: Appendix S1). We used the PROC Item Response Theory (IRT) procedure to analyze the CPCI and assess Differential Item Functioning (DIF) across maternal race and ethnicity groups. This process involved determining whether certain items performed differently across these groups, potentially indicating biases or disparities in item responses, and ensuring the questionnaire was fair and applicable to diverse populations. 23 Table 1Questions From the Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System Used to Construct the Comprehensive Prenatal Care IndexCode (PRAMS)Question (PRAMS)Response OptionsScoringGrouping for CPCICorresponding Recommendations Characteristics POBPlace of birthHospital, birthing center, medical office/clinic, residence, other Hospital, birthing center, medical office/clinic = 1 (recommended) Residence, other = 0 (not recommended) If the respondent gave birth at the hospital, birthing center, medical office/clinic, and has health care coverage = 1 (recommended) Otherwise = 0 (not recommended) WHO: Ensure birth in medical facilitiesINSNONE/INSMED/ INSWORK8/ INSHCEX/ INSMIL/ INSCHIP/ INSOTH/ INSGOV/ INSPARHealth care coverage during prenatal periodMedicaid, Private, TRICARE or Military, government plan, Tribal Have health insurance = 1 (recommended) Otherwise = 0 (not recommended) ACOG: Encourage prenatal care insurancePNC_VST_NAPHSISNumber of prenatal visits8+, <8 8 or more = 1 (recommended) Otherwise = 0 (not recommended) If the respondent has 8+ visits, and the timing was in the first trimester = 1 (recommended) Otherwise = 0 (not recommended) WHO, AAP and ACOG: Recommend minimum number of visitsNNC_1TRMTiming of first prenatal care visitFirst trimester, after first trimester First trimester = 1 Otherwise = 0 (not recommended) AAP and WHO: Recommend first trimester start During any of your prenatal care visits, did a doctor, nurse, or other health care worker ask you any of the things listed below? (prenatal care content) TLK_WTIf I knew how much weight I should gain during pregnancy Yes = 1 No = 0 If the respondent answered “Yes,” indicating that they received this information or counseling during their prenatal care. If the answer was “No,” indicating a lack of discussion on these topics. The median value was used to categorize the level of prenatal care content received by each participant. Above the median (Yes = 1) are considered to have received a higher level of prenatal care information. Scoring below the median (No = 0) considered to have received a lower level. ACOG: Discuss weight gain as per guidelinesASK_MEDSIf I was taking any prescription medication Yes = 1 No = 0 WHO: Advise on safe medication use during pregnancyTLK_CIGSIf I was smoking cigarettes Yes = 1 No = 0 AAP: Counsel on smoking cessation in pregnancyTLK_ETOHIf I was drinking alcohol Yes = 1 No = 0 CDC and ACOG: Advise against alcohol consumption during pregnancyASK_ABUSIf someone was hurting me emotionally or physically Yes = 1 No = 0 WHO: Screen for intimate partner violence in pregnancyASK_DPRSIf I was feeling down or depressed Yes = 1 No = 0 AAP and ACOG: Screen for depression during and after pregnancy ASK_DRUGIf I was using drugs such as marijuana, cocaine, crack, or meth Yes = 1 No = 0 ACOG: Counsel on substance abuse and treatment options ASK_HIVTIf I wanted to be tested for HIV (the virus that causes AIDS) Yes = 1 No = 0 WHO and CDC: Recommend HIV testing early in pregnancy ASK_BFIf I planned to breastfeeding my new baby Yes = 1 No = 0 AAP and WHO: Encourage breastfeeding planning and support ASK_PPBCIf I planned to use birth control after my baby was born Yes = 1 No = 0 ACOG: Discuss postpartum contraception optionsAbbreviations: AAP, American Academy of Pediatrics; ACOG, American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists; CDC, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; WHO, World Health Organization.John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Questions From the Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System Used to Construct the Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index Hospital, birthing center, medical office/clinic = 1 (recommended) Residence, other = 0 (not recommended) If the respondent gave birth at the hospital, birthing center, medical office/clinic, and has health care coverage = 1 (recommended) Otherwise = 0 (not recommended) Have health insurance = 1 (recommended) Otherwise = 0 (not recommended) 8 or more = 1 (recommended) Otherwise = 0 (not recommended) If the respondent has 8+ visits, and the timing was in the first trimester = 1 (recommended) Otherwise = 0 (not recommended) First trimester = 1 Otherwise = 0 (not recommended) Yes = 1 No = 0 If the respondent answered “Yes,” indicating that they received this information or counseling during their prenatal care. If the answer was “No,” indicating a lack of discussion on these topics. The median value was used to categorize the level of prenatal care content received by each participant. Above the median (Yes = 1) are considered to have received a higher level of prenatal care information. Scoring below the median (No = 0) considered to have received a lower level. Yes = 1 No = 0 Yes = 1 No = 0 Yes = 1 No = 0 Yes = 1 No = 0 Yes = 1 No = 0 AAP and ACOG: Screen for depression during and after pregnancy Yes = 1 No = 0 ACOG: Counsel on substance abuse and treatment options Yes = 1 No = 0 WHO and CDC: Recommend HIV testing early in pregnancy Yes = 1 No = 0 AAP and WHO: Encourage breastfeeding planning and support Yes = 1 No = 0 Abbreviations: AAP, American Academy of Pediatrics; ACOG, American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists; CDC, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; WHO, World Health Organization. Study Design and Participants Our study employed a cross‐sectional data analysis from PRAMS Phase 8, which spanned 2016 to 2021. This extensive surveillance mechanism meticulously gathers data on maternal behaviors, health care experiences, and the associated outcomes before, during, and after pregnancy, covering 47 US states, the District of Columbia, New York City, Puerto Rico, and the Great Plains Tribal Chairman's Health Board. 24 Please refer to the PRAMS Design and Methodology document for a comprehensive PRAMS design and methodology overview. 25 The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention makes deidentified PRAMS data available to researchers upon request. The Ohio University Institutional Review Board determined this secondary data analysis to be exempt under reference number IRB‐FY24‐52. Measures We evaluated 3 principal exposure variables concerning prenatal care adequacy: The Adequacy of Prenatal Care Utilization index, also known as the Kotelchuck Index, 16 measures the adequacy of prenatal care by combining the timing of prenatal care initiation with the number of prenatal visits adjusted for the interval between the initiation of prenatal care and the gestational age. This index categorizes prenatal care into 4 adequacy categories: adequate plus, adequate, intermediate, and inadequate. The Kessner Index measures prenatal care adequacy based on the trimester in which care began, the number of prenatal visits, and the length of the pregnancy. It classifies prenatal care into 3 categories: adequate, intermediate, or inadequate. The new CPCI was developed based on several PRAMS variables to holistically assess the quality of prenatal care (see Instrument Development section). The primary outcomes of interest were preterm birth and SGA. Newborns were classified as preterm if they were born before 37 weeks’ gestation or full term if they were born at 37 weeks’ gestation or later. Newborns were categorized as yes for SGA if their birth weight fell below the 10th percentile for gestational age and no if they did not meet this criterion. Based on a comprehensive literature review, several maternal, newborn, and health‐related covariates were selected for this study. Maternal characteristics included age (grouped into 5 categories), marital status (married or other), race and ethnicity (non‐Hispanic White, Non‐Hispanic Black, Hispanic, Asian [including Chinese, Japanese, Filipino, and other Asian groups], Tribal groups [including American Indian, Hawaiian, and Alaska Native], and other [including other non‐White and mixed race]), education level (less than high school, high school diploma, or more than high school), and parity (primiparous or multiparous). Maternal health factors examined were pregnancy intention (intended, mistimed, unwanted, or unsure), type of birth (vaginal or cesarean), prepregnancy body mass index (categorized by WHO criteria), participation in the Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children during pregnancy (yes or no), weight gain (per Institute of Medicine guidelines), hypertension, diabetes, smoking, and alcohol use during the last trimester, and depression before pregnancy. Newborn characteristics included birth weight (low, normal, or high), sex (male or female), ever breastfed (yes or no), and breastfeeding duration greater than 3 months (yes or no). Statistical Analysis Statistical analyses were performed using SAS PROC SURVEY procedures, which consider the PRAMS data set's complex design elements like stratification and weighting, ensuring representative and unbiased population estimates. Descriptive analysis began with summarizing data via PROC SURVEYFREQ and PROC SURVEYMEANS. SEs were estimated using the Taylor Series linearization method, 26 accommodating missing values via the Not Missing Completely at Random approach. 27 Furthermore, finite population correction was applied to refine variance estimates based on the sample‐to‐population size ratio, improving estimate accuracy. 26 In analyzing preterm birth and SGA predictors, we employed PROC SURVEYLOGISTIC to adjust for critical confounders like maternal demographics and health behaviors, assessing their impact as odds ratios (ORs). All covariates were retained in the multivariable model using forced entry methods regardless of their bivariate significance. 28 , 29 We incorporated variables with established theoretical relevance and empirical support for their association with preterm birth and small for gestational weight outcomes. 15 , 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 , 36 , 37 , 38 , 39 , 40 , 41 , 42 , 43 , 44 , 45 , 46 We added pairwise interaction terms to explore varying effects across racial and ethnic groups. We conducted stratified analyses to assess the consistency of the prenatal care‐outcome relationship across different populations. All analyses were performed using SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute Inc, Cary, NC), and results with a value of P < .05 were considered statistically significant. Rasch modeling and DIF analyses were also conducted using JMetrik version 4.1.1. This study adhered to the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology guidelines. RESULTS Sample Characteristics The sample of 139,181 pregnant women was categorized into various racial and ethnic groups (Tables 2, 3, 4), with non‐Hispanic White women constituting the largest group (60.7%), followed by Hispanic women (17.0%), non‐Hispanic Black women (12.9%), Asian women (5.4%), Tribal women (0.8%), and women from other racial and ethnic groups (3.2%). Maternal sociodemographic factors indicated variability across age groups, with the highest proportion of participants aged 25 to 29 years (29.2%). Marital status showed that most participants were married (66.4%). Educational levels were predominantly higher than high school (70.5%). Maternal and newborn health variables revealed a higher incidence of multiparous women (59.4%) and a vaginal birth rate of 68.2%. Newborn sex was nearly evenly split between male (50.8%) and female (49.2%). Most of the sample experienced full term pregnancies (92.7%) with birth weights predominantly from 2500 to 4000 g (85.6%). The study also examined maternal behaviors and health use factors. Notably, a large proportion of the sample did not follow the recommended daily intake of prepregnancy vitamins (61.1%) and had no prepregnancy smoking (86.2%) or alcohol consumption (62.0%). Breastfeeding duration was greater than or equal to 3 months for most participants (69.4%). Table 2Maternal Health Factors by Race and Ethnicity in the Sample Study (N = 139,181)Variablesn (Wt.%)Non‐Hispanic White n (Wt.%) 68,967 (60.7)Non‐Hispanic Black n (Wt.%) 21,635 (12.9)Hispanic n (Wt.%) 24,671 (17.0)Asian n (Wt.%) 10,353 (5.4)Tribal n (Wt.%) 5409 (0.8)Other n (Wt.%) 8146 (3.2) Age 18‐194303 (2.8)1439 (2.0)896 (4.1)1193 (4.7)58 (0.5)372 (6.8)345 (4.4)20‐2424,684 (17.3)9891 (14.7)4845 (23.9)6010 (23.9)615 (5.2)1529 (26.5)1794 (22.4)25‐2940,562 (29.2)20,276 (29.2)6508 (30.5)7257 (29.4)2462 (24.6)1660 (32.1)2399 (29.4)30‐3443,256 (31.7)23,823 (34.6)5582 (24.6)6104 (25.1)4317 (41.5)1209 (23.0)2221 (26.4)>3426,376 (19.0)13,538 (19.4)3804 (16.9)4107 (16.9)2901 (28.1)639 (11.6)1387 (17.4) Married No50,036 (33.6)15,565 (23.4)13,760 (66.3)12,345 (49.4)1183 (10.8)3578 (63.6)3605 (41.2)Yes89,145 (66.4)53,402 (76.6)7875 (33.7)12,326 (50.6)9170 (89.2)1831 (36.4)4541 (58.8) Education High school97,780 (70.5)54,556 (78.0)13,392 (60.4)12,619 (48.2)8920 (85.2)2617 (49.2)5676 (68.7) Parity Primiparous57,295 (40.6)29,609 (41.8)8166 (37.6)9384 (36.6)5044 (48.0)1675 (32.9)3417 (41.9)Multiparous81,886 (59.4)39,358 (58.2)13,469 (62.4)15,287 (63.4)5309 (52.0)3734 (67.1)4729 (58.1) Mode of birth Cesarean46,832 (31.8)21,901 (30.1)8585 (37.7)8733 (33.0)3581 (33.9)1508 (27.7)2524 (31.0)Vaginal92,346 (68.2)47,066 (69.9)13,050 (62.3)15,938 (67.0)6772 (66.1)3901 (72.3)5622 (69.0) WIC during pregnancy No93,441 (70.4)56,013 (80.6)10,322 (48.9)11,019 (48.8)8529 (81.8)2309 (45.4)5249 (64.4)Yes45,740 (29.6)12,954 (19.4)11,313 (51.1)13,652 (51.2)1824 (18.2)3100 (54.6)2897 (35.6) Prepregnancy BMI Underweight (<18.5 kg/m2)4499 (3.0)2073 (2.7)625 (3.1)773 (2.9)658 (6.0)112 (2.1)258 (3.6)Normal (18.5‐24.9 kg/m2)61,546 (45.5)33,604 (48.9)7079 (32.9)9433 (38.6)6305 (62.6)1831 (32.6)3294 (42.2)Overweight (25.0‐29.9 kg/m2)36,168 (26.2)17,165 (25.2)5837 (27.6)7288 (30.1)2262 (21.3)1471 (26.9)2145 (28.3)Obese (≥30 kg/m2)36,968 (25.3)16,125 (23.2)8094 (36.4)7177 (28.4)1128 (10.1)1995 (38.3)2449 (26.0) Gestational weight gain Below IOM guidelines35,560 (22.9)15,533 (20.5)6258 (27.4)7037 (25.8)3286 (29.1)1507 (25.6)1939 (24.7)Within IOM guidelines42,590 (31.1)22,058 (31.8)5622 (26.0)7365 (30.4)3874 (39.4)1430 (27.6)2241 (28.0)Above IOM guidelines61,031 (46.0)31,376 (47.7)9755 (46.6)10,269 (43.8)3193 (31.5)2472 (46.8)3966 (47.4) Pregnancy intention Intended85,230 (62.7)48,169 (69.4)8894 (39.8)13,610 (55.3)7420 (71.0)2569 (49.1)4568 (56.5)Mistimed25,031 (17.9)9654 (14.5)5595 (27.0)5880 (24.4)1431 (14.2)965 (19.5)1506 (19.5)Unwanted7903 (5.4)2837 (4.2)2172 (10.3)1567 (6.3)373 (3.8)394 (7.2)560 (7.1)Unsure21,017 (14.0)8307 (12.0)4974 (22.9)3614 (14.0)1129 (11.1)1481 (24.2)1512 (16.9) Prepregnancy hypertension No122,969 (90.4)61,082 (90.5)18,135 (86.3)22,256 (92.1)9603 (94.6)4719 (88.1)7174 (90.7)Yes16,212 (9.6)7885 (9.5)3500 (13.7)2415 (7.9)750 (5.4)690 (11.9)972 (9.3) Prepregnancy diabetes No134,872 (97.1)67,006 (97.3)20,880 (97.1)23,898 (96.8)9985 (96.3)5201 (95.7)7902 (97.3)Yes4309 (2.9)1961 (2.7)755 (2.9)773 (3.2)368 (3.7)208 (4.3)244 (2.7) Gestational diabetes No128,626 (92.9)64,647 (93.7)20,217 (94.0)22,660 (92.0)8845 (85.4)4838 (90.6)7419 (93.0)Yes10,555 (7.1)4320 (6.3)1418 (6.0)2011 (8.0)1508 (14.6)571 (9.4)727 (7.0) Prepregnancy depression No119,053 (86.4)57,558 (84.4)18,776 (88.2)21,969 (90.1)9875 (95.0)4330 (82.1)6545 (83.2)Yes20,128 (13.6)11,409 (15.6)2859 (11.8)2702 (9.9)478 (5.0)1079 (17.9)1601 (16.8) Prepregnancy vitamins 1‐6 times/wk (not recommended)87,177 (61.1)38,137 (55.8)16,002 (73.1)17,645 (70.8)5703 (55.6)4201 (77.1)5489 (66.6)Every day (recommended)52,004 (38.9)30,830 (44.2)5633 (26.9)7026 (29.2)4650 (44.4)1208 (22.9)2657 (33.4) Prepregnancy smoking No118,715 (86.2)57,842 (83.7)18,689 (88.0)22,490 (91.9)9964 (96.6)3336 (67.9)6394 (82.5)Yes20,466 (13.8)11,125 (16.3)2946 (12.0)2181 (8.1)389 (3.4)2073 (32.1)1752 (17.5) Prepregnancy alcohol consumption No56,318 (38.0)20,678 (29.2)10,621 (48.5)12,798 (51.7)6572 (64.4)2583 (48.3)3066 (42.4)Yes82,863 (62.0)48,289 (70.8)11,014 (51.5)11,873 (48.3)3781 (35.6)2826 (51.7)5080 (57.6) Breastfeeding duration <3 mo42,548 (30.6)18,620 (27.7)9079 (42.8)8618 (34.7)1935 (20.1)1971 (38.2)2325 (29.9)≥3 mo96,633 (69.4)50,347 (72.3)12,556 (57.2)16,053 (65.3)8418 (79.9)3438 (61.8)5821 (70.1)Abbreviations: BMI, body mass index; IOM, Institute of Medicine; WIC, Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children; Wt.%, weighted percentage.John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Maternal Health Factors by Race and Ethnicity in the Sample Study (N = 139,181) Abbreviations: BMI, body mass index; IOM, Institute of Medicine; WIC, Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children; Wt.%, weighted percentage. Table 3Newborn Health Factors by Race and Ethnicity in the Study Sample (N = 139,181)Variablesn (Wt.%)Non‐Hispanic White n (Wt.%) 68,967 (60.7)Non‐Hispanic Black n (Wt.%) 21,635 (12.9)Hispanic n (Wt.%) 24,671 (17.0)Asian n (Wt.%) 10,353 (5.4)Tribal n (Wt.%) 5409 (0.8)Other n (Wt.%) 8146 (3.2) Newborn sex Male69,878 (50.8)34,715 (50.9)10,667 (50.3)12,384 (50.5)5293 (51.1)2723 (49.8)4096 (50.8)Female69,303 (49.2)34,252 (49.1)10,968 (49.7)12,287 (49.5)5060 (48.9)2686 (50.2)4050 (49.2) Gestational age Preterm20,083 (7.3)9605 (6.5)3955 (10.8)3728 (7.4)1277 (7.1)550 (8.3)968 (7.6)Full term119,098 (92.7)59,362 (93.5)17,680 (89.2)20,943 (92.6)9076 (92.9)4859 (91.7)7178 (92.4) Birth weight, g <250023,789 (5.8)11,395 (4.6)4746 (10.9)7037 (25.8)1698 (7.6)376 (5.2)1055 (6.5)2500–4000105,170 (85.6)51,658 (85.2)15,924 (84.0)7365 (30.4)8225 (88.1)4333 (83.2)6399 (84.8)>400010,225 (8.6)5914 (10.2)965 (5.1)10,269 (43.8)430 (4.3)700 (11.5)692 (8.8) Small for gestational age No120,382 (90.9)59,366 (91.2)19,007 (91.0)20,974 (90.4)8889 (89.2)4974 (90.9)7172 (89.1)Yes96,633 (9.1)9601 (8.8)2628 (9.0)3697 (9.6)1464 (10.8)435 (9.1)974 (10.9)Abbreviation: Wt.%, weighted percentage.John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Newborn Health Factors by Race and Ethnicity in the Study Sample (N = 139,181) Abbreviation: Wt.%, weighted percentage. Table 4Prenatal Care Use and Components by Race and Ethnicity in the Study Sample (N = 139,181)Variablesn (Wt.%)Non‐Hispanic White n (Wt.%) 68,967 (60.7)Non‐Hispanic Black n (Wt.%) 21,635 (12.9)Hispanic n (Wt.%) 24,671 (17.0)Asian n (Wt.%) 10,353 (5.4)Tribal n (Wt.%) 5409 (0.8)Other n (Wt.%) 8146 (3.2) Frequency prenatal care <8 visits26,877 (16.3)10,872 (13.0)5413 (24.1)5161 (21.1)1930 (16.0)1876 (32.3)1625 (18.9)≥8 visits112,304 (83.7)58,095 (87.0)16,222 (75.9)19,510 (78.9)8423 (84.0)3533 (67.7)6521 (81.1) Timing of first prenatal care ≥3 visits14,395 (9.9)4799 (7.0)3370 (15.8)3479 (15.5)973 (9.4)946 (19.4)828 (10.6)<3 visits124,786 (90.1)64,168 (93.0)18,265 (84.2)21,192 (84.5)9380 (90.6)4463 (80.6)7318 (89.4) Place of birth Residence1523 (1.2)1084 (1.7)116 (0.5)139 (0.5)36 (0.3)35 (0.5)113 (1.3)Hospital/clinic/birth center137,658 (98.8)67,883 (98.3)21,519 (99.5)24,532 (99.5)10,317 (99.7)5374 (99.5)8033 (98.7) Prenatal insurance No14,873 (11.6)5010 (7.6)2229 (11.7)5902 (27.9)637 (6.9)404 (7.1)691 (9.7)Yes124,308 (88.4)63,957 (92.4)19,406 (88.3)18,769 (72.1)9716 (93.1)5005 (92.9)7455 (90.3) Kotelchuck Index Inadequate14,871 (10.7)5395 (8.0)3145 (16.2)3131 (15.1)1034 (10.3)1207 (21.8)959 (12.7)Intermediate14,526 (10.6)6515 (9.8)2380 (11.5)2601 (12.1)1213 (11.9)864 (15.0)953 (11.5)Adequate62,780 (47.3)33,439 (50.2)8342 (40.1)10,443 (42.8)4888 (48.4)2012 (38.9)3656 (46.2)Adequate plus47,004 (31.4)23,618 (32.1)7768 (32.2)8496 (29.9)3218 (29.3)1326 (24.2)2578 (29.6) Kessner Index Inadequate7478 (5.2)2617 (3.8)1573 (8.4)1538 (7.1)550 (5.3)728 (11.7)472 (5.7)Intermediate26,449 (18.3)10,728 (15.1)5272 (24.7)5348 (24.3)1929 (17.6)1530 (29.6)1642 (21.2)Adequate105,254 (76.5)55,622 (81.1)14,790 (67.0)17,785 (68.6)7874 (77.1)3151 (58.7)6032 (73.1) Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index Inadequate22,257 (15.4)9577 (12.7)3433 (16.2)5642 (24.6)1447 (13.7)944 (17.7)1214 (15.4)Intermediate66,150 (48.3)34,001 (50.1)9604 (44.4)11,215 (44.6)5224 (51.5)2436 (45.2)3670 (46.5)Adequate50,774 (36.3)25,389 (37.3)8598 (39.4)7814 (30.7)3682 (34.7)2029 (37.1)3262 (38.1)Abbreviation: Wt.%, weighted percentage.John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Prenatal Care Use and Components by Race and Ethnicity in the Study Sample (N = 139,181) Abbreviation: Wt.%, weighted percentage. Assessment of Index Characteristics and Reliability The raw Cronbach's coefficient α was satisfactory (0.75) and 0.76 for standardized items. Deleting any single item did not significantly increase the α coefficient, demonstrating that each item contributed meaningfully to the scale's internal consistency. However, recognizing the limitations of Cronbach's α, particularly its assumption of equal item variances, we also calculated the coefficient Ω, which was 0.81 and is considered satisfactory. To further assess the validity of the CPCI, we used IRT with the Rasch model, applying marginal maximum likelihood estimation with a logit link function. Item parameters varied in difficulty, demonstrating the scale's ability to capture a wide range of the quality of prenatal care. The item “place of birth” had a difficulty parameter of −2.93, indicating that this aspect of prenatal care required the least amount of the latent trait to endorse. In contrast, items requiring a higher latent trait, which corresponds to a higher level of the quality of prenatal care, included questions about whether the provider asked about certain aspects of care: for example, the question “if I planned to use birth control after my baby was born” with a difficulty parameter of +0.50 and “number of prenatal visits,” which had a difficulty parameter of +0.67. The item “if I wanted to be tested for HIV” stood out with a difficulty parameter of +2.10, indicating that it required a significantly higher level of the quality of prenatal care for endorsement. Regarding substance use and mental health, the difficulty parameters also varied. For instance, “if I was smoking cigarettes” had a difficulty parameter of −1.39, indicating it required less of the latent trait. Conversely, items like “if I was feeling down or depressed” with a difficulty parameter of +0.68, and “[Asked by a health care professional] if someone was hurting me emotionally or physically” with a difficulty parameter of +1.14, required higher amounts of the latent trait to endorse, reflecting more comprehensive prenatal care (see the details in Supporting Information: Appendix S2). The theta (θ) values, representing the estimated latent trait level for each total score on the scale, range from −4.7 to +4.6. This wide spectrum indicates significant variability in the quality of prenatal care among participants, reflecting differences in access, quality, or understanding of prenatal care services. It is important to note that whereas the item reliability is near perfect at 0.9, which reflects the consistency and stability of the items in measuring the latent trait across all participants, the reliability for persons was found to be low (0.36), indicating considerable variability in individuals’ responses. This suggests that there is room for improvement in distinguishing between different levels of quality of prenatal care among participants. All scale quality statistics obtained for the study are presented in Supporting Information: Appendix S3 and S4. The PCA results identified 5 key dimensions that align with the proposed components of the quality of prenatal care. The first dimension related to substance use (“if I was smoking cigarettes” and “if I was drinking alcohol”) loaded highly on the first principal component (C1), indicating a strong relation to risk‐related behaviors during pregnancy. On the other hand, “place of birth” showed minimal association with any of the components, suggesting it might be influenced by other factors not captured by this analysis. The detailed PCA results are in Supporting Information: Appendix S5. DIF was explored across 6 maternal race and ethnicity groups to determine if the items within our scale functioned differently among these groups. DIF occurs when groups, such as those defined by race or ethnicity, have different probabilities of endorsing an item on a scale after accounting for the overall level of the trait or construct being measured. The only item that showed no significant level of racial disparity was whether health care workers asked if the individual was smoking cigarettes during prenatal visits (P = .47). This suggests that this item had no differential item functioning, meaning respondents from different racial or ethnic groups had similar probabilities of endorsing this item when controlling for overall scale scores. However, all other items analyzed demonstrated significant DIF, reflecting a difference in how different racial groups experienced and responded to questions related to prenatal care. Prenatal Care Use and Quality Assessment A total of 83.7% of women had 8 or more prenatal visits, with non‐Hispanic White women reporting the highest frequency (87.0%) and Tribal women the lowest (67.7%). Concerning the timing of the first prenatal care visit, 90.1% initiated care within the first 3 months of pregnancy. However, the initiation of prenatal care was more likely to be delayed among non‐Hispanic Black women, with 15.8% reporting their first visit at 3 months or later. Hospital or clinic births were nearly universal across all groups (98.8%), and a vast majority held prenatal insurance (88.4%), indicating good access to health care facilities and financial coverage for prenatal services (see Table 4). According to the 3 different measures of prenatal care adequacy—the Kotelchuck Index, the Kessner Index, and the CPCI—significant disparities were observed across racial and ethnic groups. For the adequate care category, the Kotelchuck Index classified 47.3% of the total sample as receiving adequate care, with non‐Hispanic White women having the highest proportion at 50.2%, followed by Asian women at 48.4%. The Kessner Index reported a higher overall rate of 76.5% for adequate care, with non‐Hispanic White women again having the highest percentage at 81.1%, whereas Tribal women had the lowest at 58.7%. According to the CPCI, 36.3% of the total sample received adequate care, with non‐Hispanic White women having the highest proportion at 37.3%, followed closely by women in the other category at 38.1%. In terms of inadequate care, the Kotelchuck Index revealed that 10.7% of the overall sample was classified as receiving inadequate care, with the highest rate among Tribal women at 21.8%, and the lowest among non‐Hispanic White women at 8.0%. The Kessner Index reported 5.2% of the total sample receiving inadequate care, with the highest rate among Tribal women at 11.7%, and the lowest among non‐Hispanic White women at 3.8%. The CPCI indicated that 15.4% of the total sample received inadequate care, with the highest proportion among Hispanic women at 24.6%, whereas non‐Hispanic White women had the lowest rate at 12.7%. For the intermediate level of care, 10.6% of the total sample fell into this category, according to the Kotelchuck Index, with the highest proportion among Tribal women at 15.0%. The Kessner Index reported 18.3% of the total sample receiving intermediate care, with the highest proportion among Tribal women at 29.6%. The CPCI indicated that 48.3% of the total sample received intermediate care, with Asian women having the highest proportion at 51.5%. Finally, for the adequate plus level of care, the Kotelchuck Index indicated that 31.4% of the total sample received this highest level of care, with non‐Hispanic White women having the highest proportion at 32.1%. There is no directly comparable category in the Kessner Index or CPCI, which focuses more on categorizing inadequacy, intermediate, or adequate care levels. Interactions Between Prenatal Care Indices and Race and Ethnicity on Birth Outcomes In the regression analysis, we examined pairwise interactions between the 3 indices and race and ethnicity on the odds of preterm birth and SGA. The pairwise interactions between maternal race and/or ethnicity and these indices on the odds of preterm birth were significant: CPCI*race/ethnicity (P < .001), Kotelchuck Index*race/ethnicity (P = .042), and Kessner Index*race/ethnicity (P < .001). For the odds of SGA, whereas the interactions for the Kotelchuck Index*race/ethnicity (P = .068) and Kessner Index*race/ethnicity (P = .050) approached significance, the interaction for CPCI*race/ethnicity (P = .257) did not meet the significance threshold (α = .10). Despite this, all interactions were included in the analysis to provide a comprehensive view of the relationships between prenatal care adequacy and maternal race and ethnicity. In this context, we evaluated the association of the CPCI relative to the established Kotelchuck and Kessner Indices in predicting birth outcomes, specifically focusing on preterm births (Table 5) and SGA cases (Table 6). The analysis indicates that the CPCI shows a consistent trend across all racial and ethnic groups, with intermediate and adequate care significantly reducing the odds of preterm birth compared with inadequate care. For instance, adequate prenatal care is associated with the lowest ORs among all groups, ranging from 0.35 (95% CI, 0.24‐0.52) in women in the others subgroup to 0.59 (95% CI, 0.49‐0.71) in Hispanic women. Similarly, the Kotelchuck Index indicated that intermediate and adequate care reduced the odds of preterm birth, with adequate care associated with reductions across groups, with an OR of 0.39 (95% CI, 0.33‐0.45) among White women and 0.36 (95% CI, 0.20‐0.64) among women in the others subgroup. However, the adequate plus level presented a paradoxical association with increased odds of preterm birth in all groups, with the highest OR observed in Hispanic women (OR, 2.42; 95% CI, 1.93‐3.03). The Kessner Index results show a similar pattern of reduced odds with adequate care, with the lowest OR observed in the Tribal group (OR, 0.49; 95% CI, 0.32‐0.74). Table 5Association Between Prenatal Care Indices and Odds of a Preterm Birth Stratified by Maternal Race and EthnicityIndicesWhite Odds Ratio (95% CI)Black Odds Ratio (95% CI)Hispanic Odds Ratio (95% CI)Asian Odds Ratio (95% CI)Tribal Odds Ratio (95% CI)Others Odds Ratio (95% CI) Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index Inadequate1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]Intermediate0.48 (0.44‐0.54)0.65 (0.55‐0.76)0.76 (0.65‐0.89)0.49 (0.38‐0.64)0.77 (0.52‐1.14)0.49 (0.34‐0.71)Adequate0.37 (0.33‐0.41)0.45 (0.38‐0.54)0.59 (0.49‐0.71)0.38 (0.28‐0.51)0.46 (0.30‐0.71)0.35 (0.24‐0.52) Kotelchuck Index Inadequate1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]Intermediate0.59 (0.49‐0.73)0.53 (0.41‐0.68)0.64 (0.47‐0.88)0.48 (0.30‐0.78)0.67 (0.44‐1.02)0.66 (0.34‐1.28)Adequate0.39 (0.33‐0.45)0.50 (0.41‐0.61)0.46 (0.36‐0.59)0.36 (0.26‐0.51)0.59 (0.38‐0.92)0.36 (0.20‐0.64)Adequate plus1.94 (1.68‐2.24)2.23 (1.86‐2.68)2.42 (1.93‐3.03)2.31 (1.68‐3.19)1.62 (1.08‐2.43)2.46 (1.51‐4.02) Kessner Index Inadequate1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]Intermediate1.35 (1.13‐1.61)1.16 (0.92‐1.46)1.45 (0.87‐1.51)0.97 (0.64‐1.49)0.57 (0.41‐0.80)0.77 (0.42‐1.42)Adequate0.71 (0.60‐0.84)0.88 (0.71‐1.09)0.87 (0.67‐1.13)0.63 (0.43‐0.94)0.49 (0.32‐0.74)0.49 (0.27‐0.87)Models adjusted for age, marital status, education, parity, mode of birth, newborn sex, birth weight, Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children during pregnancy, prepregnancy body mass index, gestational weight gain, pregnancy intention, prepregnancy hypertension, prepregnancy diabetes, gestational diabetes, prepregnancy depression, prepregnancy vitamins, prepregnancy smoking, prepregnancy alcohol consumption, prepregnancy folic acid intake, breastfeeding duration, small for gestational age.John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Association Between Prenatal Care Indices and Odds of a Preterm Birth Stratified by Maternal Race and Ethnicity Models adjusted for age, marital status, education, parity, mode of birth, newborn sex, birth weight, Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children during pregnancy, prepregnancy body mass index, gestational weight gain, pregnancy intention, prepregnancy hypertension, prepregnancy diabetes, gestational diabetes, prepregnancy depression, prepregnancy vitamins, prepregnancy smoking, prepregnancy alcohol consumption, prepregnancy folic acid intake, breastfeeding duration, small for gestational age. Table 6Association Between Prenatal Care Indices and Odds of Small for Gestational Age Stratified by Maternal Race and EthnicityIndicesWhite Odds Ratio (95% CI)Black Odds Ratio (95% CI)Hispanic Odds Ratio (95% CI)Asian Odds Ratio (95% CI)Tribal Odds Ratio (95% CI)Others Odds Ratio (95% CI) Comprehensive Prenatal Care Index Inadequate1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]Intermediate0.86 (0.77‐0.97)1.02 (0.82‐1.27)0.97 (0.82‐1.15)0.96 (0.72‐1.28)1.28 (0.87‐1.89)1.00 (0.65‐1.54)Adequate0.86 (0.77‐0.97)0.93 (0.75‐1.16)0.82 (0.68‐0.99)0.81 (0.59‐1.11)0.76 (0.47‐1.22)1.07 (0.69‐1.67) Kotelchuck Index Inadequate1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]Intermediate0.80 (0.68‐0.94)1.00 (0.74‐1.33)1.78 (0.90‐1.53)0.77 (0.50‐1.17)1.35 (0.89‐2.05)1.00 (0.58‐1.71)Adequate0.76 (0.66‐0.87)1.08 (0.85‐1.37)0.91 (0.73‐1.12)0.81 (0.58‐1.14)1.42 (0.93‐2.17)1.30 (0.86‐1.96)Adequate plus0.85 (0.74‐0.98)1.09 (0.86‐1.38)0.94 (0.76‐1.17)0.86 (0.61‐1.21)1.00 (0.60‐1.65)1.21 (0.77‐1.88) Kessner Index Inadequate1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]1 [Reference]Intermediate0.92 (0.76‐1.12)1.12 (0.81‐1.53)1.13 (0.86‐1.49)0.62 (0.39‐0.97)1.20 (0.75‐1.91)0.89 (0.51‐1.58)Adequate0.81 (0.68‐0.98)1.11 (0.82‐1.50)0.99 (0.76‐1.27)0.71 (0.47‐1.07)1.39 (0.86‐2.24)1.03 (0.61‐172)Models adjusted for age, marital status, education, parity, mode of birth, newborn sex, birth weight, Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children during pregnancy, prepregnancy body mass index, gestational weight gain, pregnancy intention, prepregnancy hypertension, prepregnancy diabetes, gestational diabetes, prepregnancy depression, prepregnancy vitamins, prepregnancy smoking, prepregnancy alcohol consumption, breastfeeding duration, preterm birth.John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Association Between Prenatal Care Indices and Odds of Small for Gestational Age Stratified by Maternal Race and Ethnicity Models adjusted for age, marital status, education, parity, mode of birth, newborn sex, birth weight, Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children during pregnancy, prepregnancy body mass index, gestational weight gain, pregnancy intention, prepregnancy hypertension, prepregnancy diabetes, gestational diabetes, prepregnancy depression, prepregnancy vitamins, prepregnancy smoking, prepregnancy alcohol consumption, breastfeeding duration, preterm birth. For CPCI, receiving intermediate or adequate care resulted in lower odds of SGA compared with inadequate care among White women, with intermediate (OR, 0.86; 95% CI, 0.77‐0.97) and adequate care (OR, 0.86; 95% CI, 0.77‐0.97) showing significant reductions. However, this trend was not consistent across all racial and ethnic groups. For example, among Black women, intermediate care did not significantly reduce the odds of SGA (OR, 1.02; 95% CI, 0.82‐1.27), and adequate care showed only a slight reduction (OR, 0.93; 95% CI, 0.75‐1.16). In contrast, the Kotelchuck Index indicated that adequate care was associated with reduced odds of SGA for White women (OR, 0.76; 95% CI, 0.66‐0.87) but not for other racial or ethnic groups, with Black women showing an increase in the odds of SGA, although not statistically significant (OR, 1.08; 95% CI, 0.85‐1.37). The adequate plus category was not consistently protective across groups and showed mixed results, with no significant associations observed for most groups. The Kessner Index also reflected differences in the observed associations, with adequate care showing a protective effect for White women (OR, 0.81; 95% CI, 0.68‐0.98), whereas for Asian women, the intermediate category was protective (OR, 0.62; 95% CI. 0.39‐0.97). However, among Black and Hispanic women, neither intermediate nor adequate care was significantly associated with the odds of SGA. DISCUSSION We addressed a research gap in evaluating the quality of prenatal care by introducing and validating the CPCI, a comprehensive measure incorporating a wider range of prenatal care aspects than the number and timing of prenatal visits. The CPCI, developed using prepandemic and pandemic data from PRAMS (2016‐2021), provides detailed insights into prenatal care's impact, particularly across various racial and ethnic groups. We employed IRT analysis to assess how well the CPCI items measure the latent construct of the quality of prenatal care. Our findings revealed substantial variability in prenatal care experiences among most CPCI items, suggesting that systemic factors may contribute to differing prenatal care experiences across racial and ethnic groups. For instance, differences were observed in the responses regarding “place of birth” and whether women received prenatal care information, indicating potential areas for improvement in service delivery and communication strategies across racial backgrounds. After confirming the CPCI's reliability and validity, our secondary goal was to investigate its effectiveness in examining the connection between the quality of prenatal care and birth outcomes, such as preterm birth and SGA, across various racial and ethnic groups. For instance, among non‐Hispanic White women, intermediate and adequate levels of prenatal care were strongly associated with full term birth, with OR of 2.06 and 2.27, respectively, both with P < .001. Policymakers can use insights from the CPCI to allocate resources more effectively, ensuring that pregnant individuals receive the necessary support and education to improve prenatal outcomes. For example, targeted interventions could focus on increasing the frequency and timing of prenatal visits in underserved communities or on enhancing the accessibility of care facilities. Although useful, the traditional Kotelchuck and Kessner Indices have limitations in capturing the complexities of prenatal care. The Kotelchuck Index, particularly the adequate plus category, seems to correlate negatively with positive birth outcomes, corroborating previous findings. 45 This negative association raises concerns about the usefulness of these indices in specific contexts and differences in the predictions for preterm birth and newborn mortality among various prenatal care indices. 47 Furthermore, the Kessner and Kotelchuck Indices were used in populations with preterm birth. 48 The importance of thorough evaluation before using these indices in public health nursing and research is emphasized, particularly in understanding how each index assesses the adequacy of prenatal care. This is crucial as the indices may rate prenatal care inadequacy differently, especially when considering outcomes such as preterm births. This introduces another layer of complexity to the discussion surrounding the effectiveness of traditional indices in various maternal and newborn health settings. The paradox is that the gestational age adjustments used in the Kotelchuck Index may lead to different assessments of care adequacy compared with indices like the Kessner Index, which do not adjust for gestational age. This discrepancy can result in misclassification and potentially inaccurate conclusions about the adequacy of prenatal care. Our study's results align with this critique, as the adequate plus care level in the Kotelchuck Index was unexpectedly associated with a lower likelihood of full term births (OR, 0.52; P < .001 for non‐Hispanic White women). When evaluating the impact of prenatal care on SGA, the CPCI's association was less pronounced compared with its influence on preterm birth. However, a trend toward a protective effect against SGA was observed in certain groups, emphasizing the potential of cofmprehensive prenatal care to contribute positively even to this complex outcome. Given these findings, future research should focus on refining the CPCI to enhance its sensitivity and specificity in predicting SGA outcomes. This could involve integrating additional prenatal care components that are particularly relevant to SGA, such as nutritional counseling, maternal weight monitoring, and management of pregnancy complications. Furthermore, investigating the index's performance across different populations could help identify cultural or socioeconomic factors influencing its sensitivity. Our study advocates for reevaluating current prenatal care practices. We suggest that adopting a holistic approach, such as the CPCI, may better serve the diverse needs of pregnant women and contribute to reducing adverse birth outcomes. Additionally, when assessing these factors associated with maternal‐newborn health outcomes, it is imperative to continue refining the tools used to measure the quality of prenatal care. 15 , 30 Strengths and Limitations The study has several limitations to consider when interpreting the results. Conducted from 2016 to 2021, it coincided with the onset of the COVID‐19 pandemic, which significantly altered health care delivery and access. This period saw a significant change in health care practices and resources impacting prenatal care and maternal and child health. The study relied on PRAMS data, which are self‐reported, introducing potential recall bias as participants may need to remember or report their prenatal care experiences accurately. Furthermore, PRAMS data lack clinical variables for assessing prenatal care quality, such as blood samples, blood pressure monitoring, and specific clinical interventions. Another limitation is the generalizability of the findings, as the study sample is predominantly non‐Hispanic White, which may limit the applicability of the results to more diverse populations. This limitation is related to the specific PRAMS sample we obtained rather than the PRAMS methodology itself. The CPCI items were also directly selected from the PRAMS questionnaire, which does not encompass all recommendations from the AAP, ACOG, and WHO guidelines. For example, questions about trauma exposure are limited to only partner emotional or physical abuse, without assessment of other forms of trauma exposure such as childhood abuse, sexual assault, or community violence. Using the same data set to test the new instrument's validity strains its external validity. Future research should validate the CPCI using different data sets and more comprehensive measures of prenatal care quality. Finally, PRAMS does not detail follow‐up actions or resources provided to clients who screened positive. The quality of prenatal visits depends on the provider‐patient relationship, which may be compromised by the lack of continuity in care providers. Future research should explore building effective relationships with at‐risk patients to ensure they receive consistent and comprehensive care throughout their prenatal visits. Despite these limitations, the study also has notable strengths. Its large sample size of 139,181 pregnant women allows for robust statistical analyses and potential generalizability within the study's limitations. Developing the CPCI is a significant strength, as it offers a more comprehensive assessment of prenatal care by considering a wide range of components, including counseling and health promotion. Additionally, the study conducted a detailed analysis of racial and ethnic groups, providing insight into disparities in prenatal care and birth outcomes. The study's examination of interactions between maternal race and ethnicity and prenatal care indices is another significant aspect. It focuses on considering these factors in health care planning and policies. CONCLUSION The CPCI provides a detailed and thorough assessment of prenatal care by considering a wide range of care features beyond conventional metrics. The study emphasizes the differences in prenatal care experiences across various racial and ethnic groups, as indicated by the DIF analysis. This highlights the importance of a prenatal care paradigm that is both comprehensive and culturally responsive, ensuring that all women, regardless of their background, receive fair and high‐quality prenatal care. The CPCI demonstrated stronger associations with full term births among different racial and ethnic groups, indicating its potential as a useful tool in addressing inequities in birth outcomes. It can assist policymakers in allocating resources more equitably and effectively, improving prenatal support and education. However, although the CPCI offers a more inclusive evaluation of the quality of prenatal care, it does not encompass the full spectrum of maternal health needs, such as screening and integrative care. CONFLICT OF INTEREST The authors have no conflicts of interest to disclose. Supporting information Appendix S1. Detailed Methods for Validity Assessment and Quality Index Construction Appendix S2. JMLE Item Statistics from Rasch Analysis Appendix S3. Theta (θ) Score Table Appendix S4. Scale Quality Statistics Appendix S5. Principal Components Analysis of Standardized Residuals